What if GTA 5 had BeamNG.drive physics?

[@nothingnew3939]

A lesser person would have made this video 10+ mins long and still have less information. Thank you for a nice 3 minutes.

[@blitzerni]

For our sins we deserve eternity in hell, but God loves us so much he came as Jesus to pay the price of our sins through living a perfect life for us, his death and his resurrection so we can be forgiven and receive eternal life if we follow and obey him in faith FOR LIFE , Jesus loves u and desires to have a personal relationship with you of love, peace, redemption and obedience ✝️ May Jesus bless you, repent of your sins and turn to Christ before it's too late 🙏🏿❤️

[@organpuncher]

​@@blitzerni boi shut up

[@godofpoison6667]

It requires only probably less than 30 secs. Already he is repeating the same point over and over.

[@AussieGuy-qb8mh]

4 minutes spent on the sponsorship 4 minutes going back and fourth about the same subject 2 minutes actually discussing it

[@blitzerni]

@@AussieGuy-qb8mh For our sins we deserve eternity in hell, but God loves us so much he came as Jesus to pay the price of our sins through living a perfect life for us, his death and his resurrection so we can be forgiven and receive eternal life if we follow and obey him in faith FOR LIFE , Jesus loves u and desires to have a personal relationship with you of love, peace, redemption and obedience ✝️ May Jesus bless you, repent of your sins and turn to Christ before it's too late 🙏🏿❤️

[@Sithhy]

GTA 4 is probably the closest we will ever get to BeamNG's physics in a GTA game; don't really expect GTA 6 to be much different to 5

[@CleanBurnout]

I agree, but I also have faith in GTA 6 with the amount of time it is taking. And ye, GTA 4 is probably the closest like you said

[@E46SedanGaming]

To be fair, GTA with BeamNG physics would be beyond playing a slideshow, that would be playing a single picture

[@E46SedanGaming]

@@TelaGamer yes

[@segeros]

​Nope. If you simplify the physics enough (looking at you, Rigs of Rods), you'll succeed and will have GTA 5 with close to BeamNG physics.@@E46SedanGaming

[@ethanwayne6973]

​​@@E46SedanGamingcould you imagine the jato ramp Gavril T-Series (aka faster Phantom Wedge) with BeamNG physics in GTA, you'd be getting 1 FPH at 200 degrees (C)

[@Dat_1person]

Cant perform a robbery without having to switch 76,549 cars

[@blitzerni]

@@Dat_1person For our sins we deserve eternity in hell, but God loves us so much he came as Jesus to pay the price of our sins through living a perfect life for us, his death and his resurrection so we can be forgiven and receive eternal life if we follow and obey him in faith FOR LIFE , Jesus loves u and desires to have a personal relationship with you of love, peace, redemption and obedience ✝️ May Jesus bless you, repent of your sins and turn to Christ before it's too late 🙏🏿❤️

[@Dat_1person]

@blitzerni da fuq is this supposed to be related to my comment?

[@Dat_1person]

@blitzerni also I'm atheist

[@mr0mooz368]

He's a bot

[@skyapexxx]

​@@blitzerniof course you have to have a bot do this for you because no real person would believe in that shit

[@kui2012]

People used to think beamng was gta 5😂😂😂

[@flamenskall2016]

they did both come out in the same year i remember flockin over to whybeare every time he uploaded i haven't had a decent computer until just recently and i still haven't played it for myself yet

[@E46SedanGaming]

That’s like thinking GTA 5 is Car Crushers 2

[@Madanbek_The_Dragon_Lover]

Which ones? I never saw such people

[@nathanstroud2223]

If anything, I think people are more likely to mistake BeamNG for GTA now compared to what the early product looked like in 2013. And I for sure have seen at least one big KZbinr mistake West Coast, USA gameplay for GTA 5.

[@E46SedanGaming]

@@nathanstroud2223 skin that big youtuber, There is no way in christ you’d mistake a sunburst for a sultan

[@Paperrs101]

If GTA 6 has beamng physics it will probably crash my game which it already will without the physics lol

[@shelbysheesh]

So true

[@WOTPOLSKA_PRO]

Because of cheaters maybe

[@Havok_Official]

@@WOTPOLSKA_PROyou don’t have to play GTA online, no one is forcing you to

[@40088922]

a lot of us forget this, but GTA 5's vehicle damage actually used to be a bit more realistic, as in, the cars would deform more, including the roof, but R* took the feature away because of first person view. hopefully we can find a happy middle ground in 6, or maybe even not have first person view anymore, or just do like the video says and disable first person when the roof gets too damaged

[@zenmashh]

The only versions I can think of that still has this feature would be Xbox 360 and PS3

[@gotrickrolledyeah]

​@@zenmashhi still play ps3 version

[@satsumagt5284]

360 version, I remember it

[@dariootero5579]

I dont want first person to be removed I Like it

[@40088922]

@@dariootero5579 I like FPV too, but if removing it was the price to have better vehicle damage, I'd probably accept it, though I don't think it will be a problem in GTA6, Rockstar probably figured something out, if not, well, tough

[@segeros]

Simulation of nodes and beams. All that's needed for the crash physics itself.

