Why - Derivakat [Dream SMP original song]

[@Derivakat]

Lyrics: Look at what you’ve done, is this what you call glory Do you still believe you’re the hero of your story I longed for peace, but you couldn’t leave it be Now you’ve played your part in this forever unfinished symphony Oh, it hurts, and it hurts, and it’s getting worse A promise you made, cut down by your blade Can’t stand the rain, can’t stand the pain How it breaks my heart when you tear it apart So why? Why did you lie? Why did your words amount to nothing And why? Why did it fall? Why did you leave me here with nothing Look at what you’ve done, is this your happy ending Look around and see, this is history repeating Do you even care that you’ve left things beyond repair It was by your hand, you’ve turned a masterpiece into a nightmare Oh, it hurts, and it hurts, and it’s getting worse You act like a judge, enforcing your personal grudge Am I to pay for this war you’ve raised Yes it breaks my heart when you tear it apart So why? Why did you lie? Why did your words amount to nothing And why? Why did it fall? Why did you leave me here with nothing Look at what you’ve done, you’ve brought upon disaster Do you still believe this is the justice you sought after

[@doloresandcamilomybeloved3217]

first replay YES edit: now that i have claimed my first first... DERIVA THAT WAS AMAZING HOLY CRAP WE’VE BEEN BLESSED AGAIN!

[@raxberyxox]

pogchamp

[@rosyyish_]

great song as always !! :D

[@quinnforrester7833]

This song is amazing

[@little_ghost5906]

AMAZING SONG-

[@kanayaa]

OMGGGGG

[@truth1095]

FIRST REPLY SHEESSSHHHH

[@livonsaffron8874]

Ayyyyyyy

[@Kaizer_GG]

Pog

[@everyln7263]

GET HYPED UP GUYS

[@sbcdoesthings]

And Kanaya is even here, POGG

[@notsoadl5790]

"Now you’ve played your part in this forever unfinished symphony." My entire nervous system: *yeah its go time*

[@Purebeans]

Me when I find angst: *my soul is fulfilled for now to attack myself on every door in my house* ;-;

[@seffviklysif8893]

That was THE mood at that moment.

[@CMT_Crabbles]

Such a bop! Wish she would post these to spotify!

[@frostbiteicebow1318]

@AC Adrianne Lim I think not, it happened to me twice😂

[@NotHereAnymkreLolll]

Chats crying and giving blue to eachother It’s a mental breakdown **off-key kazoo**

[@yanlina.l.6013]

:(

[@Georgiar]

I know right, that's sad but they're giving it though ;_;

[@theletterh6011]

exactly

[@chelseanotfound4851]

here, have some blue 🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵 :)

[@remusmoony]

Yep :(

[@jasonzhou8274]

2:09 - "Do you even care that you’ve left things beyond repair" I can imagine Techno just saying "I mean, yeah, that was sorta the point."

[@bumblebeeproductions1673]

He would tho

[@jackmcdonald7900]

Tro

[@Bluebyouries]

Why did you lie, reminded me about when he said he was feeling 99% cancer free..

[@christophsiebert1213]

@@Bluebyouries Damn, too soon man.

[@mystic_spider]

​@@Bluebyouries That 1% came out swinging, man.

[@lonelycea8126]

the title: "why" the image: ghostbur **chuckles*, my mental health is in danger*

[@rileyshuman2553]

yikes, and after what happened to him... that almost made me cry over a block game

[@crscsr8864]

@@rileyshuman2553 Oh... I already have... many, many times...

[@elyxisea]

ghostbur... WHY DID YOU HAVE TO DIE NOOOOOOOOOOOOO its not even halloween and i cosplayed as a waterfall

[@CaponeCos]

@@crscsr8864 I feel that. At 4 AM is the worst.

[@random_teapot]

@@rileyshuman2553 Same

[@Skitarii-Enjoyer]

Most Derivakat songs about Karl: Sad but they have a funky vibe Most Derivakat songs about Wilbur: Sad but they have an orchestra vibe

[@rebeccaflood6526]

Its kinda interesting, because Karl has an attitude of everything is fine and he's trying to go through his experiences with a light heart even though some are really bad, which reflects I think in the tone of the song. Wilbur on the other hand is always speaking to the people, always has someone looking to him. The orchestra I feel like almost represents the people behind him, with wilbur leading them.

[@Skitarii-Enjoyer]

@@rebeccaflood6526 it really does, you captured the spirit of those two really well I think

[@camypasteria6344]

blue- oh wait.....

[@JordynNexus]

And then there’s that one Punz song 😂😍

[@colacata7078]

They are both equally sad but the tone is different between each character

[@grimcreeper1307]

It's ironic, Ghostbur wanted to come back, but once he had finally accepted and learned to love himself, he was forced out of the life he had learned to love, and into the life he had learned to resent so much...

[@JohnDoeCDR]

Man, Now I’m sad And I miss ghostbur

[@Darcar745]

The first time i heard this song i cried

[@Gurtopolis]

Ghostbur is the pinnacle of the last fall, he was the last glimpse of light, of optimism.

[@Ojfrd5185]

@@Gurtopolis how dare you make me sad

[@limitless_lagging]

@@Darcar745 same, I actually listened to the lyrics. . . I can also relate other things to her songs than just the dream SMP and its imaculate

[@L.W.74]

"you turned a masterpiece into a nightmare" never fails to get to me

[@VeryPeeved]

if L'Manberg was what he considered a masterpiece, he was farther gone than even i suspected.

[@agreengaming3959]

@@VeryPeeved L’Manberg was far from a masterpiece, but it was the homes of many who lived in piece, it was destroyed many times but it always rose. So in some way you could call it a masterpiece.

[@VeryPeeved]

@@agreengaming3959 ...what? no. that doesn't even slightly follow.

[@YoutubeMilan]

I was singing that when i readed

[@VeryPeeved]

@- TurdNuggetDude - yeah, but it's not a masterpiece because it rose and fell, it's a masterpiece because it was a masterfully designed game. L'manberg was far from masterfully designed, and it certainly was never masterfully run.

