Who REALLY Killed Hussain RA?

• For more info on the 'Muslim Survival Guide' go to
MuslimSurvivalGuide.com
• To donate, go to
www.gofundme.com/wg33tjdw

[@mahmoodtajar9937]

''husain is from me and i am from husain!....said the Messenger of Allah a,s,!

[@pakiboyjay5524]

bottom line is common sense..you dont even dare fight the family of the prophet pbuh.. I dont care wether sunni or shia.. who ever killed em n was even involved in anyway is responsible. .going to war with the prophets family is like going to war with the prophet phuh himself

[@axd2312]

Brother why have you Titled it "Killed" Hussain Was martyred not Killed

[@sandarabian]

Imagine one who slanders and hates the companions and wives of our beloved sAllahu alayhi wa sallam and at the same time expect for him to intercede for them on the day of judgement. SubhanAllah al-adheem

[@mahfuzahmed4550]

Imam Hasan & Hussain RA = the leaders of the youth in Jannah

[@linkzero4653]

Abu Bakr & Umar (May Allah be pleased with them) = The leaders of the elders in Jannah (excluding prophets)

[@Saracen-oq6ew]

Your Abu bakr & Umar (May Allah curse them) = The companions of Shaitan in Jahnam.

[@melru301]

Leaders in Jannah ? What about the prophet(s) ya kafir!, you lot think the prophet of God would leave out anything as big and important if the s7aba even his wife would betray him, Allah would've let him know that just like he let him know about husseins(AS) fate... what do u follow ? What book ?? Cause it is not the Quran, you have absolutely no guidance except for what ur lying imams of hell fire tell you, you are a lost people, run back to Allah! And Allah alone, your deviants like the khawarij no longer in the fold of Islam.

[@iicrywheniipoo]

Why do you hate Abu Bakr and Umar so much? If Aisha is referred to as the 'Mother of believers' in the Qur'an, how can you curse her? Allah is calling her the MOTHER of BELIEVERS and you people are calling her a whore and bitch, etc.

[@mahfuzahmed4550]

Umar Ali Brother, I love the Sahaba AND Ahlul Bayt (But the Prophet SAW more than them of course). Abu Bakr RA, Umar RA, Uthman RA and Ali RA were the rightly guided caliphs of the Rashidun Khilafah. I'm a Sunni. I do not curse Aisha RA either. The shia hate her because of a false rumour they heard. And Auzubillah, get rid of those disgusting words which the deviant ones use to describe her. Aisha RA is one of the best Muslimahs to have ever lived. To everyone: Don't judge someone's aqeedah when you don't even know it!

[@ArslaanIrshad47]

I am Sunni, I cry for Hussain r.a!! Yazeed was worst of creature!!

[@wzulmai]

Well said. I only wish that more of our imams & masjids actually mention, talk about or at least have a khutba once on Imam Husayn (ra) & the ahlul bayt. In Sahih Muslim, the prophet (saws) tells us we should hold onto 2 things after him. The Qur'an & his ahlul bayt. May the blessings & peace be upon ALL the ahlul bayt.

[@Ahmed-nz1rw]

"Oh mankind, you came from a drop of semen, and you’ll leave as a piece of dust. You don’t know when you came, and you don’t know when you’re going. So why do you walk around like you know everything" Ali Ibn Abi Talib (a.s)

[@MrTechnologyCentral]

Isnt it crazy how the people who claim that they love hussein and ahul bait are the one that betrayed them. Learned a lot from this video thanks akhi

[@joemark5030]

+MrTechnologyCentral er the shia and the people of kufa are two different groups. The Kuffans invited hussain, then betrayed him but the modern day shia are followers of the shia of medina, ie the people who supported ali after the death of the prophet. The people of kuffa are not shias,

[@shiaman3538]

+MrTechnologyCentral Most of what is presented in this video is fairly accurate. However there are some things ommitted and need to be discussed. The Good: - Fairly accurate portrayal of the events that transpired related to Karbala and martrydom of Imam Hussain (as). - Shimr ibn DulJawshan guilty - Ubaidullah Ibn Ziyad guilty - Sinan ibn Anas guilty - Umar ibn Sa'ad guilty - Kufans treachory - Kufans guilty The Bad: - Giving Muawiya a pass on creating fitna in the ummah by going to war against Imam Ali as. There are numerous hadith from the Prophet about only hypocrites hating Imam Ali and you only go to war against someone you hate. It was narrated that 'Ali said: "The Prophet [SAW] made a covenant with me that none would love me but a believer, and none would hate me but a hypocrite." Sunan an-Nasa'i » The Book Of Faith and its Signs Chapter: The Sign of a Hypocrite Book 47, Hadith 38 Narrated Al-Musawir Al-Himyari: from his mother who said: "I entered upon Umm Salamah, and I heard her saying: "The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) used to say: "No hypocrite loves 'Ali, and no believer hates him." Jami` at-Tirmidhi » Chapters on Virtues Vol. 1, Book 46, Hadith 3717 - Not mentioning that in the Peace agreement between Muawiya and Imam Hassan, the Caliphate would return to Imam Hassan as after Muawiya. - not mentioning that Yazid's edict to the Governor of Medina was to either get Imam Hussain's bayah or his head - failure to mention the brutality with which Imam Hussain was killed. He attacked the army of Umar ibn Sa'ad several times but they could not pin him down. He was shot with arrows; they threw spears and stones. He had so many arrows struck that when he fell from the horse his body didnt touch the ground but rested on arrows. Sinan and Shimr severed his head while he was alive. Post-death, his body was trampled with horses. The Ugly: - Failure to mention the vices and debauchery of Yazid. - Not holding Yazid responsible for Imam Hussain's martrydom. There may be a case for absolving Yazid had he punished Ibn Ziyad and his men but instead Yazid rewarded them. - If Yazid was not guilty, why were the Holy Progeny (Ahlul-Bayt) held captives, paraded from Karbala -> Kufa -> Sham. They were imprisoned in Sham. This included the Prophet granddaughter Zainab bint Ali (sister of Imam Hussain) and others. Why were they kept outside the palace gates for over 24 hours while the palace was decorated. - Did Yazid not say, "there was no wahi, Bani Hashim merely played a trick for Caliphate". - Did Yazid not boast about his victory and did Hussain's son not reply that "As long as people say Mohammad rasoolallah" in azaan the victory was Hussain's and Islam's. - Would the Prophet (saw) forgive Yazid for these transgressions? - How can you say, "We neither curse Yazid nor do we praise him"? What will it take to curse Yazid? - Let's say your love for the Ahlul-Bayt is not as profoud as you claim and you have forgiven Yazid for killing HuUssain and imprisoning the Prophet's family. Do you forgive Yazid for killing thousands of sahaba, tabaeen and taba-tabaeen in Medina? Do you forgive Yazid for his army raping over 10,000 daughters of Medina. Do you forgive Yazid for treating Masjid Nabawi as a stable for his horses? Medina's properties and women were made mubah to Yazid's army for 3 days, you forgive that? Please google Harra or Harrah - So now lets you don't love the Prophet and Sahaba as much either and forgive Yazid. Do you also forgive him for besieging Mecca and firebombing the Kaaba? - Basically you have forgiven Yazid for attacking Allah, the Prophet and his Ahlul-Bayt. You did a good job in presenting the history but saying you dont curse Yazid is an absolute disgrace. Why not hold Yazid culpable? What are you afraid of? I know exactly why you want to 'forgive' Yazid but would love to hear your reasons for it?

