Why Modi Govt HATES Middle Class? | Open Letter

[@openletteryt]

Can India have 0% Income Tax?

[@nirmitkhanna8282]

only if 50% inflation on daily items

[@Skn122]

Is neet and jee has become a rat race

[@sitarammalviy5457]

No , you have half knowledge. I am tax practitioner. Tax evasion on big level is not possible. It can be done by middle class people only

[@toshiksao]

zero ki jagah minimum 10% ka hone se bhi same faida hoga + aur jayada paisa banega gov ke pass

[@vibhutisrivastava2789]

Practically no

[@prabhjot1889]

Problem is after paying taxes we don't get anything in return. 💵💵

[@LeonXavier28]

​@SUS_nobody not only south but for all india

[@Nidhi_Tripathiiiiii]

mere mumma papa ka bhi paisa waste hota hai 😡

[@onidoremc9490]

That's why I m moving to Australia 🇦🇺 next year I m already well-off won't waste my single penny here

[@rubberbandpromax]

@@onidoremc9490best of luck and after moving share me your experience there :D

[@prodigy_jjt]

Exactly 😢

[@nikhilsingh6988]

Tax like EUROPE 🇪🇺 and services like that UGANDA 🇺🇬

[@tedtalker101]

Uganda is one of the most developed african country may be facilites like nigeria

[@MikaeilShah]

​@@tedtalker101no like somalia😂

[@Kushwahaji2708]

​@@MikaeilShah congo

[@almightypush6292]

​@@MikaeilShahSomali kuch jada hi ho gya 😅

[@MikaeilShah]

@@almightypush6292 hahaha. Agar yehi sab chalta raha to mai b job chod ke pirate ban jaunga 😜

[@CynicAtheist]

Direct tax ❌ Direct theft ✔️

[@Wjwji-82]

💯👍🏻

[@MrAtul1962]

that too overnight

[@parthf4873]

Moral of the story - Leave India and work for contries which give you good facilities while contributing in there income tax

[@agnivabanerjee6429]

Preach brother. Lets leave this hopeless country ASAP

[@parthf4873]

@@agnivabanerjee6429 True as our country hates talent and like my father pays 30% of his income as tax but still I have to study in a private school with high fees and have to go for private hospitals and buy medicines which are expensive. We have no jobs here and industrialists make the mess with the environment and then the Government tells us to care about the environment instead of saying something to industrialists

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@Aman-up9ud]

​@@parthf4873 My father pays 30% taxes too. We are from a tier 3 city in Bihar. The situation is worse than you can imagine. Whenever it rains, the roads get flooded 'cause the sewers are clogged and never maintained. We don't have access to clean drinking water. People around us who don't earn enough to afford a water purifier travel 2-3 kms to get water. The 'Nal-Jal' scheme is just a gimmick. Don't even need to elaborate on the schools and hospitals' conditions. On top of that we have the infamous 75% reservation in Bihar (which got overruled by Patna HC but the state govt is appealing it in the SC). In a nutshell, for people like me I would suggest you leaving the country. I won't feel an ounce of guilt while leaving India as I am not obligated to this country in any sorta way. My dad worked his a** off for 40 years to get us here. What has this country (more specifically my state) done for me?🤷‍♂

[@parthf4873]

@@idigitalbhilwara8797 Do the work that you really wanna do and intrested and just fuck the society

[@sagarsarkar786-yrf]

Middle class ko Mila hai middle finger 😂😂😂😂

[@Layman_O2]

Middle class ko govt ne mia Khalifa samjh rakha hai jaise chahe pel Rahi hai

[@aarushTripathi-bu3rt]

​@@Layman_O2well said😂

[@MrAbhix7]

​@@Layman_O2😂😂😂

[@SiktaPaul-u1r]

💯 right

[@abhijitham6619]

😂😂😂

[@kunalkar8315]

Rich are becoming richer day by day and poor are becoming poor day by day 😔

[@mohitharlalka2]

Middle class becoming poor

[@Hellishfire420]

Income Tax is the main reason most of the talented individuals from IIT's and IIM's leave india. 30% IS WAY TOOOOO MUCH FOR 15 LAKH SALARY, Learn from US

[@nanashi9108]

This is wrong info, for 15 lac income you would be paying around 1.5 lac as income tax. Which is around 10%

[@Shreyash112]

@@nanashi9108bruh it depends, still the tax bracket is too annoying as it doesn’t change according to inflation

[@cinephile9346]

30% is levied on the excess salary above 10 lakhs.

[@viveknegi7006]

​@@nanashi9108which country you are talking about dude? Above 10 lakh it's 30%, and in new regime after more than 15 it's 30%, in new regime no deduction and exemption, so most people file in old regime. Though pressional tax is 10% maybe you are talking about, but most of the people who paying so much income tax are salaried!!

[@nanashi9108]

@viveknegi7006 just because a part of your salary fall's under 30% don't claim that you are paying 30% tax on your income. If you divide the total tax liable / gross income you will get the actual percent of tax. Just use some online calculator of cleartax etc. You will know the exact percent.

