What If Darth Vader Joined the Rebel Alliance

Darth Vader was the dark lord of the Sith, corrupted by his Master Darth Sidious. What would've happened had Vader joined the Alliance? When would he have become a member of the rebels? What would sway him to join the alliance? Would he still be able to defeat his Master? What would his relationship with his children be like?
Support the Channel: / ppsw
PODCAST: open.spotify.com/show/4T2dHne...
Twitch Account: / pentepatrol
Community Discord: / discord
THUMBNAIL BY: Tilian_Creative: www.picuki.com/profile/tilian...
Support My Other Channels!
Support This Video's Musicians!
The Way of Water - • 🎥 Epic & Trailer (Free...
In Search of Solitude - • 🌳 Classical & Cinemati...
Permafrost - • 💭 Meditation (Free Mus...
Fire & Thunder - • ⚡ Free Epic Music (No ...
Unexplored Moon - • 🌙 Copyright Free Orche...
Eight Mountains - • Eight Mountains by Savfk
The Epic Hero - • 💪 Orchestral Trailer P...
Dunes - • ⏳ Soundtrack (Free Mus...
Refusing the Ultimatum - • 😟 Tense & Orchestral (...
Passage of Time - • ⏱️ Cinematic & Backgro...
Love - • ❤️‍🔥 Romantic & Piano ...
What Happens When We Die - • Sad Soundtrack (Free M...
The Preparation - • 🔭 Soundtrack (Free Mus...
Eglair - • 🚤 Epic & Cinematic (Fr...
Instructions for Living Life - • 🎹 Piano Instrumental (...
Terminus - • 🎖️ Free Epic Heroic Mu...
Still A Long Way To Go - • 📽️ Free Film Orchestra...
Magic - • 🍬 Free Classical Fanta...
Long Way to Go - • ⛓️ Sad & Beautiful Orc...
Age of Wonder - • 🌁 Cinematic & Epic (Fr...
#StarWars #starwarswhatif #darthvader #anakinskywalker #theclonewars #clonewars #ppsw #skywalker #ahsoka #plokoon

[@grt1769]

"I am part of the rebel alliance and a traitor, take me away!" "Hey, wait a minute..."

[@TheTrueLunarVoid]

lol

[@mikeburkhart8336]

Well,that got confusing...

[@grt1769]

@@rachelprighel4409 Is this some kind of meme im not aware of?

[@cruisingbongos4913]

​@@grt1769 It's just a quote from A new hope, Vader says that to Leia obviously not saying "I" or "me"

[@theeindhartion207]

What if Palpatine had an experience in the Light Side of the Force, and gave up on most of his plans just before Order 66, but still wanted to call out the Jedi’s hypocrisy?

[@goldenhonkbonkgonkgod]

Now that is interesting

[@bokvarv1926]

I belive he did and died from it.....TROS

[@saintb1279]

Pleeeeeeease do this one.

[@saintb1279]

This would also label him a sith deserter which would be interesting. Would the sith go extinct again? Would he try to establish the sith empire diplomatically? So much to go into

[@ToxicStoopid]

@@rachelprighel4409 Hey, why do you you keep making negative replies on people's comments? You did this to me as well.

[@loverofjesusMKII]

What if Anakin did not stop Mace Windu because he was distracted by a box of kittens left in front of the Jedi Temple

[@thecatfather857]

The second half of this question made me LOL

[@jaydub3047]

This sounds like a viable storyline.

[@AIRTALE_YOUTUBE]

It can happen

[@skeletonking1]

It shall happen some day

[@lostboynotfound]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpbOf6OEibSDn6M

[@tallytally5116]

Anakin: fine with killing children Also anakin: I DRAW THE LINE AT SLAVERY

[@serventium4049]

To be fair he hates slavery, as he was a slave himself once

[@Yakomoe]

You don't have to be killed as a child to hate someone Killing children 😂😂😂

[@panmopsel]

Vader went Among Us mode, funniest thing i heard in weeks 😂

[@doragonzx]

imagine him shipping luck and Leia than learning they are his childrens.

[@drachir000]

I have to say, I am really impressed by how natural you make Vader's turn to the Rebel Alliance seem.

[@Shadowhawk827]

Good storytelling has a natural feeling path like that. Pente Patrol did good here.

[@immortalfrieza]

I find this what if far more natural than what actually does happen, considering Vader/Anakin's history.

[@fullaregrets5015]

I've got a good one for you. Not sure if anyone has ever tackled this one, but: "What if Tarkin joined the Rebels?"

[@SpaceCase1214]

For that to happen, he could find out how the Empire killed his son in Legends.

[@TarsonTalon]

@@SpaceCase1214 Moreover, Tarkin's probably the type of person who would believe lying is a sign of weakness. Had Sidious threatened him with Force Lightning, he'd of probably submitted happily. But, because Sidious used deception to gain his loyalty, now Tarkin believes Sidious is insecure, and doesn't deserve to be Emperor via his own doctrine.

