Who sings Händel's "Tacerò, purché fedele" best?

[@philippeverdu5152]

Orlinski,douceur et finesse

[@maricarmensantander7571]

Jakub Józef es una voz angelical ❤

[@mysticmouse7261]

Exotic Orlinski was born to sing Handel countertenor arias.

[@helenearetz7596]

La voix de JJO traverse l’espace claire,pure,forte . Elle est sans pareille.

[@oranginafun]

Dumaux: live recording on stage , Orlinski :Studio recording.

[@a.mie.533]

This piece is so beautiful.

[@loresmina]

Jakub. His voice is rounder and warmer. Beautiful

[@michawolski1535]

Jakub's kind of singing is like listening to a story tell by a friend... Like it a lot.

[@Stan-j3j]

Hard to compare the 2 recordings... Dumaux (most likely live performance), Orlinski- studio recorded. I am Orlinski's fan but this time I will abstain.

[@philippeverdu5152]

Dumaux, rond et puissant

[@suzanneliapis4481]

C’est la merveille des merveilles. Bravo

[@lauracompagnoni1239]

Exquisite, B and B. I don't want to choose, but I want to thank you.

[@sabinefrank2848]

I love Jakub Orlinskis voice, he sings with so mutch feeling....

[@suzanneliapis4481]

Comme disait un des auditeurs » Both are GREAT «

[@lindapoulson2130]

JJO is more meaty, has more depth. Such a wonderful voice and young enough for us to have him around for many years (I hope).

[@verdi3333]

I prefer Orlinski but both are very good.

[@barbararota9682]

Bravissimi entrambi, personalmente preferisco Jakub per intensità di interpretazione, controllo vocale e soprattutto dizione (la pronuncia italiana è praticamente perfetta)

[@kristinaolsson1166]

Orlinski absolutely!🙏👏👏👏

[@irinaormachea4248]

En mi caso Orlinski es irresistible. Su aspecto, su voz del elfo -- todo parece de los cuentos de hadas.

[@suzanneliapis4481]

J’adore la voix des deux contre -ténors. C’est sublime.

[@zcatfanxq]

Jacob: its a tender song, and he brings it gentleness as well as a purer tone.

[@antyadel]

Jakub es maravilloso con ese canto me eleva al cielo , la nueva voz inmaculada ! Gracias Jakub !

[@philippeverdu5152]

❤❤❤❤❤ pour les 2❤❤❤❤

[@TympanKiller28]

Both voices are nice. Christophe seems to impersonate more strongly the character, due to the color of his voice. However, Jakub is a bit more audatious while singing ornaments in the da capo. So he makes me feel more emotions than his "competitor".

[@mariovalencia7167]

Orlinski tiene una voz preciosa, y maneja las emociones como pocos contratenores.

[@chlagaguel]

Christophe Dumaux pour sa magnifique conduite de phrasé.

[@olgakowalczyk3807]

I prefer Dumaux, but both are great.

[@elenarif]

I prefer Orlinski, but it was difficult for me to decide: they are both excellent.

[@zcatfanxq]

Jakub - more lyrical, tones more pure, pronounces better, but ultimately it goes straight to the heart for me.

[@talvela100]

Due voci dai colori molto diversi, ma entrambe di grande fascino. Nettamente superiore, in quanto a dizione, Orlinski

[@gustavoperez1696]

Great.

[@eulalia3446]

Orlinski - voice is so pure.

[@olgasanchez7662]

JJO clearly clear

[@beatakrupa6720]

Jakub ♥️

[@belamoure]

Entre les deux mon coeur balance entre les 2 j'hésite un peu.

[@imeketenham817]

Je trouve la voix de Jakub plus pure et concentrée. C’est donc lui que je préfère

[@StanWatt.]

Jakub!

[@nissulya]

Christophe Dumaux

[@DC-ji4qi]

Прошу простить, но Кристоф Дюмо ВСЁ ПОЁТ ЛУЧШЕ ВСЕХ! kzbin.info/www/bejne/fJ21p3qZlsiWj6c

[@nissulya]

@@DC-ji4qi естественно 😀

[@BrendaOwens]

Both were so heavenly technically but i prefer Orlinski👏👏

[@helenearetz7596]

Orlinski

[@mariejomeile4597]

Orlinski

[@pawelsobolew]

Christophe Dumaux!

