What next after EWS Quotas? Will reservations ever stop? Bisbo

Visit bit.ly/3WVaFwR or download Cambly to practise English in groups or 1-on-1 with native speakers.
As EWS quota takes reservation to 60%, many state governments are going even beyond this limit.
#ews #ewsquota #reservation
Sources
The Times of India
Should EWS families be exempt from paying income tax? Ajit Ranade; Nov 28, 2022
Chhattisgarh cabinet okays draft bills to hike quota; Nov 25, 2022
States has gone on an overdrive after EWS quota was instituted; Subodh Ghildiyal; Nov 14, 2022
Is EWS quota about another vote bank? Dushyant; Nov 13, 2022
Reservation in large doses causes more problems than it solves; Arghya Sengupta, Raag Yadava; Nov 11, 2022
Private educational institutions welcome SC verdict on EWS reservation; Nov 10, 2022
Does silent endorsement of EWS quota signal end of Mandal politics?; Radhika Ramaseshan; Nov 10, 2022
Explained: What is the 103rd Constitutional amendment upheld by SC?; Nov 7, 2022
Supreme Court order on EWS quota is setback to struggle for social justice: Stalin;
Julie Mariappan; Nov 7, 2022
Supreme Court in 3-2 verdict upholds 10% quota for Economically Weaker Sections; Amit Anand Choudhary; Nov 7, 2022
Why EWS like OBC is about caste, not class; D Shyam Babu; Nov 7, 2022
'Economic status should not dictate reservation'; Puhazh Gandhi P; Nov 3, 2022
A strong case for reservation on economic basis; Dr. Prashant Prabhakar Deshpande; Oct 14, 2022
Indian Express
Supreme Court’s EWS verdict: Why diluting caste-based reservations is a counterproductive move; Prannv Dhawan, Christophe Jaffrelot, Kalaiyarasan A; Nov 18, 2022
Wary of 10% quota, private institutions await clarity on fees; Sourav Roy Barman; Nov 9, 2022
The Caravan Magazine
EWS कोटा कैसे खोखला करता है SC/ST/OBC आरक्षण; Vishnu Sharma; Nov 23, 2022
Supreme Court Observer
The Mandal and Sinho Commissions: A Study in Contrasts; Malavika Parthasarathy; Jan 11, 2022
Does The 50% Limit on Reservations in Indra Sawhney Hold Good?; Mihir R; Mar 31, 2021
The Print
On EWS quota, Modi govt just using Congress’ bad idea and Sinho Commission report; Dilip Mandal; Nov 5, 2021
IndiaSpend
'EWS Reservation Is Very Much A Caste-Based Quota'; Shreehari Paliath; Nov 10, 2022
Deccan Herald
10% EWS quota to be distributed among Vokkaligas, Lingayats; NB Hombal, Dec 29, 2022
The EWS judgement needs to be reviewed; A V S Namboodiri; Nov 24, 2022
The Economic Times
EWS Quota: Why Centre may be forced to make a difficult decision; Nov 14, 2022
Most EWS beneficiaries from families with below Rs 5 lakh income; Anubhuti Vishnoi; Dec 15, 2021
The Quint
UPSC Topper Tina Dabi’s Success is NOT Scripted by ‘Bonus Marks’; Hansa Malhotra; May 28, 2016
India Today
Congress leader files petition challenging EWS reservation verdict in Supreme Court; Srishti Ojha; Nov 23, 2022
Congress to review Supreme Court order on EWS quota: P Chidambaram; Aneesha Mathur; Nov 12, 2022
Parents pay for fake EWS certificates to get kids into school on quota meant for poor; Kumar Vikram; Jan 23, 2014
Hindustan Times
Vokkaligas set Jan 23 deadline for hike in reservation to 12%; Nov 29, 2022
Jharkhand assembly clears bill to increase reservation to 77%; Nov 12, 2022
Scroll
Explainer: Is Modi’s government’s 8 lakh income criteria for EWS too lenient?; Umang Poddar; Jan 8, 2022
Livemint
Govt job hiring in FY21 drops to lowest level in three years; Prashant K. Nanda; May 26, 2021

[@BisboWorld]

Please support our sponsor and visit bit.ly/3WVaFwR or download Cambly to practise English in groups or 1-on-1 with native speakers.

[@mayankbisht7691]

Your research seemed lacking. Babasaheb already told that only way to remove caste is intercaste marriage. A law should be made which protects intercaste/interfaith couples from their families and assures them their children will be taken care of if something happens to them. Only through intercaste marriage, caste can be annihilated

[@Crauniverse]

You should also need to see nd research on rich people from sc and obc also using reservation like happening in ews. Best way to stop this do ews reservation same as obc and sr so they demand to cancelled this. Then everyone gets selected by merits.

[@Prashaantkumaar-os7rh]

using video about quota n ur asking to support language group

[@rahulkrishna9375]

I scored 96 percentile in the CAT exam studying for hours everyday for many months and even then, I didn’t get a call from any of the IIMs and top institutions. Meanwhile my friends who are from SC/ST, OBC and EWS got admitted in top institutes with way low marks and hard work. So as a general category student, what am I supposed to do? All my hard work went in vain because of this reservation system. And now, I’m happily settled in Europe where merit and skills matter and not your caste.

[@onefourth7421]

birth issue

[@shiva53536]

Ppl in sc st also suffered more than u, so all the higher caste ppl should go n settle in foreign countries so that lower caste live here peacefully

[@Crauniverse]

Yes in Europe you get scholarship if you are good in studies not reservation.

[@shiva53536]

@@Crauniverse there also no reservations in churches and organizations like here in india we have four upper castes

[@rahulkrishna9375]

@@shiva53536 Yes I understand that they suffered but those are many years back and why do we still have this reservation and why should I pay for something my ancestors did? We could provide reservation for education to uplift them but why for jobs and even for promotions?

[@anubhavsood6160]

EWS is good for the General category students. In future, remove reservation and introduce EWS quota for all categories.

[@Paaaaaaaaaaal]

EWS is scam. People losing money gambling, liquor will be beneficiaries even they no historical wrong has been done against them.

[@chemicalxuwu]

respectfully disagree

[@BisboWorld]

It's been there for OBCs, Anubhav. It can be looked at for other categories, after adequate research.

[@akashsingh358]

Ews reservation is just a fraud..everybody knows it

[@d2vlogs105]

Your ideology is right but many will disagree because people are too much invested in politics than to understand that its the poor people not people of different communities that need it. People talk about dispersing the of caste system is needed but fail to understand that they themselves are allowing it through sc/st/obc.

[@nuclearbriefcase7259]

Time for general category to leave the country and develop the USA ,and Canada 😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨

[@ShounakKundu]

They are already doing that

[@souvik609]

Yes the general category students atleast who are capable of leaving India should look for opportunities outside . India will never be able to honour merit over reservation. With many states planning to increase reservation, the competition among general candidates will become even more killing

[@BisboWorld]

That's also partly due to overall dearth of good education and employment..

