What if Rarity was a Villain?

⭐️ Store ⭐️ janegumball.store
🌸Sticker Club🌸 / membership
🍀Kickstarter🍀 kck.st/3xEZGQH
End of an era ;(
Patreon🎟️ / janegumball
Instagram🍏 / janegumball
Twitter🪽 / janegumball
-----
TAGS
#MLP #mlpfim #speedpaint #art #drawing #illustration #drawing #cartoon #twilightsparkle #pinkiepie #fluttershy #rarity #applejack #rainbowdash #pegasus #unicorn #dragon #pony #celestia #luna #princesscelestia #princessluna #tempest #tempestshadow #princesscadence #nightmaremoon
Music: www.purple-planet.com

[@avianlord2779]

Okay but hear me out.. What if Spike turned into a "nightmare" version of himself?

[@Depressedsimpofthevoid]

Yes

[@yammie.n]

We NEED a nightmare spike

[@user-cp3ke4xf4g]

Good idea

[@SkellSeer]

And gave into his dragon greed!

[@BenKoomen]

​@@SkellSeer NIGHTMARE SPIKE 2024🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣😍😍😍💯💯💯‼️‼️‼️

[@jharmond3874]

The only time they covered Rarity's jealousy of Fluttershy was in the episode with Fluttershy modeling Rarity's clothes and she became famous instead of Rarity. However, it was never explicitly about being envious of looks as it was more about popularity.

[@anxioussquiddy]

Well, Rairty does acknowledge that Fluttershy is super beautiful and when Flutters says that Rarity should model it, Rarity pretty much says Fluttershy will be the better model.

[@safidasango]

True, more than likely both ​@@anxioussquiddy

[@CasualVFlowerEnjoyer]

I think that episode is called "Green isn't your color"? Which, y'know, plays off the saying 'green with envy'. Fluttershy also tends to wear green-themed outfits, which I think shows Fluttershy's angle in the episode, she's only wearing all of these clothes because Rarity talked her into it. She doesn't actually want to be wearing them and showing off. The first outfits specifically chosen by Rarity for her to wear are *not* green, while every outfit (outside of magazine covers and such) Photo Finish has her wear incorporates green, or is entirely green. Rarity's envy only started after that first green outfit Photo Finish made Fluttershy model instead of the outfit Rarity chose, when her dreams were dashed in favor of Fluttershy. I'm probably reading too much into it and the design team just likes putting her in green, but its something I noticed.

[@Howaboutyes11]

OOOooo THATS SO cool!!❤❤

[@purplesam2609]

I love how in MLP they signify more powerful ponies by giving them normal horse proportions pretty much

[@T_E_G]

The fact that it's true 😭 Horses are strong as they are beautiful

[@voilet-the-non-violet-vulpix]

They have a lot of horsepower, as opposed to the more diminutive unit of measurement, ponypower.

[@LadyMajolish]

This design of Nightmare Rarity literally ✨SLAYS✨ like literally slays, like you literally ATE this up and left no crumbs and biscuits, with no tea in the cup. 😔☕️

[@GoreBunny1]

Okay imagine nightmare Octavia and Nightmare Dj pon-3 having a concert with Rainbow Slash

[@Trainspotter-]

Тhis

[@RainbowToons_]

actually!! the tantabus is NOT what made luna nightmare moon! in the dream realm, luna uses the tantabus to punish herself every night with a nightmare so she could never forgive herself, but it spiraled out of control in the episode and almost came to the real world :3 so the nightmare forces are probably still what turned luna evil!

[@noodleydoo2862]

Ooooo cool

[@christiantwist3360]

Yay PG self harm

[@incineroar9933]

Now that you've made the mane 6 into villains, what about making some of the villains the main 6?

[@christiantwist3360]

That would be cool

[@Loloany]

Up!!

