Did arevaci player just kill all enemy generals?? LOL absolute madlad XD.. You gotta cover more of these replays where generals die joe, it really brings so much more excitement and finesse.
@Seth-zz4qd8 ай бұрын
Very interesting battle. Snacks and drinks for this one. Again army comps army comps are so critical and of course the settlement as well. Ardeii and suebi can have a lot of spear/hoplite units. Getae army comp is okay but so many units of cav can only get thru the gate and potentially cause havoc. But with inner keep tight roads much much tougher. Should’ve attacked simultaneously. Also attackers had archer superiority over defenders. For kush maybe send in slave infantry and save armored shotels and disciples for end game. Multiple cav units typically not good at end game with choke points at inner keep settlements. Entertaining battle. Joe I think you won in this siege because of tips and tricks and arrows galore. I enjoy the everyday sieges keepem coming bud! Commentary great as always.
@blobdinglet8 ай бұрын
This battle has got to be the most interesting one ive seen in a while. I really enjoy these battles where the defenders make some aggressive plays like arevaci did against getae at the walls, the micromanaging was great. + I have NEVER seen this many kills with balearic slingers before, arevaci player is an absolute menace! Note that this was also played on large unit size so 308 kills would prob be 500 with ultra unit size! Some crazy plays and stats.. imo getae took a ballsy risk with his army comp, i assume he was hoping to get inside and rampage with his cav. Nonetheless, keep up the battle replays joe, especially these!
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
Thank you very much, I am glad you enjoyed this siege. I can only cover the battles that are sent in, but I appreciate your support!
@AN-nt3uv8 ай бұрын
Danke! I mean, thanks for providing your community with continous great TW content.
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
My pleasure! More to come!! Also, could you send me a msg on discord? I wanted to ask you about something
@AN-nt3uv8 ай бұрын
@@joeonitproductions Sure, later today!
@ehudzechariahschmidt70368 ай бұрын
Great replay! I think it was a mistake on Getae's part to bring so much cavalry, especially going up against Ardei (a spear heavy faction). On another note, it's always great seeing Noble Fighters carving through enemy units!
@blobdinglet8 ай бұрын
I can kind of see the idea of getae's army ngl
@ehudzechariahschmidt70368 ай бұрын
@@blobdinglet how so?
@Seth-zz4qd8 ай бұрын
One possibility would have been to take over the gate rush cav in and hopefully trap archer/ slinger units outside inner keep. You’re right though cav not going to dare well against spear hoplite units. Another suggestion for garage would’ve been to attack simultaneously with his teammates and attack the other gate. Also hid the cav on the forest they came out too quickly…..
@ehudzechariahschmidt70368 ай бұрын
@@Seth-zz4qd that's a good point. I think cavalry would have been good against factions that aren't spear heavy though
@Enterprise4Life8 ай бұрын
I would have kept a archer unit in town center til the disciples moved in to absolutely destroy them
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
I would tend to agree with you.
@paulthegaull8 ай бұрын
when i build kush i tend to stack armored shotels and balance with sacrificial slave meat
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
That's how I see Kush played often. But those disciples, if used correctly, can cause a TON of damage!
@SNPtheinsaneone8 ай бұрын
never enough calvary someone should do an all cav seige or something like that good battle though
@michaelross47358 ай бұрын
Arrevacii did so well great defense ,glad to see the pike stacking kush player lose,great commentary JOE as usual
@mysandwichishere8 ай бұрын
Yea it felt great to beat a cheater
@RubberToeYT8 ай бұрын
Great battle, really enjoyed
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
👍
@ohnoa28 ай бұрын
theres funny army comp and then theres dacia.... If I was attacker, id quit ngl since its a huge handicap
@Lord.Uchiha_Madara8 ай бұрын
I love Arrevacii army camp
@blobdinglet8 ай бұрын
army comp* ?
@thomasjesson18888 ай бұрын
Great battle
@rickjames188 ай бұрын
In this case, way too much cavalry for such an attack.
@WuCaoXin8 ай бұрын
I haven't watched this replay yet, but I am looking forward to it after reading the comments. Down to the wire grind fests are my favorite to watch. Just a reminder, It's been five months since I sent you my replay. Any news on the queue for it to be commetated?
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
Oh shoot bud, I'm sorry I completely forgot. Did you post your replay in the HW discord by chance? Its way easier for me to keep them up to date in there.
@WuCaoXin8 ай бұрын
@@joeonitproductions No I did not, I can resend to you through email? But for now on, I will send it to HW. Edit: I posted the replay on HW Discord..
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
@WuCaoXin very cool, thank you
@peterderidder99228 ай бұрын
Verry nice battle Joe ! ! Verry enjoyable for sure ! In my opinion the attackers did verry well and with a combination of somme units they could have won. The defenders (tactic)focust themselves on defending the choke points . Think this is the most difficuld city's to attack because there so much towers... Attackers better should have focused there attack on multi of fronts and force the def to stretch there defence. Suebi was out of the game so it could have been done . Non fighting (waiting) units out of reach of that towers. Annyway GG to both teams ! ! but one question remains !? Why that player brought 6 cav units ??
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
That army comp was a bit confusing to see, BUT if used correctly on a more open road settlement, cav can obviously be devastating for an attacking army to get in behind the defenders' lines.
@peterderidder99228 ай бұрын
@@joeonitproductions Yes offcourse if you know how to use them ! Same like sally out somme like to do it but fail because they cant manage cav properly . You need to have patient and strike the wright moment with youre cav . Its always a good thing if you have a player in youre team who can do it properly. The attackers then must focus on 2 places . BTW greatings from BELGICA land of the euberons and nervia
@pa52878 ай бұрын
enjoyed watching but too much calv from attackers ....way too much
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
Fair enough
@wyattjenkins78988 ай бұрын
I’m sorry but nothing is more irritating in these videos then when joe gets biased and doesn’t like it when ppl use wall artillery or bring an extra skirmisher and just play the game😂 or even just bring MOBILE artillery inside the settlement to get shots on the defenders like you can’t be upset at that it’s part of the game lol.
@mysandwichishere8 ай бұрын
Ngl there are rules like 124 for a reason bro
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
@wyattjenkins7898 I comment on these replays because I find it fun to do so. Are you saying that you don't like when I give my opinions on battles or what people do in these sieges? I am glad that people are still having fun playing these TW games, I really am.....but at the end of the day, I'm not sure what your point is with this comment, other than to try and get a reaction from me?
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
@mysahdwichishere I do understand that other groups have expanded on the rule sets, but for me, I don't tend to cover those types of replays anymore. I am used to the normal rules 1/2/4 as you stated, maybe with the added max 7 same unit I came up with about 2 years ago lol.
@wyattjenkins78988 ай бұрын
@@joeonitproductions no just curious on your opinion of certain mechanics being used and maybe getting taken advantage of, they are just trying to win and have fun and using all the tools at their disposal…. I think some of these things are smart plays but you seem to down play it sometimes just curious why that is maybe you play by a certain set of rules when you play
@joeonitproductions8 ай бұрын
@@wyattjenkins7898 usual rules are 1/2/4 unless other wise specified. This is why I tell people to join discords. Why have more than 1 artillery? Why feel the need to have 7 units of pikemen? How is it fun to camp the VC for an hour? These are why basic rules are in place. I don't really care about an extra archer honestly. But 2 artillery pieces? What for? Also, yes I have a ruleset I play my battles/sieges in with all TW titles. I also don't play in random lobbies anymore, as I don't feel like dealing with the things mentioned above.