Why Cassidy Is NOT The Crying Child || FNaF Theory

[@ImpulseEvan37]

Hey guys! Apologies about the opacity issues throughout the video. Essentially what happened was at the end I was changing opacity on one particular image, but I accidentally added the opacity filter on the entire track instead of just the singular image, and because it was the end of the video, I had no idea it was there because I didn't see the issue when continuing to edit because I was done by then. Hopefully it isn't too much of a bother. Sorry again!

[@Pixlewatchtoo]

Good job

[@tylerlyons1812]

I never believed it to begin with, so thanks for this.

[@FNaF_Fan_4yd3n]

Ok the cake thing actually makes a lot of sense. Could that imply that the birthday Gabriel went to the day he died wasn’t his but Cassidy’s?

[@jobbes3220]

GiBi pointed this out about the mirror. When you close the book it faces the word search

[@Songal18]

This is a really, really great way to look at Happiest Day in that Cassidy gave up Her happiest day so CC could have his.

[@LuisLicona-n2m]

I got the perfect title for the Dave video. Why Dave-victim is the canon name for the Bite-victim!

[@tomast7339]

ITP game pretty much confirmed that Cassidy and CC are not the same There is a very rare event that in the ballpit, after the murderes, you can see some of the NPC kids, and when you getting to close to them the light is flickering and they will dissapered. two of the kids are seeing eating pizze next to a table. and the other three are boy with freddy party hats talking to two girls, one blonde with Chica party hat and the other has black hair, tied with pigtails and golden freddy party hat. despite their models are being used during the party scene, they are the only five kids who appears as ghosts after the murderes. so if those ghosts are MCI, pretty much showing, once again, that Cassidy is both a girl and not the crying child

[@ShadowLibra]

No one with common sense would believe Cassidyvictim anyway. Such a very obviously wrong theory... Who would ever believe it... I sure wouldn't... Nope! Never!

[@locolord]

I don't really believe in the theory either, but in it's defense, the theorists that I've seen such as Duel Process Theory have said that the Crying Child survived the bite, but was put into a coma, and that William attempted to "save" him by stuffing him into the Golden Freddy suit. I think that this theory, while still pretty convoluted, is at least more plausible than William resurrecting his son just to kill him again. I'd suggest doing some research on your own if you aren't convinced. There is a decent amount of evidence to support this theory, I just couldn't find it.

[@ImpulseEvan37]

I think the flatline coupled with the fact that the bite victim faded away in the final cutscene is proof enough that he did not survive. Like I said, I have discussed this theory with the people that believe it many times over the years so I know the different ways people justify it, and like i said, I do get it, but I think there's too many contradictions, most notably what I discussed towards the end of the video which also doesnt work with what you've said. Again, I do understand the theory, It just doesnt really work

[@zeldristhecactus1304]

What do you mean by theory?! It's literaly a canon fact. XD

[@Fredboyos]

I remember when I was a big fan of CassidyVictim. Are you referring to me being one of the best online friends you've made? 💀

[@ImpulseEvan37]

No 💀 But you’re cool too lol

[@Fredboyos]

@@ImpulseEvan37 Honestly I would say "You could've at least lied" but you being honest is much more appreciated. Gotta love the honesty

[@SuperBlueGamer9000]

I believe in golden duo theory especially with the while stictch wraith parallel and hiw golden freddy is implied to be possessed by two spirits in the novel continuity

[@Unknowncameraman15]

Just let Cassidy princess die already

[@zenvariety9383]

Isn't the princess supposed to be Vanessa?

[@Unknowncameraman15]

@@zenvariety9383 yes

[@mthedarkness3383]

@@zenvariety9383 Nope. The princess is heavily implied to be Cassidy. And that Cassidy was the one to free Vanessa from glitchtraps control in one of the endings of security breach.

[@damkylan3]

⁠@@mthedarkness3383No, that’s not heavily implied at all. It became a thing because the files called her Cassidy, but that’s no longer true. Considering we now know that Steel Wool threw a bunch of crap at Security Breach while having no idea what Scott’s intentions were, it’s even less likely now.

