Who starts for Oklahoma: Spencer Rattler or Caleb Williams? - Skip & Shannon I NCAA I UNDISPUTED

Caleb Williams is reportedly getting first team reps for Oklahoma this week at practice after he replaced an ineffective Spencer Rattler during the Sooners' big comeback win against the Texas Longhorns last Saturday. Rattler started the year as a Heisman favorite and was the projected top pick by many in the 2022 NFL Draft. Skip Bayless and Shannon Sharpe discuss how surprised they are by the Sooners' move.
#Undisputed #NCAA #Sooners
SUBSCRIBE to get the latest UNDISPUTED content: foxs.pt/SubscribeUNDISPUTED
Listen to UNDISPUTED on Spotify: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDSpotify
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: tinyurl.com/y4uouolb
►Watch the latest content from UNDISPUTED: foxs.pt/TheLatestOnUNDISPUTED
▶First Things First's KZbin channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeFIRSTTHINGSFIRST
▶The Herd with Colin Cowherd’s KZbin channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeTHEHERD
▶Speak for Yourself’s KZbin channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeSPEAKFORYOURSELF
►FOX Bet Live’s KZbin Channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeFOXBETLIVE
►Club Shay Shay’s KZbin Channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeCLUBSHAYSHAY
▶Titus & Tate's KZbin channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeTITUSANDTATE
See more from UNDISPUTED: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDFoxSports
Like UNDISPUTED on Facebook: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDFacebook
Follow UNDISPUTED on Twitter: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDTwitter
Follow UNDISPUTED on Instagram: foxs.pt/UNDISPUTEDInstagram
Follow Skip Bayless on Twitter: foxs.pt/SkipBaylessTwitter
Follow Shannon Sharpe on Twitter: foxs.pt/ShannonSharpeTwitter
Follow Jenny Taft on Twitter: foxs.pt/JennyTaftTwitter
About Skip and Shannon: UNDISPUTED:
UNDISPUTED is a daily two-and-a-half hour sports debate show starring Skip Bayless and Shannon Sharpe. Every day, Skip and Shannon will give their unfiltered, incisive, passionate opinions on the biggest sports topics of the day.
Who starts for Oklahoma: Spencer Rattler or Caleb Williams? - Skip & Shannon I NCAA I UNDISPUTED
• Who starts for Oklahom...
Skip and Shannon: UNDISPUTED
/ undisputedonfs1

[@UndisputedOnFS1]

Listen to No. 1 Ranked Show: foxs.pt/no1rjyoung

[@NotSoAverageJeff]

Skip “In all my years, I have never seen anything like this” Bayless

[@dariusrucker6518]

Every show Lmaoooo

[@davideskew6065]

I have heard that phrase a billion times out his mouth .

[@MrLourdens]

I think he says that to troll or as a running joke lowkey.

[@1tjohn]

😂😂

[@Xhoven]

To Skip's credit, this really is an "in all my years" moment. Rattler went from the consensus #1 overall pick to losing his job in less than 2 months...historically crazy.

[@kevinhenry4047]

If I had a dollar for every time Skip says “I have never seen anything like this” I would be able to buy the Dallas Cowboys

[@jackbobwee2902]

Dang bro he’s only said it twice?

[@ricetoss18]

@@jackbobwee2902 u don’t watch this show often if u think that

[@rcharris1838]

Thought I was the only one .. skip been covering to long to say “best I ever seen” so much

[@deonmckinney1498]

🤣

[@jordanfranklin189]

🤣🤣🤣

[@jeremybstudentpilot5315]

This show should talk more college Football. Shannon needs to watch more CFB so he wont be so biased. With that being said, Caleb should get his shot. He made oklahoma play defense.

[@alexforbesvevo]

When you’re driving the field and scoring rather than turning it over or quick 3 and outs it gives the defense rest and momentum

[@camthesooner123]

Dude Caleb made Oklahoma finally look like that Oklahoma offense.. it’s crazy that Spencer has ruined our offense for 5 and a half games.

[@abmarin9308]

@@camthesooner123 haven’t seen Spence play yet. You think he’s overrated?

[@camthesooner123]

@@abmarin9308 he’s not doing well at all. 10TD’s 5 INT’s and 3 fumbles this year.

[@adamirizarry2983]

@@camthesooner123 What is he a true sophomore or is he a red shirt sophomore they was talking about this dude being a number one pick he let all that nil money in his hellcat and his TRX get to his head

[@ZamirStills]

If Lincoln even thought for a moment about starting Rattler after last week, he’s snorting.