[@hahahahaha1385]

+rafidhi X ignore the wobbler

[@M-O-H-A-Y]

So after all of the analysis you still came out with the conclusion that the Shias killed Hussain a.s. rather than Yazeed or Ibn Ziyad? Let's just stick to the idea that the Shias did kill Hussain but what about the Battle of Harrah???? I would love to see who you blame, for the other atrocities committed by Yazid in Medina (when his army killed the families of the companions, including mass rape) and when he burnt down the Kabba (the holiest site for Muslims). Do you care to analyse that? What about battle of Jamal when the wife of the prophet went to battle with the rightfully elected Caliph of her time??? Care to analyse that??? By your logic would that not make her directly responsible for the killing of over 20,000 Muslims? Wallahi you think you are doing your religion a favour when you purposely and knowingly defend the bastard that was Yazeed and his henchmen by shifting the blame on to those who could not help due to Ibn Ziyads presence in Kufa but Allah is more just.

[@user-ez5kq7yt9y]

Thank you so much, because I never knew about Karbala. May Allah SWT reward you :)

[@ALI-om2re]

"We the the Ahlul Sunnah are the real party of Imam Husain because we didnt turn our back on Imam Husain" . 80 percent of Imam Husains army was from kufa. Where were the great companions that he mentioned that " didn't want to get involved".The position of Ahlul Sunnah is we didn't want to get involved? Was Sad ibn waqas also part of the army of UbaidAllah ibn Ziyad? Didnt Abdullah ibn Umar give bayt and warned everyone to give bayt to yazid or die the death of ignorance. No doubt the people of Kufa turned their backs and will be answerable on the day of judgment. There is also no doubt ibn Ziyad killed those who tried to make it to Imam Hussain or imprisoned them. To suggest that Imam Hussain did this for worldly rule is false for Imam Hussain said im doing this to enjoin good and forbid evil, to revive the Sunnah of my Grandfather and my Father. If your a companion who knew Imam Hussain would be martyred or a layman from Kufa who knew Imam Husain would be martyred and didn't go and join the Imam, they have to take their fair share of the blame and will be answerable on the day of judgement because Husain is from the Prophet and the Prophet is from Husain, and many traditions that show there is no doubt that Husain is was in the right. The question which position do we take in 2016. Also to say mourning for Imam Husain started from those who turned there back is propaganda. Any one who has heart mourned for Imam Husain. We the shia don't mourn because a fringe group mourned Imam Hussain in Kufa. We mourn because the Household of Imam Husain mourned and we mourn with them till today. Allah's blessing on Mohammed and the Family of Mohammed!

[@sharps8726]

The Story of Karbala even makes you cry when you tell it in your wayward style

[@blackturban2566]

Why did you not mention ali asghar the son of hussain (RA).

[@McProductionzTV]

If your praying for Allah to forgive both armies then who's side are you really on?

[@VAPOURIZE100]

Plz rename this video 'who martyred Hussain r.a?' That is the only rightful way to put it. Any other way to put the incident of Karbala is demeaning

[@ShawdiR]

This is so wrong. If you really wanted to seek what's true you would look at multiple sources and use your aql. This is sad.

[@jeffstar58]

The army of yazid fired arrows at imam hussain a.s they did not pray with imam hussain a.s

[@camilyare7089]

May Allah increase your Knowledge, wisdon and Taqwa. May Allah protect you and your family. Jazaka allahu khayran.

[@yusraahmed7629]

thank you for guiding me back to my sense

[@ajazahmad7498]

Masha Allah every single thing happens only and only by the supreme will of Allah !!!!!!!

[@mohamedhabib4521]

Could I please have the sources you've consulted and got these narrations from please. Would highly appreciate it. Jazakallah

[@IronPearlCHI]

Mashalla beautiful video!

[@junaidshareef9670]

wallahi gt tears when u were narrating that hussain ra face was being poked... subhanallah its very saddening and eye opener

[@hamzahjameel1348]

and he doesn't cry. SAD WALLAHI SAD!

[@IGamesNetherlands]

I can see in your eyes that you love Muawiya more than Ali (RA)

[@mk-mk1hj]

off course he does remember you cant love both imam ALI a.s and his enemys. as QURAN says you have one heart not two.

[@SS-xs5vd]

Officially Iroh Equally how can claim you love the Ahlul Bayt more than him when you adopt display pictures depicting them with feminine features?

[@ajazahmad7498]

Thank u so much brother! This story was always a lil contradictory in my mind thanks for clearing any doubts

[@abshamtally]

Aslmlkm. Masha Allah very interesting bits to ponder. Could you please recomend a good book on the history of islam.. jzk

[@jeffstar58]

Imam hussain a.s was a lion and an unstoppable force of God they were scared to attack the imam a.s and by the way imam hussain never dropped his sword he only let go when Allah SWT game imam hussain a.s the sign to drop the weapon and return to the al mighty SWT

[@imranpatel7836]

Great video brother. Alot of knowledge was provided which i didn't really know.

[@chptr3]

Next video on battle of al-Harrah please bro. Looking forward to your explanation of Yazid's command to sack, rape and slaughter the people Medinah a few years after Karbala. Or is it his generals fault again?

[@firstatomoneatom2481]

Iv never really understood the elders like my dad and uncles talking about this situation when I was at a younger age, but thanks to brother Imran I completely get now. May Allah grant you jannah al firdous

[@Super-xl3yy]

Shias are not Muslims

[@HadeelMaksoud]

Jazak Allah khair Brother Imran. May Allah grant you and your team jannat elFirdaus in shaa Allah. I benefitted greatly from this video. May Allah forgive us and make us of those that never turn our backs on Him or His messengers and their descendants in shaa Allah.