[@MohitGupta-pv2fd]

The caption is Bang on They really Hate us middle class. Being an IT employee I am working 12 -14 hours, all I want is early retirement, but they have put such draconian taxes on us, which is unimagenable.

[@sameerk12982]

Thanks!

[@vakudibeardefender3953]

After 1942 that old slogan is coming back to India once again, "quit India".

[@rahulsawant8369]

It was to send😤 Not to go 😑 There is more feasble solution Change the Government. Kash Voting dhang se ki hoti...

[@Simar3107]

​@@rahulsawant8369dusre bhi konsi bohot behtar hai

[@regalmedia9487]

Yahi to problem hai. Logo ko samajh hi nahi ata ye sab haramzade hain

[@Simar3107]

@@regalmedia9487 bilkul sahi baat ki hai aapne

[@rahuldey9544]

Lanka mein sab ravan hai..

[@Dli230]

Tax like Germany. Returns like Afganistan. Amritkal - Nirmala Tai😅

[@dmcindianfan5374]

We're taxed like Europe But We're facilitated like Africa Say this 😂😅

[@alokebanerjee1990]

Election ka mudda mandir tha ... tax nahi .... religion tha ... unemployment nahi .... pakistan tha ... infletion nahi .... ush time pe bolna tha ye sab ... now its too late ...

[@kriss3pathi]

​@@alokebanerjee1990 option bhi to dekhna tha ki kya h Samne wale 78% tak tax slab badha di thi

[@amitsinghrazput]

Nirmala Tai be like - mai to kabhi infrastructure ki baat krti hi nhi hoon tum bhi mat kro 😂

[@nitin3577]

Yes we get na ₹8500 khata khat khata khat 😂😂

[@ammuvilambil8032]

Not only hatred They are not allowing middle class to live properly

[@emperor8686]

GST ON 2 WHEELER - 28% GST ON HELICOPTER - 5% #ModiKiGuarantee

[@shreeyakundaragi3136]

​@Shreradhe1008 and the till say they are educated 😂here 😂😂🎉😢😮😅😅😊😂😂

[@Sshh-l5m]

🤣🤣 ye kya mazak chal rha hai😂

[@icyhawt2854]

​@Shreradhe1008 so sad, this is the reason the rich get richer

[@nxttitan1197]

​@Shreradhe1008 middle class to 2 wheeller hi le sakte par amir lok helicopter lenge uspe kam tax 😢 aur helicopter jyada fuel consum karta hai 😒

[@gs-e2d]

abhey pagal aadmi, helicoptor aur 2 wheeler ki cost kitni hai aur uska percentage calculate karke actual amount batayio zara.

[@reginageorgetownuni]

Indian Taxes 📈📈📈📈 Infrastructure 📉📉📉📉 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@rhythmkhandelwal2940]

@@reginageorgetownuni Infrastructure is improving but only for mega projects

[@AkashSingh-pm-of]

​@@rhythmkhandelwal2940 Mega project charges extra or direct money from consumer. Like metro, toll tax, electricity and water bill etc.

[@rahulishere_5]

It's not only about infrastructure.

[@reginageorgetownuni]

@@rhythmkhandelwal2940 then what's the point when people are dying

[@tirthankardey394]

Still you'll live in this country so shut up

[@ashleshanatu1317]

I think she has put the final nail in the coffin for BJP.

[@kyrios1120]

No people will forget and still vote for BJP. Maybe Modi is taking revenge for not going 400 par

[@jaikrishnaullal7776]

Not BJP. She has put the nail in the coffin for US, the middle class

[@BadBoy-wy1il]

Lower income tax rates but taxing everyone is exactly what I had been thinking for the past few days

[@Sunny-barnwal]

Kuch bhi sabko kaise karoge bpl Wale logon ka karoge wo jeena chor de

[@reality1453]

​@@Sunny-barnwalbro he is taking about lower tax rates...and taxing everyone means compulsing everyone who doesn't pay taxes not necessarily poor people.

[@ak-nn7uc]

14 baache paida karne walo ki sewa karni h, tm tax do bss

[@BadBoy-wy1il]

@CASunnyKr my dad was a 1st grade officer of an OIL company and he has been paying taxes throughout his life. His package was very good but seeing him pay so many different taxes and not getting anything in return was definitely frustrating. He sent me to a privaye school, we had access to good hospitals where his company paid and will still pay as a retirement benefit. He never kept the option of sending me to a government school or hospital and luckily I got into a government college. But the way people are taxed where only 2-3% pay taxes is utter bulls*it. Lowering tax rates but taxing everyone is the only option especially taxing farmers. Around 56% of working indians are farmers so till this day farmers never taxed a single coin, so why not tax them a little? Otherwise say goodbye to development

[@vinestervega19]

Heck I say tax everyone above 18, as little as 50 paise and increasing based on income. Or dont tax anyone at all. This would make all citizens if the country equally hold the govt accountable in the way they spend.

[@MrDhananjayrai]

This FM is hopeless !! Exploitation of middle class is Worser than British India... salary class is being treated as 3rd class bonded labours

[@latakhandelwal8863]

I agree completely.

[@rahuldey9544]

Toh vote kyun diya aab rote raho..

