WHAT REALLY HAPPENED to Smiling Critters in Poppy Playtime Chapter 3?

[@Yourgraveisready]

4:46 the prototype killed KickenChicken, remember what Poppy said: “The moment you step outside, you’ll be killed by the prototype, we have to kill it first before escaping”

[@stormbreaker504]

This could’ve happen with the bunny too I think

[@Yourgraveisready]

@@stormbreaker504 You mean Bonzo?

[@stormbreaker504]

@@Yourgraveisready yep

[@HeadshootsOo]

Bonzo was killed by mommy ​@@stormbreaker504

[@Justanormallittlecloud]

Ohhhh😊

[@EnderSidian9339]

Hoppy Hopscotch's makes me think she tried to run away with someone else. Perhaps maybe a parkour spot they were trying to do where the purple hands aided us that she couldn't have gotten through, and either got caught and killed or fell to her death. Catnaps is likely a kid struggling to breath or something. It'd make the most sense.

[@IsupportTherians604]

No I was looking at other lores apparently she forgot to pay attention to her feet when she was jumping so she fell of the ledge, hope this helps!

[@yxri34]

𝙷𝚘𝚙𝚙𝚢 𝚒𝚜 𝚊 𝙷𝙴

[@IsupportTherians604]

Sorry- jeez@@yxri34

[@EnderSidian9339]

@@yxri34 Is it really? Idk. I don't really care that much though tbh, but my bad ig-

[@Theboogyman-w7x]

​@@yxri34it's a she

[@Epicduckys]

Everyone was killed by i think picky piggy could have died of starvation but we dont know for sure but catnap killed everyone Edit:ty so much for 53 likes I have never gotten so many likes

[@doggy601]

Why would u kill them catnap why

[@Epicduckys]

I don't know why

[@Spr4ngy]

Picky piggy says he ate some of them in the cardboard cutout

[@Epicduckys]

​@Official_SpringyProdutions but picky piggy was talking about them catnap had killed everyone and picky piggy might have died from starvation

[@Spr4ngy]

@@EpicduckysI guess your right

[@B_bzy2]

If you pay attention Bubba Bubbaphant you can hear him yell “grandma” it’s actually heart breaking that he breaks character to yell for his grandma! Most people wouldn’t do that!

[@Space_Nurde]

omg i heard it too...

[@Cai_Thorn]

And mom but it got cut short

[@TypicalGamingA24]

I heard it

[@KreateeveKat]

I think his grandmother died or smth

[@ashleyhartley1576]

I never knew that but now I know

[@SalvatoreIovine-q1o]

1:02 Dogday Seems To Be Kind But His Body Was Captured by *✨sMiLiNg AsShOLeS✨* Lol 😂

[@Wandererxxx]

DANG IT YOU TOOK MY MEME

[@SalvatoreIovine-q1o]

NO I DIDNT ​@@Wandererxxx

[@vincealvarado38]

What i personally think what i think for some of them is Bubba elephant: he is breathing in the gas while catnap and pickypiggy eat him while he's dreaming. Kickinchikin: as he tries to leave pickypiggy finds him denying prototype and eats him while leaving Pickypiggy: she worships or is under the control of prototype as she eats the other members who deny prototype and is probably trapped under the actual play place stuck waiting with craftycorn and another member eating her and waiting for more food from the god she worships Hoppy hopscotch: while she tries to jump out of the area with pickypiggy and craftycorn she is killed or is killed by prototype and catnap Bobby bearhug: probably worships prototype and got abandoned and trapped under the play house alone going insane like ms delight waiting to be with somebody as pickypiggy left her for food and thinks she's more insane then everything or just trapped alone Craftycorn: she kills a member for her painting or another toy as pickypiggy eats her fed up of craftycorn or hungry eating her alive Dogday: i agree but when he says "i am the last of the smiling critters" i believe he doesn't count the ones who worships prototype or he doesn't know their alive as the other ones he's seen get killed and when found saving somebody he is tortured and hanged That's my personal opinion But hey that's just a theory a game theory thanks for reading

[@ShadowCrew1105]

That's a good theory, an interesting. It'd make sense

[@EbubeChukwurah]

I feel that crafty corn is still alive, flayed means the removal of the top skin, plus she never had a screaming end with Bobby and picky, plus she was asking for red, which refers to the blood around her, she might used the blood to draw warning signs on the wall

[@amlieamegan31]

Yea because I search that to

[@EbubeChukwurah]

Really, am I correct

[@Snoopie_snoozie]

Smart

[@EbubeChukwurah]

Cul

[@crisantoignacio1452]

​@@EbubeChukwurah it could be bobby bear hug could be still alive I think and bobby bearhug is missing

[@gregzotter6189]

Crafty said, "out? but...we cant BE out', referring to the red paint. She never mentioned going outside.

