Who would have joined in IDFB 2, if we knew everyone's personality?

In idfb 2 match joined, but if we knew everyone's personality back in IDFB 1, what would have joined instead of match? Let's find out today :)

[@APOYOSC]

I noticed a mistake: Foldy didn't exist in IDFB, so she didn't count and that means ereaser is the most loved character in Free food (After foldy).

[@mariomifsud3216]

Oh Ok, I Just Noticed That Now With You Too! xD

[@APOYOSC]

Oh ok XD

[@asclol2368]

I was about to comment that.

[@cyronic4261]

So just eraser is the most well liked on team free food

[@jessiethomas7152]

Dora and naily

[@nuppy6584]

Fun fact: if there was an mini show for only the most loved characters, pen, blocky and eraser would still be together!

[@GameyGaming]

When you realize Foldy, Stapy, & Liy already existed

[@divine_offender]

Rainbowy panda lol and their profile pic is loser too lol

[@GameyGaming]

O O F

[@alphaamoeba]

@Rainbowy panda it wasnt known he was the BFDI Appisiote 25 cameraman at the time Or was it? Idk

[@djhellokittybangbang8764]

Gamey Gaming I love your profile picture cuz your profile picture has loser on your profile picture

[@paperbagcomedychannel7492]

Marker and winner too! They originated in bfdi

[@ItzSmashYT]

Also, I think Fanny is the most liked RC in iance.

[@APOYOSC]

ItzSmashYT but she got many votes

[@ItzSmashYT]

Votes don't really matter. Lots of people like her as of right now. That's the same case with Woody. Lots of people like him, but he gets a lot of votes.

[@ronaltz]

lollipop:hey fanny. u lol

[@APOYOSC]

ItzSmashYT you know? I think you’re right!

[@meefdesu3597]

Fanny's getting a lot of votes, but the % is gradually decreasing. When iance loses again, it's likely she'll be within the first two or three safe. Woody, however, had his votes go down from BFB 6 to BFB 10 (2544 to 2026).

[@puppup7041]

I think Grassy, Cloudy, or Barf Bag would have joined if we knew their BFB personalities. EDIT: Cloudy would most likely have the most votes to leave the TLC due to being a rather funny character. Barf Bag would get the second most votes, but some people dislike her for being a bit bland and sometimes is considered a Leafy clone. Grassy would get the third most because people like him for some reason (despite being bland).

[@tohruadachisnosehairs]

Grassy is a pure boy :)

[@adblox]

Barf Bag isn't bland but if the place is 2nd then I'll deal with it.

[@well...anyway]

Worth pointing out though that just getting the fewest votes doesn’t mean you’re the most loved. Just look at Loser. He has an enormous fan base, but most of the rest of the voters disliked him. But that doesn’t mean that the rest of the Losers were necessarily more loved than him. It just means those who dislike him managed to outnumber the split vote of his fans.

[@hlgask]

Match: gets eliminated, but stays for a few more episodes IDFB: rejoins automatically instead of Pen

[@SirGustopher]

Pen: bruh

[@teamawesomeandsquishy4216]

Neither of them deserved it.

[@whatdoiaddhere]

@@teamawesomeandsquishy4216 actually match deserved to rejoin

[@AnimatorCrumpet]

we all knew puffball did.@@teamawesomeandsquishy4216

[@Ridwan45032]

No pen

[@RobertoDeMundo]

Match wouldve joined (Or Pen I forgot)

[@hlgask]

It was Match.

[@zaznux2675]

It was Match. WHICH SUCKS ASS. Sorry for the launguage, it's just, Pencil and Match together are annoying, and Pen is my Runner up for favorite character.

[@zerbafinc854]

I was expecting for dora or remote to be in

[@trust_ice]

freesmart is my favorites

[@AriInhalesSeasoning]

PyroGamerXD SHUT UP STUPID MATCH IS THE BEST CHARACTER EVER!!!!

