Why is India not a Nuclear Superpower ? | Geopolitical Case Study

[@ThinkSchool]

👉Check out Odoo: www.odoo.com/r/3f4

[@randompie5558]

i have been wondering for a lot of time why india is not going for nuclear energy. why are we spending money on solar. your video is very informative . thankyou

[@concsciousvagabond9422]

Arre pushent%

[@Utubeisevil]

abbe akal ke andhe, India has the fissile material for more than 2350 nukes, all u need to do is put them in a cone and tighten some screws and voila, at least check the American DoD reports before blabbering about stuff you have no idea about. Do u know the yield of current bombs and how powerful they are in comparison to nukes used in ww2. stick to your lane and sell ur courses, matlab kuch bhii bhonk do uss germanshepherd ki tarah

[@manjeetshahare4986]

How the Neutron is thrown on the Uranium Atom. Where they get that particular Neutron 😮😮😮

[@rajeshrodricks3318]

Your explanation of Indian nuclear history feels somewhat one-sided and lacks depth. For instance, the emphasis on the deaths of Homi Bhabha and Lal Bahadur Shastri appears more like an attempt to spark intrigue and boost interest rather than offering substantial historical analysis. Additionally, there is insufficient detail about the Indo-US 123 Nuclear Agreement (2008), which lifted nuclear sanctions on India and was a pivotal moment in its nuclear journey. Furthermore, the impact of Smiling Buddha (1974), including the imposition of nuclear and technological sanctions that led to significant developments like the indigenous creation of the Param supercomputers, deserves more thorough elaboration. This narrative would benefit from a more balanced and comprehensive approach.

[@surajkumar5182]

Not just Homi Bhabha but more than 11 Indian nuclear scientists have died Mysterious death 😔 we all are too busy in our internal conflicts so much that some western powers are secretly paralyzing our country for decades

[@BBeeblebrox]

They are still dying, it gets passed off u der the radar of mainstream media as fringe news. See yai yay is one mf agency. They ruined our space program by leaking false info to IB about our top isro scientist Nambi Narayanan sir that he was giving sensitive info to Pakistan about our space program. He had to fight for so long and his entire family endured torture so 10 years from police and society. In the end he was proven innocent. It was too late before our IB realised that MF agency See yai yay had just sabotaged India's space program by toppling it's top scientist. In the end he was so traumatized that he could no longer work at ISRO and his career ended.

[@carcamp5451]

@@kakun63 absolute comment that shows us why India is still poor and divided.

[@kakun63]

@@carcamp5451 YUP dingus cant u see the pun never trust a word of yt comment

[@surajkumar5182]

@kakun63 Indian

[@OsinakiKun]

​@@kakun63whatever Yankie

[@Ronit_9977]

Don't know how much blood shed is there in our history. Many sacrificed themselves for us, but are unknown. I hope, we will make the dreams of Sir Bhabha true soon and make India a roaring golden lion. Jai Bharat .........................................

[@csravikumar9171]

Main culprit are west and our neighbors

[@trijalinamdar5396]

Only possible if- 1) No Political Interference Take the *perfect* example of Mumbai -Ahmedabad HSRC, its original time of arrival was by 2022.. but got delayed due to Interference of *Congress allied Government* known as *Shiv Sena* (Or Thakrey Sena) They did not give approval to the project in Maharashtra and therefore delayed it by 4 years 2)Solving Problems related to Land Acquisition A Korean steel company Announced to enter India in 2000s but after 15-20 years it scrapped off the plan Due to problems related to acquiring Land to set up the factory it also lost around *20-30m dollars* in this *This is also the reason why Tesla isn’t planning to come to India*

[@s-qc9ns]

*Tiger

[@SUNs1591]

watch Rocket boys you will get lot of essence of struggle both for ISRO(incospar in 1961) and BARC, TIRA, ATOM bomb

[@Ronit_9977]

@@SUNs1591 Thanks for telling, will watch.

[@Sarcasmmemes]

Man, we'll have to accept that our forefathers were purely genius and quite visionary. Hats off to them.

[@what2440]

Tu bhi pdh le bkl

[@शाकुन्तलम्]

😭😭😭😭😭😭​@@what2440

[@ash7604yaman]

If India wants to do tests do it near Pakistan boarders

[@Satyaki266]

U know what, We Need A Dictatorship. A Dictator who is Completely Focused in the Growth of our Country.

[@UmangGupta-s5q]

How old are you man?

[@aman6980]

​@@UmangGupta-s5q Doesn't matter man.... Actually he's right NGL... As in democracy it's really tough to get every one under a same shoe so he's kinda making more sense

[@adityachaurasia0109]

​@@UmangGupta-s5qhe definitely has a mind of a 10 year old

[@SathyaswamyS]

Yes. All other political parties should be banned and Modi should be the sole supreme leader of India.