[@Fracturehouse]

Bro do u have -0 braincells or something

[@Fracturehouse]

She meant out as in the red paint is out (gone) not going outside💀

[@ivanmonev1492]

yea.

[@vathanakkeu]

Yea the red paint is blood

[@amlieamegan31]

Well she screamed and say something so I think she is alive because most of them don't do that like Scream then say something

[@davidgallardo2213]

If the cutouts are the order in which the smiling critters were killed, I think this could be a possible timeline. Catnap: Joined the Prototype during the hour of joy. Bubba: Was the first killed. By the drawn out scream, it seems as if his death was long and painful. Maybe Catnap wanted to make an example of him. Everyone will remember the loss of the one who remembers. Kick'n: The other smiling critters went into hiding. One day, Kick'n tried to escape by going outside. Not sure if Catnap or the Prototype got him. Piggy: While she did not die at this point, she did betray the others. She joined Catnap and the Prototype and ate her friends that were killed. She probably starved or was killed sometime after Craftycorn was killed. Hoppy: She tried to escape, maybe by jumping to the ceiling bars to squeeze through. She was caught and killed. Bobby: She talks about being alone. She was probably separated from the others and lost her sanity in lonelyness. Not sure if she died in solitude or is still alive in hiding. Dogdays and Craftycorn: As the last smiling critters, they were together. They lived in hiding until Craftycorn snapped into insanity, trying to get Dogdays' blood to draw with. Catnap found them. Craftycorn was then killed and fed to Picky Piggy. Dogdays was torn in two and tortured(its around here that Piggy would have died) until the player finds him.

[@Squigglychild]

Good points. I never thought of that

[@zeblobyt]

1:00 "smiling assholes" that caught me off guard 💀

[@DiamondCreeper2007]

SMILING A- Dogday: hell nah you did NOT just call us the a word Catnap: make them sleep 😈 Dogday: wait how tf am I alive right now

[@LAMXINRUIMoe]

Yeah 💀

[@elishahardwick7164]

I love how blunt he was and that he changed what he called them throughout the video

[@leannemawson7349]

I WAS GONNA SAY LOL.

[@DianeOto]

Me eather i did not know that

[@Corrupted_LOL]

In my opinion the only one whose most likely alive is between: CraftyCorn: The screams were most likely her killing someone rather than dieing Bobby-Bearhug: She is telling you (the player) to help her and not leave her hinting shes somewhere in the factory waiting for someone (most likely us) If one of them is alive? CraftyCorn: Prob as a boss trying to kill us for more red paint Bobby-Bearhug: new allie ^o^

[@_theexticsphia_9505]

ok here is a theory of what happened to all the critters. this takes place after "the hour of joy", now that they killed all the employees they had food. Buba Bubbaphant's death - I'm guessing what happened to him because we don't have much lines from him. So he probably was talking to a toy, an employee, or us about what he remembers about them. I'm expecting picky piggy ate Buba Bubbaphant, as for he didn't say anything that rebels against the prototype. Kickin Chicken- after days or months without food, his friends started going insane. He probably to go out to find food or to escape the toy factory. I guess the prototype or catnap found him and ended him (or fed him to picky piggy). Picky Piggy- She was starving to the fact that she would eat anything or anyone. In her cardboard cutout she states that she ate grilled chicken, seared elephant, and flayed unicorn. This shows that she ate Kickin Chicken, Buba Bubbaphant, and CraftyCorn! Then she talks to somebody saying if they would like to be friends ( probably a trap, she wants to eat them too). Hoppy Hopscotch- This took me awhile to think of a reasonable theory as for this theory of her is actually the most reasonable! She could be trying to escape with a toy or a smiling critter ( Maybe it could be Kickin Chicken, or a human? give me a person who could be someone she could have been talking to). But catnap or the prototype killed her while she was jumping? Bobby Bearhug- She could have gotten lost while trying to escape or find help, she maybe was finding someone or something. She asks us to not leave her, she could be alive and hiding in the factory in the levels below. but i could be wrong... CraftyCorn- CraftyCorn's voice lines are complicated... But i've got 1 theory! She talks about paint to a toy with her. She asks for some colors. She asks for red, and more red, then it ran out. What if CraftyCorn is referring to food? She tells the toy that she knows they are hiding more food from her, therefore she harm or unalived the toy and ate them or the food they have been saving? then she states that she felt much better after the scream, but even tho she didn't scream at the end of her voicelines she was eaten by picky piggy... Or she is also still alive like bobby bearhug and is hiding too. DogDay- Maybe after seeing all his friends die or run away, he tried escaping. Catnap got him and tore his legs, thats why his screams where more longer as for he was still alive. I hope in the next chapter we could see atleast 1 alive smiling critter! Like dogday or Picky Piggy o BobbyBearhug? Lets see if any of my theories could be correct? But thanks for reading

