Which Smiling Critter Could Return in Chapter 4? - [Poppy Playtime Theory]

Which Smiling Critter Could Return in Chapter 4? NEW Poppy Playtime Theory! seeing if any of the Smiling Critter Could be in Poppy Playtime Chapter 4!
We'll be discussing a new Poppy Playtime Theory. We'll also be giving a glimpse of what's coming up next in NEWS section of our channel! So be sure to check out this video to find out all the latest news and trends in NEWS!
Go Play Chapter 3 Link: store.steampowered.com/app/25...
The Amazing BBI Smiling Critters Render Is By [@Bluegamer89] on Twitter/X
Chapters:
0:00 Which Smiling Critter Could Return in Chapter 4?
0:17 Will CatNap Return in Chapter 4?
1:18 Will DogDay Return in Chapter 4?
2:25 Will the Other 6 Critters Return in Chapter 4?
5:45 Where Could They be in Chapter 4?
8:02 Outro/Last Thoughts
Socials:
Twitter Link: / itslightnings
Discord Link: discordapp.com/invite/T4KXyK6
#PoppyPlaytime #poppyplaytimetoys #poppyplaytimechapter4

[@ShipperFireMist]

1188 is Catnap. 1186 is Bobby Bearhug.

[@ItsLightnings]

Ohh dam my bad

[@AbdullahZahid-nt7oq]

Yea I thought that I got false information 😂

[@Theprototype3234]

Pls do bubba bubbaphant

[@josephreinerth9152]

which would mean that 1187 has to be Dogday.

[@andrewsanusi8462]

A part of me feels like Bobby might still be alive since we’ve seen new content with her in the orientation notebook plus in her audio back in chapter 3 we didn’t hear it ending with her screaming or anything just that she doesn’t want to be left behind but hey who knows anything can happen.

[@Livingshadow2009]

I think its bobby also.

[@miguelflores1876]

me too 😁 I thought I was the only one that noticed her not screaming

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah it would make a lot of sense

[@ABAO2009]

either bobby or piggy

[@LambertEdits173]

Picky didn’t scream either.

[@jailenrhine2153]

My money is on Bobby bearing considering she got an experiment report in the handbook as well as having no scream in her cutout like some of the others.

[@DiscoTimelordASD]

However, the handbook said she couldn't talk but THOUGHT she was. Leith remarked in his his interview with Catnap "is his voice box still broken?" meaning that the voice boxes were faulty. However, I concede that the handbook stated that Bobby would need further testing so there's no way to verify how many times Bobby was tested on before the voice boxes would even work. Dogday did have a much more natural sounding voice box than Catnap however (in my opinion) so I think he would have come after Catnap but what do you think on that?

[@ItsLightnings]

True

[@austint4139]

I have a theory that when dogday says “I’m the last of the smiling critters” it’s actually foreshadowing him surviving after catnaps death and us meeting him again

[@ItsLightnings]

Maybe…

[@austint4139]

@@ItsLightnings for evidence look at the critters vhs a moment we overlooked foreshadowed how we meet dogday, who’s to say that can’t happen again with his dialogue

[@leonchacon7984]

Bobby Bearhug is a likely subject to be in chapter 4 Her photo was in the handbook and her audio didn't scream... But Picky Piggy... Could also be in chapter 4 as a hungry piggy... WELL I'm gonna drink lemonade. It's been a while since I done that.

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah let’s hope

[@swordheartstudios]

It could be possible that Bobby Bearhug might make an appearance in Chapter 4 as she was talked about in the Orientation Notebook with her creation.

[@ItsLightnings]

Maybe…

[@NoDingusCG]

What if we had to fight against The Prototype in a final boss-battle like sequence, where he uses the abilities of all the monsters we killed throughout the chapters and are now a part of his body Like Mommy's elastic limbs, CatNap's gas, etc Kinda like our protagonist's sins coming back to bite them in the end

[@OneASK.]

yes I agree. I also have a.. hm, theory, thought? that somewhere before the fight we will be able to create our own hands for the grabpack that will be useful in the fight, I mean at the beginning there will be a tutorial on how to do it and everything, and we will make hands that previously the factory workers wouldn't normally use

[@ItsLightnings]

That would be sooooo cool to see in game

[@Junkyard.Entertainment]

The Official CraftyCorn plush might come on the Mob Store on May 16th because they seem to usually come out every 2 weeks.

[@pallasfuller471]

Why doesn’t he understand that every chapter has a new role and every chapter instead all these smiling critters isn’t it common sense

[@Junkyard.Entertainment]

@@pallasfuller471 ?

