What if Nepotism Tax exists? | How Inheritance Tax Works | Dhruv Rathee

[@dhruvrathee]

Do you think there should be inheritance tax or wealth tax? Exclusive 35% discount for Dhruv Rathee subscribers for all ITR filings with TaxBuddy, India’s Most Trusted Tax Filing Platform! Use this link to avail 35% discount: filemyreturns.taxbuddy.com/DhruvRathee

[@dod-deadshot3063]

in my opinion , poor people should not give birth to a child , it's totally unfair to that kid who didn't even ask to be born and now they have to suffer in this cruel world . there should be a law for this like if you don't earn enough amount of money to raise a kid then you're not allowed to give birth to a child . atleast try to think from the perspective of that child who didn't even ask to come to this world but they came because of their stupid parents , it may sound weird to you but that's a fact

[@mr.rohitkumar5086]

No inheritance tax is not good Edit pehli baar itne likes m to famous Ho gya

[@Ritusingh-xw9jv]

There shouldbe inheritence tax but exemption limt shouldbe such that only for super rich people like Bollywood stars , netas,cricketer, bussinesman..

[@imrankhan-kp3jd]

Broo anything about tripura we want to know reality

[@naman4067]

Nice video

[@SurajRawat-db6ts]

Tax Tax Tax Its always consider good to take tax from rich, middle class, their hard earn money for development But government keep spending money on silly things, election etc.

[@cycle00001]

and statues

[@sameerhussain444]

True

[@yes_imadil2807]

Absolutely right bro they use our Tex on waste things like making world,s biggest statue

[@Aditya61845]

U r right bro

[@hardikkumar1737]

@@cycle00001 even on madrsachap education

[@mandyved4557]

When govt taxes the property inherited, then it should also provide assistance in case someone is inherited with debt. There should be effective policy regarding this.

[@anshulraman404]

Agree👍

[@sneha8732]

True

[@elite4wellness]

Correct

[@lopamudraray4571]

Absolutely

[@TheYodadrunk]

We can't compare this with other countries. Because the parent and children relationship is unique in India. We do not leave our elderly for themselves in old age homes and similarly parents work hard for the benificial of their children. That's why you see people still living with parents at least till the age of 30. So when this emotional connect exists, government should be very careful in implementing it.

[@medicoamir]

Awesome Point...🎗️

[@rh3465]

If my father is gifting me his ancestral land, even then during registration, we pay some tax. When my father gifted me a small property, then also i had to pay 50k rs as tax during registration. So its not like we inherit property without paying anything in India. And 50K is not a small amount for a middle class indian.

[@livefreetodiehard2550]

That is stamp duty i think. Not exactly tax on percentage of wealth gained.

[@zubair6737]

@@livefreetodiehard2550 still it's big for middle class like us

[@nikhilism_1515]

The suggestion made is to put tax with high upper limit so that no middle-class gets affected..

[@rh3465]

@@nikhilism_1515 i also dunno the actual cost of property. May be 25lakhs. Thats it maximum. Its ancestral land property of 5 cents. For that i paid from my pocket. Cos i cannot ask my father to pay for that. It is not an easy amount for me. I dunno wat kind of tax it is. It is paid during registration. This amount is low cos it was gifting. If u buy land, its actually way much more i think.

[@bharatahir7384]

I think you are misleading. Gifting is always cost you. Why can't you opted for succession/present succession type mutation. It cost you just 100 to 1000 (no matter property value) depending on state to state. I think more then 90% of property mutated/transferred by this type in india.

[@prachisingh5042]

The argument "we earn for our children and grandchildren" was very strong even though I'm pissed with rich people starting much ahead from middle class but can't deny the fact that I'm also working for a better future for my upcoming generation

[@randyorton-jl4nh]

but if the tax is implemented only on the super rich people then it's fine because if ambani gets to pay 40 billion dollar as an inheritance tax then still his family will be left with another 40 billion dollars in which they can still have the best lifestyle

[@ashishpradhan9606]

Exactly. And what if this hypothetical situation happen. Our govt will invest a small part of this in walefare but majority part in corruption. What's the use of this....

[@naveensinghnaveensingh9347]

You are right

[@yt_bharat]

Do u even know the cultural values of agrawals, marwadi, jain and gujarati families and try to assess why they remain successful? Most middle class people would never follow their passion, instead join a rat race for degrees till their 30's, they keep studying without actually any real world experience. Where as in business families child stays with the family, learn business, culture, confidence, this all builds up a strong support ecosystem. Zadatar middle class bacche 35lakh phookne k baad migrate kar jate hain for meaningless jobs (pressure factories). There r case studies why middle class mindset will always makes u a loser. Visit any Agarwal family and then tell if it is unfair 🙂 Their wealth is an enabler, they contribute lot to the society, middle class fuddu mumbai me joote kha lega, lekin izzat ki roti na khayega ghar ki

[@mr.psk.972]

@@yt_bharat I know many agarwal jain gujrati family they too have rich and poor they also do jobs it's just a stereotype that u see one side of the coin,I accept most of them who r rich from business backgrounds but it's common for every caste. Also earlier you can earn more money with a normal shop than salaried person but nowadays businesses are struggling because of big giant like Amazon Walmart reliance etc a normal general store owner cannot match the status of top or even middle level management. Now businesses needs huge capital and investments to do something good even u see the people from caste u mentioned above are doing work in MNCs and Pursuing professionals courses.

[@Riderlogy_India]

Nepotism is not about giving parents wealth to children but it is about giving a valuable position to your incompetent kid, for which many capable people are struggling.

[@drainedzombie2508]

It's more or less the same thing.. 'wealth' is value and has power in itself.