[@infiniteobject]

Oh so the bfb wiki is not hacked anymore

[@APOYOSC]

Yeah

[@akz326reppin8]

No

[@zackdoyle864]

yup

[@granty3796]

Yeah I have it on my tablet

[@xavier3658]

I saw 2 wiki of bfb, so you probably checked the wrong wiki

[@seanelillibridge]

Iance-Lightning Beep-Cloudy Team Ice Cube-Barf Bag Death Pact-Pen The Losers-Cake A Better Name Than That-Blocky Free Food-Eraser Bleh-Teardrop

[@meowsofluckiness5080]

Now let’s like this Thingadoodle!

[@mariomifsud3216]

YAY MY FAVOURITE KZbinR UPLOADED!!! I

[@APOYOSC]

Aw thanks!

[@mariomifsud3216]

No Problem! Oh And can You Do A Video Where You Talk About What You Personally Think Of Every Contestant? It Would Be Awesome! Again, Thanks For Being Here For Us!

[@APOYOSC]

Thanks! Also yeah i could do that...

[@nero7467]

Now in BLEH we know whos fan favourite: ice cube (free already), and 2nd Teardrop! So in BLEH its teardrop now :)

[@springdude1165]

It would likely be Black Hole, he already got quite a few votes when we didn't know his personality, so knowing what it is, he would likely join.

[@shufflr1513]

H didnt exist yet

[@DorosDeli]

@@shufflr1513 yes he did

[@shufflr1513]

@@DorosDeli No look at the vote to join chart hes one of the super newbies like foldy

[@DorosDeli]

@@shufflr1513 no, black hole existed before foldy. Black hole debuted in BFDIA, while foldy, stapler and liy debuted in BFB. But other characters like basketball and balloony debuted in bfdi episode 18 So you have 5 groups The OG’s (Flower, Rocky, Pencil, etc.) The Newbies (Basketball, Bell, Eggy, etc.) debuted in BFDI EP 18 The Super Newbies (Black Hole, Firey Jr., Puffball, etc.) debuted in BFDIA The Super Super Newbies (Liy, Foldy and Stapler) debuted in BFB The Super Super Super Newbies (Price Tag, Avocado, Leek, etc.) debuted in TPOT While Nonexisty was in TPOT as a recommended character, he already existed in BFDI episode 18.

[@mraxolotldoesstuff]

Match actually rejoined, but teardrop deserved it

[@user-fj1uo5zm8g]

I know :(((((((

[@JacobJohnsen-nu7nl]

In idfb 3 I think she would rejoin

[@TheArsonistIsTaken]

​​@@JacobJohnsen-nu7nlI think blocky can rejoin

[@ChorusKids]

Didn,t we know Pen's personality? I mean, he also got the 2nd most votes to be freed from the TLC anyways.

[@tannermiller286]

Good... if there wasn't a major flaw... WE ALREADY KNEW PENS PERSONALITY!!!

[@soggabossfight7171]

Pen isn’t a recommended character either

[@fal4thought]

Matheus OneMatheusMF Ummmmmmmm, are you-

[@MayorVideo]

And match

[@DpleDualies]

​@@soggabossfight7171right, but he was in the TLC, and even by IDFB 1, he got the second most votes Also, I'm a bit late lol

[@clar2837]

Yes, I am one of the Cake lovers, even if he is a follower, it’s hard (for me anyways) to not like him because he’s cute

[@Branchkid4575]

Me too

[@spinner1785]

Nice :)

[@handsplasticx]

While theoretically this could work, it’s kind of flawed. For instance, a character could be not voted for being the least horrible on a team. However, if that character were to be on a different team, they could’ve not of gotten the least votes. Moreover, your judging it by how little people dislike a character, as the voting system for BFB requires people to vote to eliminate, not save.

[@blixxy537]

oh how the tables have turned…

[@slyar]

Basing it off of presplit I think it'd be - Snowball or still Match for iance - Cloudy for BEEP - Barf Bag for TIC - Black Hole for Death PACT - Clock for The Losers - Blocky for ABNTT - Eraser for Free Food - Taco for BLEH

[@jamesmonin5981]

*IDFB 2 is in area 51*

[@inkydemon2773]

Locating current location inside of Area 51 which has IDFB 2 now…

[@RWBYraikou888]

Going by the vote percentage Bleh has leading up to BFB 15, Ice Cube is the least voted, but she was out of the TLC in IDFB. Second place is Teardrop, and since she was eliminated in BFDIA, she would be the member of Bleh to leave the TLC.