[@darkblade6460]

​​@@rahuldey9544Doosri taraf to gurudev 1Lakh baatne ke liye Ghar bhi bechva dete

[@vidyanagarajan9135]

​@@rahuldey9544Toh tum Congress bhi wahi karega?

[@ageless1003]

Not FM but Modi 😅

[@veerbhadauria]

#sayNoToTax ...No facilities ..No taxes ....we need to start a reform movement to make govt realize that we are not blind

[@tejeswar]

Most of the Minister's have registered themselves as Farmers, there's no way they will ever include Farmers to the Income Tax bracket.

[@TheCycloneTrooper]

Exactly - politicians are completely disconnected from the local population - they're only devoted to creating their own personal wealth & perpetual continuity of privilege.

[@samuelgeorge3823]

Very good catch...you got a very valid point which we forget

[@sanh595]

The most painful experience is paying a third if our hard earned wages as tax, and then to see it be spent as freebies to get more votes and deplete the treasury. Take for example, the free bus and metro rides, which we support in principle, but the capital expenditure is so high, that the government then adds further taxes to fuel costs, which are again paid by the same set of people who fund the freebies in the first place. The whole situation is untenable, and will eventually lead to a downfall of our society.

[@champion3728]

agree

[@anuraggiri4428]

Real

[@creatoramaze6697]

don't blame politicians , blame India people they wants freebies (specially baby machine )

[@MetrucTon]

biggest problem is corruption. for every 10 rs e pay in tax only 2-3 rs is being used anywhere in roads, freebies etc

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. I paid 75k per month as a direct tax सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@mudassarwaseem8027]

Actually they love middle class because that is where they earn from 💀💀💀

[@ravishmahajan9314]

Problem is not the tax. Problem is it's inefficient use. There is only one minority in India: Middle salaried class😢

[@Abhinavsingh039]

I am very grateful that i left india and now i am a Swiss citizen i pay 25% tax and i am very happy to pay it as government gives us free education good public transport and social security which is impossible in india schools and universities are free here water and air are very clean unlike india infrastructure is very good here

[@kamleshparihar1846]

What do u do as a profession??

[@dmcindianfan5374]

Not only you everyone does it who can go to settle anywhere

[@Abhinavsingh039]

@@kamleshparihar1846 software engineer

[@Manish__1306-e4y]

great job untill good netha comes it will be like this only

[@Abhinavsingh039]

@@kamleshparihar1846 i am a software engineer

[@manuagarwal3484]

Thanks

[@amitpujari2347]

Tax payers should be declared as minority. A new revolution should be started to abolish Direct tax completely. People should unite and start a revolution to stop this injustice.

[@arindamchowdhury16]

We don't have any problems to pay taxes, but the problem is we don't get anything in return.

[@ageless1003]

Kya bhai, kitne statues ban rahe hain 😅...MLA aur MP bhi kharidne hote hai

[@Love-wz4vg]

Only 2% pay tax You are minority This democracy you should respect majority

[@vinestervega19]

@@Love-wz4vgAmbedkar already said democracy will fail in India. And you are living in a bubble if you think this is democracy. This is a plutocracy.

[@pankajmadia929]

इतना tax तो विधर्मी सुलतानों और बादशाहों के जमाने में भी नहीं लगता था

[@sanketh768]

amitab , sharukh , dhoni biggest people who use agriculture loophole for tax evasion

[@RahulPatil-lr5iz]

👌🏻

[@santoshsivaramkrish]

They Must pay incomeTax+GST+ENTERTAINMENT TAX as well!, But That is Charged+Collected wrongly From The Film Watchers while purchasing Tickets🎟!

[@rahulishere_5]

KL Rahul suneel Shetty no tax through BCCI

[@vibhutisrivastava2789]

Simple solution is to widen the tax bracket of direct tax payers otherwise people would feel looted.

[@Pranesh112]

The problem is that politicians are farmers so they wont tax themselves

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

@@vibhutisrivastava2789 सरकारी कर्मचारी:- काम चोरी रिश्वत खोरी Job security Salary increment Weekly 4 holiday Pension ये सब में कर लूंगा तुम जा कर tax भरो ( private employees , i.t employees, businessman )

[@Shaktiman-l6j]

@@idigitalbhilwara8797 Pension discontinued h most states me. NPS/PF me khud k hi paise kat te hain. Sarkar kisi common man ki nhi

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

@@Shaktiman-l6j आओ कभी राजस्थान Highest pension in country

[@sushilindian1067]

The income above 15 lakh on farming, agriculture and it's allies must be taxable. This is the need of the time. Why only middle class taxpayers are been targeted ! Why the rich farmers and politicians are safe and excluded in paying income tax! This picture must be changed.

[@GirishPandit-y7v]

terrible idea

[@naveengaddam9052]

Not many farmers earn more than 15 lakhs. Many have family land distributed among family members. It looks like a big holding, but it is distributed income. you can tax farmer, but be prepared for. Rise in food grains as many will leave farming and migrate to cities. Best is to encourage manufacturing. How many time you buy local goods, local groceries, local resorts , local crafts, local ice creams instead of big Indian corporates?

