When Johnny Comes Marching Home/For Bales

[@kc8tby]

This song has such meaning for me. When I was 20 years old I came home from Vietnam. The US Navy Band was playing this song for us as we returned in Norfolk Virginia. I had lost 23 friends and was wounded myself. When I was granted leave to go home, there was nothing other than the welcome home from my family. The general public seemingly despised us. Period. The only return I remember is the playing of this song. It moves me to this day.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Thanks for your service, Soldier (Marine, I'm guessing?). And thanks for leaving such a moving comment (and subscribing !!). Nothing means more to us in the band than to hear kind words from the real troops. God bless and be well !

[@kc8tby]

@@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand Thank you and God bless! Keep the music flowing too!

[@johngee6700]

Thank you for your service. Please know the true American's appreciated and loved our soldiers as much back then, as we do today. 🇺🇲 NEVER FORGET🇺🇲

[@copernicus633]

So many Johnnys didn’t come home. And yes, our nation turned their backs on its homecoming ones. Think of the grief of parents and families of those who never came home, further made tragic by the indifference of their fellow Americans.

[@helenhighwater5313]

💖

[@Captain.Floppa]

I hope most people know that gay in this context means happy

[@georgewashington132]

wish we could go back to the days when that was the only meaning of that word.

[@FlyingTooFast]

@@georgewashington132 Same…

[@jimscaggs2422]

Yeah some LGBTQAEIOU person is asking who is Johnny and when will he be home and what time is the party.

[@BusterKitten]

it's a shame that it even has to be explained. A long time friend of mine is named Gay and once in a while she meets an ignorant soul who doesn't comprehend having a name like that.

[@jackmurphy3940]

Yeah I know that, but wish it didn’t mean what they are trying to make it mean, and the rainbow now it’s a symbol of being gay, but it actually means God will never flood the Earth again.

[@styanax141]

May all our civil war veterans North or South, Black or White Rest In Peace

[@jackmurphy3940]

Amen

[@jackmurphy3940]

And let us not forget.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

@@jackmurphy3940 What they said !!!

[@jackmurphy3940]

@@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand what they said? Who?

[@jackmurphy3940]

@GrayWolf2036 yep exactly

[@sully553]

God bless our American ancestors, and may we someday reflect their greatness!

[@soldatenproductions4587]

Indeed

[@tobystamps2920]

I think it’s important to keep these songs alive. It’s part of America’s heritage.

[@banzaist_YR]

Thank you very much to American brothers, southerners for such soulful songs! Your fan from Russia!

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Благодарность !!!

[@mr.somewhere2678]

Watching this on the Old Dixe Highway, Scottsmoor Florida 7/4/2021

[@chuaagga2830]

Ik where that is isnt there a shooting range on old dixie highway

[@cliffmays442]

The Irish song was about a man who comes back with no arms or legs, it was a song to warn against war.

[@Wotsitorlabart]

I am guessing by the 'Irish song' you actually mean the 1867 English music hall parody called 'Johnny We Hardly Knew Ye' - originally played on stage for comic effect.

[@rithvikmuthyalapati9754]

Yooo, it is here. Happy Independence Day 2nd South Carolina!

[@therabman_5606]

To my confederate cousins across the sea, the Ulster Scots blood runs in many of your veins the history and music we share should not be forgotten

[@BBHC2]

That AHhh! in the song at 4:42 gets me every time. Great performance and thank you.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Yeah. We love that too !

[@ColumbiaArchive1776]

Sad to hear you retired, but THANK YOU for enriching the entire Nation- (and beyond) with your Music!

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

We thank YOU. We sing the songs, but it's folks like you that have 'spread the word'....

[@finallythere100]

@@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand -mYour music ism fantastic. Is there another band taking your place? Many thanks.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

@@finallythere100 Not that we know of...

[@gavinb907]

Happy 4, God bless all our rebels and patriots, north or south

[@johngray2433]

From Scotland, A big thank you.

[@tophat8190]

Happy 4th, love yall !!!! 4th Texas Calvery descendant.

[@bryanthenderson1501]

"cavalry'

[@tophat8190]

@@bryanthenderson1501 always that one. Yes Sir, thanks for correcting me.. I bad, and you sir are good, thanks and everyone thanks you...

[@jmfa57]

I absolutely love the work you guys are doing. Many thanks and God Bless (from a Yankee.)

[@jackmurphy3940]

I like yanks like you.

