Which College QB is the Best Fit For the Giants in the 2025 NFL Draft?

It seems like the Giants are ABSOLUTELY going to be drafting a quarterback in the 2025 NFL Draft. Which one is the best fit? Cam Ward, Shedeur Sanders, someone else entirely? Who would you take if you were Joe Schoen and had the first overall pick? #2025nfldraft #nfldraft #nfl #giantstalk #giants #newyorkgiantsnews #newyorkgiants #football #footballpodcasts #podcast #camward #shedeur
Make sure to subscribe to Giants Collective for new roundtable episodes every week, live, at 8pm ET.
You can also hear every episode of Giants Collective wherever you get your podcasts!
Apple bit.ly/48fjEzU
Spotify spoti.fi/4eSf6BM
Amazon Music amzn.to/4dQZdKR
And make sure to follow the whole squad here:
Baddog Sports: bit.ly/4dVWzn3
The Entertainah: bit.ly/4hg3biT
NYG Fan Girl: bit.ly/48gUv7M
Fireside Giants: bit.ly/3YdW16e

[@hisuiangengar8169]

Cam Ward 👍🏻 Jalen Milroe 👍🏻 Shedear Sanders 👍🏻 Quinn Ewers 👎 Carson Beck 👎

[@chandlerowens9620]

I love Milroe but I don’t think he would fit with the giants and being in a start now scenario

[@imbatman5882]

Sanders is what we need at QB.

[@ERizzo5]

Exactly!

[@austinbrown1672]

My favorite quarterbacks in next year’s draft are Cam Ward Shedur Sanders Jalen Milroe

[@obiwonkenobi]

No shit

[@thepar7575]

You serious with Milroe. Giants should go after the free agent market.

[@kushmaster210]

Shedur sanders!!!!

[@kevv13]

SHADEUR !!!!!

[@zylander7139]

I would definitely like it to be Cam Ward! That's the guy we need!.

[@ceezy585]

Definition of a playmaker

[@nystateofmind1749]

Jones has a great personality how many wins did that get us

[@TommyRibs]

I would take either Ward or Sanders. Either guy would be a good pick.

[@smoothbee9951]

1- SANDERS 2-WARD

[@CharesWhite]

Its Cam Ward!

[@The24hrMessenger]

The next Steve Mcnair

[@stephlitt8814]

Cam Ward is that dude for us!! He's also a fit for the Saints too

[@trizzgreenery]

Cam ward is a good college QB if he gets drafted by the giants he will never be a good QB in the nfl let’s be real the jump from college to the nfl is beyond what any of us casual fan can ever imagine…

[@The24hrMessenger]

​@trizzgreenery So the jump for Ward is too big...but ok for everyone else

[@trizzgreenery]

@ nah bro it’s the same for all I was just talking about cam cause ima giants fan unfortunately and I like cam ward but if the giants draft him they gon ruin his career (my opinion)

[@Poppa_Reed]

Saints already drafted Rattler last year

[@Cvmanuel227]

I believe cam wards strengths balance out the giants weaknesses better than Sanders. He's better under pressure and he makes off schedule plays and off angle throws. And he is calm in a collapsing pocket, and he's a quick decision maker that scans the entire field and has a quick release. All the things Jones struggled with. Give me Cam easy

[@obamadidyourmom]

Idk I watch his game last week n he look petrified against that d line

[@Poppa_Reed]

Shedeur Sanders is waaay better under pressure. It's easy to say ward is good because he has a OLine but Sanders put up the same numbers without an OLine and he is always under pressure

[@kevv13]

SHADEUR !!!!!!!!!!

[@cthulhu8811]

I can’t believe I’m saying this but I would pick Sanders. But, I would be happy with Ward.

[@Locksmith92]

I'd take Sanders too. He got that DNA and I think he's determined to be great...He's always had the money so proving he's as good as prime was will make him a winner...

[@NatTurnergrandsonChrisdorner]

Exactly how I feel.

[@Poppa_Reed]

​@@Locksmith92exactly

[@ceezy585]

Cam is the definition of playmaking. I have to give him the slight edge. Shadeur throws the prettiest ball. Has to be one of the two or failure

[@davidriedy5977]

I think I prefer Cam Ward but I’ll be happy with Sanders. Even with the inevitable media circus; I’ll put up with that if the Giants are actually a winning team and Super Bowl contender

[@JeckMedina-u3c]

Killa cam!!