[@abhisheksoni303]

85% tax money is looted by the Politicians and bureaucrat's. That's why Education, healthcare and infrastructure is collapsing. Increasing tax on farmers will increase food prices

[@gloomyend1232]

@@naveengaddam9052not many matlab tax nahi karoge , waah beta waah! Keep Kama karo tax Bharani wale bhi 7% hi haina unka bhi ma’am kardo fir , na na go kaise hoga

[@sushilindian1067]

@@naveengaddam9052 if a single person earns more than 15 lakh from farming ..he must pay tax ..that what it means .

[@udhavgarkhede6028]

Who is Worst finance minister India ever had...? N sitaraman

[@typhlosion3D157]

Yes

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@HappyBabyOctopus-qu6mf]

She is merely a front for modi and his goons

[@shredder2cop]

Not supporting Modi if he's supports Nirmala

[@Ttdejjw]

Absolutely

[@escalocity]

Impose Tax on Farmers earning more than 2 Crore in an year.

[@SadBoy-bq5rf]

I know many farmers, especially sardars driving Land Rover’s but thry are not taxed whereas I earn 30k/month with alto 800 and taxed 😭

[@gurdeepsingh2837]

@@SadBoy-bq5rfYou can buy a 10 year old land rover for as low as 5-8 lacs. You don’t need to be multi millionaire to afford a pre owned land rover! You only need to be obsessed about having good cars than to have a lot of money to buy them. So your comment doesn’t make any sense!

[@SadBoy-bq5rf]

@@gurdeepsingh2837 But income makes sense

[@karate2252]

@@SadBoy-bq5rfbro they side business, stop jealousy 😂

[@icyhawt2854]

​@@karate2252abe pagal hai kya, sare ke sare farmers side business karte hai na, ye bat to news pe aani chahiye, aur fir uss side 'business' pe kyu nahi lagta tax ?

[@virasgaming1993]

Paying tax is never a concern, but paying tax alone is the main concern. Why tax is collected from only 2-3% people? Why not from everyone? All banks are linked with Aadhaar, find a way to collect taxes based on the earning in that account. Anything can be done if government wants to do it, if there is a will then there is a way.

[@kingofheroes1310]

Becoz most of the people are below exemption level or they don't show their income directly. Don't forget that an average Indian earns only about 3 lakh per year. Above 10 lakh and you are in top 1%

[@ankitasahoo6524]

Protests only help here

[@husky5912]

Bro I think middle class is more than 2-3 % aj kaal sadko ke par 10-12 lakh ki gaadi dikh jaate yeh toh ek middle class hi le sakte hai.

[@V12320]

In other countries some people become burden on government but in india government itself has become burden on 2% taxpayers.

[@therajveersingh5660]

भारत के आम आदमी में ऐकता ही नहीं है।अपने ही लोगों के विरोध में अपने ही खडे हो जाते हैं।💁🙄🙄

[@Ash760-m]

Every year 3 lakh upper class Indian are leaving India and for good future .

[@Gitae_Kim_KOS]

Most of them become labourer in gulf or taxi driver in Canada 🤡

[@malasardar3147]

​@@Gitae_Kim_KOSStill better than staying like a beggar in dicatorial India

[@Gitae_Kim_KOS]

@@malasardar3147 I wouldn't say so, there are countries better than India but to survive well there you need good education and skills , and if you have them, then you will enjoy luxury in India as well Only the lower middle class and poor suffer in India, that too because of the poor politics and government Military rule would be better than this currupt government

[@icyhawt2854]

​@@Gitae_Kim_KOSaabe chutiye labourer aur padhe likhe admi me fark hota hai 🤡🤡, yes gulf me bohot sare log labour karne jate hai par usi ki vajah se unki family yaha acchi life jee pati hai, ye sharm ki bat honi chahiye humare liye, most jo business wale log singapore aur gulf jate hai for saving hell lot on tax and also good quality of life, aur baki ke log mostly US aur europe jate hai (non labourers) jo ki actual higher middle class jo sabse jyada tax bharti hai India me 30% bharne wale vo jate hai, thats the main problem, gyan nahi jhat bhar bate pelu rat bhar

[@Rohit-ij7mb]

​@@Gitae_Kim_KOSlol. The air and infra are third class for everyone including the rich ones, not only for poor peoples

[@justsomeguywithasmolmustac9476]

True bhai The problem is not about paying taxes, but when you pay too much taxes and still get poor facilities and less or no benefit from it is the real problem.

[@BIRAJCHAKRABORTY-g5g]

After independence never think middle class family will be poor day by day

[@deepanagaraj8764]

That is why it is said Government is the biggest robber😢😢

[@mrsaklanii]

Income Tax should also be levied on Rich Farmers especially for Punjab, Haryana and UP farmers.

[@donalduncleusa6552]

You can't find rich farmers because they'll manipulate the data

[@husky5912]

Corporations and rich pay less tax as they do tax evasion and accounting gimmicks.

[@abhisheksoni303]

85% tax money is looted by the Politicians and bureaucrat's. Taxing farmers will create more problems, reducing chandachori and tax on middle class

[@Rayis4444]

@@husky5912What’s the point of paying tax here? No one wants to pay tax. Rich people buy everything themselves, they don’t rely on the government. The government cannot provide anything to them.