[@nightspawnson-of-luna4936]

I think there was a fanfic I read about that, it was kinda cracky and included the characters from the phineas and ferb crossover special

[@JediMasterZim]

@@TarsonTalon I could see that making a degree of sense. I mean Tarkin was a pretty big advocate of brute force and using fear of that to control the galaxy, and could kind of a meathead about it. Even if Tarkin wouldn't think the way you describe, just his son being killed on Palpatine's orders alone could be motivation for him seeking revenge while still maintaining his beliefs. Perhaps Grand Moff Wilhuff Tarkin simply sees the ordered killing of his son Admiral Gerosh Tarkin by Wilhuff's oldest and closest political ally as being an inexcusable betrayal of the Grand Moff himself. At the same time, perhaps Tarkin further convinces himself (or maybe even believes it) that Palpatine/Darth Sidious is simply not being effective in dealing with rebellions and senators and such who wish to restore the Republic. Perhaps Tarkin convinces himself or even believes that he would do a better job in crushing them, and that Palpatine is ultimately an obstacle to that victory. Maybe he gets tired of Palpatine not dealing with Separatist Holdouts fast enough, especially after some CIS holdout counteroffensive that is effectively. Maybe Tarkin loses patience due to the failure of the government under Palpatine to deal with Saw Guerera and his partisans, perhaps after some particularly successful and devastating attack on a key military instillation like the Kuat Shipyards or the military academy at Carida or Anaxes, or maybe even on Coruscant itself, attacking the heart of the regime. I don't know about Tarkin joining the rebels with the aim of restoring the Republic...but perhaps he launches a coup against Palpatine, or maybe a military insurrection to try to fight a civil war for control of the galaxy? Hell, maybe he waits until the Death Star is completed and he is in control of it, and he uses loyalists of his to seize control, with the Death Star being a key part of his plans to overthrow Palpatine.

[@shep9231]

Okay. this I hve got to see.. :)

[@polishscribe674]

Obi-Wan: Leia, he's your father Anakin: *What!?*

[@ToorGoruK0316]

anakin: what else are you hiding oni wan: they're twins anakin and leia: WHAT!!

[@user-et1vh7ge9f]

Vader hears Luke and Leia are being romantic then finds out their his children Vader busts in wtf! This ain't no sweet home coruscant!

[@lapisthehuman]

☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️😭😭

[@MegaMario051]

Man this was great, the whole Vader or in this case Anakin setting up the Empire to fall from within like that was well detailed. This gave me Metal Gear vibes, Anakin felt like a combination of Solid Snake and Ocelot. Obviously Anakin's actions had consequences he had to live with but was able to power through for a better tomorrow which does add this hopeful feeling to the what if. And the creativity in Anakin setting up the freak accidents and his behind the scenes actions felt well done. Heh... "What If Vader was a double agent in the Empire." That'd be a nice alternate name for this.

[@operatorchakkoty4257]

"Anakin blows up Exegol" YES THANK YOU

[@idiocrat3744]

What if Luke fell to the Dark Side while Vader turned to the light after ESB? Gradually, not instantly of course.

[@VadakinEdits]

Awsome

[@panmopsel]

Its bullshit… I like that

[@roguexvampire]

​​@@panmopselnot bs. In EU Luke was an apprentice to palpatine for a bit. Just to learn the ways of the DS

[@VadakinEdits]

@@panmopselhuh?

[@brokenbridge6316]

That's interesting

[@top_banananaplays]

Vader becomes the ultimate prankster

[@biffbuffington4393]

What a great little story. My god, this kid has more talent than anyone at Disney/Star Wars 2023. Great job kid!

[@goldenhonkbonkgonkgod]

Yep

[@daz97]

Wall paper has more talent than Disney activist's do.

[@mrbuckshot]

❤love it

[@biffbuffington4393]

@@daz97 true

[@dianesinger9729]

I like the switch of Leia being a Jedi and Luke the politician. I love the redemption of Anakin and he staying in the light

[@marikam2998]

I also love Anakin's Redemption but, it would have been better if Anakin had redeemed himself by simply changing as a Person for the better. And starting to see Palpatine's true colors when he was a Jedi Padawan because, I don't like that Anakin couldn't see his true colors until it was too late. He adored Palpatine so much that it could make his eyes blind. And make his ears deaf. I would have preferred that Anakin was insightful. And observant towards Palpatine and not vice versa because, I really always love stories where Anakin can be wise. Smart. Insightful. And observant despite his young age.

[@dianesinger9729]

@@marikam2998 true

[@marikam2998]

And I'll be honest, I considering that Anakin from 3 to 9 years old is on Tatooine where the Hutts rule, then there’s definitely no point in Anakin dreaming of an effective dictatorship for The Galaxy. And for The Republic with a smile on its face after he gained freedom, he immediately left there and became a Jedi from the age of 9 like In The Attack Of The Clones when he was 19 years old with Padme on a Picnic in the Lake District. I didn't mind if Anakin would have been shown as determined. Confident. Fearless. Serious. Brave. Militant. Charming. And charismatic like Leia but, if Anakin In The Star Wars Prequels would have been shown as Merciful. Compassionate. Peaceful. And a sympathetic Altruist. Pacifist. And the Peacemaker as Luke then to Lucas for his good portrayal Of The Light Side Of Anakin’s Personality In The Star Wars Prequels, we would definitely be left with an unforgettable pleasure. It's a pity that Lucas, having focused on depicting the Dark Side of Anakin's Personality, completely forgot to show us more of The Light Side Of Anakin's Personality In The Star Wars Prequels. Glory To The Force, that Anakin is portrayed better in Ahsoka 2023 than In The Star Wars Prequels. And that we always have Our Grand Master who, will always provide us with the Positive, so to speak, Evolution of Anakin as a Personality. Poor Hayden, he finally redeemed Anakin at least for Ahsoka 2023 with his excellent acting. And to be honest, his Anakin even reminded me there of Cole Julian McMahon From Charmed.