[@Shardekeoglesby3073]

Jalen milroe,,, all day,,, All way

[@BH02377]

No!

[@JimmyJudge]

Shedeur Sanders is raised to be a winner, Deion was transcendent talent . That's the safe choice,just like Manning..

[@juniegyllenhaal3937]

Buddy said trade for JJ McCarthy 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 as a Michigan fan I have no idea why JJ is so beloved by ppl. Gtfoh with that

[@RockyFresh1]

BRO LIKE WTF THAT IS A HORRIBLE IDEA LMAOOOOO😂😂😂

[@Keithwilsonjr757]

Being a canes fan, major thing with cam is he has to learn to take what the defense gives him. Too often trying to hit a home run when he should dead the ball to see another down

[@mirmir174]

It’s shedur Sanders

[@jc-xf7gx]

It's Cam Ward...reminds me of a young Warren Moon coming out of Washington with more moxy.

[@samuraix5359]

Drew Allar guys

[@Datnigacyf]

I feel cam ward has more upside but sanders is more polished right now and what I think will make the difference is sanders pocket presence

[@jcsquared1111]

CAM WARD!!

[@charlesamofordjuoh9940]

Plz take cam ward

[@thelakeman5207]

Cam Ward

[@bnycemusic4325]

Trading down for McCarthy is INSANE 😂😂

[@BIGBLUEGMEN]

The way sanders plays with his oline is what "yall" expected from DJ.

[@The24hrMessenger]

Hold the ball for 10 seconds and take bad sacks

[@kingjamesgorden3]

We are going to have 66m this offseason. Trade for Matt Stafford, spend to get a WR2 like Keenan Allen, a CB or two, maybe Honey Badger to mentor the young secondary, and another offensive lineman? If we don’t get a top 3 pick, why would we be reaching for anyone but Sanders? This draft sucks for QBs compared to recent years, but it’s deep in areas we need besides QB.

[@jameshollister8294]

Cam ward is good too ..no one wants a old QB

[@christophermannmanno6318]

I think that they might be targeting Sanders. Did you guys see the NY Post Sports interview with Sanders?

[@JamaalLawson-p3s]

Apparently Sanders doesn’t want to play for this ORGANIZATION Let that sink in!!! Or let’s find a way to blame DJ for that too!!!!

[@Null_Void_1]

There has no reports of the giants scouting Ward, its been reported Schoen has been to two GA and Colorado games, knowing how incompetent Schoen is i wouldnt be shocked if he drsfted Beck lol and to disagree with Chris, i dont dislike Sanders bcuz of his personality, he holds the ball too long and we just benched a kid not saying DJ is on Sanders level but he holds onto the ball too long, I personally want Ward nothing phases the kid just like Jayden

[@elijahmitchell8793]

Ward literally holds on the ball more than anyone lol

[@ceezy585]

They def are. Maybe schoen hasnt got to it yet. I bet hes at the miami vs cuse game this sat. Going there myself as a youtube scout.

[@athens_1psvr31]

The willingness to lose picks to get a QB over taking a loss on two Sundays is amazing to me. How far do you think or want to go?

[@deemyers6817]

Sanders welcom to #NyG ❤💨🙏🏿

[@obiwonkenobi]

Cam ward

[@kingdee7434]

Cam

[@Crytycal]

Ward or Sanders, if they aren't there for us take Will Johnson

[@chucklou7216]

Eli manning!

[@John_TalksGiants]

Cam or Shedeur.

[@mateussw93]

Just watched Milroe stink up the joint vs Oklahoma. Don’t want to see his name associated with the Giants. Thank you.

[@boricuacutta]

Its cam.. electricity... thats it.

[@rdijonbrundage7808]

You gots need to add Thejuke And Kb27

[@Tyrant5RDFL]

Either QB will do well for us, but this whole segment is a waste of time. There are 6 games left, and the Giants decided to start Tommy Devito, and the kid is going to get us wins. He played well last year behind a bad line, and no WR1. Now the line is better, and we have weapons. We will draft somewhere between 6-10. They should have started Lock if they wanted to play for a better draft position, but I can understand them wanting to win.

[@tsvimizrahi4667]

Milroe bear qb in nation hands down Miz. And he be star under dabbol of dabbol here. Miz

[@kamiloa5569]

Jalen milroe

[@kingdomcitizenship5613]

Either players career is over if they go to NY. Coaches are horrible. Trade back and get more picks

[@boofrisco]

Tommy Cutlets will win a few games and put the Giants out of the top 5 again. So I doubt there will a qb available.

