What Makes This Song Great? "The Sound of Silence" SIMON & GARFUNKEL

[@DoctorJohnSmith9]

I agree with other comments about missing Rick on screen, walking us through the songs. One of the main ways I learn is to watch him, and how he moves his hands and such to emphasize where key parts of songs are. Mr Beato, come back, please!

[@LipIglesias]

I couldn't agree more

[@jacobweber5743]

I like where he is going tho , he should basically just ramp up his normal content with a bit of this^^^

[@severoon]

Feels over produced. Not crazy about the docu-style voiceover, the conversational tone of talking directly to us is lost. This feels less about the music and more about the form.

[@RickBeato]

You know, I think most people missed the point of the video. Nobody mentioned that I was cutting between multiple versions of the song from different live performances. Not one comment. It's all about the visuals for people. Totally missed it. Over produced? Haha! I guess my production style has such a low bar :)

[@MICKEYISLOWD]

Copy that:)

[@nielsbie8922]

Absolutely one of the most beautiful songs ever written

[@george474747]

A very strong contender for the greatest song in the history of popular music.

[@Rift45]

It would be #1 for me!!

[@bobbradley3866]

I believe in the fullness of time people will realise that this is the greatest song ever written.

[@rogerwilliamson7161]

Yes!

[@3John-Bishop]

@@bobbradley3866 what about Bridge Over Troubled Waters?

[@CentaurYogi]

I miss seeing some beato in the video analysis! Love seeing your enthusiasm.

[@bryede]

Yeah, the visual improvements are interesting, but the video comes out too sterile.

[@Vearus08]

I agree. I reckon this style would work well with him in the corner and possible cuts to him showing techniques and playing

[@Marius-vw9hp]

I agree. I like it, but it would be nice to add him showing on the instruments.

[@aymericmarchand3472]

ultimately we're following these because of you Rick, your passion here doesn't show! Superb analysis otherwise!

[@ggeter]

Agree -- the appeal of these videos is seeing Rick talk extemporaneously. Consider adding the graphics to the side to emphasize a point.

[@Waldemar_la_Tendresse]

If "people" weren't able to communicate back then, since the advent of the internet it hasn't just become more visible, but unfortunately hasn't gotten any better either. Absolutely awesome song! The harmonies in the vocals definitely help, but so does the simplicity, which goes very well with the meaning of the lyrics.

[@EasyZee69]

Back in high school, in the 80's, my music teacher was Father Galadza. He was a genuine hippy from the 60's. He had the class singing all the old hippy songs, this song was one of them. Half the class would sing Simon's part, and the other half would sing Garunkel's. Those harmonies are forever stuck in brain.

[@pwk22]

They still remain?

[@folkmusic99]

@@pwk22 Within the sounds of silence?

[@clarenceferguson3287]

Very awesome pictorial evoking nostalgic memory!

[@truthstillmatters59]

I feel so blessed to have seen and heard Simon & Garfunkel play together when they last had a reunion in 2003.. They stopped in the middle of the show and told us they had surprise guests. The Everly Brothers came out and played Wake Up Little Suzie, All I Have to do is Dream and Let it Be Me. Then Simon and Garfunkel joined them and the four did Bye, Bye Love before Simon and Garfunkel finished their set. It was freakin' amazing. It was like being in the presence of angels singing. So pure and beautiful.

[@markvolstad9380]

The DVD of that concert (Old Friends - Live on Stage) is fantastic!

[@eddiekwok2079]

You are so lucky! They both visited Hong Kong separately and gave concerts. Of course I attended both in 1992 and 2018. They both sang this song, Paul Simon sang it at the encore part.

[@mosart7025]

Jealous!

[@michaelsparks8632]

Wow, Lucky!

[@charlieread]

My younger brother saw this concert in Columbus, Ohio ... I was quite jealous! I love both S & G and the Everlys!

[@patrickjaroch5084]

Yo dude you HAVE hands Down IMO the Best Music channel on KZbin. I have learned so much from just listening to you break down songs this way . This Song was one of the first pieces of music i ever heard as a child. Personally I like seeing you sitting at your computer or with a guitar on your lap while you explain things.

[@RickBeato]

Thanks Patrick!

