Why India needs a caste census: Let me Explain | Reservation | Siddaramaiah

After nine long years, the Karnataka government has finally, officially, got its hands on the caste survey report. But the findings are still under wraps, with the Siddaramaiah government still unwilling to share them with the public. The leaks of the survey that TNM has accessed shows that it can change the political landscape of Karnataka. In this week’s Let Me Explain, Pooja Prasanna tells you what the Karnataka government’s survey found and why consecutive government’s did not publish the report. We also address the big question: Why does India need a caste census and the politics behind it. Because the caste data on which schemes are being designed currently is over 90 years old.
www.thenewsminute.com/karnata...
www.thenewsminute.com/news/wh...
#CasteCensus #Siddaramaiah #Karnataka #TheNewsMinute #LetMeExplain #PoojaPrasanna
#LokSabhaElections2024 | You choose who forms the government. You also choose who you trust to help you make an informed decision. Help us empower you.
Pick a project you want and power @newslaundry and @thenewsminute's election coverage.
www.newslaundry.com/2024-elec...
Support our work. Become a TNM Member: www.thenewsminute.com/subscri...

[@gop1962]

Then why we are working for casteless society.

[@lalithadoraisamy4497]

It's an election gimmick.What were they doing when they were in power. They don't want obc PM they want pseudo Christian Brahmin PM😂

[@philipdsa7907]

Good point, division of votes in the name of caste, creed and religion.

[@Xeta007]

Bcz this are not journalists This are pure dalal😂😂😂

[@saurabhmahajan4459]

Because casteism exists and giving reservation is one of the step towards ensuring to make up for centuries of oppression against the backward caste people and the invisible social hurdles they still face to this date.

[@gop1962]

@@saurabhmahajan4459 Is it works?Big No.More and more castes are emerging to get reservation. If they wanted to eradicate caste inter case marriage is encouraged.

[@vikram1262]

How wil caste census identify previlige when economic aspect is not covered in the census

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@doncorleone3901]

It is actually titled economic, social development survey so it includes everything

[@kumarsaurabhsingh1485]

The survey will conclude not only the caste but the other data also. Education, Economic Situation, and many more. Health conditions.

[@vikram1262]

@@kumarsaurabhsingh1485 yeah. Right and when a surveyor comes to your door you will tell them the money you make every month! What a joke

[@cinefile0075]

​@@vikram1262so you are saying all the government data about middle class and upper class and below poverty line people are wrong?? What data would you believe then ??

[@johnjohm2438]

Cabinet 100 percentage only upper caste Supreme court 70 percentage told by congress as per data Godi media 90 percentage we knew it already How social justice will prevail

[@himanshutyagi3050]

Arjun ram meghwal is dalit and law minister of union of india you fool

[@dhrubajyotidebnath6192]

up , bihar rule by backward cast for more than 35 years still most backward ???

[@johnjohm2438]

@@dhrubajyotidebnath6192 yes only when obc sc st most deprived people develop whole state develop Womens education also important If hindi belt educated well Then bjp cannot divide people by religion They cannot do whatever wrong and just doing photo video in temple and get votes So women ,sc,st and obc education development is very important

[@indieboy1033]

@@johnjohm2438 Idiot.The caste of the ruler is not important. But the skill is. Ambedkar could come up in pre-reservation times. So, start working and proving now.

[@RamSingh-mk4gs]

​@@johnjohm2438where is right to equality basic structure of gov

[@mohammedanakorath8833]

Cast census is very much essential not only for social justice in govt.benifit and job reservation but also political justice and representation.

[@vijaychandra91]

Yes very much essential for breaking hindhus into castes before elections in Karnataka

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@Xeta007]

Make cast census on mullas they are mostly punctureer😂😂😂😂

[@yogindrajs5509]

In muslims also caste senses is very much essential

[@carlbuzz9087]

Caste is a super dose for Dravidian & leftist-marxist parties 🥳 , otherwise there is no proper scope in Politics. When all Hindus are divided name of caste than dmk, congress & leftists parties always survive

[@manisherande4568]

no it is not about hindus.. its giving obc reservation to muslims ... they will get 20 % percent reservation

[@omkarbiradar3383]

I am general category farmer,my age 42years, no benefit any single government schme in last 42years🤔🤔🙏

[@onlinme7884]

In India? Any schemes related to Farmers in India doesn't follow reservation.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@pearlr4805]

Farm subsidies ???? Farm subsidies are not based on caste. EWS reservation is for general category. Are you in India?

[@onlinme7884]

@@Artrader_em8ko nonsense.

[@tindrums]

General Category need to emigrate. They are not wanted in India. Think of you children.