[@barringtonmorris90]

Coke!

[@Blaqk_8298]

YOUR SNORTING ... THIS IS CHESS NOT CHECKERS.

[@thsu8]

Lincoln is a smart guy. Trust me, he didn't.

[@leetraviusmckay2919]

Shannon: "Everybody knew you were going to start this Williams kid"

[@DoneDealAC]

Yes we watched the same video

[@leetraviusmckay2919]

Spencer Rattler started the season off struggling vs Tulane

[@camthesooner123]

The OL was playing poorly aswell, but they have picked it up and are good again. This is all on Spencer he’s too cocky, slow, and terrible decisions. He’s turnover king.

[@Ayyerell]

7:25 😂😂 Ain’t no way I led my team from a 28-7 deficit and I’m not talking to the media😂😂

[@timantoine3839]

Anybody here after this morning? 😂

[@mical2great]

Lmaoo 1st thing i put in when skip lied was Spencer Rattler undisputed and Walah skip lies

[@fakephoenixprince]

If you're struggling to look good in Lincoln Reily's system..... then idk what to say. If Rattler stays and loses the starting job and enters the draft, he's going in the sixth round. lol

[@camthesooner123]

It’s hard to be bad in LR system. Spencer is out of shape, slow, and way too cocky for his skill set.

[@deonmckinney1498]

Yeah I think even if he transfers next year and does good, He’s still a second rounder at best.

[@john-carlosynostroza]

I think you should just go to the draft because he's going to have to earn his way even if he plays well somewhere else considering he's not six-foot-four 230lbs. He also is not mobile like Lamar or anything. In other words, he is a shorter quarterback who does throw the ball well but who runs relatively average and just lost his job. Still getting drafted and a shot is probably as good as it's going to get for this kid anyway. I'd go if I were him.

[@thearbiter8568]

Yeah… but going in the 6th drafted to an NFL team is better than being broke working an everyday job.

[@mfd588]

LR's system is built for duel threat QBs. Spencer is a pocket passer; not a duel threat QB. He would thrive more in a Pac12 type of offense.

[@dezzyschannel3078]

Skip, eventually you have had to seen SOMETHING

[@CammieMac]

😂😂😂😂

[@scruffd0g193]

No way on earth, Rattler declares for the NFL Draft in 2022. He has to transfer and build back up his drafts stock for 2023.

[@loganbremerman1248]

Hes not even close to starting on sundays. Hes ok but hes not Baker, Kyler, Jalen. Not an NFL QB at this point

[@Mocha_ChaKalaKaKhaN]

Skip Bayless said this man Spencer was the best quarterback in college football and he was going to win the Heisman 🤣🤣🤣🤣 now this man is fighting for his job

[@lyk-yt9630]

I mean everybody thought he was

[@RoyBoy-qq8sz]

He WAS…but things change week by week in sports

[@noahsmiley3099]

I been said Caleb taking that. Spencer is sorry for real

[@dominikgose6770]

Uh, everyone did

[@buckleft2317]

Skip and a million others

[@victorhopkins9525]

Would love to see undisputed talk about CFB more

[@Teddypain20]

I saw him on QB1 when he was in HS. Wasn’t that impressed with the guy on and off the field. Seemed very full of himself kinda like Tate Martell was on that show

[@Ayyerell]

Rattler or Williams?

[@Teddypain20]

@@Ayyerell Rattler

[@darryljones9014]

I watched it as well. Feel the same way.

[@tchalla7828]

that's crazy, and look how Tate turned out...bagging groceries

[@jamesjones6049]

I had to come back to this when Shannon accused Skip of saying Spencer would win the Heisman😂

[@Darealtwill]

Lol me too 😅 I was looking for this comment

[@kooooo6086]

Facts lmaoo 😂😂

[@JourTheeOnly]

I had too make sure 😭

[@tjayd1225]

I haven’t seen a consensus first overall pick flame out this badly since Matt Barkley at USC. But he at least partly fell due to injury. Rattler was just dog sh-t bad

[@Teddypain20]

Agreed. That’s the last QB I could think of

[@nea7582]

@Rod323 He went second overall

[@neelkumar9839]

@Rod323 he talkin abt hyped HSer becoming college busts, not hyped college to NFL busy

[@keenannash2947]

@Rod323 what? Mariota was very good in college.

[@keenannash2947]

@Rod323 that'sthe point... Mariota didnt fall off at all in college like Barkley and Rattler have. Brakley was considered a first round pick at one point but his last year caused him to fall to like the 4th round. Mariota went in the 1st round... and high in the first. What happened to Barkley and Rattler did not happen at all to Mariota in college.