[@Earthneedsado-over177]

Watching his recent contributions show how much he has refined his presentations in just a few short years. From good to outstanding. He makes something that sounds boring like “music appreciation” into a masterclass led by a charismatic professor who loves his subject.

[@Johnoftheshire]

This song came out when I was 15 in 1965. There was so much great music coming out back then that I think we took it for granted that this was the way it was and would always be. I feel so fortunate and grateful that there were so many true artists back then to enjoy. It was amazing. Thank goodness for KZbin!

[@rodnorris9532]

It sucks to be old, but I am so happy to have grown up with music like this all around me🥰

[@cindyinnew]

I’m 61 and totally agree

[@xiconp1993]

One of the most touching, beautiful songs ever composed. I cry everytime I listen to it.

[@cindymichel4870]

Something in their music always touches deep in my soul. Particularly this song and Scarborough Fair/Canticle. I think they were the first group where I started listening to individual parts and harmonies back when I was a teenager.

[@Chinaguitarsceptic]

One of my favorites - simply an awesome piece of writing

[@Norre83]

Always loved this song especially live just with Paul, his guitar and his great voice... Beautiful

[@G65gear]

I really applaud Rick on this video! It was not a really fancy production, but the message is so powerful...that’s what was highlighted by Rick! Sophisticated harmonies, dissonances, and a poem with a powerful message. a really great song, and Rick got it right in the money. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@guywoznicki7847]

I would put this song in my top 20 greatest rock songs ever! The guitars and harmonies have an other-worldly feel that puts you in an incredible mood! Thank you for explaining the science behind this. Pure genius!

[@LeevitDeBeeva]

So glad you did this song. One of my all time favorites. Paul Simon is one of the most underrated guitarists, as are many great folk guitarists

[@johncook7281]

With that picking pattern of his, I don't know any musicians who underrate Paul Simon on guitar. And he's one of my favorite lyricists.

[@RichSad45]

Love, love, love this song. My dad was a huge Simon and Garfunkel fan. I grew up with their albums being bought and played as they came out. This episode of "What Makes This Song Great" was short, direct and filled with delicious tracks from an outstanding, timeless song.

[@smarsville]

I'm a non-musician. It's easy to think it's just spontaneous playing and singing. Not in the least, as when I saw them solo an how different it was. Thanks for showing the how this all occurs. I have an appreciation of the many levers needed to get what I finally hear.

[@petergreen2552]

It's a truly great song because you can hear the soul in it. Timeless,bleak, beautiful and stark. A Simon classic sang with passion and heart.

[@AaronBandt]

"Hello darkness my old friend" Possibly the greatest first line of a song of all time. Prove me wrong.

[@meanrambler2295]

I don't wanna stay at your party 😥😭

[@jamesparson]

Aaron Bandt “You’ve got mud on your face, you big disgrace”

[@kayelle8005]

I love this song so much. Probably my favourite version is the one from the Live at Central Park concert. What I wouldn’t have given to be at that concert.

[@valentinvincent9554]

There must be some way out of here bob dylan

[@MrHonification]

Tom Petty said "Oh baby, don't it feel like heaven right now?"

[@CWA61]

I’ve been studying and listening to music intensely for over 45 years and yet this was the most musically informative 5 minutes I’ve ever experienced.

[@JohnBarrow1961]

Art Garfunkel had the voice of an angel.

[@douglasskaalrud6865]

Check out Garfunkel’s album, “Breakaway.” It’s awesome. “99 miles from L.A.” is the best song he’s ever done.

[@zevbleuler6998]

I Only Have Eyes For You was also spectacular on Breakaway.

[@janharris1085]

Art Garfunkel did several great solo albums in the 70's into the 80's. Several of his songs from that era can still bring a tear to my eye!

[@ze_rubenator]

I was 21 years when I wrote this song I'm 22 now, but I won't be for long Time hurries on And the leaves that are green turn to brown

[@9UaYXxB]

Your comment will elude 99% of those who read it, but it sure has me (and I'm certain others) smiling. Thank you.

[@colinslant]

People ask me when will I grow up to be a man, but all the girls I loved at school are already pushing prams...

[@Keyspoet27]

Love that song as well. Paul Simon writes some of the most nuanced and beautiful lyrics out there.