[@geocry458]

Almost that is happening now

[@srisudharsrinivasan8336]

1 point missing here: When India does try to go forward, people of India will protest severly against it like they protested against the kudankulam reactor. And when we try other options like biogas, farmers will protest against it (happening now in Punjab) We will never move forward if corrupt politicians play dirty politics abusing the poor people and keeping them backward and forcing us from advancements.

[@HarshSingh-1034]

Have you forgot what happened when Sabarmati Dam was Constructing?? Whole Leftist, Communist, Anti-India people came to oppose it Don't forget Amir Khan and some other Karchiwood people were also involved and opposing it

[@srisudharsrinivasan8336]

@HarshSingh-1034 as I said... Majority of the population is against progress and pro freebies... Most of us just want free money and complain about no jobs. No government can employ the whole nation... Instead of going after govt jobs like sheep we should help with job creation, and create streams of income ourselves. If we want the country to progress, we should progress, India can't become developed overnight and giving free stuff can't lift people out of poverty

[@biharibabu1421]

It's NGOs to be more precise Foreign funded NGOs

[@user-tr1px4sc7l]

How farmers gonna protest, where was it happened? People will protest against nuclear(Uranium/Thorium) explorations within India. That is not just how this man says in the video. Because, People live there! Not any trash that can be thrown into bin! Uranium/Thorium : A BiG NO! Renewable energy : Biogas, Solar, Wind, Hydro power : an UNDOUBTED YES! BUILD UP ON RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES as Mr.NCBN says, in his vision document and become really independent Bharat! That's what he tried in AP or in Telugu states and formulating policy reforms on. Don't know why he was hated by the so called self-proclaimed ultra/pseudo nationalists guys. Is Gujarat not a coastal state? How deliberately this video creator has shown the reserves only in Southern India. What an irony! These pseudo doesn't even care on talking a word of service when the Telugu states are in complete destructive mode from the last 5years. And censored a state of Telugus, so nothing happening by their illegal backyard silent affair with Jagan wouldn't come out to the public. How heinous is this when the same persons speak about Kerala & Bengal in relation with communism or such? Then immediately skip on or miss upon the regressive devastating situation of Telugus from the last 20years and supports the same people there? Especially in case of Andhra in the last 5years of Jagan govt? So, is this not the useless silent back-yard affair and the so called chrony capitalism of some filthy people from Maharastra and Gujarat? Why wouldn't let the perspectives flow like fresh stream of water? Why would they hide it from the thirsty? So to waste it and make it dirty and deserted and again cry upon whom they made forced slavery? Just explore the Uranium/Thorium reserves in Uttarpradesh, Madhyapradesh, Gujarat, Maharastra, Rajastan, Bihar instead? Is it OK??? Let's see whether people protest or not? These states are not protesting because they rely upon or stealing the opportunities and theft the wealth and hardwork of the southern Indian states, especially the Telugu states from the last two decades! And guys you do completely ignore a whole group of people and undermine them. Only thing you know about them is the cinema that too you guys didn't tell out openly but enjoy them in a closed setup so, no one would know and acknowledge the actual creators of arts, wealth and the work.

[@dtalkzz3347]

so true i went to kudankulam last year from my college iv and we visited the villegers and they are sooo happy now. the same villegers who protested is now so glad the reactor is there since now they have much cleaner and tastier water and food and thanks to the water emitted from the reactor being just hot enough to make the fish lives easier they have much more fish to catch and sell thanks to it. some of them even thanked the scientist that accompanied us....

[@SanjayPatendla10]

"In Geopolitics there are no friends, only benefits and rivals." It's true ,we should be conscious while making friendship with countries. And we have our man ,Mr.Jai Shankar putting it in the right way

[@JSnwl-ng5zq]

Everyone today is like "Soviet helped India in 1971, we are true brother's" but we must realise that it was in Soveit union where shastri ji died. If he had not died we could have achieved Nuclear bomb before 1971 war. If we had nuke then no country would have dared to attack India and we wouldn't have needed USSR for help in the first place.

[@aham-mumukshu-asmi]

There are no permanent enemies and friends among countries. Everything depends on the ruling powers of that time. Congress asks us to trust China and Pakistan blindly. This is what is dangerous for all of us.

[@llawliet365]

Is there evidence that Soviet killed PM Lal Bahadur Shastri?

[@mayanrjanandhu5046]

They were killed by cia and search for the voice note

[@sumitghotane]

Ahh chances are CIA is only involved or Indira gandhi and USSR involved in Sashtri Ji death....

[@JoeBiden1776]

Your soviet friends were too a nuclear power!! But it takes good strategy to disintegrate a country like USSR in 1991 not nukes!!

[@IAmOxidised7525]

CIA killed Homi Bhabha , Shastri by ISI

[@In_szone]

Pls watch taskan file nice movies....