[@md.110]

I think youll benefit more from hearing the actual story not the sugar coated one that skips the thirst, arrows on him and his familys body, the killing of his BABY and the head on a spear.

[@mumbailife2023]

I think till judgement day it will b a mystery for all of us what exactly happen and who is solely responsible for Karbala. 1 thing what I know is we should just love Allah and panjetan paak and stop arguing and wasting time.

[@nafeesa1236]

this was really interesting and informative and the basics of what happened. kind of makes sooo much sense, thank you! please if you get a chance do a follow up video on what happened after... when did the people of kufa start feeling bad/guilt... was yazid a good leader like his father or not?

[@queenbee2229]

But much respect for bringing light to this situation. Many sunnis don't acknowledge this becauese they think it's only a thing for shias. Jazak allah khair

[@Prinxali]

Does this speaker ever back up anything he says or claims? Why is he so anti-shia? He speaks against Shias in an extremely disrespectful manner, it's so disappointing!

[@shazhussain1351]

I am astounded (but unsurprised) by the inaccuracy and narrow level of knowledge. The characters of Muawiyah and Yazid can be proven from revered Sunni books and given that we will rise behind our Imam's, I wouldn't want to be in their camps...

[@muhammadjamil4174]

SubhannAllah, May Allah (SWT) forgive all our and their sins.. Ameen.

[@Fahimkarranikhan]

I cried at the end brother

[@peaceeverywhere4627]

Jazak Allah Khair

[@zahrah4145]

You know what breaks my heart? That all you people know what REALLY happened in Karbala but you still continue to follow the teachings and ways of the person that created all that fitna.

[@gamersalman1234]

Zahra Hussaini can you tell me where in the Quran it says to hit yourself for Hussain (RA)

[@sulaymaanqureshi1156]

Zahra Hussaini why don't you become qadiani at least they do not lie

[@zahrah4145]

Money Maker Is that the only thing you can use against us? Us hitting ourselves? We beat our chest lightly to express our love and pain for Imam Hussain's (AS) tragic death. There is a hadith by Imam Sajjad which explains why Imam Hussain (AS) didn't forbid his sister Zainab (AS) from crying and beating her chest when she found out that he was going to be martyred the night before Ashura. He simply told her to have patience. Now, will you honestly tell me that the prophets family would go against the teachings of the Prophet (SAWS) and openly commit a 'sin'? I don't think so.

[@zahrah4145]

Sulaymaan Qureshi What?

[@haneenz1032]

+Money Maker can you tell me where in the quran it says to offer two rakat for fajr prayers? can you show me where it mentions taraweeh prayers?

[@riyaz827]

Salam, I left a comment on ur video that has now been deleted, it was a question about salafi, you gave a me a link to watch but I can't remember which video it was 😬, please can u help?

[@ammar741]

it may be helpfull to use the annotaations to correct where u mention hassan radiallahutaalaan instead of hussain radiallahutaalaan as it confused me abit

[@none23517]

His hand gestures are amazing. All the time he uses his hands to show things

[@mrahman1992]

Yazid also has significant liability and has a lot of blood on his hands, he intentionally sent someone he knew to be a ruthless bloodthirsty tyrant to deal with Hussain (ra), he was ultimately responsible for the actions of those he placed in charge. If you send Michael Myers to someones house, you cannot then claim you are not responsible when people end up murdered in that house. Also we should not regret the people of Kufa betraying Hussain (ra), it happened as God willed and Hussain (ra) was better off without such evil people by his side.

[@SuperCatwoman09]

Well done brother!

[@durwaish2]

I think everyone who know Urdu language should search Molana Ishaq on this topic. He has very good lectures and understand why Husaain RA took his family and how he change the course Islam and history. please listen to his lectures as Muslim.

[@ha3zim]

9.26 into the video I can't take it no more, so many times he R.A. on muawia pretty much every time he mentioned him vs. Immam Hassan a.s., and the two leader bullcrap one in Kufa one in Shaam is cuz he did Fight a war aginst Ali a.s. he did not obey the 4. Halifa's order of giving up the position, ppl did not love him and respected him as a leader for the same reasons as they loved and respected the Ahli Bayt. I just cant't listen to the whole thing till the end it hurts my soul hearing such things soooo much praise from the get go for the wicked one vs. Immam Hasan a.s. disliked the fighting so much started describing him next to a spineless weakling....Estagfirulah

[@sharps8726]

Can you expand on the treaty between Hasan Ra and Muwiya. No offence you are not making any sense.

[@AS-iz3ts]

re-uploaded?? already watched it

[@lulwaabdalla3607]

this was so interesting, barakallhu feek

[@aliataya5675]

bro your welcome to any of our mosques to be educated on the true events of karbala for your own knowledge and inspiration all based on facts and references from the book don't take offense to this comment please Salam

[@rayhanshah2624]

MAY ALLAAH GUIDE YOU TO THE PATH OF MOHAMMAD AND THE FAMILY OF MOHAMMAD AND REMOVE YOU FROM THE PATH OF MUNAFIQEEN! ANY ONE WHO FIGHTS ADAM NOOH IBRAHEEM MUSA ISA AND THERE FAMILIES ARE IN TROUBLE THINK BEFORE YOU SPEAK DONT SPEAK AND THEN THINK THATS THE PROBLEM OF MUSLIMS THEY TALK BUT HAVE NO WISDOM YA ALLAAH SEND IMAM AL MAHDI AS AND ISA AS YA ALLAAH REMOVE OUR PROBLEMS. SALAM DONT TAKE OFFENCE I DONT MEAN TO OFFEND.

[@Mr14striker]

Why is this reuploaded ?

[@UrduAnalyst]

What is see here in comments is muslim fighting a muslim.i wish we could get united to fight the enemies of islam rather then pointing fingers at eachother. Oh my dear Islam may Allah bless u.

[@therealabdirahman]

I love you so much akhi I hope you see this. I loved this video please make on about zain alabudeen or Ali R.A . we would like to know their stories if possible

[@syedali-rs8cj]

no shimr ibn Jawshawn killed Imam hussain a.s. on orders from Ibn Ziyad l.a. the governor of Kufa, who worked for Yazid ibn Mu'awyiyah.

[@LabeikyaAbbas]

+syed ali The beauty of Imam Hussain a.s sacrifice is that it will never be hidden, and wallah it will hang like a noose to the necks of the followers of Yazid

[@aabisali523]

Ya hussain

[@sanjaybari]

Please can you do a video on who really killed Ali RA, please.

[@thebestfive632]

My dear brother plz read a bit more honestly, plz brother!!