[@bobriedinger5287]

@@Keyspoet27 I hope fans of Paul Simon who may have lost touch with his later releases come around to "So Beautiful Or So What" -- what you noted about the lyrics may also be said of the music, in particular "Dazzling Blue," "Love and Hard Times," "Questions For the Angels," and "Amulet."

[@BUSHCRAPPING]

@@colinslant i dont want to change the world, im not looking for a new england,

[@Tbass323]

I was just a kid when I heard this song and it totally knocked me out! It's still one of my favourites to this day. This video could easily been fifteen minutes long and you'd still get my full attention.

[@zekesterboospirit8658]

One of my all time favorite songs in any genre.

[@RSPDiver]

Amazed you kept this to under 6 minutes, but still very thorough. Well done!

[@diegoramonfuentes5584]

It didn't seem very thorough at all to me. Miss the old format.

[@RickBeato]

Diego, for real? Do you want me to come over and teach you the guitar part too? :)

[@diegoramonfuentes5584]

That would be awesome Rick :)

[@Andrea-xs4ny]

RSPDiver - Agreed! Succint and no fluff. On point from beginning to end. Thank you for analyzing - and teaching me about - one of my favorite songs and part of the soundtrack of my childhood.

[@kennyt1963]

Rick, I think your coverage of this song of this song is spot on. There is not much to say or analyze. This song is simple, melodic, and deep. So deep that it gets into your bones and takes up residence.

[@eddieavakian]

The lyrics were also what made this song great. It’s ironic that the lyrics are more applicable today than they were back then. Great Video Rick. 🤙

[@cariwaldick4898]

The lyrics are perfect. I also love the Disturbed version, which seems to add more urgency for today, but the same lyrics.

[@eddarby469]

I would go further and say the song is also about political correctness trying to silence us.

[@alancumming6407]

@@cariwaldick4898 Well, it's certainly very shouty.

[@samlynes7015]

Rick, these 'What Makes This Song Great' videos just keep getting better and better. I learn so much from them. Thank you.

[@ignacioruiz5824]

Glad it's back up. The music industry is shooting itself in the foot with the blocking and copyright strikes on videos that actually promote their music while being demonetized... It's crazy how blind and obtuse some musicians and publishing execs can be... Keep them coming, Rick. Hopefully, one day you'll be able to do a Zeppelin song without risking your channel being taken down.

[@BarrySmithviolin]

“I Am a Rock” PLEASE... Phenomenal mood, lyrics, dynamics, structure, musicianship and recording. My favorite of all of Simon’s compositions.. 🌹🖤🌹🖤🌹🖤🌹

[@Mmmyess]

I enjoy the longer, more free-flowing WMTSG format, but I often don't have much time to sit and watch long videos. So I appreciate the brevity and succinctness of this format. Cheers!

[@pinkfloydicus]

Please don't change the format to this! I can't speak for others but part of the reason I like this channel is because I like seeing you!

[@tvs3497]

And in 1,000 years from now, it'll still be a great song. I just hope wherever I am I can listen to it occasionally.

[@MelTuly]

Thank you for this . A beautiful haunting song . Almost like a lullaby . The presentation of this is amazing. It is a not just a breakdown of the song . It is like a documentary biography of the song . Extremely well done . Very very grateful. Thank you .

[@stumblebiscuit99]

I was 14 when this came out. I had a job making $3 a night and I worked about 3 nights a week. At this time I owned a Beatles and Stones LP. With the small money I made, the Simon and Garfunkle LP (mainly influenced by the airplay of this song made me have to have this LP. Now after seeing this video, I'm going to buy it again. Love the channel!

[@pauldavies1710]

I hear all you say about bass, drums, bluesy guitar and electric guitar but this was a great, great song with just the two of them. Genius at work.

[@ruebensfilms]

Love Paul's lyrics. From: hello darkness my old friend to: hello lamppost whatcha knowing.

[@yrmthr]

One of the most beautifully crafted pop songs of the 20th century. A simple, haunting and emotive piece.

[@emmicllns]

paul simon at 21: writes the sound of silence me at 21: can make an amazing lasagna

[@harrynac6017]

Nothing wrong with making an amazing lasagna :)

[@lukehunnable]

Lasagna is more useful

[@janharris1085]

Nurture your gifts, whatever they may be. It would be a dreary world without good music or good food!

