WHICH GIRL SCOUT COOKIES ARE THE BEST & THE WORST?

[@justlena1800]

I love you Ern I've been sitting up prayers for your dad and for you and your fertility Journey I hope everything goes well stay positive🥰

[@cherylweiss4106]

As a Girl Scout parent, the most popular cookies were Thin Mints, Tagalongs/Peanut Butter Patties and Samoa’s. Try the Thin Mints and Tagalongs frozen...next level!

[@HumbleWorldTraveler]

See I’m just watching this but I can’t remember when they sale

[@justlena1800]

"But then it kind of went into weird land" is the title of the book that is my life

[@ErinRobinson]

Mine too! 😂

[@JR-vx6ix]

When Erin mentioned that Ray Romano doesn’t like lemon cookies I audibly gasped and grasped my invisible pearls. Then I thought well not everyone can be perfect like our Queen Erin. We stan a queen that can appreciate the finer things in life 🍋

[@ErinRobinson]

I just chuckled! I love a lemon loving internet friend!

[@erikawier4163]

I'm with ya'll....I LOVE lemon desserts.. They just make u smile. Hope ya'll have a wonderful day 😀

[@EricaUrr]

Ok, I was never a fan of lemon baked goods... and I'm not much of a fan of these iced ones... but like 5 years ago they had a powdered sugar coated lemon cookies called Savannah Smiles, I want to say? I still dream of those to this day 😔😂

[@caitlynskiff2001]

Yes! I was so sad when they discontinued them because I loved them so much!

[@ProfessorSetterby]

Those were good!!

[@kaziebae]

The excitement i get everytime i get notified of our girl's video is up! ❤️❤️😘

[@dmdoll77]

Your pterodactyl sounds are the best! I’ve only known one person in my life who has done that (my BFF) and ironically, her name is Erin as well!!

[@lisamitchell15]

I say a pray for your dad all the time. Hope he's getting better😍😍 Your awesome to watch and your husband. You are a great couple🥰🥰

[@loriesasaki]

I love the way Erin speaks. So eloquent❣️

[@pureblue1987]

WHY DID WE SEND MATT AWAY?? WHY??? I WANT MY FAVORITE COUPLE ON KZbin BOTH AT ONCE (Its Ramadan, holy fasting month in Islam, so I am fasting which makes me too emotional since i'm hungry and I am watching you eat cookies lol)

[@ErinRobinson]

He chose this for himself...aka...he had to get back to work lol

[@pureblue1987]

@@ErinRobinson But you need to tell him that we want him back on the vlogs and videos (Its a new day, fasting again and hungry so im throwing a dramatic emotional tantrum lol) Keep the videos coming my Twin & iconic legend. Also watching your other channel, you are so brave going thru surgery, I wish you nothing but success and happiness

[@allygu2940]

this video was adorable. "it's like you in a cookie" i love watching your videos. they make me laugh.

[@debilei1078]

I enjoy you two so much! Lucky You Two!

[@mountainmama45]

The Lemonades are my favorite and I am not normally a lemon dessert kind of gal. They have changed me. Also I have found that the Lemon Kit Kats taste a lot like the Lemonade G.S. cookies, so if you like one, you'll probably like the other.

[@thegingergyrl455]

Oh my, my Daddy always stopped to get Nabs, a Pepsi and some beef jerky at the gas station. I feel so old now.

[@elizabethhager560]

I LOVE the lemonade cookies! It is the only kind of girl scout cookie that no one else in my house eats so I get to have them to myself. Plus lemon desserts are incredible, so refreshing!

[@guardchic1714]

The little shriek you made when you realized Nabs is short for Nabisco was the cutest noise 🥰 love you girly!

[@leilani461]

I’ve heard Aldi has amazing dups for Girl Scout cookies ! I really need to try those toast ones ❤️

[@KelseyAsklund]

I love the s’mores and shortbread ones. I love shortbread cookies in general. But I love the lemonades as well. They used to have shortbread with chocolate bottom called all abouts that I loved when I was selling

[@bettydraper6949]

Have to watch everytime I see a new upload from you. You have such a good energy

[@jessicamcgraw2791]

I'm in Louisville, Ky.... home of Little Brownie Bakers (the east coast GS cookie bakery) 😄. I never understood why they call the cookies by different names depending on where you are in the US. My favorites are Samoas and Trefoils. I 100% feel you on the mint/chocolate combo, but I do love cilantro!