[@philippeverdu5152]

Sublimissime

[@samet2825]

Orliński

[@charlottestedefeder3824]

Ich empfinde die Stimme von Herrn Dumaux etwas weicher als von Herrn Orlinski. Beide sind grandios

[@ritahorvath8207]

Da Herr Scholl nicht im Rennen ist um alle in den Schatten zu stellen, kann ich mich nur anschließen ... 🔒

[@ohmy5650]

Both are great+ but I'll pick Orlinski's if I have to choose.

[@claudioaprile4697]

Jakub have an angel voice., is best

[@agnieszkawiechetek3409]

Jakub Orliński przepiękny głos i wykonanie.

[@doctorfoster1968]

Jakub. No contest!

[@jennyweegenaar-possel487]

Orliński!!

[@xSxMx]

Jakub Józef Orliński for sure!

[@claudiasanchez3148]

Jacub Jósef Orlinski que voz!!

[@Inblue-sea]

Jakub.

[@esperanzadelosriosmartinez3744]

Orlinsky the best

[@malgorzatajagiello2663]

Jakub. Anielski głos w boskim ciele

[@alvaroferal2]

I prefer Orlinski

[@rosemaryallen2128]

Dumaux has weight and character intrinsic to his vocal type, whereas Orlinski has a tendency to sound beautiful but a touch insipid for my taste. I think someone else is going to 'win' this one - so far, DiDonato is the most impressive.

[@mfa2807]

Кристофер гораздо колоратурнее поет!

[@malgorzatajagiello2663]

Only Jakub

[@jeanpaulchoppart6818]

I prefer Dumaux's voice, which seems "fruitier" to me.

[@loulou1968]

Dans ce type de sondage, Et c'est leur opinion qui est demandée aux auditeurs. C'est amusant de voir certains ajouter "sans aucun doute" après avoir donné leur avis totalement subjectif ! Les Polonais d'origine (dont je fais partie) vont voter pour Orliński, les femmes aussi, assez systématiquement ... (Que pensent les cougars polonaises ? !). ;-) Donnez donc votre classement, pas vos arguments fallacieux ! Sinon, là je voterais pour celui qui à le même prénom que moi, par exemple ! La plupart des votes tiennent à peu de choses près de ce niveau de réflexion ! Merci. NB : je suis d'accord avec ceux qui trouvent que la piètre qualité de certains enregistrements peut desservir l'interprète. Cf "Dove sei"...

[@marielled5049]

On demande une opinion. Si l'opinion n'est pas sûre, pourquoi la donner? Quand on aime ou quand on déteste, il vaut mieux être sûre de soi, question de maturité!

[@Stan-j3j]

Thinking your way: the French will always vote for Jaroussky, the German for Scholl, the British for Mead etc. It is a general simplification in your thinking, in my opinion. Poland is not a huge nation so it would lose in many contests. Art is not sport. Quality wins quantity.

[@spyingonyallteacup2744]

The person that wrote it

[@ClaudineFranco-u1p]

Parfaite diction de la part de Christophe dumaux qui n'a plus rien à prouver. Il y a des années de travail derrière lui . ORlinsky peut encore travailler je trouve sa voix quelque peu atone.

[@фанатА4-й6ы]

Орлински безупречен

[@vicentemiralles4544]

i dont like jjo , no voice

[@deboraharmstrong4385]

Aaagh!!!

[@paolo108]

@vicente miralles funny opinion. and very professional and full of critical remarks .. bravo vicente !! ...

[@ritahorvath8207]

. 🤣

[@anthonyqueenmusic7523]

I do it better. I’ll be uploading vidoe soon

[@paolo108]

@The original salt dog cant wait Before or after xmas 2024 ?

[@malgorzatajagiello2663]

Ha,ha

[@anthonyqueenmusic7523]

@@paolo108 hopefully this year

[@СветланаКаширская-ч4ф]

Christophe Dumaux