[@DaPunisher85]

Shannon: "I would've got me a word in.....we did it" 🤣🤣🤣

[@joedorben3504]

Somebody gotta make Skip a "In all my years" compilation lmao, I must've heard him say that dozens of times

[@doc8013]

Hundreds, maybe thousands of times lol.

[@leetraviusmckay2919]

Spencer Rattler has been lowering his draft stock since week 1

[@leetraviusmckay2919]

Shannon: "I don't care about marketing ability I need winning ability"

[@BigTulsa]

True freshmen at OU are not allowed to be interviewed by the media. This has been a long standing policy with OU.

[@lyk-yt9630]

Caleb Williams will be the best qb in college football next year

[@old77733]

Called it. 😉

[@chipsaunders5109]

Love this. Wish the show would talk more CFB

[@mynoseisdirty1250]

Skip has never seen anything but knows everything

[@liamnelson6573]

Skip “you know it and I know it” Bayless

[@mosval8985]

Most Underrated comment in KZbin history.

[@Unriven]

Rattler ain’t all that, and as an NFL team I would never draft someone as selfish and arrogant as him.

[@vanessamartinez211]

Under the Heavens Rattler is cool funny dude. We both went to high school and played basketball and football.

[@leetraviusmckay2919]

Skip "In all my lives I have never seen anything like this" bayless

[@RalixBlaster7]

Caleb Williams broke my heart last week. I couldn’t believe how Oklahoma’s energy completely changed when he got in the game. Being a Texas fan is rough.

[@cameronb8503]

It didn't get any better for this week for you either :(

[@leetraviusmckay2919]

I've never seen a consensus first round pick and preseason Heisman candidate play this horrible to start the season

[@shawnkurtz4424]

The only reason he was a "first round talent" was because of the OU on the side of the helmet and being a 5 star. Yeah he's got a strong arm and can throw from any platform, he's got physical tools he just doesn't have it between the ears he gets rattled (pun intended). Not to mention Lincoln Rileys system is about QB friendly as you can get except for Josh Huepel or Lane Kiffin. If he can't succeed there then there's an issue with the player somewhere.

[@dolamitic]

The only thing that comes close to Rattler’s collapse is Matt Barkley’s.

[@Trapstarpat]

Bro got injured

[@elstonturner7008]

Shannon said Spencer Rattler gonna have to give Caleb Williams one of his cars 🦁🐺😁😁😂😂

[@dalegilbert4128]

This is like the jalen hurts and tua situation.tua saved them in the championship game and jalen never started again

[@apeezytv1545]

Williams proved he a top 3 qb for heisman in less than 2 weeks. Quit playin

[@MrChazb1987]

Skip “in all my years” Bayless 🤣

[@GuyDollarSign]

The only time I rock with Skip is when he talks about OU !

[@alexherbert5783]

Rattler is overrated. He’s not that impressive

[@cravens91]

I agree - he looks uncomfortable and makes bad decisions. I don’t know if it’s the offensive scheme or if it’s just him. Maybe he’s better suited in the Pac12.

[@reef4hmmm]

I AGREE.. he talks too much too cocky and doesn't have it all together..

[@unsensitised3066]

He’s not overrated no one at Oklahoma likes him either 😂

[@Kittonwy]

Rattler is not a serious football player

[@unsensitised3066]

@@Kittonwy I wasn’t defending him I said he’s not overrated cuz he sucks and we all know it

[@kbrown3712]

Skip “i’ve never seen anything like it in all my years” Bayless

[@Rheper.]

Y’all need to talk about that QB in GA

[@thebootster]

Skip “in all my years” Bayless.

[@vermontmotorsports1275]

Never saw this video before but it's pretty funny watching now after the 2024 NFL Draft. The Rattler hype was hilarious. "He went from top of the draft to 6th round"

[@montanak833]

“In all my years, I have never seen anything like this” says Skip Bayless...once per episode 😂

[@mg19cal]

Once per SEGMENT

[@Dannydimes247]

I have never seen anything like it

[@EC66OK]

Also a born and bred lifelong OU fan here. Even when Rattler went on his "run" last season, I had no confidence in him. Can't put my finger on it, but I keep thinking "Jeff George." Another gunslinger with amazing arm talent that had some quirk of personality that made him not very likeable to his teammates. That's what Rattler seems to be. Loads of talent, smart and marketable, but not a QB in the sense that his teammates do not like him at the level that successful teams have towards their QB/leader. I'm rooting for the kid to turn it around, but I'm not very hopeful. Caleb Williams has that cocky attitude too, btw, but for whatever reason it's expressed in his play and body language, whereas Rattler's swagger is "I'm better than everyone. I'm the reason." Williams thinks he's better too, but not more valuable, and I think that's the difference.

