Which Pokemon Card Grading Company Messed Up The Worst? /// PSA VS. BGS VS. CGC

[@sixtyninelol]

"All right the video is ruined we got bad words all in it" LMAO

[@MCWordicus]

A fucked up label is one thing, but I would be livid if I sent in an alt art Lugia and got a regular full art back.

[@buffalobill9793]

Bur if you sent in a full art Lugia and got an alt art Lugia back you would be doing a happy dance.

[@MCWordicus]

@@buffalobill9793 no, I wouldn't just yoink someone else's card

[@thevagrantgaming]

Ancient Mew was supposed to be a PSA 1. Probably wasn’t an actual mistake by the grader themself. Which is why they deactivated the cert.

[@kycon710]

After my few grading experiences I think I’d rather just keep my cards raw😅

[@davidridgeway5793]

Broooo thankkkkkkk youuuu, I have all my babies raw and minty in my binder or toploaders

[@kycon710]

@@davidridgeway5793 looks way better too. I actually need to get myself a top loader binder as well

[@ethanh8409]

@@davidridgeway5793 toploader binders are my new favorite. They aren't perfect yet, but it makes me feel safer.

[@davidridgeway5793]

^^^ I can sell mine for $15 bucks I used it for a month

[@thekingman5971]

I think grading is best for vintage to keep in condition it’s in that’s about it

[@ponchoking55]

NGL that Ancient Mew doesnt look to bad when its that damaged, makes it look realistic. Or so that PSA grader probably thought but hes on to something

[@Ocelot35]

People like mystery boxes. So PSA's gonna give them damn mystery boxes. It's genius.

[@ElaAmp]

The grader for the Ancient Mew took the title a little too literally. "Yeah, looks ancient to me, guess it's a 10."

[@v3ck1n]

Surprise, it was a trick question, they're all equally terrible.

[@DrHQuinzel]

As always, I'm voting early with CGC

[@scubasteve2903]

I think we’re confused on the process here. The grading process is an assembly line processes. It’s not like a grader opens your submission and then takes out the package. Grades the cards. Prints your labels and seals the slabs then checks QA. The graders just grade 😂 and then it’s gets graded by a second grader and possibly a 3rd if there’s conflicts in the grades. But each step is a different process. Your order shows up to them in a bin. They grade and it moves to the next step. So it’s not like they are sitting with 10 orders being done from start to finish. There’s gonna be errors, but to me the question is what does the company do to fix it and make it right. That’s where these companies drop the ball. But let’s be honest and fair. PSA for example is grading around 1,000,000 cards per month. Even if they operated 99.9% perfect that’s still 1,000 cards a month that are wrong… 12,000 cards a year

[@coolyeh1017]

if they have a success rate of 99.9% most companies would be praising and swooning over them, reaching such rates are pretty rare even in serious industries like medicine or pharmacy (granted their error rate is pretty low due to regulations).

[@buffalobill9793]

Ya bullshit. None of the grading companies have 3 different people grading your cards. If they did the grades would be more accurate and predictable. So your saying about 10 different people touch your card all doing something different. That's even worse. I highly doubt that's how it's done.

[@scubasteve2903]

@@coolyeh1017 that’s my point I highly doubt the success rate is 99.9% I’m simply saying due to the volume if it was that it would be around 1000 cards. I’d a wager it’s a lower success rate and is actually quite a bit more cards on the market that are wrongly graded/labeled etc…

[@scubasteve2903]

@@buffalobill9793 you absolutely get dual grades on cards. The third grader only evaluates if there’s discrepancy. That’s the process. That’s what they say takes place. It’s what people who have insider info confirm. You don’t have to believe it if you don’t want to. But until we’re provided with data to prove otherwise you have to take them at their word.

[@buffalobill9793]

@@scubasteve2903 no I don't. But it does explain some things. Let me see if I understand this correctly. Your card is first graded by the first grader then its graded again by the second grader. If the first grader says PSA 10 and the second grader says PSA 9 then they have to call in the big shot to break the tie. I'm assuming a high seniority employee, you know like a third grader. However if the first grader and the second grader both agree its a PSA 10 then they skip the third grader altogether because it doesn't matter what the hell the third grader thinks they would be over ruled by the unison of the first and second graders. I'm starting to get a clearer picture now. So the employees that do the qc checks does it work the same way. First its checked by the first grader and then by a second grader and if they both give it a thumbs up they just skip right past the third grader again. But if the first grader and the second grader are squabbling that's when the all mighty third grader steps in to settle the dispute. Really I guess that pretty much explains it all. The damn grading companies are using child labor to grade our cards. Imo they shouldn't be using first second or third graders to grade our cards they should have to at least be in high school in order to get a job at a grading company. So if your a fourth or fifth grader don't even waste your time applying because your over qualified and they won't hire you. Only first second and third graders need apply.