[@AndrooUK]

​@@marikam2998But, it wasn't too late... He redeemed himself by providing a huge help to the resistance. If you set an arbitrary deadline of redemption, then Anakin might as well say "Fuck it, it's too late for me. I'm going to kill as many people as possible, because it's too late for me now."

[@shadowcous]

Never have I seen a story where Leia becomes a Jedi and Luke like his mother. Good role reversal, really took me by surprise. Amazing story ❤

[@emiliomartinez7573]

Role reversal is such a lazy and boring way to tell a story 😂

[@jblaster0076]

What if Rots Anakin time travelled to see luke after Rotj

[@jblaster0076]

So they would probably recreate the jedi order together and train Ben Solo

[@fumkioyuki8457]

How would work also how would anakin know Luke existed?

[@jblaster0076]

Well i guess luke probably had some reputation and as soon as anakin would arrive to the future he would start to find out what has happened

[@TheFinalKnight1]

​@@fumkioyuki8457Probably in a situation where he and Obiwan/Ashoka discovered the realm between worlds. It could easily work

[@robertjv]

Anakin will probably feel Lukw in the force ans eventually be like oh sh!t that's my son

[@locoarticwolf2181]

The thumbnail art looks great! Love Vader’s design.

[@robertjv]

He should've made it pink

[@matthewmann8969]

1. What if The Jedi Order never became too sure of themselves and were always cautious in case dark siders came back to wreck catastrophe no matter how long The Sith have not made a grand entrance? 2. What if Palpatine actually genuely cared about Dooku as a best friend forever type of relation? 3. What if Obi Wan was framed for the jedi temple bombing instead of Ahsoka? 4. What if Palpatine was still a force user with the same midichlorian count the difference being he was trained by more Grey Area force users holos like Traya, Revan, And Dooku and took there philosophy yet still felt the need to be a politician although one that is a much less corrupt one like Padme, Bail, And Mina? 5. What if Anakin lost the people closest to him around the same time around Late TCW His Children, Padme, Obi Wan, Ahsoka, Palpatine(Lets Say He Did Not Find Out He Was Playing Him Until Years Afterwards). 6. What if Sidious mastered cloning of himself way before The Phantom Menace started so he felt there was no need for Talzin, Maul, Dooku, Anakin, Galen, Or Luke to be his apprentices at any point? 7. What if Mace was trained by Rahm Kota? 8. What if Mace had better social skills or people skillers? 9. What if Mace still had hair? 10. What if Yoda mastered the force so well even by TPM Timeline that he was able to use the force to make himself six feet tall?

[@fumkioyuki8457]

Obi wan being framed insterestong

[@starwarsidiot]

“What if mace had hair”🤣😭

[@jwappel3068]

What if Darth Vectivus formed a Light sith order that discovered Anakin?

[@Whatever-nd1mk]

what if anakin was framed for the bombing tho

[@thegalaxyofadventuresstudios]

@@Whatever-nd1mklitteraly revenge of the Sith earlier but padme dosent die

[@Ox9707]

Anti-hero Darth Vader is really bad ass. Another Ox approved episode

[@brokenbridge6316]

You put together a very nice story PP. I loved how unique it was. And the bond Leia n Anakin had was adorable.

[@Project_Prescott]

what if Windu wasn't stopped because Anakin stubbed his toe💀

[@Theoshobbies-lf7wc]

Palpatine dies and anakin dies

[@Spirit_Yoshino]

The one sad part about this is that we don't get Han Solo.

[@WilliamMosicki-Nystrom]

1. What if Tyber Zann became emperor 2. What if Ben Solo joined the Zann Consortium 3. What if Wullf Yularen was a Sith 4. What if Bail Organa joined the Separatists 5. What if Wullf Yularen joined the Rebellion 6. What if Andor was a Sith 7. What if Dass Jennir trained Ahsoka Tano 8. What if Wullf Yularen was a Jedi 9. What if Andor joined the ISB 10. What if Wullf Yularen died in the battle of Ryloth

[@Sacrificiumcontrol]

Yullaren fan detected

[@WilliamMosicki-Nystrom]

@@Sacrificiumcontrol He's a cool guy and I feel like he doesn't get enough screen time.

[@Sacrificiumcontrol]

@@WilliamMosicki-Nystrom I agree but he is kinda just there

[@dannylopez5976]

This has to be one of coolest what ifs and well written too. Great take on the "What if Vader turned good"

[@leifreon6117]

You know. I like how the spark that lead to Anakin's turn and redemption is actually a believable scenario. Great work.