[@cleonii]

does this census also have the split between pasmandas, ashrafs and others?

[@CaptainKGF1]

In 2024 , caste is regression concept and fading away in urban or semi urban zone.. Rural will go in next 10 years 😂😂😂😂😂

[@RakshithVenkataramani]

Make economic survey instead. Give reservation to poor people

[@youdontknow6718]

it is a socio-economic survey, so it has economic component and it will be used for future policy making

[@aadhvikkhanna]

27% are the real sufferer...

[@RakshithVenkataramani]

@@aadhvikkhanna then why we need caste in it ? There are poor people in brahmins as well and rich dalits. I know the percentage is very low but isn't it better to eliminate even the low percentage ?

[@rajashashankgutta4334]

​@@RakshithVenkataramani simple reason: our society and economic power is distributed among caste lines.

[@Pjrdjf]

Census is important. Without it we cannot make better policies and have a better country. I just hope that any reservation that comes out of it also leaves enough space for open category which is also open to the backward castes. Merit should also be considered for positions.

[@indieboy1033]

Do census, not just of caste. Parents occupation, childhood area, etc. This should be done in mega census which is supposed to happen every 10 yrs.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@aastha3428]

"Merit should also be considered." Don't you think merit should be the only thing to be considered for filling up seats .We don't want idiots just for the sake of representation. Instead of reservation, each and every individual should be provided with adequate opportunities. If govt will provide good education to all free of cost ,I don't see how there will be any need for reservation at all. But no government has shown their willingness to do the same because they very well know that once our countrymen learn to think for themselves ,they won't fall into their schemes of dividing the country on the lines of caste or religion.

[@williamliamsmith4923]

India needs to ban cast from official business and treat everyone equally except for cases of cast based discrimination practiced by people in public life. (Although in their private life people may do anything.)

[@mioVanz]

Not gonna happen

[@shabirmd]

To decide whether to remove cast census or alter and add more can be decided only after senses.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@biswadeepkundu4237]

I support this Cast census activity as it's helpful tools to develop our human resource.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@biswadeepkundu4237]

@@Artrader_em8ko is it equal against my comments?

[@primaryan0]

How to end caste system ??? By having caste census. By declaring your cast. By asking caste on the mic. By attacking one caste for historical data. By giving reservation according to caste, not by economic situation though. Isn't it ironical ?

[@user-od9vc4lr5k]

This channel was against caste system. I used to love this channel for its anti "caste discrimination" and progressive content. But now this very channel is supporting caste system and it is supporting reservation?? Common guys ! ..mature up please for gods sake.

[@youdontknow6718]

need of the hour, whoever in govt should do census and give data

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@youdontknow6718]

caste cvertificate is already there everywhere, India will never be casteless. so it is better if everyone gets represented and uplifted with their certificates atleast. where were you when people are divided on the basis of religion.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

@@youdontknow6718 having a caste less society doesn’t mean people don’t have caste identity. It means there is no caste hierarchy. All caste are treated equally. It already happens in cities. Being an OBC, I didn’t know which category my caste belonged until recently. Only when I heard of caste census, I was curious to find out. Somehow it was never a concern or conversation in school, college or anywhere else even though I grew up in a tier 2 city.

[@youdontknow6718]

@@Artrader_em8ko just bcz u didnt encounter caste in school and college doesn't mean it doesn't exist. I had many experiences of it, i am too of OBC category, being topper many of my professors though i am a brahmin or savarna, when i said i am obc i saw disappointment in their faces, it happened with friends too. They always want some of their kind to be with them and work with them. That has very badly skewed representation from obc, sc, st in those spaces. Just think of your clg or university and see what percent of employs r from these categories. be it private or govt same everywhere, and in nominated or positions selected by interview this is even more serious. So this survey is very imp to know what is status of people, what welfare and reservation done to bring them up. if they are actually reaching required people of usurped in middle by other. If u r obc check representation of ur community in govt, top universities, mncs, bureaucracy and see for yourself

[@Aham.Bramhasmi]

I am from karnataka, and the whole caste census is a sham. No one heard of any govt official coming with a set of questions to individual homes. Almost as if it didn't happen.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@Aham.Bramhasmi]

@@Artrader_em8ko exactly. Casteless society is the aim of our constitution. Central govt should sieze this oppurtunity and name economic census.

[@jamilakoshy3324]

Thanks!

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@tindrums]

Equality of opportunities not equality of outcome

[@aruna2034]

Loved it like always ❤...Ur the best Pooja

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@kamalvaghela8282]

Very Important topic chosen by The News Minute.. I appreciate this kind of Journalism..