[@kunalkar8315]

2014 se GST ke karan Desh bohot zyada bhugad raha hai 😮

[@toufiqueomar814]

Haan toh Modi Modi kyun kiye the, jaisa kaam waisa faal...aab bhugto

[@LordxDev1L]

Only one line for BJP , "विनाश काले विपरीत बुद्धि"

[@LordxDev1L]

@AnilSecondHandle BJP bhi tatti se km nhi h

[@thanos.42078]

​@AnilSecondHandle Har baat m opposition kha se aa jati h, ye policy opposition bna rhi h kya ?

[@alancan83]

Vinash kaal bjp ka nahi hai apana aya hai honest tax payers ka

[@bowled_by_boult]

​@@thanos.42078chutiye inko agar hatayenge to opposition hi aayega na, aur agar wo inse bhi gaye gujre honge to BJP ko to koi hatayega hi nhi. Isiliye jitna ruling govt pe baat hoti hai utna opposition par bhi honi chahiye. Lekin anpadh logo ko kabhi politics samajh nhi aati

[@harshakale1513]

ꜱᴀʜɪ ᴋʜᴀ 😂

[@tarunpratap8618]

Sitaraman ❌ Sidhamaran ✅

[@ravindrapalsinghchauhan2786]

Yes, I agree with the 1. Govt should rich farmers. There are many rich farmers taking 50% subsidies on bank Loans and not paying any tax. 2. Many Private schools and colleges not paying Tax. 3. Politician not paying Tax. 4. There is only one earning member in somefamilies, and in some other families 2-3 members are earning members. So Govt should Tax on average income of a family, and not on individual income. Thank you

[@Michael.The.Jack.XIIIID]

Its Such a shame that our country is going to become 3rd largest GDP and we still have basic human needs as our problems ( even after paying all our taxes )😔

[@Michael.The.Jack.XIIIID]

Literally 🙄

[@Gamaclone-]

​@user-ht2qo6zb6k Farmer protest was an stupidity the laws were good for farmers

[@amantiwari4987]

​@user-ht2qo6zb6kDidn't he withdraw farm bills even though withdrawing it was a stupid move

[@divyamrathi299]

In 5th Largest and soon to be 3rd largest , only 2-3% people pay direct tax.

[@father-of-porkistan]

​@user-ht2qo6zb6kif u have guts , then speak on sandeshkhali

[@sujaykadam5501]

Me being a salaried employee you have summarised our pain very accurately same thoughts were going on in my head and was also discussing with my colleagues and friends. Nice video keep it up. 👍

[@jeelanmahkam3372]

Reservation should be given to those 2% who are paying tax.

[@ravimishra7524]

Tax like Europe ✅ Quality of life like uganda✅

[@shivanshgarg206]

why can't we have 0% income tax on Rs. 12 lakh annual income, 5% income tax on income between 12-25 lakh, 10% income tax on income between 25-40 lakh, 15% income tax on income between 40-55 lakh, 20% income tax on income between 55-75 lakh, 25% income tax on income between 75-100 lakh and 30% income tax on income more than Rs. 1 crore..!!

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

Then this will lead to more increase in inequality which will lead to left wing populist getting ejected who will instead increase tax on all people. See what is happening in Karnataka

[@shivanshgarg206]

​​@@ShubhamMishrabro how ?? please tell my friend. If you have taken the example of Karnataka, then they are actually suffering from freebies, and also that state's capital Bengaluru is so expensive that they atleast need Rs. 12 lakh income with zero tax to stay there...

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

@@shivanshgarg206 see the inequality chart. Second average income here is 20k per month. Third now making zero income tax till 12 lpa will lead to more inequality. This will be seen in society thus you see more rhetoric about elites running india like currently you see raga speech about ambani adani. Majority population will then vote for left wing who advocate for more welfare and tax. Thus you see increase in tax for mainly upper class and some increase for middle class too. Like currently in Karnataka due to welfare government is running into deficit thus they're increasing taxes for everyone

[@commieTerminator]

​@@ShubhamMishrabrou can't expect equal wealth when every human puts unequal efforts. Inequality is all natural and should be accepted as it is... *Pareto distribution* is well observed in various fields

[@user-ro9lq3tf6v]

Wow great debate. Some points gone above my head

[@mayurannadate1403]

Nirmala Sitaraman ❌ Nirmala Salaryharan ✅

[@aadarshX]

British rule was better than The rule of REPUBLIC.

[@Mr.Factro7838]

Soch samajh kar bol Bhai kuch bhi

[@aadarshX]

@@Mr.Factro7838 जो गणराज्य की कार्यप्रणाली और उस की नीतियों को समझ लेता है, वह गणराज्य से घृणा करने लगता है।

[@abhisheksoni303]

Jumla rule

[@aadarshX]

@@abhisheksoni303 irrespective of Political parties

[@coolcapybara111]

Bhai tax british k time par bhot bhayankar tha, compare toh sahi kar😢

[@srichander2641]

When govt can't be held accountable for finance, it is bound to be misused.

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@Thunder84806]

Who still thinks British rule is way better than independent India?