[@mtc5]

@@lukehunnable I'm sure Paul Simon found more use in writing Sound of Silence in the past 50 something years, then all the lasagnas he could have made and eaten during the same time.

[@jormayorccis1028]

Never underestimate the power of lasagna.

[@francisconarvaez6029]

nah man. You see, the best thing about your videos is just how enjoyable is to see your passion for music and composition, even for people like us that maybe do not understand about it. We want to see YOU.

[@NahreSol]

I learned a lot from this video!! The flow of the video matched the song, and made me really feel 2:39. I also loved seeing footage of the band! 🙏

[@samsonandre1486]

a tip: watch movies at InstaFlixxer. Me and my gf have been using it for watching lots of of movies during the lockdown.

[@quinnjorge8820]

@Samson Andre Yea, have been watching on instaflixxer for years myself =)

[@muhammadvictor9539]

@Samson Andre Yup, I have been watching on instaflixxer for months myself :)

[@QuinnTeal]

I don’t know why people don’t like this format. This format was obviously more work to do this way. I just wanted to say thanks for all the hard work you put into this.

[@brian2174]

I'm in the middle...I like the new format but with a little more cowbeato! You are part of the reason I tune in...not just the song. Great job!!

[@debmurray2734]

Giggling ... Cowbeato ... Giggling😆

[@kenlee5015]

Don't know if you revisit your old vids or comments, but seeing this again, many months later, I'm still very impressed with this style of video. So many versions to choose from, I love how you weave different cuts together. Thanks, teach.

[@jaymo83]

Mr. Beato, I really like the new format you chose for the WMTSG series. I personally would listen regardless, but I think this current format is great to capture new ears. Cheers from New Brunswick Canada

[@debmurray2734]

This song reminds me of my 4th grade teacher Miss Sharkey, who turned me onto Simon and Garfunkel one late late spring day, when our class was overly excited and loud with the impending summer break. Recognizing the need for a calming influence, she turned off the harsh lights and put the album on. Ever the consciencious teacher, she broke down the lyrics and imagery for us as a young literature/poetry lesson. She explained the structure of the song in a way I hadn't heard before. I was transfixed by the experience and became a forever fan of Paul and Art. More importantly, I never listened to any music the same way again ... since that experience, I always break down music in my head and in my playing ... the instruments, background, production style, leads and melodies, and of course the words, structure ... Everything I can hear. Full circle, here I am some 45 years later, breaking this same song down again (and so many others) this time with Rick Beato at the helm. Thank you, Rick, for spending your time sharing your expertise with all of us, for simply loving the music the same way I love it and for just being you!

[@MsAussie83]

+Rick Beato "The Sounds Of Silence" was originally released in 1964, on an album titled "Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M.", and was just Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel's voices, their acoustic guitars, and an acoustic bass. Art's voice can be heard on the left side, while Paul's voice is on the right side.

[@phillipcarr9092]

I agree. Really love it when your at the desk isolating bit and pieces. Love your work Rick.

[@deangoritz9625]

It doesn't matter which format, excellent as always Rick

[@todhamilton5055]

Rick -a huge part of these( for me ) is seeing your expressions and body language. The love of music you convey, please go back to the good old way!

[@procrastinator9]

So glad to find this one after having been taken down. I missed it the first time and the copyright strike kerfuffle drew me to seek it out. Much to my benefit. Thanks, Rick.

[@ruthdillon9663]

Wow just wow, I have an even deeper appreciation for these wonderful artists. Thanks

[@lewsheen7514]

So back in the day in the 70's, there was Yes and there was disco. Yes, with Jon Anderson's ambiguous vocals and harmonically complex music required imaginative participation on the part of the listener. Disco, not so much. From Rick's latest WMTSG video here, I kinda got the same vibe. Instead of a detailed, lengthy lick-by-lick breakdown (which I ALSO love), we get a bare-bones and well-documented comparison between the artists' original musical statement and the end product - which was the result of brilliant production - and yielded an epic musical mega-hit for the ages! Absorbing Rick's lesson here requires intellectual participation on the part of the viewer. The most valuable lessons aren't those that teach memorized rote, rather they're those lessons that require the student to THINK and absorb the deep CONCEPTS! I appreciate both of Rick's WMTSG styles. I find it FASCINATING that the additional production elements, added without the artists knowledge - and apparently to one's distaste - eventually yielded a HUGE #1 hit. Rick - some people don't like change at first. You hear their feedback on here. I want to tell you that I DEEPLY appreciate your broad depth of musical knowledge, and your willingness to present your knowledge in a wide and at times unexpected variety of editorial formats. Don't change a THING, Bro!