[@user-fj1uo5zm8g]

Hooray TD is my favourite

[@electrowarrior_pvz2]

Fun fact: in IFDB 1, they actually spoiled the BFDIA 6 voting results so its also why puffball is in the tlc and many people knew puffball would be eliminated in BFDIA 6 because of IDFB 1

[@kimberlynathoo203]

I want noneiztey back because I didn't see him/her

[@Enderthey]

It was a joke-

[@alphaamoeba]

He wasnt present for BFDIA anyway

[@wobber.]

/them

[@susanresma3713]

nonexisty is a boy

[@pronoob1760]

@@susanresma3713 nonexisty is nonbinary actually

[@tiax0340]

Actually Teardrop is the most loved character from bleh

[@AC-fl1le]

@@ByIethSimp Icy was out of the LOL

[@mariomifsud3216]

Hey Guys, Now I Know Loads Of People Might Hate Me By My Name.. Match Is Disliked But Even I Understand He Did Wrong By Trying To be Someone Else But I Just

[@subtlesugar1225]

BFDI Match, Match didn’t deserve elimination. Snowball did.

[@stuffy707p5]

Diamond Destroyer yup

[@wiz6r]

I think Bubble deserved to swap with match

[@stuffy707p5]

Wizer I agree

[@Zachyshows]

BFDI Match I said #SaveMatch (w/ others...)

[@recycling7469]

Wow, people like me! Good job,

[@aimeejones1292]

Lightninng

[@Zeus_404_]

4:28 Cake For The Losers! LOL

[@CornInSpace]

Actually Match was first Pen was second Puffball was 3rd Tear Drop 4th was Taco 5th was Bell 6th was David and I dont remember the rest

[@SRBAnimate]

Nice

[@FireballAnimates]

Yay, Blocky is the favorite on his team :D

[@bombyman84]

I'd vote God, aka Eggy. I'd die for eggy just to stay in the show.

[@snongycakebfdirock4901]

I will choose tear drop

[@johannkendrickvalerio3903]

oh good video

[@bubblegaminglol]

For bleh, it’s teardrop ;)

[@seanelillibridge]

I think Pen is the most likely to join, or maybe Teardrop, who was eliminated in BFDIA 4 over Coiny

[@thegrishplays3356]

In the real IDFB 1 votes, Pen got the second-most votes to be freed, just after Match. Teardrop would be freed only 2 episodes after. (she got the 4th most votes, after david)

[@seanelillibridge]

@@thegrishplays3356 Of the top 3 in the rejoin, only Pen was still in as of BFB 12, because David and Match were eliminated. Teardrop was also still in. And I think Match rejoining in IDFB 2 was a dumb idea. Could've Pen or Teardrop joined instead of her? Teardrop would've been in the top 3 in the rejoin.

[@Hermit__]

They forgot non-existeny in bfb

[@superblox6205]

Pen is the coolest he should be out of the TLC

[@KingAtriox]

happy bday to this video

[@catshadesmsp3125]

Me:FOLDY WASN'T IN IDFB *looks at the pinned comment* Me:Sorry i'll die

[@kassiemcgowan]

😭😭😭😭😭🐣🐣🐣🐣🐣🐣

[@LebaneseAdmiral]

Bleh elimenation went like: Ice cube(dead) So teardrop actually is the fan favorite

[@Bayock162]

I think Eggy

[@flyingdoggy9613]

nahhh its teardrop in bleh whos most loved

[@ClatterPix]

3:43 that’s you when you realized foldy wasn’t there in idfb lol

[@stouter.6004]

I Made Some Calulations And It Appears Cake Would Join The Game. My Proof: 1st Cake (Only 826 votes against) 2nd pen (only 1093 votes against) 3rd eraser (only 1151 votes against) 4th lightning (only 1336 votes against) 5th Blocky (only 1420 votes against) 6th barf bag (only 1893 votes against) 7th cloudy (only 3255 votes against) 8th taco (only ???(?) votes against)

[@Gaming_Buddy]

I thought that they should've chosen naily to let out first, as naily can slowly break through metal, which means that naily can also help with getting everyone out of the TLC.

