What is Free Will - Religion, Fate and Free Will - Determinism vs Free Will

[@mustajabkhan7997]

Buddy in your splendid effort separately and in the order mentioned is, opening eyes, minds and mentalities. these are best videos for Muslim ummah.دوست آپ کی شاندار کاوش میں الگ الگ اور ترتیب سے ذکر کیا ہے، آنکھیں، دماغ اور ذہنیت کو کھولنا۔ یہ امت مسلمہ کے لیے بہترین ویڈیوز ہیں۔❤🎉🎉🎉

[@MuhsinLaskar-MBBS]

14:43 . I think muslims who are doing this type of acts are wrong. But Islam is not wrong. Allah says in Quran about Perseverance and Hard Work** "Man will not get anything unless he works hard." (Quran 53:39) **Meaning**: Success in both this world and the next comes through dedication and effort. Hard work is rewarded by Allah. 😂😂 So people are saying no molves were harmed ❤ Love you bro❤. I have gone through all other religions and I found Islam is more logical that's why I am following islam. I have read Bible, Gita, ramayana , Qur'an ❤

[@kidskat191]

I love you only because of your videos on philosophy...Thank you for focusing such an underrated topics of philosophy in Pakistan..

[@PradipMithu]

I have become a fan of your philosophy. Your explanations are quite easy to grasp. After Bernardo kastrup's, i found your explanation on this topic the most compelling one. And i will definitely order your book. Keep it up bro. Love from INDIA

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thx Pradip

[@STUDENT-OF-ISLAM518]

Kuch sawal hai unk jawab day please . 1:agar sub Ameer ho jaye to Kya Hoga? 2:agar mot na ho to Kya Hoga? 3:agar beemariya khatam ho jaye to Kya Hoga? 4: agar qudarti afaat na aye to Kya hoga? Sir in sawalo k jawab day agr ap dy sakty hai to please me wait karuga❤❤❤

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

@@STUDENT-OF-ISLAM518then the world economy will collapse and the whole world be in chaos! Thanks God these things happen and these are the circles of life…….😊

[@STUDENT-OF-ISLAM518]

@@mohsinafzaal7159 yes right bro

[@Abdull3h_vfx]

yo dude what book?

[@sofie9d202]

Pakistan needs people's like you, i appreciate you and I'm greatfull that you share your golden knowledge to us ❤

[@JunaidAshrafLone]

Dear sir actually from the very beginning of early schooling my parents insisted me to study only science subjects till comlpete my medical degree from one of a leading Medical college of India.But sir this pre,existed in mind why am reluctant to study about all this universe's philosophy even about myself.But my pleasure that i watced you almost all episodes,For this wish you all the best....From.India..Rajisthan.

[@rahul19ify]

I am regular visitor of your channel. Love your content. Rahul from New Delhi

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thx Rahul

[@BookWorld153]

Love from odisha ❤

[@nadirdhuka4991]

Sir you deserve millions of views 👏

[@thealihasnain]

Finally, someone talked about free will and fate. I've asked this question from every person, but no one answered me satisfactorily. And now you clear my perspective Waiting for your next video

[@trueguide3502]

آپکا انداز بیاں بہت عمدہ ہے

[@kailashpatirai]

According to my experience 100% i agree with you sir ji.

[@drsaqibsaavn....805]

Great sir i am a doctor and have deep interest in leaning Philosphy ,etc beleive you are an Ocean in ypurself . Your analysis is highly Intellectual. I kearn from you too much sir . Love and Respeect❤❤

[@Pakistani_1999]

Internal causes •Genetic Determinism •Physiological Determinism •Psychological Determinism External causes •Physical Determinism •Social Determinism •Economic Determinism •Religious Determinism •Environment Determinism •Heart Determinism •Soft Determinism A Man is but the product of his thoughts what he thinks he becomes. (Mahatma Ghandi) The greatest discovery is the discovery of the unconscious. (Sigmund Freud) Khudi ko kr buland itna k hr tqdeer say pahlay Khuda bnday say hud poochay bta teri raza kya ha (Iqbal)

[@sardarsaqibjaved9556]

Thanks

[@shoaib_akhtar_1729]

Thanks for guiding us, these videos makes us know about how to think instead of what to think...

