Why Pink Pearl Was Replaced By Spinel and Pearl! (Steven Universe: the Movie Theory)

[@RoundtableVids]

Why do you think Pink Pearl was replaced? STEAMBOAT SPINELLY: teespring.com/steambot-spinelly THUMBNAIL ART BY ARTWITHKODA: artwithkoda.tumblr.com/ instagram.com/artwithkoda/ kzbin.info/door/zNnvLLuJ7qhu1c9-_d5oKg

[@justiceprice836]

Hey

[@_Kesh__rko]

No I think Pink diamond did something wrong then got pink pearl Taken away then She was given our pearl

[@wrdgaf]

Love the artwork

[@deshawnedwards6412]

Thank you Pink Diamond, you doom the planet!

[@guiguygaming1844]

That shirt is amazing I think it's great you monetize other people's creations 😁😁😁

[@hornyluvsickness]

White Diamond to Steven: "you are all we have left from pink!" Pink Pearl: "Am i a joke to you?"

[@valentinevonboo]

_ Snowman _ what if pink pearl left when her mind control was broken

[@-Genki]

Coughcough her bubbles,the human zoo coughcough

[@valentinevonboo]

Blue and yellow pearl stayed because they weren’t under mind control. pink pearl was abused. so I understand her completely if she left

[@hornyluvsickness]

@@valentinevonboo idk... she still a pearl. our pearl only became "independent" bc of Pink's encouragement and the gem war...

[@WyxienTheFox]

@@hornyluvsickness Except blue pearl and yellow pearl are also independent now, but they still stayed on Homeworld

[@ChangDaChun]

Why does it feel like pink pearls story will be sadder than spinels

[@aiiiia9971]

It would probably be really sad too, but they might also relate to eachother, which is cool.

[@juhlsghouls]

She’s the only gem with a scar that we know of, they gotta explain and see if Steven can can heal her

[@Logomachy]

I’d say it is worse than spinels because spinel was actually herself, pink pearl did stuff for thousands of years she didn’t know of

[@thatpersonineverycommentse2195]

pink diamond probably did something really bad and then blamed it on pink pearl

[@mista-jay]

KiNg_ KaMbInG knowing rebbeca sugar she won’t even elaborate about the character 🙄

[@maizstars]

It’s because Pink was actually treating pink pearl like a friend and not a servant.

[@orangesfpop]

Oh yeah and by the rules that is unprohibited :0

[@themagnificentorange672]

Spot on and i think thats what he said

[@mishaforeverx3187]

That is kinda true....

[@aiiiia9971]

True :(

[@maizstars]

Bruhflovski lol. I think Pink got tired because she thought Spinel was childish, and Pink had to act mature since she had he own colony.

[@kuroneko9167]

Plot twist: pink diamond lost passion for spinel because she reminds her of pink pearl.

[@johnnysalery7383]

Kanna Chan Pretty much! And I think the reason why she tricked Spinel into waiting was because she knew Spinel would've followed her regardless of the situation. The same way Spinel follows Steven around without his permission until later on.

[@onyxtreme]

aight ima head out.

[@funnivamp55]

Wha-

[@rosykindbunny1313]

I'm gonna cry

[@everyonessunshine]

That’s not really a plot twist but I agree with you :D

[@whitneyl.1856]

When Spinel finds out *SHE'S* the "other woman."

[@jellygachaboo8124]

When she realizes thes the side chick

[@redrocket2880]

She was the Other Friend all along

[@peridotcipher2109]

Other gem

[@lemonadecrushedice]

“Side bitch”

[@Hiroto340]

She was the other friend

[@Lisey91]

I always through that our Pearl wasn’t a pink pearl but was made by the diamonds. Her designs is not just pink, but white, yellow and blue. Her skin is white, the others diamonds pearls skin is the a really light blue or yellow colour. She dress is yellow and blue clothes, while none of the other pearls “stray” from her master colour. So, if the theory is correct, and she actually been customise by the other diamonds for keeping Pink more in check. And we can even see in which way! White made her organised and elegant. Blue made her emphatic and caring. Yellow made her strong and able to fight.

[@GwenKalash]

that is actually smart of you good theory dude

[@jayaaaa._]

Lisa DellaValle i always thought this too! it makes the most sense considering the color scheme of all gems or pearls in this case

[@josephbojarski2536]

Woah cool theory

[@lisetteiona1028]

also since the pearls gem location correlate to their diamonds, pearl’s gem on her forehead could be white.

[@jacoblol901]

your theory makes so much sense bro

[@angsilaw]

If Spinel and our Pearl fused, would they act like Pink Pearl?

[@valentinevonboo]

RavenousRetro no, garnet was the first fusion pink diamond saw

[@joelreed7212]

@@valentinevonboo ACT, not be.

[@angsilaw]

Zackery Sinclair What do you mean?

[@angsilaw]

Axt im Walde I still don’t get how they even got Garnet out of it. Haha

[@legowhite2]

Zackery thought you guys meant Pearl and Spinel WERE Pink Pearl and that they were the first fusion Pink Diamond saw

[@selenerose1988]

"it's all fun and games until someone loses an eye." This is what I think happened.

[@mooncrumble9036]

"you'll shoot your eye out" Possibly pink got a shotgun and started playing with Pink Pearl

[@cutiebee123]

😂

[@The_Dud3-is_C00L]

Selene Rose was that the ruby with one eye (eyeball)

[@what-jani-ano6668]

Everybody gangsta till somebody loses an eye

[@kae4993]

Pink got so angry at the other diamonda and lost control sooo pink pearl was the nearest to her so she got hit

[@Kai_Equine]

Pink pearl as already told her side of her cracked eye ,she said that Pink Diamond had a fit and ended up like screaming and pink pearl was too close! So yes Pink Diamond is the cause of Pink Peals eye cracking

[@vivalapluto2501]

While you aren't wrong at all, this video was posted LONG before that episode-

[@lullabysorrow5746]

kind of wish it wasn't like that, but instead White Diamond teaching Pink a lesson about how reckless behavior leads to "little unwanted accidents". It would of made White diamond so much more intimidating, but with a show about hugging being the god cure for everything can't keep expectations too high, or any at all.

[@shaina899]

@@lullabysorrow5746 I like that it was Pink, because Pink was a young child. Impetuous, irrational, prone to "tantrums" (which they talk about in Future). Small children are selfish and callous--they break things and hurt people with little to no remorse because they don't know any better. They can't comprehend much outside of themselves, and they often don't understand their own emotions or how to control them. As we grow, we mature, and we become aware of the world around us and how we affect it, but Pink never had that--she was literally made smaller than the others, and Gems don't grow. At most, you could say that Rose was a young adolescent by the time she met Greg, and was just starting to get a hint of maturity when she gave up her form to have Steven. But even that was a decision she made without regard to what effect her absence would have on the rest.