[@solangekervella583]

I am a fan of your music, and of the history of the south of the USA I live in France and we really need motivation at this time thank you

[@OberstTeuton]

Officially the new best version

[@airpenguin6988]

I love your profile pic and name. ~A random Texan on YT

[@kenlandon6130]

Nah there's way better on youtube. honestly the instrumental versions are the best

[@FinalFront]

Stalag 17 version best

[@leoocta6510]

GREAT SONG! 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍📺🇺🇸

[@theozarkblacksmith9234]

When I was playing with the 52nd Regimental String Band this tune was one of our encore tunes at the end of the concert. Sadly, our conductor (Greg Todd) passed away 10 years ago next month. I really miss those days. Thanks very much for continuing the traditional music. I plan on attending the event at Shiloh in April. Perhaps, you all will be booked and attend also. Thanks again, and good luck!

[@itsnotme8047]

Love seeing this on the 4th

[@airpenguin6988]

Yo your profile pic is cool

[@itsnotme8047]

@@airpenguin6988 thanks

[@robertford8263]

@@airpenguin6988 your songs have a pep in the step, makes you proud to be the part of bad that God makes good ,there is joy in this singing, with zeal for what' cheers you up . Johnny came home to a homestead destroyed , his family scattered , crops burned ,still with joy he survived the evils of war ,with his positive mind, and zeal to overcome ,music from the heart that God gives is enough to preserve the soul spirit

[@taxistarmaker]

May all Americans remember that they are a great country under God. And wish the patriots win back the states. Greeting from Taiwan.

[@lewiemcneely9143]

Thanks, Neighbors, Happy 4th and it's been WAY too long since I heard this song. Thanks be to God that Johnny is home. GBWYall!

[@christydennis751]

Hello from Rock Hill, South Carolina! Love the Irish music with this!

[@RPM1776]

I’m south asian living in Florida this is my fav music

[@RPM1776]

The south is rising as America’s economic hub now, she has risen

[@velociraptor3313]

Fantastic! Greeting from Australia.

[@Brady10thTX]

Happy independence day 2nd south Carolina to bad the south doesn't have there own

[@theguide1192]

Truly this is legendary

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Truly kind of you to say so ! Thanks !!

[@sidahmedheros]

Greetings From Algeria . God Bless The 2nd South Carolina String Band . Pray For Manal Haboub She Died AT The Age Of 17 OF Heart Attack . She Was A Great Fan Of Your Songs .

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

رحمها الله

[@jamespetrovsky2774]

Keep up the great work guys! Happy 4th and stay safe and keep playing. I am actually reading The adventures of Huckleberry Finn right now and I love the book thought I would share this because it is sourhern.

[@lewiemcneely9143]

I read or rather reread Tom Sawyer a couple of weeks ago. Can't be beat and GBWYou!

[@Jubilo1]

Perfect for Independence Day this year especially!

[@rangertom2203]

best regards from AUSTRIA

[@freddykruger4499]

Thanks from Germany for this great Confederate-Song!!......in this bad times!

[@federicoseribelli3021]

Congratulations from Italy 🇮🇹🇺🇸

[@lagatita1623]

I am here because I'm enamoured of this wonderful band. But I also will pay my respect to those still dying for their country.

[@thomasschied6665]

There's at least a Guy, in France, who's listening to your songs ! Great job, Dixie !

[@luckyrebel3437]

Love it! Greetings from Germany.

[@zsoltpeter9234]

Best version ever heard. God bless the beloved south and the truelove upthera😁 Greeting from hungary

[@Heinrich22233]

This music from you guys just hit different, its sad to hear that you retired. Anyway greetings from Poland!

[@gaetanbeauvallet1583]

God bless you !

[@chuaagga2830]

God bless Robert E Lee

[@bemotivated8443]

God bless the south

[@airpenguin6988]

Amen!

[@chuaagga2830]

Ty for hearting

[@Eeek183]

Great stratagist

[@chuaagga2830]

@@Eeek183 I agree

[@s.f.n.4491]

God bless the south

[@seand9852]

Going to buy a cd, what gives you the most direct money?

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Bless you ! Take yer pick: Amazon, Spotify, iTunes, CD Baby... There's plenty to choose from ! THANKS !!!

[@JohnBrown-rg7ug]

I would love to see this in person !

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Too late. We've retired. Sorry.

[@jimnorbert21]

Awesome! Man carry on!

[@ПавелНовиков-х3б]

I remember good old Die Hard, used to be a hit in Russia. Thank you for this magnifiscent song!

[@Sharps.50]

From an English Rebel , The South Will RISE AGAIN , 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Already has, friend...

[@CalvinCoolidge24]

Meanwhile every southern state ranking rock bottom in education and economy:​@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand

[@marcojacintodecamillisbuen3935]

Very Good!