[@AtoManPL]

Actually, that Charizard IS a Special Illustration Rare. You can tell that by the two rarity stars being gold. I assume the gold one will have the same artwork on a regular Full Art. We just did not have any Tera SIR card before.

[@nevercold808]

Dang, bro. It's impossible to say who f'd up the worst since those were all epic fails. I'm hyped for Obsidian. I think it has a ton of cool cards.

[@GODTeez]

ive sent in cards that were perfect and got 6s and then ive sent in cards that were 6s and they get 9s or 10s not really sure what psa is doing but im gonna be switching to beckett they seem like the best option for grading.

[@cafe100mph6]

I am buying Cgc 10s. That gold label is going to be selling for more than a Psa 10 soon. Surprised its selling less than Psa right now considering Cgc grades harsher and pop reports. Gold 10 will be the next chase like a cheaper Bgs black label.

[@weskarp7643]

You are completely wrong. You must be inexperienced. If you think some new grading company will surpass PSA your nuts just cuz their prices are cheaper don't mean they will be worth more.

[@cafe100mph6]

@@weskarp7643 oh my bad, Cgc has only been around 20 years. I need to be looking at 50 year plus I guess bro...

[@cafe100mph6]

They grade thousands of cards a day, the mere .05% screw-up rate that makes the news is pretty good actually

[@naidraug1990]

I can understand a mistake or 2 but these mistakes are unexcusable

[@DivaMsDivine]

Ummmm I think there all epic fails. Clearly little Timmy wasn’t doing his job this day.

[@BillieandRubixPokemon]

rattle with the one f bomb proceeded by about 25 others had me roaring

[@cjhorrocks4661]

Raw is the way to go nowadays

[@neseirf70]

Halloween packs don't ship till September. Costco already has winter coats for sale!!

[@Redlotus425]

I wanted to say I seen something I thought was messed up a bit a Pokémon KZbinr that opens cards got a Cgc graded card inside a different company’s case and it was a psa case that just made me wonder that’s all

[@KykyJyky]

That error Gengar is wild

[@WYO_BONES]

Hey that’s my gengar! Thanks for the shoutout!

[@potatopack]

The most pro grading service that is legit and takes pride in grading as an art is CGA (card grading australia) Their training stems from forensic and documentation examination. So they understand how to observe official documents on a professional level. The only issue i feel they have is a they lack a register, which is a big thing of data collecting. But they really grade well overall.

[@patrickbaklava7297]

Im disappointed in all of them equally

[@thePeoplesCoachBurtRhombus]

Now that I see that Ancient Mew, pretty sure my entire collection is gem mint 10. Value just went up📈

[@ryanorionwotanson4568]

I agree! 😂🤣😅

[@riggsvsoliver]

“And creased and wrinkly as your grandmas undercarriage” 😂 that’s amazing

[@inasuma8180]

Lol quality control is the part where the cards sit until they ship.

[@MuddyDango]

Maybe they need some kind of regulatory body to keep these companies holding true to what they represent. Something like a commission that overseas the bare minimum standards for grading and conducting business in this field.

[@nexus5128]

BGS and CGC equally fucked up. I can imagine the PSA fuck up was actually someone typing 10 instead of 1, which MIGHT make sense. Either way I agree with you on the fact that they likely don't have a QC step.

[@RFseeker]

Lol...that Ancient Mew was by far the worst.

[@BillieandRubixPokemon]

sam chibi coming in like I got this

[@jakeryanoc7870]

🤣🤣🤣 PSA is currently defending the 6 mislabeled cards of mine since the day the asked me to review it for errors. This is funny though because I only send to PSA in hopes for a higher grade for selling. The BGS guy was clearly high off of his mid grade texas weed. I imagine the CGC guy gave up the moment he clocked into work.