[@millennialmind9507]

India never had the contingency plan

[@arunkris7299]

KGB also had hand on it

[@In_szone]

@@arunkris7299 not kgb isi ... Our own people were also involved.....lol

[@imperial_Drag999]

​@@In_szone KGB killed sastri ji I have no hate for Russians and Soviet union But they tried to put leftist forcefully in india and killed nationalist leaders who were more pro US and I can say wanted to stay too much neutral instead of being more Soviet alliend

[@rohitraj-ig8to]

One of the best videos that Think School has made till now, the quality of animation and the flow of video looks as good as big budget movies. Think School is one of the few channels which is actually making people learn from mobile. My only request is that please don't ever compromise quality for quantity. I can wait an entire month to watch your one top class video rather than multiple mediocre ones. There are billions of videos on KZbin but very few have this type of quality. A commendable work by team Think School. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@suntzu1409]

A video titled "Why is India not a Nuclear Superpower ?" where he talks about everything OTHER THAN "Why is India not a Nuclear Superpower?" is the best video? Not surprising. A clickbait to rule them all

[@sahilparmar148]

I wrote an article for our college's annual magazine with same title "India's Nuclear Program" just 2-3 months ago....... So good to have immense knowledge on the same topic. Thank you brother for giving us this much knowledge in a very elegant way.......🙏🙏📿

[@Laxmanca]

if indian government starts giving more attention and focus on our scientists, trust me our nation can really boost in technology and efforts and hardwork Indian peoples give towards their passion/profession is mindblowing, but what they are getting back towards services is so undercasted till ! Respect for our Great patriot, Homi Jehangir Bhabha🙏 Lal bahadur shastri🙏 Jehangir Ratanji Dadabhoy Tata🙏

[@llawliet365]

Bro that won't help them gain much votes. Caste politics and freebies do. People need to start voting for development for country to truly change for the better.

[@Laxmanca]

@@llawliet365 bro but caste politics and freebies is not something they can able of if we peoples are smart enough for what right and wrong.

[@vishnuMSify]

There Are still people around who kiss the boots of the people who came from west

[@Laxmanca]

@@vishnuMSify 🤣🤣

[@llawliet365]

​@@Laxmanca Yes. That's what I said in my last statement. People need to become smart and prioritize development and not based on caste or freebies.

[@-7-man]

Homi Bhabha and J.R.D Tata.. True patriots. I don't know about KZbin baba.. But Homi Bhabha would be smiling up there watching this tribute.

[@atmaatma1996]

Both are relatives also

[@TreeShakura]

😂😂😂 jrd was the one who killed homi .. it was vishwasaghaat USA wanted homi gone and jrd wished for the same for he felt jealous of him terrified of homi's growing influence.. Saanp Ghar me bethe h . Jrd and homi were relatives , so Homi had equal RIGHTS over the TATAs inheritance

[@justaguywithcoolusername]

@@TreeShakura source : trust me broo (who probably failed elementary school)

[@TreeShakura]

@@justaguywithcoolusername ANDHABHAKAT OF TATAS😂😵‍💫 ... do you know what TATAs are??

[@ABUUTURAB]

The video gave me goosebums

[@SHOAIBAKHTAR-f5n]

An eye opening video.. More power to you!!

[@srinath8980]

Thanks

[@S.T.E_YT]

4:28 France has dried up its precious water bodies to run its nuclear power plants. The nuclear power plant can't be comletely shut down, you need a lot of water for cooling the reactor even in passive state to prevent reactor meltdown.

[@HOLYWARRIOR-hr7qd]

Correct plus nuclear waste is still an unsolved problem

[@av5051mc]

Do you know how big our coastline is?

[@S.T.E_YT]

@@av5051mc Do you know that water contains salt, it isn't fresh water.

[@thedoctor649]

India is among the countries which have the highest water %age in its geography.

[@HOLYWARRIOR-hr7qd]

@@thedoctor649 bro it needs fresh water not sea water go study first

[@S.T.E_YT]

21:31 @ThinkSchool The cost of nuclear energy is very high due to safety precautions need to be taken in a nuclear plant are complex. Secondly the cost of renewables like solar energy and wind energy is decreasing year by year, therefore India is investing on affordable renewable energy than expensive nuclear energy.

[@ravikumar-er1kv]

While initially it is expensive, it is more efficient and reliable than other sources of energy. You can't be at mercy of solar and wind energy for long. Nuclear plant however expensive is a long-term solution.

[@S.T.E_YT]

@ravikumar-er1kv Yaa true, its long term distriction plan with nuclear radioactive waste which lasts 1000 yrs.

