WHICH COTTON HARVESTER IS BEST? | Farming Simulator 19

Which Cotton Harvester Is The Better Choice? Let's Find Out!
#FarmingSimulator #JohnDeereVsCaseIh #CottonDLC
_________________________________________
Check Out Our Merch Store! Get Yourself A “GET OUTTA HERE BIRDS SHIRT!”
teespring.com/...
Become A Full Member Of The GoHamFam!
/ @djgohamgaming
Click Here To Make A Donation To The #GoHamFam!
paypal.me/djgoham
_________________________________________
Where To Find New Mods & Mod Testing Lists
Giants ModHub (XB1/PS4) - www.farming-si...
Giants MoHub (PC/Mac) - www.farming-si...
Giants Mod Testing Forum (Updated Mon-Fri) - forum.giants-s...
_________________________________________
Social Media
Twitter - / djgoham2
Facebook - / djgohamgaming
_________________________________________
Consoles
Xbox One X (2018 Model)
PS4 Pro (2018 Model)
_________________________________________
Recording Computer
Custom PC Build (Built Mid July 2019)
CPU - AMD Ryzen 9 3900X 12-Core 24-Thread 3.8 GHz
Graphics Card - Nvidia RTX 2070 Super Founders Edition
Motherboard - Gigabyte X570 Aorus Pro Wifi ATX
Memory - Corsair Vengeance LPX 64 GB 3200mhz DDR4
Storage - WD Blue SSD M.2 1 TB, WD 1 TB Hard Drive
Power Supply - MasterWatt 750 Watt 80 Plus Bronze
Case - Cooler Master MasterCase H500 Mesh
Fans - All Cooler Master - 2x 200mm RGB, 2x 140mm RGB, 1x 120mm
_________________________________________
Editing Computer
iMac Retina 5k 27” 2019
CPU - Intel Core i9 8-Core 16-Thread 3.6 GHz
Memory - 64 GB 2666 DDR4
Storage - 500 GB SSD + 1T SSD
_________________________________________
Streaming Computer
Custom PC Build (Built Late October 2018)
CPU - AMD Ryzen 7 2700X 8-Core 16-Thread 3.7 GHz
Graphics Card - EVGA GeForce GTX 1070 SC Black
Motherboard - Gigabyte X470 Aorus Ultra Gaming ATX
Memory - Corsair Vengeance LPX 32 GB 3000mhz DDR4
Capture Cards - Elgato 4K60 Pro (Internal), Elgato HD60S (External)
Storage - WD Blue SSD M.2 500 GB, WD 1 TB Hard Drive
Power Supply - MasterWatt 650 Watt 80 Plus Bronze
Case - Cooler Master MasterCase H500 Mesh
Fans - 3x Cooler Master 200mm RGB, 1x 120mm

[@DjGoHamGaming]

It's been done a million times. John Deere vs. Case IH. Which one is better?

[@paweoopp6966]

Did modcontest ended?

[@emplaas6585]

John deere

[@rowanprice2304]

Case IH

[@Jakknifed]

John Deere definitely! 👍

[@mattalford3932]

They are both fine. I'd say equal in work performance. The case drops less bales meaning less work. The JD is convenient, and cool for JD only farms.

[@mattalford3932]

The gain from not stopping is voided. By all the extra bales you gotta collect lol.

[@Galerak1]

Exactly! Add to that the insane cost difference and this test showd me the Case won hands down.

[@nicke1903]

That and you can basically have 3 Case machines

[@ram89572]

@Baron Marseille Well....Mr. Kettle, Mr. Pot called. He said to tell you you're black. You say that it's a game, so no real life comparisons, yet your previous comment is speaking in terms of the real machines instead of how they behave in game.

[@evantaylor7465]

more bales =more lag

[@manderson8599]

Exactly!

[@DannyStar91]

The price speaks for itself.. when you buy the JD Harvester just think you could buy 2 case harvesters & get the job done twice as fast 🤔

[@sadcattoclips]

DannyStar91 now that i think about that you’re right!

[@Cavediver86]

This guy maths

[@justsaying833]

Not to mention you lose whatever cotton is left behind in the JD because unlike the case you can't empty a partial bale from the JD

[@sadcattoclips]

Yee thats y i didn’t download it

[@TheRedneckReaper92]

@@justsaying833 with a mod we can get a wider JD round baler, and personally I don’t mind picking the bales up, plus they can stack tighter than the cotton one from case. Don’t get me wrong, I love the case harvester. For leasing and contract: case, ownership:JD (mod) solely because the case will let me drop an unfinished bale. IRL for the JD: the basket of leftover Cotten is side tipped into a trailer similar to a sugarcane basket then hauled off, idk if that’s possible to do or if maybe that edit can come later, but you’re supposed to be able to tip the collector basket Cotton from the left side into something else.

