What If Tartarus Listened To The Arbiter?

[@zahylon5993]

On the other hand, I can imagien Truth just dropping F-bombs all ver the comms channel when he sees Tartarus, Atriox, Chief and Arby knocking on the door.

[@IvanicohG]

Idk how many more he would drop when Tartarus starts eating him

[@captain_will.]

Yeah the alliance and truth have vary different definition of the word holy

[@Chrisspru]

tartarus falling to his death is a good outcome, as truth was likely already infected when tartarus ate him. his death spared a lot of trouble.

[@Beathisat7]

"Oh i know what the Monkeys Like" is totally something i can hear Johnson saying in this type og situation 😂

[@IvanicohG]

I think that is so in character for him lol thank you for watching

[@mycreativitymaster3295]

Dam that was funny as hell 😂😂

[@konahrikb1578]

I love these alternate ideas where Tartarus wakes up to the truth and leads the brutes in rebellion. In the crossover "War, Peace, and Other Galactic Customs" the war finally ends with the Chief, Six, the Arbiter, Rtas, Tartarus, and his OC brother Taurus working together to kill the Didact in conventional combat. Tartarus and Taurus smashed his legs while the Elites stabbed his arms, it was awesome.

[@chillokay5189]

Can you please tell us the the name of the channel because I can’t find the video

[@notaclass-d1822]

why was noble six there lmao

[@konahrikb1578]

@@notaclass-d1822 Alternate universe, long story, pretty decent read.

[@notaclass-d1822]

@@konahrikb1578 fair enough

[@My19922]

Ive read that story a few times pretty damn good and very long. Has some minor Mass Effect crossover after the Covenant War. Any story that shows Humanitu jouning forces with Covenant Separatists before the events of the Halo's Reach-3 is amazing even better if the UNSC,Covenant,Citated Council join forces against the Flood,Reapers,Promotheans

[@dakotalange2858]

What if Halsey got her full funding for the Spartan 2 program and we got 300 Spartan 2’s

[@IvanicohG]

I like it, but With the Augmentations killing so many spartans, I think Yes we would have a lot more spartans, but realistically I think that Only Delayes Humanity's downfall a decade or so. HOWEVER. I see a scenario where, 100 Ish Spartans Do OPERATION RED FLAG, and that changes EVERYTHING

[@HUNKMrDeath-lt7kq]

Funny enough I once had a stupid idea that’d make for a shitty vid most likely. XD I sorta have a made up alternate Halo timeline of sorts, most of the lore is the same with a few minor differences, one such is that O.N.I had found and decided to play with a bit of forerunner tech for the SII program which also lead to me making 8 or 9 OCs for it, but it lead to some advanced weapons and armor systems however was VERY costly, as such only two teams of SIIs were selected for it, and those two teams basically functioned as SII Head Hunters. I dod do various things to make sure they wouldn’t show up or be available during Halo CE-3. I ended up making another faction involving only Elites using reverse engineered Forerunner tech more so than the Covenant and with more effectiveness than the covenant. I won’t go into detail about everything, but most of those OCs I made up for it are dead, only 4 remain.

[@commandercody2980]

The S-II program only ever had 150 potential candidates max, meaning that if they did get as much funding as Halsey wanted, they'd still only end up with half of that number. The program with 300 candidates was S-III, where Alpha and Beta Companies both had that many. Gamma company however had 330 candidates.

[@IvanicohG]

@commandercody2980 JUST to play devils advocate here. If she had all the funding she wanted, she’d FIND a way to kidnap another 150 kids. Inferior maybe, but she’s still taking the subjects.

[@jakefrompc6287]

@@IvanicohGeh Halsey was in it for the science. Why use “inferiors” was the mindset during S-II program. S-III was the oh we need bodies.

[@wilmeragosto1756]

I want a continuation so bad of this to Halo 4 with Atriox around… PLEASEEE

[@IvanicohG]

I hear your pleads. I shall write it on the list. List has changed a lot but every week or so a new comment pops up on this video people wanting a continuation!

[@lynrin9355]

That’s my husband!! Such a great video guys! I love it! No one’s a bigger Halo nerd than Kody, let me tell ya! Hope to see more from both of you!

[@IvanicohG]

Thank you for supporting his interests!

[@Ahhkiba]

I genuinely think if Tatar sauce joined up with the humans and elites I think Atriox would ally with them to get revenge against the prophets. It seems almost a common goal for every being to stop the flood and prophets. Even in the most desperate times, people will unite under a common goal.

