Why horn sounds of electric locomotive are different from horn sound of diesel locomotive?

[@rahuldeshpande4449]

Diesel locomotive horn are louder than electric locomotives.

[@MOHITJADHAV-ot9vu]

WDP4 HORN IS BEST HORN

[@ashutiwari9564]

And their engine sound is also louder.😁

[@rksmusi1991]

To dono me difference kyon rakha gaya h same mechanism kyon nhi use karte

[@ankitdas7742]

Obviously

[@comrade_marshal]

And the diesel locos sound cooler as well

[@dharmrajmaurya5011]

आपको ये भी बताना चाहिए था कि दोनों के हार्न में ये अंतर क्यो रक्खा जाता है। यदि एक ही टाइप का हॉर्न हो तो क्या प्रोब्लेम होगी। धन्यवाद

[@vikastiwari348]

मेरा भी same question है

[@rituparnsingh5093]

पहला कि दूर से सुन कर पहचाना जा सके कि कौन सा लोकोमोटिव है, दूसरा कि दोनों का निर्माण अलग अलग इंजीनियर्स द्वारा किया जाता है.....तीसरा कि डीजल इंजन की खुद की आवाज बहुत होती है, तो इलेक्ट्रिक लोको की तरह हॉर्न होने से इंजन की आवाज में हॉर्न की आवाज दब जाएगी....और ऐसे ही बहुत से कारण हो सकते हैं

[@ashutiwari9564]

@@rituparnsingh5093 sahi kaha

[@longhornfinch]

it is also because of specifications. Europe specifies to have two-tone (high and low) horns so that a wider spectrum of people can hear it. While America specifies a louder horn. Our electric locos(wap5 and 7) follow the European style while diesel follows the American style of horns.

[@Travelwithfz]

[@prashantmishra9985]

Best comment here. Underrated. Thanks bro.

[@rahultechnodevices9646]

बहुत सुंदर समझाया अमित जी।।

[@utkarshbhargava3877]

I always thought this question ,thanks

[@K4Khabar]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/anyYip-tq7F-b9E

[@K4Khabar]

Support us and share

[@ashutiwari9564]

Me too

[@9904288542]

Nice Information Sir... Maine Bhi Isi Topic Pe Ek Barr Apko Sawal Puchha Tha Aur Aaj aapne Video Bana Diya. Thank You...

[@Soulspaceofficial]

I appreciate your effort but the explanation was not that much clear and understandable. Please script your words before making the video which will help you to explain in a better way. I write about Indian Railways on Quora and I have over 10 million views. No hate for you, loved the information you provide but please script your video before you make it.

[@rahulsoni3980]

I agree with you prashant bhai, the explanatn was not clear enough. But he always puts effort for his videos. Coming to the point its not about stored air or something, both electric and diesel have different horns, they always sound different. Even if you see, wdm and wdp, both series are diesel, but their horns are again different. If you see MEMU, they also got different horn.

[@Soulspaceofficial]

@@rahulsoni3980 Thank you for sharing your views. I also think that ALCO locos sounds louder because their engine sound is loud and its horn has to overcome the engine sound.

[@Kai33728]

I love Alco locomotive sound because alco locomotive sound is beast sound of IR I love to hear the sound of Alco locomotive sound is so sweet and loud I like it

[@Kai33728]

@The Irshad Khan emd ka to etna ata pata to nahi aab me eak example deta hu tum konsha mahabharat pasand karte ho br chopra ya starplus ka batao phir me agya ka bataunga

[@Kai33728]

@The Irshad Khan acha tab tum yaha batao ki tumha bro chopra ka dekhta hi to tumha kutch pasand aata ha

[@Kai33728]

@The Irshad Khan in case me bhi esh sae releted example dea raha hu me ne first locomotive alco dekha tha or first horn bhi alco ka suna tha or first traveling train me bhi mera alco hi dekha tha eshliya me alco ka fan hu

[@Kai33728]

@TIGER々 ClAW sabki apni pasand hoti ha ok

[@Kai33728]

@TIGER々 ClAW np

[@jeetbandhopadhyaya8265]

I really like your videos regarding Indian Railways... Proud of u.....