[@luggy3480]

I hope someone makes classic John Deere in the future for consoles it should be 40s, 50s, or 60s series that would be awesome

[@jracer7189]

I agree

[@colbybarbour9990]

well they did

[@oddranch1429]

But you can run 2 case harvesters for a little more then 1 john deere, so much faster with case.

[@jag497]

You understand when using the jd you drop the bale at the head rows. You don’t keep it until full again. Which yes you pick up more but in same place.

[@cdostheimer]

It would be interesting to see difference in an unreadable total across an entire field since cotton requires a certain percentage to unload an unfinished bale. It seems like you could finish with nearly 2500 liter that cant be unloaded in the JD while the Case only requires 2000 to generate a partial bale.

[@Patchypatch09]

Hmmm 400k more and having to pick up a crap load of bales on carriers that can haul max 3 at a time compared to picking up a few bales 2 at a time? Case all the way. Bale collecting is a pain and the Case saves a boatload of time and money.

[@gustavolugo9558]

Yup and you can carry 2 20k cotton bales compared to 3 10k cotton bales

[@SUPERDUCKcromobe]

Try putting covers on those case bales. Thats a whole 'nother level

[@PAplowboy]

Now if you take the time to pick up the bales the case will even up on the truck you only stop twice but you have to stop four times to fill it with the round bales. Just some food for thought

[@Patchypatch09]

@@MultiTurbospeed too bad this isn't real life lol

[@nicke1903]

Deere boys better be glad it ain't real life,repairs would cost 1k more because of "Diagnostics" and you would have to haul it to the shop to get Maintnance done

[@WPUpioneer]

Using the JD on Estancia Lapacho. Loving it :-)

[@yubiaozhang4556]

Case New Holland 620 cotton picker has upgraded the baler system, and the air duct and cotton duct have also been further designed to greatly improve work efficiency

[@killianfritz5840]

Case ih cuz it's free, makes bales twice as big (so less to store) and the case ih is almost half the price at the dealer

[@puremark403]

I was hoping for a trailer that could carry more then 20000

[@mattalford3932]

Case. It does a better job at half the price. Just like in real life.

[@stevenpdxedu]

I love green and yellow, however, if I want to pick up twice as many bales I might as well have twice as many harvesters and get done in half the time . . . which is what one can afford to do since the JD is twice the price. No brainer Case wins this one. Doing cotton is boring anyway, I just put it on a worker and pick up the bales when it's over. Good money in it though. Thanks for the review. BTW the machines getting off row is caused by the map set up not by the machine itself.

[@sebastianvera363]

Jd as it offers a whole variety of different ways to handle/move the bales and the round bales are supported by tension belts unlike the square modules

[@braden7465]

Case IH: I'm good at life John Deere: I'm about to end this man's career

[@unbiasedcobra6672]

Because of modded trailers I use JD. The auto load bale trailer holds more round cotton and a low loader only fits the JD. This particular loader can have multiple trailers added. So I drag 3 pickers in one trip then 4 trailers.

[@texasjoe71]

You still have to collect twice as many bales with the John Deere adding more time to being totally complete with the harvest

[@m60x75]

And if the operator knew how to run one of these machines, they would drop the bales on the turn rows so it’s much quicker and easier to pick them up

[@clayrichey309]

The jd made 1 bale. Its not compleated until the bale hits the ground.

[@TheJadeStorm87]

I do like the Deere, and it is fun to play with, but that price is a hard pill to swallow anytime. You could essentially buy 2 Case harvesters for the price of 1 Deere. Then not only are you harvesting twice as fast, you have half the number of modules to pick up. Then in order to unload a partial module with the Deere you need to fill the pre load chamber (2500L). The Case can be unloaded earlier than that. The Deere is cool and the non stop harvesting is nice, but I have to give it to the Case.

[@justsaying833]

What wins me over is the case because you can unload whatever is left inside the machine and you lose cotton with the JD because you can't do the same

[@claytonhoffman3533]

As a proud Government Subsidy player, I choose green. Less downtime, less left over in the baler, more fuel in the tank.

