What if Lotso Was Good? Toy Story Theories

What if Lotso didn't turn evil in Toy Story 3? A brand new series of alternative plot points and fan fiction though out the Toy Story franchise. Edited and Narrated by Shahzaib Yaqoob
#toystory #theory #lotso

[@Kirby_Tankson_39]

I definitely like this alternative timeline, and this alternative Lotso. Definitely 1000 Times better than the real Lotso. I feel sad about seeing Woody staying with Andy, but it’s better than Toy Story 4’s ending.

[@spideybatt]

true

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

I hate that film!

[@chickenkid7072]

@@AlfieTrevor4444he’s saying that toy story 4s ending was good

[@aureliamastergoomba1278]

Woody is loyal to Andy to a fault, he knows that Andy does care about them, besides, he at least manages to get there

[@maxkelley2003]

Yeah. By the way didn’t Woody fight against Lotso and get him off him when Lotso dragged him into the dump with him because Lotso wasn’t seen after that when they all were

[@dantecopy4619]

I think he should stay with andy Plus I like imagining that eventually Andy has a kid of his own and he drops him off to sunny side with woody

[@nicksolis555]

Ideas: What if Andy got Spider-Man What If Andy got the 2022 lightyear version of Buzz lightyear What if stinky Pete never turned on woody What if utility belt buzz and zurg went with the toys What if wheezy’s squeaker was never broken

[@divinechild_creativerebellion]

These What if Episodes are very well written 👏 👌

[@oliverpony]

I just remember in the video how it should have ended woody saying : Daisy didn't replace you her parents did and the only reason why they had to do that is because she did love you

[@thomaspixarmarvelfan]

I absolutely love this! This reminds me of the Disney+ MCU series What If…? and it would be awesome if Pixar could make a What If series with the original voice actors reprising their roles. It’s too bad Ned Beatty passed away because this would be a perfect way to show an alternative version of Lotso as a caring and grandfatherly character as opposed to the cruel and evil tyrant we got in Toy Story 3.

[@calypso_th]

Idea: What if Woody met one of his replicas?

[@michaelgualtieri651]

I can't be the only one who thinks Lotso got off WAY to easy in Toy Story 3 right? I mean that strawberry smelling psycho was a total dictator and than left Woody and others to die in the indicator, despite the fact they saved his life litteraly 2 minutes prior. And you mean to tell me that all that happens to him is getting tied to the front of a Garbage truck?

[@KDawg92801]

He can’t corrupt sunnyside anymore

[@michaelgualtieri651]

@@KDawg92801 True, and that is a plus.

[@EthanEs-hp6nn]

Yea that’s why they dropped his redemption because they wanted people to know that Lotso got what he deserved in the end. And another reason is because they didn’t want Lotso to get off so easy and for people to sympathise with the heroes more

[@Knightrogue24.]

This theory makes me feel a lot better for lotso, it convinces me to forgive him. Unlike the original timeline where he becomes jealous n evil. I was thinking of bringing lotso back in my alternate timeline story for my personal written toy story 4 n 3, 3 is the prologue because they don't end up Sunnyside and 4 is the main story because my take on 4 is differently written. I'm not going to spoil my story , lotso happens to be at the dump, where two of my antagonist toy characters are in the last place I left off. And I was also going to bring back stinky pete but I'm thinking this should reflect my version of lotso in my story Unlike stinky pete where he's still tempted to get revenge on woody but lotso may just be able to change the prospector in my story. The two antagonist toys in my story are imposter buzz and Luke Skywalker. And also Darth Vader. The story setup is close to the original toy story but in my story Andy has a family and has a son and a baby daughter . He kept his toys at the end of three and passed them on to his son Antony in the beginning of 4. Except now Jesse is back with Emily, bo peep has been retrieved and buzz and woody become less happy when Luke and Vader arrive, and imposter buzz is a thrift store old toy same as when buzz lightyear toys came out and he had an owner named Harold but he was donated, because video games took over.