[@aarushgajbhiye2357]

Amazing i had the same opinions👍🏻

[@neoxoull]

I was thinking maybe her and picky piggy were together and they started going insane from hunger and CraftyCorn tried to kill Picky Piggy, but failed and ended up being eaten instead. I could be wrong though.

[@_theexticsphia_9505]

@@neoxoull that theory does make sense!

[@youraveragegameriguess]

@@_theexticsphia_9505dogday could been helping kids or employees to run so they can escape from the playcare or factory and dogday prob sacrificing his life to help them escape (too bad that they are too late lol) and catnap saw this and decide to tore dogday legs and torture him for helping or encouraging people to escape

[@Yume-AW]

The most common theory for Hoppy is that she died to fall damage or something, but I kinda agree with your theory more.

[@Sun_Real_40]

You can hear bubba break character while he dies. If you pay attention he yells for his grandma. edit: yay I’m one of top comments thanks bubba. Edit 2: guys what if catnap was the reason for gas attacks in ww1?

[@ptero6606]

i thought he said "grab on"

[@beastman302]

bubba has a grandma confirmed

[@Sun_Real_40]

@@beastman302 grandma bubba 😳😳

[@eldiepalacol9269]

"AAAAAAAAH.. GRAND" (lagging) "MAAA... *dies*"

[@DinobEpic67]

I thought i was the only one who thought that bro i thought i was crazy

[@Star19532]

10:12 "Craftycorn says we cant go outside." Craftycorn a few seconds before: "More red please! Out? We cant be out!(Of red paint)" How does anyone come to the conclusion that the player just changed the topic to "hey, can we go outside?" When being asked to give red paint?

[@Golden-berry]

It's obvious that after 10 years, the pig ate. Some of the other clones of the smiling critters. And the others went mad.

[@Iaminsideyourwalls208]

1:30 you gotta remember by now that the smiling critters once contained the catnap character before he was erased from the line and taken out of the character’s TV show meaning that Catnap although once considered a smiling critter is technically no longer one

[@Walmart_Gojo-u4z]

Fact: the main villain of chapter 4 is daddy long legs because when chapter 1 released there was huggy wuggy that was tall and in chapter 2 we had an spider and in chapter3 there's an very tall cat and so did y'all feel anything? Because Like 2 chapters done then it was an spider just imagine if another 2 chapters there must be another spider

[@rahulbangladesh]

All of them are scared except the pig that means…and crafty corn was smart but she got really angry and she screamed and then.we know what happened half of poppy playtime is full of prototype wordshippers and if u guys didn’t know Theo was an orphan who had a strong connection with the prototype even drawing him in purple with black hands under his bed so he turned into catnap…

[@Tigerkatfluff]

What if the prototype is freddy Kruger.

[@Sun_Real_40]

😳😳😳😳

[@RebeccaHall-g3g]

Maybe 😂😂😂 lol

[@totally_notjesse101]

this isnt part of the lore but a cool detail is that the coloured crayons in the vhs matches the colours she says in her button where she uses blood as paint

[@Chikesedit]

Picky Piggy and BearHug aren't Dead Piggy Ate the Smiling Critters that was killed by Cat Nap And Bearhug is Hidding somewhere really Hidden I'm sure we'll see her in Chapter 4 her and Piggy Piggy might be the One that Attacked Kissy

[@Yooreek-the-orange-whale]

They definitely went insane

[@RandoinVR]

Imagine a monster that would be all the smiling critters (except for dogday and catnap) mangled together like something tried to make something out of them but failed

[@chrystinesheffield8662]

Cough prototype cough

[@RandoinVR]

