What If Month: Duncan Didn't Wake Up In The Dodgeball Challenge

[@thearmchairgamer2668]

What if Heather didn't steal Eva's MP3 player but instead caused a fight between Kaite and Sadie

[@miguellikestotaldrama]

Katie got a MAJOR improvement in this universe 😮

[@TotalDramaKalo]

she deserves it

[@dougtheghoul2845]

In the original season, I was expecting Sadie to find new friends without Katie. Like in phobia factor challenge, it seemed like Sadie and Lindsey were going to become friends but nothing really came out of it

[@windynalison4869]

Ya, because she have to prove that her bestie and her have to be popular🎉

[@JoboGamezzz]

Would be cool if we saw team escope form in the merge

[@brandonridge1342]

Already got your next What if: What if Harold didn't get distracted by Heather's boobs

[@DG_editsroblox]

Whenever Katie takes a chance she takes it far✋🤭✨

[@PerpIsSpoopy]

Request : what if heather didn’t have plot armor

[@Novaughe]

she would get out 4th

[@Hm_a_random_dude]

No, she would get out in Justin's elimination

[@snobey]

My theory: Courtney wouldn't kick Duncan anyway because she was attracted, she was just lying to motivate him. And if the lost, Harold would be kicked out.

[@SpeakNowCourtney]

Wait noooo Duncney would have never happened:(((

[@jaxonjarosinski]

What if Sam completed the pancake in all stars?

[@KJBobbyBillyjo]

I think that Katie would've been eliminated instead of Leshawna. I would love the finale to be between Gwen and Leshawna

[@NicverdiNWah]

What if Heather didn't distract Harold?

[@PsycosmicDigital]

Katie says go big or go home-

[@CrimsonLoki]

Now that I think about it. It really annoyed me that sadie had no story when Katie left. Like they could’ve made her try to make friends with Bridgette or someone else.

[@mariodobrev3105]

Harold won't side with his archenemy's love interest. He should side with DJ and Bridgette.

[@adammartinez8061]

What if Katie Won Total Drama Island?

[@sh4ane]

katie is one of my favs i’m so glad she made it far 😭😭

[@TotalDramaKalo]

Same, she deserves redemption :)

[@squidward1024]

What if Heather manipulated Duncan and kissed him infront of Courtney

[@adammartinez8061]

About 8:01. I just did a what if A.I generator to see what would happen in order for Katie to win and she kept getting immunity 💀.

[@boringchelseafan]

In this reality, Geoff could technically be considered a 2-time winner. I would happily accept that success!

[@dougtheghoul2845]

Or they would make the best friends finalists instead. Not sure if true of not but ridonculous race had multiple winning teams drafted with ice dancers always dropping in third place

[@mattspacc8570]

I dont know why but Geoff gets so much far in this what ifs

[@Catvinity]

Ok but 100% true but I would hate this universe lol But not knocking on you you did it perfectly I’m just saying it would be a very boring season to watch cuz Duncan was an mc of the season

[@Hello_7383]

Gj for Katie making the top 3. I feel like in the actual total drama, they should of voted Sadie instead of Katie tbh. Katie was much better than Sadie.

[@nozominous2956]

I’m not sure if Bridgette convincing the others to vote Courtney fully makes sense, like weren’t they friends in Island?

[@code_purple3348]

alternate title: what if Duncan died

[@playtaggerbutexistsreal]

Day 2 of asking: what if chef declined on blaineley’s alliance

[@maxchristopher4352]

In are we there Yeti Chef is gonna Geoff over Owen because Owen is only one who likes his food.

[@иир-у6и]

Cortney and Bridgette friends, why she vote for her ? And geoff like Cortney too

[@mattspacc8570]

What if the bass found out that Heather stole the MP3 and loss(vote out Heather)

[@Yourpositivefatbestie]

Day 2 of asking what if katie and izzy didn't switch teams

[@hanslaurens6851]

What if Harold didnt give up in ep3 of world tour?

[@TheIceCreamWizard]

Without Duncan to tell the Killer Bass not to vote Courtney, no one is keeping Courtney around in Phobia Factor.

[@imjusthimfrfr]

I love that u gave noah the improvement he rlly deserved good job 🎉

[@Numberonetreemoteshipper]

What If B Talked?

[@EiscueBall]

I feel like they would’ve kicked Tyler out instead of Duncan. At least Duncan was useful last episode, being the last bass awake, unlike Tyler who messed up in both challenges

[@lechuguin3319]

I think in basic straining Courtney wouldn't be eliminated. Since Duncan is eliminated earlier Harold wouldn't be that bullied so Bridgette would not interact with him that much. Bridgette is friends with Courtney and Courtney is friends with Katie. Geoff and Bridgette like each other, the outcast is Harold, so he gets voted off. And with Harold gone it would really change things since Killer bass wouldn't lose next challenge

[@Beth_220]

I would like Katie and Geoff as finalists better tbh but thats ok too

[@TotalDramaKalo]

same but Gwen can beat her

[@bombwajasz391]

I appreciate you using suggestions i gave you in the episode when noah wasnt useless in dodgeball! very cool video:))

[@ErinIsBack]

Katie is so underrated

[@gavinskinner968]

Video Idea: What if Owen got eliminated in Episode 10: If you can't take the heat.

[@lechuguin3319]

Also, would you do what ifs of other seasons?

[@TotalDramaKalo]

yeah, but not next month cause it's tiring and i need a break

[@LemonLoverXD]

Wow! I didn't expect that! BTW Is it just me or this man just makes plot twists?