[@noahsmiley3099]

Favoritism at its best.

[@afk2291]

He has a "TRX Ram 707HP 100k" truck and a "Scat Pack Widebody 60K 485HP". THESE KKDS LIVING IN GOOD TIMES LOL

[@michaeluzoho5838]

I don't really follow Collegiate football, but I was hearing that Rattler is a dual threat QB, who is a Heisman contender, and a top QB in the upcoming draft or something like that. Now, they're saying he's gonna get dropped for Williams......wow, I'm honestly surprised. Has Rattler been that bad recently???

[@ht82smash42]

Yup. He's pretty bad m

[@michaeluzoho5838]

@@ht82smash42 Damn

[@WENOTMEPRODUCTIONS]

Finally college football talk

[@Cms927]

I wish they would talk more college football.

[@JonquezMoney]

Why every time they talk about a play we can’t never see it when they look

[@adriankendrick4281]

Spencer has been struggling this season. I think Willams will start against TCU but we'll see.

[@sharifs649]

Never seen anything like it😂

[@leetraviusmckay2919]

People thought Spencer Rattler would be the next Patrick Mahomes

[@michaelchamp5877]

It's weird cuz he actually has that play style and that kind of live arm. If he can't make it with Lincoln.. lord help him

[@marleycoldburr]

Caleb Williams has some Mahomes magic I think he stole it from Spencer 😂

[@devontricmoore]

@@marleycoldburr That man pulled some Space Jam magic out.

[@camthesooner123]

@@marleycoldburr lmao like space jam but for football. 🤣

[@JB-tp6uj]

To be fair, Patrick Mahomes wasn't the next Patrick Mahomes when he was coming out of college.

[@BigTulsa]

The issue is that OU has been successful in the last few years with QBs that are true dual-threats (run, pass). Spencer is not a runner and not much of a scrambler so now teams know not to expect him to run and force him to pass, which makes the OU offense one-dimensional. With Williams, it now appears you have a guy that reminds me of a combination of Jalen Hurts and Kyler Murray and teams will be forced to respect his legs, which they didn't do with Rattler.

[@TheGenieLover]

Skip claims to be an Oklahoma fan, but doesn't seem to know that they have a long-standing policy regarding freshmen not available for interviews. I wouldn't worry too much about Caleb Williams not getting interview opportunities. I suspect he will have more than enough in his future😎.

[@whdawg1506]

Spencer Rattler was the Heisman favorite and the projected 1st pick in the draft by a lot of people. Look where we are now

[@wesleyeggleston8510]

Here after watching night cap on Rattler

[@Drewmack22]

I thought it was comical when people said Spencer was the #1 recruit

[@fatherdoom6702]

Fowler Dodge rep: "Spencer, I'm sorry son, but we need those keys back by this afternoon".

[@zay007]

He might end up like D’eriq King

[@pebsmith2696]

Rattler might as well declare for the USFL draft in the spring

[@11fromheaven1]

Nice

[@sheldonbond7572]

So much better than ESPN First Take, you don’t need to yell to get your point across. Just casual sports talk with facts rather than feelings.

[@Rosinronin]

This whole situation gives me Braxton Miller vibes however spencer rattler wasn’t injured like Miller was

[@genesisofsound]

Lincoln Riley might actually be a genius. This style is basically him saying to Caleb, you're already going to be great, you don't need the limelight yet. Basically telling him to stay humble and good things will come, showing he's got confidence in him but not straight giving up on Rattler. That's some high IQ coaching there. Defense is still the worst in the league and has been for over a decade though so no chance at a chip.

[@Davo2times]

digging into caleb’s lore

[@rodgerbane3825]

"Superman" (Celeb Williams nickname) is and will be the clear starter.

[@bryanchan9537]

C Williams reminds me of a bigger version K. Murray.

[@bradleyjacks2691]

If Rattler starts I guarantee Lincoln Riley's gonna lose the team.