@@chrystinesheffield8662 I was thinking one of catnap’s shrines or an attempt at making a shrine

[@ivanmonev1492]

You don't get it. CraftyCorn killed the guy who helped her. And when she was saying ''out? but.....we can't BE out'' she meant it for the PAINT. She never mentioned going outside :/

[@NuggetGuy_X]

Most critters died while saying their cardboard cutouts: DogDay was trying to telk us to leave in his cutout then the prototype got him and their tortured him in his cutout by cutting off his legs you can hear it while he screams. Kickin' Chicken was killed by the prototype as soon as he tried to take a step out. Hoppy tried to jump to the moon but feel from a high place probably. Bubba probably figured out everything then the protoype sent Catnap to kill Bubba. CraftyCorn probably was told about the prototype and everything since Bubba would usually be with her and Catnap killed her. PickyPiggy was the last to die excluding Catnap and DogDay, because when she found the dead bodies and she was already starving so she ate them since they were already dead and then was either killed by Catnap or the Prototype or died of starvation. BobbyBearhug was all alone so she probably was killed by Catnap or The Prototype

[@NuggetGuy_X]

After the events of all killing of the people in Playtime Co. The Critters had to listen to the Prototype or die Kickin' Chicken broke the rules and walked out of the area and the Protoype killed him, Bobby survived because she went to hide after we left Playtime Co. now that we came back she wants to come with us, and CraftyCorn kept asking for more red meaning blood, she killed one of the Critters which was what the screaming was about but she wasn't eaten by PickyPiggy,

[@Ashie_kit]

1:02 best words!!

[@mrverycold]

Agree😂

[@Damietroblox]

Sooo true

[@D0gn4p_and_cr3w]

Lol yes😂

[@Callm3Van3ssa]

the way be said "smiling a$$holes"😂 Made me dying on the floor 1:02

[@your_ph1a]

All deaths👇 Picky piggy: starvation (maybe dead) Bobby bear hug: alive but alone Bubba bubbaphant: eat an alive by picky piggy Crafty corn: eaten alive by picky piggy Kickin chicken: eaten but not alive by picky piggy Dog day: mini smiling critters took him over (screaming from cutout was catnap ripping his legs off) Hoppy hopscotch: died from catnap while trying to “jump” to the moon Catnap: prototype Extra deaths-👇 Huggy wuggy: falling from height Kissy missy: unknown maybe not dead Mommy long legs: from crushing machine 😈😈 And that’s all I know lol-

[@OussamaBihaouargui]

Bobby bearhug and kissy missy 😅 others 😵😵😵

[@edryanangeloDiamante-el8qn]

Bro violated the critters by saying "smilling assholes"💀💀💀💀💀

[@PokeGod4445]

" And it's not a fucking dream, it's reality" got me cracking up

[@timeadobak-kiss4356]

1:01 "But his body was captured by smiling @ssholes" was personal.

[@Justanormallittlecloud]

Yessss😂

[@timeadobak-kiss4356]

@@Justanormallittlecloud ❤️❤️❤️

[@angelynraboy4228]

"Dogday seems to be kind, but his body was captured by smiling a$$holes💀"

[@For_fun_305]

The stupid little critters

[@D0gn4p_and_cr3w]

😂😂Man I'm dead😂

[@alvarox951]

I have the theory that the critters dialogs are stuff they told you as a kid from the Playcare, and during the happy hour Kickin, Hoppy and probably Dogday wanted to help you escape the place (via some games like fetching and jumping)

[@esacausby5668]

Here's my thing, I've seen videos of people saving both Dogday & Craftycorn. So, I wouldn't want to say they're "ALL" dead, really. 🧐

[@Silly_gacha_gurl]

Picky piggy might have died from eating herself because everyone else was dead except for dog day and catnap and she didn’t want to eat catnap and maybe catnap already took dog day hostage and just made him hang there and she might have been referring roast beef with apart of herself…

[@wolfegirl30ful]

That's made from cow-

[@MichelleHatton-x9j]

When crafty say your hiding more red she means your blood

[@nymphiachan5822]

I think Bobby bearhug and PickyPiggy survive… But I think PickyPiggy is kind of… Like, not just surviving in the factory, and also eating her own friends or something. And Bobby did like was Hiding somewhere…

[@Epicduckys]

Well that could be a theory but everyone was dead bc of catnap

[@RolandoAlcantara-o6n]

Maybe how Bubba died Will Be Catnap, The 1006 Or miss delight.. Bobby bear hug saw this. He went into the tunnel And Catnap Maybe Ripped his arms

[@nymphiachan5822]

@@RolandoAlcantara-o6n Bobby is female…

[@justice8718]

What if Bobby was the orphan the protagonist wanted to adopt, so out of everyone, Catnap was most familiar to you who knew how much you meant to her. Catnap was the most hesitant to attack you out of all toys in Poppy Playtime, even Kissy Missy.