[@sonicfan7643]

the story is pretty good, I think that instead of leaving it off there we get to see the gang decide to go like Woody did, they can convince Lotso to go with them and like the original Andy will the toys in the box including Lotso and they can be given away or put in the attic then at the very end Andy is back with his kids and give the toys to them and the gang and Lotso can finally feel the joy of being played with again and to be there for a kid once again (I still love this story tho)

[@Teh69thSpartan]

Here's a few ideas mine for theories. 1: What if Andy met Sid & his toys during Toy Story 1? 2: What if Andy never tried to giveaway the toys during Toy Story 3? 3: What if Andy also owned Bullseye, Jessie & Stinky Pete during Toy Story 1?

[@ronbinscatsco5249]

What about jessie

[@alvarer1]

Can you please do What if Woody stayed with Andy in Toy Story 3

[@Leah-ki7gm]

Yea I really wanted him to be good

[@BarakaPlay]

This is amazing and very well narrated!

[@mattthebfdiandagufan1st772]

Idea: What if toys that disappeared between Toy Story 2-3 (like Wheezy, Mr. Spell, Bo Peep, Etch, RC, Sarge and the Soldiers, Rocky Gibraltar, Robot, Snake, etc.) were in Toy Story 3.

[@gemmaburge2178]

Good idea

[@Gpzeldafan10]

You’re a genius!

[@mattthebfdiandagufan1st772]

@@Gpzeldafan10 Thanks!

[@Gpzeldafan10]

@@mattthebfdiandagufan1st772 No problem! It seems like a great idea, and Toy Story 3 would be completely different.

[@mattthebfdiandagufan1st772]

@@Gpzeldafan10 Yep. Plus, it would be great if all minor Andy toys that disappeared between Toy Story 2-3 got screentime. I would even be glad is See N' Say from Toy Story 1 appeared

[@alexpadilla1207]

Can You Please Do What if Stinky Pete Never Betrayed Woody? Toy Story Theories, and What if Losto Pushed The Button? Toy Story Theories.

[@EthanEs-hp6nn]

Yea id love to see the one if Lotso pushed the button

[@latinomarcobelvis2133]

If Lotso Did Push The Button Than He Would've Been In Least Evil Category Of Pixar Villians Evil To Most Evil Instead. And Would Have Been In The Heroes Wiki

[@bendyfan-yd1ez]

Here some ideas for what If What if woody convinced bo beep to come with him with bonnie. What if buzz & Zurg got bought at the same time. What if sporky never came alive. What if Andy kept his toys.

[@chilldedede]

forky*

[@damianhendriks6162]

1. Amazing 2. Painful 3. YES YES YES 4. Best

[@damianhendriks6162]

Here's a suggestion: what if Andy took all his toys (yes, even the potato heads) to college?

[@SonicJrandSarah]

If this was the plot of Toy Story 3, I feel as though it would work better at the end of the movie. Like maybe the movie could be about the toys watching as Andy grows up, and then at the end of the movie, this is the scene that plays out.

[@kaidenzarif9086]

Do what if gabby gabby's voice box wasn't broken

[@kaidenzarif9086]

Do what if ken and barbie join Andy’s toys to try and help rescue woody from the dumpster in Toy Story 3

[@EthanEs-hp6nn]

Lotso would most likely betray Ken and leave him for dead with Andy’s toys in the incinerator

[@Thenarrowgaugeengines3690]

@@EthanEs-hp6nn the Aliens would still save Andy’s Toys, Ken and Barbie

[@duanesmith1989]

I think Woody should stay because it won't be the same without him.

[@Sonicfan2592]

Suggestion: What if Jessie tried to help Woody in Toy Story 4

[@sir.confident]

Now, this was an amazing story! Perhaps if it went like this, the saga wouldn't have been killed by Toy Story 4.

[@jonmcinnis1645]

What if lightyear version of buzz meets toy story version of buzz?