[@Kevin_YT1133]

​@@pallasfuller471 he didnt talk about chapter 4, what are u talking about?

[@ItsLightnings]

Let’s see

[@Impendingdoomiedoom]

i actually had a idea that bobby bearhug and craftycorn were important that i posted on twitter based off the logo 4 the cartoon

[@ItsLightnings]

That’s interesting…

[@bxnnybby4430]

This is the first video I've seen from this channel and I love it! I definetly will be a regular around here. Also, I really do think Bobby or Crafty will be showing up at some point. They definitely seem like important characters to the series.

[@ItsLightnings]

Thanks so much 🥹 and Welcome aboard! 👋

[@mirraalex1752]

1:56 we actually see their bodies in the webs of the game station the only one we don't see dead its Pug-A-Pillar!

[@DiscoTimelordASD]

Very true. We have no idea where it ended up.

[@mirraalex1752]

@@DiscoTimelordASD There are multiple as pugs as we see two dead ones in the prototype statue so he could also be on the next or at least another one, we also saw another bunzo bunny so another could also

[@ItsLightnings]

True bc one PJ is not dead it’s been confirmed and Bunzo and the mini huggys still had a off screen death

[@flametrap9529]

5:55 Speaking of that, I'm pretty sure i saw this in the gas production zone map while porting it into blender. I Can't tell where exactly but i'm gonna tell it later when i find it again edit: it's on the left above the warning sign after we enter the gas production zone

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah it’s pretty interesting

[@SirMegaStudio]

I hope to see dogday being a good guy in chapter 4

[@ItsLightnings]

Sameee

[@connorgaskin8811]

I hope that both Bobby Bearhug and Craftycorn are alive, and will helping us in chapter 4.

[@Takilicious17]

i don’t know about craftycorn cause one of pickypiggy line says that she might have eaten her but bobby bearhug i can see her help us

[@connorgaskin8811]

@@Takilicious17 that's just a cuttboard line, who knows. Maybe my theory might be right.

[@ItsLightnings]

Same

[@Takilicious17]

We don’t know we just have to see and find out

[@KalinTheZola]

I don't think any of them will be showing up again outside of art much like most of the cast from the other games. They had their purpose in chapter 3 and they fulfilled it

[@8The-angel8]

I think that too

[@TheHoppyOfHopscotch]

New characters for each chapter.

[@ItsLightnings]

That makes sense

[@richardmiller7705]

I feel like the failed bigger bodies were just either left to rot or replaced with more successful versions so I feel we could see something like that Bobby Bearhug we see in the orientation notebook. Maybe as another devoted believer in the prototype but has no power to help him in anyway

[@ItsLightnings]

That seems possible

[@project_KickinChicken]

Am I the only one who want to see what the bigger body versions of all the smiling critters?

[@TheHoppyOfHopscotch]

Nah, you’re not the only one

[@ItsLightnings]

I do too

[@TransportLife397]

Same I want to see their official models not fan made models I want to know what they looked like and what Dogday looked like with his legs on whether he stood up like a human or was on all 4s

[@IdonthaveFriends72]

yeah it would be weird as hell to mob just show 7 new characters. only to show 1 dying, kill another offscreen and forget abt the rest-

[@TheHoppyOfHopscotch]

The critters are probably all dead, so a new cast of characters come in for the next chapter. (Following the theme of new characters per chapter.) But if anyone, there are three that even have a chance at being alive: Picky, Crafty, and Bobby, because they didn’t have super dramatic screams in the cutouts. :/ But it was a fun theory to *hop* into, don’t get me wrong.

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah it makes the most sense

[@paulamontesinos7300]

I hope we see Kickin chicken he’s my second favorite after dog day cat nap is my third favorite and we’ve already seen dog day and catnap in monster form!

[@ItsLightnings]

Same

[@FraminghamStubbs]

Catnap is dead, Dogday said he was the last of the smiling critters, but it would be interesting to have an another encounter with him. For the others, idk, Chapter 4 is gonna have the focus set on the new antagonist rather than a returning smiling critter

[@ItsLightnings]

Dang

[@jeremyhenry7600]

Whenever we go to the labs, we'll probably find a couple of failed experiments locked in cells. It wouldn't surpise me if Bobby's body was among them.

[@ItsLightnings]

Maybe..

[@WPFLAWLESS]

As someone who's witnessed A LOT of my favorite bands / groups break up saying 'the smiling critters are no more' doesn't HAVE to mean they've died.