[@yaldaz4217]

This video is honestly disgusting, at the same time he is saying 'may Allah be pleased with them' to the traitors and oppressors of Islam, his mentality is exactly like ISIS. It's because of videos like this, and teachings like this, shias are being killed and persecuted,. It's because of videos like this the followers of ahlul bayt are being killed for their beliefs. Perhaps if he feared God and feared his own sins he wouldn't cast any judgement on another group of Muslims, stating your opinion is fine but it's to the point where you are almost segregating and skapegoating your fellow brethren and are crossing the line. May Allahs curse forever be upon the oppressors of the ahlul bayt. May Allah withdraw his mercury from the oppressors of the ahlul bayt. Ya Allah, Ya Muhammad, Ya Ali, Ya Zahra, Ya Hassan, Ya Hussain 💚💚💚

[@bahjakoshin1073]

subhanaALLAH my almighty guide you. You are putting ALLAH and makhluuq at the same time in your pray. and second thing, you people you have to stop dividing Muslims in you own way. the prophet (SAW)never pointed anyone when he was dying. the sahabaas choose ababakar and you people you are arguing over nothing. it's sahabaas's choice. who are we to talk about while the religion is for all not a particular people. no ahlu bayt no any other family. our religion fights with tribalism. so stop tribalism if you really saying you Muslim

[@alim-rk7nx]

Is it sahaba's choice or the Rasool's (saw) choice? You're chatting shit bro

[@at3717]

salam bro Imran i love you and i have learnt a lot from you and i believe whatever you do is to please Allah s.w. I just want to remind you that the prophet ignored controversy and focused on the truth, he did not spend his time campaigning against or collecting evidence to expose Abu lahab, or abu jahl, he did not even expose the munafiqoon in madinah. you can choose to spend 10 minutes explaining tawheed or you can spend 5 minustes exposing every single type of shirk that exists today (which will cost you millions of minutes). so stick to that 10 minutes job and all of shirk will be defeated without even mentioning them. may Allah keep you safe and guide us all.

[@yeahbuddy9046]

real leaders of islam real role models

[@user-qn5bn7pm9l]

Love Abu Bakr(ra) Love Umar(ra) Love Uthman(ra) Love Ali(ra) Love Muawiyah(ra) Cause the Prophet(saw) loved them.

[@JustinCredible786]

I am guessing you've taken out the parts where you repeated yourself like 3-4 times?

[@RighteousnRich]

+Justin Credible yes :| sorry about that

[@JustinCredible786]

Naseeha Sessions No problem, I kinda liked it like that though.

[@opocoyo]

+Naseeha Sessions Baarak Allahu feek for this. I learnt a lot Alhamdulilah. On the previous channel, before it was deleted, there were a lot of beneficial videos addressing issues facing the youth especially. Things like pornography, relationships, peer pressure and the so on. Please consider discussing these topics again as I think they'd be of enormous benefit. I wanted to share some with my siblings but unfortunately, they're no longer available. Jazzakillahu khier.

[@shiaman3538]

atif ghalani This guy clearly said Yazid is neither cursed nor praised. I dont get it! His people attacked teh grandson of the prophet, then imprisoned the survivors. Then he attacked Medina, then Mecca and you absolve him of all his crimes. I blamethe ppl of Kufa too, and Ibn Ziyad and Umar ibn Sa'ad and Shimr. But the root cause of all is Yazid. And matam and beating is not changin aqeedah. And even if it is, there is such a thing as good bidah per Caliph Umar.

[@talalsiddiqui2061]

+Shia Man We don't curse Muslims, and we don't love people who do evil things. Matam IS changing Aqeedah, because when our Prophet (SAW) says "The ones who strike their cheeks, tear their clothes and cry with the cry of Jahiliyyah are not from us", and Allah (SWT) says "don't make your hands the source of your destruction", then anyone TRULY BELIEVING that Matam is OKAY and HALAL then has changed his Aqeedah and added bid'ah to it. And no, there is no such thing as good bid'ah or bad bid'ah. As we know from the sermon of the Prophet (SAW) where he says "All newly invented matters (in the religion) are a bid'ah, and all bid'ah leads astray and anything that leads astray is in the fire". The Prophet (SAW) didn't ever differentiate between good or bad bid'ah, so even if Umar (RA) meant good bid'ah in the way you are interpreting it, we don't take his word over the words of the Prophet (SAW) because Umar (RA) is fallible, and the Prophet (SAW) is not. If the Prophet (SAW) ever mourned for someone by hitting himself with blades and such, we would never call this action a bid'ah, but seeing as he never did this, then doing this is a newly invented matter in the religion. The Prophet (SAW) has already taught us to not mourn for any man for more that 3 days (except for your husband). He never made any exceptions for any Sahaba (of which included Abu Bakr (RA) and Umar (RA), the greatest of men to walk the earth after him (SAW) ) so how can we ever mourn Husayn (RA) until today?

[@user-xu4ei7wp4h]

Asalamu 'alaykum. Khilafah of Yazeed was an innovation?? Please mention a chapter of reference to make it easier for us to return back to.

[@saphlayla8066]

can you please do more of these videos + stories of the prophet (may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) and the companions jazakhallah it was very informative.

[@11Taqi]

You are misguided May Allah swt guide you

[@muhammadhussainbaqeri5794]

i listend very carefully dear, so strange that Muawia would not leave Ummah without a successor, without a leader. makes sense. Now, if that make sense do you believe that Prophet P.B.U.H. will leave the ummah without successor? Will Ali leave the Ummah without successor?!! What a contradiction!!!

[@thegreatersomaliapresident3171]

Who said Ali should be leader after Nabi Mohammed SAW?

[@alim-rk7nx]

The Rasool(saw) at Ghadeer Khumm even Umar gave bay3a to Ali (as)

[@sharps8726]

Mawiya the person who was endowed with the following hadeeths from the Prophet "Please show this man the straight path" and "Teach this man the Quran" has more knowledge then that Prophet (SAW) ----- SARCASM

[@HH-ey6xx]

seems like you got your info from yasir qadhi's video - yet you refuted him

[@frankabacus7375]

Ali's (RA) appointment as successor should have been announced at Arafat when there was the largest crowd. And the Prophet (SAW) should have kept repeating it to people in Madina before he died

[@dilzzy360]

i can't stop laughing from how much crap that is coming out of this guy's mouth. i suggest you read the the speech of Zainab bint Ali in the court of yazid.

[@muslimahalislam2949]

dilzzy360 can you explain too on KZbin like brother imran do if you think you smarter then him?