[@sarahpickle1913]

I always thought that Pink Pearl was trying to console PD when PD completely lost it, turned on Pink Pearl, punched her in the eye, Pink Pearl poofed as the fist made contact, PD freaked out and showed White, White replaced Pink Pearl, took over Pink Pearl, and Pink Pearl regenerated as the new White pearl. With a permanant injury. Either that or she reformed as PINK Pearl, and tried to defend PD, but White wouldn't excuse PD's actions this time, and, defeated, Pink Pearl was taken over by White as PD was forced to watch. And once Pink Pearl became White pearl, WD probably said something to Pink that made her feel even more guilty. All in all the experience probably had her sobered up for when our Pearl showed up.

[@l0v3rb0y_xoxo5]

Hold on a sec i dont remember that happening ;-;

[@Local_Clownn]

I love how he said “pink pearl, OUR pearl and spinel”

[@milliesbiggestfan]

c o m m u n i s t p e a r l

[@marczyair2881]

@@milliesbiggestfan t h a t s w h a t i t h o u g h t

[@hi-wy7ph]

@@minecraftfnafsbrp5194 I M G A Y

[@matineeman3038]

@@hi-wy7ph c o n g r a t s

[@fastbear9681]

*trumpet sound* soyuz

[@kanatsu6609]

Spinel: "exists" Pink Pearl: *You Dare Oppose Me Mortal*

[@s_caesar]

@【S】【p】【i】【n】【e】【l】 tf

[@susanharrison4162]

Lol

[@chaospigeon2319]

Nah bro thats my cinnamonroll she would never say that

[@hachuwa]

Plot twist: Pink pearl gave Spinel the injector and rejuvenator

[@abluerainbow]

Actually. That'd make sense. Considering she was also left behind by Pink Diamond >.>

[@devongene9584]

oh shit

[@Bobalu89]

I've been thinking for a while that Pink Pearl is going to be the next villain in the series.

[@ernestlam5632]

Pink pearl and Spinel team up and/or fusion villain. A Joker like villian.

[@sumeiyahsyeda9386]

Yeah I was thinking of the same thing. Like the injector and rejuvenate are just things pink diamond left behind

[@cggrizzlyb92hd35]

Pink Pearl did nothing wrong honestly. Pink Pearl doesn't deserve trash.

[@Ruby-Doc]

*_[Extremely true]_*

[@m.ivyluna4632]

cgGrizzlyB92HD We dont know what happened yet honestly For all we know whatever happened was Pink Pearl’s fault Probably not because she was a servant and all but honestly who knows Im not making any more calls on who is good/evil on this show 😂 Everyone is gray lol

[@Ruby-Doc]

@Sapphire *_[I agree, your clarity ❖]_*

[@Jos3jmsfkl]

Except she does

[@horrorterrorharvey]

cgGrizzlyB92HD I read that as pink diamond for a second and I was like *mmm, bitch what?*

[@MaxRanIn2aWall]

The crewniverse should work on mini-series similar to “Steven Universe: Future” called “Steven Universe: the beginning “ and it could show pinks life and what happened before Steven in more detail

[@flossiecarter5409]

YES YES YES YES

[@tired_birb7241]

Yeah your right

[@denyraw]

Yeah but it would have a lot of timeskips because main events are thousands of years apart

[@anniepark6694]

MaxRanIn2aWall Yes, I want to know what happened before Steven and before the rebellion more.

[@jayaaaa._]

MaxRanIn2aWall YES and how Steven even came into existence. i want to know it alllll

[@fandomtrash6016]

By the time Pink grew and became Rose it was too late. Pink didnt care about other gems, only the earth, but Rose saw that her rebellion was something that could free other gems. Pink Diamond left Spinel in the garden, but im sure Rose Quartz would've gone back for her if she could.

[@Kagome3lover14]

After watching the movie I kind of thought this: Pink Diamond thought of Spinell as a toy or just a brainless gem specifically designed to like her. She probably thought of Spinell as an embodiment of all her childish flaws and was secretly annoyed and angry with her. She knew that if she wanted a colony (which to her would mean to be respected as a true Diamond) she would have to leave all her childish behavior and her "toy" behind. It kind of explains why she could leave Spinell so easily. She may have liked her at first but you can see the tiredness in her eyes after a while and the slight frustration and anger at Spinell/ her childish self. I also thought that this is why she didn't fall in love with our pearl; she knew pearl was free but knew deep down that pearl was designed to at the very least respect/ care for her and that any feelings our pearl would have for her would stem from that, which would cause Pink Diamond to not completely trust her feelings. (And now that I think on it , is probably why she fell for Greg who not only isn't programmed, but also teaches her about love.) Sorry that was so long, I just needed to get that out my head finally. Thank you if you actually read all that.

[@beegreimoo3440]

I like this opinion

[@beegreimoo3440]

And is now my headcanon

[@slimetime9985]

Your welcome

[@Amentiople]

Poor myself

[@crazypanda-wy7ws]

Dam that's deep

[@HYPERPLASMATIER]

Pink pearl was goofy like spinel, But pearls shouldn't be emotional at all-- They should be Obedient little walking computers/cabinets. She was replaced by a new pearl, However the diamonds recognize that pink pearl's goofiness helped occupy her. So they made spinel to keep pink diamond out of their hair when she got bored.

[@ooferssixtynine4232]

That seems alot more realistic

[@edwardmccabe5447]

And maybe it came with limitations like she's not aloud leave the garden

[@leafythesylveon8220]

150 or more to see yes im the 150 like so rip ditto

[@kaylayes3308]

Her cut is perfect and she’s *pink as well* COINCIDENCE I THINK NOT

[@Dakotayes1426]

Zsazsa LPS she means pink Diamond is pink

[@iagotorres8903]

@Zsazsa LPS what @McKayla W means is that Spinel is pink like pink pearl, and when pearl said that was like if she was programmed to convince Steven (at the time pink diamond) that Spinel will be as good as friend as pink pearl.

[@atomic9145]

She does belong to pink diamond

[@furrypupsangel5446]

@@iagotorres8903 now that you point it out she did sing, “Your new best friend Spinel.” That means that they were probably made at the same time and confirms that Spinel was made to be Pink’s best friend though the artificial friendship wouldn’t last.

[@pikachuplayz7808]

Pink diamond leaves spinel in the garden for 6000 years Fandom: OH MY GOSH YOUR SO TERRIBLE gems leave lapis in mirror for 5000 years Fandom: we forgive you!

[@stevenuniversevideos144]

Well pink diamond did do bad things then that she left spinel she lied to all the diamonds and gems that she got shattered and That she was rose quartz this whole time, So I do think the fandom should not forgive her. 🙂

[@raaragonite]

@@stevenuniversevideos144 But what about all the other horrible things the diamonds did? Corrupt gems,Shatter,collect the pieces to make a weapon,etc.But an opinion is an opinion so I respect yours😃

[@yan-bc5sb]

when people defend the other diamonds I literally get a headache, and I agree with the lapis thing.