[@IvanicohG]

That was the main idea I wanted to convey here. These are groups that generally hate each other for nearly 3 decades of war, but this conflict was too big for them

[@kodymcgrath8002]

I am so glad with how this turned out! Thank you so much. I’ve been writing down some ideas for the reclaimer saga and I hope we can make it come alive

[@razakeldrukata6502]

Id like to request a continuation of this

[@IvanicohG]

The people have spoken. I will have to work on this timeline. It was a fun one after all

[@dakotalange2858]

What if the Sangheli didn’t join the covenant during its beginning and later joined the human side when war broke out between the human and the new covenant so Human/ Sangheli vs covenant war

[@IvanicohG]

It Is now, On the List !

[@terribe_preacher743]

I want to see a part 2 to this if possible. To see how the events of post-war will play out.

[@IvanicohG]

Kody and I came to an agreement, If the video does well, I'll do a part 2. Meanwhile he was already planning to start writing down some ideas for the Reclaimer saga, either way. So lets keep our fingers crossed.

[@terribe_preacher743]

@@IvanicohG cool

[@mrsquid1360]

Another banger what if the rookie from ODST became a spartan 4

[@IvanicohG]

Thank you!

[@MeddlerPropagandist14]

RIP rookie😢

[@mrsquid1360]

@@MeddlerPropagandist14 fr

[@TeaganL1701]

Also maybe do a What if the Ur Didact Wasnt evil ( maybe you can also kinda include mendican Bias whas right about the ur diadact wanting to help humanity ? Now that i think about it this could be a completely different timeline except everything up until chief unlocks the diadacts cryptum wold pretty much be the same , and how a UNSC-Diadact alliance would work! And maybe a what if the librarian ( halo 4 ) cured Cortana’s Rampancy when she took her ?

[@IvanicohG]

I have an idea in mind for a what if, didact woke up earlier, and if didact was good/on our side. And another one regarding Cortana’s rampancy. You have REALLY good ideas mate.

[@TeaganL1701]

@@IvanicohG thank you kindly ! Your very concept about a channel solely based on community and sharing of theories is amazing i kinda wonder if you will become the Alternate History hub of halo combined with somthing like installation 00 ( the yt channel not the lesser ark )

[@TeaganL1701]

@@IvanicohG can’t wait 🤞🏻

[@IvanicohG]

@@TeaganL1701 XDbut i wanna become th eArk, My arks become the Ark's spikes! My legs too!. My face becomes a Monitor! I am Chakas 2! Thank you though i really appreciate the vote of confidence

[@dakotalange2858]

What if the humans found a halo ring before the covenant war?

[@IvanicohG]

Thats going on the list

[@HardCorePoration]

They accidentally release the Flood, or turn on the Halo in their own hubris. Either way, game over.

[@morienforeshadow4553]

Honestly, they could blow themselves up but maybe with the assistance of the Monitors they might be able to replicate Forerunner technologies, and just curbstomp the covenant, or just turn the entirety of the covenant against the prophets immediately.

[@IvanicohG]

Hey as soon as you see this, Email me, My email for these what If is in the "about" section of my channel. Your suggestion won the What-If poll for next commenter what-if

[@dakotalange2858]

@Ivanicoh I am very exited to have won that’s awesome news! I looked in the about section and I didn’t see it is it the twister account?

[@TeaganL1701]

WE NEED A PART TWO ! i wanna see how this UNSC & Swords of sanghelios (ill refer to as SWORDS OF HELIOS ( SoH ) as in a nickname of sanghelios and the god of the sun from greek gods ( earth ) ) and this new Banished that is more friendly towards SoH and how this alliance will change the created crisis and what happens with the zeta halo aka ( halo infinite ) maybe cortana ( created ) somehow activates the endless earlier and thus delaying the end of the created conflict and instead really turning ut into the Creat WAR !?

[@IvanicohG]

I have some ideas in mind, and Once it comes time to do a part 2 I’m gonna run it with Kody and see what his core ideas are

[@callumkristofer7793]

@@IvanicohG I imagine it should go the same as halo 4, actually. Except, now the Banished and SoH are assisting humanity against the Storm and Prometheans.

[@BaconLover100]

heres an Idea: What if the proto gravemind escaped Installation 04? Bonus: Flood and Covenant ally during the battle of Installation 04

[@IvanicohG]

I like the first part, The Bonus, I just dotn see anyone teaming up with the flood, specially the covenant knowing the flood is Their god's enemies. But I will write that down

[@youraverageuser7039]

@@IvanicohGwhat if the UNSC and covenant ceasefire when the flood is released

[@youraverageuser7039]

@@IvanicohGanother awesome what if is “What if Staff Sgt. Marvin Mobuto recovered the index” i think that would be a massive game changer depending on WHEN he recovered it as it could end all life or have a special meetup between him and the chief

[@jacobvalentine2339]

Nice Darkseid/Batman convo reference with Atriox and Johnson

[@IvanicohG]

:D i was wondering if anyone would get it

[@phatdog]

I was curious to know if Atriox would somehow get involved in this what if. Truly awesome.