[@blitzerni]

For our sins we deserve eternity in hell, but God loves us so much he came as Jesus to pay the price of our sins through living a perfect life for us, his death and his resurrection so we can be forgiven and receive eternal life if we follow and obey him in faith FOR LIFE , Jesus loves u and desires to have a personal relationship with you of love, peace, redemption and obedience ✝️ May Jesus bless you, repent of your sins and turn to Christ before it's too late 🙏🏿❤️❤❤

[@eggs4561]

It's a bit more complex than that.

[@Ratz-s5q]

@@blitzerniyou put black hand emoji, change it to white

[@dashingriggs]

I know a dude on reddit is slowly importing the gta map to beamng. So far he's gotten a couple buildings imported and some roads nearby the central of the town with the skyscrapers. I haven't checked in a while (around a month) and he hasn't posted anything about it yet. It'll take a long time to create for sure, but it looked pretty promising with a download he gave me.

[@satsumagt5284]

That I’d love to see. I’d love even more to see Liberty City from HD Universe into BeamNG, can you imagine the Grand Marshal and Lansdale Taxis doing their job?

[@Itsayush_k]

Share his reddit username. I'd love to help him out with it. Also I wanna play the map he created so far

[@Madanbek_The_Dragon_Lover]

If GTA V will have same physics as BeamNG Drive then: 1) There will be much kess aggression during police chases from both sides: criminals and police; 2) Stunt jump will become WAY MORE RISKY, than they are already; 3) No more need to SHOOT a gas tank pixel to be in a "leaking fuel" state; 4) Much less burnouts for sure (as well as RPM limiting the engine on a Neutral+Handbrake), because the consequences will be more dangerous than just tires popped, such as engine components overheating as well as brakes overheating. 5) Probably fire traps from Arena War will cause engine to actually overheat. At the same logic we could just find an ocean/lake/pool shore and carefully put our engine in water to forcibly cool it doen when the radiator will be damaged and won't be in working condition (without flooding the intakes).

[@satsumagt5284]

6) cars would actually be automatic/DCT or manual, and have dynamic shift points based on throttle input and engine load instead of the current mess we have in GTA V

[@Osifilms22]

Beamng's Physics GTA 6 ❌️ Beamng Career Mode ✅️

[@mkv1.wood1]

If gta 5 had beamng vehicle physics. Youre be able to cook steak on your cpu.

[@mkv1.wood1]

Gta 5 traffic are 2 or 3 times higher than beamng (maybe). So with that much traffic your cpu gonna struggle to simulate beamng physics on gta 5 (unless youre using server cpu like amd threadripper)

[@gnrtx-36969]

well thats the reason they nerfed allot of things in gta v compared to gta 4

[@marsco25177]

There is a fix to that and it already exists in game currently. Have your car be able to take more hits anytime you’re behind the wheel but allow NPC cars have more realistic physics when you’re not in them. How we have this already is with gun battles. PC can be killed with one shot. However, it almost always takes a number of shots to bring you down. I think that is the best of both worlds

[@CallMeDreadingDark]

this guy is underrated, imma be here when he hits 1 mil bruv

[@flamenskall2016]

if you limit then it could happen say like burnout paradise does it could actually be a really cool feature

[@Borexz]

This is the kind of thing I think off when I m trying to sleep great video

[@KellyBeeSan]

That red wagon... Sheesh! 😮‍💨🥵🔥

[@v.s.727]

I finde both games very enjoyable. I love the realistic physics and details in beam, but I also love the freedome and inversion from gta.

[@rayyagamer2011]

I think the best crash model for gta 5 that still looks good is flatout's crash physics,since they didnt allow cabin deformation

[@segeros]

what.

[@eggs4561]

​@@segerosI think he means burnout: paradise

[@Damian-cilr2]

@@eggs4561 no the fuck he doesn't have you not heard of flatout?

[@eggs4561]

@@Damian-cilr2 It was 2am man I forgot about that game

[@Drunken_Hamster]

BeamNG suspension/handling physics but completely rigid chassis and components (sorta like Assetto?), then GRID(2008) destruction with a difficulty toggle to make it mostly visual-only destruction or not. Oh, and probably about 2x the grip as real-life tires with a broader range on the transition between full grip and full slide. THAT is perfect "arcade" physics.