[@stevenuniversevideos144]

The Hybrids They learned there ways they know not to do it now Pink started a whole WAR she was very mean but as rose quartz she was nice but I think The 3 diamonds are nicer than her White,, Yellow, And blue Is way nicer than pink diamond.

[@pikachuplayz7808]

Gacha SushiRollei ok pink did do a lot bad things but the other diamonds litterally killed entire planets, shattered gems, they made an colony based on military and not allowing them to love who ever they want but pink she changed that she tried to do good and save earth and she kept protecting it by giving life to Steven he changed every thing he brought the diamonds together! (No hate on your opinion)

[@CatWolf_Gacha]

The Diamonds: "Come live with us in the palace." The Diamonds: "There's a room waiting for you." "Come On" "Come On" "Come On" *The Diamonds look at pink pearl* *"Just let us forget you"* *Like to help save pearls just like pink..today*

[@stannersboyle1093]

I think it's closer to a broken memento, best leave it to the owner. Spinel is like a souvenir and pink pearl is like a phone. They don't need an extra pearl to cause jealousy but pink wasn't found of the souvenir they provided so it was no problem taking it back.

[@janeenstalnaker8395]

Pink Pearl:😐 Who do you think you are?

[@seoul6327]

Last time I was this early, pink diamond and spinel were still playing a game in the garden😣💔

[@Palliser99]

I doubt your 6000 years old

[@seoul6327]

Palli - Playz that’s the joke.....

[@Noah-hx9oi]

@@seoul6327 EwE FoRtNiTe

[@Palliser99]

Kammi Unicorn and I'm also making a joke

[@seoul6327]

Dantezzy Games you play- nvm😂😂😂

[@hannah.7768]

"If you love somebody. Let them go, for if they return, they were always yours. And if they don't, they never were." - Kahlil Gibran

[@Mimimimi-uz6jv]

Yup

[@whitneyl.1856]

Pink Pearl: *exists* Spinel: "Who the hell is this?" 😠

[@blueheart039]

Your next wife

[@redbllits3981]

blueheart039 yesh!

[@welcometoowo8446]

Spinel it’s your soulmate

[@williamroman5187]

Don't woire Spinel you are the better one

[@milliesbiggestfan]

@@blueheart039 *our* next wife

[@FlamedancerStudio]

6:23 her eye was pink diamond, pink diamond asked white for a colony and white said no, so pink lost it. And cracked pink pearls eye.

[@HonestlySpeaking028]

Not on purpose of course😂😅

[@0rangeeige199]

What if the mirror that Pink shattered while stevonnie was dreaming was a representation of volletball's eyes

[@SoftshellTaco19]

@@0rangeeige199 it most likely wasnt, since later after the dream, stevonnie sees the cracked window.

[@dayandere2669]

Comment section: "Our Pearl was definitely White's" Rebecca Sugar: "I'm about to end this man's whole career"

[@xanderschmidt9361]

I still think she was White's pearl first. The first time she booted up must have been with White, the second time she was rebooted and given to Pink, and then the third time she's rebooted was in the movie

[@dayandere2669]

@@xanderschmidt9361 It's been deconfirmed by Rebecca Sugar. So whatever floats your boats, but it's 100% not the case

[@NoName-xm8oc]

@@dayandere2669 well, but who was the ACTUAL white pearl the first? Interesting..

[@yny045]

No Name Since White Diamond is superior I feel like she wouldn’t have a Pearl. She is quite capable of things so our Pearl is probably an extra just in case for the higher ranking gems (morganite and the Pearl from Rhodinite)

[@MattRealest]

I think our pearl was whites because if u notice where each pearls gem is placed they match their diamonds and look at where our pearls gem matches where white diamonds gem is there fore she most likely is

[@MewDenise]

Spinel wasn't replaced as the new Pink Diamond who is gonna sit on the throne. She will do what she is meant to do. Be a friend and entertainment

[@nyamaynyam]

But I’m to busy keeping gems sane I don’t have that much time for the diamonds sadly

[@billmcdonald8011]

I believe Steven is the new pink diamond.

[@cosmog9310]

Exactly! I have no idea where this replacement talk is coming from. The diamonds took Spinel in, but that doesn't mean Steven is losing his spot among the diamond leaders.

[@billmcdonald8011]

Cosmog he literally pink diamond(because of is gem) so obviously he is gonna be the new diamond

[@tater4442]

You’re best Friend sipnel you misspelled *spinel

[@forever.rendeavor]

I'm hoping and praying that we get a story arc of pink pearl

[@taykumori]

MY TIMELINE COMPREHENSION: . . . ~Pink Pearl was taken by White, for misbehaving with Pink Diamond ~Pink Diamond is granted two new gems, Spinel and Pearl ~Pink Diamond plays with Spinel in the garden ... and conducts Diamond duties with Pearl ~Pink Diamond is finally granted a colony, abandons Spinel in the garden ~Pink Diamond and Pearl colonized Earth, builds a relationship, and rebels. . . Meanwhile, Spinel is still waiting for Pink Diamond's return and Pink Pearl becomes White's Pearl. side note .... have you guys noticed that the garden looks like its sitting on a planet ~ but destroyed ... that's probably how Spinel got the idea.

[@guilhermerafaelzimermann4196]

The video actually mentions that last bit about the planet And yeah, it kinda looks like a piece of an old colony that either was almost completely used up, or simply got ripped out of the planet during the time it was active, since we do see other discarded old colony's husks in the sky in that scene

[@taykumori]

@ yeah that too🖤🖤thx

[@ValerianSantosa]

I think it was more suitable to say that White has swapped her pear with pink's pearl. Judging from our pearl's ultra-perfectionist trait and the colour pallet which mostly pale white (maybe some blue and pink additions come after she was owned by Pink).

[@riantozier4532]

i agree with most, other than the diamond granting spinel, spinel was designed for jokes and games. the diamonds wanted everyone to be serious and proper, so i think that spinel was a gem that pink made, or a gem that was born in a kindergarten, or some other way.

[@ernestc5641]

I think Pearl is actually White’s Pearl. If she wasn’t around Pink, then Pearl would be extremely uptight about the rules and perfection, a lot like how White is. Blue and Yellow both have pearls that are physically and mentally similar to them, and White is clearly missing a Pearl, so it’s only make sense that our Pearl was White’s.

[@pinkmario0]

Where is our pearls gem? her head where. is whites gem?

[@wargeneral0659]

@@rachmae4180 yep

[@0rangeeige199]

This makes sense she would give her well behaved, motherly pearl to pink to have a better influence

[@Gregory-cz7tu]

This comment didn't age well huh?

[@ernestc5641]

@@Gregory-cz7tu It was neither confirmed nor denied even after Future, so it aged the same way it began: as a thought. It’s just as plausible as it was before, we’ll just never know because it’s a detail that happened eons ago.

[@HonestlySpeaking028]

6:15 pink pearl explains what happened to her in season 5, in the episode "volleyball". She said"when pink diamond got tired of ask yellow and blue for her own colony she went straight to white, When white refused pink got mad and through tantrums", apparently at that time pink pearl was standing to close to pink diamond and got hurt. I'm guessing the same thing happens to steven in the future episodes every time he turns pink.