[@infinix3890]

Awesome explanation sir, love from India ❤🙏🏻

[@humanityismyreligion8149]

kya baat hai sir lots of love from India 🇮🇳 ❤

[@Simple_livingwithBv]

This session reminded me the debates of Mutazilites on free will early in the 10th century 😊 thank you for enlightening us these kinds of discourses are really needed. Prayers From Capet own, South Africa

[@raviprakashombedkar718]

I keep saying to self, finding your channel is the best thing to me in 2024. Thanks a lot...lot to know & feel from your videos..

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thanks Ravi

[@sherryxd5379]

Great Respect for your work from Shakargarh

[@Obscure1329]

Sir I really enjoy your videos and logical content. I've gained so much knowledge from your videos that changed my behavior and broaden my thoughts. Thanks for amazing content😊❤

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

😊👍

[@sksoyebali7654]

Eagerly waiting for podcast of book buddy with Eng Muhammad Ali Mirza!! And hardest questions ever 🚀

[@FrazyyBanum]

Mirza is stupid and always runs away when confronted with tough questions. He ll be like “Namaz ka time ho rha hai”. Shahrukh has no match as yet in Pakistan. Maybe he has but people are hidden

[@HisanMahmood]

Mirza is also a kind of Molvi Sorry, but it’s true

[@cryptoknight9440]

What about qaisar ahmad raza?

[@zahidhassan348]

Book buddy you have changed my life❤

[@SuvaMukherjee]

Besides the amazing content, I love your tone and the humility with which you speak. You are a blessing to your nation and outside ❤ 🙏🙏 Greetings, from W.Bengal.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thanks Suva

[@Hafsah01-cz9km]

"Aasaar to kuch kuch nazar aatay hai ki akhir ,tadbeer ko taqdeer ke shaatir ne kiya maat"

[@29js]

aapka video bahat aachha hein aap acharya prashant ke video vi dekhe o vi bahat aachhe salha dete hein human life ke upor

[@sujalkamble0295]

Shayad "Free Will" jaisa kuchh nahi hota kyuki hamare actions bohot se chijo par depend karta hai jaise ki past events , parents, religion, genes, health, food, society, knowledge, information, social environment, geographical location etc. iske aadhar par ham decision kar paate hai, to isse ye conclusion nikalta hai ki free will jaisa kuchh nahi hota.

[@QuranBibleVed]

free will sirf sochne samjhne walo ke liye hai jinke paas aqal hai aur wo uska istemaal karte ho, be careful you are not a animal , otherwise your wrong decision can be fatal to you by judge Nature(prkriti )

[@R.kandaswamy]

“ If a Religion wants you to give up your freedom, just give up that religion Nothing is holier than your freedom!” --Mehmat Murat Ildan

[@premKumar-tc8ew]

The Imperishable Seed: How Hindu Mathematics Changed the World and why this History was Erased. Sir ise padhe . Sir iss book ko padhe

[@RavishKSingh]

when anyone relates science with religion then I understand that he does not have scientific temperment.

[@zeeshanchishty232]

Qismat/ muqaddar is something like a coding/ Programming of game or website or app . Jis me ki hum ko bhot saari jagah par Free Will di jati hai. Jaise ki agar aap ko koi chiz kharidna ho to buy now ya add to cart 🛒 ka option diya jata hai . Yani aap jo action lege result usi ke hisaab se nikle ga . Aur bhot saari cheeje limited hoti hai un par hamara ikhtiyar nahi hota jaise ki game 🎮 ka map 🗾 ho sakta hai usse bahar hum nahi jaskte usi tarah real life me hum kaha paida hoge ye hum decide nahi kar sakte. Lekin isme se har ek cheez coder ne pehle hi coding kar ke pahle hi likh di hoti hai, kis chiz par click karne se kiya hoga , kis tarah ka action lene se kiya result niklega. Yeh sab chize game ya website launch karne se pehle hi likh di jati hai . Bilkul usi tarah jaise humara imaan hai ki humari qismat humare paida hone se bhi pehle likh di ja chuki hai.