[@GD_Mambra]

Really good video, i love how compact it is. I the September 2022 GTAVI leaks, we saw a car crashing and deforming more realisticaly than in GTAV. it kind "twisted" at the front, so it is not just dents and scratches, its actual deformation. The best i could compare it with is a game called "Wreckfest". GTAVI will most likely not be as extreme with the deformation but how the car deformed looked quite similar.

[@Jason32Bourne]

I use one of the gta v car physics mods, I don't remember which one it is, but it feels amazing and has deformation. It makes you actually have to be good and practice. I also have the manual transmission mod which adds so much in terms of control.

[@shelbysheesh]

Sounds fun!

[@FlooferLand]

Rockstar could always just, not make the cabin deformable, and make the rest of the vehicle deformable. They could also keep the extra toughness of the vehicles in GTA 5, while adding the deformation and driving physics of BeamNG. They couldn't possibly reach the realism of Beam without making GTA 6 very laggy, since Beam is a simulator, but they could try to get as close to it as possible. They did it with GTA 4, a game launched in 2004. The GTA 4 physics were awesome in every way

[@xX_Gravity_Xx]

GTA V with physics modsis pretty satisfying. It sucks that the damage can only ever be what it is. Even if it just had curb damage and bottoming out I'd be happy. The playstyle changes and it's a LOT of fun when you use a physics mod and a surface grip level mod together. Makes driving more of a central focus of the game, and forces you to get good at it.

[@CrystalBalderson]

GTA five gameplay with beamng physics: and this gta four is born

[@2PIXELS24]

Head crushing would be instant death. that's why flipping over would be a death sentence unless you rolled over one time even, and that is deadly

[@DigitalForged]

This would be incredible, but you can only imagine getting into a horrific car accident, and with the soft cars in BeamNG, the scenery of the player in the accident would be grisly.

[@bobogus7559]

2:44 That means it would probably make for a good mod. That way, people can choose whether they want that or not. The first-time player might not care for that, but it makes for a genuine challenge for a better player since the stakes during a chase are raised.

[@shelbysheesh]

🙌

[@manat31790]

An official GTA 6 game with BeamNG driving physics being paired with 2-star police chases or any gang war where the enemies will intentionally shoot guns at and crash into you to stop you will make the game nigh unplayable. Remember that GTA is not a car driving simulator, but a roleplaying game where you play as a criminal that hijacks cars, shoots people, commits drive-by, and reenacts Hollywood-like high-speed chase scenes. If every car breaks down with the slightest touch for the sake of 'realism', you will ensure that people will never play your game because it can never be fun unless you're a driving guru. Yes, GTA 4 had good driving physics, but it's not just about the vehicle realism, it's also about the city designs and layouts where you have to carefully navigate narrow roads while being fast. The cars were less arcade-like floaty than GTA V, but they weren't terribly realistic either. Putting BeanNG physics even in a game like that will turn an already challenging game into an endless frustration.

[@majesticmajesta5463]

They should balance it tbh, Just make the cabin holding the occupants non-destructable except for some dents, Make the drivetrain solid so you can still somewhat drive even after a bad crash, And give the rear/front end of the car soft body physics but 3× stronger than in Beamng so it'll still be as playable but also a little more realistic.

[@thekangaroo1880]

GTA5 did have decent vehicle damage on the Xbox 360 and PS3 versions of the game. Thanks to reworking the game from the ground up and adding in first person, things had to be dialled down. Also would like to point out the lack of gravity effect in the game. Cars can easily flop around and do not accelerate at a rate believable to represent the acceleration due to gravity when let's say, driving off a building.

[@SALON_V_STILE_TRIBAL]

if gta 5 had a beamng physics it would be a game of a time

[@Jeremy_Hill_2020]

imagine trying to evade police with a 3 star wanted level & griefers & a NPC decides to cut you off making the front of your car torn off

[@Galvatron99]

The fact that the tank in gta5 can deform vehicles more than crashes is interesting and give us how realistic crashes would look like

[@shelbysheesh]

Good observation!

[@gamingfrog1234]

its not just the crash physics, the driving is also much more realistic, it simulates pretty much everything in a real car

[@kgxtofpugjrzoyclhc5330]

All physics in GtA6 better be top notch! All of it! Its been 100 years since 5 came out. We better be blown away by 6 or im dumping rock star😮

[@bakerap2211]

“You see, vehicles in BeamNG can deform easily. Just like I-“ *permanent hearing loss*

[@shelbysheesh]

Sorry about that..