[@The24hrMessenger]

You really forgot how he won those games last yr huh lol

[@BeastCoast4747]

Lol

[@Dylan-xs7lo]

Still think that?

[@76ersdodgersgiants74]

😂devito not winning nothing 😂

[@JasonMB11]

Doesn't look like he is, the team as a whole gave up.

[@dariusjones2593]

Sanders is good, I want Cam Ward, the Giants are very old school, we have never drafted a black QB ,think we the only organization, Giants have a type. Milroe would be QB 3 because he reminds me the most of Josh Allen

[@stephlitt8814]

I've been talking about Cam Ward since wk 5. Shedeur Sanders is Deon's son most likely will be a Cowboy or Raider. If Mara has any say he may get Sam Darnold as a free agent or draft that mediocre bum Carson Beck

[@Handsofstone-dy5qz]

Ward is weak in going through his progressions. If his initial receiver is covered he will start to run the pocket.

[@ChrisJones-jz6el]

Sanders is going to the Cowboys goodbye Dak 👋

[@phwaygodarhma2328]

Chris let others finish there sentence lol

[@strettoasino9006]

Anyone remember The 3 Jeff's, Hostetler and Rutledge? Both could throw a long 🏈 better than Simms.

[@Oneshotdee]

Can ward gives me Dwayne Haskins vibes.. I feel like he has high bust potential .. great college player not sure it’s gonna translate .. and his o line allows him to sit in the pocket for 5-7 seconds .. sanders comes from greatness .. sanders played behind a bad oline .. that’s what we need in nyc .. cam ward will come here behind this trash oline and probably play horrible .. but sanders plays with a bad oline as the norm so him coming to giants will be familiar territory

[@alexiscollazo4907]

Sanders holds on the ball too long and always takes bad sacks. Watch a Colorado game

[@Oneshotdee]

@ I’ve watched Colorado like 4 games and he’s not perfect no qb is.. he has his flaws just like cam ward has flaws .. that’s not the point .. I know this man is built for the bright lights.. this is NYC this ain’t the Tennessee titans lol we need guys that are gonna be built .. and shedeur is made for the bright lights big city

[@jameshollister8294]

Cam ward has family in the NFL too Diggs and jammer I don't see big deal his attitude is way better then most QBs especially sanders

[@jameshollister8294]

Sanders looks more like a bust to me and is elevated because his daddy

[@miguelbaez2728]

The Giants O-Line is not bad at all this year. idk wtf you on about. They give Jones a clean pocket, and he still does bs. Cam Ward moves and keeps driving alive with his O-Line, so he'll do fine in N.Y.

[@Handsofstone-dy5qz]

Sanders has too long of a delivery telegraphing his throws plus he mostly throws balls at the same speed making easier for NFL corners to time.

[@larrymeglino4059]

were still playing around with jj mccarthy? hes not the guy

[@Kinggdarian]

Why would you trade for a qb who’s coming off injury that’s Daniel jones all over again smfh

[@jameshollister8294]

Jj wlways w white boy huh

[@sharonwatts7905]

Ward

[@jameshollister8294]

I can never respect a player who throws teammates under the bus you just dont do that ... If you do it college you will definitely do it it NFL

[@carltonpenn6467]

Im taking jaxson Dart

[@toddmarble6217]

CLEARLY WARD!!! If we draft Sanders, it would be a SHIT SHOW From Day One!! Deon would inject himself into everything the Giants will be doing with his kid. I think it would be a major problem.

[@MrTreyshawn22]

Yall come up with the wildest scenarios smh not even believable

[@toddmarble6217]

Plus, Ward is better than Sanders! HARD STOP!!! Sanders has shown that he backs into sacks too much!!! And we are talking about the N.Y. Giants O.L. Here who gives up far too many sacks as it is! Ward is more polished and the intangibles are beyond what Sanders brings to the table. I'm praying the Giants pick Ward in the 2025 Draft!!

[@az8theist977]

Who the hell wants Sanders and that ridiculous circus show that comes with Deon???

[@jamesmccracken2542]

Winners want winners . Losers stay losing.