[@jonas4732]

I love this song so much

[@pineapple0748]

I LOVE YOUR GUYS MUSIC YOUR MUSIC IS THE ONLY MUSIC I LISTEN TO!

[@GutoKowalski70]

You were great as always! Greetings from Brazil. ♥️

[@WhiteLeviathan]

Great videography and live performance audio once again! You guys are great!

[@jimstewart6587]

Cool song

[@MakeNumismaticsGreatAgain]

Thanks so much! Keep the vids coming!

[@johnogrady7440]

lets goooo been waiting for ages for this

[@jaxsongambill4063]

if im correct the band sang a mix of for bales, johnny comes marching home north version and south version. thats pretty cool

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

BINGO ! Thanks !

[@jaxsongambill4063]

@@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand no thank you

[@FinalFront]

Great

[@readingthroughhistor]

Have you all ever made high-quality instrumental versions of your music? We will be needing good, slow, instrumental music for background music for videos in our Civil War video series. I would be very interested in knowing if you have ever done this before.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Yes, we have. You can reach out to me at [e-mail] or thru our Facebook page Messenger. Look forward to hearing from you...

[@bootpringle7241]

I'd love to hear you guys do a version of "I love to be a soldier" by bobby horton

[@tombankwel4822]

Listen to your 🎶 music and have a Nice glass of bourbon makers mark 🥃 or Jack daniels thats Nice i AM 70 years old and love 🤟 your 🎶 music 🤟 😊 from tom

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Thanks for listening. Try a glass of 'Rebel Yell' sometime. I've been told it wins all taste tests, hands down. I like it !

[@tombankwel4822]

Thats a Nice drink, when Johnny comes home to his love a beautyfull colleen with deep blue eyes wow and black irish hair in green hills of eire

[@tombankwel4822]

Thank you so much for your feedback you Are real gentlemen and a gemstone to this wonderfull 🎶 music May god bless you All always from tom your friend always 🤩

[@ajmickey7280]

"So what kind of music are you into"? Me: it's complicated

[@Mukspsychosis]

all yall being soo supportive is great

[@danielalmeida3064]

I love your music! You wouldn't sell any vinyls of your music by chance?

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Thanks a lot ! We love to hear that and we love our fans ! Sorry, tho'. No vinyls....

[@johnogrady7440]

when will this be on spotify

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Should be already - "Lightning in a Jar"

[@douglasnolan4494]

Sometimes the simplest things are best.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Amen to that !

[@taufeeqkhan2629]

I am fan of this band from India

[@jaanuskrevald5456]

Howdy y'all greetings from Estonia damn keep the old tales high hiostory and so on, keep the flag high mates! and SKOL for IRISH too HUURAAH!! HEY! if i ever visit your continent! i am there for good old stuff :D prepare the burboun!

[@chuaagga2830]

Happy 4th

[@orfeo793]

who is the maker of that beautiful large tambourine that your percussionist plays? they seemed popular back in the 1800s based on the art and photos of the period I've seen, but modern makers are few and far between it would appear

[@iorgen1684]

это прекрасно!

[@ANIND123]

how do you learn songs, are you playing off of sheet music. Im a classical violinist and im interesting in playing civil war era tunes on period instruments

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Lucas, virtually all of our stuff was learnt by ear (not including the lyrics). You can find copies of original sheet music online via the Library of Congress - 1.Lester S. Levy Collection of Sheet Music levysheetmusic.mse.jhu.edu/index.html check out Box 17 through 25 2. Music for the Nation American Sheet Music memory.loc.gov./ammen/ check out Performing Arts/Music Sheet music 1820-1860 3. dl.lib.brown.edu/sheetmusic/afam/index.html

[@ANIND123]

@@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand thankyou so much

[@sleepover7645]

I was born in NY but raised in GA, god bless the south, I just got into civil war reenacting recently

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Good for you ! You won't regret it.

[@sleepover7645]

@@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand nop I won't regret it, I have always been interested in the civil since I was 8 and now I'm 14, not many people my age do civil war reenacting

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

@@sleepover7645 I too became interested... no, fascinated by the War Between the States from 4th or 5th grade... in 1949... (do the math, dude...) :O)

[@sleepover7645]

@@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand what do you mean

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

@@sleepover7645 How old I am... (by comparison...)

[@juanferco8397]

Dude this john never come

[@jackmurphy3940]

Hahahahaha

[@UglyLazyBastard]

Did THE CLASH covered this ( Give em enough rope LP) ? anyway , great music , lovely southern atmosphere. Cheers from Venice (North Italy)

[@fastsetinthewest]

Johnnie needed help getting home. All my family through the generation have the middle name of Lee in tribute to General Lee. Chickamauga and other places are where my ancestors fought for Independence. Eaglegards...