[@dilzzy360]

i doubt im smarter then him brother, never claimed to be smarter then him. but there are fields of study that can be more understood by others then this guy. he speaks history through their hypocritical/ sweep under the carpet history. not the clear history. watch sayed ammar nakshawani's lectures, he's an actual historian, thats his field of study and you come to the real history of yazid and "how he never intended to kill hussain (as)" and read my statement before you preach. read the speech that Zainab bint Ali, im fairly sure you respect her as well, but i suggest you read her speech in the court of yazid and obviously this guy talking hasn't read a word of the speech. "Speech of Zainab in the court of yazid" thats what you want to read

[@SuperTruthonly]

She is certainly more clever but she does not admit. WHILE this git Imran pretends to be too clever. Ask him to answer the points I have raised if he can.

[@nazshah3932]

this guy has a tendency of talking bullshit he's a fukin idiot

[@muhammadshahab5205]

+Naz Shah Truth hurted you

[@bilalhussain97]

Bro change the link in your bio its wrong and greaaaaat speech btw!!!

[@RighteousnRich]

+BILAL SZN i fixed it bro

[@kabbyabbas110]

+Shia Man brother he can't answer you everyday they try to cover up the truth harder and harder but truth always prevails

[@asimhussain869]

+Shia Man an excellent objective analysis and I encourage anyone who watches the video by brother Imran to research the points made before coming to a logical conclusion.

[@sulaymaanqureshi1156]

BILAL H dawahman dressed like a shia in black

[@yeahbuddy9046]

ya allah guide who really wants to be guided ya allah explain we do not pray to the imams we reamber them for there imam and sacrifice for allah and the muslim world ya rab you are the only one worthy of worship and I'm still screaming ya hussein one of th

[@JerseyCreole]

Asalam Aaikum brother, its nice to now the full details about this wonderful but sad story, but the question is which doesn't make sense to me is, where does the Jew Abdullah Ibn Saba fits in here when does he comes into the story??

[@ahmedw5]

Comment section makes me very sad. So much misguidance.

[@sharps8726]

Lol make him guided and teach him the Quran.

[@timremmont569]

if they didn't know what's going around in kufa, so why the sahaba want come to hussain as. to warn him? mashallah knowledge ...

[@timremmont569]

could you please tell the people what ubaydullah ibn ziyad did with the people of Kufa- and why many of them couldn't reach imam hussain as. could you please tell the people what he did with the shia in his time!? the companions - habib ibn mudhaher- of imam hussain were did they come from and how did he reached the imam as.?!!

[@shehzadsyed3368]

I am going to say something controversial as Shia and hopefully shed some light on some inconsistencies that I have seen and things that I would love to get sincere answers to. First of all, the love of Hussein (as/ra) is imminent in your eyes. The point about when you said "it brings me to tears about Hussein (as/ra) and you hear your voice breaking share great GREAT affinity in my heart and I can't thank you for this sincere gesture as it is not for me to judge but allah in the eyes of Shia this is a great great sacrifice he made and you can see, (and not from your conclusion- which I Will shed some of my views on as a SYED- family of Hussein (descendants) Imam Ali Naqi (as) - Son of the one of the twelvers, one that would stand with HUssien no doubt my life on the line as the Son of Hussein (as/ra) would be of the select few insha'ALllah insha'Allah I can sincerely say yes there would be some to turn away, but not the select 100 or so you mention in your GREAT oration. This was factually some of the best and non biased view points- but setting aside some of the differences of which were 1) Muawiyya had a great and peaceful and tranquil governing- however how close to the principles of Islam was this golden age? please shed light brother 2)Did (according to your beautiful speech) YAzid not choose Umar ibn Ziyad to go from Basra to Kufa? so he had a part to play? You also mentioned When Umar ibn Ziyad was seiged he said a whole army would come and slaughter all the kufans? how do you think that reflects on him... just a view point- please shed and clarify 3) Umar ibn Ziyad was a bad man, shimr was a bad man, anas was a bad man, hURR was a great man- this is very very similar to the ideology of shia. so thanks. 4)AS Hussein being insistent? did he not know that he was to die on the plane of Karbala according to Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) prophecy- so I was unsure how to take this, please help and direct me of your sources 5) IS it true all shia came from KUFA- no doubt not every shia would stand up to fight with Hussein and they will be judged according to Allah (swt) however there were 70 that did fight, and of the select few, isn't this the case with the husband of Fatima (as/ra) grandson of the prophet (PBUH) Ali ibn Abi talib (as/ra)?? When there are many hadiths which say about his true Shia being very very small in number 6) Finally all shia are not bad, they want to follow the Sunnah as equally as our brothers in faith (ahle Sunnah), our rituals may not be 100% correct but the love of Hussein we share- brother I would love to invite you for further discussion and enlighten BOTH our view points- where conclusions are drawn some may or may not be legitimate on BOTH sides. So I can address some misconceptions and I would love for you to ELIMINATE my misconceptions. But thank you as LOVER OF PROPHET Muhammad and his Sunnah as lover of ahlulbayt and as lover of the companions of PROPHET Muhammad- I bid you a peaceful peaceful blessing and may you make productive videos like this for all to see Alhamdullilah

[@C--Ray]

Muaviyyah Fought Ali because according to you he wanted justice for the murder of Uthman now my question is this to you or any sunni did he bring them to justice while he was in power for 20yrs of his reign...

[@goldenfrieza7638]

The salah bit when he was talking about wen Yaris army was praying behind him is bs they tried killing him by shooting arrows but the guard risked his life by putting his body in the way

[@motv1094]

How do we turn ur our back

[@syedhussainhassani9279]