[@IvanicohG]

Thank you! He is a big part of the universe now. That’s the advantage of hindsight but thanks for watching!

[@phatdog]

@@IvanicohG Honestly this is a very thought provoking 'What If' scenario as it would almost be a repeat of Chief and Arbiter in H2, but instead Chief and Atriox against the Didact which really makes you wonder if it would end in an alliance again or end in a last man standing scenario. Love the content, keep it up 😁

[@MichaelAttridge-g2b]

Part 2 please

[@fleetmastermichael]

Love it. Another idea. 343 remembers. His life as a human as the lord of admirals and or the iso didactic companion right before the start of halo one.

[@IvanicohG]

I’m gonna write this as PART of the “what if 343 did not betray Chief”

[@fluent4530]

I still recommend my idea on What if Noble Six went to Onyx after the Fall Of Reach but I have another idea that could be interesting. So as we all know the forerunner dreadnought that powers high charity and the one truth uses to go to earth was originally meant to go to earth. Onboard the dreadnought was the Forerunner A.I mendicant Bias. The reason Mendicant Bias was going to earth was to atone for his sins and help humanity soooo, What if Mendicant Bias actually made it to earth but was only found during the human covenant war. Edit: Really loving these what if videos I was sad when Reclaimer gaming stopped doing them and I’m glad someone else has stepped up to the plate. Good work and keep on chugging

[@IvanicohG]

I had no idea reclaimer gaming existed until someone kept commenting for me to do a Noble 6 surviving reach. Like I told that guy, I will tackle noble 6, but only once I’m more comfortable with my own style. I’ve seen Reclaimer’s video and I wanna make sure mine is different. I’ll tackle N6 when I have a bigger audience but I promise you I will make one

[@KyleStock-s8n]

The sound is better than expected.

[@TheZamaron]

Part 2 please. I’d love to see Halo 4 with Chief and CC Atriox.

[@masterdrew2494]

I can't wait for this to be updated.I'd like to see The brute and master chief worked together And maybe they will probably be found by the spirit of fire in Halo 4.

[@smokeyredmeadow]

Part 2 when

[@lordmessoric]

Hey, I have an idea, what if the banished aligned with Humanity in 2550? Not full on joined, but an alliance against the covenant? It could lead to humanity getting access to covenant technology, the banished getting full on military support to their raiding parties, maybe a full on infiltration of high charity to kill the prophets

[@razakeldrukata6502]

excellent rendition

[@IvanicohG]

:D thank you!

[@jonathan_1177]

Great video man take your time no rush

[@IvanicohG]

Thanks! Will do! hope the Sound wasnt too grating

[@lordmessoric]

I love the darkseid reference btw

[@IvanicohG]

I was wondering if anyone would get it! Thank you!

[@racknack5778]

I want to see a part two for this video seeing halo 4 with the chief and atreox fighting against the convenient and sentinels

[@richardbarrett4488]

14:10 Well played Darkseid

[@IvanicohG]

Did you like it? Or did it come off WAY TOO on the nose?

[@richardbarrett4488]

@@IvanicohG i geeked out when I recognized it!

[@IvanicohG]

@@richardbarrett4488 :D that was the intent

[@miscuser5534]

Write a part 2 to this with Atriox accompanying the chief to Requiem

[@IvanicohG]

this seems to be catchign a lot of views now a year later, so I think i might go back to it to be honest.

[@dwane_ronk_ree_rongsong5624]

I also have a cool what if,what if instead of master chief in the events of halo CE,it is Buck's ODST squad instead,Cortana is still there BTW

[@IvanicohG]

I wrote it down, but I’ll have read up on the ODSTs a lot before I take on this.

[@My19922]

What if Blue Team,Noble Team,Alpha-Nine and Fireteam Raven lead the UNSC Ground Forces from the Pillar of Autumn during the Battle of Installation 04?

[@Captainwill2]

Pt2 when

[@lunerwolf6588]

What if noble team survived reach

[@IvanicohG]

This is plan to do 100% if I reach 2500 subs

[@TheZamaron]

This would be a test of Tartarus’s influence, cause if he and Arbiter could unite most Brutes and Elites against the Prophets, then Truth’s plans come to a screeching halt as he wouldn’t have many to trust, and the other species would either fall in behind the rebels, or easily get slaughtered by the combined might of the Brutes and Elites.

[@IvanicohG]

The only reason I never made a part two to this was cause the person I collabed with for the idea disappeared. But this video is getting a lot of traction again so I might revisit this timeline soon.

[@windless4770]

Is there going to be a part 2

[@IvanicohG]

Eventually. When I’m not super busy with work 😅

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

117th Like. Loading Mjolnir Mix...