[@yarie9210]

look at the pearls gem placements. yellow and blue gems and their placements match up w their pearls. the gem placement for our pearl matches up w whites’ gem. white rebooted her pearl to give to pink. the reboot that happened in the movie was the 2nd bc when you make file copies it goes like (file, file (2), file (3)) my english isn’t great, i hope it made sense

[@shuu0707]

True 🤔

[@MakotoWright]

Actually your logic is false. It is the 3rd reboot because file is one, file2 is two, file3 is three

[@urmomlovesme811]

@@MakotoWright yes, so file 1 was when she was with white, file 2 rebooted to pink, file 3 rebooted to greg

[@Paimordial]

bee IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOWWWW

[@anniepark6694]

bee I guess that sort of makes sense. After all, we're in the third era now, right? So maybe it has nothing to do with anybody's contact, rather that every time there's a new era, the gems automatically get rebooted. I don't know, just a theory. To be honest, this whole thing has flipped at least half of my SU understanding upside down, so I have no idea.

[@onlynadia6724]

I love Steven universe honestly I just got into the show at the start of the summer Edit: mainly bc my brother asked me to watch it

[@Palliser99]

Your brother is very smart

[@tee-p6f]

ha ive been watching since it started, 2013

[@Woopersolo]

Tyler Arnold 2014

[@Ruby-Doc]

*_[I've been watching since 2013, December 2nd aka since bubble buddies]_*

[@motehz]

Been watching since it started, it honestly has always been a good show.

[@JunDageki]

As for why Pink Pearl face was cracked, remember Steven's dream where Pink Diamond punches and cracks a "mirror"? when gems are cracked their eyes can become like a mirror (see Lapiz and Pink Pearl) that is all.

[@dayandere2669]

But like... Pink Pearl's gem isn't cracked

[@CrazyAnimeGirl8D]

But her eye was cracked. Eyes are the mirror to the soul after all.

[@dayandere2669]

@@CrazyAnimeGirl8D... You stating that gives nothing to this comment

[@SonniDez]

Oof.

[@anamariamalo]

Pink probably punched Pearl in an attempt to free her from White's control, or as an act of rage when White was taking her away.

[@josephbojarski2536]

The reason pink pearl has a cracked eye is because pink diamond was having a tantrum and accidentally hit pink pearl with her powers, so white diamond took pink pearl away from pink diamond. I'm from the future

[@soupernova396]

Hello fellow person from the future

[@josephbojarski2536]

@@soupernova396 hello!

[@Monkey-081hs]

Hello from way in the future.👋

[@HorrorFan567]

Hello, from way, WAY into the future!

[@laneyfaulkner1040]

I figure that the scar that Pink Pearl got was from Pink Diamond, when it happened White Diamond scolded her, Pink Pearl was permanently ostracized for her scratch, Looking down on Pink Diamond for recklessness and injury of Pink Pearl, White Diamond fixed it by giving her a new Pearl, permanently changed from seeking fun. Spinel was her toy to make her happy but her sadness came from being reminded her fun hurt her best friend and abandoned her, resuming her duties. 1000 years go by with the new Pearl and her 'controlled' playfulness gave her some freedom to explore her 'childhood' again, when she realized that Humans was like her she wanted to protect them, starting a rebellion. When Bismith offered to destroy her family she bubbled her. ect... It explains why she went from Playfulness to her Seriousness, her desire to run away, her weapon of choice- to poof gems but never hurt or crack them, why her tears or saliva could cure Lapis's broken gem. she felt bad that her play caused the Diamonds to believe that Pink Diamond was shattered and seek retaliation. It is a story of Pink Diamond growing up and maturing. White Diamond as the mother, Yellow and Blue Diamond as her protective aunts.

[@ShankiaMrsRidiculous]

Wow that does make perfect sense to why Pink Diamond left Spinel in the garden. Pink could only play with Spinel in that garden so when she left to go colonize earth I don't think she knew she wasn't coming back. Woooow okay.

[@darkmystery5731]

Good point!

[@sqitspanders9057]

she has big shoes and acts like a kid at recess SPINEL MORE LIKE SPINELLI!!!!!

[@keepsmilinglittlemax1244]

Sqit Games AND THEY HAVE PIGTAILS

[@nyamaynyam]

Honestly I want cotton candy garnet back she was so nice to me

[@snowflakeserpert6834]

@@nyamaynyam I thought you never met Cotton Candy Garnet until after she reset?

[@p0l4r0ids3]

@@nyamaynyam did you meet Aquamarine yet?????

[@Rainbowdragonzs]

My friends: spinel Me: SPINAL

[@danielsegres7086]

Did everyone notice that when spinel region a little bit of her memories that she grew a little bit

[@MJYoutubers]

but shes elastic so i mean....

[@sleeplesssincat]

I have a feeling telling how Pink diamond had acted throughout the series I think Pink diamond had started to mature overtime compared to how Spinel was DESIGNED to be immature and playfull all the time and when Pink noticed this she left thinking of Spinel as immature.

[@spinel3435]

Rebecca stated that OUR Pearl originally belongs with Pink Diamond,BUT White Diamond had a part in the creation of Pearl. At SDCC comic-con panel 2019

[@Mr.Buxaplenty]

The diamonds took everything away from pink that was “fun” from her and she maybe left spinel to show the diamonds that she was mature Edit: if pink came back which I think that’s impossible🤔 I wonder what she would think of the new rules,changes.

[@rickrollrizal2364]

Pink would have to leave Spinel because Spinel would give Pink's disguise away especially if they find Spinel on the battlefield with Rose. Spinel was originally a non combatant so she would be useless and a distraction. Given Rose had her hands full with the war, rescuing Spinel wouldn't be a good idea. Even during the peace after the war and Pink's shattering, using the personal warp pad would tell the diamond's that Pink is alive. And why would the crystal gems attack spinel?

[@naolucillerandom5280]

@@rickrollrizal2364 But at the time she abandoned Spinel, Pink hadn't even visited Earth yet.

[@rickrollrizal2364]

@@naolucillerandom5280 true. But looking at the montage, I can see Blue admonishing Pink. What if she was telling her not to bring Spinel because she would be a distraction in making the colony?

[@asteriastars6757]

@@rickrollrizal2364 I know right?

[@lifegen1927]

@@rickrollrizal2364 the warp was broken though

[@CarlosPerez-ie3oq]

Probably white shot her beam at her eye accidentaly

[@sauce4279]

Didn't damage Yellow or Blue diamond OR Garnet Amethyst or Pearl.

[@CarlosPerez-ie3oq]

@@sauce4279it's because she shot their gems not there phisical forms

[@sauce4279]

@@CarlosPerez-ie3oq okay...? Why didn't she do the same with pink pearl, then? If she wanted her out of commission, but still accessible to brainwash, she would have done the same with the diamonds, since I'd assume 2 diamonds are a bigger threat than a pearl.