[@TheGamingG810]

Although that didn't exist 5 years ago, you could have made an updated version based on the BFB 13 votes for who is the best character.

[@kiarrapablo7369]

Also lollipop is a fan favorite on bleh/*8 names at once* ever since bfb 10 ending

[@joawzy]

Not Foldy, Cause She Wasn't In IDFB

[@APOYOSC]

Treemote yeah, my mistake XD

[@averagejoe2301]

It's not idfb it's bfdi !

[@patchworrk]

Joe Moma ...

[@zerno_dread]

@@averagejoe2301 *Facepalm*

[@ClodsireYT]

@@averagejoe2301 **102929 Facepalms.**

[@candy-canepie2187]

First Time to see this!

[@jenng4439]

Ok

[@elenaarutunova9906]

That was the whole entire video I thought it would be longer

[@reagelacio9665]

Cake is adorable :)

[@chrisa341974]

But if pen had the 2nd most votes, then who got the most votes.

[@sponsoredbywalmart]

Match.

[@chrisa341974]

Oh ok

[@ivywt]

it says at the start of the video

[@mateicsito]

Well, you should change the VIDEO NAME from "Personalities" to "Votes"

[@jesseickes1696]

So...

[@CrystalCM]

I’m pretty early :0

[@sasho524]

Iance: match pencil bubble ruby flower fanny Snowball lightning

[@goldensponge5847]

My guess is: Iance- Fanny Beep- Cloudy Team Ice Cube- Barf Bag Death P.A.C.T- Pen The Losers- Cake ABNTT- Blocky Free Food- Marker Bleh- Lollipop Although they don’t have the least amount of votes, that doesn’t mean that they aren’t the most liked. I know that Fanny, Lollipop, and Marker all get tons of love. Cake would join just because there isn’t much other options besides Clock and Eggy...

[@soapinsteadofsyrup4960]

TDLindsay07 ITS TIME FOR THE RETURN OF THE BEEP BEEP!

[@gracjanwrocksdorasucksEnternai]

Good

[@ashleysmith2417]

How do we see who came yellow face I'm sad because yellow face lied

[@rovizo]

4 Years later.. it’s about to come

[@keewee2117]

Aww I ship cake and loser :( I ship it because cake and pie have only talked once, so they can’t really of liked each other in that amount of time..?

[@copycat7156]

Cake and Loser are both male

[@wallpaper208_]

Never ship them, it’s very *gay*

[@keewee2117]

CowishChuncco wdym gays fine

[@gb-929]

Someone named “Martin Lynch” Stole This video.

[@arctomatic5029]

3:22 Gay.

[@jamespeterson3753]

no. cake is actually a boy. pie is a girl. look it up.

[@bridinanimation]

The whole pals is rejoining :D

[@rageagainstthelillard]

But remember people wanted match out because they were curious what pencil would do

[@cakesjay3064]

3:19 none!!!!! and cake and loser are both male

[@cakesjay3064]

and what pie ralated?

[@APOYOSC]

cakes man do you know there are gay ships right?

[@cakesjay3064]

yes

[@infiniteobject]

A person on KZbin i don’t do gay ships -but two-

[@cakesjay3064]

but not look to me like that

[@JTD845]

Here's the thing with the Cake ships. Cake is male. Yeah. That means that the Cake x Pie is good, cause Pie is female. But the cake x loser... That'd be a same gender ship. If you like that, then that's fine, but I'm not really one for that.