[@ItsLightnings]

Fr

[@PixelatedHoppy]

Bro I always appear at the beginning of the video. "hOp" and I'm there 😭

[@ItsLightnings]

Yes you are

[@EVANmelton-fv9of]

The thumbnail looks so good!

[@ItsLightnings]

Thanks :)

[@biancacoffey4913]

I think all of the other six are alive, why else release the plushies ? Possibly to tease the order we see them ? The Bobby plush did release after catnap and Dogday.

[@ItsLightnings]

That would make sense but… money XD

[@Axelfnaf200]

I think that out of all the smiling critters picky seems the most likely to get a brief apperince due to in the cardbord cutout she states eating the other smiling critters

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah that’s reasonable

[@neverlandtails]

Foreshadowing. Remember the small bobby bearhug we saw in the security clip and how she was walking through the smiling critters prison? What if the next game IS about the prison/lab theories and the foreshadowing part is we finally get to meet the bigger bodies bobby bear hug?

[@ItsLightnings]

That’s true…

[@jonathanaguilar5380]

I love the video never stop being you ❤

[@ItsLightnings]

Thanks so much 🥹

[@ThunderBZaper]

I feel like the last living members of the Smiling Critters would be DogDay, Bobby, PickyPiggy, and CraftyCorn.

[@ItsLightnings]

Possibly

[@skunkman9815]

I think pickypiggy should return because she didn’t get killed by catnap, but she did get fattened up, if she’s still alive i think it should be like that one scene from slither where the character brenda is now a bloated meat balloon

[@jhenderson2159]

Picky: *proceeds to explode into a swarm of Mini Critters* Someone at Playtime Co would be fucked up enough to find alternatives into getting new toys while being inconspicuous

[@ItsLightnings]

That would be so cool to see

[@user-cq2cu6jb3k]

Bobby bearhug, hoppy hopscotch, crafty corn, and picky piggy might still be alive

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah

[@Catland2914]

I have a few theories why Dogday is dead and possibly catnap being alive Dogday could be dead because the mini smiling critters devoured his organs so they are possibly controlling his brain now. Catnap could be Alive mabye that was a dream in the game he put gas on us but we thought we were awake when he got stabbed maybe it was a dream and he stole our arm and maybe Ollie knew that for some reason idk but maybe he lied to make us think we were safe this theory is mostly known but I think catnap might be alive

[@ItsLightnings]

Those are some good ones

[@Catland2914]

@@ItsLightningsthanks

[@Recommend20]

0:29 don’t be too still, mind you that before 1008 stabbed catnap, catnap blew us large amount of red smoke and the whole area is soaked in red smoke, we’re not sure if the things that we saw was real.

[@ItsLightnings]

We still lost the green hand how was that fake

[@jackdejarnatt5698]

I have a theory that Craftycorn may still be alive and that she was never evil. She was probably suffering loss because of her friends being killed by CatNap. I also think that she never killed Bubba and KickinChicken (because Pickypiggy did), instead, she may have killed one of Miss Delight's sisters to protect herself since they went insane, and she used their blood to paint on the walls to warn us about the Playcare

[@ItsLightnings]

That’s a good theory but I guess only time will tell

[@jackdejarnatt5698]

@@ItsLightnings true

[@DefokoAFK]

Since it was confirmed that Dogday's position in the intro animation was a spoiler for how it turned out, I kept wondering if something like that happens with the others... How Kickin, like Dogday, is missing his legs and his position doesn't seem as strange as the others, maybe Catnap tore off his legs and fed them to Picky as a punishment for trying to escape or I don't know. .. I don't know how to explain it well but I'm sure Bobby is alive and I kind of agree with that kickin too. XD

[@ItsLightnings]

That’s an interesting theory…. And don’t worry I get it 👍

[@DefokoAFK]

@@ItsLightnings omg thank you very much 😭

[@angelicafigueroa0221]

Going by the cardboard cutouts and how they could indicate whos all alive and who isn't it seems that Hoppy Hopscotch an Kickin Chicken died or were attacked in their attempts to leave, Picky piggy could be our antagonist as it seems they attacked the others, the unicorn is probably still looking for more "red paint" so thats nice And Bobby Bear hug, now they could be our ally, because they wanted to come with us, almost like a partner would sound like, but who knows they could feel resentment at seeing us again if they're still alive and not let us leave Maybe like Poppy they'll help us to the exit only to turn on us and leave is behind like we apparently did everyone else

[@ItsLightnings]

That would make a lot of sense

[@Livingshadow2009]

Got a feeling it will be either an insane Bron who was NEVER let out of his prison, or an insane bobby bear hug. it gave us info that bobby was going through many operations. at no point, did it say bobby was destroyed, only that bobby was screaming and didn't realise no one could hear, and that bobby needed to be 'fixed' since it couldn't really move. For all we know bobby was 'fixed', or bobby learnt how to make do with what it had. Also, if chapter 4 is set at an amusement park. A bear is kind of fitting. If its a prison/lab...still fits.