[@okman9684]

​@@drainedzombie2508you can tax wealth but can't tax personal favour

[@drainedzombie2508]

@@okman9684 you actually can that is the where socialism comes in

[@tvchannel3908]

It is also a dual taxation. One earning should be taxed once, either take income tax or take inheritance tax. Abolishing income tax and introduction of inheritance tax would encourage people to spend more during lifetime and help the economy to grow

[@xavierspapa4069]

Nepotism is everywhere around us not just in Bollywood. Whether it is Cricket, big business, Nepotism exists even in our school or college.😔

[@kedar_official2890]

judiciary tooooooooooo

[@masoomsanadi]

Nepotism also exists in home.

[@nikhilrawat007]

In politics also..

[@sudarshan3965]

Nepotism is in human genes

[@unssenworld0029]

@@masoomsanadi are you adopted 🧑‍🦲

[@arghamukherjee4940]

This topic was suggested by Dhruv himself when he made the video on "Should salary tax be exempted by the Govt? "

[@altafqureshi08]

Ha salary tax hata dena chahiye isse ye lagta h tho

[@uniqueideas8049]

Hum garib hai ?garib 😅😅

[@michael..35]

But do you think inheretance tax should be there

[@sheelamahar5711]

हाँ वेतनभोगियों पर से आयकर हटा देना चाहिऐ ।

[@arghamukherjee4940]

@@michael..35 in my opinion.... Inherent tax should be imposed on transfer of min ₹10 cr or more... Subject to certain Deductions, Exemptions and conditions.... And such tax should be Progressive in nature... Like 0.5% on ₹10 cr 0.75% on ₹10-25 cr 0.8% on ₹25-50 cr 1% on above ₹50 cr 5% on above ₹100 cr....

[@ishapatil1332]

My father belonged to a poor family yet through his very very hard work he now holds an executive post in a bank. I think that all the wealth that his has earned through 'blood & sweat' should not be given as tax to the government who isn't accountable of how that money this being spent !

[@bhavikagarg9535]

I think it should be implemented in such a way that if a person inherit more than a fixed amount of money like say 4 crore then on the rest of inherited property tax should be implemented

[@thefilmyarchitect1888]

Then what is the value of the hard work there father had done for there children every one start from the bottom one who work hard get rich and then of there children work and keep the level upto mark they should have every right to use there inheritance and who did not work hard will eventually loose all the inheritance at last or sabse badi baat jo is video ki pehli line me hi hai dusre se kyun jalna hai uske pass sabkuch hai toh kisi ne mehnat ki hai na sab karte hai apke bacho ke liye and they had paid income tax on it na and where was the government when that person started to build his empire but when he is set for his children govt comes in

[@aman4609]

@@thefilmyarchitect1888 the thing is, there should be either income tax or inheritance tax, one person should be taxed once for their income

[@thefilmyarchitect1888]

@@aman4609 yeah income tax is okay coz inheritance tax will eventually cut a good amount of savings

[@sanjeev5546]

Congratulations sir for wedding 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@akashjain-fh4hz]

How do you know that ?

[@chaitanyagupta5374]

@@akashjain-fh4hz Dhruv Rathee vlogs bro

[@jogendertech6059]

kis se shaadi kiya ?

[@samirali6782]

@@jogendertech6059 juli

[@vedantingale2669]

@@jogendertech6059 uski girlfriend Julie se karne wala hai

[@amitavachatterjee288]

Most Importantly there should be a "NETA TAX", after every 5 years the valuation of assets of any NETA / or Part will be evaluated, if Party Hold its > 50Cr. on surplus they should deposits 40% and Neta should deposits 40% of his Delta income. Trust me it wouldn't take more than a month for the SMART PEOPLE of India (Except Andh Bhakt)

[@ntonsalli]

There is no way a politician or a political party earn in a legal way. As per 13A political parties are exempted from their income tax. But any incoming funds from any person or business should be made transparent and evaluated. Section 29A has that provision but nobody does. Electoral bonds introduced by present government where donator names are not disclosed. Ironically whatever so… there’s always a loophole.

[@abbu-dz9gd]

buddhe tune apni jindgi me kya ukhad liya jo commeent section me gyan jhadd rha hai

[@saikatkhan7162]

Even smart people (supporter of rahul gandhi) will not support this😁😁😁😁😁

[@beckashwin]

Bhakt nahi menege . 🤣

[@ckspernicious4723]

@@saikatkhan7162 tko ye kaun bola ki andhbhakt ek hi taraf h. Dono taraf h, ek taraf itne jyada ki TV channels me bhi dikhta h. 😂 Lagna chahiye neta tax, party tax ; logon ka paisa mla kharidne aur apni jeb bharne me jyada phukkte h.

[@ankitjain8026]

We almost pay tax on everything we earn consume in India. e.g Income tax, Capital gain tax , STT, GST , registration of house, vehicle etc. and after that we save something to cater uncertainty in future and some for our children studies / marriage / profession / business. Inheritance tax / Estate tax is not a good idea as that money is left after paying tax to govt. form my point there should be one tax either GST or Income tax. We are already suffering from multiple tax without getting anything in return.

[@thefilmyarchitect1888]

Exactly and yeh desh kaam karne walo se hi chal raha hai yeh video ka pehle point hi galata hai kyu dusre ke inheritance se jalna, whats the value of there father's hard work everyone got the same opportunity everyone started from the bottom some become rich and save there every penny fir there children fir poor middle clas is rich and for middle class upper one is rich but keeping the standard and staying at that level is what it is, govt was not there when they started at bottom but get rich so these people got fire in there ass and want these tax

[@adityabharadwajusa]

Big fan here! Loved this video! One thing that makes it different from other videos is the discussion of tax laws adopted by other countries. John oliver does it from time to time. Would love to see more of it in future videos. For example, can you also discuss some farm laws that have been working for other countries and how India can learn from them?

[@zeeshanchishty232]

This is IMPOSSIBLE to watch DHRUV'S video without reading Comments.that are always POSITIVE.