[@Yourpositivefatbestie]

Day 2 of asking what if katie and izzy didn't switch teams

[@willbyers5700]

I thought it was gonna be about his elimination lol I don’t know what will be for heather and Gwen but I think for Owen it is what if he got eliminated in episode 10

[@TotalDramaKalo]

if it was his elimination, it would have been a really short video

[@willbyers5700]

@@TotalDramaKalo fair

[@Kerem_ozzy]

Katie always gets 3rd I feel like ur biased on Katie (no hate) but just make her win a season 😭

[@TotalDramaKalo]

this is (in my opinion) the most logical way the season would go if an event doesn't occur like in the show. ive made many mistakes ofc but im happy when people correct me :))

[@Kerem_ozzy]

@@TotalDramaKalo oh ok ty for explaining

[@Valentina-ci8ww]

I wish Katie won but I’m glad she made it far

[@Thatrandomplanet]

What animation studio did u use to make this

[@TotalDramaKalo]

I use Powerpoint to create almost all of my vids :) I save the presentations as videos, AFTER I record their timings! Then, I put the intro, outro and music using Clipchamp :)

[@satorigoku316]

I actually want to see this as the show it would make so much more sense with the show

[@dougtheghoul2845]

I would have sent home LeShawna in the triathlon challenges as she would be the biggest threat. Sure Noah is a smartass and they could grow tired of his attitude but he isn't good at the challenges. And then send home Katie after Sadie and others say her name.

[@rgbeet]

This is the premise for the fanfic "For Want of a Mohawk", it's a really good fanfic. Go look it up.

[@kizmation]

Nah dude i dont think he would have been eliminated cause they knew how strong he was so they wouldn't have voted hik out

[@TotalDramaKalo]

I mean Courtney said she'd eliminate him

[@kizmation]

@@TotalDramaKalo sorry man forgot

[@иир-у6и]

​@@TotalDramaKalo it s just threat

[@rachelzellmer]

Owen was not the first caught but technically the first out in the serial killer challenge. Personally I don’t see Katie doing well in that challenge because of how she panics in critical situations

[@Supreme-AMVs]

Can you stop giving immunity in episode 20, that challenge had no immunity to win, it was just a reward for some good food, no one was actually immune in that episode.

[@TotalDramaKalo]

well, still the winner wouldn't receive votes, soooo

[@entymash]

Okay, but why does Owen vote for Leshawna so often in these? I don't think he ever did that in canon.

[@blakeanderson629]

What if Duncan was on the screaming ghopers😊

[@Jackmoo101]

what if heather didnt steal eva’s headphones

[@TheSilliestGoose655]

I have a feeling this guy is a fan of Katie

[@TotalDramaKalo]

I am :)! But that doesn't give her a high place her, only logic!

[@PurpleLyndzee]

What If: Eva won the first challenge in the merge?

[@TotalDramaKalo]

i have done it

[@sadies.bfffl.forever]

in my head katie won

[@casswhitehill9522]

Sadie out to early man :(

[@CJM94]

No one cares

[@TotalDramaKalo]

rude

[@casswhitehill9522]

@@CJM94 I am a Sadie fan. If you don't like her, I honestly couldn't care less. But how do you know nobody cares? You aren't everybody :)

[@casswhitehill9522]

@@TotalDramaKalo lol

[@lotsopontso4023]

Nah you gave Katie way to much plot armor, she was going home in episode 5 and Sadie still gets eliminated like in canon since her elimination wasn't really a plan by Duncan, more from Courtney, and on Ep 12 I think Bridgette and Courtney were good friends so they most likely are voting for Harold first but even without Duncan he might still rig the votes since he knows how to do it

[@TotalDramaKalo]

ok

[@Ieshawna]

she didn't had no plot armor, this was made logically. I only think she would've placed 5th instead of 3rd.

[@waffle_enjoyer_]

Okay but why was courtney voted when she and bridgette are canonically friends and everyone voted for harold in the original???

[@TotalDramaKalo]

tbh idk, this was an year ago so idk 😭

[@waffle_enjoyer_]

@@TotalDramaKalo tbf she wouldn’t have lasted longer

[@Night.cat21]

What if Katie and Sadie didn’t get lost :0

[@TotalDramaKalo]

i have done it

[@rosetta23]

Can you do if Ridiculous wasn't a spin off and Chris hosted it

[@totaldramatdmw-td.]

Nothing would really change

[@иир-у6и]

Duncan elimination not make sense ,they definitely voting for Tyler

[@TotalDramaKalo]

I mean, Courtney said that they'd eliminate Duncan if he didn't help! I do think Tyler should be the one gone, but Courtney's got influence :(

[@иир-у6и]

@@TotalDramaKalo i dont think she was seriously and if they voting for Duncan ,they lost good player and in the start episode Cortney was carrying about team because they lost Eva

[@иир-у6и]

Geoff and Harold didn't make his fear,and we dont know what Katie fear

[@TotalDramaKalo]

i mean Chris only said about Bridgette, Courtney and Tyler! Katie's fear is the same as Sadie's

[@иир-у6и]

@@TotalDramaKalo yeah ,but he didn't give point to Killer bas

[@tory8458]

You should do “If Heather wasn’t evil and mean”

[@CJM94]

Nah, it's impossible. He can't change their personalities...

[@TotalDramaKalo]

this ^

[@thearmchairgamer2668]

@Kalo's Total Drama Aw and I was actually just going to request what if Heather and Lindsay switched personalities Lindsay becoming a ruthless villan and Heather becomes a nice girl who instead of being enemies with Gwen and Leshawna she becomes friends with them in taking down Lindsay

[@claudiomarmol1554]

Can you do "what if Ezekiel never said the bad stuff about the girls?"

[@TotalDramaKalo]

I have done it already