[@Achuidian179]

I had originally came up with the idea of Leai saving Vader as a child, but this story has better ring to it. Day 13 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love? Side note: I noticed a lot of your stories has Bail Organa being the chancellor in the end, so I was wondering about a what if Padme was chancellor or at the very least thinking of making Padme chancellor at the end of the story.

[@Achuidian179]

@@rachelprighel4409 sorry auto correct for Leia

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" the Jedi Discovered that the Sith Temple under their own on Coruscant was corrupting them?

[@animefreak9798]

Later April Fools what if suggestion. What if Qui-gon Jinn was a prankster as a force ghost? There's nothing in Star Wars lore that necessarily saying that this would be against the will of the force.

[@TheGooseOfChaos]

Qui-Gon: *proceeds to prank the entire order*

[@anthonypyritz2927]

​@@TheGooseOfChaosand palpatine

[@fordoslegacystarwars]

Yet again another great video by Pente. One of the few SW Creators who portrays Vader so well in all of his videos.

[@shep9231]

I love this story. You have manmaged to do something I never considered possible. You turned Darth Vader into a hero. Someone who I'd follow through hell...

[@austinestep8461]

To be fair being a hero is a matter of perspective, for the stormtroopers Vader fought with he was already that guy

[@XSouthparkisawsomeX]

What if the clones had 50/50 split? Anikin didn't turn but Ashoka did with the 501st. While factions of the CIS split some rejoining the republic

[@alexanderkidonakis9185]

What if Disney never bought star wars and mark hamill bought it instead

[@konkros7495]

He doesn't write Sidious like he's an evil mastermind, he writes him like he's a fool.

[@ericjones3692]

I'm sure these aren't easy to write, but it amazes me how a youtuber can make better content then the writers Disney employees for their movies.

[@DarthCherry8]

Love the Leia and Her father’s Relationship

[@jotheunissen9274]

What if, instead of Qui-Gon, another Jedi Master found Anakin?

[@optillian4182]

What if Han Solo was adopted by Mandalorians? What if the Yuuzhan Vong were canon? What if Chewbacca was Force-sensitive?

[@TheUncivilizedNation]

The Yuuzhan Vong would destroy the New Republic. However they in turn decimated by the First Order. Starkiller Base carries them. If they fall the Sith Eternal would win a war of attrition. A fleet of thousands of Star Destroyers that can each destroy an entire planet would be unstoppable

[@josephjohnson5766]

Great story and a worthy end for the Empire. What if Vader arrived at the Inquisitor base early and upon seeing Leia's fear of him made him remember Padme and forced him to face the truth of what he had become. Not returning to the light but no longer a Sith, more of a Grey Jedi who used both the light and the dark. What if Anakin and Kit Fisto were dispatched to Dooku's palace on secret mission to find information on the Sith lord after the rescue of the chancellor.

[@rufusnelsoniv8573]

The what if Vader trained Leia was good! I feel like he would have been interested and involved in any plan concerning kenobi. Very well done.

[@christopherjohnston8556]

What if Anakin left the Jedi order to free slaves in the outer rim?

[@chasetauscher9544]

Maybe after Slaves of the Republic

[@mattstorm360]

Yep. He just did that. Just tried to make slavery a good thing to a former slave boy... What if Steela Gerrera survived? What if Tarkin Destroyed Lothal instead of Alderaan? What if Hondo discovered Ezra before the ghost crew? (Pirate Jedi!) What if Ezra's parents, or at least his father, was sent to the Narkina 5 Imperial Prison Complex? What if Anakin helped Obi Wan save Satine? What if General Kalani joined the rebels? What If R2-D2 failed and the Rhydonium bomb went off on time? What if Palpatine lost his connection to the force? (When trying to turn Yoda, the force would push back.) What if Ezra joined the empire? (Like the what if Luke joined the empire.) What if Palpatine really did love democracy? What if Dooku owned a tusken rifle for home defense? (Three jedi ruffians break into his home.) What if Pente Patrol Star Wars was the Jedi's PR manager? What if Star Wars was in Earth? What if Cham Syndulla was made Senator? (Instead of trying to get rid of Cham Syndulla, the empire gets rid of Orn Free Taa and makes Syndulla the senate leader. Using his popularity with his people to control the population and the semi unspoken threat that his daughter could be considered an accomplice to Gobi Glie's vile act of murdering Orn Free Taa if he didn't.) What if Imperial Bio-weapons project I71A was run by dr Nuvo Vindi on Lothal? What if Sabine Wren stayed with the Empire? What if Haji fired on the escape pod? What if Obi-Wan used force heal on Padme? What if Captian Tarkin died at the citadel? What if Asajj Ventress and the Nightsisters successfully assassinated Dooku? What if Anakin was born a women? Kendall Skywalker. What if Anakin died to torture? (I don't know what you mean. -Dooku) What if that super Tactical droid that threw hands with Anakin, killed him? (Smashed his helmet and he suffocated.)

[@ondrejtravnicek8705]

I want What if the jedi legends came back to life.I really want this.