[@ravikumar-er1kv]

​@@S.T.E_YTI don't know what to tell you man, you fail to understand that solar and wind are not reliable sources of energy however cheap they maybe. There are ongoing research on what to do with the waste or how to minimize it, you opt to totally dismiss nuclear power. Please tell me what should we do instead of what we shouldn't do, to meet the energy demands once we exhaust all the coal we have. Also please tell me how to scale solar or wind energy with this increasing demand.

[@S.T.E_YT]

@ravikumar-er1kv Simple answer for this is our nation needs to work on grid scale energy storage like closed loop pumped hydro and thermal batteries to reduce power curtailment of renewable energy source.

[@ravikumar-er1kv]

​@@S.T.E_YTwell I would say then to have both. But thanks for pointing this out. Never knew we had a solution like this.

[@pardhivvarma]

Whenever you talk about India's development in the field of Education, Defence, Economic or any field the foundations go back to the contribution of the TATA's. Incredible family Missing Ratan Tata Sir

[@TENGRI-101]

You forgot to mention scam call centers

[@letitgo151]

Millions of Indians died due to famines under the British, yet no one dared to make it as horrific but when the west died due to war they proclaimed themselves as heroic, saviours of humanity

[@getexplainedone]

The word hero is for people like bhabha

[@tejasam2341]

What do you mean?

[@RakeshKumar-js1in]

One of the best episode 🎉🎉

[@chickurats]

Kudos to the editing team for such a wonderful presentation of uranium atom at 3:15. I was blown away! Great editing guys

[@Tanmay_IN]

21:40, Oh man, you have to be kidding me if we still haven’t got the reactor! This is unbelievable-knowing that this technology could make us an energy-surplus nation. Why on earth are our leaders and bureaucrats afraid to approve and fast-track the process? This isn’t the only case; it’s the same across every essential field, whether it’s the jet engine, AMCA, nuclear attack submarines, EVs, or many other things. It’s incredibly frustrating.

[@SuyashBajpai-k6z]

The reason is almost no budget is allocated to research and development in our country. The voters should stop the internal politics of religion, caste etc and start asking questions to the government on how they will make india great again and seriously contribute in R&D. Our timelines for completion of these projects are so slow and delayed

[@darshan.babaji]

Hi

[@pranavjayaprakasanut]

​@@SuyashBajpai-k6z50 % clowns here can't have 3 meals 😂, better to get out while you still can

[@SuyashBajpai-k6z]

@@pranavjayaprakasanut Care to elaborate? If you are saying to get out of the nation, I won't. Instead of blaming what's bad i will try to make something good no matter how small the change is i will make it, I won't leave it. And no one is a clown, all have their circumstances. If my tone feels provocative I'm sorry I didn't mean it.

[@HOLYWARRIOR-hr7qd]

Brother their 2 big problems with nuclear that it requires a lot of fresh water (which we do n't have in abundance) and second it's nuclear waste problem is still unsolved plus it is not profitable

[@aham-mumukshu-asmi]

The Tasken Files is one of the most underrated movies which asks a lot of questions about Shastrijis death.

[@relaxingvideos2974]

18:25 that's incorrect . US after Japan nuke never wanted to repeat unless if attacked by another nation. It's over exaggeration we Indians want to keep repeating USSR helped india to thrawt USA , same USSR supported china in 1965 war against India. Let's not forget nations act based on their interests not for showing bollywood friendship like relationship towards us.

[@ramadevikaneganti7144]

In 1965 India fought against pakistan not china, India-china war happened in 1962, and Russia didn't helped us because they're already involved with US in cuban missile crisis at that time.

[@navan1087]

if your talking about India China war in 1962, then it was a limited war on no mans land without any air force involvement and USSR had no obligation to overtly support India since we were not an ally of USSR.But after the war, India and USSR signed a military pact where India and USSR will mutually help if got attacked by China.

[@ayushnews5735]

but entire indian media has fed the country on how Russia was the friend of India since long. Who'd tell them

[@riderchallenge4250]

India and China actually never fought a full scale war they have only fought land war that too without any heavy artilllery

[@arahul4045]

Nah, you're down playing US's ambitions and hegemonic tendencies.

[@justaperson2247]

Ganesh you have touched a very imp topic , instead of focusing on just solar we should move to nuclear power....we need to start questing our politicians to move towards it.

[@arcothmmjaswanth4319]

The day we prioritie the lives of our scientist's and great minds of our nation by providing the right security we'll advance more in any field.

[@rohithbandari]

Why aren't people like homi bhabha or apj Abdul Kalam exist today in India in 21st century who are actually close with top Indian govt officials like homi was. India eagerly need these kind of people. Why should we be dependent on solar today too. What are people in this country doing?????

[@dibadyutiroy1964]

They now are more greedy and don't stay in India. Also government policies and public ignorance is behind this. Today gen z's kids philosophy is earn much more anyway. They lack the feelings of nationalism.