[@jackbobwee2902]

Lincoln didn’t let Caleb talk to the media after the game because it’s a school rule where freshmen can’t talk to the nedia

[@thechosen1226]

If you gave up on Spencer rattler as a QB … your sadly mistaken … whether he transfers or wins the job permanently… this kid was ranked top 5 in 2 sports in HS … gone have to miss me w that .. stats and eye ball test don’t lie .. he may be slipped but give him time .. Oklahoma ain’t going no where in the next 2 years anyways .

[@yungmark09ify]

Shannon and Skip need to learn the Freshman at OU don't get to speak with Media. This has been in effect since we got destroyed by tOSU.

[@yuriburkel686]

Skip, Skip, Skip and Skip. I told u

[@darronlt81]

Come to Texas

[@davecoffield7893]

Guys, the Sooners need your love..... Nothing about "The Play" on 4th and short at KU? The "build" as injured players return to OU against Tech? Caleb's 6 TD's at Tech? Something strange, weird, unique, and getting more bizarre by the week. C'mon, Mr. Skip "love my Sooners" dude!

[@ajcoronado812]

I said it on Williams first drive In, they settled for a field goal, but he threw 2 dimes in a row that were dropped, I said immediately that Rattler lost his job.

[@taligokrazii1147]

I didn’t know he was the #1 recruit in the nation

[@airyoxus]

Only reason they replacing him is because the Sooners are in the playoffs as of now

[@cliftonconnor9389]

Real simple, if Spencer is benched, why stay? It makes no sense to stay at Oklahoma when he can start with a number of other FBS schools? If he is benched, he needs to enter the Transfer Portal before the December early signing period so other schools can make a decision about their recruiting class. It is not selfish, it is smart.

[@paulsmith5803]

“i don’t care about no marketability, i need win ability”😭

[@trethomas8600]

Caleb

[@JHargis68]

Spencer needs to transfer to East Central.

[@notjmlowe]

Riley can’t keep those “incumbents” either a transfer or a freshman alwayz takes the spot.. best wishes to Rattler When he transfers

[@MrZeroe1]

If Skip was a real Oklahoma fan he would know true freshman are not allowed to talk to the media, no exceptions. It's been that way for decades.

[@Jayytoven4]

Im kinda disappointed that they didnt touch on Spencer's character and lack of leadership with a very big ego. The kid is a big "I" guy

[@adlersreynolds8526]

Shannon isn't feeling this topic. Just gives Skip an opportunity to rant

[@danko6498]

But I don’t believe Caleb Williams wouldve got them to 5-0 just because he looked good in one game 🤨

[@BigDilf3]

Rattler didn’t get them to 5-0

[@mfd588]

SKIUP "DUEL THREAT"

[@macp2657]

havent watch much oklahoma this year, but someone tell why rattler is so bad? that attitude of his, alone drops his stock big time. should take notes from jalen hurts' classiness and leadership

[@25nahshon]

He was cocky then played mediocre

[@alexrodriguez9498]

The issue is rattler isn’t a dual threat. He is a pocket Passer. OU lost 2 OL to the NFL and immediately you could tell a difference the OL now is not good for OU. Meaning OU can’t establish the run early in games so that causes teams to rush 3/4 DL and sit in a 7/8 man cover 2 zone coverage eliminating the deep shot for rattler. Because teams are in a zone coverage 70% of the time it causes rattler to have to throw tight window passes or just check it down because the deep shot will never be open. With Williams he can run so teams have to stack the box against him which open up the passing game, and opens up the deep shots.

[@JB-tp6uj]

@@alexrodriguez9498 Excellent analysis.

[@briannewsom2439]

It’s a rule no freshman gets interviewed

[@TheOnlyBallout]

Why yall just now talking bout this 😂

[@jaystacks5249]

My man got to get a new line. I never seen from skip bayless is used every segment

[@deshawnhundley8819]

Hopefully the rams can get rattler in the 2# round

[@Midwest51344]

Spencer " im about to transfer" Rattler

[@mveytia]

OU loses if Riley doesn't make that change last week. Simple as that. Rattler shouldn't see the field again this year.

[@adlersreynolds8526]

So did this kid just go from 1st pick to undrafted???

[@loganbremerman1248]

Rattler wont be on OU roster next year. Surprised he hasn't entered the draft portal yet

[@keidrienwadley21]

There is one defense I will give Spencer & nobody wants to point it out. Lincoln was calling a terrible first half by continuously forcing the pass & not running more. 2nd half with Caleb OU ran the football. OU’s oline isn’t great at the pass blocking. I think Caleb is overall better but that is due to him being able to use his legs better than Spencer.

[@llklik51]

He should transfer to Clemson

[@charliewilliamson5777]

This is worse than 2012 Geno Smith