[@canarianyellow]

I know this is supposed to be Ghostbur singing to Phil, *but the image of this being Ghostbur singing to Wilbur is so fucking good too*

[@PiryuOfficial]

You have a point Even a good one, I dare say

[@sunflowerseeds8270]

Isn't it supposed to be ghostbur singing to tommy

[@canarianyellow]

@@sunflowerseeds8270 in the description, it says Ghostbur to Phil

[@sunflowerseeds8270]

@@canarianyellow oh lol

[@allinory]

Wow I thought it was to Dream lol

[@miragracestudios5104]

Another song to bop to? *Nice*

[@DaleCrem]

A verified youtuber with 37 likes? *Nice*

[@DaleCrem]

/JJJJ

[@Mel_TheBudgie]

Yes yes

[@ghostjune7]

im most likely going to cry to this instead of bopping

[@caitbelart]

more art to enjoy? nice

[@puffingcat]

the chat is such a vibe, they’re singing your new boyfriend

[@wonderland7017]

@sofixvee and now we’re singing Voices

[@erose4208]

I love the chat sm

[@cosmickinnly]

They just did it again, and Turn Back Time

[@yishaa6097]

Why hello there

[@paranoiaocean]

Still are

[@margaretredner5075]

“Can’t stand the rain” Ghostbur cannot stand directly under the rain. It like, burns him. He starts disappearing. He quite literally, can not stand the rain. Just thought that was a nice line

[@furredBird]

lol

[@pepsisavedtheworld9125]

probably why it hurts because he's been singing in the rain for 3 minutes lol

[@zk2-pj4bq]

Forgetting the origin smp, yes maybe.

[@kiraszabo1333]

Wilbur: **touches rain** pss Pss That's me, touching the rain :] Philza: stop touching the rain- Wilbur: *touches rain again** pss Pss

[@Samuel1181s]

This is perfect for Ghostbur! Him just constantly asking questions as he doesn’t get why everything’s happening or why his dad of all people would have betrayed his nation… It’s incredible!

[@kastheglitch]

HONESTLY

[@mr.sheeppeehs4204]

I feel like it could have mentioned friend, but other than that, yeah it’s a really good song

[@mr.sheeppeehs4204]

@@sidiwvwhi what is that supposed to mean

[@melanch0lycat5393]

@@mr.sheeppeehs4204 He's very naive to the situation, so he doesn't really understand why stuff happens. The lyrics of the song actually further highlight this, Ghostbur talks about Phil as if Phil was the one who started things, as if Phil helped in the destruction of New L'manburg without reason. The lyrics also talked about how New L'manburg was a "masterpiece" when it was anything but, which further references Ghostbur being unable to remember the bad stuff.

[@mr.sheeppeehs4204]

@@melanch0lycat5393 I know that, but he was also sad about friend, it’s a good song, I just feel friend could have been mentioned

[@MonkeyE00]

"You act like a judge, enforcing your personal grudge." For some reason, I really love that line

[@DTIloverrr-1989]

I read this cmmt as it sang in the song

[@finleyymeow]

AGREE

[@RiverGeode213]

It hits so hard

[@contmusic1727]

Watch trendy remixes and 4K clips))

[@Dumbsourplum]

I believe from that point on thats techno saying that from behind phil, Not to ghostbur but to the actual wilbur who blew up lmanberg, He left techno Alone , With Phil locked up and techno forced to run away to a Empty Snow biome

[@menacingjojoker9079]

Ghostbur is the embodiment of what L'manburg should've been Unfinished, free, and blue Yet, as he said, as probably the most peaceful entity on the SMP... *_Am I to pay for this war?_*

[@sbifuelv9837]

...Sad

[@rajalaireya1748]

😭

[@ilovemango26]

😭😭💙

[@0opsOhNo]

and addicted to drugs

[@apersonwhomayormaynotexist9868]

He's the only truly morally innocent character, yet he's the one who pays for the wars, for tommy's lies ("It's going to be all right"), for Wilbur and for dream

[@radical9619]

This hits different after Ghostbur died.

[@lpssnakmoved1857]

Totally-

[@fubukishiro2279]

How did he die?

[@radical9619]

@@fubukishiro2279 Dream revived him, and because Ghostbur is the ghost of Wilbur that's death for him

[@R4inb0WGUTZ_d0tz1p]

Especially how hes in wilburs limbo.

[@JoshGens]

And it's official he won't ever come back, which is even sadder.

[@lamuliz]

The collab we never knew we needed

[@joxe1088]

there was no collab?

[@Absolite_]

@@joxe1088 I think they might be talking about Late Augusts art

[@enste1]

@Rob Rainsden GO FOR THE NECK

[@kupssauser4702]

*Preach*

[@beanebaby]

but are so very grateful for

[@taynye4245]

Everyone is talking about the "Why did you lie?" but never about the her singing "It hurts it hurts and it's getting worse" Cause Ghostbur was in so much pain at that moment and that it wasn't stopping

[@Byslie]

Give the guy a rest omg, even now in death he's in pain

[@Ramzi65ok]

No one every talked about how NIGHTMERE (the name of dream's axe) made an appearance.

[@coopercarrington527]

Nobody’s talking about “cut down by blade” which has two meanings

[@JubileeSys]

Yo yeah... even at the station with wilbur and glatt he is still gonna be it pain from the scars and never seeing Tommy or friend again..

[@mr.simplicated3658]

Don't forget, even before he entered the prison cell he had to go through pain. He swam through a lake to make it safer for friend. He endured the pain of dying with the water system in the prison.

[@MonkeyE00]

"I didn't hurt anyone and yet I'm the one who pays." "I know I'm forgetful, I know I'm an amnesiac and I know I'm the comic relief in all your stories, but I still feel this. I still feel things and I try my best to make sure no one else feels it." - Ghostbur when talking to Phil after Doomsday

[@nilanjangoswami2890]

This deserves way more likes.

[@contmusic1727]

Watch trendy remixes and 4K clips))

[@bumble___beaa]

Oh my god that scene almost made me cry-

[@StylishWitch]

*sobs internally*

[@jackob4271]

"i sow the seeds of peace yet i'm the one who pays for war"

[@Optimsy]

My god the dream smp community is truly amazing, first we have derivakat and cg5 making best dream smp songs then we have toktopus and Sad ist making unbelievable animatics, specially sad ist.

[@sovietmarshmallow1283]

I hadn’t actually heard of toktopus before this comment, thank you for introducing me to them!