[@mthedarkness3383]

@@damkylan3 The files wasn't the only evidence my guy.

[@mxsxnslxy]

Is There Issues With The Opacity Or Was It On Purpose

[@ImpulseEvan37]

if you mean at the end that was on purpose lmao

[@mxsxnslxy]

​@@ImpulseEvan37Things Like Mike's Paycheck And What I Can Only Assume Is A Picture Of The My Name Gravestone Over Jeremy's

[@ImpulseEvan37]

huh idk why that happened

[@ImpulseEvan37]

Update: I figured it out and it was a dumb mistake lol

[@EliRetroVHS642]

The theory alone doesn't work for two reasons 1. William wanted a family to look like a good man so... Why kill his own son? Episually the crying one? I'm not saying I don't think William would do that but then people would just know it was William 2. If William indeed killed his youngest son THEN sees him alive why wouldn't he kill a second time? To my those two points are what automatically debunks it

[@Impostor20112]

i still belive in evan victim

[@nlm9587]

I have a feeling that you have a very closed mind.

[@ImpulseEvan37]

It's not having a closed mind if you have actually reasons for not believing something. How is believing something and having evidence to back it up any different from NOT believing something and having evidence that convinces you it isn't the case? Really think about it

[@nlm9587]

@@ImpulseEvan37 Well i remember that when mat had so much evidence you didn't liked the result so you disagreed and he turned out right.

[@thepixelman4776]

Huh. I’m not really a Cassidyvictim believer, it just doesn’t feel right that CC wouldn’t be freed by his own changed memory (on screen), but saying Cassidy gave it up for him is an interesting idea. It’s still a bit roundabout for me, but always nice to have new options to consider. I honestly don’t disagree with Cassidy being a girl despite how I still stick with they/them; the movie kid I just consider to be a gender change between different adaptations because that just happens sometimes. It’s just that it’s still too unconfirmed to me to feel it can be used for theorizing (this is mostly for VS stuff though which is a separate matter; you have other solid points.👍)

[@Oli6906]

May I ask what implies the missong children were electrocuted inside of the suits? 11:52

[@ImpulseEvan37]

in fnaf 1 phone guy claims that inside the animatronics are crossbeams wires and animatronic devices, so if you were stuffed in there it would kill you. In the silver eyes trilogy the missing kids are not only stuffed by afton but also are stated to have died in the suits. Sure its a different universe, but the fact that its what happened there coupled with what phone guy says makes it clear thats how they died in the games too

[@Oli6906]

@@ImpulseEvan37 yeah it says you would be crushed by the parts. Nothing about electrocution. And pretty sure he killed the kids before putting them in the suits

[@ImpulseEvan37]

@@Oli6906 it does not say you would be crushed, it says it would cause discomfort and death. Given the fact that its crossbeams and wires, it’s definitely the zapping part that would kill you. And in the books it is outright stated that the kids died in the animatronics, they didn’t get stuffed after death

[@Oli6906]

@@ImpulseEvan37 which book?

[@ImpulseEvan37]

@@Oli6906 the fourth closet page 178

[@ADonutMan]

ImpulseEvan_37? More like FaxSpittinEvan_37! Yea, idk where I was going with this...

[@Arkham13v]

You're a bit late, but hey, you're welcome to the party anytime

[@bathilra5364]

Yeah I never liked bv 5th

[@zenvariety9383]

I have yet to check out the games, but could it be possible that Cassidy could be the puppet? Yet anything is possible within FNAF.

[@amyeasler2086]

Honestly i think the plushies in fnaf 4 were the mci kids and he was friends with them.what if cassidys death was what dave saw, And she possessed him. Then when he got bit they both possessed fredbear

[@damkylan3]

No. But the plushies are representative of the MCI kids. Just like how CC is representative of the Puppet, but is not actually the Puppet.