[@securitydgw1142]

It's an outstanding video sir Thank you so much for adding value in our life

[@kailashpatirai]

100% i agree with you sir ji 🙏

[@AliHassan-r6x]

Shah rukh sir, you should be beware of molvis because you are talking about critical issues.

[@saadlakha650]

He's aware bro ...

[@infpvlog8]

itni sare new new term ayege toh insian confuse hei hoga Yeh sabhi term generate huvi ha taqdeer sei Log aksar ise galat samajta ha insian apki qismat badal saqta ha apni habits aur neki kam karke maa baap ki khidmat karke dua is the weapon Which help me in real life ❤️ Har chez uske control ma ha aksar jinko childhood truama hota ha woh kafi kind heart hota ha samajhna wala hotai ha ALLAH kise na kise zariye sei insian koh Badalna ka moka deta hai Fer insian ki choice ha Aj apka man kiye tha coffee pina ka jab apna coffee koh kal khareeda tha Chahat free hai insian azad ha Islam kehta ha Woh apni chahat ma qaid ha Allah huma rasta dekhata ha samajna wala chalta hai Marne waqt sabko yaqeen hoga Allah kalam

[@Faiq-1712]

He know what he say

[@afghanatheist813]

Molvi are the misinformative persons in the society,

[@MoizRehmanK]

​@@infpvlog8Kun faya Kun but fir bi 6 din lagy universe ko banny mai 🤔

[@sohaibrgaming2441]

Sir you are great please recommend me the book for about the secrets of nature and philosophy. Please sir ❤❤❤

[@MAbdullah-iy6mu]

i become big fan of your lectures

[@89P13-c6s]

Wese to boht se videos pare hen homo dues pr, but apka storytelling is outstanding

[@harisafridi1289]

Sharukh sir I have been fan of your since 2 years and I really appreciate your efforts and I have also recommended your channel to my fellows and friends for constructing a better tomorrow. And in the last I would like to ask for the (Readistan Book) to read.

[@bilalafzal4752]

Hats of to you Sir ✨💕

[@azharrehman5016]

it is always useful and informative listening to your videos on philosophy,.. keep it up sir

[@uzairkashif5255]

Shahrukh bhai please make a video on quantum physics( quantum entanglement) and parallel universe

[@rituunarwal]

You are making my mornings brighter and night soother ☺️

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

👍

[@shoebansari5281]

Mai ek "INDIAN" muslim hu, but Jysi knowledge aap dete ja rhe hy, ab tk to mai khud ko Islam se kharij hi samjhu...😂😂👍🏻👍🏻

[@premKumar-tc8ew]

Roman mein likho isko urdu samajh aata hai

[@shoebansari5281]

​@@premKumar-tc8ew,,👆👆ab thhik hy bhai 😀😀👍🏻👍🏻

[@SamJee-wx9mz]

Tum Muslim ho bas. Name me Indian Laga kar badnam na kro

[@shoebansari5281]

​​​​​​​​@@SamJee-wx9mzSb ki soch ek jysi nhi hoti mere dost, jbki tum logo me bhi bahut algao-wad ❌ hy, aur na jane kitne mt-bhed ❌ bhi hy apas me...👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@shoebansari5281]

Bhai Mai to mazak kr rha tha, aap to serious ho gye. 😂😂😂 Bhai mujhe bhi is tarah ke informative videos dekhna bahut pasand hy. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 Mai bhi shahrukh bhai ka fan hu. ❤❤😊😊 Aur ha mai apne naam ki spelling ayse hi likhta hu, kyuki mujhe "AIB" (NUKS) pasand nhi 😜😜👍🏻👍🏻