[@Changbinsbum]

There's also bettlebug and Kanaya

And Precious Jewel Amor

[@near5148]

Why did I read Phil why? With full emotion in my voice

[@iamr9819]

Premiere: *starts in 2 days* Me: *"I can do this all day"*

[@hars14]

69 likes nice

[@theshinyshinx8736]

Lol

[@milkyway5810]

Too bad its gonna take 2

[@MN-ys2pe]

Not me thinking it was in a couple hrs-

[@reinhardvanastrea3986]

umm, I didn't notice you broke my heart

[@glombard8583]

The fact that Phil said "Son, why did you lie ?" Talking about Wilbur's letters two days before this was released is a chiling coincidence

[@err894]

Plot twist: It was planned

[@glombard8583]

@@err894 it would be Pog cause it would implied that CCs know about derivakat. But so far only Tommy and Karl aknowledged her sadly

[@err894]

@@glombard8583 still waiting for her to become an actual character Along with SAD-ist of course

[@glombard8583]

@@err894 apparently we're getting Kristin soon so one can hope

[@err894]

@@glombard8583 Who? Im not that good with celebrities so don't blame me

[@sjhddhdhs]

i was gonna say "rip ghostbur" but we all know that he is far from resting in peace

[@kaboomgaming4255]

_sobs in the corner_

[@quillcow]

FJCK NO STOP SJAJWJEJSKSKEO mans resting in a wet train station instead😔

[@saviorofthedreamingdead]

SPAIN WITHOUT THE S

[@ilovemango26]

😭😭😭

[@JustTowas]

*starts sobbing*

[@kentiar9488]

This has become a hard song for Derivikat to keep open. But don't hold feelings against her for keeping it open. It's a good song. Let it help you shield you against those who harm you. Make it your shield, because it's not about the ghost of the nightmare. It's about you. It might hurt, but you are strong. You will rise and become stronger. You are important. You matter.

[@dull_demon4717]

Ironically, the song is about someone who is the exact opposite of him too

[@lydiannathanailaki]

This is an 1000% lore song

[@thunderskull258]

I agree to your comment

[@biggieandsmalls2154]

Yes

[@man7912]

Derivakat makes the dream smp 1000% loreier

[@allensdumpling]

They're all

[@DTIloverrr-1989]

@@man7912 ‘loreier’ Grammar police go wee woo

[@mikkywestlake3456]

The second “so why did you lie?” Is so freaking powerful wow

[@Byslie]

yesss ikr? It's so gooddd

[@fat_whiskers6525]

jesus fr tho

[@sooahnim]

You can hear the anger with the emphasis on each word, but you can hear the sadness from the passion behind it. Especially at the "leave me here with nothing"! You're a brilliant performer

[@Nem_nem143]

And yet she still has some haters bruh who would hate on her?? She's a very talented person i mean she makes dream smp songs *ORIGINAL SONGS* if she colabs with SAD-ist im going to lose it they make such a good team

[@yaellevi5448]

I was just thinking the same thing. Explaining this to a character in my book.

[@yaellevi5448]

@@Nem_nem143 she has haters? Well, I guess people are *really* stupid sometimes…

[@X-SPONGED]

Ghostbur from everyone else's POV: A gentle, cute, and kind ghost, a far cry from the mentally unstable former president and an overall welcome presence to the server Ghostbur from Phil's POV: a former hollow shell of your own loving son who is close enough to the real thing to hurt, but not close enough for him to be comforted by. Must feel bad for lying to him like that, I'm sure behind that neutral face after the Doomsday dust settles he's still holding back tears from seeing Ghostbur sob over Friend's death even though you know it's only temporary

[@thescarletemperor64]

Hi Dr. Pepper

[@ero9981]

@@thescarletemperor64 hi The Scarlet Emperor

[@Formless_Blob]

@@ero9981 Hi Ero

[@danieltorralbolopez8169]

@@Formless_Blob Hi Formless Blob

[@asyl944]

@@danieltorralbolopez8169 Hi, Daniel Torralbo Lopez

[@jameskaski9525]

What’s interesting to me is that this song could go along with either the lmanburg explosion or when ghost but dies and Wilbur returns

[@BillyBob-wh4sq]

Yooo are you also a fan of Samsa?

[@apersonwhomayormaynotexist9868]

Isn't it the doomsday war, since he's talking to phil, and Phil wasn't the one who caused the L'manberg explosion, he tried to stop it

[@Lorelai_Di-Angelo]

I like to think they mean Ghostbur singing to Tommy even though he knows he can't hear him and 'why did you lie' is referencing 'You told me I was gonna be okay'. And now Ghostbur is forever stuck in his personal limbo; the prison, with Tommy, Dream and Sam as he screams his lungs out but no one can hear him. P A I N

[@Lorelai_Di-Angelo]

This hurt to write :)

[@diamondswordhd2232]

@@apersonwhomayormaynotexist9868 the second with Phil and techno and dream

[@frenchiefry7802]

I would die a million times over if SAD-ist and Derivakat did a collab to this song

[@romeesaalii]

Derivakat did a collab with Late-August (another animator) with this song! I bet she might do it with another tho! :)

[@stafey7659]

@@romeesaalii what were?! The two best animators!

[@romeesaalii]

@@stafey7659 haha the animation for this video was from Late-August. You can check the description!

[@anastasis2291]

She also did collab with Dropster. Look her animations. They are insane 😍. But I am also looking forward to collab with SAD-ist 🤪

[@MikayaAkyo]

I don't think the Universe could withstand it if Derivakat and SAD-ist did that. I mean this feelt like the Universe was on the verge of breaking and i don't think it could survive another go.

[@TimeBucks]

how they nail every single song??

[@Apex_Warfare]

finally a verified person with 10 likes, Dang man!

[@maggiedillon496]

What’s up check mark

[@p.t.557]

This hit a lot more hard when you know that ghostbur is literaly dying when in the rain.

[@maggiedillon496]

@@p.t.557 /j oh god now I’m crying you son of a- (/j means kidding)

[@Anthony-yg6zu]

Fake Verified person

[@aishathleah1330]

ghostbur didn't deserve what happened to him :(

[@Shawn-bu5kp]

In order to make myself less sad about ghostbur, I’ve convinced myself that tommy’s ghost is keeping ghostbur company in limbo, as he probably died in order for tommy to come back

[@aishathleah1330]

@@Shawn-bu5kp People call the ghost version of tommy 'phantommy' but yeah i agree

[@Shawn-bu5kp]

@@aishathleah1330 I’ve seen people use like three different names for tommy’s ghost so I just call him that

[@bumblebeeproductions1673]

@@Shawn-bu5kp thank you I needed this

[@imaghost2961]

Ghostbur brought a lot of comfort to me when I was going through a dark time.. watching videos of him made me smile when I thought I couldn’t anymore. As cool as the Revival thing is.. I want Ghostbur back, or to at least have a better afterlife. It just breaks my heart..