Asalaamalaikum brothers and sisters in Islam. Question 1: Weren't Shias responsible for killing Imam Husayn (AS)? This is a very serious allegation made against Shia muslims by some ill-informed or ill-intentioned individuals. Invitation to Kufa: The claim is that it was Shias in Kufa who wrote letters to Imam Husayn (AS), inviting him to Kufa and it was they who then betrayed him. Imam Husayn (AS) had sent his cousin, Muslim ibn Aqeel to go and assess the situation in Kufa, where the people of Kufa promptly gave allegiance (bay'at) to him before turning against him once the army of Yazid arrived. The Kufans failed to join the army of Husayn (AS) or go out to protect him from his enemy and now, 14 centuries later, some Muslim and non-Muslim commentators claim that Shias do maatum out of "guilt" for having failed and betrayed their Imam, Husayn (AS), On the day of Ashura. This, however, is a historical nonsense which is designed to try and shift the blame away from those really responsible for the murder of Imam Husayn (AS) and his family in Kerbala. Historical facts: Kufa, contrary to conventional wisdom, was not a "Shia city". According to the famous Sunni scholar and biographer, Shibli Numani, Kufa was a city in Iraq that had been founded by Umar ibn Khattab, during his caliphate, as a military fort for his soldiers and supporters. Imam Ali (AS) then moved there during his caliphate, in order to keep an eye on the rebellious antics of Muawiya ibn Abu Sufyan, in neighbouring Syria. After his death, according to Sunni historian Allama Tabari, the Shias of Kufa, who had accompanied Ali ibn Abu Talib (AS) to that city, were rounded up tortured and killed by Ziyad, one of the appointees of Muawiya (and the father of Ubaidullah ibn Ziyad, who was governor of Kufa during the Kerbala tragedy). Abdulibh ibn Abbas, the respected companion and cousin of the Prophet, even warned Imam Husayn (AS) when he was leaving Madinah that the people of Kufa were "deceitful people" who could not be trusted. Then there is the key historical fact that the army of Yazid which first starved and then killed Imam Husayn (AS) and his followers were from Syria, not Kufa. It is narrated by Shah Abdul Aziz, the Sunni scholar: "The Syrian forces upon orders of Yazid and the efforts of Chief of hatred and fitnah - Ibn Ziyad martyred Imam Husayn in Kerbala." The history of Kerbala has been recorded in a number of Ahle Sunnah books, and it is very clear from this history who was and wasn't responsible for the killing of Imam Husayn (AS). Today, those Muslims who pretend Yazid ibn Muawiya was not responsble for it are like those neo-Nazis who deny that Hiler was responsible for the Holocaust. Question 2: Why do Shias cry so much in Muharram? Some Muslims claim that crying, and especially excessive crying is wrong, uncalled-for and un-Islamic. Yet crying is part and parcel of human nature and Islam. It was encouraged by the Holy Prophet (SAW ) and in one famous hadith he states: "May you weep more and laugh less if you understand what is coming". The Holy Qur'an has many verses which refer to the importance and validity of shedding tears: "And when they hear what has been revealed to the messenger you will see their eyes overflowing with tears on account of the truth that they recognize; they say: Our lord! We believe, so write us down with the witnesses (of truth)." Ch. 5: V83 (Surah Maidah) Then there is Surah Yusuf, and the reference to Prophet Yacub (Jacob), Ch.12:V84: "And he turned away from them, and said: O my sorrow for Joseph! And his eyes were filled (with tears) on account of the grief, then he repressed (grief)". In fact, the fourth Shia Imam, Zainul Abidin (AS), referred to this particular verse of the 12th surah when he was asked by a companion why he cried so much for his late Father and brothers. Shaykh Suleman ibn Ibrahim al-Hanafi al-Qandozi states in his book, Yanabi al-Mawaddah: "The grief of Imam Husayn (AS) is the grief on which not only humans, but even jinns, angels, animals, birds, the sky and trees, all lament and weep. It is written that the sky wept for forty days after the martyrdom of Imam Husayn (AS)." Question 3: Why do Shias do maatum in Muharram? "Maatum" is the symbolic beating of one's own chest or head as a physical sign of grief and sorrow. The critics of the Shias claim it is an un-lslamic and extremist practice, a symbol of the pre-lslamic period of "jahiliyyah" (ignorance) that was banned by the Holy Prophet (SAW). But the truth is that maatum has Islamic origins and justifications. Evidence from the Holy Qur'an: Turning again to the Holy Qur'an, we find in Ch.51:V29, in reference to lady Sarah, wife of Prophet Ibrahim (Abraham), being told she was having a baby: "Then came forward his wife in grief, she hit her face and said (what! I) an old barren woman?" [Surah Dharia]. References from books of Ahle Sunnah: There are many references to maatum-like behaviour during and after the time of the Prophet in the books of the Ahle Sunnah. Ahle Sunnah scholars, for instance, narrate how Owais-al-Qarni, a companion of the Holy Prophet (SAW) who was in Yemen during the battle of Ohud, broke his own teeth when he heard that the Prophet (SAW) had been hurt in battle and had lost some of his teeth. The Prophet (SAW) did not criticise or denounce Owais for doing so. Then there is the aftermath of the Battle of Ohud, in which the Holy Prophet (SAW) established a period of mourning, including maatum, for his uncle Hamza who had been killed in the fighting. Shibli Numani narrates: "The Prophet ordered the folk of Madinah to go to Hamza's house and to cry and grieve over him." Then there is the example of Aisha bint Abu Bakr, the classical Sunni scholar Allama ibn Kathir narrates from Aisha that when the Holy Prophet (SAW) passed away she said: "I got up beating my chest and slapping my face along with other women." Allama Muttaqi-al-Hindi, the Sunni scholar, narrates: "When Hazrat Umar heard of Nu'man ibn Muqrin's death he beat his head and screamed, "O what a pity that Nu'man died". Umar could do maatum for Nu'man, who was one of his military commanders and died in batte, but when Shias do the same for Imam Husayn (AS), the beloved grandson of the Holy Prophet (SAW), it is frowned upon and termed an innovation (or "bid'at"). Does this make any sense? JazakAllah for taking the time out to read this comment and I pray to Allah (SWT) that he guides you to 'siratul mustakeem' Ameen. Salaam.

[@duaaali786]

Syed Hussain Hassani .. you are the first person here who has provided references to justify your beliefs....no rudeness or swears.. thank you for that

[@onlyme373]

beautifully explained akhi, may Allah keep you firm on haqq!

[@thehermit6198]

Is he reading something or knows the story in depth himself

[@rayhanshah2624]

are you of those people who pray all night and recite the quran all night and yet not ponder over the verses read surah tahrim

[@AliHussain-fz7pd]