[@GDNashit]

*homophobe! homophobe! code 15a this is not a test!*

[@user-xt5vx7vj7r]

"Barf bag would be the best *guy* to get back"-TB

[@roblox-bfdi3414]

Guys, so IDFB is not cancelled, it is just due to Cary starting collage and they said on Cary’s channel their having a break, but not for long.

[@thepinksheep0183]

-i hate taco- *i love taco*

[@APOYOSC]

Ok

[@stuffy707p5]

-I hate book- *I love book*

[@APOYOSC]

Ok

[@wiz6r]

-i hate myself- *i love myself*

[@salomeyakuffo6208]

Wizer How did you cross what you written?

[@rockyfromtpot7346]

For team bleh it's teardrop since Ice cube was out of the lol

[@TheWolfOC]

hey APON I know this but who do we know who is themoast TOP 1 Chariter that has the moast votes

[@saltywafflez5133]

Idfb hasn’t come out yet im confused

[@sshot7539]

I think in IDFB Match won the rejoin, it says so in the BFDI(A) wiki

[@RedditorScareMe]

Technically if you count when BFDI was close to it's finale,JacknJellify made a joke video were it was Liy vs Foldy and Stapy.

[@APOYOSC]

I know that but that episode isn't canon (I think)

[@theactualhero1326]

What about Bleh in Episode 15, that was released?

[@Byfvdude]

KZbin just recommended me this, so uh, hello APOY

[@ToastersToastToast]

Lightning! My poor little lightning!

[@daschwartz1902]

Of course, Teardrop. I need some more quietness in my life.

[@disamious]

Wait wait wait why do bell and snowball have 5here old assets and why do all the CONTASTANTS have the body’s from bfb but in bfdia 1 they have there old old body’s?

[@freakyspiderr]

4:18 Umm, he was invented in the first episode, but the creators didn’t think to put Loser in this game. Until they brought in Loser from BFDI but now, he’s in BFB.

[@unhandleduser2701]

Which episode is when cloudy turned orange?

[@whyisthislimenow]

If This Video Was Made After BFB 15, Teardrop Could Be The Most Loved Character (Considering She's 2nd Safe)

[@blulagoonanimation]

Match would have rejoined.

[@sergiogama350]

Wait:40 are in TLC 10 have to rejoin the game 3 and 4 person por team.

[@linorder22]

Black Hole would be my guess considering they won the BFB 13 poll and was first safe in TPOT 2

[@SMLEditorYTP]

I wan't Match to come back to the show because, she is in an alliance.

[@Tennisballs101]

Golfball: shoots the tlc with minigunny

[@Jem.Studios]

My favorite team name in BFDI history is “ wheel ooze a hole bunch”

[@zerbafinc854]

We'll lose a whole bunch lol

[@irmayunita8430]

Match is my fave route

[@Arlen56_]

Pen was already out so how he is the fav recommended?

[@mathguy37]

Iance, Beep, and TIC probably play a larger role than the others as they were ufe more. Of course, though, being popular in general is also important.

[@QuesQuestion]

It would be nonexisty but what if they telelport nonexisty out would it be count as a waste or the first contestant out and you only look at the bfb vote but did not look at the old vote.

[@SlushysSecret]

At this point, if they are continuing BFDIA it would mean idfb isnt canon or they have to remake the first episode, unless BFDIA 7 has aome kind of twist to it

[@springdude1165]

But from the votes for 15, TearDrop has the second least, so for bskfj it would be her. (Ice Cube got the least out of all of them, but was out the LOL, so Teardrop.)

[@spacesandwich5593]

You didn't take into account that some characters are divisive (get a lot of votes to eliminate AND to save) and others are discreet (don't get that many votes one way or the other)

[@reemyt6517]

Lol I'm almost done with the 6×3 meme, I only got like 3 days for that work, I just need to use my editing app and I'll be surely done!

[@APOYOSC]

Oh ok then :)

[@ratthing4800]

Im here too!

[@anerferdous9399]

Yay my favorite character is still in the lol

[@cdnmom4107]

It's teardrop who is the most loved on bleh

[@Deerugly5mla]

Foldy wasn’t a recommended character at the time.