[@LordMayorOfDairyBell]

What if Anakin was Guybrush Threepwood, mighty pirate? Adventuring across the Tri-Planet area, dealing with the evil undead pirate Captain Palpatine, and winning the love of his life Governor Padme Amidala. Basically, I'd love the story of the Monkey Island games told in the Star Wars universe. The first 4 games are a product of LucasArts and reference other Lucas properties like Star Wars, Indiana Jones, etc.

[@Only1199]

What if Darth Jadus who Valkorion once called the greatest sith lord his old sith empire ever produced returned during the events of the sequel trilogy instead of palpatine?

[@zbanul10]

Who? I’m being true because idk who that is and I’m being sarcastic because no one would know who it was.

[@andrewwinslow9315]

You have a way with words that few have. Well Spoken, and Well Written. Can't wait for more What Ifs!

[@ExileRika]

This does make me wonder how the story would have gone if Vader had defected after witnessing for the first time what Death Star was capable of doing

[@reeceemms1643]

What if the Sith Empire returned during the High Republic Era? What if Avar Kriss and Elzar Mann had a child? What if Cal And Merrin had a daughter? What if Ezra and Sabin had a child What if Luke Skywalker found love? What if Luke and Leia found out they were siblings earlier? What if Padme was enslaved? What if Han was saved from Jabba but Leia failed to kill him and escape so was still enslaved?

[@TheMimiSard]

When I first saw this video was coming up, I thought "Oh, Double Agent Vader!". The only thing with that is that for someone who reads a lot on AO3, that is the flagship title of Fialleril's Tatooine Slave Culture fanon. Basically, Fialleril created a concept of a secret culture that exists amongst the slaves of Tatooine, with its own gods, myths, stories, language, and customs. There is another fic series named "Desert Storm" by a different writer that is usually quoted as one of the tentpole fics too, but now, people take the general slave culture and throw it into fics as flavour, even in fics that are not featuring Anakin, or Tatooine, with the story I am currently reading actually having a scene where an elder slave explains that no one is sure which world it started on, and the circumstances may change details (like ocean waves replacing sandstorms, and a purrgil god being the spacefaring cousin of the kraytt dragon goddess Leia), but it is has spread across slaves all around the galaxy as they have been sold off. The Double Agent Vader storyline has the trigger moment for Vader being a mission he is sent on to Tattooine, where while he is there, he hears a Gan-Amu (slave "Grandmother" wise-woman) telling the stories of Ekkreth, the Trickster god. He reconnects with his birth culture, adopts the identity of Ekkreth, and starts working as, well, a double agent, feeding intel to the Rebllion, which in turn results in him sneaking data drives into Princess Leia's pockets, and eventually becoming her mentor in mind shielding when he realises she's Force Sensitive, and eventually building her a lightsaber (which Luke spots the symbol of Leia the Kraytt Dragon on and thinks it looks like something he knows but has misgivings because how would a Coreworld Princess know Amavikka symbols?).

[@redneckgaming1590]

What if Vader raised starkiller like he would have Luke?

[@Bobby_TX-210]

Lucasfilm really needs to do a Star Wars “What If” with the stories from KZbinrs like yourself writing the stories. This was really good.

[@hgtrftfr]

What if Vader found yoda on degobah and Yoda successfully turns Vader back to the light, just before the events of A New Hope, everything else with luke still happens but obiwan lives?

[@timothyschwartz5518]

What if Saw Gerrera joined the formal Rebel Alliance? What if Saw Gerrera joined the phoenix squad as an actual member? What if Saw Gerrera left with Jyn Erso when in Rogue one before the Death Star destoryed Jeddah city? What if Luke fell in love with Sabine Wren? What if Luke was raised on Naboo? What if Luke was raised in Lothal?

[@jdgreen1802]

What if Anakin and Vader were actually separate personalities inside of one body

[@Embersofthedark]

They are tho, Anakin is the Jedi side of him and Vader is the sith side just like The Brother and The Sister

[@jdgreen1802]

@@Embersofthedark that’s just simply incorrect Vader and Anakin are one person, no spilt personality, no two minds sharing one body, Vader and Anakin are the same. One of Vader’s quotes is the he “destroyed Anakin skywalker” Vader doesn’t even truly believe this statement. If that was the case then Vader wouldn’t hate himself as much as he does. He wouldn’t care about the past, padme, Luke, obi-wan,etc. If they were truly separate people Vader wouldn’t have let Luke live the first time they fought. If Anakin is truly a separate personality that Vader “killed” then there would be nothing left to bring back to the light.

[@Embersofthedark]

@@jdgreen1802 hmmm seems I was incorrect upon further research please do excuse my lack of info I have not kept up in the past five to six years of stars wars lore Edit: I fuckin said I was correct when I do infact know I'm incorrect now I'm a fucking dumbass when typing

[@diamondman307_]

Great story! Wish we could have heard a bit more about other Jedi and how they reacted, but besides that it was very interesting.

[@brandonwolak836]

What if Dooku went with Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan back to Naboo after the conversation in Tales of the Jedi? What is Dooku accpeted Yaddle's offer and fought Sidious? What if the Jedi Council went with Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan back to Naboo? What if Dooku was on the Jedi Council/What if there were 13 seats on the Jedi Council instead of 12? What if Cham Syndulla successfully assassinated Palpatine and Vader? What is General Grivious killed/captured Obi-Wan on Utapau?