[@CarlosPerez-ie3oq]

@@sauce4279 well ya but it's still just a theory and if it this does become cannon it will probably be explained in the show or even by Rebecca sugar herself

[@andrewt329]

After Spinel, I'm pretty sure that Pink Pearl's eye is the result of something Pink did instead of White. Before they made it seem like White took Pink Pearl away because they thought she was a bad influence on her. However, now that we know about Spinel that theory no longer makes much sense. Why would White take Pink's pearl away for acting childish and then turn around a give her a gem that's WAY more childish than her Pearl was? Long story short, I think Pink screwed up and damaged Pink Pearl, so White Diamond "fixed" her and gave Pink Spinel to placate the incredibly upset Pink Diamond.

[@poknberry5795]

This theory makes total sense. After the diamonds realized Pink's playful habits weren't going to go away, they gave her the garden as a temporary solution. I assume that once she got the colony she wanted so much she decided to not be so playful and take things more seriously, deciding to leave Spinnel, and not finding it much of a difficult decision since it was an artificial relationship in the first place. Still gotta feel bad for her though, she accidentally scars her best friend so White decides to take over her body. Im super curious to know what the hell exactly happened though, as of now we know of nothing that can scar a gem without damaging the gemstone. Also kinda makes me wonder if White didnt have her own pearl originally as well? Any particular reason for that?

[@Robofrog100]

she probably used to have one, and discarded it when she took pinks. after all, shes not exactly compasionate or caring when we meet her.

[@poknberry5795]

@@Robofrog100 Well yea but I cant imagine White would have to kill the poor thing just to take on Pink Pearl. I'd sooner expect White to just have two pearls.

[@nomorepikachu]

i still think that our pearl was initially white pearl. otherwise the fact that she was booted 3 times just seems too random to me?

[@Angryginger2421]

@@nomorepikachu I agree with you

[@zaclegoattack]

Elijah - I agree, maybe she took Pink’s and booted her pearl to become OUR pearl. The rule of gemstone placement doesn’t seem to contradict this (though we have only seen 3 instances of it)

[@gemtasticdiamond8855]

PD left Spinel in the garden because she realized how silly she was so she didn't want to goof off because Earth meant a lot to her

[@asteriastars6757]

Why did I just read this while hearing Garnet's voice?

[@baraxor]

There are essentially two Pink Diamonds, who existed at different times although having the same gemstone: Bratty Pink, and "Rose Quartz". Something happened to PD that changed her from an impulsive, violent entity with the mind of a six-year-old human, to one with the intelligence and conscience strong enough to wage a successful rebellion to protect this planet and its inhabitants. From the episode "Volleyball", we now know that Pink Pearl was permanently scarred by a force blast from Pink, done out of venting at the Diamonds in her frustration but which caught Pink Pearl inadvertently. From Steven's Homeworld dream we know that Pink Pearl and her mistress had no problems between each other, so that Pink Pearl was willing to help PD keep her un-Diamond-like pastimes concealed from Yellow Diamond's spying. This sort "bad behavior" was probably the reason that Pink Pearl was taken away from PD. Our Pearl only knew the more mature and self-controlled version of Pink Diamond, the form that was the result of PD's upgrade. Ironically, that upgrade proved counter-productive as far as the Diamond Authority was concerned, because while they got rid of an imbecile of a Diamond, they unwittingly replaced her with one capable of turning against them and their entire social order. I find it difficult to believe that Spinel was added to Pink's court after the upgrade, when Pink was expected to play her part as a full member of the Diamond Authority. Perhaps Pink knew that Spinel was always going to be more loyal to the Diamond Authority than to her personally...why she wasn't taken away as Pink Pearl was...and that may have been a major reason Pink didn't want her on Earth, whether before she conceived the idea of rebellion or after. From TA and ASPR, we see that Pink Diamond had in succession two Pearls whom she trusted implicitly, and their loyalty was and is steadfast.

[@crystallantern]

Spinel fishing Steven away from the injector is like Steamboat Willy (I think that’s what it’s called) Edit: wow I’ve never had so many likes on a comment!

[@LukeDeGraff1]

It's injector

[@wulf768]

You have a point

[@crystallantern]

Lingering with Luke fixed it, thanks

[@rameezmayet8217]

What if Pink Pear was replaced because she resisted the rejuvenator (which left the scar) or she was rebooted so many times that she had to be replaced by our pearl and Spinel ?

[@loyina310]

*Pearl Lol

[@Jacob-xm6hg]

Well, thats a good theory

[@zana2587]

I think there’s a reason why Pearl had all the colors of the diamonds. I think she was modeled after all of the other Diamonds. Yellow, Pearl’s sense of structure, Blue, Pearl’s care for pleasing Pink and wanting to be there for her, and White, Pearl’s strive for perfection and order.

[@tera633]

Pearls seemed like a present for growing gems to me... I like the idea of Spinel being Pink's companion while she's growing, with Pink Pearl a gift afterwards as the diamonds try to teach pink diamond responsibility. The juggling scene could be our pink showing her Pearl stuff she learned from Spinel while also pretending to behave because "if you want to play, go to the garden, your pearl is meant for more important work". Dunno. Love the video!

[@lightninggacha7818]

This pearl won’t be able to encourage her Pearl: **makes it worst**

[@theoneandonlynutzley1946]

Pink: This is probably the best for her. Spinel 6,000 years later:ExCuSe Me WhAt ThE fUcK?!?!?!?!

[@The_Gidz]

The scarring on Pink Pearl was caused by White tho. That was in a past interview with Rebecca that you went over yourself

[@ambermoon2326]

I just realised that the Pearl's gem placement is in correspondance to their diamond, pink pearl as well. And yet our pearl has her gem on her head, like white diamond. Another connection that our pearl was like a babysitter for pink created by white to keep her in line

[@l4in44]

WD: I think PD needs someone to play with PD: no I- WD: here you go be greatful YD AND BD: 👁👄👁

[@raaragonite]

WD:Here you go,Starlight.Take it and don't say a word.

[@kyoten19]

Lmaoooo

[@temmiewithasmile2169]

Spinel could’ve been way different if Pink Diamond would just say “ Keep taking care of this garden, I’ll be back in a long time”

[@WhimsyFloof]

I think what probably happened has been hinted at in a few places in the series. Remember when Steven was talking to Yellow Pearl in Pink Diamond's room and kept playing around with what she was calling him, and Pearl interrupted with "Stop that. You'll break her."? This suggests that Pearls can be broken if handled too carelessly. Pearls are made to be obedient servants. That's what they're programmed to do. You know what else was made to be obedient and give its owner their every want? Rose's Room in the temple. Remember when Steven brought Connie in there and shenanigans made him hang out with a fake Connie that he accidentally broke by telling her to stop doing what he wants? I think something similar to that might've happened to Pink Pearl. Pink Diamond was way too careless in how she managed her Pearl, to the place where she ended up accidentally breaking her. Which, if she was truly friends with her Pearl like this suggests, would've completely broken her heart. White Diamond finds out that Pink has broken her Pearl, takes Pink Pearl away (and keeps her T-posed forever after) and replaces her with a new Pearl. This one, either is activated under the supervision of the other Diamonds so they make sure she's formed with only the default settings. OR Pink Diamond, not wanting to repeat what happened with her old Pearl, opted not to customize her. Leaving all the default settings. She doesn't make the same personal connection with this Pearl, or any other gem for that matter. She still needs a playmate tho, so that's how she got Spinel. The rest is history.