[@cloudchaser7716]

can we have a round of appreciation for Late August's artwork for this? Like holy fuck that is gorgeous

[@kimtu2779]

IKR!!

[@DTIloverrr-1989]

YESSIR IT DOESS

[@Akknights]

When you see there is a new song coming up: HYPE When u realize its 36 hours from now :

[@Maaminextdoor]

so true

[@ryanchou5549]

Sadge

[@chakocha]

sad

[@yourself2.08]

L

[@NxtsuoX]

LMAO SAME

[@bluejellie]

THE SINGING COMBINED WITH THE ABSOLUTE GORGEOUS ARTWORK IS INSANE. HOLY SH*T

[@MISTERX_5890]

I love the artwork with the Obsidian grid

[@stoneforest2639]

This song gives me goosebumps. The art and the lyrics and the thunder and the base is all just perfect. I never thought a Minecraft roleplay series fan song would make me get goosebumps.

[@bagelmaster2498]

It’s interesting if you imagine if he’s talking to either techno or Philza the songs message changes just a bit.

[@treeeyed8578]

I think he's talking to both at the same time

[@treeeyed8578]

@LittleJo1ie right before the music starts it says why pliza

[@tbgbeats4480]

It’s referring to Phil after he participated in the Doomsday War!

[@spixisingss]

Hes talking to Phil, look in the desc

[@RockinIan121]

He's mainly talking to Phil but it seems as if he's speaking to both. It also seems like he could be talking to Tommy aswell.

[@katmatte640]

Late-August drew this??? Holy cannoli it’s the collab of the century

[@magdalenamarszalek]

Imagine if Late-August drew backgrounds, Sadist characters and Derivakat made a song for their animatic. I hope one day they can get in touch and do the greatest collab of the entire universe's history

[@rebeccaflood6526]

@@magdalenamarszalek Or or Sadist did the story boarding and sounds while late-august did the artistry and Derivakat the music

[@ssjbro9086]

Omg the "Why, Why did you lie" part is so powerful for some reason.

[@paarzvahl]

the "Phil, why" at the beginning killed me.

[@rozugold]

“You act like a judge, enforcing your personal grudge” I AM ON THE FLOORR!!! WHAT A KILLER LINE

[@lukiklepsa6218]

It was time somebody spoke back to The Blade. And dang the line was strong! (Same for Dream)

[@stafey7659]

@@lukiklepsa6218 so being a drug dealer and killing people unprovoked is fine? War crimes are fine? Why is Technoblade wrong while tubbo and Lamberg are such amazing good guys

[@desiredsweets]

Bruh I read this comment as the line came up for me the first time

[@high9170]

​@@stafey7659 theyre both shitty people its just that one has the power to cut down all opposition and the other doesnt

[@turma8eac]

Think this was more aimed at Phil He had a grudge against lmanberg ever since he had to kill Wilbur (understandably so) and later tried to justify it by saying he was removing a corrupt government that would only corrupt good people

[@caitbelart]

the emotion and the lighting when she yells “why?” is just so powerful

[@duckied7208]

“Premieres in 30 hours” Chat be having fun with a food fight and hunger games

[@raniacat9742]

I wasn't there

[@sendhelp1517]

kahoot too :)

[@erose4208]

I was on my murder arc >:)

[@crscsr8864]

Yes, Techno won the hunger games. Also, Philza was eaten by a beast. But it's ok because someone gave me virtual popcorn for the sleepover and sing-alongs.

[@CRAutist]

Theory: Wilbur has a shattered soul. Split directly down the middle. Ghostbur, and new alivebur, are the two halves. The soul was shattered the moment Wilbur died, but it was shattered because L'manburg was gone when he did. Ghostbur is what's left of President Wilbur. This is why Slimecicle referred to ghostbur as "Ashy." Anyone notice how there are times between when Wilbur "snapped" and when Wilbur Died, that he walked around giving people blue. Nobody noticed this, and I don't know why y'all just forgot about it. It happened at least once. I dont remember when. But I just KNOW it happened. Aswell as how conflicted he was when the button was in front of him. Almost as if there were already cracks in the soul, and the halves were fighting. ASWELL as how when he was talking about the festival to Tommy after it was announced, he LITERALLY SOUNDED LIKE GHOSTBUR. "How would the souls already be cracked?" In my personal opinion I think there are 3 places the souls could crack at, and honestly all three of them coulda done something. 1. When Wilbur was exiled. More specifically when he saw that everyone in L'manburg was yelling at him to get out. He felt betrayed by his own country. His whole point on the server. The extremely conflicted thoughts of being rejected by his own point of existence caused the first crack. 2. The moment Wilbur said "let's be the bad guys." Aka when he became the enemy of L'manburg. Becoming the enemy of his own point of existence causes the second crack. 3. When Wilbur agreed to be L'manburgs "traitor" with Dream, aka when he knew he was gonna do it. Agreeing to end his own point of existence creates an apposing point of existence. An enemy of himself. Thus, there is officially two souls. But they aren't completely separated. Not yet. They still have a battle to fight. A 1v1 against himself until the day he dies. Also notice how Alivebur is well aware of Ghostbur, but ignores him. He rejects the blue, "don't give me that shit." And when he rejects Friend, he doesnt reject it, he doesnt know who Friend is at all. This is definitly because alivebur was.. well.. in hell when Ghostbur met Friend. Alivebur doesn't know who Friend is, but rejects blue because Ghostbur was giving out blue far before the two halves split. So alivebur is well aware that the blue is Ghostburs thing, And is angry with him. Almost the same way Ghostbur doesnt like Alivebur, and wants to stay away from the things that Alivebur did. Also not to mention that Alivebur LITERALLY SAID that he never gave a single shit about L'manberg, but Ghostbur SCREAMED AT PHILZA for blowing it up! Speaking of, anyone else think that the extreme emotions in the moment where he yelled at phil is Ghostbur unleashing his anger on Alivebur aswell? Letting out his anger on Philza. Realizing Phil became the exact same thing Alivebur is. Oh, and heres where the "soul being split" bit comes in. As in, the halves the two souls are. The memories are built apon the halves that were split, and the whole reason the halves were split in the first place. Ghostbur has the memories of L'manberg, and working to fight to keep Freedom, friends, and positivity. Alivebur remembers the exact opposite. Alivebur remembers blowing up L'manberg and rebelling AGAINST L'manberg and being selfish, careless, and manipulative. The emotions are built apon who lost and who won in the fight against eachother. Alivebur won in the fight because he managed to blow up L'Manberg eternally, so his emotions are either happy or focused. Ghostbur lost in the fight because L'Manberg was blown up, so he's much more sad, and angry. Ghostbur became a "ghost" because he lost in the fight. Causing him to live the rest of his existence as a weak, disabled, and frankly depressing individual. Forced to stay on earth and stare at his failures. He creates his own ways to help ease this depression, but it never works, because he's not capable of feeling anything else. He can fake it all he wants, but it will never work. He is, quite literally, the definition of depression and trauma. Wilbur Soot. Eternally Broken. Officially A *_Shattered Soot._*