[@ItsLightnings]

That will be interesting to see

[@elfnafdecarckholaqhace]

Really good video I like it

[@ItsLightnings]

I'm glad you like it

[@rebeca6414]

Seeing Bobby bear hug like that is so sad

[@ItsLightnings]

Fr :(

[@jenniferhanses]

Cat Nap died on screen. Dog Day also died on screen (we saw the little critters eat him from the inside out and then pilot his body after eating the brain. . Kicken Chicken is dead according the the audio signs found in Chapter 3. His voice log indicates this, as does Picky Pig's Bubbphant is dead according to Picky Pig's log. Crafty Corn is dead according to Picky Pigs log. The Rabbit (blanking on the name ) died attempting to jump off of high things to an even higher point. So that leaves us with the ravenous Picky Pig possibly still around, though I think the Pig and the Dog would have fought. Or the Pig and the Cat. Because the Pig would have tried to eat them. And clearly it did not succeed. And Bobby Bearhug, who according to the audio signs is lost somewhere. There's no death flags, Picky doesn't record eating her, and there's no indication anyone else killed her. So she has the highest odds of still being alive and just not in the Playcare any longer. Though it's entirely possible Cat Nap gassed the Pig and locked her up still alive.

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah that’s all possible but I guess time will tell

[@nediajones7231]

Seeing how close this supposed lab location is to the playcare it wouldn't be too much of a surprise for the other creatures to hide down there from Catnap

[@ItsLightnings]

Fr

[@Blazen0214]

Subscribed. Get that 50k

[@ItsLightnings]

Welcome aboard! Thanks so much

[@TheManBehindTheSlaughter87]

Bobby might return and probably picky too

[@ItsLightnings]

Maybe…

[@nediajones7231]

I think craftycorn bobbyBearhug and pickypiggy are still alive because they're Cutouts don't scream or have some dialog after the scream

[@ItsLightnings]

Maybe m..

[@znm2106]

I also think your plush will come June for bubba

[@ItsLightnings]

I hope so

[@Vanessacat2942]

Maybe Picky Piggy or Bobby

[@ItsLightnings]

Maybe

[@hellbot.9666]

I feel like Bobby might be in Project Playtime along with Catnap and Miss Delight because they have been hinting at her a lot.

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah fr

[@Godzila787]

Can you do more merch News vidios

[@ItsLightnings]

We need more merch for that

[@baybay468]

Love you video

[@ItsLightnings]

Thanks

[@SakuraStarKey]

If the smiling critters are truly dead then they are probably added to the Prototypes build body… I mean it has been collecting dead bodies of toys and probably peoples remains too… 😨

[@TheHoppyOfHopscotch]

That’s how prototype works

[@ItsLightnings]

That will be interesting to see

[@themoviestudios6688]

What are your thoughts on Dog Day?

[@ItsLightnings]

I have a full video on him lol

[@project_KickinChicken]

I hope we see Kickin chicken

[@ItsLightnings]

Sameeee

[@escape_the_atmosfear9193]

I'm hoping, catnap with dog day because they are both loveable characters.

[@ItsLightnings]

Sameee

[@somebodythatiusetoknow2027]

I hope no any smiling critter dies permanently for the next chapter as I’d be devastated. I just hope Catnap and Co will be happily ever after 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@ItsLightnings]

I hope so too 🥺

[@Randomatgames]

I have a theory that hoppy is olie because the text is green and the door that they send you the key the hoppy thing is right next to that... but idk Tell me if I am wrong

[@TheHoppyOfHopscotch]

You’re onto something

[@Takilicious17]

hoppy is female and olie is male and at the end of her cutout she screamed so i don’t think she alive even though she one of my favorites

[@ItsLightnings]

That’s…actually pretty good but… hoppy is a girl.. and Ollie is a boy

[@TheHoppyOfHopscotch]

@@ItsLightnings Oh yeah that’s a small little major detail

[@Takilicious17]

Yeah

[@ILoveZeke]

They won’t show up again, dogday said that they are all dead

[@ItsLightnings]

:(

[@Songal18]

Yeah I think the prison/lab will be shown in Chapter 4...maybe the final resting place for all the Smiling Critters or the ones that weren't possibly killed already by CatNap if they were heretics like DogDay but rebelled more.