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@divided_by_0]

Would like to know what exactly is the difference between a regular census and caste census is... Can you make a video about that

[@vikramad36]

I want to contribute to the joint fund but the website asks me to register. I just want to make a donation.

[@thenewsminute]

Do try this link- www.thenewsminute.com/subscription

[@chandu25abc20]

I think caste census should be taken but should not be given any weitage for any govt programmes/jobs except financial status as any such weitage is only promoting caste segrgation in the society.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@poojan423]

Why not just ban caste? This caste thing is actually making India backward. But opposition just wants caste politics and not progress. Caste reservation should be banned and reservation should only be on financial background

[@shashijain5084]

Great show 👍👍 !!!! Have made it a point to watch & listen every Friday !!!!

[@thenewsminute]

Awesome, thank you!

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@Deepankar.ahlawat]

Subscribed!!

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@Deepankar.ahlawat]

​@@Artrader_em8ko Reservations are not just for economic factor but also social factor. For example, If someone cleans the sewers, no matter how much money he has, can he proudly say that he cleans gutters and sewers? Also do you think his children can get same social status as someone like a doctor's child? Will you or anyone from let's say Brahmans, will drink water or eat food given from him? And not every Dalit is a sewer cleaner, but every sewer cleaner is a dalit. Do not believe everything you read or see on social media, coz there are 150 crores indians and out of those, there are so many who do not get education, healthcare, and opportunities based on their social status and not the economic status. In UP, there are many instances where children of 5-10 years old in school are bullied coz of their caste, do you think they don't have money, they do, and that is why they are studying in a private school, still the social factor will always matter. Trust me, India is bigger than we all can even imagine.

[@vijayakumartc4902]

Yes; it is the need of the hour.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society

[@ajkhandms8919]

Very informative Keep it up

[@bhuvanajayaramu4299]

Informative

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@user-ee9eo3ty7f]

Pooja Narration Content All beautiful.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@prakashponnuchamy7030]

As long as reservation is based on caste we need a caste census..

[@thebaclub5255]

But caste census also encourages the vote bank politics In india and it also focuses on the development of a particular caste or community when it comes to power

[@padmaravi341]

High time shame on Indian politicians and beneficiary on caste basis. Don't require religion and caste based census. We don't want politicians to devide and rule like Britishers. We need I frasteucture and Development talk about them.

[@adithya390]

How Andhra Pradesh could not have a obc chief minister until now can u do a video in this aspect

[@ukuk179]

Quoted SEBI companies legally should publish OBC staff data. It should be included in co's act & a SEBI requirement

[@user-lu7uc4tz7k]

What is your caste? what is the percentages of dalit people in your chanel? will you hand over your position to other dalits?

[@artofwastemanagement4484]

Necessary subject. Thank you.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@ajeetalbert91]

Caste census must be targetting for 'Equality of opportunity' rather than 'Equality of outcome'.

[@user-ld7ug2fc8n]

The effective fruits of the country' s development should be scared by everyone , both High & Low castes, everyone should live in Harmony , everyone and everyone should feel comfortable being Indians , .... Help the poor fellow Indians

[@indieboy1033]

Caste census, victim card are pushed by the career activists. As long as we keep giving them incentives, they will keep finding social justice cause. As long as they are there, there will be no harmony. It is against the relevance and interests of caste activists.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society

[@Azee2]

Great presentation

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@user-cn2lk7vy5s]

Economic status itself enough, if really want to improvement in society. Birth and death certification itself gives number of people needed education and subsequently job or self employment opportunities needed for society. First provide education and skills then earning possibilities to find out even after having these facilities why any specific community is not improving themselves. Because so far, so many got all reservations and schemes and need to analyze status of improvement of those sections

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society

[@bharathbharath1110]

caste census is much needed my vote will for that party which promises caste census

[@philipdsa7907]

Caste census is a discrimination of citizens.reservations should be on the basis of eligible candidate for jobs as well as schemes and not only on the basis of caste as it hampers the growth of the country.

[@rajendrabareto8065]

Caste is not only numbers but numbers which make significant numbers. Big numbers are only for low income groups but when it goes to higher it is the income also. Don’t is complicated.

[@ukuk179]

Brilliant analysis

[@ananthan8951]

Breaking India Channel agenda.

[@murkri8723]

How long are we Hindus going to be fixated on caste? Focus assistance on economic status. PLEASE STOP THIS DIVISION.