[@meiciaq_]

OMG- This theory is sooooo good!

[@thedabbinggamer3726]

Wow that basically ties up every lose end I could think of. Nice

[@sleepii__storiez]

Apart from the fact that you just wrote an entire essay about your theory, I love this so much. (I can't even begin to imagine how long this must have taken to type out.....)

[@flowyguy]

This has to be the most underrated thing i have ever seen

[@sydney.s]

That’s actually a really good theory. It kinda connects to the story line if you think about it.

[@slayedfr2300]

song isn’t finished yet and i have already played it 1000 times crazy how that happens update: song is finished and i’m in shock its so good wtf

[@daripoo]

IKR

[@user-pp2yj2yx2x]

Derivakat is like the sadist of dream SMP music

[@ninomusic1492]

They must collab

[@hawra5743]

@@ninomusic1492 *must* collab

[@bharatsama1]

@Choccy Milk With Sand indeed *must* collab

[@Oceanius7871]

@@hawra5743 Must collab

[@marysworld9760]

@@hawra5743collab

[@clrdhot]

Everybody gangsta until the chat goes crazy with the premiere only 24 more hours.

[@memechild]

“It breaks my heart when you tear it apart” You suffocate when you don’t breathe

[@sickenedguts1385]

SHEEESH I CANT WAIT FOR THIS ONE. TURN IT UP

[@pastelteabiscuits]

SAME SHEEEEESHHH

[@thedusterbin.819]

SHEEEESHH IS THAT A SAKURA PFP?

[@rena8182]

SAMEE

[@AriaBluey]

Yas

[@sickenedguts1385]

@@thedusterbin.819 IT ISSS

[@pau9957]

watching the lighting go in sync with the beat is so satisfying

[@pareyoi7888]

YES OMG IM GLAD IM NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO NOTICED

[@clairexu4566]

Tommy getting electrocuted

[@marjoriew5989]

I didn’t notice that til you mentioned it, but now I can’t stop looking at it

[@cosmickinnly]

"The internet is a dangerous place." The premiere chat: Saluting Wilbur, singing Your New Boyfriend, Turn Back Time, rescuing cats and bees. (Reminders) and the Bee Cult with the hunger games Edit: 15 minutes until it starts and literally the whole chat is saluting for Ghostbur as well as singing your new boyfriend. AND playing Kahoot- o7 Edit2: Now it's the L'manberg anthem Edit3: Spamming blue and singing Your New Boyfriend once again Edit4: *can no longer explain what's going on * It started let's fucking go!

[@Kookaburr-a]

Oh S¯¯t, that’s what’s causing *Satan* to Die and our souls going to hell

[@thedusterbin.819]

a few hours later; the premiere chat: HUNGER GAMES, KAT FOR THE WINNN KAT POP OF QUEEN

[@jellilo0]

The chat is going on a camping trip with an enderman now LMAO

[@karlothers2487]

Dont forget when it spammed "why"

[@azphelion]

currently it is getting mad at the injustices of discrimination against the lgbtqia+ community

[@Thefailure91]

"am I to pay to pay for this war you raised" and "look around this is history repeating"are perfect

[@raynish4543]

I joined two cults because of this premier chat and I don't regret it

[@iampidgeon6923]

Pog

[@LittleDoggy]

@@luvrxz ya there was a bee, shriek frog, and unicorn one

[@LittleDoggy]

And also a bee

[@-yourlittlegremlin6762]

@@luvrxz you forgot.... about the SAND CULT.

[@FharaS]

*Premiere : is in 1 day* Chat : Casually singing your new boyfriend, l'manburg anthem and spamming E This chat is just incredible

[@justaveraeg]

Now they are spamming o7 lyrics and pogs

[@nevieoconnor]

sounds like good old us

[@rebeccaebersole3275]

Thank you: D

[@arianvixal7143]

and the beans

[@aikomatoriona]

POG

[@tadpollie]

THIS SONG IS A LITERAL BOP KAT

[@driedscones8746]

Someone once said that ghostbur represents the good Wilbur once had within him ,but with ghostbur now stuck in limbo; Wilbur is now half the man he used to be.

[@sarahkhan4154]

It would be so cool if Derivakat and Sadist could just be whitelisted on the SMP as entities roaming around recording everything

[@wickedwoodfairy]

YES

[@annikarosas2720]

Yes omg they’re both like camerawoman wandering around.

[@annikarosas2720]

@Carsten Angelo Francisco okay thank you!!!

[@Charlesinthebox631]

Lmao now i want animators to put them in the background just recording and writing things down

[@joey5o5]

Would they be put in adventure mode tho?

[@millyhearts]

“I’m alive, I’m revived, I survived, gonna cry about it? You should see the other guy-“

[@catherinewong7288]

WHITE STRAKS IN MEH HAIR NOW, NO STRESS LOKIN LIKE A MESS NOW. DRiving off the tracks..... I could sing it for hours :)

[@finnchh_]

WAIY WAIT THATS WHAT THIS SONG IS GONNA BE

[@randomghost4929]

WAIT IT'S THAT SONG!