[@Amanecer458]

The IDW comics were so good, more of the fandom should read them. Nightmare Rarity should have toys

[@user-th1be7mb5g]

Idea: could you make some of the villains or ‘nightmare’ characters into the protagonists and heroes? Ponies like Chrysalis being changed into good guys could be really interesting to explore as a concept! Love your content so much! Keep up the good work!

[@LunaSilverPelt]

Oooh I love this idea

[@Cenmeow]

HER HAIR!! sorry i just had to mention it

[@megadrivesonic]

congrats on finishing all the mane six, been fun watching you make all these great designs.

[@JaneGumball]

Thank you!

[@megadrivesonic]

@@JaneGumball you're welcome. When I have some free time I plan on drawing my favorites of the series and will be sure to tag you in them so you see them.

[@Cristaltimetdmfnafmlpv71.3]

Nightmare rarity Remastered 💎💠

[@creatchure]

Spike always gets left out of stuff in the show, so what if he basically cosplays a Nightmare version of himself and just commits petty crimes but then goes back and makes up for them lol

[@SpacialRend7]

Love the add-on accessories you gave NM Rarity, it’s a major glow up and fits her character much more imo. Wonderfully done! And I do like the spin on her dark turn, the Snow White bit, as well as the tie-in ideas with the Nightmare Pony theme you described.💎💎

[@ThePearlision]

No nightmare big mac video 💔 He need a evil version of his magical princess power form

[@bok9596]

Cutie mark crusaders as cheeky sidekicks!

[@katarinamy7879]

This series has been the highlight of my weekends these last few months 😊

[@JaneGumball]

I’m honored! Thank you for watching!

[@victoriavidaud]

THERE WAS STILL A FLUTTERSHY IN THIS ONE Also I love how the beauty queen has grey hair 😂 (white, but still. I thought it was funny)

[@StellaPinkbird]

The "not you lol" from the mirror is such a nice touch lmao

[@OwlsEverywhere]

I'd love an AU where one of the others was the first to crack but then ends up leading to the others also getting corrupted until we have a full-on nightmare mane six

[@isabelportmann2695]

Sunset shimmer is next for season 2

[@yeyovalium7818]

I think we saw a bit of that concept between Rarity and Fluttershy in that episode where she became a model and Rarity was supporting her even when she was jealous, and Fluttershy didn't want, but she thought quitting would made Rarity upset.

[@lynnboartsdye1943]

The fur mantle is giving snow queen I love it!!

[@tegueggu]

It would be so fun to have a short comic for each evil character showing a dive into their world

[@LannyLeArtist]

The fluffy scarf like thing is giving cruella deville

[@Im_Tori_Senpai]

If this ever continues, I'd love to see Nightmare versions of Starlight and Sunset. I know technically, Sunset's would be based off the monster design from Equestria Girls, kinda like with Twilight's, but I think it'd be fun to try.

[@weaksaucet.t330]

IDEA: Nightmare AU🌙😈 The story goes similar to the Nightmare rarity thing except whilst she is evil, in her jealousy of fluttershys natural beauty she steals an apple from Sweet Apple orchards and uses magic to make whoever consumes it become a monster She then disguises herself as a memeber of the Apple family to give to fluttershy and when she consumes the apple she becomes flutterbat Due to being a “monster” the animals now fear her and she loses her connection to them and retreats to the Everfree forest, where she is left vulnerable to the Nightmare forces and becomes Nightmare Fluttershy (still don’t have a good name idea) After becoming nightmare fluttershy she begins terrorizing Sweet Apple Orchards to feed on their apples causing the family to be in a struggle. Applejack distraught by the idea of losing the farm wants to protect it & her family at any cost, which leads to her corruption into Apple Hijack, who terrorizes Ponyville with her flawed sense of justice. Any ideas to tie the others into it. My end idea is that all the most important figures are corrupted by the nightmare forces Celestia becomes Day breaker & destroys everyone’s sleep schedule. Maybe Luna becomes Nightmare moon again and they fight for eternal day or night, with some areas having one or the other Cadence becomes DIVORCE HORSE. And inspires hatred The nightmare forces goal of spreading hatred & evil across the land is almost unstoppable, except for a some that stand up and fight for friendship Starlight glimmer, Trixie, maybe Zecora (she deserved more on the show), spike, discord (more or less for friendship and more for Fluttershy), and another character that I can’t think of that will become the mane six of this world to replace the mane six that became evil and fix equestria Any suggestions for this story