[@desidesigning]

Absolutely outstanding 🎉

[@afghanatheist813]

I have a huge respect for sharukh bhai, love from Afghanistan from an under pump atheist ⚛️

[@RafaqatAli-hs7js]

Great job and I agree ❤❤❤ sharukh sir. Joo insan sochta hay Kar sakta hay sirf focused or sabir Hona chaye

[@shahabalitrainer1801]

I m agree with you 😘 everyone is freedom

[@UsmanTheBroken]

Aao jald hi Viral ho jao gey Mark my Words !!! But aap par bohot criticize bhi hoga because of typical molvies....

[@bijoykrmandi4065]

🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 sir ,Hard determined control Kiya ja sakta hai . Hard determined ko control kornako jindegike real hard work bolte hai .❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤.

[@javaidiqbal8467]

Friend The. Best !!!!

[@fahim8695]

I watch your video from Bangladesh. Lots of love.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thx Fahim

[@javedjutt660]

Best thanks Sir

[@sultangaming3109]

sir whats your perspective about existenialism

[@anwerjehanjafri1075]

اس ویڈیو سے مجھے ایک بات یاد آئ کسی نے حضرت علی سے پوچھا انسان کتنا خودمختار ہے اور کتنا مجبور تو انھوں نے فرمایا اپنا ایک پاؤں اٹھاؤ اس نے ایک اؤں اٹھایا کہا دوسرا پاؤں اٹھاؤ اس نے کہایہ تو ممکن نہیں فرمایا بس انسا اتنا مجبور اور اتنا خود مختار ہے یہ بات بچپن میں مجھے سمجھ میں نہیں آتی تھی اب اندازہ ہوا کہ انسان کچھ معاملات میں مجبور اور کچھ میں خودمختار ہے ۔

[@maheershalal5987]

بحکم الہی۔ عزت ماب غزالی صاحب😊

[@Ghsjsjjsksaoowusudhdhdbd]

Kash Pakistan mein sab ki mentality aap jesi ho jaye aur Extremism ka end ho jaye!!!

[@AlijaRabha]

Oh nice explanation sir from india

[@MurtazaThekhan2]

Make a review on the Biography (My life and struggle) of Bacha Khan Baba.

[@AnonYmous_Icon]

sab say pehlay ap nay kabrana nahi ha , my captain ur content is really cool

[@AbdulMoiz-or8mz]

Bookbuddy please do a podcast with engineer mohammad ali mirza. Eagerly waiting for it. You two are assets in Pakistan.

[@sahabsingh8087]

Love from Indian🎉🎉

[@SimanchalSahu-i7o]

Truly amazing content ! Love from India !

[@noorimran2179]

Well explained ❤

[@tfpohistory]

Hey Book Buddy! You haven't replied to my comment on your post, The comment is: Hey Book Buddy! I just wanted to say that I really enjoy your informative videos and the effort you put into sharing your knowledge with your audience. However, I have to be honest with you - I personally don't like it when you upload personal life pics on this channel. As an informative channel, I'm looking for content that's focused on life changing Philosophy and historical events, and while it's nice to get a glimpse into your personal life, it's not what I'm here for. If you're interested in sharing more personal moments, maybe consider creating a separate vlogging channel? That way, fans like me, can still follow your personal journey without it feeling out of place on your main channel. Thanks for understanding, and keep up the great work on your informative content!"

[@ubaidullah1072]

Sir huge respect💖....... just ye kehna tha ky it wont take more than a line to say ky ye topics Religion vs Athiesm nhi hein............... blky real Islam ya even dosry Ibrahmic religions ya Hindusism mein bhi Rational thinking ky sath log soch skty hein............... ye topics to traditonal blind followers ko provoke krny ky lye hein chahye onka taluq kisi bhi community sy hi kyon na ho....... after all sab humans hein........