[@P_A1_N]

Nah there are still some negative people. But positivity is to ignore them.

[@katsukibakugo2318]

Bjp it cell : ahm ahm.

[@shantanushinde7291]

BJP it cell . hold my bear .😂😂😂

[@fukedbylife9484]

@ALL TIME GAMING lol

[@askalmaskalmemes5460]

🥺My father is not having any job 😢""I want to do somethingFor my father""😟but KZbin views subscribe"ya iam,worse than other,and I am17 year old class 10th 🥺

[@alfwaq]

If we think that a wealthy man passing on his wealth to his children is unfair, then a professor passing on his knowledge is also unfair as it gives them an advantage over others. Same is the case with passing on good values... This is natural and we should stop bitching about everything.

[@alfwaq]

@PRIYANSHU SINGH exactly. If a computer engineer teaches his kid how to code... And he starts earning good money from the skill.. That's an unfair advantage he has over other kids with unskilled parents.... Should we ban parents from teaching any skills to their children as well? Is that nepotism?

[@kiranagrawal829]

@@alfwaq yea and it's not necessary that a rich man pass on his wealth to his kids so their life will be set, of course they have to work to sustain that like ratan tata

[@sanjanaislam2212]

Wealth decreases when it is passed to someone but knowledge never decreases even if we pass the knowledge to everybody in the world.

[@alfwaq]

@@sanjanaislam2212 So its a bigger form of nepotism then? Why should anyone have the advantage of skilled parents? There should an information inheritance tax. Anything you teach your kids, you must also teach two other kids who are born to unskilled parents.

[@oodaehungufef9547]

@@alfwaq But for gaining knowledge also needs effort from both side and wealth is just passed without any effort.

[@cOffee1750]

13:43 i agree with mr srinivasan even i as a middle class person would work so my forthcoming gen would have it easy Its not a childs fault that s/he is born in a rich or poor family its how much grateful the person is n where he stand with their values And also we all know where the tax from the rich go😒

[@srigautham1021]

Coming from a lower-middle-class family, my opinion: I am against inheritance tax! It's unfair to tax and intervene on the fruit of hard work or talent they earned throughout their life! It should be their free will where to spend it.! And of course, nepotism is a problem and there are many alternative options to deal with providing equal opportunities!

[@mubeenakhan5548]

👍👍👍

[@kangvariant5441]

Then why do you want to inherit all your wealth to offsprings? Make them capable enough to earn themselves...

[@Gaurav-ss3je]

Its mean other country's who have inheritance tax are fool my opinion is that it should be applied in India

[@garv._gupta]

@@kangvariant5441 because it is not necessary your kids will always be talented enough to become as successful as you. But as a parent its your responsibility to ensure that your kids not have to live a harder life than yours just because they were not as talanted as you

[@garv._gupta]

@@Gaurav-ss3je yes they are fool, everything western's do isn't necessarily better than us

[@anilaeek4374]

This will definitely shake the real estate business. The house prices will go higher and higher because the seller(inherited property) will consider it as loss and fix high prices for it.

[@MrCat-sl6zf]

are they decreasing without in inheritance tax ?

[@raviagrawal8281]

No it will go down as everyone will be selling the land and no one would but due to inheritance tax

[@cristinarunte499]

Been seeing this LUMI coin everywhere lol. Did anyone invest in it??

[@insaanrenlei4043]

"We earn for our children & grandchildren" it's good But we shouldn’t spoil them with lots of money, they must have atleast to live happily not to live worklessly ..👍 so there should be a Tax

[@user-tu7rh2hr1n]

Do u earn money ?

[@kamalsaurinsagar]

How about you mind your own damn buisness and let other people pass on their wealth as they want to be while you and the Government don't be envious and jelous about it.

[@harshjain3655]

When someone transfers any property or any assets to someone in India then the government already takes fees and taxes. And every year we are also paying property tax. So directly or indirectly we are already paying these taxes. Now if taxes like these are keep introduced, soon there will be a day when we have to pay taxes for living and even for taking birth.

[@vizz1878]

Damn right about that !!

[@rudra20048]

But where does tax goes? Paying house tax from years still have bad road in colony

[@vizz1878]

@@rudra20048 True we shouldn't discuss more ways to add taxes but what we should discuss is how inspite of all these taxes we don't get the facilities we deserve and that's because of corruption !! What we should discuss is how these other countries don't ask for such lame taxes and provide people with so many facilities but here in India we still have to pay money to drive our vehicles on clean and secured roads inspire the taxes we pay!!

[@masoomsanadi]

Nepotism is everywhere. Those who deny this, let them give their business to their employees.

[@harindersingh6922]

Would you do the same ? If you have kids ?

[@harindersingh6922]

Try giving your one month salary to someone start with that , in theory this is a great deed but try it practically

[@nikhilism_1515]

@@harindersingh6922 I will surely push my kids to be smart enough to earn money. The tax is not about giving someone ur salary no one is asking for it

[@mohammedzabiullah1026]

bro, to become a CEO one must struggle. some become one luckily but if they aren't talented then they will for sure face loss. but if a normal employee is really talented then he should make is own empire (but have some backup plans also)

[@mrmemer5520]

@@mohammedzabiullah1026 correct 👍👍

[@JaanoJahan]

Hats off to you! You are a great narrator. Can you make videos on Vietnam and korean wars?

[@rohitgupta1979]

Chanakya has said taxation should be done in such a way that people would like to give it happily and clearly see the benefits of it. That will always be ideal for any taxation. Currently it is not so for any tax.