[@vamshiv2109]

Yes 👍🔥✊✊✊

[@NecromancerTO]

This is true and anyone who says that people who go abroad are not patriots are complete idiots

[@chaitanyavelamala7268]

In Tamil nadu, dravidian ideology driven DMK kept pushing upper castes people into OBC so much that the general category is the minority now (Also things like brahmins being driven out by periyars has to be considered for low gen category population). EWS caught them off gaurd as it turns out govt can't take back what they offered when it's reservation. Now DMK can't push BCs to general category to avail EWS. their ideology basically reached it's expiry date

[@siddharth2754]

haha checkmate

[@BisboWorld]

That could be the case, Chaitanya.. But AIADMK took the step of increasing quota to win elections

[@ThakurGovinnSingh]

Haha

[@yuvarajavijiy]

In your dream.. Dravidian ideology will never ever get expire in TN. We guys don't know about Tamilans. DMK government already announced it won't implement EWS Quota in TN. It was implemented only in union government's institutions. 🤣🤗🤣🤗🤣🤗🤣

[@Ezhil-dq8op]

General category is always minority lol. You think Brahmins are majority here ??!!

[@krishnaSagar69]

I remember how my friends with general category topped all exams and yet guys with reservation got placed in IITs so simply, they didn't worked hard at all. Now all those guys who topped the exams have left India to settle abroad and are going extremely good. This has always been the cycle.

[@AP-eb8hd]

@Souven Tudu Ask the President...

[@AP-eb8hd]

All I was saying is IITs come under the purview of President. He/She can then decide really to call of this quota thing.

[@akashsingh358]

He might leave this country because of casteism ..he may do not like how you people exploit the lower caste here..he may do not like how RSS propaganist destroying this country socio economic fabric..that could also be the possibility.

[@kumargupt3426]

@@akashsingh358 RSS Destroying the country 😂😂like Doing sar T@n se juda lol kid you need to watch pogo

[@batman3490]

@Souven Tudu c'mon dude number of dalits is very low in big institutes. big institutes don't even fill full quota allocated to dalits.

[@prabhulpillai6425]

Can't understand why higher educations like Neet pg needs quota... This exam is for those who cleared MBBS. I mean even if some one from ST Sc cleares mbbs... How is he gonna remain poor..... He will earn fine in his life. Hi gher education should always be based on merit.

[@Manhafuture]

Even the worst scenario is that goi has introduced next exam which means u need to pass 2 exams at entrance level to just get a fucking medical degree and thinking that this will produce one of the best doctors wtf here also reservation will be the derved ones , conclusion is that this will eat students age and especially the general one making them handicap for other competitive exam if any one wants to switch the field the same goes for jee exam ,upsc,ssc exams as well still irony is that india is a developing country

[@futuredoctor20055]

Nhi hoga se want equal representative in all exam 😂😂

[@adityarana2897]

I think the reservation was started because the upper caste had the economic winnings against the lower cast. Also the reservations should be restricted only to education sectors and not to jobs because after that both sc/st and general guy got same education and opportunities for learning, so the one with better skills should get job.

[@BisboWorld]

Important point to consider, Aditya

[@adityarana2897]

@souventudu6154 well thats the different debate that the caste exists or not, but one can't deny the fact that the upper caste were little wealthy. Yes, but that doesn't mean that there is no poverty amongst the upper caste. My opinion is that only one generation of lower caste should have been given the reservation because even if one generation is lifted out of poverty, then the coming generation have a high chance of not going back to poverty. So, after 1 generation of reservation for lower caste, the reservation should have been only for people living below the poverty line.

[@Playerone1287]

Nice point

[@pradeepmuniandi]

You can't provide the same or similar kind of education to a boy in Mumbai heart city and a boy in remote villages of Arunachal Pradesh. Mumbai boy can reach his school in 20 mins in a sophisticated school bus and his school might possess all modern day amenities. But the boy in villages of Arunachal Pradesh has to walk several KMs to go to his school which might not even have sufficient and skilled teachers to teach

[@sw_2421]

​@@adityarana2897you upper caste people exploited lower caste people for more than 2000 years.. U were the ones who kept 100% reservation in education I.E you never allowed lower caste people to get education You upper caste people introduced untouchability And then u say only 1 generation of lower caste should get reservation Why u people never talk about this.. And only 22.5 % reservation is there for SC/ST..combined

[@Kushagra.j]

I am a Jain by birth. Statistically apart from the Parsis we are the most successful community in India in almost all measures of Human and Sociological development. We are a true minority aswell unlike the Peaceful community. We consider ourselves and our way of living as similar to Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists yet we are fewer in quantity than any of those. If we are going to provide a reservation to everybody and anybody then why not for us aswell? I am 110% against reservation it should be on Merit. But since Govt and other political bodies want marginalized sections to get excessive support and opportunity then why not for others aswell? Your actions are anyway destroying the Upper Caste of Hindus especially Males!

[@BisboWorld]

I do think that poor amongst Jains will also be eligible in EWS quota

[@akshat4311]

Bro according to 2011 census we paid 23% of the income tax

[@sambs3609]

Do you guys truly pay Taxes?? Ask yourself first.....most of your businesses still run on Cash and avoid Cashless or Bank Transactions. And stop playing victim card and comparing yourself with other minorities.....you squeeze poor and suck their blood...Pawn Brokers!!!!

[@akshat4311]

@@sambs3609 but still accounts for 23% of income Tax. Have a peaceful protest, you're just jealous of us.

[@NecromancerTO]

@@akshat4311 not every Jain is rich, many are actually BPL

[@deltasquad5313]

Next we need to make reservations for general class

[@sairam-uo6pq]

Already in it

[@annimishra9913]

For sure

[@BisboWorld]

EWS is that only

[@shailjasingh3609]

@@BisboWorld next step is 200% reservation 😂

[@shiva53536]

Its already there, ews is for general class

[@navneethks8677]

very happy to see such brave video's coming up, hats off to you people

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks Navneeth

[@gauravattri1250]

Exactly..it takes guts to make such videos.

[@rajatsharma1498]

bisbo hats off to u...for bringing out this extremely brave topic which no one dare to even discuss on public platforms

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks Rajat 👍

[@rajatsharma1498]

@@BisboWorld subscriber for life...🤗🤗

[@AmitJaglan777]

Dear bisbo, There is 99-100% reservation in Haryana. Please make a video on this issue. There is 60% raw + 15% Ex-serviceman + 4% Handicap + 1% Sportsperson + 33% women(in education sector) So general category is fighting on only 20-30% seats *but wait wait* Government is also giving *extra marks* based on socio-economics. *So a person without reservation and extra marks is eliminated even after coming in top 10.* 3 lakh candidates appeared for Sub-inspector exam. I know a person who was in top 10. But was not selected. ✓Number of person who were selected without reservation and extra marks in various exams of haryana(selection commission released detailed marksheet of selected candidates)-- Sub-inspector : 4-5 out of 450 seats Staff nurse : 0 candidates out of 600+ selected candidates Constable: 20-50 candidates out of 5000 candidates. Vlda Exam: 2-5 selected out of 400 seats. Female Durga Force: 0 out of 1000 seats(even state rank-1 was thrown out) So basically there is 99-100% seats reserved in Haryana. Even after scoring rank in top 10, there is no guarantee that you will get a job. (My story - My rank is about 200 out of approx 50,000 students for science tgt exam(prelims). Government released a notification of 1600 science seats(now cancelled, will release again in future). Still I don't stand a chance. Even a person with top 10 rank is jobless in Haryana) Please make a video if possible. I emailed to various youtubers, TV channels, popular teachers on yt. But, no one is raising this serious issue. I tried to apply for neighbouring state Rajasthan. In rajasthan, there is 85% reservation.(on paper it is 64%, but in reality there is 85% reservation in Rajasthan, I have counted each and every seat). *I am born in a country/state, where I am not eligible for 99-100% seats.* I am *not* proud to be an Indian anymore. I lost faith in everything. PS. I am not a Brahmin(I am mentioning it because there is a trend on social media to abuse Brahmins).