[@bravojl]

agar log dossery religion main rational sochain gaey tu phir woh kissi false religion par Qaim hi nahe reh saktaey, agar kissi religion main rationality hi na hoo tu phir woh true na hua , Rational ka matlaab scientific nahi hai yeh baat bhi clear hooni chayeh , because cannot anser everything

[@ubaidullah1072]

@@bravojl lagta hai ap ny Sharukh sir ki religions introduce krny wali videos nhi dekhi..... Rational thinking kr ky ap apni society ki falsies ko khatam krny ky bary mein sochty ho..... Ap ye check krty ho ky wo religion ki waja sy hein ya logon ki lack of knowledge ki waja sy hein..... Ap onka hal dhont tay ho..... Rational thinker ko aghr apny believes par proud hony lag jay or wo apny ap ko superior smjhy to wo rational thinker nhi hota .... aghr apka religion achy kam promote kr raha hai to apko os ky khilaf khary hony ki zrorat nhi ha.... Context is important for critical thinkers....

[@umairrana6491]

Precisely said!

[@HarshVardhan-ec6jg]

Salute to you beta ,Pakistan me reh Kar aisa bolna , I think you are great 👍

[@shadabakhtar7442]

Bhai, please explain philosophy of ( khudi )

[@rashidfani3874]

@@@ Grand Majestic Veil @@@ All that exists in this world, has just a fleeting tale, From mist it comes, to mist it sails, behind a grand majestic veil. Where does this path begin? Where does it truly end? No traveler yet who walks this road can fully comprehend. It seems as though life unfolds in a blink of a fleeting eye, And within that fleeting moment, every joy may lie. Who knows what turn awaits us, what fate the next bend holds, For each twist in this journey, a hidden cause unfolds. Life is a test of transient time, where choices shape our fate, With faith and humble focus, we must evaluate. For deeds done with pure intent, and talents wisely used, Shall carve the worth with which we’re finally introduced. --- RA Fani

[@Fun-Free912]

Sir behtreen ❤🎉

[@exmuslimluckysabir3251]

یہ ویڈیو بہت ہی اچھا بنا، اُمید ہے کہ اس طرح کی ویڈیو اور بھی دیکھنے ملےگا۔ بہت بہت شکریہ 😊

[@infpvlog8]

itni sare new new term ayege toh insian confuse hei hoga Yeh sabhi term generate huvi ha taqdeer sei Log aksar ise galat samajta ha insian apki qismat badal saqta ha apni habits aur neki kam karke maa baap ki khidmat karke dua is the weapon Which help me in real life ❤️ Har chez uske control ma ha aksar jinko childhood truama hota ha woh kafi kind heart hota ha samajhna wala hotai ha ALLAH kise na kise zariye sei insian koh Badalna ka moka deta hai Fer insian ki choice ha Aj apka man kiye tha coffee pina ka jab apna coffee koh kal khareeda tha Chahat free hai insian azad ha Islam kehta ha Woh apni chahat ma qaid ha Allah huma rasta dekhata ha samajna wala chalta hai Marne waqt sabko yaqeen hoga Allah kalam

[@adab-e-ishq7642]

This is kind of videos I wish social media is full of

[@hameedhussain4614]

Surah Al-An'am, Ayah 59:** _“And with Him are the keys of the unseen; none knows them except Him. And He knows what is on the land and in the sea. Not a leaf falls but that He knows it. And no grain is there within the darknesses of the earth and no moist or dry [thing] but that it is [written] in a clear record.”_ (6:59)

[@GentlemansWatches]

Hum aksar Sigmund Freud ka zikar karte hain Jo normally humari zindigi main Kafi kirdar hai. Aap Kisi din Alfred Adler (Adlerian Psychology) par bhi baat karein.

