What is the difference between a vessel underway and making way??

[@jemimahmaiyeni]

Very well explained in simple terms. Thank you

[@eliakamel7805]

Anyhow you are doing so well and Continue what you do on KZbin cause it’s benefits for all seafarers around the world thank you so much♥️

[@raymondallenjhangiani7670]

Awesome 👍 explanation ! You have made it so simple and clear for fresher's to understand the meaning of these two Tricky and Sensitive terminologies in marine navigation ? Thank you so much ! I appreciate this video alot ! kindly continue to promote more informative videos to enhance knowledge and benefit for new joiners in the merchant Navy ?? God bless you always 😇🙏

[@sanjeevverma6348]

Thank you sir, I watch a lot of your videos on KZbin. Helps me a lot in teaching gp ratings.

[@discountcuppon]

Hi friends For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@antonioleone6123]

Very clear and easy to understand, Thx.

[@pinetimoteo9070]

Thank u captain this is very helpful as this to clear out the ongoing doubts especially to Mariners

[@nkadiirr]

often these concepts gets slipped from the mind. You explained it in a simple manner to remember both for exam and also onboard

[@mohammedahshan0855]

Thank you sir for this best explanation and your kind works for us

[@discountcuppon]

Hi friends For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@gauravkumarrai2942]

Brilliant explain sir .....

[@discountcuppon]

Good morning For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@cherelle-louiseking793]

Resultant speed. Perfect 👌😇

[@VritikasanDensgeete]

Thank You

[@dhanasekar847]

nice Explanation sir very helpful

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@PrinceKumar-ku9jg]

Thank u sir for clearing the differnce bw underway n making way

[@SteeringMariners]

:) you are welcome but how are you watching my videos meant exclusively for paid members? haha...no worries

[@maharshiraj4660]

Good day sir, When vessel is stoped and drifting and having current of say 3 knots, in this case will vessel will be consider making way???.

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@despicablesailor2445]

thankyou sir its little tricky but i understand

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@adeshmahato9445]

Thank u sir ...for clearing a huge doubt.😍

[@discountcuppon]

Hi friends For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@HUMMUD3]

Making way meaning there is speed overwater , thank you

[@sauravkumar-jb1le]

Thnk u sir...videos really helped me a lot

[@discountcuppon]

Jai hind For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@gautamverma3484]

Nice explanation sir

[@discountcuppon]

Hi friends For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@pratikmohanta3128]

nice video sir, rule no 3😂,tysm sir also sir the example you gave here made crystal clear this concept

[@discountcuppon]

Good morning For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@Joshua-qr8zk]

Thanks for the explanation sir 👍😄

[@SteeringMariners]

Always welcome:)

[@discountcuppon]

Good morning For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@ghostwokeup]

very helpful video

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@minakshikumar4532]

May i request you to make a similar video on difference between tide and tidal streams. Most often asked question in orals and always the surveyors mess the candidates up and literally we go blank with the cross questions.

[@discountcuppon]

Hi friends For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@capt.ajaykumar3953]

I differ little with your explanation of resultant speed through water, if there is speed through water but speed over ground is zero, it is making way. e.g - STW-3 knots, Current - 3 knots against, SOG = 0 but it will be considered making way

[@vivekchauhan888]

if there is a speed through water, it should be making way through water... SOG doesn't count here.

[@capt.ajaykumar3953]

@@vivekchauhan888 Yes, that's correct but the vessel should be underway also. eg. if vessel is at anchor and have 2 knots speed through water, it cannot be a case of making way

[@discountcuppon]

Jai hind For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@kildersanchez4088]

My friend. It's very clear. We're or he's talking about two important terms, one of them is Making way THROUGH THE WATER. So the video is clear and correct.

[@AkashSharma-js5rq]

I also wanted to say the samething

[@Saarathi777]

sir, in ror cards making way is mentioned only for fishing vessel, NUC and RAM. and what is .....underway using engine.?

[@discountcuppon]

Good morning friend For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@yucelbegel18]

Hi power driving vessel at nite under way and making way which light should be on thanks

[@mammypocopant]

Case 1: STW = 0 and SOG =1 Case 2: STW = 1 and SOG = 0 Pls explain what is going on in both the cases.

[@tusharcolz9803]

First case- making way Second - underway Second case is subject to rule 3

[@yugeshh]

@@tusharcolz9803 you're right. The second example is exactly like explained in video when going against current. A speed of 3 knots against current of 3 knots will give: STW = more than 0 SOG = 0

[@discountcuppon]

Good morning For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@shipyXpresss]

Sir, what will be Underway probably making way means ? Plz reply

[@CptDangernoodle]

I thought STW is unaffected by current, and SOG is the one that takes it into account. So in your first example, ship speed 3kts with 3kts current against it --> STW is actually 3kts and SOG is zero. So I'd imagine the determining factor for Making Way is SOG not STW. But I'm just a cadet, I might understand this wrong.

[@dimaz3]

It is always against STW to check if a ship is making way. Making way means a ship is cutting the water , it doesn't necessarily has to move in relation to the ground. If a ship is going forward 3kt and counter current of 3kt is acting then it's still cutting the water , will respond to helm and show STW so it's making way through water even though it's NOT making way over ground.