[@debanjansarkar6021]

Similer situation in West Bengal as well on paper reservation is 60% but in reality at the time of teacher recruitment in various school college & universities many students give bribe to the ministers to get the job (recently CBI pointed out that ) over & above reservation . There is no opportunity for the middle class ( so called general) capable students.

[@AmitJaglan777]

@@debanjansarkar6021 India is slowly turning into a communist/socialist country. This reservation/representation is a socialist principle. There is no place for hardworking people in India. World experienced socialism in 20th century. There is not a single successful socialist/communist country in world. Socialism killed more than 100 million people in 100 years. India and Indians are just laging behind still having 19-20th century sense. Capitalism dominated society performs better because they are based on merit system. Socialist/communist Ideology- Everyone will get equal pay/land/property/etc. No matter if you work hard or not. These countries failed miserably because human beings are lazy by nature. They were getting everything by doing nothing. Capitalist Ideology - You will get paid according to your skill/hardwork/creativity/etc. The countries who followed this system in past(and still practising) are now developed countries. Because this system provides incentive for hard work. Moral of the story - *India is a sinking ship.* I agree that there should be 10-20% reservation for poor, downtrodden, etc. This 70-90% reservation is just going to destroy India.

[@debanjansarkar6021]

@@AmitJaglan777 If you observe their actions you can find that politicians have a hidden plan to throw general casts into private sector and give heavy reservations to those casts to gain vote bank slowly they will increase the percentage (as you mentioned in Haryana) & take it into a position where Pakistan stands in Pakistan's civil services current reservation is 97% approx.

[@AmitJaglan777]

@@debanjansarkar6021 There is *silent gen*cide* of general category people going on in India *by their own general category politicians for votebank.* ⚫ Reservation first started by - Brahmins(General Category) ⚫ Reservation in free India given by - Congress a.k.a. Pandit Nehru(in constituent assembly you need *majority* to pass a bill. And Pandit Nehru was the leader of house. A bill can be passed only if Nehru agreed.) ⚫ Bhudaan Movement (Land gift to backward) stated by - Achraya Vinoba Bhave(Jain, General Category) ⚫ Land reforms Act passed by - Pandit Nehru(my family lost something around 2000 acres of land because of this act) *Because of this Act a family can't have more than 40-45 (land ceiling varies from state to state)acres of land. And 33% of that extra land will go to SC/St* ⚫ Who was the first person to talk about OBC reservation - Then PM MORARJI DESAI(Brahmin general category) ⚫ Who introduced OBC reservation - Then PM VP Singh (Rajput - General Category) ⚫ Who introduced SC/St Act - VP Singh (Rajput - General Category) ⚫ Which state has highest reservation - Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu breached reservation limits 2 times 1) First time by the then CM MG Ramachandran (Nair - General Category) 2) Second time by the then CM Jayalalithaa ( Brahmin) ⚫ In Punjab, AAP govt started concession in *electricity bills based on caste* *After 10-20 years you will see that electricity will be completely free for so called backward and general category will be paying price for them. Now let's see who is All India Leader of AAP - Arvind Kejriwal (Baniya- General Category) Current CM of Punjab - Bhagwat Maan (General Category) ⚫ In Haryana SC farmers are getting free tractors - Now guess who is CM of Haryana - Khatter ( BJP General Category) Who is Agriculture minister of Haryana - JP Dalal ( General Category) Soon you will see people getting cars, motorcycle, etc for free based on caste. They are already getting free food, jobs, toilets, houses, electricity, education, etc. General category people are paying taxes and are not getting anything in return.(I want that money to be spent on public Infrastructure). While *they* are getting everything for free. *They are living on heavy discount and are still complaining.* That's why I hate to pay taxes. Moral of the story - General Category leaders know that they can easily get votes from reserved people just by giving them something for free. General category politicians are destroying their own people.

[@AmitJaglan777]

@@debanjansarkar6021 Everyone suffered in history but some are complaining to get something for free. *In modern world you get immense power just by portraying yourself weak* *Muslims ruled Delhi(political center of India since ages) straight for 800 years, and now more than 50% Muslims are in OBC.* Now tell me how they are backward. It was never about discrimination, upliftment, etc. It was just a propaganda for votebank, freebies, etc.

[@nivinpauli6012]

I've seen many people commenting that economically weaker sections should be provided reservation. I really don't know how can it be proved whether a person is really economically backward and on the top of it if a person becomes economically backward by losing in gambling then he also becomes eligible for reservation. I think the best solution for this is remove the reservation entirely and provide free education to everybody!

[@lahifdasurkar8783]

I partially agree with your statement bro. It is very easy to prove that you are economically backward in India. Free education is available but the quality is very poor.

[@adithyaiyer2698]

Free Education Cannot Be Given To All, And Nobody In This World Will Work For Free(You Need a System To Provide Education that Requires Money To Function)

[@Crauniverse]

Bro see I europe Or USA they gives scholarship to those student whi are good and eligible for scholarship not by their religion . We need to stop reservation.

[@thegeneralwill3358]

Your view is welcome.

[@abhishekseth8008]

ews is only applicable for gen categ ...so its not 10 % reservation for poors its 10 % res for gen catg

[@nickblue11]

No politician will ever get rid of caste reservations.....not even Modi has the balls 🔥

[@kshitijshirke5139]

they just can't general cat people are very less than all others combined we have to live with it or leave the nation

[@balajisai459]

My only question is reservation’s are to improve standard of living right? Since i am doctor, my example is A person who studied in a medical college after his undergraduation he can get a nice job which uplifts his standard living for sure, for what sake did they are giving reservation in postgraduate neet exam? Just imaging getting treated from an unqualified doctor? He is unqualified so he shouldnt get the seat. Ask these political Leaders who are amending law to get treatment from them, why are they ruining peoples life? Two people from same college did UG with the help of same professors, during neet pg one got nice rank for which he didnt get a desired college,but the other from same college with reservation who got 10-15 times more rank(means less marks) when comparing to the first candidate is getting amazing college. What kind of a country we are in, doesnt merit wont be counted? Is it our fault in being born in upper caste family? Just make video on this too, just imaging ur mom or dad getting treatment from a unqualified doctor too…then You will know the pain

[@BisboWorld]

Whether reservation should only be at one point, that is graduation level, is a valid point to consider. But those coming via reservation are not good doctors, this hasn't been proven yet. If any studies come on this, we will surely make a video on this.