[@Lugodu87]

I think many disco songs are really interesting from both a production and harmonic standpoint.

[@RickBeato]

Great comment. The form for this video I changed to show how the song was taken from a simple 2 part folk song to a hit radio song. If this song didn’t happen there would’ve been no Simon & Garfunkel. The decision by Tom Wilson to hire session players to create an arrangement made their career.

[@jamesmackay4529]

you're onto something with the new video format! Lots of comments asking to keep the best bits of the previous format, excited to see the next one blending traditional Rick with the new format! great work as always. thanks!

[@TheGerkuman]

Hey Rick, the original acoustic version of the song was on Wednesday Morning 3AM. The Sounds of Silence version is the rocked up version.

[@DjNikGnashers]

Indeed, and I much prefer the acoustic version.

[@mosart7025]

Was on what? A radio station? Oh you mean that was the title? Was it "On Weds. Morning 3am"? Or "Weds. Morning 3am"?

[@TheGerkuman]

@@mosart7025 on the album 'Wednesday Morning, 3A.M.' The album was named after the final song on it, which got remade as 'Somewhere They Can't Find Me' on their subsequent album 'Sounds of Silence'.

[@lisag18]

@@mosart7025 that's the name.lf song. search KZbin. it's a good one!

[@elgerardoedwardio2498]

Calm down You Tube comments, this isn't Dylan going electric... It's a nice little side video, informative and educated as usual. I for one appreciated this AND the usual videos.

[@johnmoser2689]

I can't believe I have not seen this episode this is such a fantastic piece of music that was ahead of its time Paul and Art were so good together what a shame things went so sideways

[@mikebehrend3152]

Different kind of song, different kind of video. The voice over works and is part of what makes this video great.

[@sinistergrey3]

This format lacks the 'Heart+Soul' of the previous videos, I like to see you get into the songs and watch your face light up as you get excited at the parts you think are really cool/interesting+then play said parts on guitar and piano while explaining the structure in a more 'one on one' style...please go back to the previous format :(

[@MrBoz1968]

These guys said it below, what I like about these videos is you, and your reactions to what you are listening to. And you picking out parts to play along w/.

[@reinpost]

I think it would be ideal to have both. This format is more suitable for introducing more context.

[@davidflint12]

This song touched me the first time I heard it in the early 70s. Still touches me every time I hear it. It’s has its own power. Rick your work also touches me on many different levels. Intelligently, musically, and emotionally. Thank you

[@Sc0tther]

Great style to this one! I really love that the format is divided by topics, and that it includes clips and material from the artists. Since a bunch of folks are saying that they miss your visual presence in the video, I wonder if the two styles could be combined? Your in-person energy and analyzing/demonstrating how to play the song might work really nicely if it's woven between these different kind of cuts.

[@Hmantooth]

Totally agree!

[@ciccaj]

I love that you cover every genre. There's great music everywhere.

[@martinheath5947]

Quite an affront for a producer to add drums bass and electric guitars to an acoustic session, to rework songs without authorization from the artist. Paul Simon loathed the results also on on Bridge Over Troubled Water, hated the production values, the reverbs, the presumption behind the producer's audacity hijacking and meddling with his masterpieces. I do feel however his bank balance and subsequent career provided some mild consolation and compensation for the indignity! Def Leppard apparently hated the sound and mix of Hysteria so vehemently they were on the verge of splitting up - then surprise surprise they had their first breakthrough multi platinum hit and they LOVED it! All hail to the producer with vision

[@philipgior3312]

Even though I agree with much of your post and the sentiment behind it I actually have come to like the result - the twangy guitars, the bass coming in at just the right moment and holding the bottom. Perhaps it would have been better if the producer called Simon back into the studio to rework the song himself along with some session men.