[@utkarshshukla6246]

Tq sir nice explained Aaj sara doubt clear ho gya hai Jai Hind

[@s.kirtivasen5752]

Thank you scientist Amit ji. 😊😃😆

[@nmggamerz6887]

धन्यवाद हमारे लिए इतनी अच्छी वीडियो बनाने के लिए इतनी रात तक जाग कर दिल से धन्यवाद

[@waqar_ahmed3168]

Sir aapka Bohut Bohut shukriya ye video banane ke liye aapne meri comment finally read kar hi li thanks sir god bless you 😇 Main aapki video 6 months ke baad dekh raha hun 😅 q ke main dusri I'd use kar raha tha abhi ye I'd open kiya toh ye video aagayi but main late ho gaya 😅

[@piku1431]

That's why I like Electric locomotive 📯 horn

[@tinoysantra1556]

Happy Independence day...mai aapki saari videos bohot ach6e se dekhta hu kyuki mujhe railway mai kaafi interest h

[@krishanubiswas2485]

Happy independence day amit bhai 🇮🇳🇮🇳❤❤

[@Vaazhgabaratham]

Bhahuth achcha explain, thanks Amit ji 👍

[@AYYANAK18]

You are the best teacher of RAIL FANS 😁

[@NadeemAhmad-ko5ow]

कहिया एक मिलियन होई भाई? जल्दी हो जाओ भाई एक मिलियन।

[@rameshbhorkar9261]

Hello sir I am Uday and I am 15 years old I want to became a loco piolet that's why I saw your vedios this is truly good and fully with knowledge

[@shibooster]

You have explained in best possible way 👍Thank you!!

[@railloversayan.1662]

Very Good Analysis for This Topic Ki Amit Sir. ✌👌

[@rajverma9473]

I always thought this question Thanks sir Or happy independence day 🎉🇮🇳 Video achha hai ❤️❤️

[@ranjitsingh4527]

Bahut suljhee hui video hai, Dhanywad

[@anirudhyabatabyal9949]

Very nice information 👍👌

[@rajeshkumarsharma8100]

You are always outstanding sir 💯

[@beeteinlamhein9201]

Nice information bhaiya👍👍👍

[@karan_rajput457]

sir literally i wanna say you thnx coz the knowledge you give

[@bablupaswan23]

Happy independence day 🇮🇳..... Amit ji bhot ach info..... Form saudi arabia

[@chandanbish4805]

Bhi superb thanks for your kind videos

[@waseemrizvi6665]

Sar you are God of railway God bless you 🙏🙏❣️❣️

[@Amrit_chourasiya]

Visit amrit railways

[@siwan4862]

Electric loco .. never replace disel locomotive feelings, engine sound , and horns!

[@anilkumarmunshi4174]

Nice . Technically clear description . Explained well . It is a topic concerned with Acoustic Physics . Thanks .

[@sridharraghavan3106]

Very nicely explained. 👏👏👍👍

[@wiplashw642]

Happy independence day sir ji. Your videos are ready fun and informative

[@im._.AjayKumar]

I love electric locomotive honking..., ❤❤❤❤😍😍😍😍

[@Amrit_chourasiya]

Visit amrit railways

[@RameshKSingh-gp2mx]

@@Amrit_chourasiya ok

[@RameshKSingh-gp2mx]

@@Amrit_chourasiya good channel subbed

[@piyushtamhankar8244]

👏👏👏👌👌👌❤️❤️❤️😁😁😁 Superb Amit Bhai mujhe bhi yehi question Tha Jo Maine comment kiya Tha aapke channel per Jo finali aaj aa gaya....🙏🙏🙏 Thanks for making video on this topic & Happy indipandance day

[@usmansayyad4641]

सर हम आपके सभी व्हिडियो देखते हैं ओर आपके बडे फॅन हैं,कभी पेट्रोल लोकोमोटिव बना हैं क्या ये बतायिये ❤️❤️

[@shrishsingh9791]

Your information is out of the world, Great Job by why they change the horn system when they work the same way?