[@tanmoybiswas8782]

Remove Nirmala Sitaraman ‼️

[@rhythmkhandelwal2940]

I don't think that would change anything

[@Shreyash112]

Thats not the solution bruh,it aint if she decides all herself.BJP itself should stick to improving middle class peoples life than to exploit us

[@Valueinvestment22]

The worst Finance minister

[@skz2.010]

​@@Shreyash112 They just used us(Hindus). I was a hardcore Modi, BJP fan due to this. But I stopped voting since last election. Because I needed Yogi Ji as our PM candidate. And also I was tired of being looted in Stock Market by govt.

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@MillionaireMafia-sh5ud]

We are just 5% more developed than Pakistan and less 70% than china 😂😂😂😂

[@NitishKS-NX]

Gov will only say that 5%

[@SalimKhan-hq8cd]

Good job💯👍👏

[@coconuttree3222]

I left India 6 months ago. But whenever I miss my home, I think about the taxes and facilities. It snaps me back to reality

[@tanmayraazpradhan9235]

Good

[@shees1993]

😅 🎉

[@jaikrishnaullal7776]

Never ever think of coming back to this sinkhole

[@pradeepbansal008]

A special income tax card should be issued to all salaried individuals who are paying income tax under 30% bracket. This card should allow free travel in AC coaches of railways, free bus and metro travel in cities, free health insurance cover, free education and admission in premier govt schools and colleges, reduced interest rate of loans from govt banks, etc. The point is if we are really the people who are paying extraordinary taxes, then only we should get premier services of govt.

[@The90sbuoyy]

Exactly my call - 'a privilege class scheme'

[@salmanhaidr]

Best comment

[@mozart7299]

Kya baat hai bhai❤🎉

[@husky5912]

😂😂😂 bhai government ko tax hi mat do. Jo apan logo ko chaiye woh apan log milke hi bana lete hai na. Kon rok Raha hai.

[@pradeepbansal008]

​@@husky5912Bhai TDS cut hoke salary haath me aati he. Har saal refund lena padta he. Usme bhi income tax wale natak karte hai. Pahle govt apna hissa le leti hai fir humare account me paise aate hai. Jo hume karna he wo possible nai he..😢

[@prajapatifam]

Painful thing is that PM who himself comes from the poor family background who has lived once in similar condition does not understand the problems of middle lower class and farmers. How can you expect from someone else than?

[@kamal_ludhani]

No its not completely true Dhruv Rathee mentioned in his video which is about Modi's life

[@gs-e2d]

@@kamal_ludhani arrey woh Soros ki funding leta hai aur kuch bhi anap shanap bolta hai.

[@ximin_sleepy]

Taxed like Europe services like pakistan🤡🤡 improving quality of service is next to impossible for next 30-40 years. They should give exemptions from every other tax or abolish income tax for salaried employees only

[@SumairKhoso-sc1sg]

Pakistan service is really good

[@ximin_sleepy]

@@SumairKhoso-sc1sg yeah okay don't have food to eat but "the service is good" 🤡

[@SumairKhoso-sc1sg]

@@ximin_sleepy 800 million India's are don't have food to eat so what do you mean Pakistan India both are one of the poorest country of world

[@ximin_sleepy]

@@SumairKhoso-sc1sg 800 million is extremely exaggerated, some 40 million at best, which is also no less terrible. Um my point is our income taxes go to waste.

[@rhythmkhandelwal2940]

​@@SumairKhoso-sc1sgLol 800 million😂 you pulled that number Outta your ass didn't you

[@SoumyaChakraborty-es5hg]

I want to leave this country man😢😢.......

[@ituskisanpai8667]

same here bro

this is complete video, not only problem but also solution is described.

[@MohitChaturvedi-ef6op]

Paying tax without quality life really hurts a lot 😢

[@itaraj6054]

Seeing similar videos on almost every channel on every social media. Government is so deaf, they are not able to listen.

[@harikiranv8580]

Thats because they ban ur account permanently for criticising them!

[@maheshkrathi1645]

Strong commentary. Bravo !

[@umairsyed7465]

Absolutely agree! No tax cut or increase in tax slab. I am frustrated about it and inflation is so high that I am left with no savings at all

[@jayaramprabhu5595]

Even Amitabh Bachhan declared himself as farmer to evade tax.😊

[@priyanshusrivastava9292]

Superb video brother 👏 Ekdam dhaga khol diya aapne...👏

[@s_20201]

Worst FM of Indian history 😢

[@Shabbir1277]

As if she makes all the decisions.

[@mayurdugar03]

Exactly what wanted to convey! Why will rich and qualified people not leave?

[@rbdubey5855]

Bahut hi achhi prastuti saral per satya bibechana

[@Prince-9871]

Finnally bro is rising voice..😊🙂🥂🗿🗿 We need this type of content..🥂

[@prashantmore21]

Taxes are not problem, but use of taxes is. Developed countries take taxes upto 50% bit they prvide great survice in every sector.

[@excelbypradeep2869]

Middle class ka vote sabse jayada bata hua hai.... Sarkare unhi logo ke liye kaam karti hai jo United ho....