[@IvanicohG]

Lol this made me put it as part of my next video

[@VunderGuy]

What if Tony Stark between Iron Man 2 and The Avengers joined Halsey's team at the start of the Spartan program?

[@IvanicohG]

Thanks for watching but it’s Gonna be a while before I can ever tackle this.

[@SuperSonicSauropod2401]

What if... Thel was executed instead of becoming The Arbiter

[@ForsakenSandpaper]

Halo 3 would have tartarus and arbiter together with chief.

[@IvanicohG]

That would be absolutely the most fun ever. Add a grunt or something as the fourth playable character and that’s priceless

[@xxcrazymanxx1001]

What of keys never discovered the first halo ring

[@dragonpro7484]

Will there be a part two to this?

[@IvanicohG]

I hope so, Let me just copy Paste what I told the other person "Kody and I came to an agreement, If the video does well, I'll do a part 2. Meanwhile he was already planning to start writing down some ideas for the Reclaimer saga, either way. So lets keep our fingers crossed"

[@MichaelAttridge-g2b]

Part 2

[@Black_Dragon_Studios]

could we get a part 2 for halo 4, that would be cool

[@IvanicohG]

If I can get in contact with Kody, if not I’ll have to wait and I’ll just write out the whole thing with or without his blessing :/

[@Black_Dragon_Studios]

@@IvanicohG cool, hope that goes well, I really like your halo 'what if' videos.

[@IvanicohG]

Thank you very much

[@thomasjones3206]

W

[@IvanicohG]

Thank you!

[@masterdrew2494]

When are you gonna update this or you're other what if?

[@IvanicohG]

I’m gonna post Melinda-043 next week and after that I’m going back to what ifs. First one is gonna be “what if B312 hadn’t joined noble team part 3” and after I’ll put up a poll to see what people want me to go back to

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

When do we get part 2?

[@IvanicohG]

I'l have to consider it, i need to learn more about the banished first though!

[@cqb3814]

How the hell is atriox gonna breathe in space

[@IvanicohG]

Energy shields. Also not meant to breathe. There was cut content for part 2 but part 2 never happened :(

[@cqb3814]

@@IvanicohG atriox in halo 4 would have been something fr

[@skelesidiantherevenger]

Do a what if called what if arbiter and chief roles were reverse in halo 2?

[@IvanicohG]

That’s already on the list 😊 just haven’t had much time in life to get to it, it’s like #4 on the list

[@gaiusmariuscaesar]

I personally think that tartarus would have killed atriox as he was more experienced while not being too old.

[@IvanicohG]

I dont know man, Have you seen the opening to halo Infinite? He lifts Chief up with one hand and that tells me attrox has some sort of augmentation going on. His reflexes and bones too.

[@gaiusmariuscaesar]

@@IvanicohG true but most brutes could do that, also don't spoil infinite for me i have yet to play it, although my reason is Tartarus took on several high ranking elites and the arbiter and killed many of them, me personally i don't think atriox would be able to do the same thing although he is defiantly smarter then Tartarus

[@IvanicohG]

I’m not trying to spoil H6 but NOT all brutes can lift 1000 pounds with one hand. Specially not as easily as attrox

[@gaiusmariuscaesar]

@@IvanicohG Maybe not all of them but Tartarus is probably one of them as well, and with the first of rukt and him being just as ruthless as any other brute i think he would at least make it an even fight.

[@albertwesker6463]

Just out of curiosity how can you make a part 2 of this since atriox killed him

[@IvanicohG]

Did he though? DIIID he? jk idk Kody is the one who seems to believe so. Also a lot of people seem to want a part 2

[@thecomedygamingnetwork261]

What if Tartarus and Aatriox made love UwU

[@IvanicohG]

This is going on the April’s fools list xD

[@thecomedygamingnetwork261]

@@IvanicohG yeeeeee :p

[@cjisawesome3686]

What if Thel never Became the Arbiter 😒🤔!?

[@IvanicohG]

That’s a good one!!!

[@jonathan_1177]

23:50 dude I’m sorry that’s just bad

[@IvanicohG]

XD oh no!!!!

[@MrWin-pj4sg]

Infinite bad lol

[@IvanicohG]

The game or?

[@jonathan_1177]

Do halo reach

[@MeddlerPropagandist14]

gotta be more Pacific

[@IvanicohG]

Lol

[@IvanicohG]

What about reach? Any specific idea in mind?

[@jonathan_1177]

@@IvanicohG something with noble 6 escaping and helping cheif in halo 2/3 or cheif helping noble team on reach and they all live as a outcome and then go to fight on the ark

[@IvanicohG]

@@jonathan_1177 basically AS LONG as chief and 6 teram up to duo tea-bag the covenant?

[@treavy1]

What if the covernant accepted humanity as part of the covernant

[@IvanicohG]

I have added it to the list. I have a long case scenario and a short one in mind