[@saraalarcon891]

@@catherinewong7288 BUT I'M BACK AND I'VE SEEN HELL BUT *THIS IS A BIT MORE MY STYLE*

[@Ally-gx4hu]

@@saraalarcon891 IM ALIVE IM REVIVED I SURVIVED YOU SURPRISED GONNA CRY ABOUT IT

[@mintyglitches]

i know everyones talking about the lyrics but i just wanna say how much i adore the instrumental too. the tiny details in it hit my brain in all the right spots and really add to the atmosphere and emotion of the song perfectly ahh

[@PROfessionaltrollers]

Ghostbur: Crying because Lmanburg is gone Technoblade: *default dancing*

[@obyvenus5820]

I absolutely love this! Ghostbur is always portrayed as a wholesome, forgiving character, but this song shows how sad he truly is and how angry he can get if someone has hurt something he cares about. In other words, I miss Ghostbur

[@imawaffle148]

o7

[@tomrees3]

I showed my mum and she actually liked it, I feel so powerful

[@tomrees3]

@thibault that's what she's like when I watch the smp streams 😂

[@warriorcatkitty]

I just show my mother nothing because I'd be mad if she didn't like it xD

[@yourself2.08]

Impossible

[@CaponeCos]

Same tho

[@emilybejan]

@@tomrees3 IKRR

[@grimcreeper1307]

"You said I would be okay!" "I promise you will be. Now count to 10 with me." *10 minutes later* "I'm back... Dream brought me back. He's my hero." (: "Wilbur, no-" "Can't you see Tommy?! I've been given a second chance!" (:

[@contmusic1727]

Watch trendy remixes and 4K clips))

[@thelegitpotato1248]

Aaaaaaaaaag- 💔

[@teresaromanelli5174]

why must you do this to me

[@hifzxx]

Dream really stepped up his game after going from traumatizing minors to patronizing adults. Proud of the homeless teletubby ;)

[@sydney.s]

@@hifzxx Yet, he’s still in prison 🥲

[@BloomSkyz]

LYRICS SHOULD NOT STAB THIS HARD

[@debkalpapal2682]

Proud 1st comment of verified youtuber 😌😌😌

[@eirah4072]

Ah yes, the premiere chat spamming lyrics to Blue and Ain't No Crying. This is great lmao Edit: Now we're simultaneously singing Mask and Voices- Edit 2: Oh god everyone's spamming "dududu" for Your New Boyfriend- Edit 3: It’s starting!! Time to cry :D Edit 4: Omg I love this- I love the aspect of the rain coming down harder and harder as the song goes on

[@alliumboo7003]

Edit 3: We are now playing kahoot

[@TheHat_32]

Edit 4: we are now spamming o7

[@johannabielenberg2630]

Edikt 5: 💙💙💙

[@space_0wl480]

"Do you still believe, you're the hero of your story?" "A promise you've made, cut down by your blade" "Do you still believe, this is the justice you sought after?" As always, muffin god tier lyrics. (Edit : got languaged, and obliged)

[@space_0wl480]

@Clo #2 you're right, I'm so sorry xD

[@tumblingartist]

:D very cool

[@MikayaAkyo]

Don't forget: "Now you've played your part in this forever unfinished symphony" and "You act like a judge, enforcing your personal grudge" The way Derivakat always incorporates so many things into the lyrics always surprises me.

[@space_0wl480]

@@MikayaAkyo oh yeah can't believe I forgot those, especially the judge one And I agree! She makes stubtle references to many things and it's amazing

[@bibbles8219]

Im thousandth like ;)

[@taylorclark964]

My parents: the internet is dangerous The internet: just vibing and singing honey

[@carisrandomchannel5101]

very much :]

[@lyz_skycotl]

*I can't believe how, a single word "Why", can be such a godly melody. It is so lovable.* *HOW!? HOW DID U DO IT? I WANNA BE JUST LIKE U IN THE FUTURE.*

[@MyoticTesseract]

Dude why is Finn so prolific, he's made like a million animations starting from Innocence already it's insane This song is a certified BANGER

[@Ramzi65ok]

finnn never misses a beat.

[@SmeltingSmores]

I love the irony that ghostbur asks Phil why he blew up l’manberg, be a part of the unfinished symphony and starting the war when Wilbur did everything he’s blaming Phil for but he just can’t remember

[@williamnabors5185]

Not nearly to the extent Phil did though. Phil aided in a war against all of the SMP essentially. He spawned countless withers that took many lives. Few to none died in Wilbur’s explosion, which was purely a thing because he had gone clinically insane and wanted to send a message about l’Manberg.

[@shinygames7393]

Yeah but ghostbur is connonically a different person

[@williamnabors5185]

That too, Ghostbur isn’t Wil, and he doesn’t like being seen as him

[@Gvi80]

No this is the one were dream and techno destroyed iy

[@Reevazard]

@@Gvi80 Yes but Phil played a role in it none the less and to Ghostbur that that's just as good as blowing it up himself

[@miccellab6170]

Dream SMP fans are going to relapse so badly when everything finally ends. I almost hope it doesn't just for the sake of everyone's mental state.

[@ligamo]

we'll just watch everything again its fine

[@thebutterscotchkid2481]

Yeah... It's the thing I'm most worried about...

[@imyourmotherinlaw8032]

I don’t think I could be mentally stable if it comes to an end.

[@yourself2.08]

I don’t care if it becomes one of those tv shows where they release too many episodes that it gets boring. I. Will. Still. Watch.

[@whydidyoueatmycake3019]

we'll still have the origins smp!

[@makenzieleigh1365]

I love how it kinda sounds like “Night before Dawn” but more solemn, it really ties the characters and the story together :)

[@alysaloha]

"A promise you made, cut down by your blade" I know is directly referring to phil's sword which he used during doomsday, also the same sword he used to kill wil. But I couldn't help but think of techno "the blade" who is arguably the strongest "weapon" on the server

[@wisewolfen9544]

When I hear the line "enforcing your personal grudge" I always think of Techno first because L'manberg attempted to execute him.