[@indianR8418]

Nice sir Happy independence day 🇮🇳

[@RFAbhinavSain]

Me bhi ye Janna chahta tha😍 Thank you Amit bhai :-)

[@rahulsreenivasan5494]

Usefull information for loco lover, good Amit

[@dhananjaybhide7006]

Good comprehensive explanation

[@goyaldeekshant]

Complex mechanism, but easily explained.

[@vjitesh13]

Am i the only one who loves diesel locomotive honk 🤔🤔

[@deepakrajawat9335]

Happy Independence day Amit sir.again I am first viewer

[@Amrit_chourasiya]

Visit amrit railways

[@mr.manoharshirude797]

Thanks for the best information sir 👍👍

[@Prakashkumar-vd8hh]

Hamesa ki tarah bahut badhiya banaye hai

[@aniketbhole2269]

Aapne information to achhi dedi. Ekdam sahi. Lekin us frequency me avaj me fark kyu hota hai?

[@dibyanshuprasad]

Very nice info ♥️♥️ Keep it up ✌️✌️

[@shubhamg_3545]

Once again great information Thanks sirji

[@abhijitmajumder4023]

Sir why both mechanism of are different..? Why not maintain same horn system

[@rajd33p42]

Exactly

[@rfpramitgamer9819]

@@rajd33p42 both engines has its own specialities

[@rajd33p42]

@@rfpramitgamer9819 Ooh Ok...

[@guruprasad2409]

Super explanation Sir thank you

[@jayantamanna7496]

Thank you sir iss informative video k liye..

[@souvikmukherjee617]

You are giving new informations everyday.. thank you so much.. for this information... expecting more interesting informations..

[@jaibharatjaimaharashtra3516]

nice video bhai 👍👍👍👌👌👌👌👌👌👌 👌 👌

[@arunsadhukhan4661]

Awesome explanation ❤️

[@reeganronald]

Nice explanation sir❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@manoharprasad1353]

Super video 👍👍👍

[@rajd33p42]

Thanks a lot I always had this question from my child hood....🤯🤯🤯🤯 But still I have a question why don't they put the diesel locomotive horn mechanism in electric 1.... As the Diesel horn is more powerful...

[@pnv1974]

Even the platform vibrates when diesel locomotive honk . Same happened with me I was sitting on the platform chair and suddenly Mangala express wdm 3d honked , I was so afraid that my heart started beating

[@rajd33p42]

@@pnv1974 OMG!!!

[@pappunahak7867]

First views like and comment and happy independence Day

[@techwyn]

Aaj bhi bhai 15 august hai 2023 ❤

[@SurajSingh-nx1th]

I love you sir....Nice your video..sir

[@agasheparag8382]

Very nice information. Earlier I also asked same question to you. After knowing this information, one more quotation raised. Why this difference. Dono locomotive mein ek jisa horn bhi laga sakte hai. Any reason behind this philosophy?

[@VishalRawat]

sir g pamban bridge accident pr video kb ayegi plzz sir

[@md.yasirarafatansari2762]

Nice Information Sir. 🇮🇳🚉

[@Rail_Fan_Ritik_Basoda]

Thanks for this knowledge

[@sayanchakraborty9975]

My favourite electric locomotives is wap 7,wag 9h,wag 9hh,wag 11,wag 12 b & diesel locomotive is wdm 3A& 3D, wdp 4d,wdg 4d, wdg 4g. Jay Hind Amit sir.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@sunirbanbiswas6038]

Diesel locomotive sounds heaver than electric locomotive

[@pappu0024]

Badiya... Sab thik hai lekin aapne Diesel loco ke bare me jo Electromagnetic valve ya solenoid valve ki baat ki wo kuch confusing lag raha hai kyuki Electromagnetism ke liye current ki jarurat hoti hai jabki yaha pura mechanism Air Pressure ka hai...