[@GAJake]

What if the New Republic never signed a treaty with the empire and kept fighting the remnants? What if the New Republic did sign the treaty but kept militarizing and kept and adapted imperial technology and research (like Dr. Pershing)?

[@seanmalloy0528]

I have a What if for this What If; what if Vader also tried converting inquisitors back?

[@whiteerdydude]

This was a nice story and was quite enjoyable the whole way through. I do admit though I really hate the force projection scene, and I have yet to see it used in a way that I enjoy. Still a great story 9.9/10

[@willamahrens538]

What if the Thanos snap took place in the Star Wars galaxy? Would the Empire and Rebels join forces to return the galaxy back to normal?

[@phillapine3682]

“Yo The Rebels Is Very chill, Maybe you can join it or something”

[@ivanbadaev6621]

Omg I was actually looking forward to this one Props to Tilian for this epic thumbnail btw! We don't say it much, but we do love him ♥

[@magpiekritik3123]

What If on Halo 3's final mission the portal on the Ark sends the Forward unto Dawn (intact or split) carrying Master Chief, Cortana and Arbiter (all together, two or one depending if the ship splits or not) A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away . . . . Star wars (or to be more specific at the start or little before the Phantom Menace or New Hope) let the debate begin !?! Warning this is a work in progress! but feel free to take, edit and use in your final draft if you wish, just a small mention/credit of what I may have contributed will be fine with me :) Option 1, Arbiter solo: The front half of the Forward unto Dawn carrying Arbiter teleports into the Star Wars galaxy at speed, passes the CIS blockade, who are left wondering WTF was that, but of course turn their attention to another approaching ship ( Qui Gon Jinn / Obi Wan kenobi journey stays the same for now ... ) Arbiter crashes into the ocean or large lake on the planet of Naboo, after salvaging what he can and escaping the sinking wreck Arbiter sets off in search of civilization ... only at first to find Jar Jar Binks !?! ... After setting up camp for the night and having something to eat ( either human ration packs salvaged from the F.U.D | or some form of creature that Arbiter would be able to catch/eat ) lured by the smell of food Jar Jar " Attempts " to sneak up! ... Only to get caught (detected via Arbiters hunter/warrior senses ... that or his motion tracker) after a lot of begging/bargaining Arbiter takes pity on him and offers Jar Jar a deal, guide him to the " Human " capital of Naboo in exchange for food/protection (Jar Jar of course would accept this offer, what with being banished from going home for being clumsy) along the way perhaps they'll find a crashed but still operational warthog (which is worse, trusting Jar Jar to drive or shoot !) after some driving they come under attack from scouts of the droid invasion followed by the JEDI who come to their aid and ... could also appreciate a ride ... ( JJ will likely call Arbiter " Arby " for short throughout the story ) Option 2, Chief / Cortana: The back half of the Forward unto Dawn carrying Chief / Cortana teleports into from their perspective a unknown region of space! Cortana of course will start running scans of the area and drop a beacon for potential rescue (for about 4 years, 7 months, 10 days she won't be suffering from rampancy yet) ... oh would you look at that its the ship that Qui Gon Jinn/ Obi Wan kenobi are traveling on, after some basic introductions / explanations the JEDI will ask if MC/C would like to accompany them to the planet of Naboo or wait for another ship to give them a tow 1a) if they stay some time later the JEDI will send a message saying the CIS have just attempted to kill them, rather than being sitting ducks, Cortana uses what control they have over the F.U.D to steer it to Naboo for a controlled crash landing then using a escape pod. 1b) if they leave with the JEDI, the F.U.D will be left behind for now, will it stay adrift in space, get caught in Naboo's gravitational pull and crash there!) When arriving at the CIS blockade MC/C will have another two choices 2a) Stay in ship until what should be " short negotiations " are over! ... outcome: ship gets blown up with MC/C just about escaping the blast or rises from the wreckage like a Demon to the bewilderment of the battle droids 2b) Join the JEDI in the meeting to introduce themselves to this new galaxy or pretend to be acting security! ... outcome: oh boy, if the CIS were spooked about JEDI showing up in the original story, what are going to think Chief is ... Mandalorian perhaps ( they won't know anything about Cortana yet ) When Lord Sidious gives the order " kill them immediately " so the CIS blows up the horse they rode in on and " try " to gas the JEDI / Chief ... pfffft ha ha ha ha HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA cue the song ( Unyielding Soul ) | whichever scenario plays they link up and fight their way to the bridge (next question is can Cortana interface/hack the doors for the bridge e.g. is there a control panel they can hack? ... also don't forget the blast doors) still even after all that the droidika's with their shields may still be problematic leading to the group needing to sneakoff the ship! Option's 1/2 combined: When combining these perspectives most details stay the same, with the exception of Chief / Cortana telling the JEDI that Arbiter is about to crash-land on the planet of Naboo (or already has) they'll also be able to keep in contact with Arbiter via COM's until the CIS blocks communications!