[@AnaPaula-2000]

Yeeees, I've been waiting for Rarity's turn ❤❤❤

[@welp4130]

if you continue to do these sometime, starlight glimmer, sunset shimmer, etc would be super cool nightmare forms !

[@user-wf6yt5qh3h]

NOOO, I'm not ready for it to be over, but, I'm glad you did this Jane, like always these Nightmare 6 (Technically 7), they were so well done and your designs for them are amazing, I hope you enjoy your little break and I can't wait for the next video you come up with EDIT: These guys in the main MLP show would have made for a killer episode too, make the show 1000000000000000 times better than it already is

[@Missty_the.aliencat]

Nightmare Rarity is✨ SLAY✨ and sooo pretty!! I loved your series of the ponies they're all great and the idea of the snow white story is cool!

[@EclipseTheFox]

I am so here for the Monster High series. No idea the "topic" of them is, whether it's a redesign or in your style, regardless I'm here for it!!!

[@purrfurr4803]

MAN i love love love the idea of nightmare rarity with opal too. like that's iconic, evil ladies need their cats and i will stand by this until the day i DIE

[@justdrums8273]

I want to read a fanfic about your super cool AU 😮

[@late_prince8945]

She actually gets an armor in the comic, it's gold with blue crystals, looks a lot like nightmare moon.

[@SkylethrinYT]

they did keep the jealousy trait for Rarity - in the episode with Fluttershy becoming a model :P

[@AnnamatopoeiaArt]

I AM SOOOO EXCITED for the enamel pin set! I adore enamel pins and your designs. Also LOVE LOVE LOVE your Rarity so fabulous

[@JaneGumball]

Yay! Thank you!

[@concernedweeb6722]

Wow, since the the concept of Nightmare Rarity already existed. I'm glad you went ahead and did this!

[@daisydaisyrust]

Ahahahah my drawing is in there! That is serendipitous because I thought this series was over 😂 I love how you gave the queen a glow up

[@someteennamedcharles2035]

Okay, here's my suggestion and concept for your next part: What if Spike was a villain? You discussed before the Mane 6's "nightmare-ification" would be based on them succumbing to their insecurities. Spike's is definitely him being "left out" of their friend group, he's the "unseen underdog" just like Stygian with the Pillars or Luna when ponies don't appreciate her night. With him being left alone thinking if the Mane 6 were truly his friends, if they ever appreciate him, or if he was ever useful/helpful or worthy to them, it would definitely attract the Nightmare Force to possess him.

[@espresso5990]

This is so beautiful oh my goodness.. I REALLY LIKE THIS! She’s gorgeous!!

[@Songal18]

She is SLAYING even more than the comic has her!! Gorgeous job!

[@amethystrose1888]

Rainbow Slash was sold out!! Noooooo!!!

[@Eyrinthefae04]

I would love to see more worldbuilding on this! The main six become evil versions of themselves leading to the only person that can stop them being Starlight Shimmer. She could battle them one by one turning them good each time she wins and joining forces with them to stop twilight and eventually Luna bringing back Celestia and peace to Equestria :D

[@k0perr300]

im very sad this series is over, i really love your art and i cant wait for more !!

[@derpylizard7020]

Absolutely love your art and designs!

[@JaneGumball]

Thank you so much!

[@mokimochi02]

Thank u for the art so i coiuld get off my art block with Nightmare flutterrshy

[@SugarsnapCaely]

I've adored this entire series! I loved seeing the way you worked with all of the different concepts, playing off of their characteristics! while I don't know much about Monster High I've enjoyed your pony videos and art so much that I am 100% subscribing and watching that series anyway :D

[@JaneGumball]

Thank you so much!