[@jayantchatterjee6521]

#knowledgeknorr अमित जी नमस्कार, आप जबलपुर गोंदिया ब्रोडगेज के बारे मे वीडियो बनाये

[@aradhyadixit6754]

Most awaited question for me🤗

[@dhanaraj8993]

Sir mera ek questions he ki Rajasthan ka samdri jalor bhinmal se lambi duri ki train jaise ki Hyderabad channel tiruchirapalli coimbatore Mangalore Kerala ke liye Sidhi train kyon nahin hai??????????

[@thakorvijay5312]

Wdg6g locomotiv jyada takatver he ya wag12 ?

[@samarthsax]

Very well explained. Could have been a little more educating, if you would have added a sound sample from both.

[@arbaazmevkhan7296]

Nice job sir aapka sumriya

[@Sameerbhagat7]

Thanks for this 👍

[@sekharmadhavdas1359]

Very nicely explained

[@MOHITJADHAV-ot9vu]

I LOVE EMD LOCOMOTIVE SOUNDS

[@jayprakashshah7326]

Amit Bhaiya g Mera ek question k Kya look motives me airplane jaisa autopilot hota. please let me know if you agree. Mujhe yakin h ki aap jaroor ek video is topic pr banayenge. Thank you.

[@akvinodin]

Thanks for the easy explanation, wondering how Steam engine horn works

[@ashishsanavlog2480]

Bro keya northeast mey electrified Hoga keya ismey eek Vedio banau I never miss ur vedio

[@pankajvishwakarma2620]

Happy independence day amit ji aur dosto🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@debasismandal8754]

Very nice 👌👌👌👌

[@mr.dhruvyadav8839]

First view jai hind 😍🇮🇳

[@aakashjadham7271]

Thanks For This Video

[@karunratanyadav8053]

Good video bro. Thanks

[@PardeepKumar-tx8nz]

Hlo sir I have a Question Sir jsa dono pantograph nicha ho tho cabin ma electric kha sa agi . Or electric locomotive ma battery bhi hoti ha ..... Plz reply me 🙏🙏🙏

[@satishgupta8025]

जानकारी अच्छी रही.

[@airtelbroadband8419]

Hello Amit ji, I Amit from delhi, maine aapse kafi baar question commments mein poochhe but aaj tak uska koi reply ya video abhi tak nhi banaya aape, aaj last question aapse krne ja rha hu, agar iska bhi reply ya is question pe video nhi bani to kabhi koi question nhi poochhunga aapse, aaj ka mera question yeh hai ki maan lijiye agar koi freight locomotive chahe wag5 ho wag 7 ho ya wag 9 ho, agar kabhi woh locomotive apni journey ke dauran fail ho jata hai and near by station pe us locomotive k sath lage load ko pull karne k liye same locomotive availabke nhi hai, to kya us condition mein us load ko pull krne k liye passenger locomotive ka use kiya ja sakta hai, chahe usko pull karne k liye 2 ya usse zyada passenger loco motive hi kyo na lagana pade, is it possible or not. Pls ans my question by makin video on it. I hope this time u will not disappoint me. Thank u and love u amit ji for uploading such informative videos abt indian railways on youtube.

[@akshith4901]

Last one example is better for understand😁

[@tridibsarkar2202]

Love your videos. I want to know that "kisan special train" aur parcel van wali train jo hain kya wo dfc per chalayi jayega ya phir normal tracks per jayega. Please is par ek video banana. Please it is my humble request to you.

[@swapnomayrsaha2359]

Good explanation.

[@vipulbhardwaj5884]

Diesel loco honking is lit 🔥

[@MOHITJADHAV-ot9vu]

WDP4 HORN IS BEST HORN

[@monalisamaji7678]

Electric locomotive has most beautiful horn and I like electric locomotive horn

[@pradip9365]

डिजल लोकोमोटिव्ह का साऊंड अच्छा लागता है

[@rohitlohar]

It was my question commented many times.

[@rahuldeshpande4449]

Nice video. But what's the reason behind the difference in horn design in diesel and electric locomotives?

[@photoaddicts0017]

I love wdm3a diesel locomotive horn ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@Kai33728]

Me also

[@tarajyotish121]

Sir kya es saal trains chalege ya nhi plz reply sir