[@youravghuman5231]

Short answer for vehicle realism is it will take fun out for majority of players. People would totaled their cars just a second after they steal it and died from the police.

[@ronnie7aep]

I was waiting, thinking bro would install a beam ng car mod for gta 5 💀

[@mr0mooz368]

Yeah i think i got scammed

[@remuz3561]

It would be cool if it had such physics, maybe not exactly 1:1 to beamng but enough to make it count when you collide at high speeds, making high speed chases less forgiving and having it take skill to be a getaway driver or else you'd just always crash, total your car and have to resort to a shootout and grand theft auto to retry escaping with a civ car ;D

[@WOTPOLSKA_PRO]

People can't drive, that's about it, Sim racing is way more fun than arcade

[@joey87589]

Remember, Beamng drive has SOFT BODY physics, so in terms of that its realistic

[@The_Noobest_Player]

but what if the GTA Online servers had options such as arcade and realism, and the campaign would also have that

[@jackdesanta69]

Modder spamming hundreds of cargo planes: 💀💀💀

[@UnreasonablyIrrelevant-gv8xx]

2:30 "even such a *small* hit like that-" bro your rim is an oval 😂

[@sandstinger3454]

GTA 4 has one of the best deformation in the series

[@dopebossgamerz]

Theres also the fact that most people wouldent get more then a couple cars with good framerates and even the best pcs wouldent be able to fill a busy 4 lane highway. Gta6 will liekly have a more realistic damage model similar to wreck fest but will still be arcady and one crash won't disable your car.

[@techbaffle]

GTA 5 takes more of an arcade style to driving. The fact that the cars handle easily, and damage less means the game can focus more on weapons and other destruction. It would be funny if GTA 6 had an Advanced Mode which allowed your car to be damaged more easily.

[@オDarkAngelMVPヅ]

but, GTA VI could add a different mode than online or story mode, freeplay mode, in freeplay mode, cheats, flying, invulnerability, infinite money, everything should be allowed. and in freeplay mode, if you want, you can turn on vehicle physics too!

[@takumikid]

if gta had beam physics id play it

[@Sebastian-yt1zh]

The cops: sir we need more vehicles he keeps juking us

[@Boypogikami132]

They should really open up cabin destruction again, but make it so that you die when the roof crushes into itself

[@arandominternetperson4462]

Have you heard of GTA 4?

[@jamiereddy6128]

well they abandoned that so yaa

[@satsumagt5284]

GTA IV is nowhere near as good as BeamNG is

[@geehammer1511]

R* disabled roof deformation in GTA V after they PS4 era when they introduced 1st person view. On PS3/X-360 cars deform a lot more.

[@IllegallyAcquiredKIA]

They could make GTA 6 where stock cars crash like beamng then make it so when you put 100% armor on its more similar to GTA 5

[@shelbysheesh]

Great idea!

[@Bahnfanatiker]

BNG Physics in GTA would make a total different game. I don't think a worse game, it just would play different and in my opinion it would be interesting.

[@sgovender1994]

I enjoyed the hypotheticals and pretty visuals. I hope GTA VI has a more realistic physics model than GTA V. I miss being able to power slide cars without having to pay Hao $200 000 first.

[@elusivephantom7040]

I would love for GTA to take a similar route but a little less extreme. It would be super fun to be racing through traffic trying to get away from someone and then you have the serious consequence of crashing. Plus if you have a serious crash and survive it then your forced to exit your car and start a gunfight to defend yourself as you attempt to get a new one. Its GTA (Grand Theft Auto) I want to have a real reason to ditch my supercar and steal a normal car. Right now the GTA damage models is just an annoying inconvenience but if the damage model was better I think it would add consequences and therefore more fun.

[@MICKEY-LOGANO]

To be honest, I want to see this in GTA 6. Plus, it would make car chases more interesting & fun imo.

[@Erryl_Edits]

And driving fast will be too risky

[@FNAFPIZZAFAN]

Flying upside down in a car in gtav gives me ptsd

[@jamiereddy6128]

no if the roof caves in or smth the character ducks down if it gets to caved in you die if you get hit from the side character gets pushed through the center of the car going in the passenger seat if there is a passenger you die if it gets to caved in you die

[@thfrussia6717]

this could be working only if they allow flexible mod system like in minecraft. because first - they don't make a realistic damage system because most of people wouldn't see it playable and like it, and second - such thing take a big part of the game resources and calculations

[@sandcrakes]

This can be modded with Deformation mod + the GTA 4 handling. It's not the same, but it will make it better

[@cherrythehusky9911]

The soccer mom van though💀💀

[@OmegaHellHound543]

GTA's damage physics need work regardless. I swear, every new car they add is done by a different part of the dev team. Some can be bent into literal toasters while others don't even deform. Hopefully they fix that in GTA 6.