[@UnknownManOf_india]

Perfect slap bhai 0 % tax its very important

[@divyamrathi299]

Puri video dekh pehle. 0% tax is not possible in India , it's not possible even in countries like US , UK or China.

[@UnknownManOf_india]

@@divyamrathi299 i know only solution is 5% flat tax.. i know this but this government not going to do this 5 or 10% flat.. last year jab nhi kiya to ye saal bhi nhi hoga..

[@UnknownManOf_india]

@@divyamrathi299 aur i m paying 9 lakhs as tax .. and wife paying 6 lakh .. uske upper what not indirect tax... actually hum salaried log khatam hai..mera demand sirf road ka hai.. mei hospital and school expenses dekh lega.. but road to nhi bana skta ... I'm not getting roads kya bolun... Kaise bolun meri tklif.. esse better hai na lo...last year upgraded car actual price was 13 lakh usme bhi company got some profit.. as he manufactured.. 28% gst + 3.5lac road tax car ghar pe aayi 24.30Lac..

[@UnknownManOf_india]

@@divyamrathi299 tax se problem nhi hai.. problem hai against mei kya basic facilities humesha top notch nhi mil kti kya.. apne aap se pucho.. kya itna difficult hai basic facility .. india jaise country jahan mehnat krne walo ki kami nhi if 3 star hotel can be categorised as good enough then i dont think its not possible

[@Adi-oc2hd]

Iska mtlb tum India ki 0.01% population m hoge..salary of around 30 lakhs per annum+ your wife 18-20 lakh​@@UnknownManOf_india

[@Maheshl43]

Protest should be held 👍 vote for protest

[@prabhakarguptas.9491]

Excellent analysis and good suggestions too. Even TAX filing also is very cumbersome and complicated. In the name of rationalization capital gains tax enhanced instead of abolishing LTCG on shares and MF 's. Even savings interest is taxed. The suggestion that Agriculture income beyond say 10 lakhs should be Taxed.Schedules 112A etc should be simplified. Minimum Tax threshold should be raised to Five lakhs atleast. Hope more such videos are aired and Government make life simpler for Seniors and Pensioners.

[@Sarkara-p5l]

Exemption ki limit increase , additional deduction, taxes on farmers whose annual income is above average might be good solution

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

@curiousshiv भाई इतनी तकलीफ है सरकारी नौकरी में तो छोड़ दे

[@abhisheksoni303]

85% tax money is looted by the Politicians and bureaucrat's. That's why Education, healthcare and infrastructure is collapsing

[@TheYellowshuttle]

Agree with this video 💯% ❤. Intent is the problem. For example: 1. Constructing parliament building - 2yrs. Metros 15-20 yrs (still not complete). 2. Income tax website - always works, advance technology, finds out every bit of savings which even your family didn't know.😅 Other govt websites - 404 Error!😐 India chased away the British hoping for a better life. But now our people want to migrate to the West for a better life. How ironic!

[@bhagyesh_knowledgecity]

मेरा भारत महान... अब ये बोलणे मे कोई गर्व मेहसूस नहीं होता... बल्की बुरा लागता हे कि कैसा देश हे ये जहाँ खुद का कामाया पैसा बिना वजे सरकार कोण देना पडता हे... और बदले मे कुछ मिलता भी नहीं

[@globalcurrentaffairs8927]

Why government didn't published JUNE month GST collection data😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@pinakbuddhadev5413]

Because of Rajashahi 😂

[@Shabbir1277]

Because it's reducing.

[@storytellinghindi1111]

Worst finance minister ever 🤬🤬🤬🤬

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@burnermalaya]

They are trying best to make india the worst country to live

[@Hindustaani-r3y]

Dusre country jao bhai​@@idigitalbhilwara8797

[@Hindustaani-r3y]

Abhi pention band kr diya jaye to fir yahi German youtuber video bnane lg jayenge aur bolenge sarkar aise h waise h

[@Hindustaani-r3y]

Finance minister ab kharab ho gye aur jo development ho rha h o to dusre desh ke liye ho rha h bas phone utha ke bolne me asan hota lekin jo us jagh rhta h usko pta rhta h

[@NirmalaRebello]

Such a sensible video! Hope someone in high places takes the trouble to watch it and share it!

[@basantitanga3631]

Can anyone explain why a farmer earning more than 7 lacs should not pay tax while anyone earning the same from any other profession has to pay tax.

[@arshmumtaz4205]

Because we are politically, socially emotional fool 😂

[@gurdeepsingh2837]

Because what will you eat if they stop producing food? Agriculture is far tougher than you think. You might manage without many things, but not without food. So, respect the farmers who put food on your table despite being grossly underpaid (with no proper MSP!).

[@manfromdownunder8407]

​@@gurdeepsingh2837it is hard for poor farmers, Rich can afford machinary and credits!

[@basantitanga3631]

@@gurdeepsingh2837 you will also die if Doctors stop treatment. Miners stop mining all material required for our daily life. Your next generation will be helpless if teachers stop teaching and milkman stop working. The economy will collapse if banks stop working. Etc etc...... everybody's work is important, so why should farmers be given undue privilege????