[@Miatacrosser]

Being a fan from their start, I'll just say that the SoS LP version was far better. Folk music was on it's way out with more artists switching to Rock, so that producer created a successful career by doing this. And to the people who think that Paul Simon was stabbed in the back, he didn't have any say so as he didn't own the property(the song)anymore. Columbia did

[@arthurbishop3173]

'Hysteria' is AWFUL...overproduced GARBAGE. 'High and Dry' is where DL blew their load...and then Mutt took over and they lost their nads.

[@greense65]

@@Miatacrosser I like the fuller version more, too. It got me into rock music.

[@davep5647]

apparently ,the over-production on hysteria cost so much that that album had to go 4x platinum just to break even...regardless,it is pure 80s schlock.

[@aMulliganStew]

Some works of art, like this one, are worthy of worship.

[@vgarc7]

Uh , no. I don’t like this format change. I like seeing you talk about the songs

[@ianbrandao8899]

This is more artistic, but i prefer seeing your reaction, rick. But it´s like a pocket video too, also great

[@RickBeato]

You got to switch it up once in a while :)

[@HumanThoughtExpression]

I like the shorter format but I agree, missing out on Rick's excitement/body language etc.

[@trbldrl]

@@RickBeato just please tell me this is a once in a while thing and not a permanent change

[@dcurry7287]

socalsilva You know the good shit's coming up when Rick starts air-drumming.

[@darrellrees4371]

I have heard this song almost all of my life, but only in the last year have I come to really appreciate its beauty and message. It really makes me wonder what else I have been missing all these years.- signed An Old Fart.

[@amirrubinshtein2646]

Beautiful song which is true till this day! Geniuses! thanks for the song breakdown loved it

[@Nikkimaya1]

I have to agree with almost everyone else. Watching your unabashed love and enthusiasm for these songs as you break them down makes these songs even better than they already are. I hope you go back to that way. Please??

[@alex_montoya]

Wow, that's the first of your WMTSG videos that I see and its truly amazing. Great, great job!

[@AndrewLale]

Are you related to Inigo Montoya, by any chance?

[@cindymancini6153]

Every one of his wmtsg videos is truly amazing to me. And your opinion is irrelevant

[@laurabusse1832]

LOVE the slideshow approach! Love seeing the pics and videos germain to the song...

[@gowers1972]

Please do an evaluation of "The Boxer" by Simon and Garfunkel, Rick. The world is waiting for this one.

[@harmoniabalanza]

Now that is one helluva song.

[@Jason-ft6ro]

The combination of there voice's are out of this world!

[@numanuma20]

Rick, I like this new way of production in your videos. Also love the story behind it. Would love to hear the original version before the remix.

[@bfish89ryuhayabusa]

It's freely available, and was on their first album. There's also a great version made between the two releases, on Paul's first solo album, The Paul Simon Songbook.

[@Miatacrosser]

The original version is on their first album titled "Wednesday Morning, 3 am"

[@tomspallone1868]

Your efforts to up the production appearance of your videos have not gone unnoticed. I, for one, appreciate it and like it very much. Keep it up.

[@axlrio]

Please analyze “Baker Street” by Gerry Rafferty.

[@jamesmegill]

Good one🗿

[@Goctagon]

Oooh good choice

[@Darkhalo314]

Yes! Excellent choice! Sexy Sax song!

[@OtherTheDave]

The original or the cover? They’d probably both qualify :-)

[@Red_Lanterns_Rage]

gods I love that song....that sax tho lol

[@kenlee5015]

I know this series i very educational, but I truly appreciate how you took more of a backseat approach to this highly influential song. Well done.

[@ridgerunner4943]

Hey Rick, glad that your video was un-strucken! Keep truckin'!

[@groksr]

I remember the first time I heard it on my older cousins record player. I was awestruck by its incredible harmonies it's Beauty and simplicity

[@cwgochris71]

Why is Frank Zappa seen at 0:57? In 1966, Tom Wilson signed the Mothers of Invention to Verve Records and was credited as producer on the group's seminal debut album Freak Out! although it is widely believed that Frank Zappa, the leader of the group, did most of the real production work. Frank Zappa paid this tribute: "Tom Wilson was a great guy. He had vision, you know? And he really stood by us ... I remember the first thing that we recorded was 'Any Way the Wind Blows,' and that was okay. Then we did 'Who Are the Brain Police?' and I saw him through the glass and he was on the phone immediately to New York going, 'I don't know!' Trying to break it to 'em easy, I guess." "Wilson was sticking his neck out. He laid his job on the line by producing the album." Source: Wikipedia

[@Flash023]

One of my all time favorite songs. Thank you so much. I then researched drummer Bobby Gregg and it turns out he plays on most of my favorite Dylan songs, Like a Rolling Stone, Positivity 4th Street, Desolation Row, and so much more. I thought it was drummer Hal Blaine on Sounds of Silence, but I was incorrect. Thanks!!