[@emplaas6585]

I really like the john deere but its so pricey

[@nicke1903]

What's the Slot count on the JD

[@Noodlzified]

Advantages of JD harvester: pre-chamber for non-stop harvesting and the back bale "holder" so you can dump the bale when you want (at the same egde of a field everytime for easy loading). Advantage of Case IH harvester: less modules to deal with. In real life application, the JD is the obvious winner in my opinion.

[@nicke1903]

Don't do any Cotton but not a JD fan boy persay either, maybe a 2wd 4640 or something.Think of it this way, you can have 2 Case Harvesters to 1 JD.

[@franselshof]

i think i stay with the iconik ideal harverster, with cotton pack. 250.000 liters, 36 m wide header, 50 km/h.... outruns them both :)

[@dahlmasen3084]

Case is better for sure, also nicer colour👌🏻

[@ToTster12]

Ow isn’t that a pickle. That little of a difference harvesting and the vast amounted difference in price. Still gonna try the JD though.

[@garybarrett537]

All you really need to use is the Iconik Cotton Addon Pack

[@DjGoHamGaming]

I agree lol I've got it installed and love it!

[@dixiecupdrinker1]

Not if you're playing realistic.

[@tannerrutland2730]

Honestly i like the old basket pickers like the 9960's-9996's and cases 2-6 row pickers these balers just aint for me

[@SnaFubar_24]

Great test! I am just starting a new play thru on West Texas map and I am definitely going to DL this John Deer CP690 cotton DLC.

[@chrisiverson257]

Dont drop a cotton bale while transporting. Cars dont stop for them on the road in FS19. Knocked one of mine into the water while trying to pick it up.

[@benjaminringrose536]

CASE wins this hands down, you may lose like 2-3% in time to bail but the CASE produces half as many bales. You'll easily save 15 minutes on picking up squares vs brown.

[@mt975]

The John Deere is best with the variable bale density mod. Can carry twice as much as the case harvester in round bales.

[@Razorback83]

Case of course,

[@stianhaukelid8358]

Case is best

[@Jschultzy21]

I like that John Deere but the only reason I don’t have it is cuz it has round bales an I like square ones that the case has.

[@RichardDower]

What happened at 10.07 ?....looks like the JD went into a wall or something

[@DjGoHamGaming]

I had 3 of each on the map. 1 for the thumbnail, 1 for the test, and 1 to mess with. That was the one that I was messing with lol

[@matthewmasternak3555]

I'm using the JD cotton picker on Dahl Ranch.

[@necromonger2391]

What about that the JD was also doing 6 rows and the Case only 5 after the 3 passes....maybe the Case could have done more then?

[@northerner4913]

I love both harvesters

[@The_Black_Knight]

Real cotton farmer here. Real comparison for efficiency and effectiveness. The Case 635 is directly superior in capacity, resources, price, and performance overall. Try comparing TWO Case for cost versus one John Deere. The results co completely trash the John Deere. Faster speed and fuel capacity is inconsequential even in very large continuous fields. Handling bales is a poor comparison because experience and proper equipment negates any advantage of handling round bales, which is NOT easier when storing and require twice as many transport actions. What was not even considered? Repair and maintenance costs. Guess who wins this area as well? Case again due to its modular nature.

[@megakillerx]

Easy, it’s the black one.

[@jaredstivers]

Considering JD started behind

[@PirateofAE2]

would love to see done this with other tools as well :)

[@coleschowe7706]

awesome video very informative

[@bryangoodson3538]

I do have to say the price sucks but its constantly moving is nice I'm 50/50 about it

[@sovietelmo3017]

This is very informative

[@BigbyWolf76]

I used the round cotton bale harvester to get the Gone but not for cotton trophy.

[@Yes_man]

yes

[@sadcattoclips]

GET OUTTA HERE BIRDS

[@theonewhowatchesthewatchme2275]

yes i will use this infomation wisely, thats the same me who cant play the game pc not strong enogh, hasnt set eyes on cotton i fs15 which i can barely run and also dont really care which harvester takes longer since i run workers and cheat in money anyway

[@Noncuttingedgegaming]

Case: exists John deere: I'm about to do whats called a pro gamer move

[@seanbuchanan8773]

JD: Watch me dance around and be pretty. $2million please for that show... We call it pro gamer moves. Case: I'll get 'er done in the same time with less work from yourself, and I'll only charge half as much. You're welcome.