[@abhishekahirvar7783]

@@dibadyutiroy1964 bro govt doesn't spend on r&d and increased gst even on research equipment doing research in india is terrible everyone tries to pull you down

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

​@@dibadyutiroy1964Thanks to globalisation for that.

[@fnamelname4146]

@@dibadyutiroy1964 What greed you're talking about, our Phd students get hardly 30,000 as fellowship, do you think its enough to survive in a tier 1 city and also support your family back, also the gst on research equipments. And Govt keeps on increasing reservation in institutes and jobs that previously were based on merit, then you wonder why students go out of country. Firstly Govt neglect these students and then you guys question their nationalism.

[@akileshbhat7021]

Trying to leave the country where intelligence and talent is appreciated, not a country with sc st reservation and muslim appeasement

[@pandurangarao3739]

Kudos to Think School for bringing up this informative video. I still feel proud of our country that we have so much talent and will have. We just need to put it in the right path and our leaders should focus on the country instead of only getting into power.

[@rajdeepsen3011]

Rocket boys is an must watch for india growth story believers , goated series to the evergreen greatest personalities of India

[@AritraBanerjee-l3p]

I wish my college classes were as interesting as your videos are. Hats off to you brother for making such an amazing content. You are really an inspiration. ❤

[@amolshinde6778]

hey @ThinkSchool Video is good but As a part 2 of this video, please make detailed video on how today India's progress in energy sector, specific on nuclear energy

[@sweetyforever1876]

A CIA agent wrote in his book that they were responsible for shastri death and homi bhabha plane accident 😮

[@Kishore-fy9tk]

Bro can you please mention the book name?

[@gettingfunded]

@@Kishore-fy9tk Mitrokhin Archive Vol. 2

[@g.p.kuberangpk5160]

this case study was really a good one that gave me more valuable insights on defense and the way you used AI to depict scenes was really very nice✨

[@Dave-zyan]

Homi J was the visionary for India . We need more inventions like west rather than normal food and textile tycoons who just focus on filling their pocket . Working in West on super classified technologies , I believe we are really behind in the game . The west always does things secretively to make their position at least 2 or more decades ahead .

[@devamjani8041]

The west was never ahead. It was only during colonial era that they got ahead. Now that colonies are no more. They are rapidly loosing their edge to US and Asia.

[@arunkris7299]

first govt need to put rule that every IIT ian need to work in country for atleast 5 years, they using country top research facility and labs and flew to west and work for them,

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

​@@devamjani8041US is actual west.

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

​@@arunkris7299That's not how it works. Nowhere in the world.

[@fnamelname4146]

@@arunkris7299 You pay 2-4 lacs as coaching fees to prepare for JEE, then pay 10-20 Lakhs as college fees to get a degree. If you are from general category, then it's worse seeing your friends from reserved categories who got similar rank as yours getting better colleges or branches than you. Even after that getting a job and good package, you have to pay 30% as income tax directly, getting nothing in return. Nationalism comes from within when you feel being treated equally, and see govt working for you not for politicians and businessmen.

[@Lifeonsaddle]

Man hats off to your research and development, respect 😉

[@abiuniverse]

As an insider into India's nuclear scientist community, I can tell you that we need more collaboration for India's nuclear dream to work. No one is working towards new nuclear technology except very few; the rest are wasting their time on stupid research to get grant money. The amount of exploitation in Indian academia (especially physics, from my perspective) is unreal, and that is the biggest enemy of our nation.

[@fauj7860]

Pin this comment for the sake of our beloved india (and not Hindurashtra of andhabhakts)

[@saudsurti6587]

Absolutely best editing 👍🏼👍🏼

[@theseeker_]

Thanks for creating a gem of video ❤

[@joesanga7x740]

im from myanmar and i love this chanel ..stay strong india

[@mugambo5505]

It's sad to see how these geniuses changed India's fate but corrupt politicians are eating everything

[@t.narayanalokesh9895]

The content which you are posting is damn useful. Keep going

[@Ro-nal-d0]

Please do a Video about NAMMALVAR 👨🏽‍🌾👩🏽‍🌾⚒️🚜🧺 ஐயா and Organic Farming 🌱☘️🌼🌿🍀🍁

[@shashwatshrey9248]

Great Video! Jai Hind.

[@thehellsangel1]

India needs to work faster towards this dream.. ASAP

[@GOKULSREE007]

You just earned a subscriber !