[@ninjiinc.8883]

@@wisewolfen9544 well l’manburg put phil under house arrest

[@Erika-sd5ru]

Chat is being awesome right now, giving out blue, singing your new boyfriend, spamming o7, playing Kahoot!, and hyping the song up :D

[@tpwkbethh]

YOU WELCOME

[@pie4557]

ikr that was so fun

[@andyo3637]

also druggin

[@Spermman69]

YES CHAT WAS AWESOME :) 💙

[@coffeecup8722]

18 minutes until the premiere begins, this is your quick checklist for the journey: • Possible need for tissues • food to enjoy while waiting • headphones for vibing in peace • a heart of steel because I can already tell this one is going to be painful asf Enjoy everyone, buckle up and get some blue o7

[@cryo_8488]

It was painful you were right. Please Ghostbur dissapeared at the end. I'm convinced that that was the latest edition after Wilbur got revived. Nothing can change my mind. Edit: I still prefer revivedbur. Revivedbur supremacy❤

[@coffeecup8722]

@@cryo_8488 same, as much as I adore ghostbur it just had to happen ✋😔

[@Tiara_Princess7]

I am obsessed with these songs. Thanks for introducing me to the Dream SMP Favorites: 1. Why 2. In My Head 3. Welcome Home 4. Night Before Dawn 5. Tell Your Story Honorary Mention: Blue

[@analogicaleuphimism2078]

*Do you still think you're the Hero of this story?* Techno: *Yeah, pretty much.* _(Ranboo appears)_ Techno: _*starts sweating_

[@bubble_tea7777]

phil are we side characters?

[@sillygoosetaur]

phil are we side characters?

[@lunaeriksson9275]

phil are we side characters?

[@bluelemon4593]

Phil are we side characters?

[@hussamlamtalssi2966]

phil are we side characters?

[@wawaristi]

The chat are singing ten different songs at once. Its chaos rn. 😭

[@jellilo0]

its harmonic chaos-

[@digital_leo96]

VERY POGCHAMP. Fun fact: the chat are singing your new boyfriend

[@galaxydiancie]

and they still are 45 minutes later

[@chloehartshorne4641]

and they still r aha

[@yes5974]

now they're singing i'm in love with an egirl

[@ma4rtj3]

after 1 hour we are still XD

[@windarchermadeanartchannel984]

I joined in

[@ghost_of_luna]

ik this is to phil but i feel like a few of these lines are to techno too like the line "you act like a judge enforcing your personal grudge" rlly fits techno. yes, it also fits phil. also "do u still belive you the hero of your story" fits techno too. (even though he is a tragic hero in my opinion.) but to some techos actions were villainous. There's lots more to lol just listen to the song

[@teafloofs7091]

I've been thinking of it as towards anyone. Ghostbur's just upset in general about all the events, so while yeah a lot of it is directed at Philza, it's also directed at anyone involved. Dream, Tommy, Techno, etc. (Just my opinion) /lh

[@oatmealdoodles]

Also that part about a promise cut doun by your blade. That little quote reminded me of him

[@VeryPeeved]

tragic? his life isn't a tragedy. maybe to a lesser man, but he keeps going. past the tragedy, past the drama. into the comedy. he keeps his chin up, and makes the world a better place bit by bit. think of all the tragedies he's averted: Tubbo was being forced to choose between his country and his best friend, cracking under the strain. Technoblade solved that by destroying the country, destroying what kept the two apart, and dividing the whole server. which of course led to them almost immediately wrapping up the longest story arc of the whole server, and rallying most of the server to deal Dream his first ever serious defeat. he takes the blossoms of tragedy, and he rips them out by the roots. destroying them utterly, and tearing up the foundation in the process, so that it might be repaired into something better. like a physician breaking bones that have healed wrong, ripping open these old wounds. painful, and damaging, but ultimately for the better.

[@Someone-hy6xz]

@@VeryPeeved Technoblade's solution to problems is that instead of solving the problems, just destroy the thing that is causing the problems in the first place.

[@VeryPeeved]

@@Someone-hy6xz yeah. and it works.

[@arkkangell]

I will never understand how they nail every single song

[@RaeandtheDiamondCastle]

This song hits so much different now that ghostburs gone...

[@ThrowawaytheRatman]

NO DONT REMINDED ME

[@mattgaleur4240]

But dude it has never felt different when Wilbur was alive cause it didn’t existed

[@hello-np6vb]

It does I want him back

[@ast3r1an]

@DONT.TOUCH. MEE here take a carrot calm yourself. 🥕

[@Version_Object]

Wdym it was released today

[@ohshitabug5791]

please just Ghostbur singing this to the top of his lungs at the train station.... if y'all excuse me imma go cry

[@frostbiteicebow1318]

Ouch, why did you do this???? 💙💙take some blue💙💙

[@birbelle]

Y O U,,,,,,, W H Y

[@frostbiteicebow1318]

@@birbelle yup that is what the songs called😃🥲 Here have some 🔵🔵blue🔵🔵

[@ActuallyMori]

I need blue...

[@frostbiteicebow1318]

@@ActuallyMori 🔵🔵🔵🔵

[@New_Studios]

My sister: ‘singing revived’ Me: why are you so obsessed with that song? My sister: ‘shows me song’ Me: listens to everyone of derivakats songs

[@mihai.sondkejd]

In this case, it's *"every one"*

[@aliciawhite8276]

Ikr

[@possibly_stupid]

@@mihai.sondkejd lol

[@marvik3743]

YEAAAAAAH YOUR SISTER POOOOOOOG

[@marvik3743]

I wanna be friends with your sister, we're like the same

[@GirlAb9]

Please, give the person that made this all the love and care in the world cuz they deserve it

[@GirlAb9]

@thibault okay ! Then i may sub :D

[@danken7733]

Amazing song.. And for the readers passing by... Have some blue 💙💙💙

[@AliSGG4774]

Thank you- i needed some

[@danken7733]

@@AliSGG4774 you are welcome, have a great day 💙

[@maravanderwill2915]

Thank you, it was needed

[@danken7733]

@@maravanderwill2915 no problem friend, I wish you a happy day💙

[@lilahb]

Thank you thank you thank you

[@gambler.6925]

We're now singing One day by Lovejoy! Lmao Update: We're making the Live Chat a cult and we're determined to summon Wilbur Soot Update: Guys please- all i wanna do is sing Revived Update: 6 MINUTES POGG Update: YOOO ITS STARTING! Update: Ill get back at you after the song. Its really good :]

[@kathefirst]

so this is what i missed

[@mrheat8376]

Pog

[@alliumboo7003]

We are now playing kahoot so POG

[@spiritaurideus]

Try @ then wilburs name on KZbin that is the only way I know how to summon Wilbur

[@jazzymcfrazzle529]

THE GENUINELY SUMMONED ME LIKE THEY WERE TRYING BECAUSE THEY KNEW ME FROM THE WRITE IT DOWN AND THEN I CAMEEEE HFLADSIUS AND IN THE WRITE IT DOWN WE SUMMONED MUMZA AAAAAAAA

[@violetflame6084]

confession. i don't even know what's Dream SMP is. KZbin recommended me about her songs and now i'm addicted to these songs of hers

[@The_Spirit405]

It’s basically a Minecraft scripted Roleplay about different Nations fighting for independence, while the mastermind attempts to keep full control of it all.