[@ericbrower611]

Seeing the way Spinel reacted whenever Steven tried separating himself from her, I can't help wondering how she would have reacted it Pink told her that play time was over 6000 years ago. So many want to condemn Pink for the choices she made. But few consider what the alternatives were to those choices. Yes, she bubbled Bismuth for thousands of years. But the alternative would have been shattering her. And Pink wasn't willing to do that. And yes, she kept the truth of that from the others. But the alternative was finding out how many others shared Bismuth's 'Eye for an eye, let's shatter ( re: kill) all upper class gems' philosophy. Hey, if you think I'm exaggerating, rewatch the 'Bismuth' episode, and pay attention to the way she speaks. She might as well have quoted from 'The Communist Manifesto '. Always talking about tearing down the upper crust system. The difference between Pink's goals and Bismuth's goals, was Pink wanted *independence* for Earthworld gems. Bismuth wanted a *revolution* . Pink's actions were *for* Earth gems, and all lower class gems. Bismuth's were *against* the upper crust gems. Especially Diamonds. And she wasn't going to let anyone stop her. Not even Rose. Everything pointed to Bismuth willing to use the Breaking Point to shatter Pink Diamond (a.k.a Rose). But Rose (a.k.a. Pink Diamond) wasn't willing to shatter Bismuth. Yet *Rose* is considered the villain in this scenario? (I know I wandered a little off-base. But I think I made my point).

[@vrabiealexandru2755]

i agree

[@nicolesmith4371]

Eric Brower you are completely right and I don’t understand how people don’t get this. Every single other person can be forgiven for their selfish mistakes (the crystal gems keeping lapis trapped in the mirror, lapis bailing and taking peridots home to the moon) but Pink is supposed to be this amazing beacon of perfection that isn’t allowed to make mistakes?? Wtf

[@carrot7868]

@@nicolesmith4371 The same goes for Steven. People blaming him for ignoring Spinel (who, for a minute, tried to destroy the Earth not so long time ago) while trying to bring back other gems memorys and not holding her hand. (sorry if i spelled something wrong)

[@nicolesmith4371]

Carrot yeah those people are just super clingy and needy themselves so they see themselves in spinels obsessive behavior. It’s sad.

[@Finite_Source]

Yeah the fact that she broke the law and never dealt with it, made her family think she died causing them to go into mourning for thousands of years and also y'know the whole mentally scarring her best friend but yeah, other than that she's greeeaaattt

[@izzymcgee2527]

I think the creepy Room Connie in Open Book is foreshadowing to what happened to Pink Pearl.

[@curlypinkfangirl392]

oh wow that's true because since the room was made to only give him whatever he wants when he gave it free will it literally freaking broke. the room connie had a covered eye as well, same one as pink pearl if i'm not mistaken.

[@littlefishbigmountain]

Curlypinkfangirl She didn’t really break because she was given free will, or at least not exactly. She had free will but chose to use that free will to do whatever Steven wanted. She broke because Steven said he wanted her to not do what he wants, which created a paradox for her: I want to do what you want which is to not do what you want me to do, but by doing that she’s doing what he wants which isn’t what he wants. That’s why she says, “You want me to... not... do.. what you.. want.. what you.. WANT. WANT. WANT. WANT.” or whatever. The logic doesn’t make sense

[@squib2118]

I’ve always been confused why Pearls Homeworld outfit had Pink, Yellow, and blue. She had a white gem, and whiter skin tone. I was always confused because even though I knew she was a replacement, I was confused that white diamond didn’t have a default pearl, and pearl wasn’t pink at all. This clears it up

[@halimakimathi4189]

9:28 Pink diamond remembering how she missed pink pearl, and realizing that she's settling for spinel.

[@hatusnee]

When did this show officially stop being a kids show lol

[@raaragonite]

Probably the time Steven started collecting the pieces of his heritage

[@Jijo2003]

Just like Adventure times

[@krnst4r]

I never thought of this show as a kids show. I think its for Teens

[@janeenstalnaker8395]

Future? Steven needs therapy.

[@oliviaaliva9322]

@@krnst4r no it's not if it was for teens I would have swearing and other sevens so no it's actually for pre teens

[@chickennoodlesoup3340]

This is my theory on our pearl She was first whits Then pinks Last Greg's

[@maizstars]

Hollow Pearse Not Greg’s. Even during the series, she said that she is her own pearl.

[@Evanexus]

@@maizstars Did you not watch the movie or?

[@raumple]

UmGreg Universe

[@silverwolfkai]

I can't remember where I heard this but I believe Rebecca sugar said, when asked, that our Pearl was never white diamonds

[@Fortnite_Whopper]

Our pearl was never white diamond's pearl because when she was first made she had all four diamond colors cause she was on default settings

[@anthonyganzeveld1549]

Wait so can Steven HEAL THE KINDERGARTEN I hope we can see that edit: also could the cluster be take out of the earth if the bubble was "sent off" and could steven/ all the diamonds fix broken gems if they have all their pieces and even find their pieces

[@sharktenko267]

most likely no since spinels injector was putting stuff in not taking stuff out

[@danielc2530]

I think the cluster is happy with where it is now.

[@guilhermerafaelzimermann4196]

@@sixsiamang6481 actually, it's stated even rose couldn't heal shattered gems, pretty sure they hadn't mentioned the diamonds that early on in the series, but yeah it would indeed be impossible to heal the forced fusions unless they had a thing that can undo the very structure of the gem shards in such a way as for them to separate

[@monsieurromanbedlam5101]

@@guilhermerafaelzimermann4196 I mean, there's the rejuvenater and the distabiliser(and the cure for corruption), so I think they have the bases for that project

[@leroy8922]

A lil kinda cool thing i noticed during my watch of the movie is that Spinel is more of a 'monkey see monkey do' person. In the scene when the gems reform Steven shakes Spinel in anger and then she does it back, after the song We are the crystal gems Spinel copies the line that Steven sang at first "Here we are in the future and it's bad". In the song No matter what after Amethyst turns back to normal, Steven hugs Amethyst and Spinel joins in. Spinel even juggled the way Pink diamond did for her pink pearl, so i think there may be some details hidden too of how she learned how to be 'her' and her when her heart is upside down. So maybe she copied something else from someone, i don't know fully but yeah. Dere ya go~

[@juhlsghouls]

Can we talk about how pink pearl had a gem on her stomach like pink so she theoretically also thought “with her gut” whereas Pearl’s gem is on her head so she would be more level headed.