What Hassan (as) did was expose Muawiya by doing what his grandfather (saw) did in Hudaybiya. Muawiya was governor of Sham, he like his predecessors knew how to make use of the treasury to benefit himself, he had 76,000 troops and the power to buy their loyalty. If he had gone to war, the people would be oblivious to the truth, they'd have seen it as simply a dispute where either could be right. So, instead, he signed a treaty that would serve to expose the character of this imbecile Muawiya. Clause number 1) You will stop cursing Ali (as) at the start of the Khutba after all, was he not 4th Khalifa? did that happen, no. 2) You will not change the sunnah of my grandfather, did that happen? no. These idiots prayed Jumma on a wednesday. 3) stop killing the shia of Ali in Kufa, did this happen? no. 4) You will return the unjust spoils of war from the battles of Sifeen and Jamel, did this happen? no. 5) When Muawiya dies, he will give the Khalifah to Hassan(as) or Hussain(as), did he honour this? no. He did not honour a single clause. History shows us that Muawiyah was not a man of principle. Then we come to the issue of Yazid, who was he? It is known that he was the son of a Christian Syrian, his mother, and it is known that he much preferred the company of his mothers family, mixed gatherings, hijabless women, and alcohol to the family of his father. Unlike his father who was publicly very religious, this bastard was privately and publicly secular, that is why nobody was prepared to give him bayaa, that is why even his fathers own people advised against it, it made a mockery of the whole thing. Anyway, Yazid on the back of his father's treachery comes into power, he has 4 governors, Nauman who was made mention of in this deluded video was as patient as described, he was seen as a weak link, because he would not have the audacity to kill the grandson of the prophet, so Yazid relayed his problem to a chief advisor, known as none other than Sir John, yes, a christian adviser to the Muslim Khalifa, when today, people who run Hijaz don't have a single church, he asks Yazid whether he knows what his father would have done, he advises Yazid, in spite of his rivalry with Ibn Ziyad to appoint him as governor and sent him to Kufa. He began massacring supporters, he killed Hani, he killed Muslim bin Akil, he imprisoned Mukhtar. All this was borne out of a vendetta.This was all on the instructions of Yazid. No bayah meant no validity, and its clear that in the face of such circumstance, he felt compelled to order the murder. Yazid, his desire for the Khalifah, the sunni belief that you should just instill democracy into the ummah and neglect the fact that there were divinely appointed beings from the family of the prophet caused this, lust for power and money and status caused this. Not too long later, Yazid fought Abdullah ibn Zubayr who had the loyalty of Medina in the battle of Harrah, culminating in the order by Yazid to attack Makkah, and the cloth of the Kabbah was ordered to be burnt. Yazid died instantly, as a result of a bite from his pet dog that had accompanied him on this particular excursion.

[@navedabbas7648]

👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻 Wrong info

[@haqkisada5845]

after watching this video i really proud to be shia because a sunni is claiming he is shia bt shia r not shia is that not funny tthanks God people r coming towards true religion shia islam.....

[@haqkisada5845]

by my this coment knw may be some sunni will claim no this guy is agent of shia ......

[@hassanaltaay2603]

Confused , so Who killed Hussian ibn Ali , is he good or bad ?

[@hassanaltaay2603]

Your portraying the people of kufa like there made the fitna, infact the people of kufa were specifically chosen by Ali and you can see what he said about them

[@alisarwar9234]

In Respect to all my Sunni brothers, the speech this individual is giving is an absolute Salfism Wahabism state of logic. if we are Muslims and Islam is a religion based upon logic, then how can this man say that" Muawiya...Radhiallah o anh" and "Imam Hussain RadhiAllahhu anh" but history tells us that the Mother of Muawiya was Hind, who ate the heart of Hamza (RA) who was one of the first Companions of RasoulAllah(saw). and Muawiya was the one who raised a son like Yazeed(Alaihil laana) who was the Khalif of the time that ordered the masscre of Imam Hussain (as)and his family (they are the Ahlel Bayt of RsaoulAllah)in karbala. what kind of absurdity is this?, Muawiya was the one who in the battle of Siffin stuck pages of the Holy Quran on spears to stop Imam Ali(as) from finishing him off. Prophet Muhammad’s saying about Imam Hussain (PBUH): حسین منی و انا من حسین “Hussain is from me and I am from Hussain.” This saying was quoted in many Shia and Sunni books including Bihar Al-Anvar V.43 and Sonan Termizi, V.5, p.658. and Prophet Muhammad sayings about Imam Ali (as)...The Prophet (P.B.U.H) said, “We were created from the same tree, I and Ali (A.S).” Al-Tirmidhi, 13/178; Ibn Al-Maghazeli, 122; Asad Al-Ghaba, 4/26; Al-Riyadh Al-Nudhra, 2/216. The Prophet (P.B.U.H) said, “Of whomever I was master, Ali (A.S) is his master.” Mustadrak Al-Sahihain of Al-Hakim Al-Nisabori, 3/129; Kenz Al-Omal, 6/157; Al-Dilmi....and also this saying that is not denied by both Shia and Sunni school of thought. The Prpohet(PBUH) said من کنت مولای، فهذا علیئ مولای" for who ever I am a Master, Ali is his Master. but this man here sits and praises the killers of Muhammad wa Aale Muhammad. did the Prophet (PBUH) not say " Ana Madinatul Elm, wa Ali un Baabo haa" ( Iam the city of knowledge and Ali is its gate). now read the history of Muawiya and who his mother and father was and who his son was. and what did his Son do to Imam Hussain(as) the very Grandson of our Beloved Prophet(PBUH). when one if RasoulAllah's hadeeth says " Hussainu minni wa ana Minnil Hussain" (Hussain is from me and I am from Hussain.) what does that mean to you my brothers and sisters. a man like this individual are the very reasons why Islam is Branded as a religion of terrorism. the very reasons why ISIS exists. who rape people's women and children. go and read the history of Karbala.

[@5maz]

The only thing you have displayed during this 1 hour rant is 1) that you hate Shias and 2) you know nothing about history / and / or you're deliberately leading astray.

[@mickyhouse8753]

+Naz Khan I agree, please do not listen to him, but rather hear someone who is more knoeledgable and has studied this, such as sayed ammar nakshawani

[@5maz]

+Micky House Yes Syed Ammar Naqshwani is amazing in his knowledge, education and delivery.

[@maythamhosain]

+MysterieusM XD XD XD XD XD XD XD XD XD

[@Zarghaam12]