[@DeclanColwell]

I’m pretty certain that the replacement Lotso Daisy now has is a pure-hearted good counterpart of the evil Lotso.

[@caribou3552]

Here’s an idea, What If Woody And Forky Never Went To The Antique Store?

[@damianhendriks6162]

What if Emily kept Jessie (except, unlike the one you made, it supports the Emily Davis theory)

[@matthewsoares9880]

This is lovely.

[@RyanMattingly-2023rtm]

For my future universe that has my Spider-Man character, Wayne Werewolf, Mr. Smee, and the Toy Story gang, Lotso was a good guy, and the main villain of that story was Spider-Man’s old archenemy, the Green Goblin, who takes control of Sunnyside Daycare. 😊

[@spencer9183]

Gotta say i would have loved for lotso to have turned good

[@LucyVanPelt2022]

I mean Andy intended to take Woody to collage with him so well he HAD to be there for Andy. Andy also was trying to put the other toys in the attic to keep them safe but they were mistaken for trash due to being in a trash bag

[@theganonmastermindcrapprod1798]

What if this Version of Lotso somehow found Andy’s Place before the Events of Toy Story 2 instead of Ending up at Sunnyside?

[@BlakeJ-bl1gj]

Maybe He Would

[@kaidenzarif9086]

Or maybe after he leaves daisy’s house and try to find another place to get play he gets found by Bonnie’s grandma and she takes him to the hospital and and give him to baby Bonnie as a gift on the day she was born

[@KDawg92801]

@@kaidenzarif9086that would actually be a good story, you should do it yourself

[@Kirby_Tankson_39]

I missed this series

[@tannermacdonald1239]

What if buzz was Andy’s toy in the first movie and woody came over and thought he was a real cow boy

[@nicksolis555]

Do what if stinky Pete never betrayed woody

[@2182jenny]

Hi I would like to see you make a video of what if buzz kept his Spanish mode

[@businessgamer2668]

I’ll bet that even though Lotso was good here. The toys would have the immediate urge to return home if it wasn’t for Mrs. Potato Heads eye.

[@ciarangleeson2880]

I think that they would explain their situation to Lotso, and he would be more understanding and willing to let them leave. After Woody would arrive back from Bonnie’s house, Lotso would explain that his friends already set off for home, so Woody would head back to Andy’s house and meet the gang there. The ending would be more or less the same, with Andy still passing his toys along to Bonnie.

[@simonlarkins7531]

Do a Toy Story theory on What If Bo went home with Woody in the end of Toy Story 4

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

That'd be a better ending

[@gl6806]

Can you do Toy Story What if but if Andy took all of his toys to college and didn’t give the toys to Bonnie

[@masteroflaughter870]

You should do “What if Andy got the Roundup gang (Jessie the Cowgirl, Stinky Pete the Prospector, and Bullseye the Horse) in Toy Story” (they and Woody manage to protect each other and Andy’s other toys from Sid and Andy ends up getting Buzz Lightyear on Christmas Day).

[@nilehoruseus]

What if Woody was captured by Gabby Gabby in the beginning of Toy Story 4?

[@hedgehog07productions91]

Toy Story What If: What If Buzz is the main character

[@JE-wg3jv]

I think their is a book Buzz is the main character and narrated the story it’s called I come in Peace, especially Rex only in TS2.