[@satyasankalpapanigrahi9416]

@@BisboWorld these studies are often defiled by those politicians, even if they want to publicly file it, they can't, since it will hurt their's reputation in vote banks. You cannot even make a video without conducting yours own research. Huh

[@anildhawale9342]

Reservation is for equal representation of people of backward caste in all areas of life not a economic , equity or make rich programme

[@regal_lane]

​​@@anildhawale9342People like you with cheap fish-like saucy mindsets ruin India to doldrums. You believe yourself to be Sir Oracle, perhaps!😂

[@Boeing-ER-zf4ph]

People dont event know what is the seat matrix for central institute like aiims jipmer pgi in this years ini exam 2023 November for PG There are certain departments in which total seats are 4 out of which ZERO seats in unreserved category and all 4 are reserved for obc ews and Sc st ehich means even if you get rank 1 you camnot avail seats if you are general category student I could nt even understand how is it possible

[@swapnilkadam8410]

It's a curse to be an Indian... Let's go abroad and flourish . But those countries are also going towards lobby system, where gujju calls gujju ppl, punjabis call their ppl abroad, Telugu ppl calling their ppl.... So again... It's a curse to be an Indian

[@shreyaskashyap1582]

The best method of implementing reservation is :- Why can't the government employ targeted upliftment of socially backward people by better and efficient delivery of governance!! The current system allows a blanket permission for everyone with just the tag to avail the benefits. This results in a huge difference among the different classes within the socially backward classes and rendering only few of them predominantly in the urban areas, or not so socially backward to claim for reservation. One of my friends used to claim for scholarship amount of around 20000 per year during my college days but he was good enough to buy an iPhone (twice), costly play stations, and had a beautifully designed house which I would have never imagined. In another case, a lot of my college students (non general category) used to get jobs with annual CTC of 10+ LPA way more than many of the unreserved category students. I can bet that they would have never went through any sort of discrimination. (If you ask them, they'll obviously lie lol 🙄). So what sort of relevance does the socially backwardness have in today's world where class difference is on high rise? For the actual inclusive growth of India, there must be a revamp in the current reservation quota which is not only harming the highly deserving unreserved category people but also the actually backward people among the so called socially backward people!! Also, just a fact :- why don't we have any reservation in cricket, movies etc? It's because they are business. Apart from promoting sports in the country, they are money making means too where there can't be any compromise on the quality and the efficiency. Even the Indian Armed Forces doesn't have any reservation as the purpose of the job is just pure patriotism and serving the country in the best possible manner. If not everyone, at least we, the unreserved category people should make it a point to force the policy makers to consider the above mentioned issues and bring the necessary changes for the better, faster and inclusive growth of our country. Another fact :- Ambedkar and the other constituent assembly members had given a periodic review of the quota system after every 10 years. If a person like Ambedkar who in his life only had to undergo highest order of discrimination had kept a 10 year review, this explains the gravity of the situation!! Giving too much power on either of the sides is just very harmful. PS :- this doesn't mean I am preferring a complete ban on caste based reservation as even today we get to see discrimination in North Indian states (South Indian states have performed exceptionally well in eradicating discrimination, isn't reservation a kind of punishment to them for doing something good!?) and rural areas. The point is, a blanket permission for all is not correct and this also results in snatching of the opportunities by those who never have faced any discrimination from the actually backward people who needs social upliftment (ex :- people involved in the unimaginable act of manual scavenging, tribal people, rural citizens, etc and not urban people). I am not even asking the government to reduce the percentage of reservation for the time being at least. But the actual point to worry is, the eligibility criteria to avail the reservation benefits should be made stringent so that those underpriviliged from the backward castes can lead a better life compared to the current situation where well-off people from their own castes are snatching away the opportunities. Also if a person has availed the reservation benefits once or let's say even twice in his/her life, then what's the need to keep availing the benefits again and again and again!?

[@shreyaskashyap1582]

@@souventudu6154 thanks.😁 Yes it should be very specific unlike the current scenario where it's generic.

[@AttyDG]

I am from general community . The best solution for me was to leave and settle in North America .

[@rookie1491]

You did right 👍 atleast your kids will not have to suffer with this BS

[@Ajay_Singh2020]

Just leave my India

[@annimishra9913]

I think that reservation should be minimal and only for the economic weaker sections irrespective of their gender caste faith etc.

[@BisboWorld]

Cool suggestion, Anni

[@Degana962]

@@BisboWorld Perhaps you are telling this as a good suggestion because you have not done any ground study about socially backward people in rural areas.

[@isuzu343]

@@Degana962 Are these people you talk about, economically well placed? If not, your argument is invalid since these people would be included in the economically weaker sections irrespective of their caste as proposed by the original commenter. There's absolutely no justification for children of certain IAS officers to benefit from caste based reservation which actually deprives these from the very people you talk about.

[@ankitait2]

@@Degana962 perhaps more research is needed on urban rural divide in socially weaker sections in itself.We don't need any more Khobergarde family members or Tina Dabi's progeny in the IAS because of quotas. We want rural poor to have that opportunity. Otherwise the quotas fail on their basic premise, to end discrimination and create a representative set in policy making.

[@sanathhegde007]

@@Degana962 bro please understand the sentence before u blabber shit! ... EWS for socially backward is always acceptable .... Not for the rich but socially backward ... In this age it doesn't make any sense

[@gg_fireland216]

Stop reservation.. Promote meritocracy..

[@aakarshjha1633]

+1

[@abhishekagrahari8667]

Bhim get offended

[@rommy007]

Jai bheem Jai meem Bullshit

[@Rapid-Shuttle..]

No bro, don't see it that way, just don't look at the partial data

[@Rapid-Shuttle..]

see the landholding pattern and people in higher education and top notch jobs

[@Phych0path]

Being a Brahmin this country is not worth dying for if war happens and country needs me ill not fight for this country we call country as mother but true mother never discriminates between her children

[@billybutcher6504]

U are the biggest oppressers of India. U have divided India into caste for centuries

[@Phych0path]

@@billybutcher6504 I no it was like 1000 years ago now I'm also a proud Castist you can't get equality and reservation at same time

[@sagaraiwale]

What about Marathas and Jats, who actually died for soil and still dont get any reservations

[@unknown-us5vs]

*There should be a maximum of 40% Quota ,60% should be general. The smart general category leave india due to no seats inspite of 98%.PROBLEMS OF DEMOCRACY !*

[@Theodore92477]

Reservation system should be removed for all.... Instead, give scholarships to the meritorious students whose family income is below 6 LPA regardless of their caste.

[@yashwanthv9429]

@@souventudu6154 simultaneously stop discrimination in society by upper caste

[@Theodore92477]

@@yashwanthv9429 Right, that should be...but giving quota to lower caste people is not the solution. Better the authority should try to improve the standard of living of the poor. It's not fair when an upper caste student with high marks can't quality while a lower caste student quality with low marks

[@aakarshjha1633]

Remove all reservation based on social standards and have reservation for poor people,they are in all communities,it will benefit them irrespective of caste

[@BisboWorld]

Fair suggestion, Aakarsh.. that's what the minority judgement was

[@hritikbhat6658]

Remove all reservation and start Scholarship of full fees waive off by govt to poor people instead of giving seats. In this way, a true merit person will get the seat only if they are eligible to cuttoff and those who are poor among them will be provided scholarships/waive off by govt. Note: We can also add clause to this scholarship by rejecting this scholarship to a person if his/her parents have more than 2 children and both have availed the scholarships on graduation level. In this way population control awareness can be propogated which will benefit India's long-term growth. I think that would be good solution for this deadlock.