Wahhaabi / Salafi propaganda won't do! This topic is well covered by many scholars, Sunni and Sh'ia, from the "classical" age till now so you are fightinh a loosing battle by distorting facts and taking advantage of how language and words were used in 7th-8th centuries and how they are used and understood now. The following Sunni texts mention that it was Yazeed and his henchmen, Ubaidullah ibn Ziyaad (Yazeed-appointed governor of Kufah at the time), Umar ibn Sa'ad ibn Abi Waqqaas (commander of Yazeedi forces ar Karbala), Shimr ibn Zil Jaushan (a Khaarjite and second in command of Yazeedi forces at Karbala), Marwaan ibn al-Hakm (Yazeed's "lota" in Madina), these are the some of the main characters responsible for the killing of Imam al-Husain. the Prophet's grandson, and his family and friends at Karbala: Here we shall cite the following reputable texts of Ahl’ul Sunnah, that confirm that Yazeed killed Imam Husayn (as): Maqatil Husayn al Khuwaarzmi Volume 2 page 80 Chapter 9 Ya Nabi al Mawaddah page 223 Chapter 91 Tareekh al Yaqoobi Volume 2 page 299 Dhikr Yazeed Matallib al Saul Volume 2 page 26 Nur al Absaar page 139 Al Bidaayah wa al Nihaaya page 219 Dhikr 63 Hijri Tareekh Kaamil Volume 4 page 69 Tareekh Tabari page 408 Dhikr Ibn Ziyad Akhbar al Tiwaal page 384 Tadkira tul Khawaas page 159 Hayaat al Haywaan Volume 1 page 88 Tareekh Khamees Volume 2 page 301 Sawaiq al Muhriqa page 134 Sharh Fiqh Akbar page 73 Tauhfa Ithna Ashari page 6 Ash’at al-Lam’aat Sharh Mishkat Volume 4 page 623 Bab Manaqib Quraysh Shazarat al Dhahab Volume 1 page 69 Dhikr 61 Hijri Muruuj al Dhahab Volume 3 page 71 Dhikr Yazeed Tafseer Mazhari Volume 5 page 21 Part 13 Surah Ibrahim Aqaa'id al Islam pahe 232 ny Maulana Abdul Haqq Haqani Imaam Paak aur Yazeed Paleed page 88 Aqaa'id Nafsee page 113 Sharh Maqasad Volume 2 page 309 Nuzul al Ibraar page 97 Irfaane Shariat Volume 2 page 21 Fataawi Maulaana Abdul Hai page 79 Shaheed-e-Kerbala pages 11-12 by Mufti Muhammad Shaafi Irshad al-Saari (Sharh Bukhari) Volume 10 page 1717 Bab ul Fitan Durre Maarif Volume 4 page 295 Zikr Zaynab binte ‘Ali Sharh al Muneer Sharh al Sagheer Volume 1 page80

[@mumbailife2023]

Listen, no matter how much you have love and respect for Imam Hussein and entire Able bait, but do not use any such word which may hurt to others. Our beloved prophet Mohammad (saw) said no matter how much ibadah you do if you hurt someone with your words (oral/written) then none of your good deeds will get counted. so stop blaming each other. All are Muslim, but try to become Momeen.

[@samsingh6643]

dawah man is not sunni...he is wahabi a minority sect in islam In todays society, the love of Ahle al Bayt has unfortunately and falsely been attributed to something which shia do; this is far from the truth. The love of Ahle al Bayt in reality, is the foundations of the Imaan of Ahle Sunnah wal Jamat, one cannot love The Beloved Prophet (upon Him peace and blessings), without loving the Ahle al Bayt. It is deeply rooted in the core and essence of Sunni Islam and Aqidah. The great Imam “Imam Shafi’i” (Allah be pleased with him) said: When in a majlis the praise of Ali, Hasanain and Fatima alaihi mu sallam is done… then they say O People lets go from here because this is a rafidi talk…. I seek Allah’s refuge from such people who label the love of Fatima’s progeny as rifidi, may the blessings of Allah be upon progeny of the Beloved Prophet, upon Him peace and blessings, and curse of Allah be upon such ignorant people. The Noble Imam also said: If loving the household of Prophet is a sin… Then I’ll never repent on this sin! He also said: “If loving Ahle Bayt, is Rafdh.. Then I’m Rafedhi of the 1st rank!” There are countless sayings and advice of Imam Shafi’i RadiAllahu anhu on loving Ahle Bayt (alayhis salaam), More recently the reviver of Islam in the Indian Subcontinent, Ala Hazrat Imam Ahmad Raza Khan (alayhi Rehma) loved the family of The Prophet,upon Him peace and blessings, wrote poetry in praise of them, amongst them is a most beautiful verse: “Teri nasle pak me hai batcha batcha Noor ka Tu hai ‘ainai Noor Tera sub gharana Noor ka” “From your blessed progeny every child is Noor (Light), You are the essence of Light and Your blessed Family are Light” Love for the Prophet’s family is enjoined by Allah in the Qur’an, where He says: Say, ‘I ask no other reward of you save love of my next of kin’ (42:23). It is of Husayn (Allah be pleased with him) alone that he declared: ‘Husayn is of me and I am of Husayn. May God love those who love Husayn. When sura 108 (al-Kawthar) was revealed, the Prophet announced this great favour to his close companion Anas b. Malik, on whose authority this tradition is reported. Anas asked: ‘What is al-Kawthar?’ He answered: ‘It is a river in Paradise, but neither those who violate my covenant (dhimma), nor those who shall kill the people of my House will be allowed to drink of it.’ -1 Spread the Love of Ahle Bayt alayhis salaam into the hearts of all.

[@sulaymaanqureshi1156]

sam singh he is actually a deobandi

[@4gkhan981]

BISMILAAH Salaams It's unfortunate my brother in Islam that we all try and find out who really is to blame for the killing of Imam Hussain S.A when history shows that it was a collective affair not just the ones present in kerbala but those who weren't there also have the blood of the prophets pbuh family on there hands I don't agree with many sects that use these events to show they have more love but I tell you this those who stood by and let this occurs knowing too well that blood will be shed are all part of it... Brother you make good points and bad points some done motivated by your understanding some by your belief but fact is fact where was the Ummah not just the kufans. I've seen other videos of yours they all have the same theology please I admire your passion for the Ummah but need to look at the bigger picture a real photo not a painted one May ALLAH guide us all Aameen Wa Salaams

[@C--Ray]

now this myth that the kuffans were Shia of Ahlul bayt can be scrutinized and we see in history as the power shifted from one Khalifa to another the support shifted hence they were supporters of Imam Ali at the time of his khilafah just like they supported the khilafah of Uthman in his time they shifted as the power of Khilafah shifted they were not shia in true sense of the meaning it was evident that even at the time of Imam Ali's Khilafah his own "shia" who had done his bayah after uthman were against him ie, they were inclined to give bayah to Imam Ali because of the circumstances

[@5eek3r0fknowl3dg3]

wonder what rafidhis would say about this?!! that even a wobbler criticise yazidh and like other sunnis, expose ibn ziyad [only tubby yasir qadhi makes excuses for him but says he is makavellian]. he even said muawiyah ra made a biod'ah! i think most ppl know ibn ziyad is a kaffir but they are all with Allah swt so cursing isnt gonna change that ahlus sunnah say Ali RA was in the right side so i wonder how rafidhi shias can justify saying ummaya to sunnis? it is a weird pitch, bakri[rasullulah SAW father in law and best friend] is better