[@RolandoAlcantara-o6n]

@@justice8718 It's Almost true

[@Gachakid56Doodooohead-rv7rc]

The way he said "dog day was captured by the SMILING A$$H0LES and devourd" got me dying XD

[@Farmer_Sprout]

BLUD THE SONG IS THE DANCING TOOTHLESS LMAO

[@starboy0714]

look closely how they sleep that is their death positions most likely

[@Zamandla18]

i can't believe catnap died because his own god

[@BeeRue]

What If It Was Puppet Insted Of Dogday Wait Oh God That Would Be Disgusting But Cool Can Someone Please Make A Animation Of Dogdays Death But Its Puppet Insted Of Dogday

[@SelebriusX]

wat

[@MichaelGill-mz1pw]

I wonder if all the smiling critters died during the hour of joy and dog day was chained up and cant escape because he has no legs and can crawl slowly

[@ACatWithABallOfYarn]

I can also see that Dogday is not only laying like he does in the game, but his legs are also covered... Proving the point that his legs are going to get torn off. 😰

[@Sxuarae]

The company Rosies playtime which was the real company was founded in 1936 the zeaglers which what the critters were called are still alive but all died alone chained up the in 2009 the company was abandoned somewhere and the main protagonist angel was named Samantha Lopez explored the factory and already defeated to prototype was torn apart and exploded into peaches which all the toys fell all over the floor then she escaped the factory leaving poor shinypup/dogday left behind but fiery giraffe the critter from the garden/zoo is the main villain in irl I wonder if mob intertainment might not add him in chapter 5

[@FishSticksSkin.]

It looks even creepier with PickyPiggy

[@sabrinejovellanos5870]

0:04 smiling creatures got me rolling on the stairs 😂

[@wolfie_sunlight2475]

He’s trying to sound serious as possible at this game and video when he’s just playing the Night fury song in the background😂

[@DeanBeanW0W]

Is not from the toothless meme but it be came poplar by it

[@Yume-AW]

It’s a text to speech voice. He isn’t speaking. It’s the AI.

[@loveytemara1061]

So remember when dog day said fetch he's meaning leave kickchicken remember him saying I step out first he's saying leave to

[@yadielquesada5782]

Maybe in chapter four we might see picky piggy and bobby bearhug

[@hatsuki_glit3h18]

I am sorry, but I started laughing when you called the ruining smiling critter plushies 'smiling @$$#0l3$'

[@IsupportTherians604]

Okay so I was investigating further and I found out these deaths! KickenChicken tried to escape but the prototype caught him Bubba Bubbaphant was at the front on the show so he died from the gas Hoppy hopscotch was not paying attention to her feet while she was jumping so she jumped of a ledge Picky Piggy is still alive but it is believed she tried to eat her friends Bobby Bearhug she recognized us because we left and we just came back “take me with you this time?” Means she wants to get out like said in the vid Catnap in the board actually was the boy he had lung cancer and the purring was him trying to breath as he was turned into one of the smiling critters if u listen further it shows him changing his pitch because he was a kid just trying to escape then he got injured by electrical wires and that’s why he couldn’t breath. Dogday, well we know how he dies but just in case he was possessed by tiny small smiling critters going into his insides slowly merging into DogDay Crafty Craftcorn in case you don’t know she is still alive, see the paintings on the wall from chapter 1? Those are from her, telling us the truth about poppy, she’s trying to protect us from going to whatever mystery poppy is leading us too…. HOPE THIS HELPS!!!

[@Hart_dragons]

After 10 times watching the trailer from the smiling critters I just found out that dog day is the main😅

[@Your_Local_Artist_Echo]

Remember if you hear the cardboard cut out audio and it doesn’t glitch or scream at the end their still alive.

[@Editking676]

First we have smiling creatures then we have smiling @$$holes after that we have smiling animals and dog day’s STORYS?💀💀 (Dog day told only one story)

[@Rajd_is]

Rule one of storytelling. If you don't see a body, they ain't dead Kreekcraft 2024 (Poppy Playtime Chapter 3 Release Livestream) Which means, we don't know if DogDay is actually dead. We know CatNap is.