[@nomadpi1]

All of the males, in my family, have the name, "Ruedell, " since the 1700s, in tribute to a man who crossed the Appalachians, and lost his wife and children to Indian murderers.

[@jjsmith7707]

All I got to say is nice.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Thanks again, JJ. We have more ! Please subscribe & click on the ‘notifications’ bell, so you won't miss any new releases ! kzbin.info/door/6RHX6u-WDoS0EuMgIyfHrA

[@davidjohansson113]

Is this Gettysburg festival/celebration?

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Yes. 155th Anniversary reenactment of the Battle of Gettysburg - 2018.

[@Brady10thTX]

God bless America and GOD BLESS THE CSA

[@Jacob-fk7fx]

Somebody please tell me the other tune played in this melody. I’ve forgotten the name for years

[@Jacob-fk7fx]

It’s the part played at the beginning and end of “when Johnny comes marching home”

[@imperialguard28]

Never heard this version of it🤔

[@themischeifguide]

That was a riled up crowd.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Aye, that is was. It had been advertised as being our last live concert - possibly ever. The following year's Gettysburg event (156th) was completely unexpected at the time - and it was the last of its kind after a 25 year run. Too bad. "Progressive"" PC/Cancel Culture...

[@jackmurphy3940]

Is this a yankee song? I thought it was used by both sides.

[@joemam6405]

Both sides have versions of this song,the only difference are the lyrics In this case,this song is For Bales which is a southern version of Johnny Comes Marching Home

[@jackmurphy3940]

@@joemam6405 “bales??”

[@joemam6405]

@@jackmurphy3940 A satirical variant of "Johnny Fill Up the Bowl", entitled "For Bales" or, more fully, "For Bales! An O'er True Tale. Dedicated to Those Pure Patriots Who Were Afflicted with 'Cotton on the Brain' and Who Saw The Elephant", was published in New Orleans in 1864, by A. E. Blackmar. -got it from wikipedia

[@jackmurphy3940]

@@joemam6405 uhhhhhh, right.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Apparently, Jack, you eschewed pushing the "SHOW MORE" button right under the song's title... ? Should you ever revisit the video, check it out. I think I can safely say, what's written there is 'a bit' more explanatory than DoomFist's effort above (although he did manage to hit many of the high points). Thanks, btw, for watching and listening.

[@Кирилл_Тихонов]

Отлично! Глядя на вас, мы видим настоящую Америку! (А не ту, что говорит из Белого дома).

[@eboneezeradams1821]

We might need new music Dave, for a new war. No one seems to know that it has already started.

[@dorianmarch5811]

May that disastrous event never be repeated!

[@lorenzobosisio3838]

Johnny I hardly knew Ya, same song different end

[@crawwwfishh3284]

He don't talk like a southern man.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Well, that's 'cause he ain't one. Sorry.

[@crawwwfishh3284]

@@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand That's okay . He sings great songs just fine. He just doesn't have that southern slang.

[@olskool3967]

SC confederate here, will be till i go under,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

[@crawwwfishh3284]

Georgia REB.

[@Ilovechocolatelabs]

Texans always turn em!

[@zafer3973]

Plase play istiklal marşı

[@Stive-v8m]

The confederacy always followed the constitution. Slavery would have ended like europe over time peacefully. The union victory is why America is on its death bed now . Dixie is my homeland though in exile thousands of miles away.

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Thanks for your comment 'S'

[@nathanbond8165]

Such BS if they had actually followed the Constitution the very first line in the Constitution says that all men are created equally in the eyes of God therefore and also the Bible condemned slavery so the Constitution condemns slavery and the Bible condemned slavery and yet they still insisted upon using slave labor and then even after slavery was legally abolish the South institutionalized racism Jim Crow laws sharecropping to further economically enslaved black people your comment is simply incorrect the fact of the matter is is that white people loved free labor and they would make any excuse to have free or close to Free Labor just like we're letting millions of poor desperate Brown Latino people into this country to enslave them as well the soil of this country is red with blood of the innocent and enslaved and genocide plain and simple no you had nothing to do with this neither did I I'm not mad at you nor am I seeking revenge or punishment I'm just stating simple facts😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@GeremiasVi]

+1 comment

[@remissrain9207]

The 4 dislikes are Yankees

[@pervysage599]

even yanks should like this

[@pervysage599]

at least a little bit of it

[@eboneezeradams1821]

READ ^^^

[@kazakhstanenjoyer8487]

Q errar Q bush

[@kukuri007]

Irish?

[@2ndSouthCarolinaStringBand]

Seems like...

[@winkywark6505]

God Bless you!