[@roshansingh1819]

Thank you bhaiya for introducing me these knowledge

[@roshansingh1819]

@ALL TIME GAMING you also

[@Farhan-rs9wt]

@ALL TIME GAMING COPE

[@Shivam-jv2me]

Thanku kya uski job he, ha acchi vedio banata he par aehsaan thodi kar raha he

[@sahariyakawsar6426]

Ok

[@dashrathbhatia9485]

@@Shivam-jv2me ye sab attention pane k liye karte hai ye log

[@quranremedy126]

I am from a middle class family but still I believe that inheritance tax should not levied because our whole life we put a lot of efforts in make things better for us and our future generations and also we are paying a lot of tax to the Indian government along with it.

[@vizz1878]

You're right !! This inherit tax bullshit !!

[@DineshKumar-pn6wr]

Agree

[@devkinandansingh326]

True..

[@abstract2694]

@P Pierre if govt brings inheritance tax.. many will start laundering

[@eren8808]

@P Pierre Entreprenures will leave if this is implemented. Ab tum to job doge nahi. So please my advice tum bhi ek book likh lo about how rich should be taxed. Idiots will buy it, you will become millionare.

[@kulsumkiani7724]

There should not be inheritance tax at time of transfer but when the beneficiary disposes it off and he/she falls in regular taxable limits. Let's don't destroy fortune made by someone and let this fortune continue helping to build economy of the country.

[@logic1137]

See the wealth they earn is their struggle being a middle class person I confess that a person earns for his children only what else? Though this tax will benefit us (middle class) but then it will be unfair for upper class as there is no value to their struggle and hardwork And are we very confident that the tax money will not go in the pockets of politicians Specially in our nation politicians are corrupt and the honest entrepreneurs who are building a nation through their businesses will have to suffer and politicians will just sit and eat????? I think inheritance tax should be imposed only on Politicians and all the wealth of Fraudsters like Malia and Nirav Modi should be confesticated that will provide more income than inheritance tax and Government should work on empowering middle class but they are just depowering rich class (irony in India 😂, I am talking about other nation like US) Yeah but I agree that starkids should not be privileged and all should get equal opportunity

[@themehmood]

Nepotism का जीता जागता उदाहरण Jay Shah है।

[@realmehmood]

सहीपकड़े हैं

[@e-accountant]

Exactly 😂💯

[@treeofbluegreen6171]

Rahul Gandhi

[@swayampravanayak4343]

Meanwhile the gandhi..

[@ritikbhatia5361]

Many many congratulations to you Dhruv for your marriage. Stay blessed and enjoy happiness in the rest of your life. "Rab ne bana di Jodi". Long live Dhruv and Juli ❤️❤️

[@unicornicideas9241]

Kab hua ..?

[@aamir-khan]

@@unicornicideas9241 check latest vlogs.

[@hamen03soft]

God bless dhruv

[@prakashnandaniya2668]

My family is lower middle class but I think in india parents motivation to earn money is their childrens as my father

[@shrihara]

The goal should be to make next generation financially independent so that they can think of innovation, problem solving, entrepreneurship instead of traditional way of growing up just thinking only about scoring marks for exams, crack interviews of big corporates etc. Next generation should be free from thinking about bread and butter by removing inheritance, gift tax etc and even encourage Universal basic income. However wealth tax should be brought back to put a limit on maximum wealth in terms of real estate ownership that one can accumulate or it will bring back zamindari system.

[@amankumarsaxena4168]

It's very informative and a unique idea . Mainstream media couldn't do debate on these kind of topics.THANKS DHRUV

[@Gunika_Saxena]

Yes they will not

[@prachisingh5042]

Why everyone ignores nepotism in bureaucracy which is literally deadly, this "amir" 2lakh coaching ke "SC" student steals place of an eligible person. That's heartbreaking 💔

[@randyorton-jl4nh]

yes the quota advantage should be given to people according to their wealth and not by their caste anymore.

[@pilot7977]

Maam IDK where u live that u see SC are very rich it might be very less percentage SC needs uplifting still in the society just leave city and you will see the gap

[@rohitchetry7868]

@@pilot7977 it's taking too much time for uplifting..

[@shrihara]

@@rohitchetry7868 Of course it is not a magical solution that solves the problem overnight. It will take decades but eventually we will get there.

[@shrihara]

Life of GM student is like driving on a 6 lane tolled well maintained National highway while SC student life is like driving on a unpaved, dirt, pothole ridden road. Hence SC student is as much eligible as GM as their starting and the path to success is not the same. I agree that rich SC should be excluded as they are like driving a SUV on off track road.

[@harrehmatsingh]

Personally, I'm against inheritance tax

[@protecz5370]

i think our indian gover... not ready for this indian people1 : "yes we should have inheritance tax" indian people2 :" NO we should not" indian gover... : nice , we will take tax and waste all money in process.....

[@heyy9527]

14:38 he is right I don't wanna pay tax just because I want I family to have a batter life ...and if I have a expansive property and lot of money which is helping my family or kids it's not there fault that they are my kids or family members

[@technologylapersonne8587]

No inheritance tax should not be introduced it’s what our parents left for us not for some government official to buy a Mercedes and a bungalow NO INHERITANCE TAX

[@ramwaghmare2254]

@@madhavpatil2221 are you gone mad

[@utubefreak7167]

@@madhavpatil2221 10Cr? Lol so at least 25% of Delhi People will pay this tax xD

[@debdeepchakraborty6800]

@P Pierre as far as I know, black money is untaxed weath and it is mostly in form of movable assets. I fail to understand how such assets can come under the purview of inheritance tax?

[@dakshsharma8294]

Now in 2024 where richer is getting richer and poor getting poorer we should introduce this tax.

[@anand1915]

By the way,, a person does all the struggle to get succeed just because of his children or upcoming generation,, so that they could live a prosperous life ❤️❤️

[@indraneelmitra663]

The argument "we earn for our children and grandchildren" is very true. We tend to save money for our future generation so that they can live happily. It the nature of any human being or you can say any animal to save something for their future generation. If at all it's necessary to implement this inheritance tax then as @Dhruv said, should have a higher limit so that super rich people comes under that category. Middle class people or upper middle class people work hard to earn every penny but for super rich, their money earned is not proportionate with the time they invest as most of the work is done by some other people who work under them. So in my opinion, then limit should be high so that only super rich gets eligible.