[@SergeantGhost171]

That's the best "what if" I've seen for a while. 👏

[@SamCaiman14]

1) In Marvel What if, Ultron and Watcher briefly broke into Mustafar overseeing Vader's castle. What if Vader senses a great disturbance was coming and prepared himself being in that brief moment and while Ultron is fully focused fighting Watcher, Vader pulls out with the Force the Infinity Stones from Ultron, so fast that neither Watcher or Ultron can react and they continue breaking into another dimension, leaving Vader with the Infinity Stones on his hands? 2) What if knowing how treacherous the Sith are and that obviously Palpatine wants Anakin as his apprentice, Dooku set up a deadman switch in case Palpatine betrayed him? Just as Palpatine is declaring the Empire the timer hits 0 and the Holonet is hit with a full confession from Dooku as well as mountains of evidence with conversations between him and Palpatine/Sidious? The spread by the Holonet is done by Super Tactical Droids specifically commanded to ignore any shutdown command. 3) After learning about Darth Sidious in Geonosis rather than dismissing it, the Jedi Council combine their force power, with Anakin invited, to try to find the truth. A future far ahead in a galaxy far, far away, a young man is falling from a heart attack only to suddenly find himself floating in a starry strange world full of portals as he is pulled into one. The great detective L. Lawliet appears in the council chamber with the information about him imprimpted on the minds of the Council and Anakin (L knows nothing about them so they will need to explain). It is clear this is a gift from The Force to help them solve the case of Darth Sidious. 4) What if the Anakin from the World Between Worlds went back to beginning if the Empire to train Ahsoka in both the light and dark as the successor of the Chosen One to bring an earlier end of the Empire and prevent the events in the sequels? He could even eventually direct her to bathe in the pool of knowledge and drink fron the font of power making Ahsoka a being of balance ready to whoop the Sith's asses.

[@elibedard6373]

I really like number 2! It would be a great way for Dooku to have the last laugh.

[@SS_Atlantic_Greyhound1119]

Their was a series of comics known as "Star Wars: Infinities" which were alternate history type stories where certain events and Characters take a different path. Now thinking about it, imagine a comic based on the scenarios you created, including this one?

[@SS_Atlantic_Greyhound1119]

@@rachelprighel4409 Oh? So no longer is it a mere idea, but rather a reality?

[@bigmanhelper]

I prefer this version of the Original Trilogy to the Canon version! Great job as always, PPSW!😄

[@jonahstirbis3408]

Anakin beat sidious by force projection that's freaking dope.

[@judgejohnson2796]

Question: How did Anakin know about force projection? Sorry if this seems like a dumb question, but it sounded like Anakin would have been too busy to learn the technique and as far as I am aware neither Ben nor Ahsoka knew of it either.

[@TheUncivilizedNation]

It’s not a dump question. It was never explained how Anakin learned such a difficult ability. A rare PPSW “L” ngl

[@isgamer-8732]

​@@TheUncivilizedNationObiwan underestimated his power

[@Devilhand21]

He would probably experiment with the force here and there as he may not have had all the time in the galaxy with everything going on, but he would still have time to improve his use of the force at some points. That is my guess for how he learned the force projection technique, and I could 100% be wrong.

[@Imagination4all]

What if Anakin didn't kill the Tusken Raiders but instead left the camp, unleashed his rage on some rocks all while the Tusken Raiders watched from a safe distance. The idea with this is the Raiders were spared his wrath and saw his pain in his strikes against rock faces. Rage unleashed upon inanimate objects is healthier than doing it to living beings.

[@witherslayer4239]

That's a really interesting idea. The Tuskens could see that he could have killed him all easily and maybe that tribe would become a little more compassionate, possibly even helping in the rebellion.

[@fakenuke7487]

What's good about this is that Kanan gets to live, as does Cere and Trilla. Couple that with Ahsoka never having to fight Vader and we have a decent roster of powerful unorthodox Jedi to kiclstart the Jedi order again. Cal Trilla Cere Ahsoka Obi-Wan Ezra Kanan Luke and hopefully Leia too

[@karithomas5064]

YAY!!!! Can you please do... What if Anakin vowed loyalty to the Zygerrian queen What if Dooku didn't go to Zygerria and Anakin couldn't escape What if Ashoka fell in love with Anakin but he didn't fall in love with her What if Anakin trained Ezra What if Ezra and Leia fell in love What if Ezra saved Mace when he was trying to save Ashoka What if Hera was a Jedi What if Anakin didn't fall in love with Padme but she was OBSESSED with him I would love to see these videos!! Can you please do them? Thank you for what you are doing!

[@nerysghemor5781]

It's hard to see Vader not having a grudge against Obi-Wan for the way he abandoned him to the fire, personally.

[@Fracture_.]