[@DimentioFan1]

@@The_Spirit405 Yeah, but said mastermind keeps blowing himself up and breaking his mic, and the main character keeps getting interrupted by his mother. Oh, and people predict the future by accident, but we don't talk about that.

[@Reevazard]

Seven hours to go and the chat is singing "Your new boyfriend". I now know the true meaning of insanity

[@jesterrhq1896]

𝒀𝒖𝒉. 𝑾𝒆 𝒘𝒆𝒓𝒆 𝒑𝒐𝒑𝒑𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒐𝒇𝒇

[@vanillarosekitchen]

The chat is awsome. We’re singing My L’manburg and giving endless amounts of o7

[@hallooitshalo4479]

The “it hurts and hurts and it’s getting worse” and “why why did you lie why did your words amount to nothing” Is really just my pain about this whole thing with Wilbur (I knows it all a rp) Edit: this the most likes I’ve ever gotten tysm

[@nyllyte]

"Why are you crying, its just minecraft." "You wouldn't understand."

[@miasii]

god i have been searching for someone who understands yes I know it's all an rp but wilbur makes it hit so much harder and with the recent thing with ghostbur i just cannot-

[@hallooitshalo4479]

@@miasii yes he’s such a good actor along with almost everyone on the sever

[@miasii]

@@hallooitshalo4479 I know and everyone's talking about how ghostbur really made you believe he didn't want to die, and he did, but nobody's talking about how sam REALLY MAKES YOU HATE HIM WITH EVERY CELL IN YOUR BODY and that takes skill

[@hallooitshalo4479]

@@miasii I don’t get why people blame just one person about Wilburs revival it’s all there fault

[@meganbarnes5211]

Derivakat and Sadist live through the smp and become the ones who write the history books and everything about the DSMP world and become the ones who make the myths and such

[@jamieishere216]

i like that he asks “did you even care?” because he realizes phil didn’t really care about him, friend, or l’manberg

[@aeonblade64]

To be fair Phil did care about ghostbur. However he valued taking revenge on l'manburg more than keeping ghostbur happy.

[@wawaristi]

@@aeonblade64 eh, not rly. C!Phil himself said that he never rly considered ghostbur as his son. He _tolerated_ ghotsbur, but didnt truly care about him.

[@aeonblade64]

@Aniqa Salwa Risti oh I guess I missed that stream. My point still stands that Phil had no reason to care about l'manburg though.

[@aubarlowe]

@@wawaristi WHAT!?!? When????

[@emijunkai]

@@aubarlowe A while. C!Phil said that speaking to Ghostbur was more like speaking to a doll. Edit: Here's the clip. kzbin.info/www/bejne/nGLQknp3dq2XibM

[@Dewdear]

The fact that chat is giving each other blue is so wholesome Edit: I hant gotten this many likes on a comment yet

[@laurachristine3221]

Here friend, have some blue! I can give you some by turning that thumbs up blue! Sadly can’t get the thumbs down blue, though....

[@nothingisdue]

here have another thumbs up

[@margoshatoliashvili852]

FOCK ITS THE SCENE THAT BROKE MY HEART MADE IN A SONG NONONONONO I WASNT EMOTIONALY READY WAIT-

[@FidemObduro]

The lightning striking on beat is such a cool detail.

[@ohnod3107]

When you think about it, it could be Ghostbur talking about Tommy: “Why? Why did you lie? Why did you words amount to nothing?”, a reference to the broken promise that Tommy made to Ghostbur saying that everything would be ok when he took him to the prison. “Cut down by your blade”, because he revealed his axe and wanted to kill dream so bad and “couldn’t leave it be”. “Can’t stand the pain” Tommy has such an intense fear of death that he will do anything to be safe. “Look at what you’ve done, is this what you call glory. Do you still believe you’re the hero of your story?” Look at what you’ve done, you brought back Wilbur and now I’m gone, is killing Dream what you call glory? You killed me and tried to kill Dream, you knew it was dangerous and that everyone else told you not to. I didn’t know better to tell you not to kill him and you took advantage of my naivety, look in the mirror, can you even call yourself a hero? “you act like a judge, enforcing your personal grudge. Am I to pay for this war you raised?” You tried to kill Dream for your own selfish reason, why did I have to pay for what you did. “Do you still believe this is the justice you sought after?” Is this really what you want? (btw I know it’s about Philza but when I first heard it I thought it was about Tommy and also realised that the lyrics fit for him as well)

[@wickedwoodfairy]

I think parts of this song could work with Ghostbur singing them to Tommy, Phil, and Wilbur.

[@arson_atlas]

all the separate parts could be sang to alot of the members for example: "cut down by your blade" could be said to tommy for your reason, phil as a flashback to phil killing wilbur, even techno as he helped blow up l'manburg the final time

[@jackob4271]

The blade one is about techno i think

[@bestbuddy9489]

I thought it was about Wilbur honestly, cause of some of the lyrics: "Now you've played your part, in this forever unfinished symphony" "Why did you lie?" "Why did it fall?" "Why did your words amount to nothing? "Look at what you've done, you've brought upon disaster" "Do you still believe your the hero of your story?" "Is this what you sought after?" "Is this your happy ending?" "Look around and see, this is history repeating" "Do you even care, you've left things beyond repair?" "It was by your hand, you've turned a masterpiece into a nightmare" "Am I to pay? For this war you've raised?" I could explain my perspective if ya want--

[@TheBreadedPigeon]

I was looking for this comment but now Im sad

[@freezingsn0w_]

Rest in peace Ghostbur, you were a tragic character

[@wolfy.makes.art._]

THAT WAS AMAZING POG. It really showed Ghostbur's feelings about Phil blowing up L'manburg, o7