[@JMarquez15]

I know what happened to hoppy hopscotch, when she was jumping and she finally made to the moon until she fell to her demise I know what happened to crafty corn she was just saying red paint not blood but catnap has the paint she said give it here until catnap snap and started killing her on purpose I know what happened to picky piggy, she was doing a joke and she was actually eating some normal food and then when she was done catnap gets her and then kill her I know what happened to the dog days legs his legs was caught off and then catnap hide it for dog day can't find his legs and you can also save dog day if you think i got it all right like because this took me so long❤ 👇

[@cinnamonroll-wd5bf]

But she said much better at the end

[@JMarquez15]

@@cinnamonroll-wd5bfwho said at the end?

[@POKER742]

I think that Picky Piggy was kept alive. She sided with Catnap so she would be able to eat and not starve. Picky Piggy was fed her friends by catnap. The ones she didn't talk about was the ones that she wasn't fed.

[@SAMURAI_-ml3qm]

My theory about CraftyCorn maybe she is just somewhere else starving but how did he survive for years? if she's starving if i think CraftyCorn is really behind DogDay the wall behind DogDay may the room behind DogDay is dirty and Crafty is also dirty thats all bye.

[@camiuribeg]

I have a theory .maybe pickypiggy was hypnotized by catnap and eated kickenchicken when he steped outside,killed craftycorn when she finished her painting,and bubba bubbaphant he said "hey i remember you" voice line

[@The_baddie_is_back]

There’s a smiling critters, not creatures🧟

[@Atlas_TAOG]

I Hope Bobby Is Alive, And Appears To Help You In Chapter 4 - 5 And Escape With The Player, Kissy, And Poppy!

[@Farmer_Sprout]

Yall know that the qords written in the vents and at the end of chapter one u can see some words written from crafty corn yk cuz she likes to paint and draw

[@Wafflenotfound]

“smiling *creatures* ” 💀

[@D0gn4p_and_cr3w]

CRITTERS!! SMILING CRITTERS!!

[@brooklynnsantana2631]

@@D0gn4p_and_cr3w thank you!

[@kairidunphe3262]

Or SMILING ASSHOLES? 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀

[@rylie2014]

Wait toothless meme song at the background?????? Man this is so random

[@alyssanicoledanao-ui9db]

1:03 "Smilling asshole" I laughed so hard😂

[@PurpleMaskSiblings]

What I think happened to the Smiling Critters BubbaBubbaphant: I don't really know much because he has the shortest voiceline but I know 1 theory, you can hear BubbaBubbaphant laughing and screaming at the same time, I think he inhaled the red gas and fell asleep and then CatNap killed him. KickenChicken: In his voiceline he says that he has never been outside and tried to go and step out first then you can hear him screaming. It might be because that the Prototype killed KickenChicken because Poppy said that if you leave the PlayCare the Prototype will catch you and emidiently kill you. PickyPiggy: We know that she ate some of her friends and those are KickenChicken, BubbaBubbaphant and CraftyCorn. I think I know why, I think she tried to eat her friends (her friends dead bodies) to survive but she also says that she is still hungry so she starves to death. HoppyHopscotch: On Hoppy, I think he tried to escape with someone or was just playing? Listen to her voiceline, she says "No! Don't look at you're feet! None of it matters!". I think she fell to her death because she didn't see whe're she was jumping to because she says looking down doesnt matter. BobbyBearHug: BobbyBearHug was probably lost and starved to death or I think she was killed by CraftyCorn because she needed Red, "More red, pls!" and she says "GIVE IT HERE! *static*" the *static* may mean someone was killed which is BobbyBearHug and her Blood was used as red paint for CraftyCorn. DogDay: We all already know (eaten in the insides and possesed) CraftyCorn: I think she was punished to death by her friends for killing BobbyBearHug(I think) because she needed red and used BobbyBearHugs blood as red paint. CatNap: Obviously the Prototype I don't think atleast one of them are still alive because DogDay says he is the Last SmilingCritter

[@sharonbyrne3174]

craftycorn is alive

[@loghan3715]

It is not conformed that the real dog day isn't dead or dead but he is possessed from the small smiling critters one went in his eye and there was no pupil in his eyes and when the critter in his eye he had White pupils so it might be true that the prototype took and killed dogday so if you do comment your reason