[@justlena1800]

The genuine excitement I had when I saw this was real❤️❤️❤️

[@lillythf]

My fave were always the caramel delites (samoas), but I like the pb patties too. I was a girl scout as a kid, so always will support

[@gabriellebutler1990]

In Oregon we have a different s’more cookie and they amazing.

[@carrieswank]

We freeze them, too! In fact, my hubby only eats his thin mints right out of the freezer. I like the shortbread cookies with coffee. But my faves are the Carmel Delights and the Peanut Butter Patties-I’m in Kansas City, so they’re not called Samoas here 😜

[@AKbaby89]

Oooo is it the everything but the sink cookie from panera?? Cuz that one is really good. But my favorite is the lemon delight(duh...lemon)

[@victoriamarch-rico431]

Have you gone to the Two Hands korean corn dog place in LA?? I would love to see you try all the flavors and see which is your favorite especially since I don't live near it haha

[@nadiadansani2139]

The Savannah Smiles. Those were my girls! but they discontinued those, and got second best the lemonades. I loved sour things as a kid and lemon flavored things as a kid. I like it now, but definitley not a first choice.

[@telizabethxo]

I had to go gluten free this year. Sadly I order Girl Scout cookies before this happened but I had order Carmel chocolate chip cookies and I will attest to them being pretty good. I order like a whole case more after. My favorite Girl Scout cookies growing up was the lemon sandwich creams or the animal treasure (shortbread w/ animal pictures and a chocolate coated back). They were discontinued at some point can’t remember when tho. Also the different baker cookies are different and I do notice a difference. In my area based on county there are different cookies though so tbh I can never remember which cookies versions I like better. My girls scout region switched bakers at some point during my Girl Scout tenure. The. They switched back. Idk Girl Scouts was great it’s full of great memories for me. Thanks for feeding my nostalgia today.

[@FoodTastertv]

this was an awesome delicious video :) We dont have girl scouts in Canada. We have girl guides instead and apparently they only have one cookie !!!

[@heidirobinson3352]

I just placed my order for Girl Scout cookies!! They should be arriving this week. Good grief the shipping was $12.00 though! ⚜💃💛🥳

[@lyndao320]

I love the Tagalongs the best with Do-Si-Do's a close second.

[@michellealbert2457]

Omg pls make more videos with ur husband, the dynamic is amazing

[@NorseButterfly]

The caramel delights are my all time favs! But seeing as girl scouts are so freakin expensive, I had to get my fix on the "blue market".... yes, Walmart😞. They have their own brand of the caramel delight...and it's pretty dang good!

[@jamie-leebenji]

Omg! Has anyone told you that you remind them of the Hart of Dixie character Annabeth Nass?! So uncanny 💕💕

[@sydneylawson9337]

So true!!!

[@sharonreed2753]

so I like thin mints but I think the Keebler grasshopper cookies are better. You can get them year round at a fraction of the cost.

[@redyellow415]

This made me crave a Samoa so badly! 🍪 🤤 💕

[@londoncoco2617]

I look forward to your taste tests every week :-)

[@oliviaspreen5940]

the toffee tastics give me flashbacks to when my troop couldn't sell them cause no one liked them so we had a ton of boxes left over after cookie season ended and for multiple trips afterwards all we had for snacks and desserts were toffee tastics.

[@FoodTastertv]

How do they taste ?

[@MakeupbyRocky]

I’m on my tv watching. I came here on my phone just to defend the s’more cookies. I love them and topped Tagalongs for me and those were my all time favorite.

[@FoodTastertv]

Now you are a dedicated viewer to be willing to come on this video on your phone to comment lol . I wish I had dedicated viewers like you LOL .

[@ErinRobinsonVlogs]

WHICH GIRL SCOUT COOKIES ARE YOUR FAVORITE!?!?!?!

[@LanieandMatt]

Tag a longs🖤

[@tinatee6334]

Thin mints, Samoa’s and tag a longs

[@paigelongenecker7865]

savannah smiles :))

[@amethyst4990]

Samoas for sure!

[@usagimoon.x.o6256]

Samoa's and thin mints!

[@cdean115691]

Erin, Dollar General has a cookie thats a dupe of the samoas! They are my go to cookie when not GS cookie season!

[@abbyalarid6877]

Totally agree with the winner! Carmel delight aka samoas are the best, I agree with the second place as well.

[@mthrofwntr]

My grandmother always had the Keebler fudge striped cookies. Like my whole life. Never changed.

[@ErinRobinson]

Oh YES! Those too. I actually could taste those as I read your comment. They're legendary.