[@LunamoonTwT]

I've seen a LOT of nightmare versions of the mane 6, but yours are by far my favorite. I can't wait to make fanart of all of these!

[@noeysnowy14]

Ive really like this series! Your ideas are so fun and ive always wondered wjat these ponies would look like. Also excited for the monster high designs!

[@ivydbomb-6969]

Preordered a rainbow dash pin!! Super excited to get it. I love glow in the dark stuff.

[@animated_finn]

6:46 It was never explicitly stated what actually caused Luna to transform, but she raises to moon (causing an eclipse) and yaps about the night being forever. The tantabus was created AFTER lunas redemption and she says she created it to torture and give HERSELF nightmares as punishment for being nightmare moon

[@xsevilite]

YESSSS omg I was waiting for all of them to be done so I could try to draw all 6 of the nightmares together 👀✨ All of the designs are so gorgeous 😭😭✨

[@alexhoskins1685]

I’ve enjoyed this series so much!! I love your art style and even thought I haven’t watched much of mlp, this kind of content makes me want to watch all of it!

[@kingasbackupchannel1773]

Gotta love the snow white refrence there

[@themagicconch.804]

Oop buffet! ✨ Because you tore that design up! Rarity looks incredible 💎

[@YR-zj2ik]

I just love Jane's impression of Twilight lol.

[@dinstraction]

they did touch on the rarity being jealous of fluttershy thing, in the episode with photo finish! really enjoyed this, very cool to see all of them in your style, and seeing your sketching process is really fun! what is her name though ........!!! and did you pick a fluttershy name?

[@AMS-tothepm]

“ She’s giving mirror mirror on the wall, who is the fairest pony of them all” and then it goes showing Fluttershy. Very evil queen. 👸

[@juliemesser2053]

Ahh,she's so elegant and dressed up.Eeeee. So beautiful. I never knew Laura Faust's plan to make Fluttershy after Snow White. Snow White of all people!! So, genius! I love the pearls and the foax fur. Maybe in a new generation of Mlp, the character of Snow White would go to some pony else.

[@miiirky1904]

A ha! Just as I suggested in the Applejack video

[@Rex_TheTex]

ooo she's giving Georgette from Oliver and company

[@twidashfan]

10:00 i never read the mlp bible thing your talking about,but you're saying that the creator of mlp/lauren faust basically confirmed that rarity is always jealous of fluttershy,because of her natural beauty and cuteness.(and that fluttershy is like snow whiite )and i kinda believe that,because you can kinda tell how jealous rarity is of fluttershy in episodes like "green is not your color"

[@SpineBones]

I wanna make a silly au where this is just what regular rarity looks like because the design is so pretty :>

[@yourshoulderdevil5229]

3:23 is beautiful.

[@TheButlerForYou]

how in all this time this went under my radar!? this ii awesome!, I love the art, love the mlp comic and I was in love with nightmare rarity's design when I read the comics so long ago, for art class I even made a cathedral-like window of her for my room, I insta-liked and subscribed, if not for the distance I will also have loved to buy one of the pins for the fund, wish you the best on that!

[@-RaidenArts-]

absolutely 💖GOURGIOUS!!!💖 well done on the designing and story, it ties to the other nightmares so well hehehhe

[@christiantwist3360]

6:55 in this scenario, it’s really messed up Luna was sentenced to a thousand years of isolation just because some monsters fed off her insecurities

[@siamuchesiameja3566]

Love the volume of the hair💅🦄💎💎💎

[@faithtibbit3765]

Shattered Jewel: villain of evil beauty

[@cupcakekitcat]

She’s so pretty!

[@imaginations_animations4928]

This is the end of the series? I'd really not like it to be bc I was hoping to see a "Nightmarified" version of Tempest. And maybe a few other characters too? Like, perhaps Starlight and Trixie?