[@gabrielstudio5497]

I want to see a what if stinky Pete went with the toys to Andy

[@HAZBINHOTELGFAN]

I think this could go in a very good way this time Andy's toys can get to stay in the butterfly room and have a good playtime not like the rough one they originally had in the original timeline they'll actually enjoy Sunnyside so far then Mrs potato head will see in her other eye she left behind at Andy's house that Andy's mom realized the mistake she made then they'll realize that Andy needs them so they ask lotso if they can leave lotso actually agrees and helps them with directions back to Andy's house they make their way back just in time Andy's about almost done packing up and they toys come in through the window meanwhile Woody's just in the box with Andy's stuff that he's gonna take with him to collage he recognizes the voices and peeps out of the box to see that all his friends have decided to come back home he's seems happy to see them all the toys apologize for not believing Woody at first they bid farewells and Woody realises that Andy is grown up and doesn't need him anymore but his friends still do in a last minute attempt Woody successfully sneaks into the box with his friends and they all get put in the attic they all seemed confused on why Woody is not going with Andy Woody tells them it's ok he looks to buzz and says my Mission with Andy is complete and what's important now is we stay together they all hug and live out their days in the attic awaiting what the future may bring for them

[@chilldedede]

This makes me like Lotso

[@vahidhosoda6614]

Then mrs potato would find out Andy was really wanting them they would’ve been in the attic still once deciding to come back they would escape easy without lotso being a dictator after returning woody would realize it’s time to say goodbye again they would’ve never met Bonnie at all unless woody was chosen by Bonnie then the plot would become the same

[@kaidenzarif9086]

Do what if Andy takes both woody and buzz to collage instead of one of them

[@Thenarrowgaugeengines3690]

Then Jessie would take over as Leader of the toys while Woody and Buzz went with Andy to collage

[@evanmiller2472]

Heres one, what if Sid's mutant toys left with Woody and Buzz to live with Andy?

[@aureliamastergoomba1278]

So Woody stays loyal to a fault. I actually had one if you want to hear it.

[@StrawberryShortcakeFTW]

Can you do what if stinky pete was good, and went with woody

[@rahmadewi255]

I love this alternative timeline. I dont want that fluffy magenta with strawberry scented bear becomes a bad character. And i actually want woody stays with Andy forever.

[@damianhendriks6162]

Mr Potato Head never got himself filled with sand, right?

[@kaidenzarif9086]

Do what if bonnie dose get a mini buzz as a kids meal toy instead of the zurg belt buckle

[@GuyWebz]

Can you do what if Al was caught for stealing Woody?

[@JE-wg3jv]

Imagine Buzz caught Al very quickly before he gets inside to his car.

[@victorishema6427]

At least Lotso tries to be nice in the movie Toy Story 3

[@josefengelhardt2767]

You mean he was pretending to be nice cause deep down inside Lotso is pure evil

[@EthanEs-hp6nn]

Fax

[@nicolelawless9942]

Yea, he’s just hiding his true identity, thank god Woody.EXE isn’t like that because he cares for my wellbeing so much that he admitted me to hospital when Woody.EXE noticed something was very wrong and I had collapsed in front of him. I’m alive today because of his bravery

[@kaidenzarif9086]

Do what if the toys call the police on al for stealing woody from the yard sale in toy story 2

[@2182jenny]

Hi can you please make a video of toystory what if stinky pete went to Andy's house

[@Nick-zj2bv]

When does live action toy story 2 come out?

[@BlakeJ-bl1gj]

November 2023

[@oliverthegreatwesternengin6685]

What if Jessie was the Main Role in Toy Story 3

[@denisebither4810]

I think woddy would stay with his friends

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

I feel bad for Lotso tbh What he did was beyond wrong but I can't help but feel a little bad for him And this good Lotso is definitely sympathetic

[@josefengelhardt2767]

I don't feel bad for Lotso because his tragic past is not an excuse for his actions. He was just Pure Evil. He took his anger out on toys that had nothing to do with him being replaced

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

@@josefengelhardt2767 did I ever say it was an excuse?

[@josefengelhardt2767]

@@AlfieTrevor4444 no i'm just saying Lotso does not deserve any sympathy with or without a tragic past.