[@jameshollister8294]

I agree .his dad overated him just like ball brothers

[@MrTreyshawn22]

What circus? Y’all come up with the dumbest scenarios and run with them

[@king_gt7996]

CAM WARD as a huge Canes fan is not going to be a great pro. STOP looking at highlights and realize he has supreme offensive talent on that team and offensive line. That run around and buy time shit worked for Caleb in USC and does not in the NFL. Sanders is the better pocket passer, but I can give 2 shits that his father is Sanders and that will make him great because the NFL will push that. Dumbest shit this guy said. I think Ewers or Beck with a trade up into the first round is as good and we can use our top pick for an impact defensive player

[@Jakey_2]

Cam ward!!!! Shedur is mid I don’t see his skill set translating over to the NFL

[@TyStreets34]

Cam Ward process is not on the level with Sanders. Cam buying time is not the same same Sanders reading the defense at the line of scrimmage

[@robfromdowntown4117]

1 Sanders 2 Ward. There's not a 3rd qb on this class. Milroe is straight garbage Dart is young Daniel jones

[@MileyPitt-ee1wv]

Ward is a dual threat QB. Sanders is a pure pocket passer that holds on to the ball too long and takes unnecessary losses. It's not complicated.

[@Poppa_Reed]

Shedeur runs when he has to. You must not watch him play. He better than Ward. Put up same numbers as ward without an OLine

[@nystateofmind1749]

We need dogs not good personality

[@JimmyJudge]

JJ McCarthy 😂😂😂 , dude is a dumpster fire

[@nystateofmind1749]

We need someone who's confident someone who's outspoken having a quiet personality hasn't worked since Eli

[@BH02377]

No we don’t! We need someone who can win games, period!!

[@alexiscollazo4907]

I don't like this year QB class. Giants will be reaching again

[@jameshollister8294]

The way Williams a nix is playing definitely depends on COACHING but hey what I know I just know I never seen it it young are ar15 everyone desperate for QB play

[@kingdee7434]

This is why Giants lose this man think JJ is a good quarterback JJ is not going to be a good quarterback

[@nostradamusprophet3624]

Sad to say The giants is not drafting a black quarterback never happened never will giants gonna draft Travis hunter gonna play it safe

[@jamesmccracken2542]

I don't think joe gives a fuk about that

[@Bambino_60]

None

[@Thebiggest12]

Alabama don’t produce good QBs

[@jameshollister8294]

If its not CAM WARD ITS NO BODY IF YOU ASK ME

[@khawarsiddiqui341]

2024. That was the year for the Giants to go and get their guy. Whatever it took. They declined. That decision will haunt this organization for some time. This years crop… I don’t see it.

[@roshan2865]

We didn’t decline, we were denied any possibility of getting either Williams, Daniels or Maye. Nix and Penix wouldn’t have necessarily been good with the supporting cast we have

[@khawarsiddiqui341]

@@roshan2865 Am I the only person who heard the phone call on hard knocks 4 hours before the draft where the Patriots told Joe Shame straight up we want a 1,2, and 3 this year and a 1,2, and 3 next year? I can't be because that clip is still available on YT. Also you do not go into the draft knowing that you will have to trade up for a QB having traded away your picks (Brian Burns) in advance.The minute we traded for Burns I knew were were not going to be able to trade up to go get Maye.

[@khawarsiddiqui341]

​@@roshan2865 I know I cannot be the only person who saw the hard knocks episode where 4-hours before the draft the Patriots told Joe Shame we want a 1,2, and 3 this year and a 1,2, and 3 next year. I can't be because the clip is still on YT. I also take issue with trading away draft capital prior to the draft. The minute we traded for Burns I knew we did not have enough to go up and get Maye. And we did not. That was a choice.

[@johnstrika9170]

They're both going to be trash

[@mikeherrera7678]

Unfortunately the Giants organization will never draft a black Qb1…..before I get called racist …name me one

[@Oneshotdee]

@@mikeherrera7678 black qbs just got popular within the past 5-7 years .. before that black QBs were very rare.. now half the league is black qbs.. so they better get with it or get lost

[@Shardekeoglesby3073]

Fact's

[@SoldOuttaSouls]

Facts it’s different times this will be the time they prove the theory wrong

[@khawarsiddiqui341]

Andre Woodson. 2008 NFL draft 6th round pick. There you go.

[@khawarsiddiqui341]

Must be alternative facts.

[@patrickgrove3469]

Cam Ward,Shedur has his fathers baggage and dissaproval of coming to NY

[@jameshollister8294]

I can never respect a player who throws teammates under the bus you just dont do that ... If you do it college you will definitely do it it NFL