[@yogeshpattewar4419]

Just divide hindus and rule -pseudohindus and commies Do also tax wise cast census

[@Chrisbbilger-yp4fz]

I like this news channel. I subscribe your channel. ♥️🇮🇳

[@abdulrahoof8785]

How many of here, who say that there is no caste discrimination will marry from the caste which is defined as lower? This caste system is not only prevailing in hindu religion. It's also part of up muslims. So caste discriminates. Am from an iim student and i have seen that very much prevailing between these highly educated people. Some of many are reported in media. It's not money that discriminates but it's lile racism. What's wrong with the survey, let's see hownisnthe representation of different section. So those who offend it are very well aware of it.

[@kcm4554]

Caste census is need of time for overall development of country & country's people.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@kcm4554]

@@Artrader_em8ko Both social economics & social inequalities discrimination basic.

[@subhrajitgupta5535]

Cast census is casteism/cast discrimination!

[@thrillshanks]

Pathetic logic. After 76 years of Independence, we want to still divide the country on the basis of caste, religion and what not? When will we start living as human beings?

[@LaPlaya-rw1cp]

We don't want the country to be divided that's why Caste census is a necessity

[@Chrisbbilger-yp4fz]

When you Stop asking someone, what is your caste?

[@rajashashankgutta4334]

​@@LaPlaya-rw1cpyour caste census will divide India.

[@rajashashankgutta4334]

​@@Chrisbbilger-yp4fzokay some folks are casteist so let's give government permission to collect caste data?

[@rohithk3976]

ದರಿದ್ರ ನ್ಯೂಸ್ ಚಾನೆಲ್ ಗಳ ಹಂಗಿನಿಂದ ಬಚಾವು ಮಾಡಿದ/ ಮಾಡುತ್ತಿರುವ ನಿಮ್ಮಂಥ ನ್ಯೂಸ್ ಪೋರ್ಟಲ್ ಗಳಿಗೆ ಧನ್ಯವಾದಗಳು.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society!

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Google’ Indian media bias chart’ to see which media is biased to which ideology n which media is neutral. Can do the same to find International media bias chart!

[@Tamilarivu782]

Caste based survey Is must.....then only we know which part of society looted india and the specific community in ruling after independence

[@crazy_boom1141]

Caste census even if done should be done for demographic awareness not for providing reservation based on caste assuming that general caste always born privileged

[@ambarishcr5768]

social media is the new 4th pillar of democracy

[@aastha3428]

True, TV journalism has already lost its legitimacy .However , social media isn't free from the agents of these political parties either.

[@ukuk179]

Unclear from video whether citizens wants to know the data To do a census such as this must be by an ACT and the ACT must specify publication of data. State govt onlidge to publish

[@mohan1997]

Upper Cast Minorites have enjoyed using the OBC majority as slaves for thousands of years and do not want to let go of this privilege. Hence do not like to share/conduct cast census

[@saureld2229]

First of all the way in which this "census" was conducted is itself dubious, they claim to have gone to every house but no one heard of them, there are allegations that this was rushed and data created in office due to political pressure, just looking at the number of certain groups that show decline from 2011 census when actual data shows an increase shows how dubious this survey is, secondly, caste is not the end all be all, there needs to be economic survey and only based on economic condition should there be things like reservation etc, Blanket reservations for people who don't need it just because they are form some caste needs to end.

[@VikramKumar-oy8gq]

Caste census is only needed for those who want to divide people or to claim as minorities.

[@Artrader_em8ko]

Very essential for making caste system more rigid. People will need caste certificates everywhere for schools, colleges, jobs etc etc. can’t make out if these blinded lefties are so vile that they would risk the social fabric of the society to win an election or are they really dumb to believe anything that is told to them! Just give further reservations purely based on economic indicators irrespective of caste or religion! That is how you build a fair, castless n secular society

[@user-lp9eg9pp8o]

Please do research on casteless India and organise their program.

[@mioVanz]

Caste use not going away from India.... It will pull india from development

[@hithkarikatte3577]

There's nothing wrong in doing caste census.

[@Kan467g]

Remove reservations.

[@aadhvikkhanna]

I think you are not getting benefits out of reservation. Even Forward caste also need reservation depend upon economical conditions. They are getting poor and poorest but not by rituals. Big play by Govt. People to understand those things.

[@Chrisbbilger-yp4fz]

Remove Caste system.

[@abhijitdesai187]

Looks like, you are biased against BJP! You did not put forward any solid analysis at all. So superficial!

[@Pradeep_889]

We need a reservation system that fully reflects the caste demographics, ensuring 100% representation (100% reservation).

[@humshuklajihain9173]

India does not need a caste survey.