[@abhishekseth8008]

@@BisboWorld yes then you should also stop all govt schemes related to female reservation , female empowerment ?

[@bumblebee2956]

No wonder brain drain is common in sub continent. This system is destroying the progress 😢

[@gopimanohar945]

Such a gutsy video from @Bisbo. I suggest a similar video on benefits for Tax payers (if any) and who don't pay Taxes.

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks Gopi. We will think about this topic.

[@vedantbansod9900]

Video is spot on, Supporting reservations for historically marginalised communities and criticizing irrelevant vote bank reservation

[@BisboWorld]

👍

[@soham2638]

That's the point which majority doesn't get the still fight in name of caste.

[@viirom4629]

And conclusion is remove reservation so that youth morale should not be down

[@youtubestudies4173]

This is discrimination in its purest form 😭. I have jee mains in 10 days and getting around 120 in mocks which is useless for a general but gold for sc st

[@Tonad_Drump]

@souventudu6154 For qualifying the Jee Mains General Category requires 100-110 Whereas SC/ST require just as low as 40-50 marks Out of 300....

[@Tonad_Drump]

@souventudu6154 Its like hell.... for comparison its too bad being a general male . Minimum 150+ for safeside in general

[@Tonad_Drump]

@souventudu6154 Reservation is absurd ... if they are asking for talented students in IIT's then why do they take people having less marks in their entrance exam ... Give me a valid reason.

[@Tonad_Drump]

And hence reservation has no means in todays standards

[@Tonad_Drump]

@souventudu6154 you may also go and look for minimum cuttof percentile Its 88 percntile for General And 60 percentile for ST/SC 's

[@vikramaadityamishra7303]

This video raised an important point. We need to go beyond the social-economic binary when it comes to reservation - Adopting a purely social criterion would allow excess discretion which will see even land-owning communities get benefits due to vote bank politics -Adopting a purely economic criterion would be impossible to implement as documents can be easily fudged to reflect a lower income level, it would require constant updation following changes in the cost of living and actually serve as an incentive against economic upliftment of the community on its own. Hence the solution is to add an economic filter to the existing social categories so that we’re not faced with situations where children of IAS Officers are claiming SC/ST quota ( something like a reservation impact assessment)

[@BisboWorld]

Seems like an interesting concept of 'A quota within quota' with the economic filter

[@adityadubey5390]

Your solution is contradicting with your second statement.

[@shubhampathak6178]

The people need to see the bigger picture otherwise it will result in a economic collapse in years to come. Hats off to you .

[@elnaantony1447]

Excellently portrayed 👍

[@BisboWorld]

Thank you! 🙂

[@01_nimishagarwal76]

Ews quota is completly flawed because i know of so many people in my college who have produced rigged income certificates. I know of a friend who has shown is family income as low as 2 lac and has a bussiness of crores.

[@BisboWorld]

Wow.. that is something, Nimish.. There should be rigorous checking for this

[@rd2664]

My Friend too whereas as me who doesn't have even have land and father earns only 20k a month has no EWS certificate

[@lahifdasurkar8783]

@@rd2664 bro my father was NRI and I had income certificate of 60k😂 NRI income is not accounted at all

[@Crauniverse]

I can also show you thousands of example from St and obs who's father or mother have government job but still getting reservation. And ews reservation never be cancel untill obc and st reservation are there.

[@GirishHR]

My sc friend has 11k per annum income certificate too. His home is 1.5cr

[@Kushagra.j]

I am a Jain by birth but if you're providing Reservation to all and Sundry irrespective of Merit or Potential then give it to Jain's, Hindus, Buddhists, etc and especially to Males since they are anyway destroying this section

[@lahifdasurkar8783]

Bro this EWS is for all including jain Hindus buddhist

[@careerprism64]

Fine narration. Excellent.

[@yashwanthv9429]

Every dog has its own day being upper caste discriminating lower caste was pride moment now suffering. Remove reservation but simultaneously remove cast discrimination which still exists in major rural areas of India

[@12345ngb]

Reservation should be purely based on economic criteria

[@kshitijshirke5139]

people cheat during it also my friend who's parents are rich managed to get ews certicicate by showing the income of his farm meanwhile they are in transporting business

[@12345ngb]

@@kshitijshirke5139 it will soon change (soon in India means 5-10 years) This Pan-Adhaar link will make it next to impossible to hide real income (white) in India

[@JackRyan101]

​@souventudu6154yes your surname tells why you support reservation based on community.

[@akshat4311]

Even after 72 years of quota if ST, SC still can't be socially and economically strong then reservation should be completely abolished.

[@abhishekseth8008]

72 yrs vs 3000+ yrs of caste system ...not even 5 % of time given for improving their lives which was ruined for centuries and generations ....

[@rd2664]

@@abhishekseth8008 3000 years??

[@savlon-bhoi007]

Why can't we demolish caste system other countries calls us backwards for still using caste system

[@billybutcher6504]

@@rd2664 u ppl took reservation for 3000 yrs. Why u are silent over that. If we took reservation for 75 yrs u start to cry. Lol And we didn't demanded for reservation, we demanded for separate electorates. Lol

[@rd2664]

@@billybutcher6504 I was born in 1998

[@martinharold7397]

Well researched and presented 😮

[@drhouse392]

I really don't know why everyone is crying about ews The other quota has such a great % but no one has guts to challenge it

[@AP-eb8hd]

Video is good.. If you think deeper.. it looks like Indian politicians are least bothered about the country and want to ensure... their breed stays longer.. People who are smart and get demoralized with this reservation, leave the country.. and give their best for some other country.. This is sad reality which our incapable politicians can't understand..

[@BisboWorld]

To be fair, people move for greener pastures of money and better lifestyle

[@shivachitti5274]

Dear Bisbo, Reservations are evil in jobs and promotions. Socially and economicalluy backward people should be encouraged in education by providing them facilities to compete but providing quotas in jobs and promotions is like genocide against merit. Errors of history cannot be cured by errors of present. Politicians can't improve the infra to provide equality for everyone so doing shortcuts as quotas, this will boomerang to us , already we are seeing daughter of IAS becoming IAS on quota and many people underreporting income .... if next generation of quota parents taking reservation, they are discriminating their own community and actual marginalised remain marginalised.

[@BisboWorld]

Lack of infrastructure is such a huge bane since 70 years.. pathetic state of public schools.. if we would have built it, the debate around this could have changed

[@shivachitti5274]

@@BisboWorld Expecting middle class genral category to bear burden of all infra failure of India has become a norm

[@rockybhai084]

Your content are superb ☺️

[@madhusmitasahoo7049]

Nice explanation with a beautiful animation ❤️

[@harigovindsroriginal]

EWS isn't good, no reservation is good. But seeing as reservation will never end, having EWS is better than not

[@deltasquad5313]

I would rather have EWS than Caste based ones. The SC, STs are not that much backward now.... But many meritorious candidate even in general class does not get chance due to financial reason. But the cuttoff should stay the same.