[@marlipri]

i dont think the Diamonds customized Pearl at all. I think she was just a fancy Pearl. Right before she boots up in the movie she says her Default Settings were chosen. When she reforms she's in the same outfit we saw her in and had her default personality while she was Pink Ds Pearl. I think Pink could have changed her settings but didnt bother and just used her in her default form especially after the trauma of losing her first Pearl

[@yooringonghan]

Becky already stated CG!Pearl =/= WD's Pearl

[@marlipri]

@@yooringonghan right. I never said I thought cg pearl was wd pearl. I said that I think that she's a random fancy pearl with default settings that no one bothered to change

[@monsieurromanbedlam5101]

Well, from what I got from the Video is that they custom made CG! Pearl, making the customisation the default setting(if that makes sense)

[@marlipri]

@@monsieurromanbedlam5101 this video is only a theory. its not confirmed canon. I presented my personal theory here because typically channels that post theory videos want discussion, not people to take every word as absolute canon. its ok to agree with their theory and not mine.

[@walnut6922]

Pearl was rebooted three times. 1st when she applied to be White's pearl, changing her form and whitewashing herself to be in the likeness of her diamond. 2nd when she was given to Pink, wherein they reset her to default. 3rd when Spinel hit her with the rejuvenator and she goes default once again. just a theory, feel free to question it.

[@kkvalen]

My theory is that the reason why there’s a (3) in the song was because yeah that was pearls 3rd reboot but I think that her first reboot was for white diamond it makes sense because she has her gemstone on her forehead and white diamond has her gemstone on her forehead too then the 2nd time she got rebooted was for the trading of pink pearl and pearl I think white used the rejuvenator to wipe pearls memory so she can be given to pink entirely new and white diamond just used her mind control powers instead of using the rejuvenator on pink pearl. Then pearls last and final reboot was when spinel used the rejuvenator on her. Makes sense huh 1st she was made for white, 2nd she was made for pink, and the 3rd time she was made for “Greg” so it makes sense now.

[@OriasRofocale]

Yeah that was what I took from it, but the whole thing of Spinel being an outlet for the playmate aspect of Pink Pearl makes a lot of sense.

[@ultima1594]

You saw how Spinel reacted to Steven’s friends, I don’t think Pink Pearl will like that either.

[@merilpts]

I used to think that Pearl was white diamond's pearl and when Pink diamond "broke" her pink pearl they switched pearls, as a way for white diamond to have more control over pink diamond. Since she knew that her pearl was well behaved and very attached to detail and had some experience in building colonies she also thought that it would help pink not to fail in her task. Obviously I was wrong, since it was said that pearl was tailor made for Pink diamond, but I like my theory nonetheless.

[@pompe221]

Adding to the theory a little -- I think our Pearl was given to Pink after she (Pearl) was slightly infused with qualities of all the other Diamonds (like Blue's compassion, Yellow's adherence to rules, and White's perfection-seeking.) That would make her more like the ideal servant she was meant to be. And that's why our Pearl's original outfit has all 4 Diamond colors in it rather than just being pure pink.

[@anamariamalo]

I think the 4 colors are the "default" customization

[@overlymetaromantic]

One thing I noticed is that rebooted Pearl was her "default" setting. Personally, I took this to relate to her appearance, explaining her multi-colored outfit - without a designated customization, she defaults to representing gem society as a whole, and the prestige that goes along with owning a pearl (she is a fancy one, after all). Alternatively, the mixed colors could relate to the idea that she was a joint effort from all the other diamonds to make a new pearl for Pink, but either way, I think it relates to this theory in an interesting way: she's a pearl that was made for Pink Diamond, but she's not a Pink Pearl. The dissonance is there all the way down to her color scheme.

[@trace5394]

*Who every is reading the comments I just wanted to tell you have a amazing day! ❤️*

[@shortcake4418]

Have a good day too!

[@d3adxb0yxwalk1ng]

you can’t tell me what to do ٩(๑`^´๑)۶ (jk lol don’t attack me)

[@cwazykitten7806]

Thank you!! 🙂

[@thatrat8414]

Thank you ❤

[@loopyninjabear666]

Thanks 😁 you too!

[@k9dominica277]

I think it's really interesting that pearls are supposed to be the color of their diamond, and Pearl is the color of all the diamonds. She has yellow, blue, white, and pink colors to her. Is almost as if she's made up of traits of all four diamonds both physically and mentally.

[@temmiewithasmile2169]

I feel like pearl was white diamonds pearl because of the traits she had (I.e motherly, elegant, gets frustrated when the gems didn’t follow her orders) and the color match as well

[@cheetopuff8888]

I think White might have broke Pink Pearl's eye as a punishment for being too emotional and for doing stupid things with Pink. And then she was taken away from her, and White took control of her mind.

[@Ruby-Doc]

*_[Ooh, interesting, very interesting... buuuut... I'm still wondering... what might've happened to me and my squad?]_*

[@Ruby-Doc]

@Jacobi Brown *_[Wow, someone woke up on the wrong side of their bed last night]_*

[@SwiftmanW]

Jacobi Brown * uno reverse card* no u

[@Ruby-Doc]

@Mia. *_[Hi!]_*

[@TRahjey]

Ahhhhhhhhhhh this makes so much sense! Now I can see why Pink Diamond so easily left Spinel! The artificially-created friendship wasn't as real as the spontaneous creation of a relationship between two friends!

[@corvidmurder]

It was a forced relationship all and all. It's like arranged marriage but you know in the end it's bound to fail

[@recalypso7567]

I’m pretty sure pink diamond was actually the one who broke pink pearls eye, not white diamond

[@recalypso7567]

@Brittany Bennett maybe just like a child breaking their "toys" pink diamond might've accidentally been using her floating power with pink pearl and broe her, and instead of fixing her she was replaced, or maybe pink was just throwing a tantrum and in her bind rage we see a power that steven hasn't unlocked yet, the ability to hurt a gem without breaking their actual gem

[@recalypso7567]

@Jude Luckett the response is below

[@carrot7868]

@@recalypso7567 I don't think that she thought of Pink Pearl as a toy. Maybe you can say that for Spinel, but not Pink Pearl

[@bethanymcgonigle]

@@recalypso7567 I don't think pink ever saw pearl as a toy maybe spinel but not pearl

[@lucasmartinez5703]

The Diamonds specifically made Spinel to be a "plaything" for Pink and told her as such. So that's all Pink really saw her as. Pink was clearly closer to Pink Pearl then Spinel because they developed a bond that Spinel and Pink just didn't have. It's why their relationship was doomed to fail. Spinel was forced on her.

[@hypnoleaf3390]

The best Easter eggs is sad spinel singing other friends Why? Because it comes in a package of memes and cursed images

[@SXJAYSX]

There's a scene where blue says to yellow when talking about white "any gem would crack under that kind of pressure" I'm assuming that's it. White was too demanding and Pink Pearl cracked.