[@ShaneGillis432HZ]

If your getting paid $25 hour to grade 500 cards a day I guarantee you f up now and then

[@The5thColumn]

the first one is just a typo, 10 instead of 1 lol

[@markbrown5756]

Does cards rock. Thank you for putting me on to them and I also bought a beautiful base set Charizard. They also sell singles 😊shipping fast and packing is very professional

[@TheRepoMan360]

Rattle getting extra spicy today!

[@cognacyang9342]

Wtf!!!!!! 😂😂😂😂 lugia turn into AA???? Sign me up😂😂😂😂

[@TPTShop]

Beckett is SO bad. And customer service is atrocious.

[@MARAXUSOFVLADD]

That PSA 10 is correct, because those ancient creases and should not effect the grade. Nothing new by PSA the grade fake cards and giving them authentic grades 😂

[@Mrgentlemans_vault]

I want to say PSA but at least they sent the correct card lol. Gonna go with Beckett as they didn’t even send a Pokémon card. Cgc close but at least it was the right tcg and was the same Pokémon even if it was the wrong card

[@moisesgalas5968]

I was going to give a like the I realized I already did

[@DrHQuinzel]

LMAO Jolly Rancher King, ded 😂☠

[@GoLatios]

I love it when you say WTF 😂

[@NaturalAnimalKG]

Not watching the video because of this data - PSA grades 1 million cards a month, the others COMBINED do around 100k a month. PSA should have fuckups, the others shouldnt.

[@edsblazeeken]

So CGC basically gifted someone a $150 plus card? Yeah they take the L!

[@SonOfSassy]

At this point why don’t we just laminate our cards and right down a grade on it 😂

[@jasone42683]

I like these kind of videos. A companies love to lie and cover up, and fact is this shit happens. Sad shit.

[@jameyjacade28]

Meanwhile My pack fresh cards are getting 6’s and 7’s

[@EmmAyeVee]

youre living in a fantasy world if you think that just because your cards are "pack fresh" means they should be 10s. LOL

[@jameyjacade28]

@@EmmAyeVee no one said Pack fresh cards should get 10s so I think you’re living in that fantasy world by yourself

[@EmmAyeVee]

@@jameyjacade28 if youre saying no one said it including myself. then how am i living in that fantasy world?

[@jameyjacade28]

@@EmmAyeVee my claim was pack fresh cards are getting 6s and 7s, no one said 10s except for you

[@Ian22222221]

Am I the only person who suspects some of these images to be photoshopped? Not by rattle, but by the person who took the image and posted on social media. Not saying all the images, but perhaps one or two ?

[@RattlePokemon]

No, one was like that on the psa website and the other two people reached out directly because the cards belonged to them. All very real.

[@EmmAyeVee]

@@RattlePokemon so these 3 examples of fuck ups, ill even be generous and say 1000 examples in comparison to the millions of cards (excluding other collectibles) that these companies receive yearly means these grading companies are complete garbage. if thats the case, that just about every single service provider regardless of the type of service that is being rendered is garbage.

[@steveirvinejr1672]

I would to own that psa mew 10

[@Faber0k]

I think someone was just trying to be funny. Grading is a joke and this is Proof! Why would i send my most valuable cards or sealed video games to these clowns?!?!?

[@MrChonkachu]

Its one thing to be off by a point or so by mossing something but wow those are REAL GEMS 😂

[@Torsten8392]

Imagine there is a QC step that catches 95% of errors and we only see the 5%

[@boondockgames8805]

I imagine the keyboard criticizers will never be happy even if they catch 100%

[@aveighht1007]

That’s Rihanna’s Charizard, shine bright like a charizard

[@MarketScraper]

Your favorite zard 🤣🤣🤣

[@redeyez8288]

😅😅 just a reminder that graded cards are just a joke.

[@Ratlif]

My guess is gonna be bgs>psa>cgc, lets see how the video is going to rank them Edit: now cgc did the biggest fuckup here the rest is really bad but not as bad as giving someone else their $150 card lmao

[@theskytoday9239]

Jolly Rancher King! lol

[@Dr.Magikarp]

Obsidian flames!

[@1ivingdeadgr189]

I am never getting my cards graded with these guys ae, too many horror stories

[@Haveafastbath]

Grading… ewwwwwwww

[@Runnygraph20]

All grading is a scam the cost after grading ect ect and that mew was a fake slab wow come on