[@Priyanka-ye6zt]

We earn money for ourselves.... Money can't buy happiness... It is necessary tool for survival

[@vizz1878]

You're marginally right !! Even though I belong to upper middle class family, I still think not every rich person earn money with illegitimate methods and not every middle class person is always honest, e.g. corruption in govt. officials those belong to middle or mphigher middle class !! This nepotism topic mostly is seen in Bollywood and Politics so perhaps those should be places where such inheritance laws come into being which actually is a complete crap !! Perhaps this nepotism thing have been stretched out for long and doesn't deserve much attention, these things still exist and will continue to exist cause as you apsaid its the law of nature !! There definitely are bigger issues to deal with than actually think about this nepotism with is more drama and less seriously concerning!!

[@dontcheckmychannel5882]

Ab ye bata kaha se copy paste kiya

[@kumarsatyam3314]

ha to middle class pe inheritence thode hi lagana chahiye.....inheritence tax is for people like Paris Hilton (mentioned in the video), aryan khan, alia bhatt type of people.....kaam dhanda kuch nahi aur duniya bhar ka paisa maa baap ka diya hua

[@vizz1878]

@@kumarsatyam3314 You're just toxic ? Why do you care if they inherit the money or not ? Seriously you also will inherit your parents money and asserts and you're only saying this cuz you don't come in the elite class !! Everyone I hermits their parents money !!

[@Dushyantdabas]

Why should my children pay tax for my hardwork and for the tax I have already payed for. I pay income tax, house tax, paid car registration tax and gst on everyday use Yeh kangana ranaut ki MKC Yeh nepotism har jageh hota hain per galat nahi hota hain. Its a capitalist ideology tax.

[@binitakaphle6092]

Nepotism ka meaning pata hein terrko.

[@Dushyantdabas]

@@binitakaphle6092 tum khandani gareeb ho tumhare dada gareeb Baap gareeb ab tum gareeb. Jalo kabhi naukri chahiye ho to batana

[@constantinebyzantine2898]

@@Dushyantdabas I agree it would be immoral to introduce inheritance tax but having so MUCH PRIDE ON YOUR WEALTH is not a moral thing

[@Dushyantdabas]

Where do u see pride in my comment. I was merely answering to a rude lady in her chapri way. And buddy if I have money I have worked for it it's totally cool to be rich. Sad for poor people though.

[@Dushyantdabas]

@Jawed Khan Arre bhai Baat Yeh hain agar maine tax bhar diya meri aulad fir dubara tax kyun bhare usi cheej per. Double tax galat hota hain.

[@Dhirajk1]

Nepotism Tax sounds like an Utopian world (ideally in dreams only) but the topic of this Inheritance Tax is quite more complex for India.

[@ajay34555]

Dhruv Bhai India Is Welfare Country For The People. Corporate Taxes Zada Hona Chahiye Upto 25%-30%. Regards Ajay Kumar. Thank You.

[@owaisjavaid4969]

I come from a middle class background.. but still i would say that this is stupid... My father is working hard for us..not for funding of corrupt govt officials.. who buys helicopters and cars from public money

[@JavedShaikh-eu9er]

Educational video, much appreciated. At last you mentioned 3 points but let's read in between the lines. 2.1: What if only child is abnormal / semi abnormal. How he/she will pay tax.... Now my opinion: Tax should be implemented but it should not affect middle / upper middle class people. And this tax money amount should be transparent, shouldn't be use for election campaign. Thanks

[@zebaseraj5005]

Good point 👍

[@udayravjotsingh4171]

Please make a video on abolishment of direct taxes

[@michaelscofield7907]

Music played at the end was so beautiful

[@arunavkumarsingh3659]

i feel its quite wrong to impose inheritance tax, our fathers earned money by pain and sweat , ( while paying income tax) filled it taxes in the annual year, and when it comes down to passing it to us , the government wants some of that too? what for to fill bureacrats and politician's pockets , cus no real works happens here

[@sharllmao5920]

True, all that nonsense of education this that is total garbage, we all know where our income goes too an where will this new tax will also go to

[@aamir-khan]

There should not be a Inheritance tax but instead of that there should be atleast minimum wealth tax which had to be paid yearly for rich class only, not for upper and middle class.

[@alphachoiceindia8165]

Sahi kaha aap ne...!

[@shaurya2599]

Bhai my father is a farmer he earns money(80, 000 per year). I applied for jee but could not afford coaching after a year got GKV college through jee but I know I will not be able to pay seat acceptance fee(40, 000) till 24th nov. And today I realized that We are very poor. Some people can't study in good Institutes even though his father is working hard in fields.

[@sahilpatil9000]

@@aamir-khan do u think it is easy to segregate rich class from others?

[@shivanshusharma7741]

The irony is that most of us see Nepotism as unfair/ discrimination while the same people support quota.

[@kanakalatahembram1650]

The same people who object to quota also support quota. In short everyone wants quota for himself but objects to quota for others.

[@saumitit944]

Abey positive discrimination laye kyunki negative discrimination ho rhi thi. If you truly believe caste and caste-based discrimination as a concept doesnt exist anymore, then it'd be fair to say quota shouldnt exist.

[@ghi1]

Unfortunately the biggest example of nepotism is caste system

[@binitakaphle6092]

@@hazelwood6088 what minorities?Are dalit minorities and poor is not according to caste .

[@binitakaphle6092]

@@hazelwood6088 but education is not only medical science?There are home science also .

[@luckyzeyan5391]

Rich Indians will never let inheritance tax..... Look at the life style of indians and westerners earning the same amount, im sure the Indian will save more

[@user-pp8kd2sq9b]

Please make video on overseas policies of different state governments and how it is benefitting. I am from Bihar and i want my peopel to be aware about this and demand same from government.