[@charleslyster1681]

@@dimaz3but this is the opposite of what he says in the video. He contradicts himself; first he says the vessel is making way if it is moving through the water but then in the river example he says if SOG is zero it is not making way even though it is making 3kts through the water.

[@dimaz3]

@@charleslyster1681 Damn..coming back to a 3 year old comment haha. Anyway I have had a lot of discussion about this with plenty people , plenty captains and you know there is no exact definition of this in ROR , which leaves confusion for interpretation. I will just paste what I try to interpret as from a book I followed and felt correct : The best interpretation of this term 'making way' would mean a physical movement of the vessel through water, or the vessel must have some relative speed through the water because of the use of her own propulsion, or having stopped the propulsion, then because of her own momentum, but not any movement through the water caused due to wind or movement over ground due to wind and/or current. In short , I disagree with his first statement as the ship is using her own propulsion and still have a stw.

[@vitaminsea786]

When a vessel is at anchor, What will we say it making way or underway?

[@TheMachineAnthem]

My mate master oral been asking these type of question literally.. i mean..

[@surajdayal5837]

Dear sir does this explanation of making way applies to lights for fishing vsl,NUC,RAM vsl also. Because in rules light for these vsl...they have given... Vsl making way to exhibite side and stern light....plz clarify

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@dennydavis7671]

Thank you sir,I have a one doubt regarding this video all underway are. Making way but all making way are not underway is it correct please clarify me?

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@rahulpradeep2508]

Thank you sir

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@ranavikassingh3304]

Sir, Can u plz answer to my question ?? Sorry sir but I'm little bit confused here, you said, a ship is to be known "making way" if it is registering 'STW' but in your second example, u said that if ship's engine is stopped and ship still moves due to external factors is known to be "making way". My doubt is, if ship's engine is stopped then how it could register "STW"?? It would be "SOG" in my opinion!! Plz correct sir if I'm wrong.

[@tusharcolz9803]

Stw is in relation to water means a ship at anchor with current will register stw=current and sog=0. Basically sog is the factor which determines whether ship is making way or underway.

[@krishserai6252]

If the ships engine is off we r not putting any further command on vessel so it is vessel making way

[@discountcuppon]

Good morning friend For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@vishaltandel7336]

Sir, when vessel is registering some speed die to current and engine speed is zero. So is it making way or underway?

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@shankarbhandari9315]

Sir it is also known as Inertia stop right???

[@SteeringMariners]

Yes, moving under momentum and coming to a gradual stop:)

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@shubhbadola4604]

Hi sir..can u plz explain...for mine clearance vsl...why is it underway..?

[@shubhbadola4604]

It comes in RAM vsl

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@geraldgould7791]

Great job, thanks

[@VatsalKachhawa]

what will we consider if a vessel is drifting ?

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@mrthamizh6942]

What is difference between give - way vessel and stand- on vessel

[@ranavikassingh3304]

Sorry sir but I'm little bit confused here, you said, a ship is to be known "making way" if it is registering 'STW' but in your second example, u said that if ship's engine is stopped and ship still moves due to external factors is known to be "making way". My doubt is, if ship's engine is stopped then how it could register "STW"?? It would be "SOG" in my opinion!! Plz correct sir if I'm wrong.

[@SatishYadav-ks2tl]

Ranavikas..2 criteria define the vessel making way or not...1 ) Is the ship cutting through the water 2 ) can the vessels rudder be used effectively...both these criteria have to be fulfilled for a vessel to be making way through water...and yes sir somehow got the 2nd explaination confused..even though the speed over ground is zero,yet the vessel is making way through the water cos it fulfills both the criteria above...hope it helps u..btw Sirs other vdos are really amazing and we'll elaborated .

[@rachitmathur3246]

Good video

[@mdanasshaikh3150]

Means sir we can say under way and making way is same but only define in another words

[@sahansanka4856]

Sir you explain very clearly thank you I have one question "when we transit in TSS our engine all ready stand by so we need or not to give 30 min notice or 1 hr notice to engine room

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@kidsgang1428]

U need to

[@paramsingh9169]

Bravo👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@roycefernando177]

👌🏻

[@someonesomething8997]

Sir put question 7 of capt errol fernandes cargo handling book Plzz sir

[@discountcuppon]

Good morning friend For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@discountcuppon]

All CARGO WORK NUMERCAL SOLUTION videos come in #kundanpatna

[@someonesomething8997]

@@discountcuppon Thanks 😇😇

[@discountcuppon]

@@someonesomething8997 welcome bro

[@vipinchahar6462]

Hello sir . Can you give me placement because I have three sailing experience

[@GHTOONGHTOON]

Greatttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt..... (Y)

[@sumitmohanty6246]

Thank you Sir

[@SteeringMariners]

Most welcome:)

[@discountcuppon]

For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@roycefernando177]

👌🏻

[@discountcuppon]

Good morning friend For preparation of second mate / DNS/ BSC nautical science/NCV come in #kundanpatna

[@kaylynsmall3222]

Thank you Sir

[@SteeringMariners]

You are most welcome buddy, and thank you for your kind membership:)