Day 16: What if Darth Zannah was a Jedi? Either she refrains from killing the Jedi who originally comes for her, or another Jedi takes her instead soon after, assuming Bane doesn't find her or a twin of some kind exists. She undergoes training until she becomes a Jedi Knight or perhaps even a Jedi Master. Then, she receives one of two visions. The first vision portrays Anakin or Luke as the chosen one. She believes in the prophecy and enters stasis, intending to train them to confront Palpatine during the Clone Wars or the time of the Empire. The second vision involves Palpatine himself, maybe as the Emperor. Believing that she is the chosen one due to this, she enters stasis until the Clone Wars, awakened by the Force or some other catalyst. To fight him herself. To maintain her characterization as the Zannah we know and love, she excels as a master of Form Three and is proficient in Jedi Alchemy or sorcery, perhaps even both. I think the second vision would make for a better story, as training Anakin/Luke videos are already abundant on your channel.

[@mikecotto1167]

Here’s a good one to make: “What if the Jedi secretly ordered thousands of Jedi to be cloned 20 years before Episode I?” I think the Jedi sensing the dark side beginning to engulf the galaxy was enough to convince them to make a very secret choice by getting hundreds of the most powerful Jedi knights and masters to be cloned. I think this would catch Palpatine by complete surprise as the Jedi would do the cloning in a designed facility in the depths of one of the old worlds such as Ossus or Ak-To.

[@john98765333]

Now that was an interesting and well done video! I really liked the way the story formed. Although, a small note, is that I heard that Vader was actually really close to having his lungs fully healed in canon. He just needed another week or so in Bacta. So in your story, with him being in Bacta more, I think he could have lived without any respirators. Just a small thing.

[@user-rg7gm4rh9c]

Wow, you are really really good at this bro. Honestly very impressive!

[@jb-wc1hx]

I like the mental image that Vader unable to feel close to any colleagues, made an army of droids to cooperate and maybe consult with.

[@nez9751]

What if R2 was a smith, with salacious crumb on his little shoulder laughing at everyone

[@DarthKrellon]

Anakin trolling Sidious like Luke trolled Kylo Ren on Crait was just awesome

[@aidenwolfe3893]

Love this story. Well written thank you for making great content. An Idea a friend and I have had is What if rey and Kylo switched roles(ie luke doesn'ttry and kill ben and Palpatine found Rey and trained her)

[@jonathanraven5939]

Absolutely excellent presentation.

[@Ellman1231]

This was a great take. Nicely done. My only suggestion would be that Vader's guilt/trauma at having killed the children/younglings in the Jedi temple have a bigger effect on him as well as Obi-Wan's willingness to trust him, & be a bigger part of Anakin's efforts at atonement. It might even conflict with his desire to be in Luke & Leia's life, having him question why he would deserve to have them if he kept those other children from a long life. Also, i would love to see a story similar to this, but where Thrawn lives, still figures out Vader is Anakin, & they bring down the Empire together with the Alliance.

[@adamb2954]

If you think about in each way if proves Qui-Gon was right Anakin being the chosen one while almost everyone else didn't think it was so. The movie 4-6 shows it, as well as this video you did.

[@KanshouXBakuya]

i still wish for a what if the force itself trained anakin. in a way that its neither jedi or sith but how the force intended.

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Sabine Wren discovered that she was force-sensitive at the same time Ezra did in the SW: Rebels series.

[@maestro-zq8gu]

I don't have Disney Plus so this is all very fascinating thank you very much.

[@naw9549]

Would love to see a video of Luke and Anakins force ghost just... Talking. For the first time. I think you get a lot of the small details right and id love to see your take on it!

[@noneofurbusiness5223]

I think Luke was *emotionally* more like his mom.

[@armalite5.56]

Very interesting to see leia and luke swap places

[@chineseman6580]

You just killed Thrawn like it was nothing…

[@johnraynor489]

Yes! Poor Thrawn deserved a bigger role in this story. Suppose the Emperor decided to put him in a counterintelligence role and, after a long cat-and-mouse game, he figured out what Vader was up. When theyfinally face one another, Vader manages to convince Thrawn that the Emperor is not just a ruthless dictator, but Pure Cosmic Evil, and Thrawn defects to the Rebellion, instead of reporting his discovery to Palpatine.

[@GAJake]

What if Thrawn (or thrawn and vader) joined the rebellion? So maybe an alternate version of this where thrawn doesn't die?

[@delta18520]

What if Alderaan wasn't destroyed? What if the R5 unit has a good motivator? What if the Millennium Falcon get destroyed in the asteroid field?

[@joshuacorless1233]

What if the jedi temple guards had been at the temple on the night of operation knightfall and fought Vader and the clones

[@AutumnThe_Toaster]

This is by far my most favorite story I could probably see George Lucas make a what if exactly like this amazing work

[@Dragon359]

If he did join them, I would prefer the concept art of him having his burned form in Jedi style garments, with his breathing apparatus being more minimal compared to how it was in the suit.

[@Rusty-Doggo]

Stories like this make me want a Star Wars what if show

[@thewritingsoff.c.williams830]

This should be made into a What If movie, damn would be soooooo goooood.

[@jotheunissen9274]

'fallen from the dark side' So if you fall from the light side into the dark side, wouldn't falling from the dark side be the same as RISING to the light?

[@Phoenixesper1]

This was fascinating, This needs a part 2 to show and explain how this new order and galactic setup deals with the yuzangvon War.

[@TheDreamerintheStarlight]

The start of anakin’s career: blowing up a battleship The culmination of anakin’s career: *blowing up a bigger battleship*