[@user-pp8kd2sq9b]

overseas scholarships policies

[@rishitajain4470]

Congratulations to you and Julie for your wedding ❤️🙂

[@jogendertech6059]

kahi bgp love jihad na bol de

[@MuhammadIrfan-iu2ty]

@@jogendertech6059 oh! According to bjp it cell and bhakt gang dhruv is maulana 😂😂😂

[@jogendertech6059]

@Neptune Aur india me RRS wala game maat khelo

[@1BlueSkyy]

“What if nepotism tax exists“ *Bollywood would be highest tax payer on this planet.*

[@Neha-us2nf]

South industry would be

[@onlysecret3337]

yeah😅😂

[@Sree-qo8xc]

Tollywood too 😂

[@TheJohn222222]

how will that work.

[@boldecor2676]

@@Sree-qo8xc 😂😂😂😂timing guru

[@jigyasaanand9751]

Introduction of inheritance tax wouldn't be the affective step towards balancing society in our country because amount of cash would meant to be negligible for both sides. Even after that nepotism will be continued with more arrogance.

[@anand_bhasme]

I didn't know about such tax but now I am hearing about it, I am a huge fan of this. I am strongly in favor of Wealth/Inheritance tax

[@tapamay]

Inheritance Tax is a progressive thought if Health, education and Social Security are completely taken care by government.

[@vrishankpandey8537]

Whenever there is something knowledgable to watch I always click on it, Dhruv Rathee produces very good videos, thank you sir for helping me gain my knowledge!

[@jeevankumarsen8668]

Please Start Series On How Amazon Tesla Spotify etc. All Companies Are Successful.

[@yuddhveersingh8233]

Inheritance tax should be imposed to reduce corruption and nepotism

[@lokeshrastogi4184]

Really your video sir helps in improving critical thinking. A person can collect best points for debate events.

[@lokeshrastogi4184]

Thankyou Sir

[@strangerr2362]

I am from a lower middle class family but I don't support this tax. But if we can stop nepotism by other means then it would be great.

[@ribhavmishra1103]

Against it. Simple as that. The last line by the TVS chairman makes sense. And bigger thing, we all work hard for one reason, for a better life for our upcoming generations.

[@piyushtajne3495]

Inheritance tax should be imposed with a higher upper limit even if it's only 1% of government revenue it would be useful in healthcare and education, and the administrative cost required can be reduced by using the existing government services. Talking about argument that "we are earning for our children" the tax won't affect children if they are capable to handle that money

[@JNinu]

Our fathers work hard to raise us and tried to earn until their last breath only to make sure that us his children could support our lives and we will work until we die for our children to ensure their livelihood is good. To bring a child into this world filled with evil people and just let them live by their own is unfair. The parents property is fairly for their offspring. No tax should be levied.

[@okay1775]

But the tax is only levied for the super rich

[@_Infocars]

But super rich people don't work as hard as average people. If you are super rich you can put all of your money in FD & live a comfortable life without worrying about jobs. So I think Inheritance tax should be applied to super rich people. Not middle class.

[@mksa2858]

@@_Infocars then the course of action rich people should do is go rogue and weaken the economy. People like you like to lick somebody’s wealth while you are sitting at home. Wow

[@user-hg2pc]

@@_Infocarsif you think they are not working hard then you may try and reach their net worth

[@elishane1252]

@@_Infocars what u said can offend a lot of people as no one ever can reach a high height without working as hard as hell.... And mostly those fd and other things are there side bussiness and not main bussiness... But even if it's main then i can guarantee that u they study like madmen about everything to be successful otherwise everyone can be successful just by taking loan from banks and use on fd

[@secunder999]

Sadse bada nepotism to judiciary me 1947 se lekar aaj tak 350 family ke hi judge aaye hain 130 crore ki Population vaale desh me.

[@strongmuslim4004]

Tabhi to ye log judiciary Mai reservation Nahi lane de rahe.

[@siddharthyoyo]

@@strongmuslim4004 tumko har jagh reservation chaiye haram ka khane ki adat hogai h desh ko. Lower judiciary mein reservation h jake waha fayda uthao.

[@levimujahid8940]

@@strongmuslim4004 look brother ..I'm" general(UR)muslim " aur Mene bhot suffer kya hai is reservation ke chochle me ....iski wajah se mera dream college me admission nhi ho paya !! So plzz

[@Ridham33571]

@@strongmuslim4004 bina res ke kuj hota ni na tumse lol

[@KEVIN-ru4hd]

@@levimujahid8940 my dear I'm also general muslim(shia) . And I totally support reservation. Haa thodi bohot cheeze h jo mujhe theek nhi lgti reservation ki.

[@Sans_OO5]

I am ready to pay any kind of tax but in return I want development but when I see Lucknow then metro is not expanded from last 6 years since the government has changed, so I am not happy to pay the tax

[@Sarthak_laghe]

Please make a video on increase in gst from 5% to 12% on CLOTHS as Orderd by Union govt. Now even small shopkeepers have to pay more GST. Is Modi Govt. Doing right they have already increased petro price and now Cloth. Very disappointing as a Shopkeeper.😔😔😓

[@pratappawar8899]

Everybody hates nepotism but still want to inherit their father's wealth. Life is full of contradictions and hypocrisy.

[@pradeepsao4951]

I don't hate nepotism because I know that everybody takes birth according to their own KARMA.