[@BisboWorld]

But income limit should be less for it, as we have pointed out

[@narayanprathap1619]

Still SC ST OBC still economically very backward in India compare to most of the general category people's

[@Crauniverse]

Woooo so you also thinks ews need to get cancelled because it's just 10% and sc and obc reservation is 26% ews . Bro it's 2023 now there is no need of reservations.

[@BisboWorld]

Yeah.. stats do prove that, Narayan

[@saikatbasuri6125]

One of the best video 🔥

[@rahulsamant2003]

Removing reservation goes togather with ending caste system.....caste is the root problem, remove caste from society and there is no need for reservation.

[@prajwalbgowda]

In a era where money is everything.Only economic criteria should be used for reservation because no child , irrespective of his/her social background, should not be at a disadvantage just because they were born in a poor family.

[@BisboWorld]

Scholarships would be a good tool for that, Prajwal

[@Mr.SledgeHammer]

Money isn't everything even in this era. There are places where marriage of 2 people isn't accepted because of difference in caste despite groom being in a well paid job. Even if caste matches , because of obsession to govt jobs , family's aren't ready to commit to the marriage despite private jobs paying more than govt. Hence people depend on reservations to get into govt in these places. Need of the hour is educating people. Unfortunately education is the last entity to be focused by govt of our country

[@AjaySharma-em2ez]

You Bisbo Team are the real Gods of this mother world, i dont have enough words to express my thanks and gratitude for making us literate in all the social economics political subjects, Thank You Thank you, I bow and teach all the Team Members, content creators, knowledge experts of BISBO thank you Thank Thank You, especiallay for sharing all the sources for preparing these great contents.

[@beastbhaiya04]

The real empowerment of the Oppressed and the "So called Oppressed" (no offence) will be shown when we will reduce the reservation over the time not by continuosly increasing it. The reduction will show the devlopment of the community, While the increment is showing that they are backward. For ex- Even after having this much reservation, If we look at UPSC result, Toppers are mostly mostly Genral, Is that reservation even working?

[@BisboWorld]

There could be indeed more research on how much it has helped, Adarsh.

[@AshishYadav-my7kd]

General candidates are made toppers by providing them more marks in the written examination to keep on the hierarchy of upper castes in the top offices. Otherwise lower caste candidates perform better than upper caste candidates in Prelims which is omr based.

[@vinubaby1]

reservation is just keeping the backward people backward. they will never build the competency... just increase mediocrity.

[@mjordan1333]

@ashish yadav i mean really ashish you think that the govt. Exams which have reservation in it ,do partiality against all other castes except general just to maintain superiority i mean you dont even trust the selection process that much.

[@mjordan1333]

Or rahi baat prelims aur final ki toh omr sheet me aur subjective paper me jamen asman ka farak hota hai ,omr me elaboration nahi karana padata, usme apne point ko prove karne ke liye options already diye hote hai ,mains me apna point explain karne ke liye communication skills bhi jaruri hai.

[@suryapradeep6370]

Now, 12% people(EWS) of india are getting 10% reservation where as 55%(OBC) people of India are getting only 27% reservation. If you interpret above data you will find that Probability of selection is much higher in EWS class than OBC, in mathematical terms probability is double. It may be possible that cutoff marks of EWS will be higher for some years but in near future this will go significantly lower than OBC’s cutoffs.

[@kiran8656]

Ews 12% how?

[@vjeminem]

The irony is many people well off from quota benefits, use the same for their children as well. Total shameful

[@GhostRealm8]

Indian always demands more from the exisiting system but they never demand to create new system,it would had been fruitful as well as beneficical for country if we would havae fought for more new IITs,IIMs,AIIMS and various other reputed institutes ,but it seems no one is worrying about the future generation and all are busy in presenet benefits.

[@BisboWorld]

Overall infrastructure in education has to go up.. important point

[@RAVISHANKAR-ck9lt]

Ews should only for economical backward Not for Earning 8 lakh per annum and many relaxation as per relaxation given by states According to currrent eligibility for ews around 90 percent of generals are economically backward(>8lakhper annum) At the same time they are also paying income tax(>2.5 lakh per annum) Its a political freebie thats why states are are also copying the centre

[@BisboWorld]

Yeah.. everyone's lapping this up

[@Crauniverse]

Why only ews st and obc should also have this rules. Bro now ews only stops when all reservation stops.

[@GiGaChadAF]

Perhaps the rules can be different from state to state. In some states discrimination is non existent and hence reservations are redundant.

[@kumarr14567]

In some of the recent exams for government jobs, the cutoff marks for ews category is lower than obc category's cutoff marks. How it can be justified?

[@dr.sourabhharal3372]

More than 50% of those 71 % who applied in ews stating family income of 2 Lakh were from private medical Colleges paying a average fee of 10 lakhs per year for last 5 years...surprising that no one questions from where those fee were paid

[@abhishekseth8008]

hypocrisy of gen catg

[@kushalkollu8628]

Damn

[@bharathraman7234]

EWS cut off is 8 lakh not 2 lakh

[@bharathraman7234]

could be education loan

[@BisboWorld]

Hi Dr Sourabh.. we didn't come across any such figure about 50% were from private colleges.. Can you share any source for this figure?

[@rahiloza1311]

The purpose of reservation was to provide substitution for opportunities which the lower casts did not get , after 70 long years of reservation & opportunities in name of it ,if sc st are still backward then its not about the missed opportunities. If OBCs can improved their level by so much that they had to differentiate the creamy layer, why can SCs & STs not make progress ?! If you've made the desired progress then let the non creamy part of your community take the help of your quotas & then you'll see that EWS is justified in every way possible.

[@BisboWorld]

Creamy layer can be looked into SC/ST quota, after adequate research on beneficiaries

[@rajvardhanch1258]

Strive for abolition of caste certification along with caste reservation. Then even though I am SC candidate my support will be with you.

[@arun37625]

Just do one thing rather than vertical reservation do horizontal reservation in every sector. Vertical reservation is where reserved candidate have better marks he/ she will got a seat in unreserved/ general category ,but in vertical reservation a sc/ st candidate have to fight with his own category students and even if he got good marks he never get a general category seat.

[@tonystark_min2]

Give reservations to all then there will be no value of quotas

[@ShounakKundu]

We are heading towards that. If 90% is reserved , then there will be no value of quotas.

[@BisboWorld]

Now we are actually there.. but with privatisation only, its relevance is decreasing

[@asutoshghanto3419]

@@BisboWorld nothing will ever get privatized ,it is just a marketing gimmick by bjp .The core sectors are still govt and will be govt in future .Will govt ever give up on 1lakh crore of profit from all the PSUs overnight ? They also get bargaining power during elections due to PSUs as well.