[@yesm23]

The do si dos are one of my favorites!!!😋 It's so good

[@taylorclark5054]

This video made me order 12 boxes! I’m so excited for them I love Girl Scout cookies 🍪

[@FoodTastertv]

WOW !!!!! Im jealous !!! We dont get any of these cookies in Canada !!!!!

[@halliec379]

Caramel Delites and lemonades are my favorites!!! Also thin mints are great, my mom used to make homemade ones for gifting that were so so good!!!

[@jamesalberg3243]

As always Erin, you create the most fun and entertaining food reviews on KZbin!! :-) That being said, what I'm about to say may be blasphemy to you... but, cookies just aren't my thing. Although, I Do have fond memories of the Samoa. Now, Haggen Daaz ice cream, whole different thing, and/or video :-P

[@ErinRobinson]

James, we all have our things!!!!! I have to admit that I realized after this video that Girl Scout cookies are not my favorite cookies overall 👀

[@jamesalberg3243]

@@ErinRobinson Now that I think of it, a warm. soft, chocolate chip cookie from Chic-Fil-A is pretty dang good! Mmm 😋

[@nicolewhirley7745]

You should compare the girl scout cookies to the closest option from the grocery store. I'm not sure it they are regional but I think Keebler cookies have quite a few girl scout dupes! 🍪🥰

[@sunnydaze3131]

They should, since they make the Little Brownie brand of GS cookies.

[@tommiegnosis]

Hot take: I don't really like Somoas. Its so many people's favorites but it hurts my teeth and the texture doesn't work for me at all. I'm not saying I don't get why people like them they're just not my personal type of cookie. Also, speaking of lemon...yes...I LOVE lemon desserts! Those and thin mints are my favorites.

[@tasiacross5173]

My favorite girl scout cookies are. Tangalongs, trefoils, do si dos. I gotta try the new ones

[@cje24576]

Any chance of you posting the taste test (from both bakeries) here on KZbin? I for one don’t use TikTok.

[@Becca123b]

Do you remember sugar wafers? bought a pack last week and it was super good brought me back. Ps also I’m so glad I’m not the only one who has really loud hiccups.

[@Chelsyclb]

Trefoils are the best cookie in my opinion. Maybe I just like classic! But I love peanut butter as well but never tried that one.

[@laurenschenck5355]

Omg girl! I love ❤️ GIRL SCOUT COOKIES SO MUCH i can eat them for breakfast lunch and dinner!! Praying 🙏🏻 for your dad and for felicity journey bestie xoxo 💋

[@mizzbritt2082]

Shortbread cookies wit Hershey chocolate bars are EVERYTHING!!!

[@monyjust2243]

I am similar to you Erin, I am not a mint and chocolate person, I don't even like mint chocolate chip ice cream (I know), but I will eat thin mints!! They are so good and are best in the freezer!!

[@balvyllaere]

I'm jealous, I didn't know about the cinnamon toast ones! 😫

[@amandafriedman646]

I used to put the thin mints(grasshoppers) in the freezer. Much better.

[@mlemcgeee]

if matt wants to be in the video so bad then what's his ranking?? he's gotta tell us.. the people need to know

[@ErinRobinson]

He didn’t have time to eat them all this day, but I did consult with him on my final choices!

[@Wondertwinsmom01]

For those of you with an Aldi grocery store near you, try their version of the tagalong‘s a.k.a. peanut butter patties, they are awesome and only cost around a dollar per package!

[@KelseyAsklund]

They also have Samoa ones too

[@vicbess5758]

Also have a STRONG aversion to mint and chocolate together- with ya sis

[@rachelg5321]

Thin mint all the way!! 2nd fav is samoas 💕 these vids are the best Erin!

[@reneeortiz1123]

I looove the lemonades but last year I moved to an area that uses the other bakery and can only get lemon ups which are nowhere near as good

[@ErinRobinson]

That is so sad. I can confirm there is a big difference in the cookies.

[@amandahammack1669]

Currently have a box of Thin Mints and box and a half of Tag A Longs in the freezer.

[@lelarockin]

Do-si-dos were always my favorite haha and it makes sense cause I loveeee nutter butters

[@JenniferKlumpp]

FYI, it's the S'mores that are discontinued, the Lemonades are still going to be a thing. The Toast-Yays aren't limited edition, afaik, they're simply new this year and will continue.

[@cierranicole5485]

I bet the lemon ones would make a great crust for a raspberry cheesecake

[@justinvarnet5461]

This needs more views, Erin is the best.. That is all.

[@ErinRobinson]

Justin! From your keyboard to God's ears!

[@mattrobinson695]

Never make assumptions when dating!