[@garv._gupta]

I hate nepotism but for me nepotism has a different meaning. Jab aap kisi ka "hak maarke" apne bacche ke liye cheeze asaan kar rhe ho use mai nepotism kehta hu. Jaise ki aapki kisi school me sirf ek bacche ko admission mil sakta hai, ek gareeb baccha jo bhot hoshiyar hai aur ek ameer baccha jiske papa ki school ke principal se pehchan hai . Agar ameer bacche ke papa ki pehchan ki wajah se gareeb bacche ka admission cancel hota hai to woh mere hisaab se galat hai

[@pradeepsao4951]

@@garv._gupta In your example, both children should appear in exam and better performer should get admission. But giving work in movies or giving businesses/wealth to own children if children are talented and able is completely right.

[@garv._gupta]

@@pradeepsao4951 yeah

[@AmanSingh-cu1vt]

Ananya be like: Pta nhi aisi dangerous situations me mai apne aap age kaise aa jaati hu

[@upscme5944]

😂😂😂😂

[@AbhishekKumar-is8ew]

I am against of this tax scale because we are hard working for many

[@queen3832]

I am against the tax. My motivation to work hard and earn more will be gone .in Indian context paying more tax to government is lke paying more and more opportunities to politician's do more scandals in the name of development and earn more money for themselves and to spend more on there comfort and standard for enjoyment

[@sajidurrahman6989]

Will a rich businessmen give his empire to a talented employer or his children?In some cases nepotism isn't a bad thing.

[@tanishvedak9196]

Tbh I oppose the idea of inheritance tax . And see if a child gets advantage from birth what's wrong in it ? If their parents want a better future and a relaxed and comfortable life , it's not bad I think. If rich people want their kids or family to inherit it , it's their choice tbh. I am not from a rich background but I look at things from their perspective.

[@atulshetty5312]

If you re talking from their perspective, they are just being selfish

[@atulshetty5312]

May be not 40percent but just 15-20 would be good enough.

[@atulshetty5312]

But still US (because of high unequal ity)does require this law and India doesn't because of the pre-existing taxes like gst and stuff

[@kulsummirza4314]

Agree

[@ibrav7979]

@@atulshetty5312 why is it selfish

[@rcubeclips1820]

I am just against by that simple reason, that whoever earned, it should be on that person, whom he wants to give his/her wealth. Bro if one has money, does he or she shares it with the person who doesn't have, a progeny is his or her legacy that's why it should go to the next generation. If someone thinks his/her money is not going to the legacy he expects from their children, they can simply donate. You do not need to force one. It's like looting a person. If those reach people want to do taxes they can simply donate in there will. A child is a legacy of someone and everyone wants to thrive there legacy for that you need to leave your wealth to ur legacy.

[@LAKSHAYVATS777]

Who is telling if anyone start taking rubbish on Indian politics and then there is this man who just does not have any big information and good just enjoy with her girlfriend and tells us what is right to do

[@aniceguy6065]

Finally a video worth my time and data.

[@terence602]

Wait you

[@devbhandari7581]

Dhruv, an important thing to note would be that suppose Mr. A is a crorepati, he pays income tax regularly, if you look his pov he is earning all of that just for his family’s better standard of living i.e better education, better food, better surrounding etc,. Now if such a tax exists that will tax the property of Mr. A, that was earned after paying tax to government at roughly 42.744% at the time of his death is a mere injustice to him. Nepotism is not good for the development of society but demeaning someone’s hard earned money just so that the poor people who may not have worked as hard as Mr. A would be an injustice. Ik this applies to a very small section of rich people who pay tax regularly but we can’t leave them out as we need the nation as a whole to progress. Corruption is the root of the devilry of nepotism and I guess government should focus more on how to deal with increasing corruption.

[@deepEleven]

Except that most rich business men avoid paying income tax by investing their income back in their business. And speaking of injustice, is it fair that a person gets best education and opportunities throughout his life and still needs his dad's money to survive as an adult?

[@randyorton-jl4nh]

but if the tax is implemented only on the super rich people then it's fine because if ambani gets to pay 40 billion dollar as an inheritance tax then still his family will be left with another 40 billion dollars in which they can still have the best lifestyle

[@devbhandari7581]

@@deepEleven so you’re just jealous of the rich kids cause they get the best education and still don’t apply that to its full extent! Who is the India’s richest person as of today? Mukesh Ambani, right? Well he was born with a silver spoon but what he is today can’t be referred to just as his dad’s wealth. He worked “smartly” to be there. Dhirubhai ambani, his father, well he worked at a petrol pump prior to reliance happened; if you call it education that brought him thinking of creating an empire of reliance, it’s defaming his “knowledge” & “skill”. Parents just want their kids to have the best of everything. Yours, mines, even Mukesh Ambani. They don’t want their kids to suffer or go through what they went. They work their ass off just so that they can give everything their family demands. The rich kids who get a headstart is a must for society as it will give people like you and me a reason to prove ourselves and be hard working. Cause in the end hard work pays off.

[@deepEleven]

@@devbhandari7581 I'm not jealous of anyone. If Mukesh Ambani really has "knowledge" and "skills", inheritance tax would have changed nothing about his life. But, for those people who do nothing but live off their father's wealth, the money can potentially be used better by the government to improve the nation. And inheritance tax is just taking a fraction of wealth from rich kids, the child would still be super rich after paying it.

[@devbhandari7581]

@@deepEleven I understand your point and I’m not completely against inheritance/wealth tax but I just feel that for some super rich families we cannot cause harm to the average rich people like someone who are not as rich as Ambani, Tata, Birla, etc,. and not as middle class. And that forms a big chunk of our Indian society. Cause there are many families that are well off and their kids are also doing great by themselves and not eating off of their parents wealth. And in my opinion, “It is corruption that gives birth to nepotism.”

[@dynamichuman2007]

In my opinion inheritence tax must not be there. 1. This can harm the freedom of the people that to whom they want to give their wealth. 2. As revenue generated is very less but the small rich havin 2 to 3 crores of wealth will find it difficult to pay the inheritance tax

[@mustafabashirkhan]

tax is a joke in itself but Inheritence tax is the biggest joke ever.