[@itstechraaz851]

If a person is in govt job but his annual salary is within 5 lakh Nor he has more land Then he will be considered as a EWS category or not

[@rd2664]

Yes

[@hrithikraj209]

Basically this video is a tad bit more than all the arguments made in the Apex court in all the judgements

[@MrSingh369]

The funny part is we can only feel guilty and can't change😢

[@advik1862]

Being General in India is a punishment (Although I'm OBC but above 8 Lakhs)

[@savlon-bhoi007]

Back in a time being a Brahman is pride and now it's punishment lol

[@STUDY_Mood_ON]

@@savlon-bhoi007 Stop using reservation for a while then you would feel it's a punishment in India and it's being 75 years still if those people have not evolved then you guys can never evolve .......

[@vijayvijju4821]

At least someone has the guts to release a video🔥

[@BisboWorld]

👍👍

[@Prashaantkumaar-os7rh]

general category situation would b such that general quota will need gen reservation quota

[@ramkethineni5114]

A person from sc/st community, after getting into central services like IAS and IPS,gets access to the best of facilities.yet,his children and their children continue to get benifits of reservation.should this continue???

[@ArjunJangidHere]

Meritocracy is what can make India vishwaguru again..... reservation seeping in more areas will make it difficult to eradicate it whenever a brave leader and party decide to do that.... Building public consensus on no need of reservation is already difficult It will get much more daunting task going forth

[@abhishekseth8008]

if meritocracy is such a good practical idea ....pleas name few Countries which run on meritocracy .... and also before proposing such brilliant suggestions ...dont just speak about advantage of meritocracy but also reaserch on disadvantages of meritocracy......

[@ArjunJangidHere]

@@abhishekseth8008 any good idea or great idea doesn't mean it should apply without exceptions. Every governance today is a blend of different ideologies because world keeps evolving and learning adverse impacts of extremities. I hope you read between the lines because there's a lot water flown under the bridge of governance systems in last 4 centuries. Cheers mate you were not saying anything wrong but such gigantic changes need a lot of caution to be applied. Caution can mean certain exceptions as far as and as much as they are needed.

[@ArjunJangidHere]

@@abhishekseth8008 OK mate educate me on disadvantages of meritocracy as per your understanding. you can take trophy of pride in this argument in case you need , learning is what matters the most though.

[@ArjunJangidHere]

@souventudu6154 economic conditions to be precise.....

[@anonymous-zt9xw]

@@ArjunJangidHere hey man there minds are on other level they can't debate on facts

[@mrlucifer8455]

Everyone always b like "kaun jaat se ho" , kyun sc caste ke jesa behave kar raha hai , also then when it comes to career "We need equality"

[@nareshkteja1895]

Reservation is for caste based discrimination & not financial basis!. So let's talk about the discrimination we want & not equality which we don't want which promotes reservation!

[@x.sanjiban.x]

If u go by caste census gen 22% obc 53% sc 18% st 7% Seats they are getting Gen/UR : 40+10=50%(with ews) Obc: 28% Sc: 15% St: 7% So basically who are more in benifit. U deside End note: reservation not about economic status upliftment it's about community representation in education and job (affiliate with govt). Less educated people is more dangerous than uneducated people. 🤝🏼

[@tonywayne4610]

General category students must know how many students prepare and fight for various exam in category wise... General are more educated,that's why they have to fight more... Also,EWS General category people have 8 lakh as creamy layer as same as OBC class... But General category have more land holdings that OBC and SC/ST... And history tells about how permanent settlement made poor cultivator into just tenant... and these land didn't fairly divided after Independence... In 1857 revolt, we the Non-general people fought in mass , (please don't tell about Rani Laxmi Bai , Nana saheb etc - they just fought for their kingdom not for the poor people..) And the Brave Rajputs , who became langotiya friend (vaasal states) of British...

[@x.sanjiban.x]

@@tonywayne4610 the actual problem is upper caste able to spread there own narrative becoz of strong media access than sc st obc all over the nation and suppress the perspective of sc st obc. 🗿

[@satyasankalpapanigrahi9416]

@XsanjibanX, yes then go for population based on caste too. SC,ST and OBC are highly dominant in population both on rural and urban. We generals are minorities with less hope to be live a better livelihood in india

[@satyasankalpapanigrahi9416]

@@tonywayne4610 we Generals are suffering. This indian politics are further fueling up in this caste division.

[@satyasankalpapanigrahi9416]

@@tonywayne4610 we Generals are more educated bcz of competition. However this idiots classes like SC,ST and OBC are enjoying with their lazy ass reservation system. 😒😒

[@sureshkumark2672]

Upper cast people were getting reservation for thonsands of years. A few decades back only sc/sr/obs started getting government jobs through reservations. The purpose of govt job reservation is to allow the 'sidlined ' people to take part in governance. A survey ia required to estimate the percentage of such people in the government services

[@BisboWorld]

This is also an important point, Suresh

[@CARL_093]

thanks bisbo

[@saiteja.5498]

There should no reservations for IAS OR IPS OR 2 TIMES WORKED MLA OR MP. or even if father or mother is working in any higher gov job there should be no reservation for their child

[@VijayKumar-ps9jd]

Thumbnail pic is perfect example of 'Telent Killer' Reservation System...😡

[@sambs3609]

We often criticise Reservation as it's been there ever since we got independence. However, is it fair to just oppose reservation for underprivileged from SC/ST Community while Shudras and Dalits were denied even basic rights of consuming waters etc coz of Manusmriti for more than 3000 years?

[@vinubaby1]

this is the common excuse given.. which appears to be so stupid. According to your view will 3000 years of reservation reverse it?? no way.. 10,000 years of reservation will still keep them in the current state.. Once you get the taste of a reservation, you will never let it go. of the last many years have you heard of anyone who have let go their reservation after their economic status changed??

[@isuzu343]

The arc of the moral universe is long but it bends towards justice. Correcting a historical wrong by perpetrating another wrong today won't fix anything because two wrongs never make a right. Like the video explains, a rising tide lifts all boats. The focus should be on collective development of the society and we cannot do this when reservations are weaponized for political gains. There is no justification for children of parents who've benefitted from reservations to still claim benefits while others in their very community still remain left behind after 75 years of independence. And to do this at the cost of meritocracy and growing resentment in the merited youth who're now seeking to take their talents elsewhere in the world, is just plain criminal. The more appropriate response should be to focus on truth and reconciliation rather than retribution. The darkest aspects of our history must be brought out into the sunlight and current generations should be taught about the injustices of our past so we can acknowledge them and let the healing process begin.

[@BisboWorld]

We surely empathise and recognise these historical wrongs, Sam

[@deepmishra9940]

Yes lower caste learns to live and survive without water.😂😂 how foolish is this to say that few incidents are presented as 100% reality

[@snehalmishra7549]

having caste certificate doesn't necessarily mean that you are underprivileged, there can be many cases where the reverse holds true

[@vagishgpatil3013]

I don't totally understand how the system is working in reality .Recently I applied for constable exam in Karnataka (general category)..but When I examined the previous provisional selection list ,there were hardly 4 or 5 from GM out of thousands..This is reality of Karnataka services. I am not hoping for any job from my home state.

[@aimexcellence1315]

I dont remember or seen any incident of caste violence, discrimination or temple entry denial for poor "uppercaste" people.