[@mobiletweaks4637]

1. The second stage fast reactor went under construction in 2004. It means that the R&D was already completed back then (or so it should have been) 2. If you think budget is the problem here, ₹ 5,850 crore (equivalent to ₹ 220 billion or US$2.58 billion in 2023) were spent until now. 3. Saying that one reactor is completed now won't be correct. A reactor can only be said to have completed when it achieves its 1st criticality. It is well known in Nuclear community 4. Homi Bhabha did bless us with the 3-stage programme, but even if he hadn't passed away untimely, it was unlikely that the programme would have been completed by now. It is possible that a lot of challenges might have been unknown to Bhabha, which we now know. It is very common in R&D. I'll list out the steps required and challenges: i. Developing reprocessing tech for 1st stage reactors. We can do that well. ii. Building a fleet of stage 1 reactors and the reprocessing plants to cater to them. We're a long way to go. iii. Building a stage-2 reactor (we've been at it for 20 years). The R&D is actually going on since 1980s. iv. Developing reprocessing tech for 2nd stage reactors (good luck with that, a lot of engineering problems. I don't know the current status of this stage) v. Building a fleet of stage-2 reactors vi. R&D and construction and first criticality of stage-3 reactors and then building a fleet. Also reprocessing tech for these. We're in between points ii and iii. The video here is good. But it fails to address the current problems. A case study needs to be done on why we have not progressed beyond this point despite large budgets being allocated (and not for a fleet of reactors, but a single prototype reactor to get it started and it has yet not started). To say that India is lagging due to controversial death of Bhabha is an insult to him, as that was 50 years ago. We need to reflect on where we're actually making a mistake and improve upon that.

[@kuriakosekjoseph6253]

Such a well written reply. I hate it when people are like if that didn't happen we would have reached here etc. I am sure Homi Bhaba mentored some really top notch nuclear scientists in his time and till 1974 we were doing academic collaboration with western scientists so I am sure our scientists must have picked some things.

[@Sylvester4571]

It's clearly western corruption in India. The only country that has almost full energy dependence is France. Most countries use natural gas and oil as a fuel for energy. Clearly India has rulers with western agendas

[@suntzu1409]

Finally an intelligent comment. People are so obsessed and fantastical with the "3-stage plan" that they forget that what it is: a plan. A scientist thinking or saying a plan does not magically realize it or spawn it into existence. Realizing an advanced technology plan is EXTREMELY hard, time-consuming and risky. People don't really understand how incredibly challenging and hard nuclear energy is. Its not like building a new railway line or metro. Fuel reprocessing and breeder reactors is not trivial at all and are incredibly challenging. Each of that will take several years/decades of R&D. You have not mastered fuel reprocessing or breeders by mastering basic nuclear energy. There are only a handful of fast breeder reactors and fuel reprocessing sites that EVER operated at large/commercial scale. P.S.: Its a clickbait to rule all clickbaits. It discusses everything OTHER THAN what went wrong

[@rohansarode7430]

U good...but we will never know...I would to trust that he would have made it possible,give him some benefit of doubt plz...

[@kavinkarthikeyan6043]

Great content and a very useful video Man🔥 Thanks a lot Ganesh🫡

[@vipulgupta]

0:45 Choose your words carefully. US didn't put an end to WW2 by dropping those bombs. First of all WW2 was ended by Soviets once they captured Berlin and second US dropped those bombs despite knowing WW2 has ended and Japan has agreed to surrender. There was absolutely zero need for those bombs to be dropped. Speak the history as it was, not the Western version.

[@ak171287]

Hey buddy. Japan hadn't surrendered before the bombs were dropped.

[@vipulgupta]

@ak171287 I didn't say Japan had surrendered, Japan had offered to surender which was not accepted by US, instead they dropped the bombs. Besides, there was no need to drop those bombs to kill tens of thousands of innocent civilians to defeat Japan.

[@rishyasirungen9211]

Guys, I learnt it in a different way in my school textbook. US asked Japan to surrender or else face it's wrath. Japan send US a voice message through radio that they need time to think in Japanese. US personnels didnot know the Japanese language except for few words which included surrender. Since Japan did not say " we surrender " in Japanese they thought that Japan decided to continue the war. And so US nuked it. The entire nuke happened due to misunderstanding by US and later they felt guilty for all the destruction. Due to this US decided to pay compensatory amount for all the loss it caused every year. They are paying it even today. I am not sure whether this is true or not but i just wanted to share what I learnt...

[@ravikumar-er1kv]

Bro how can you say with much surety that US didn't need to end the war and that Japan had agreed to surrender. It is still a contested topic that no one has right answer to. You are just taking the other side like people from other part of the spectrum do. And are doing for the very same reason that so many people died. What we know is that Japan's leadership was not unified, some wanted to surrender while others still wanted to fight. We can't take a side in this matter that's all I would say.

[@shi_va6754]

​@@vipulgupta probably wanted to set the narrative that they caused the ww2 to end and also test the weapons.

[@Defence_kaksha]

Gr8 learning after long time thankyou Ganesh...

[@truth_questioning]

Briten fighted world War 1 and 2 by using the money of India

[@sandipchatterjee3560]

No.