[@drkt6888]

The reason why this channel is growing at a very rapid pace - 1) the simple breakdown of news on any topic making it listenable to even those who never saw news in their lives until now are getting educated regarding the current state of affairs and also history etc. 2) His channel covers a wide variety of topics 3) The lighting speed at which he is publishing videos ( one almost every 3 days ) is the main reason for this rapid growth. All the best Team Dhruv Rathee.

[@danish1108]

Nepotism ends where Jay Shah starts.😂

[@_kartik_chauhan]

Biggest Nepotism Rahul Gandhi hahaha

[@subodhraj1591]

@@_kartik_chauhan Every industry is full of nepotism

[@MrBabajikijai]

Har ladka apne baap ki jayedaad pe kabza karta hai. Ghar ghar me hai nepotism.

[@parhamkanth5676]

@@MrBabajikijai honestly really true!

[@SQUID12]

@@MrBabajikijai nepotism se farq nahi parta lekin agar nepotism kisi talent ko kill karde toh farq parta hai(not talking about SSR)

[@AmitAgarwal1977]

Dhurv Sir My proposal is that no body should be allowed to hold more than 1 billion dollar. Every year wealth should be calculated and if wealth have increased and crossed 1 billion dollar then all amount above 1 billion dollar should be taken by the govt as tax This tax can be named as "High Limit Tax" India have only 225 billionaire so it will applied on 225 people only

[@ShantanuJha97]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@ShantanuJha97]

That’s like saying nobody in class should get A+ anyone who gets above A+ will be downgraded to A

[@Nirvanaattainer54]

If inheritence tax is justified then there should be a intellect/merit tax. If youre intelligent, you should pay taxes too. Because inheritance and talent are not in our control and it is within pure luck

[@jacksfc2065]

India is run by basically TATA,AMBANI ,ADANI etc to India me inheritance tax nhi aayega.

[@legendkartik2285]

@ISHANT SHEWALE jiske pas paisa hai wo hi baap hai . He is right. If today ambani wants a rule directly he will say to the pm .

[@vaneetgarg2517]

I guess this one of the few moments where you will get both support and contradiction from both ruling and opposition.

[@SandeepBhaiya721]

Kaha se hai bhai tu 👍

[@Factzone1234]

Aapke channel pe aapke ads 😍🥰😀😀🤣🤣🥲🥲😁😁😄😄😋😚😉😉😍🙂🙃😆😁😅😂

[@8141673121]

Hello Dhruv, Rich people have their past where there is a will to alter something in their community or infrastructure where they used to belong! Government shall give them the freedom to give directly to the poor people or poor infrastructure. This way government will have less burden on a collection of it and conserve salaries of hundreds of gov. employees to something useful whereas the inheritance will gain their popularity within the people or even nationwide! Or maybe straight away ₹10 inheritance = 1 dense foliage tree. We don’t need their money but we might need their kindness! Big fan of yours, lots of love to you and your family and i hope there are fewer advertisements in your video! ✌️😊

[@1415sushil]

favours - It will also help for equal distribution of property among sons and daughters. The Law of equal distribution is only on papers not reality. Tax on inheritance will help because one person realizes and share the property for tax distribution liabilities.

[@thankyou230]

Government:-we want to implement inheritance tax.. Mukesh Ambani:-chanda cahiya ki nhi ... Government:- ab hum mazak bhi nhi kar sakta..

[@akshatkanodia1573]

Har chiz me modi ambani lana jarori hai

[@soumyaranjan2895]

@@akshatkanodia1573 MODI KE BEST FRIENDS HAIN AMBANI AND ADANI..

[@jojven7514]

@@soumyaranjan2895 toh iska matlab elon musk, Jeff Bezos Donald trump ke bhi dost hai kyonki Trump ek business man hai Or ek businessman ko jaha fayada dekhega wo wahi deal karega

[@_kartik_chauhan]

@@soumyaranjan2895 Ratan Tata Nahi?

[@MarvelMysteriesUnveiled]

@@soumyaranjan2895 bhai yeh sabhi country apne bade companies ko support karti hai kyunki inka contribute apne desh ki gdp ki growth mein madad karta hai

[@surajjain074]

The idea that we work/earn for our children is the idea of our parents and grandparents. This idea majorly, I think, doesn't have in today's generation. And I think now or a few years down the line could be a nice time to again bring the Inheritance Tax. And again the idea that it is just 0.5-1% of the total tax is irrational since the total tax collection will vastly outweigh the administration cost.

[@iaskriti9375]

Earlier I don't know about inheritance tax really your video updating my knowledge

[@tseringdolma4721]

Thanks sir..for the informative topic,and making it so simple😀

[@Crusade56]

When there is talk about nepotism Le Ananya pandey:- aise haalat mein na jane kyu mai hi aage aa jata hu 😂😂

[@_o6629]

Also varun dhawan lol

[@xavier7888]

Rahul gandhi , jay shah , , gandhi family ,

[@dr.pakalupapito6015]

That’s like saying going on a vacation with my family to Maldives is unfair to all the other people. No one will be equal in this world. We just have to create more opportunities for people to rise up the ladder. It shouldn’t bother them who is on top; focus on you going upper. I’m not responsible to be fair to other people. I earned my way up to where I am today. I won’t be able to enjoy the full of it; my children should have the full right to enjoy the rest. I’m not responsible to give anything to anyone. I already pay enough taxes. Cut this socialist bullsh*t.

[@themaniacjoker9185]

I am neither for or against this tax but I believe if this tax is levied on Indians to make the starting line equal then the reservations should be abolished!

[@rohanjagdale97]

Hamare ma Baap ke pass paise he but wo 1 1 rupe ka hisaab magate he. And jab tak ham apne pair par khade nahi hote tab tak wo hame normal bache jaise he treat karte he. hame bhi bohot mehnat karni padati he.