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah it would make a lot of sense

[@Songal18]

@@ItsLightnings It would, but probably too much to hope for. Though maybe we'll get something connected to the rest of the smiling critters?

[@elizabethperez4975]

Bro your my favorite KZbinr keep up the good work

[@ItsLightnings]

I appreciate that thanks so much 🥹

[@SQUISHYCANDYGUT]

Catnap is 1188 XD

[@ItsLightnings]

lol my bad XD

[@dragonboi173]

What's your favorite dinosaur

[@ItsLightnings]

Bronnn

[@prabhjotkaur6613]

Wow good

[@ItsLightnings]

Thanks

[@arminhorvath4957]

None of them, cause its basically confirmed that they died.

[@ItsLightnings]

Not 100% tho

[@arminhorvath4957]

@@ItsLightnings praying

[@Gamemusic56723]

I hope hoppy or catnap who do you??

[@REAL_DEAL_VR]

Hoppy

[@TheHoppyOfHopscotch]

Sorry, too dead :/

[@ItsLightnings]

I hope them all

[@FreddyandFriendsAdventure]

I think catnap made picky piggy eat the dead bodies of the other smiling critters

[@ItsLightnings]

Maybe…

[@FreddyandFriendsAdventure]

@@ItsLightnings I think that because in picky piggy’s cardboard cutout she starts naming foods that resemble the other smiling critters

[@user-md3vk7zu8o]

What you need to replay poppy playtime chapter 3 because dog day says catnap and dog day or the last of the critters so basically the smiling critters they're not alive they're dead so basically there's no smiling critter anymore😐

[@ItsLightnings]

I saw that in the video but cat nap was still alive when he said that soo… who knows

[@BlizzyAndUnknown]

Catnap is a love cause the red smoke

[@ItsLightnings]

We still lost the green hand

[@jordyncooper5190]

Cat has 9 lives

[@Takilicious17]

but not catnap cause he has a kid inside not a actual cat

[@ItsLightnings]

lol

[@Takilicious17]

Lol

[@overpoweredgaming6432]

Yea I also think dog day is still alive

[@ItsLightnings]

Sweet

[@Mige210]

Do you think chapter 6 is the end?!

[@ItsLightnings]

Maybe 5

[@BrandonAgee-sq5ez]

Review the new bendy and the ink machine figures and plushies

[@ItsLightnings]

I need to fine them first

[@BrandonAgee-sq5ez]

K

[@ubahabdiosman9397]

0:13 💀

[@ItsLightnings]

XD

[@ubahabdiosman9397]

XD

[@Theprototype3234]

Pls do bubba bubbaphant

[@ItsLightnings]

Wdym?

[@jhasegaris8]

Hi

[@ItsLightnings]

Hiii

[@Catnap_real]

Fun fact not a fact: but you saw catnap used red Gas On the player it was enough to give a illusion , but I’m probably wrong

[@ItsLightnings]

We still lost the green hand

[@Catnap_real]

@@ItsLightnings he used the red gas before that happed I don’t know how to explain it, but

[@dipfish1427]

dogday litteraly said he was the last one besides catnap ofc

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah but who knows..

[@dipfish1427]

@@ItsLightnings true true

[@JubyArceo-dy8du]

dogday

[@ItsLightnings]

:0

[@AbdullahTahirYt.]

I Think Dogday Is Still Alive And CatNap Is Dead

[@ItsLightnings]

Looks like it

[@8The-angel8]

They are all dead

[@ItsLightnings]

That’s probably true

[@sonicteamplushchannel]

i think it is a not real cuz he put red gas out🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@ItsLightnings]

That’s why lol XD we lost the green hand it was real

[@huggywug1984]

yeah it's Right lightning Catnap is DEAD Theres no way he is still alive after getting electrocuted, burned and then stabbed in the Mouth by 1006 Sorry to say this but yeah catnap is 💯 DEAD

[@ItsLightnings]

Fr 👍

[@REAL_DEAL_VR]

🍔

[@ItsLightnings]

🍔

[@janaplankova1421]

Okay huggy wuggy ths not derd

[@ItsLightnings]

Yep

[@Rainbow_Playz99]

FIRST

[@ItsLightnings]

Yeah you are

[@TheBlupellerAnimates]

e

[@ItsLightnings]

E

[@rebeccadeaton269]

Hi

[@ItsLightnings]

Hii