[@SKULLFVK3D]

Like the simplistic format.... but I like to learn from you , so please go back to old way

[@brian2174]

I'm in the middle...I like the new format but with a little more cowbeato! You are part of the reason I tune in...not just the song. Great job!!

[@KRAFTWERK2K6]

I too prefer this format here as it is to be honest. It's to the point without any extra load that just makes it slower.

[@alexruiz421]

I agree with the comments written. The heart of the channel is Rick, I connect more if I see him as well.

[@bobthesuper1]

I actually like this new format. Mr. Beato’s expertise in unquestionable, but this feels more professional to me. Maybe he could try a hybrid of some sort.

[@haveamourwilltravel]

Hey Rick! We don't just love your knowledge, we love having you on screen. My partner and I found your channel several months ago, and we've always been so engaged by your personable yet educational style. While there's still a lot of valuable content in this video, this just isn't quite the Rick Beato of which we became fans. Hopefully you can find a happy medium that fulfills you but also keeps your audience satisfied. XOXO

[@halfshark101]

Hey rick, for what its worth, i liked the documentary type feel to this WMTSG. It seemed fitting for the song. I even had to shazam the outro song cause it was catchy! Fantastic upload as always thanks!

[@davidhoxit4274]

The power of Music is the torch you carry Rick....Many thanks sir

[@tonybates7870]

Nice to see Tony Soprano's dad on second guitar there, under the Witness Protection name of Vinnie Bell . . .

[@benmeltzer]

No, the TV show came much later.

[@tonybates7870]

@@benmeltzer Thanks for that. I feel so stupid now.

[@br1an_b]

Holy crap, amazing animations and text in this video!! Your visual presentations are always great and somehow keep getting even better! Thank you for sharing this.

[@ipsurvivor]

Rick, I’m pretty sure that the original song was released on the album ‘Wednesday Morning, 3AM’ but was not released as single until approximately 18 months later... Tom Wilson learned that DJs in Miami and Boston were playing the acoustic album track and Wilson remixed it with a full band and electric guitar/s as you mentioned.

[@MyBohemianDreams]

That is correct. The remixed version appears on their third album "Sounds of Silence". The first album was released in 1964 .

[@robertdiehl1281]

This song...the lyrics and vocals are timeless. Haunting vocal harmonies and guitar work.

[@bimbettocavallo]

Who's here after the "second copyright strike"?

[@RAkers-tu1ey]

yep, had to check it out... recommended by you tube, if you can believe it!

[@coltseavers6298]

Same.

[@tripcopeland3420]

Yep.

[@wobblewarfare4494]

i see...

[@mikeshipway6158]

Yep, one of my favorite S & G song.

[@droxyy]

I love seeing the gear used. .. and the words of the prophets are written on the subway walls..

[@gustavocabral3101]

Hey Rick, please don't change the way you've used to make WMTSG! This episode got so cold without you... It kind of loose funny/life... Just be Rick again! 🤘

[@victorzaror]

Agree!

[@RickBeato]

Don't go changin'... :)

[@wishnewsky]

WOW! Amazing format!!!

[@Jason-bg7jc]

I'm a simple man, I see "rick beato" notifications on my phone and I watch.

[@RickBeato]

There you go Jason!

[@sarajamus]

You & me both, man!

[@thomasmcgill6918]

Rick Beato is the best drug to be addicted to.

[@Miatacrosser]

Talk about taking me back to my roots. Herb Albert and Simon and Garfunkel are what started me on my musical journey in life. Thank you, Rick, for this most unexpected episode.

[@quicktastic]

Personally, I like the way Rick did this with this particular song. A little more subdued, but so is the song and a wonderful song at that.

[@johnsmith-pw7oj]

daaaaaaaamn that is an awesome song, thanks mr.Rick