[@JaneGumball]

Maybe in the future! I need a break for now though.

[@imaginations_animations4928]

@@JaneGumball I understand. Hope you feel better! Love the vid. 😄

[@JershReed-fw4wk]

Ahhh the preorders sold out already! Congrats!

[@Fourger14]

Tantabus was Luna's creation to torture herself, not a replacement for the Nightmare Forces. No cartoon canon contradicts them explicitly.

[@gibbs9206]

Imagine a wanted poster of nightmare applejack though 🙀

[@LunarLioness]

I got an idea, how about Nightmare Starlight? Y'know like if she had a Nightmare moon form.

[@brianahawkins8124]

I love all your nightmare design of Twilight, Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash, Apple Jack, Pinkie Pie, Rarity, Cadence, & Flurryheart, I don't know if you did Nightmare Moon & Daybreaker but if you did I will always love your artwork. I don't know if you did Cozy Glow in either Alicorn or Chaos Alicorn. I did drew free hand art of the Mane Nightmare six as magical humans like how Hextian made his MLP FIM Ooak dolls so I had to give them the Nightmare Sona's look. I may have to try again & use your Nightmare designs to give mine a lvl 2 Nightmare forms, my take on for evil Pinkie pie I use Loki from Avengers his armor for some idea's but use candy & Ice cream for armor which didn't go well as planned so I'll try the clown vibe like how you did with your Pinkie Pie's nightmare form.

[@grimgingrin830]

Yeees Rarityy!! Love her

[@SilverVixen-yl6tc]

What about mlp villains as heroes?👀

[@Simon-wi8ed]

Idk know if you know her but it would be nice if you did a nightmare version of Starlight Glimmer

[@NerdyPony]

INeed those pins omg

[@carolinea3899]

This has been such an awesome series, thank you!!!

[@Craftycatz1289]

Honestly, Rarity's fall could be her nightmare, which has her friends taking advantage of her generosity. And this return makes it easy for the nightmare forces to get in.

[@justabird0]

I'm in love wuth the series, your take on evil mane 6 was amazing! Hope to see your future proyects soon

[@AngelDragonAnimations]

You cant have the main six without Spike! We need a nightmare spike... guess Ill have to make him myself xD

[@WhatABinglylittlescronklylil-]

I imagine she has the personality of velvet, but mix in insecurity about thinking her friends betrayed her/ we’re never friends with her

[@floofycupkim1197]

Idea. Mlp characters as Undertale monsters

[@Constantine_Cvl8]

We got the whole gang now! The only thing I need to do now is set up a basement, thick chains, and find a good fimfiction writer...

[@Praise-Algoritmi]

Rarity.

[@SpineBones]

The tantabus wasn't what corrupted Luna, she created it to punish herself by giving her nightmares because of how horrible she felt about what she did as nightmare moon So, magical sh =[ Very upsetting

[@LibraWolf-lp4td]

I'm curious to see your version of nightmare moon Maybe a redesign?

[@littlestrawberryfaery]

If you don't do a Snow White story where all your aus get mixed then ima be crossed

[@mossy_dropTHEnumb3r13M0]

Dude this slays so hard

[@Gjoob]

SHES SO PRETTY YASS

[@-kanju-]

I LOVED TJISSS can’t wait or what’s next :D

[@DelightfulDragonflies-ie6nl]

Stop because she’s so pretty!!

[@LatestCreatureFeature]

i saw you on tiktok, holy shit i had no idea you had a youtube

[@LovebugsLab]

Will we be seeing these for other popular characters? You've done Derpy, what about characters like Sunset Shimmer, Spike, Trixie, Shining Armor, etc? (/notforced)

[@donuko]

would "Vanity" be too on the nose for a name?

[@cinnamonsugarcourtney6073]

why not Nightmare Starlight Glimmer or Nightmare Trixie? lol