[@meeshalarshad8240]

Amazing ❤

[@MohsinKhan-w7e]

Great work bro

[@mhlectures875]

Shah Rukh Sir please make any video about that your degree does matter? I've been facing this conundrum, I'm not satisfied with the education system of Pakistan, Currently I'm doing Bs Physics from UE and due to lack of rationality and critical thinking its not good, I've been teaching physics since 3 years and wanna start my teaching business in a remarkable way, I'm your biggest fan please any comments?❤

[@murtazakhanshah3740]

Sir, can you elaborate the "Critique of pure reason " Of Immanuel Kant.

[@MonosijMitra]

I believe in hard determinism

[@KalimKhan-jb1os]

Sir aap ne book urdu ma q nhi likhi? Jabke KZbin channel pe aap urdu ma baat krte ha aur Pakistan ma ziada log English nhi jante

[@joydebmondal5522]

Good research from india❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Dany22771]

My dream Podcast will be : javed ahmed ghamdi and bookbuddy

[@akhtarnizami8666]

Really a good v log. Thanks dear. I wait for your gupshup 😂. I also believe in freewill . Moreover please tell me where can I get your book READISTAN , in Pakistan. I love in Lahore.

[@ashirdar4905]

اللہ نے ہر چیز کی ایک تقدیر بنا دی ہے جیسے قدرتی اشیاجیسے درخت کی مثال لیتے ہے اس میں اللہ نے اس کی تقدر میں پھل دینا اس کی لکڑی کو استعمال کرنا مطب محتلف فائدے رکھ دینے ہے اب فری ویل یہ ہے ہم اس درخت کی لکڑی استعمال کریں یہ پھل یا کچھ بھی کریں یا پھر لکڑی کے ڈنڈے سے کسی کو پیٹ دیں ہم لوگ فری ویل کا مطلب ہی بدل دیتے ہے فری ویل اور تقدیر کو ایک ہی پیمانے سے نہیں ناپ سکتے

[@LAPDking]

Sir is world main rahnay ka fayda kiya hay What is benifit of this living in world

[@MonosijMitra]

I do believe in theoretical deterministic. God exist in omnienergy energy being determine every event by its flow of energy

[@Farida-w4k]

To understand Taqdiyr first look at the root word which I think is qdr then find out meaning of qdr and then see how humans are using qdr to make AI work

[@KartikeySahani-s7o]

Hello book buddy I am from India ❤❤

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Welcome Kartikey

[@Gilgitpost]

😊 You can read a small book Al Tawhid of sheikh Saduq to understand about Taqdir and God

[@akhtarnizami8666]

Really a good v log. Thanks dear. I wait for your gupshup 😂. I also believe in freewill . Moreover please tell me from where can I get your book READISTAN. I live in Lahore. Pakistan

[@MonosijMitra]

I believe our life energy deterministic our brain instructions

[@wahidabbasi9751]

Great analysis 👍

[@chiltantravel6886]

Allah ka shukar hai koi Pakistani bhi quality videos banata hai. Humain Book Buddy jese or bhi bohot se samajhdar logon ki zaroorat hai.

[@JarwarEdits-m2b]

Bro please make a video on law of attraction

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

Excellent video Sir! We need people like you 👏👏👏

[@NomanAli-ex6vf]

Great lecture ❤

[@E.QFlicks-zl8sl]

Best❤❤❤❤

[@zahidhassan348]

Great ❤

[@kidskat191]

Please sir give us reference of the books as well,so we could read the books as well for deeper insight

[@confirmjannati]

Why didn't you gave the refrence of the Book "Free Will" by Sam Harris?

[@SamiQadir-g8s]

Sir aap Nasir Iftikhar ke saath aik video karen please es topic pe

[@SamJee-wx9mz]

With respect i am saying that, Whatever terminology you explained kindly provide source . For example who started economic determinism terminology, why he started, what was his environment. Philosophy depends upon Many factors, for example some people balsed twin tower 🗼🗼 it was right according to their philosophy because they grew in such environment etc etc. So i believe you can improve

[@ShahjadShaikh-cz5eo]

Aapki har malumat acchi huti hai ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