[@himadrib4743]

If representation based on population numbers is right, then Southern states should not cry when Northern states get more seats due to higher population

[@NandanLG]

Even Northern states should not cry/lobby when Southern states have performed well and contributing larger extent in tax collection. And Southern states have every right to ask for appropriate share. Either it is tax collection or population, the tax should be distributed fairly.

[@himanshutyagi3050]

@@NandanLG all the tech gaints founder and key people are from north right from paytm to flipkart to cred bharat pe lenkart,boat

[@onlinme7884]

South Indian states abided by the population control directive from Govt of India & improved their quality of lives, education & income. while north India as usual did not abide by any rules, less educated & reproduced in higher rates, contributes marginally to the taxes. Now, u r bothered that south India doesn't want to follow ur rules?

[@himadrib4743]

@@NandanLG Southern states have larger tax collections, only because of Northern and Eastern states were drained of their wealth through freight equalisation policy of Nehru and advantage of ports of southern states. Read it out before commenting

[@prashanth7097]

Like himanata said we need a caste census among muslims...there are like 1000 castes among them. When you say caste you mean hindus ,every educated hindu knows your designs😅

[@harshpalsingh1145]

Wrong analogy.

[@aaravraj4769]

But no tool to end caste . 😂only create division and division. 😅and enjoy it

[@manisherande4568]

no it is not about hindus.. its giving obc reservation to muslims ... they will get 20 % percent reservation

[@cinefile0075]

Caste census is the need of the Hour. Without data, how will government make schemes for underprivileged class and castes.

[@ukuk179]

Unclear to me why caste matters? Gandhiji against cast

[@adienjoy136]

Mil gayi na famous hine ka tarika

[@indieboy1033]

Irrespective of the outcome, country has to face moment of truth: Scenario#1: "dalit castes" are still in bad shape. Food for thought: Karnataka did land reforms in 1970s. Rich land owners were stripped of land. So-called upper castes are also middle and poor now. With unlimited chances to prove if 'dalit' caste are unable to make the cut, there is fundamentally wrong. (a) They truly are incapable. (b) They can improve if there is better approach than reservations and victim card. Scenario#2: "Dalits" achieved a lot and caste reached good shape. No need to continue reservation. Abolish caste discrimination by government. Scenario#3: Lot achieved. Little more pending. Then give a time frame. If we achieved parity in 75 yrs, may be 5 more years are good? Given internet and democracy of learning & knowledge now, it does not need more time. Use funds for their tuition, coaching. But end reservations in 5 years. None of the scenarios justify reservations anymore.

[@essanand]

Thanks

[@athirajm]

I wish all states did it before the election,but there is no time

[@meetankush]

Remember people, all these clowns that advocate for caste based positions, won't let go of their own positions. They could have walked the path and lead by example. Instead, they lecture you into submission from their positions.

[@Iamnotajournalist]

Instead of eliminating caste totally, they want to divide them again based on caste?? Your comparison with birthday cake is illogical.. Instead of doing survey based on their economic levels, just grouping them with caste will have negative results😊😊

[@rachaiah8187]

Bharath don't need

[@pgkrishnaniyer7606]

The udea of Caste clandestine introduced by The Moghuls and exacerbated by the British still lurks on the face of Indian society because of politics of caste. This will only be further accentuated by caste surveys. Sops and Reservations have heli3d but in a way reminds one of the recent past. The best way is to don't revive it by such means as the caste survey. The caste is sustained only by tge beneficiaries and politicians

[@graphiota18]

true...

[@thewhatorwhy]

Shut your mouth, Iyer.

[@ontisalaga1789]

The TNM has finally revealed itself as the congress mouth piece.

[@bloodwargaming3662]

If wanting justice for all segments of society as per the constitution= congressi. Proud congressi

[@ontisalaga1789]

@@bloodwargaming3662 oh . By that logic you are not a proud congressi as there is a lack of wanting justice for All, and only a select section.

[@bloodwargaming3662]

@@ontisalaga1789 no a part of segment of society has aldready it's fair rights at the cost of others they don't need it . The ones who don't have it are the ones I will be fighting for . Iam a uc Bengali Hindu but still solidarity with the lcs of this country

[@ontisalaga1789]

@@bloodwargaming3662 what does being a Bengali Hindu have to do with anything ? Doesn't make you any superior to anyone else.

[@ontisalaga1789]

@@bloodwargaming3662 yes , so the Congress does not represent everyone , only a segment, you are proving my point.

[@dengxaoping5031]

Odd day: Caste is evil and needs to see beyond caste Even day: Let's ask for everybody's caste allocate resources according to the caste Remove reservations and help people the other way without the interference from the government.

[@manusblr]

Simple point .. at least to know "how much has minority development boards helped" or even the minority has changed and are the development even effectively