Why boolean union fail even all parts are solid polysurface: Q/A Session (2019)

[@dustin2740]

Over 40 minutes struggling with a boolean fail was resolved after watching this! Thanks so much for the tutorial!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You're welcome! glad it help!

[@tiagolemeoficial]

Solved my problem, thanks a lot!!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Glad it helped!

[@baubash]

2 days try to solve this problem. with rebuild curve all works. It was bad kinks... Really thanks

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Super!!

[@Isabellaaaaaaaaaaa]

I've been spending the whole weekend struggling with this but my question was solved in the first 2 mins of the video. damn i should've thought of this sooner

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

glad to help!

[@Boomshankarim]

Great tutorial, going back and fixing the original curve is the best advice to fix these kinds of problems.

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Thanks, Gamma.

[@jeffalessi]

Excellent, another trick to put into my repertoire. Thank you very much.

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are welcome!

[@artemispan]

Thank you for your videos, you are the best! I had the same problem the other day and even though there were only closed curves and closed polysurfaces, still union didn't work!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

great. glad it helps

[@josjaniessen7588]

Thank you PJ , very instructive an so good to know!!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are welcome!

[@RionaFinnJewelleryCAD]

Great tutorial, and great checklist. Thanks so much, I'm learning a lot from your channel.

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Great to hear!

[@patrickahfane2919]

hi PJ thank you to give me the solution of my problem

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

very cool. glad to help, Patrick.

[@zolahilt]

could you do a mesh version of this tutorial??

[@johnsingh7962]

Great tutorial Pj

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Thank you!

[@mickaelblache4178]

Thx for all your vids !

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are welcome

[@mac77ws]

Thanks for the tip. Great video

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are welcome!

[@antonsteblikov6789]

Very good tutorial!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Thanks!

[@Boomshankarim]

Thank you so much for your tutorial, you just made my day 😃🙌

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

that is super! happy to hear that!

[@custom3djewelry507]

Thank you PJ

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are welcome!

[@janourzua]

Luv ur explanaions....

[@pettersonystrawman9291]

I just did the intersection between screw thread and a bolt I couldn't bool unite. It found 477 intersections, most of which are short lines going along the bolt around the surface that is supposed to touch the thread model. What do I do now?

[@zzzmutations]

ual! PJ thank you for this tutorial!!!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

You are very welcome, Marcio!

[@peter962592]

Thank you.

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

👍

[@ליאורמגן-ש7ל]

Thank you for the tutorial. But sometimes I get non manifold edge error how to solve it?

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

It is really depends on the situation. If the surface fold into itself, I will try to trim the problem area, and rebuild the surface.

[@juansebastianrico3944]

Worked!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

perfect

[@21copyCat]

Why add one point to rebuild curve? Why not 2 pts or 3? How do you determine how many points to add to rebuild curve

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

it depends on how many turn you need. Ideally, the less point without changing the shape is better.

[@zzxo2471]

Save my life, Thx!!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

that is great! you are welcome.

[@asiaalhabib4754]

We want to explain the Reno Kold method of opening a file and save it to PHP format and thank you

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

I am not familiar with PHP

[@Awras_Dz]

the problem in boolean commnd is that cant worck when you have much objects maximum is 5 or 6 objects

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

that is possible too.

[@asbedemirkhanian7094]

you are best

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Thank you!!

[@creativevideos4291]

please help me for solve this problem .... how can i send file to you ..... i can't to solve it

[@engyghoneim70]

Hello I wonder if I can send a rhino file that I tried 3 different ways to solve it and your solutions works but when I try to join or Boolean union it it breaks out and I don't know the reason why can you help me please 👉🏻👈🏻

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

It is hard to say without seeing the model. Are the parts you try to boolean solid?

[@engyghoneim70]

@@PJChenJewelryDesign no it is a sweep 2 rails surfaces that i blended the surfaces and joined them to create a mesh can't I Boolean them?

[@Gelincik8lc]

thanxxx

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

you are welcome!

[@Gelincik8lc]

@@PJChenJewelryDesign i tried but i couldnt information style so good

[@abdengineer6225]

i have this question i deal with surfaces have i to bolean union them or i can print directly what i have to do

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

if all the parts are closed solid form. some printers can take the print.

[@abdengineer6225]

@@PJChenJewelryDesign thanks

[@rameshguggila4823]

wondorful

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

Thanks!

[@pooriasalar1198]

🙏🙏🙏

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

^_^

[@FMFvideos]

Thanks uncle roger

[@RosarioEspositodesueto]

I'm just sorry that I don't speak Italian otherwise it would be perfect

[@janourzua]

Tai weveando....

[@mr_goldsmith_1]

Lord murugans logo ohhmm am tamil guy.. Does any one speak tamil here

[@egonssteinboks1562]

!!!!

[@PJChenJewelryDesign]

🙂