[@jordanobafemi8086]

What my head tells me that hoppy hopscotch got to the moon but lost balance and fell. That’s why she was like JUUUUU cause it sounds like she’s falling

[@AngieTheSilly]

My theory is picky piggy ate them…because of her dialogue tapes, is very clear that she ate her friends

[@BengermenFranklin]

DogDay did not survive As you made your escape the critters ate him from the inside leaving him lifeless and possibly a puppet

[@safansohaib]

The only bigger part initiative of kicking chicken is when dog day gets his legs back, which is actually kicking chicken legs

[@AzizAhmad-k1x]

It’s weird how in the hour of joy they don’t show any sneak peak of any of the smiling critters

[@nadiamushtaqm.mushtaq7430]

Well I think that pikky piggy, crafty corn and Babbage bear hug are still alive they are hiding some where in the factory and hoppy Hop Scoth and dog day were helping someone to escape from their dog day say you can't just stand their and hoppy say's jump when she says that she wanted to say jump but she can only say juuuu- then we hear scearming they both were trying to help some one well hoppy dies but in dog days voice line at the end we hear cutting legs and it fell down you are saying that they were trying to escape but they were helping someone

[@Wesmalshehab15]

Craftycorn says she wants red and blue and 🔴+🔵=🟣 and catnap is purple

[@daruxhassan5695]

The reason why those smiling critters were scared because picky piggy was eating them

[@abbiechinkerqimoe9103]

There is a way to help dogday! Just open the trapped hand…

[@Yurrilovesgreencolor]

"Smiling @ssholes" got me 😂

[@kennethnorris906]

For crafty corn what actually happened was she wanted more red but she thought that somebody was hiding the red from her so she killed one of the smiling critters and used their blood as red that’s why you heard screaming then after she said much better than she was either killed by piggy piggyor the prototype or catnap

[@randomer-v6y]

Hubba is alive! He just got gassed and chained up.

[@zeblobyt]

Proof/theory?

[@Justanormallittlecloud]

He did get gassed as he was screaming you could hear him laughing while screaming and yelled GRANDMA dieing so he is gassed but not chained he was raised by his grandma sad story right?

[@Justanormallittlecloud]

@@zeblobytso he was gassed…

[@Elizah-x9y]

"But his body was taken by smiling as*holes"🤣 oh and I think crafty corn killer one of the smiling critters and pretended their blood was red paint and in the scene as you click her button you hear a scream that I think does not sound like crafty corns scream.And for dog day his was pretty disturbing...plus you can hear a suspicious thud that sounded like something hit the ground which could be his legs being cut off and he screamed for a quite long time which sounded like he was being tortured by telling us to leave

[@DefokoAFK]

okay...I don't want to sound like a crazy person, because every time I mention my theory they take me for a fool and ignore me, I still wanted to share it here, it's about kickinchicken, I think I found some curious details... since it was confirmed that in the animation where catnap sleeps the others and the position of Dogday was a spoiler of how I was, I was wondering if something like that happened with others, and I thought that Kickin could be alive, as well as Dogday is covered in half, so he might mean that his legs ripped out. But why? Well, on his speaking poster his dialogues suggest that I try to escape with someone (probably another of the smiling critters like Dogday or Bobby) and that's why Catnap started his legs as a punishment of trying to escape ... He also says that never State outside what is rare ... Unless a child is also a child as well as Catnap so I think ... Catnap let smiling critters who were children and those who were adults the killer (like Dogday Bubba or crafty) And the legs of Kickin served as a food for Picky, that's why she says to eat chicken meat if she is referring to Kickin. That would explain why he screams as soon as his Pocision, like Dogday ... he may have been imprisoned in another location because he may not be considered a heretic like Dogday. and other things that I think is that Picky was on the side of the prototype for food. and maybe crafty too ... since the "red color" can be interpreted as "blood" or "food" so if she talked about food, then she must have been hidden with another entity, maybe Bubba, PICKY or a human (I think picky because in her Voice lines talk about eating Crafty, but she does not scream from agony, so I'm sure they were fighting for food revealing your location) 🤪🔫

[@vieneddiesongarcia-wz6rh]

Picky piggy is still alive (i think) she was starving so she saw her friends dead then she ate her friends but soon she will starve she says if you want to be friend in a creppy way so she maybe betray you if you become friends with her (Also craftycorn he asked for red red means blood when he asked for red she says it's out but you give it anyway but maybe craftycorn killed his own friend and gets her/his blood to paint) That's my theory plsss reach this comment to 50 likes