[@MzGumby02]

I'm a former Girl Scout, and I never knew there were two bakeries. I was in two different troops too. I use to love girl scout cookies.

[@MrsWill-wd3mb]

Samoas were my fav before finding out I was gluten intolerant. Now I hardly ever get them period but I may try that new GF one! 👀

[@derryXDINES]

I don't know how I missed this one, but I gotta say I feel like the quality has been slipping the past 10ish years. Also, Aldi has dupes of most of the Girl Scout cookies, would be a fun follow-up to compare them and possibly expose that they're made at the same factories.

[@mysticloverfairy1]

Can you do everything at Chipotles,if you haven’t already

[@tarapenn463]

Does anyone else remember the caramel delights/samoas beling called jubilees? I swear that is what they were called when I sold them!

[@northup2011]

Omg! Why did grandparents AWAYS have those crackers?! NABS nostalgia. 😅 the best! Why were they orange with peanut butter though ?! Was it cheesy? I have questions. Never questioned it as a kid though!

[@ErinRobinson]

I agree. It's a mind warp. I liked the cheese nabs more than the peanut butter ones.

[@cassieliles9960]

I made homemade thin mints in my cooking class in high school and oh my lord they were incredible! We kept the in the fridge so the chocolate wouldn’t melt and they tasted so good cold!

[@AKbaby89]

WHAT?! I am SHOOK about the cookies being made in different places and being different. I grew up in Alaska, and moved to Washington a couple years ago, and I got girl scout cookies for the first time this year since moving, and I couldve sworn the lemon cookies were in different packaging and looked different. They could've changed them tho, but still.

[@pennywisethedancingclown2702]

I know one of the bakeries makes some of the cookies vegan while the other one doesn’t.

[@cperi2583]

peanut butter sandwich dipped in nutella!!! AMAZING!

[@ErinRobinson]

My eyes just rolled in the back of my head!

[@cperi2583]

@@ErinRobinson try it and come back and let me know what you thought!

[@laurenschenck5355]

I love thin mints so and and samosas my favorite! You are gorgeous BBFLS I love you ❤️

[@gagoloss9153]

Love u guy so much . And this sweater I remember !!!!

[@justforthelulz93]

I love dunking trefoils in milk until they get kind of soggy.

[@AKbaby89]

Lemon anything is sooo good to me. I loooove it.

[@inlovewithJLT]

Never seen that French toast cookie! Looks worth a try, so rare to see a GS cookie bigger than a quarter 😬

[@ErinRobinson]

I think it's new! I had to go on a big hunt for it!

[@cmtaylor531]

Somaos and Thin mints are interchangeable to me. Followed by the peanut butter patties.

[@nikkicoffill4574]

Lemon all the way! I LOVE THEM! 🍋

[@ErinRobinson]

SAME SAME SAME!

[@l.c.7955]

Smores are the ones that will be discontinued, lemonades will still be around, at least until next year.

[@nadiadansani2139]

trefoils and the lemon cookies were always my fave.

[@TXNinjaQueen]

I am a mint and chocolate person, but I hate thin mints. I’m just a weirdo lol Samoas (I don’t think I spelled that correctly) and the peanut butter patties are my FAVORITE 😍

[@gailstevens8487]

Is your favorite cookie from Panera the Kitchen Sink cookie?

[@wendysumner8899]

So sad...in Canada, we get only three types of Girl Guide/Scout cookies...chocolate and vanilla sandwich cookies and chocolate mint....soooo boring!!!!

[@BoltCRNA]

Forged in the fire of cheat day. Bellissimo!

[@ilanakarp]

Lemonades are my absolute favorite Girl Scout Cookie!

[@jasonsong6747]

'Somoas taste so signature' - EXACTLY! You have good taste Erin!

[@GameSubster]

Considering I just bought 3 boxes of these this video came clutch

[@kellyhowland783]

Yes! Samoa's #1! My favorite!

[@BleuSquid]

Thanks for fighting the good fight, Matt! Thin Mints are the BEST

[@Danielle-tz9go]

Gotta agree I 💛 lemon dessert

[@ErinRobinson]

Thank you for the support out here, Danielle!

[@Mandilynn223]

Paused at the beginning: SAMOAS hands down!.... alright. Pressing play now

[@ErinRobinson]

You might not be wrong!

[@totallyspiesrock89]

Peanut butter cookies are always top of my list then the Samoas then shortbread then thin mints is dead last. I think they changed them over the years. I thought they had more chocolate and now they taste like a chocolate cracker. Still trying different flavors but snores I don't really care for either.