[@codyscherer6930]

i rather pick up three square bales vs 6-8 of those round bales

[@Phantom-mh8xq]

FOR ME JOHN DEERE COTTON IS KILLING IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@eanna_murray1703]

I would take the case just my opinion

[@shawnward8830]

John Deere maintenance is much more expensive as well

[@pusheengaming7434]

I love the JD but.. you had set it so it harvested 1 row more than the case.

[@vato4160]

But you can always unfold on move 😂😂

[@brianmillard3385]

just watched daggerwin do this same thing

[@waltcovey6281]

John Deere 100%

[@Surron-Nigth-Rider-Qc]

no one notice the second john deer in the forest ? when he switch ?

[@DjGoHamGaming]

Haha I had a few of each on the map. That was one that I was messing around with between takes

[@davidwhisnant3230]

John Deere is the only one making pickers now

[@redturbo6698]

I have never purchased a cotton harvester, just rent & return. I will give the JD a try. How does the slot count compare between them???

[@masus81]

@@MultiTurbospeed our 40 something if your on PS

[@dan5137]

It was helpful. Doubt I will spend the $5. I don't do much cotton. I don't do a lot of bale wrapping either so I didn't download Anderson either

[@joesphbrown7322]

I got it on steam this morning and plan on using it!

[@wayneisaacs7511]

all so the JD is good for flat land but sucks on a hill. im not running down a hill to cach my cotten

[@maxtitterington3217]

first like the cool kids say... AGAIN

[@brodieratledge6561]

I don't even get the option of the round cotton Baler harvester but yet I have the option of buyin the trailer for them. How do I get it?

[@DjGoHamGaming]

Brodie Ratledge You need to purchase or download the John Deere cotton DLC

[@208SledHead]

Case and New Holland >

[@thedevonshirefarmer3611]

I'm using the John Deere cotton Harvester on the walker farm map and I have got 2

[@rainwingmichael6691]

I think that you think the jd will win because you are John deer fan

[@franksharal5512]

I think you're a case fan makes you salty

[@stijnriver9467]

I am a John deere fan so i choose always the John deere

[@DeeWadeSoundz]

Of course tha round bale is better in real life .

[@Peanutbutterkush]

Hi dj

[@colton3455]

Your content is the best bro

[@peterbilt3597]

Good video

[@iisteefgamingii1179]

im using it on ps4 on welkers farm field 5 next to woolset point with 2 machines field is almost done have 13 bales so far and its not ferilized

[@Cavediver86]

I wouldn't use it John Deere if it was free

[@RoooSs0]

dont blow hate at me but john deere is my fav and i hate case

[@farmermahnew1910]

Btw DJ, the amount in the JD hopper is waste.. You can't unload that amount.. Just an fyi.. Anything over 2000 in the case can be unloaded..

[@seanmacfarlane6571]

I'm using the John deere

[@chrissanchez8615]

nice video man

[@cookie7595]

I have not got the DLC yet but do you know if the bails are going to roll down the hill

[@DjGoHamGaming]

I'm sure they will. I'll be doing cotton on a hilly field in about an hour for tomorrow's PeterVill Video. I'll let you know lol

[@peterbilt3597]

Amazing

[@dbddimov]

We need non stop round baller :)

[@rcmike09]

That's why I always do square for grass and hay

[@tomschutte7947]

Case!!!!

[@codyhoerner5268]

John Deere goes 16 mph

[@blakecox6455]

The John Deere is better

[@vernonarseneau7995]

Got it I use it all the time now

[@tylerpoepping4140]

CNH know as Case And New Holland will always win. ps New holland bought Case ih

[@francoispelletier9441]

Tyler Poepping still 2 crappy companies. Even together, they cannot match John Deere. Same tractor in 2 different colours. Nice try.

[@gavinjunkermeier8267]

Francois Pelletier John Deere literally copies everything case does

[@SadLifeLV]

where to download this?

[@maxtheinvincible1925]

Me at the start CASE IH

[@liamcarey7533]

Case

[@wilburandwilburjrgaming4669]

Of course JD won 😂

[@KanekiAtOtaku]

Case won hands down, Not only is it way cheaper, it also drops less bales. Less bales, less transporting, less transporting, less time spent.

[@billthornton5956]

I still dont have the option to buy the dlc on xbox. What do I do?

[@waynereibsome]

Bill Thornton season pass will have to reinstall it but if you don’t have it might have to restart your Xbox to get to pop up

[@hauskin_farms_tn2322]

JOHN DREER!!!!!

[@jessehuss1484]

Bet on john deer