[@Laxmanca]

@@sandipchatterjee3560 they did they used 200,000 men soldiers in ww2 and also the money mainly comes from INDIA

[@Hillskarbi_official]

This is amazing... Need to reach 1 crore views

[@devamjani8041]

We are building new reactors rapidly right now. Don't worry, we will be a nuclear superpower within this decade.

[@Laxmanca]

i don't trust. i would love to support the process but results are still lacking.

[@twoface5609]

dream

[@AceMaheswaran]

i second this🎉 we will make it happen soon.

[@JoeBiden1776]

Still wont be given any place in NUCLEAR SUPPLIER GROUP for decades to come Regards💝🇺🇸

[@twoface5609]

@AceMaheswaran dream.

[@sambanthamkarunakaran360]

Excellent, keep doing it.

[@hariomt159]

good editor and information

[@jeychandru5881]

This video is full of Goosebumps ❤

[@malaykisku091]

India has 172 nuclear warheads in 2024!

[@cnbsrinivas]

Mind Blowing info Ganesh and Think school Team

[@bhushanpatil7018]

Yes... Feeling the same situation in Russia Ukraine War. For India its will be A friend, A Neutral and A Strong Leader in world.

[@sramshankar672]

Thanks for sharing this info, very informative and learning lot of things through your channel

[@abhinav.amarapuram1013]

00:07 India's pursuit of nuclear power 02:42 India's lag in nuclear energy development 05:02 India's nuclear program leaders died in mysterious circumstances. 07:25 India pursued nuclear energy for energy independence. 09:45 India's need for a nuclear strategy and the importance of uranium as an energy source 12:02 India's abundance of Thorium reserves as a potential source of clean energy 14:27 India's pursuit of nuclear power was hindered by unfortunate events 16:37 India's Non-Proliferation Treaty stance 18:42 India's dependence on other countries has paralyzed its economy 20:50 India's challenges in becoming a nuclear superpower 22:34 Homi Baba's vision for India.

[@dukkhobilash9418]

Your English is just fantastic.. I'm doing ielts..and your videoes helping me❤❤❤

[@Sudeep.J.B]

APJ. Abdul Kalam & Atal Bihari Vajpayee. Respect Button 👇

[@abdulhasham5599]

This episode was truly amazing. Inspiring for the youth and scientific community to work on our national security

[@shask2157]

The video would have been more useful if it had focussed more on what are we doing about it now like challenges, advancements happening now instead of talking about historical incidents for 20mins.

[@royarsofficial4788]

Your videos are so good, by all aspects

[@FinancewithArunn]

KAMINI (Kalpakkam Mini reactor) - the world's only thorium-based experimental reactor. It produces 40 MW of thermal energy at full power.

[@scp-yearsago]

Thorium is exclusively found in the black sand off of the coast of western india. Fullscale implementation of thorium based reactors can cause depletion of the fuel source. Once tokamak fusion reactors are deemed efficient, only the geopolitical stressors and stupidity of the civilians pose a threat to nuclear revolution in india.

[@soumosen9652]

What a video bro❤❤

[@SandeepKumar-wm4gd]

India India..🇮🇳

[@saraswathisatish8883]

Ganesh sir, always you come up with enlightenment sessions, thank you🙏

[@AnuragS2742]

Ganesh bhiya, you should also take interviews from scientists and experts from every field and make world-class documentaries and case studies never made before. This video was as good as an inspiring movie 🔥🔥 Keep inspiring us 🙏 Jai Hind 🇮🇳

[@nidhishah3135]

Your way of case study telling is amazing, Its keeps the interest till the end, hooks up from the very beginning, great ups and downs in the timeline. Half way into the study I was like damn yea how come we are still at 3% when some one so knowledgeable had a plan and at the end of the study I was just nodding yea totally makes sense. And Im very sure India really could have been on another level if it wasn't for internal politics and geopolitical issues. *Sigh in disappointment*.!

[@nithing2426]

Hi bro can u make a detail biography of Vikram Sarabhai life story .... Waiting for this

[@AmanKumarSingh-o2d]

Thnx dude for such a life lesson for the nation

[@flash6797]

Gist: we don’t have uranium, we have to import it. So we have been experimenting with thorium for 40 years and are in stage 2

[@Designawinyall]

Aksai Chin, bro. We do have it. External powers hindering our access.

[@ashedits460]

That was very informational. Loved the video🙌

[@Sanskriti94111]

Love your content sir ❤❤❤❤

[@RaviKiran-us6gd]

Your content never fails to amuse and add value in easy ways to viewers.. great job Ganesh🎉❤

[@_.falcon777._]

The biggest problem is Indian Education system . No one focuses on research and if someone wants too , they can't because there are very less facilities or salary and more exploitation. Everyone is just running to get a government job No one cars about the Country or any other person . People literally don't have basic civic sense here . If we want to go grow as a country our main focus should be Research & Development. There are so many flaws in our country's system. I'm deeply saddened to see the state of Our country. I hope more educated youth and people run the country

[@ravikumar-er1kv]

Very true brother, I have the same opinion, we spend less on education and R & D. But when it comes to government jobs, it is not entirely true. I have been to most parts of the country. Most people from north want government jobs, but in south it is a different matter altogether. As far as I have seen in south they choose to be a doctor, an IT professional or have their own business etc. Just saying that government job is not their first priority. I may not have a source for this, but I have a sample space of whole college where I graduated in Tamil Nadu. As far as I have seen there is huge demand for government job mostly from UP and Bihar.