[@GummyGoberYT]

No pigy pigy is just saying all the dead friends because i think all the soul (and hopy hop shcopsokh jump of proff 7:48 he or she says jump 6x thats all i got :)

[@tiffanymiranda4376]

My Theory about Chapter 4: So when kissy missy gets attacked by something, when we go down in that hole, i do not know who attacked her. Probably a new monster? it could have been the prototype. Anyway, once we try going up the hole to help kissy missy, were too late and we have to go down to get out. And i think that picky piggy is the "something" down in the hole. I mean, he ate his friends, maybe he eats the dead humans that are down in the hole. The hour hour of joy thing is probably recorded by ollie and only Catnap, And dog day were the only ones who got out of the hole, BECAUSE THE PROTOTYPE OPENED IT FOR THEM! Maybe, the others wanted to stay in the hole and picky piggy ate them and bobby bearhug hid and we went down there to find him, i mean, somewhere in there we have to fight picky piggy, anyways, back to the main thing i wanted to say. We find bobby bearhug, we try to get out of the hole with poppy, and we eventually escape out of the hole. then, we show up in the front of the factory, like when we started at chapter 1, and kissy missy probably escapes too, and then we stop, but bobby bearhug escapes and gets killed by the prototype. then all of us get knocked out by the prototype and we all get trapped in a solitary confinement room and you probably know what a solitary confinement chamber can do, it makes you crazy. so kissy missy probably goes crazy and attacks the player and poppy.

[@zirkumtanatara1209]

IF you save the dogday he will tell you where is his friends his friends is dead if you save dogday he will found his legs and dogday will tell who kill his frinds

[@allentejada7681]

Remember, when crafty corn said, give me more red.Please bobby , barehug is red

[@Amsodumbbruh]

Am preety sure bubbo elephant and kickin chicken and hoppy hopscotch are still alive and maybe lose some of their body parts (agree with me?)

[@Epicduckys]

That is a great theory but they all scream at the end bc they were all killed by catnap

[@amongus9029]

@@EpicduckysDogday also screamed but he was alive.

[@Epicduckys]

@amongus9029 true but if you listen close you can kinda hear his legs getting cut off he is now dead

[@amongus9029]

@@Epicduckys So I think he is alive, he got only controlled, not eaten. We hear that he gurgles. So I think he is still alive, and some of the other critters also.

[@Epicduckys]

@amongus9029 that might be a theory bc I think everyone but picky piggy got killed by catnap picky piggy might have died of starvation

[@kingoscar5447]

Hoppy Hopscotch jumped from a high place and died. Her death was probably a suicide.

[@martintran6360]

i thought that craftycorn killed a smiling critter for their blood as "red".

[@Hurrlyandsockskayastella]

Kickinchikin didn't deserve to die he just wanted to hang out outside

[@BernardAgor-l1h]

Your vids are cool and great you have been giving people huges you have been a good guy you have been feeling bad for a lot of many days but we are here your supporting, subscribers and friends you are the best pet simulator 99 KZbinr or all games I know people are happy because of your personality good,great and other things I have watching your vids for 2 years but I know seens 2 years you have been a bad day

[@1ITSFLORALL]

You could actually save dogday and later on you see crafty corn she’s still actually alive! You could also safe catnap at the end isn’t that cool!?

[@icyboy8314]

Yeah i still think bobby bearhug is 100% still alive...shes probably hiding scared somewhere

[@Bw0mp_lmao]

0:01 Smiling Creatures is crazy

[@IAMABIGBIRD]

I laughed so hard when he said “Smiling Assholes”

[@ashleyhartley1576]

I think Bobby bear is most likely missing maybe locked up somewhere as a punishment😢

[@Squigglychild]

I'm hopeful that Dogday is still alive and Bobby Bearhug as well

[@Ccelix]

"smiling assholes" LMAO

[@joecaldwell446]

i have a theory how hoppy died. so we know he went to the moon, but when he reaches the moon, catnap was waiting for him. So CatNap grabbed him with his tail and threw him down, causing him to fall to his death. Edit: got a theory how dogday died to, so actually he didint die. But when we hear screaming, you may think it is dogday getting killed, well u are wrong, it cant be his cry, dogdays voice is alot smaller then the "smiling assholes" voices. so it has to be there cries.