[@Zunix24]

i'd like to see a mixture of gta 4 and gta 5 driving physics into gta 6. an accurate simulation just like beam ng wouldn't work well in the genre.

[@djclipbasslower2519]

Maybe it could be an optional setting you could enable to have that deformation or just regular gta physics.

[@huntaaa4]

that would make gta a hell of a lot more fun

[@DangerAngelous]

Bro the first time I played GTA V I spun the car out because I was too used to GTA IV’s physics

[@Dxeeny55881]

would be perfect imo. BeamNG need GTA AI traffic and GTA need beamNG handling physic and crash physic.

[@ILOVEsnickers15]

GTA 4 had similar crash and driving physics to BeamNG, the reason why GTA 5 cars are tanks is because ppl complained that GTA 4s cars were too hard to drive.

[@exrahh]

if gta had handling physics like beam all of the casual players that don’t care about cars would hate it

[@PepGuardiola4805]

Just make it so that it has the same physics but it takes less damages,make car repairs cost less also

[@kidmyron3751]

Everyone who tought we gonna see gta 5 with beamng physics put your hands up :(

[@bradentheman1373]

ive been thinking about this

[@ShadowAkatora]

They should have used damage physics closer to what was in GTA 4 imo.

[@MA-jz4yc]

The cabin deforms in gta 4

[@KennstWohlKeinSarkasmus]

GTA IV ragdoll physics should be come back in gta 6 in a better version with better driving physics as V and more detailed damage as IV. I miss so much things in GTA V

[@HysteriaDelirium]

Gta 4 physics were perfect when it came to combat and driving

[@andipajeroking]

That would look like GTA 4 ❤

[@2xShlong]

Just an idea but what if you could change the deformation settings in gta 6, like say your doing a heist online and they have a easy, medium, and hard setting and hard is like just straight up realism versus easy which could just be more like gta 5 and when ur not doing a heist you can just have a setting to change if you want heavy mid or light car deformation physics, would make more since

[@shelbysheesh]

I’m all for this!

[@bartholomulethe3rd]

The owner of fivem should see if they can buy a license for the engine bmg uses tbh

[@engineerbeta1515]

Gta 5 story : more realistic Gta Online : Arcade driving

[@anonymousunknow5612]

Ppl who watch the entire video tryna see both games combined 😂

[@MogTheg]

i saw gta 6 leaks and car phisics are amazing

[@HeyhoBrando]

I will always say gta 4 had better car damage like I remember if you hit the car hard enough the car would not even drive

[@Heyant]

Let's say beamng is 100 on the scale while gta v is around a 10 on the scale. What people that are asking want is the deformation of beam with the rigidity of gta, so basically, 50 - 60% of beamngs physics

[@shelbysheesh]

That could possibly work

[@AussieGunzel]

So it's basically GTA 4

[@jamiereddy6128]

beamng drive and gta have to partner up call it gta6-beamng drive partner edtion like gta6 normal edtion then beamng edtion just crash physics

[@twicethefun5949]

0:54 i had earpods on and it 1 am my heart

[@shelbysheesh]

I set the volume too high for that, sorry..

[@waynepayne9875]

It shouldn't be as realistic as beamNg but it should be more realistic than GTA 5.

[@mrschoko565]

They won’t have real crash physics because the car companies don’t want there cars to be crashed and so on

[@Yes-lq4bb]

This sounds difficult to do, but why not make a specific part of the car destructible so you get awesome physics while still being able to see from the cabin?

[@shelbysheesh]

I like this idea a lot!

[@thomashenderson8630]

You do not say that because if they really do day they will hold GT a 6 back.Don't say it😮

[@Gdud2727]

Just imagine the gta cops with there terrible ai with beaming physics.

[@viperdio69420]

Yessir

[@gdjejfvfvbdbfjfjfj450]

Gta v :arcade physics Beamng:rl It would be a crime if soft body physics were included in gta v game engine gta v is completely perfect with these physics I love the game because of the arcade physics it's funnier and more enjoyable

[@hampter_gamingyt]

gta 5 cars dont worry abt repairing remember just respawn the car

[@JusAFurryThatLikeAviation.]

"Oo O O O O H M y P C"

[@Dead_inside7240]

I actually did that using mids of native trainer and menyoo mod menu combination

[@V-Y-K-T-O-R]

Old gta 5 cars has deformation but new ones don't