[@basantitanga3631]

@@gurdeepsingh2837 I can live without what farmers produce. Milk, egg, chicken, meat, fruits are all taxable farming. I can live on these items. So farmers are getting extra privileges in india.

[@darshan_v_rock]

First they should remove this undeserving Nirmala from Financial minister post, she is the most undeserving person to sit in that post.

[@Lovely-dl5cw]

India doesn't have any future for Middle-class, Women, Youth 😢😢😢

[@deepjanideep]

Agree to each & every line you said, this is too much for middle class citizens paying taxes. Govt. can't abolish unfair rules to please farmers to save their govt. but when tax paying citizens rise up there won't be any govt left to follow the institution.

[@prashanthgowdagr]

Fyi- Bengaluru is still considered as non metro for HRA.

[@MrPrince750]

Even Hyderabad as well.

[@rajanverma1885]

Stupid things

[@mehulgohel2363]

They see middle class as foolish, because middle class still voting current rulling party😅

[@jaikrishnaullal7776]

You said the right thing. They know we middle class are duffers and can be easily swayed by the Hindu Muslim thing

[@samindian4987]

I will say just one thing - "Your video is nothing short of Perfection" 👏👏👌💯

[@Yalla_Habibi_Cat1]

N. Sitaraman is worst finance minister of India. 😢

[@tusharmore7801]

0 Tax is not practical. But yes kam zarur hona chahiye..

[@somnathgiri356]

I have waited enough now I will vote for NOTA

[@LryuzakiLN]

Welcome to the group my fella citizen, and offcourse NOTA doesn't do any good even if it has majority of votes, that's just a failback "Shishtaaaam" for the corrupt govt 😅

[@ansaritw]

I have always voted NOTA

[@curiosityideaunlimited2779]

My suggestion : 1% tax on 0.6 lakh to 3 lakh income [All type of income including Agriculture income and business income] and provide Free Term insurance coverage of 15 lakh life cover and Health insurance coverage of 3 lakh for one year and tax pay not compulsory upto 3 lakh. 2% tax on 3 lakh to 10 lakh income [All type of income including Agricultureand business income]. Above 10 lakh income 10% tax [2% tax on 3 lakh to 20 lakh on Agriculture income and 10% tax on Above 20 lakh Agriculture income and business income]

[@WeThinkPunjab]

India tax🗿🗿 Infrastructure 🤡🤡

[@keyurshah6298]

The biggest scam in India is terming farmers as "Ann Daata" (provider of food). Why are they not seen as regular businessmen? While it is true that farmers face significant risks due to unforeseen events, there are insurance mechanisms in place to mitigate these risks. When businesses incur losses, the government doesn't typically intervene to prevent bankruptcy. So why is there an exception for farmers? Every year, substantial subsidies are provided to the agriculture sector, and loans are frequently waived off, burdening taxpayers. Agriculture is a business and should be treated as such. No one is "Ann Daata"; no one is feeding my family unless I earn money and pay these so-called "Ann Daata." Additionally, why aren't taxes imposed on farmers with an annual income exceeding 1 crore? Wealthier farmers still benefit from subsidies meant for the deprived classes. This unfair advantage needs to be addressed to ensure a more equitable distribution of resources.

[@bravikumar8950]

Good report. 👍👍👍

[@1carusGG]

As someone who voted for BJP, I 100% agree with these points. However I do believe that a bigger reason for this war on the middle class is the whole welfare and reservation system. The government is a coward when it comes to implementing meritocracy, because if they do so, half the country will come down to protest. An internal strife is the last thing that any democratic government needs, especially in a country like India, which gets targeted and ridiculed by western nations on a daily basis.

[@Manish__1306-e4y]

ok paar main mudha services nhi hai even after taxing

[@idigitalbhilwara8797]

मेरा मित्र सरकारी नौकरी में है... मुझे बोलता है की तू private ओर business में मेहनत कर और tax भर मेरी पेंशन के लिए, मेरी सेलरी के लिए तू 1 साल में 4 -6 महीने मेरी लिए ही तो काम कर रहा है.. सोसाइटी और समाज मुझ पर हंसता है .... तुम कमा किस के लिए रहे हो ... जाओ सरकारी नौकरी करो .. ...i feel guilty in this country😢

[@HappyBabyOctopus-qu6mf]

And they themselves are tired of it​@TanjiroKamado-ih5xt

[@1carusGG]

​@TanjiroKamado-ih5xt Tell me with a straight face that the amount of reservation that exists in India, isn't holding the country back. I'm an SC and even I stand against reservation. It is an archaic constitutional clause that promotes divide and demotes merit. The ONLY reason to even have a reservation, is to bridge economic divides, rather than being caste based, which is the case with Indian reservation. You call me a BJP supporter for going against reservation, I call you a hypocrite to not see the destruction that its causing the country. Three things that we don't need: 1. Caste based reservation and quotas 2. Income taxes for people earning below 30L. 3. End of government welfare schemes (freebies).

[@vidyanagarajan9135]

​@TanjiroKamado-ih5xtIt has been by US Supreme Court. Infact you are blind.

[@Rajesh13087]

Worst Taxtaion in the world with zero facilities