[@jddiggy2343]

Pink Pearl literally said Pink diamond cracked her.......................

[@melissaemery9054]

@@jddiggy2343 that was 9 months ago he commented that wjy reply to it at all

[@SunshineCasy]

The devastating part of this theory is which Pearl Pink may have actually been in love with. It's likely that if Rose ever showed affection for or flirted with our Pearl, it was only because of those moments she reminded her of the original Pink Pearl. The relationship Pearl thought she had with Rose was unrequited because Rose realized she would never be like her original Pearl...

[@iCOOKIEmischief]

Theory before I watch the video: Pink Pearl was like PD, much like how the other Pearl's match their respective diamonds. Because of this, she was immature and goofy, much to the dismay of WD. Soooo they got rid of her and gave PD our Pearl; a pearl that would keep PD in line in a pearly sort of way. This displeased PD because she grew bored. Soooo they/she created a friend for her who's sole purpose was to be fun to keep PD happy! The end.

[@rainbowquartz9513]

I still think white diamond GAVE AWAY her pearl (our pearl) to pink diamond

[@thatrat8414]

I'm pretty sure Rebecca Sugar said that's not what happened

[@Fortnite_Whopper]

Our pearl was never white diamond's pearl because when she was first made she had all four diamond colors cause she was on default settings

[@violentjuggalo]

I wonder if White ever had a Pearl

[@JamesBigJ]

Anna Lialine I do

[@Fortnite_Whopper]

No,I don't watch Kubzscouts

[@floppa2462]

They told us already, I think it was Blue who said Something like "if you don't follow the rules we are going to take away your pearl" That's why white gives pink our pearl and that's also the second boot for our pearl. And then there's what's in the movie and how Pink abandoned Spinel

[@Vallamaria]

Yeah, you're remembering right.

[@lucasmartinez5703]

Exactly. It all goes back to the other Diamonds.

[@Chi.mer4]

When you find out why pink pearls eye is damaged in future : 👀

[@squiffymango]

The reason why pink left spinel was because spinel was mainly programmed to entertain pink, but what pink really wanted was someone to share a deep emotional connection to. We see this in how pink is deeply fascinated by humans and how they are able to grow with complex emotions driving them and changing their identity from year after year. She sees this and loves everyone who is full of growth and passion. But with spinel, spinel never changed, never matured or shared a deep side to her, and was on a one track mind full of entertainment and fun, and that was not fulfilling to pink since she wanted something more, something deep. And thats why she left spinel and tricked her. It was because pink felt she would never change, and so she wanted to start a new beginning and leave the past with spinel behind because she feared it would affect how ppl perceived pink and judge her to be immature. With that said, i still think pink is a jerk for doing that. But everyone can relate that they have been with someone who just keeps up the same persona for years. Its like a 60 year old being with a 10 year old that never changed. And that can be very unfulfilling ina sense that they are two different ppl with different goals in mind.

[@aimeec.7716]

Pink had a temper tantrum, causing pearl to get hurt, the diamonds thought they had to replace her because she wasn’t perfect, and wanted to replace her with a perfect pearl that would obey pink. But that’s just my theory

[@blitzus5022]

Remember when Pink Diamond tired to have a side conversation with Pearl about Controlling a Colony. Then Pink Diamond was unsatisfied by Pearl’s response. Only in later season Pearl started doing the things she wants

[@dronef0415]

9:56 There’s a hole shaped as a heart in a planet on the right. I don’t if that means anything on how Spinel felt

[@nikgeniuses6856]

I personally think that Pink just left Spinel thinking ;"Oh, if I left her for a few years, she would've gone her own way right? She'll definitely be given to someone else, if it's clear that I don't want her. Let me just tell her to wait for a bit, she'll get bored of it anyway"

[@darkmystery5731]

That's exactly how I feel. I genuinely think PD just assumed she'd leave eventually.

[@reze4695]

That's right I heard the story over and over again gee it's swell to finally meet her other friends

[@thegodofgoats3313]

Kit Kat what she say about me what did she say what did you do without me what did you do did you play games without me what did you play did you think all this time I wouldn’t find out about you

[@starlightassassin5592]

What did she say about me, what did she say? What did you do without me, what did you do? What kinds of games did you play without me? What did you play?

[@sodarrific]

There's already 2. When Pearl was first made, and the movie. The 2 times. That means Pearl has been changed between that time.

[@justataco8398]

Krizzlekroo Rebecca Sugar said that Pink Pearl was never White Diamonds pearl. White never needed a pearl to me, she IS a leader of the diamond and yet still is a perfect diamond.

[@Vathananable]

Maybe Pink Pearl was the ultimate pearl and our Pearl was not great at that time

[@justataco8398]

Mahendren Vathanan *GASP* We have been loving the less superior pearl _THIS WHOLE TIME!_

[@ZinSikola]

Yellow’s neck just snaking into the room. I can see now why they call her a giraffe.

[@Spectre00]

Honestly, I always thought Pink Diamond left Spinel because she didn't think she was gonna be taken serious since she had a colony now as long as she had Spinel.

[@mitamita2640]

You missed the part of how Spinal address to Pearl when seeing her for the 1st time.

[@monsieurromanbedlam5101]

What did she say?

[@tiacool7978]

@@monsieurromanbedlam5101 "And Pink Diamond's Pearl. Well she took you with her. Isn't that just... Swell?!" Unless I'm miss-remembered something. Pearl also seems to remember her as well. So more proof that they knew each other around the same time.

[@mekostuff]

@@monsieurromanbedlam5101 *_WHAT DID SHE SAY ABOUT ME, WHAT DID SHE SAAAY--_*

[@steampunkwilson7435]

Dang, sometimes I wonder if you actually secretly work for the crewniverse!

[@ghostkitten6779]

Okay but she tells Garnet not to "question it" and she never says a question after that... long after she's gone. I think maybe Pink can issue commands (perhaps even without realizing they are commands) to more than just her Pearl(s).

[@GwenKalash]

"The Diamonds saw Spinel" Blue: "One of Pink's lost treasures" Pink Pearl (volleyball): "Umm excuse me im one of hers too because I exist you know that!" Yellow: "Yeah we know but you're the most pathetic little treasure that is like JUNK!" Pink Pearl(Volleyball): "TrIgGeReD mOdE aCtIvAtEd!"

[@slmmd_]

Why didn’t yellow, white, and blue not just use the rejuvenator on pink pearl?

[@johnnysalery7383]

Hypebeast Nerd My guess is that Pink would've been outraged like she was with Yellow when she begged for a colony of her own. Although she had fun with Spinel, Pink knew that she was just a replacement for Pink Pearl and it caused her to resent Spinel. Which could also explain why she abandoned her rather than out right saying "You're nothing more than a replacement". But that's just my theory.

[@tiacool7978]

Probably because her base characteristics were the problem. I would assume whatever custom settings that where hinted at, when CG Pearl rebooted, had more to do with looks than behavior.