[@zalayashpalsinh5427]

😑😑😑, poor are poor, who is discriminating obc people

[@shivamshukla8805]

It's also with me I clear NEET with 592 num but due to reservations That tooks me very low rank so I can nt afford government medical collage for mbbs Isme meri galti kya thi

[@kshitijshirke5139]

this thing really hits bro i also share the same story

[@shivamshukla8805]

@@kshitijshirke5139 thanks bro for sampathy

[@sayanbarik6065]

are you not eligible for ews?

[@Ajay_Singh2020]

Tumhari galti ye hai ki tumhare poorvajo ne hamara haq khaya

[@InvinciblePepe]

​@@Ajay_Singh2020victim card sabko khelna hai 😂

[@deveshbalkote3114]

In 2050 YT videos would be "why india failed" and the list will start with reservation.

[@RAMTA_SLAYER]

Even today you can see why India became a slave since hundred years of invasion and the list starts with reservations. Remember Alexander and his army was scared of Nanda's army which had almost 3lakh soldiers on merit,but later on reservation started and quality decreased and we were invaded and ruled. So, reservation was from beginning and not since 1950. Problem with PUBG kids is that they only want to highlight one part and intentionally wanna hide other.

[@BisboWorld]

To be factually correct, reservation at the most started in last 100 years.. that too in education and jobs.. i don't remember any militaries having reservation

[@RAMTA_SLAYER]

@@BisboWorld militaries were formed on the basis on caste. Only particular caste was allowed later on to pick up weapons( i won't mention caste as you might think I hate those communities). I think you should have that general knowledge atleast if you have such a huge base of subscribers. Even indian army today has 14 lakh soldiers from different religion and caste. Now just think what will happen if we do like past and allow only some caste to be in Indian army? You can't even imagine the scenario.

[@AyushGupta-sm9ux]

Good video 👍. Keep it up 👏

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks Ayush

[@bishalchatterjee745]

Caste based reservation at all costs has to be abolished.. Even the SC has said that reservation can not continue for lifetime..!!

[@Param.G.C]

In this compititive era if we talk about reservation than it is like taking handicaped into to war. Only solution is provide all the required facilities like scholarship, education to the economically weaker families and select on the basis of merit. Because after providing all the required facilities if he/she didn't able to crack an exam then they are just an burden our sociaty should bear.

[@vinubaby1]

excatly... this is just building up mediocrity and burden to the workforce.

[@isuzu343]

You're basically advocating for an equality of opportunity rather than what we currently have, which is equality of outcomes. Everyone knows that it's the right thing to do. That's why it's never going to happen in our country.

[@skarrin6207]

Fuck reservation it took me a rank of 300s to get tge second best college in MHTCET While i saw a nt girl with 15k rank in the same class Edit: They were rich too

[@braveheart4388]

I personally have come across so many upper caste poor who work really hard to meet the needs. EWS is a boon to them. However I have also seen so many lower caste fuerdai filthy rich who snatch away the opportunity from the deserving upper caste who ultimately settle abroad. India and all countries of democracy function for vote appeasement and are destined to remain mediocre. The system is designed that way and not a thing will change till the nation remains a democracy. The western world will thrive because of the brain exports and will remain that way forever. So the prudent thing for any upper caste is to quit India and prosper rather than listening to the BS of dheshbhakthi and giving it back to India.

[@soumyadebnath4369]

Yes ,create reservation for "poor SC , ST" by cutting away from the SC, ST , OBC reservation , respectively. For example, let there be 100 seats in a college . Acc to law , 15% reservation for SC. So there is 15 seats for SC candidates. Then take 10% of 15 seats to "Poor SC" candidates, thus creating SC-EWS. Same goes for ST and OBC reservation. That seems pretty logical, because GEN-EWS seats were carved out from GENERAL seats , to help the economically poor general category students. So, should be the case for SC,ST and OBC.

[@soumyadebnath4369]

Correction : In first line , read it " poor SC ST OBC reservation"

[@the_vertex]

Finally someone said what this...totally agree

[@BisboWorld]

Soumya, that can be done for SC-ST.. but would be tough to do it for OBC because creamy layer already exists for them.

[@Paaaaaaaaaaal]

Thanks for exposing EWS scam.

[@zalayashpalsinh5427]

Obc scam? Who is discriminating obc people? I can undwrsta d for sc and st but why obc?

[@Paaaaaaaaaaal]

@@zalayashpalsinh5427 go through mandal commission report. It shows how much inequality is there between obc and general. You have similar data for general? No. General are just bjp votebank that's why they got it.

[@marypradeep1078]

Bisbo u got obc NCI criteria wrong.the 8 lakhs don’t include salary and agricultural income

[@sagaraiwale]

What about Marathas and Jats, who actually died for soil and still dont get any reservations, people arguing they were oppresed are here to claim they were oppressed, those Marathas actually died while fighting against islam and british

[@InvinciblePepe]

What about Brahmins who died fighting the British while the SC/STs under Ambedkar bootlicked the British and requested them to not quit India and these are the same leeches benefiting from reservations?

[@Tum_Tum_]

Hey General Category student, either join Army(no reservations) or do business or go abroad. Only option in India.

[@Philosophy_WH]

All sorts/quotas of reservations have the same issue. Only first layer (better income earners or employee group) only using reservations.

[@BisboWorld]

Quota within quota' for first generation learners can be looked at

[@gravity1648]

Reservations should be stopped if India aspires to be a Superpower. I hope the 3rd Modi government would stop this curse on the nation.

[@Varun32924]

You have problem with reservation but no problem CASTE or caste based discrimination

[@deepakrajouri9703]

It's time for all OBC+SC+ST+MN completely covered Unreserved Seat... We will, We can

[@vismay5495]

2:09 but aren't SC/ST already included in reservations and obc already has NCL Certificate. What is your point??

[@I_am_No1]

I believe in Ability which make opportunities

[@sayanbarik6065]

i want to just highlight two points here. and i want bisbo's reply to appreciate my concern. 1. this 10% ews seats were carved out from the remaining 50% seats for generals. while 10% seats added in educational institute to accomodate ews, so it didnt affect unreserveds in those institutes but the govt could not and can not do the same in the govt jobs. they simply can not add 10% additional vacancy in any department, hence here non-ews general candidates losing out their well deserved 10% seats permanently and no compensation for them and they are left with only 40% vacancy. 2. most of the general catagory people gloating over ews quota but not me. because in the criteria candidates with bigger plot than 100 and 200 sq yards (which is quite small) in town and village areas respectively are excluded. 😅 think of the irony, even i am a begger i am not economically weaker section cause i live in a house of plot little over 100 yards which my grand father brought and made. this criteria is mockery of poor people.

[@vinfinity8940]

There are more minority nowadays than general category. The general category people do mixed caste marriage and now they are in minorities. And a lot of people who do not have to show proof of income bribe or somehow show themselves as bpl. So basically these laws are largely misused. Nowadays getting into a government job is super hard because the ones with political strings and far less qualifications are appointed into government jobs and even being on the rank list might not help and sometimes things get harder for a person in general category.