[@AlfieTrevor4444]

​@@josefengelhardt2767I feel bad he had to see Daisy with another toy and it literally broke his heart But ye what he did really made me angry at him and you are right but I still feel bad for him when it comes to the "tragic past" alone

[@josefengelhardt2767]

@@AlfieTrevor4444 there are some people in real life like Lotso. Some of these recent mass shooters because similar to Lotso they don't want to love or feel loved in case they might again experience that horrible feeling of abandonment. And they project their feelings of abandonment onto others

[@ocean9983]

what is the music at the very beginning of the video

[@Lil_slack]

I felt like he turn into to a sociopath

[@gemmaburge2178]

Do what if bo peep duke ducky bunny woody and the cop girl comes with the other toys

[@damianhendriks6162]

Woody should stay at Sunnyside.

[@KingJuliantheloneliestwolf]

What if stinky Pete was a good guy

[@louistudor1086]

Well the plot would be better if lotso was a good bear that would make the movie great if this happened in the movie their won’t be Toy Story 3

[@adammartinez8061]

One thing though……..remember when Woody escapes the daycare…..he gets taken by Bonnie? Does that still happen?????

[@JE-wg3jv]

Hmmm…. possibly yes. I remember a little bit, Mrs Potato Head learned the truth Andy still needs Buzz, Woody and other toys before he’s ready to live on his own and being a student in college, they probably have to wait for a day, when Woody picks up the gangs and find the way getting back to Andy’s house earlier as possible.

[@pervertedstoner69reborn70]

It wasn’t until Woody tried to leave through the cat flap at Bonnie’s house that there was much of a difference. The rest of Bonnie’s toys would have shrugged off Woody’s request that if they make it to Sunnyside, that they would tell the others Woody made it home. When they found that out in the original timeline, they were shocked and thus prompted Chuckles (Who is absent in the theoretical scenario) to explain to Woody the true nature of the “evil bear who smells of strawberries”.

[@adammartinez8061]

⁠@@pervertedstoner69reborn70 So Woody would never have gone back to SunnySide.

[@pervertedstoner69reborn70]

@@adammartinez8061 And the rest of Andy’s Toys would be finding their own way home to both chew him out for abandoning them to begin with and then apologize for not believing him that Andy still cared about them enough to put them in the attic.

[@DonaldTheScottishTwin57646]

See? Instead of making sequels, make what ifs for your previous works.

[@Manuqtix.Manuqtix]

stay at sunnyside Pretoria

[@mostafaabdelaziz7850]

I would have rather had woody stay

[@danielbocz3918]

I've got a better Toy Story what if? for you. What if Lotso didn't notice the button?

[@Thenarrowgaugeengines3690]

Then he and Andy’s Toys would all be in the Incinerator

[@danielbocz3918]

@@Thenarrowgaugeengines3690 But the Aliens would still save them all with the claw.

[@Thenarrowgaugeengines3690]

@@danielbocz3918 even Lotso

[@danielbocz3918]

@@Thenarrowgaugeengines3690 Then what would happen after that?

[@Thenarrowgaugeengines3690]

@@danielbocz3918 the toys would head back to Andy’s House

[@malakyedoesvoices7142]

This is a sad but great what if video🥲👍❤

[@jonmcinnis1645]

@malakyedoesvoices7142 if Woody and Lotso saw Woody X Lotso Woody(shows a cringed out expression):I’m not into Foe Yay Shipping. Sorry. Lotso(shows a disgusted expression):I’m not into LGBT. Sorry.

[@Xavier-the-voodoo-king]

Can you do what if stinky pete/prospector was good and went with andys toys and what if woody and buzz swapped places were buzz is andy's favorite toy and knows he's a toy and woody is the new toy and believes he really is a cowboy

[@damianhendriks6162]

Alright, so Andy got Buzz first and Mom found a Woody that was never alive at the antique store.

[@Xavier-the-voodoo-king]

@@damianhendriks6162 I mean it would be pretty interesting he could even change it to where buzz is the rare to from the 50s-60s and woody is the new popular toy at Al's toy barn

[@damianhendriks6162]

I have a idea: what if Hasbro refused to let Pixar use Mr Potato Head?