[@-AkhilTej-]

🎯💎🏆 Great insightful & fruitful video 🏆💎🎯 लोकः समस्ताः सुखिनो भवन्तु ( May all beings lead prosperous life across Globe 🌍 )

[@MosfetBjt]

Rocket 🚀 Boys❤!!

[@raniratna8407]

It was very insightful...Thank You

[@lavanyasenthil3267]

1. What was Bhabha’s nuclear secret that could have changed India forever? Homi Jehangir Bhabha realized the potential of nuclear energy amidst the destruction caused by nuclear bombs. He saw nuclear energy as a solution to India's energy problems and initiated India's nuclear program. Bhabha's vision and leadership laid the foundation for India's nuclear capabilities. 2. Why has India fallen behind today? What are the challenges that are paralyzing our growth in nuclear energy today? India has faced challenges in the nuclear energy sector, including regulatory hurdles, safety concerns, public opposition, and international sanctions. These factors have hindered the growth of India's nuclear energy program and limited its expansion. 3. Where does India’s nuclear energy program stand today? India's nuclear energy program has made significant progress since its inception. The country operates a number of nuclear power plants and continues to invest in nuclear research and development. However, challenges persist, and India faces the task of balancing nuclear energy growth with safety and security concerns.

[@harishparida]

Thank you , wonderful research video in short time equally easy to understand

[@iwillbeno.1]

Only 4 lakh views? Every Indian needs to watch this.

[@subhashlodha4212]

Thanks for making such videos ✨❤️

[@vickysmart75]

7:40 actual vdo starts...

[@tathagata_chakrabarty]

Thanks

[@punamkumari-ce3sz]

Always learning something new from your case study.😊

[@murugandevara1982]

Brother, Could you please cover the US 36 Trillion debt. Possibilities of US Default. Impact in the world and mainly in India.

[@AvinashSINGH-lw4lr]

This channel should be the most popular channel in India

[@rameshvenkateshappa8443]

You missed a issue that's related to this topic. Our neuclear scientists dead mysteriously from 2004 to 2016 they're working in kaiga neuclear power plant Karnataka...

[@arul_r_learner]

@18:14 I read the New York Times article you mentioned. Statement is unclear that whether really Mr. Nixon wanted to bomb India or Soviet if it had intervened China's action. Also when I read more about this, I came across one article where Nixon and his assistant for National security affairs Mr. Kissinger discussed. It conveys that Nixon wanted to bomb Soviet not India.But again its not clear in that article too.

[@baibhavsharma5397]

Watch rocket boys , an underrated gem

[@amolsawarkar4928]

Much needed video ❤

[@PrajwalDSouza]

Indian government has paralyzed Scientists over the course of time. It is a torture for scientists to stay in India. There was a time when scientists led missions, but it is now taken over by bureaucrats and politicians. This is not a problem for India, it is a global problem that plagues NASA too. But it is getting worse in India. There must be more power given to scientists to lead good programs without bureaucrats and politicans weighing them down. 9:19

[@jarvis9309]

What a wonderful video bro 😍 👏🏻 Salute to our national hero Mr Bhabha who deserve a Bharat Ratna for his futuristic thinking in India's atomic energy developments. ♥️🏆

[@anandprashntsingh4624]

भैयाजी ऐसे ही इनफार्मेटिव और unbaised videos बनाते रहो.. हमारी शुभकामनायें आपके और आपके होनहार टीम के साथ है... Dhruv rathee मत बनना... Best wishes..

[@anakin_black]

The only way to respect his legacy is to create 100 more Homi Bhabhas. Dr. Bhabha was a great man and it's difficult to fill in his shoes. But for how long are we going to hold on to the past and cry about it? It's scary if a country's development is championed by just one person or a small group of people. Sadly our collective priorities are quite different.

[@rahulchowdary1237]

the best video by far

[@sunnyy6295]

Thorium tech is must for India till date.

[@SrikanthIyerTheMariner]

No country has it... it always 10 years away

[@nischaymiglani2617]

@@SrikanthIyerTheMarinerbut according to this video, china has achieved this technology.

[@SrikanthIyerTheMariner]

@nischaymiglani2617 BS... it may have done at an experimental level ... but there is no proof having an operating reactor...