Why Telecom Draft Bill 2022 is a disaster in the making? : Telecom draft bill 2022 Case study

thethinkschool...
On 21st of september of 2022, the govt of India launched the telecom draft bill 2022. and as soon as it was launched, there was huge wave of outrage from both media and the stakeholders of the digital ecocsytem!! and trust me, it actually looks like a disaster!! and the fun fact is that, if this bill passes the govt might indirectly force to pay for whatsapp, facetime,telegram and all other apps!! and more importantly, its will kill the progress its very own vision of a digital India!!
So in this episode today, let’s do a deep dive and try to understad,
What is the telecom draft bill 2022,
Why has it become such a big controversy
how did whatsapp come into the picture?
and most importantly, if executed the way it has been proposed, how will it affect the lives ordinary people like you and me?
Think School is a Digital School that we all deserved, but never had
►►Check out Think School's Online courses: www.thethinksc...
⬇️Our Top 2022 Playlist
Geopolitics:
India is Trapping China - • How India is TRAPPING ...
Oil Giants Crushing Europe - • How Saudi Arabia & Rus...
Israel’s Secret Strategies - • How did Israel become ...
China vs India Military Strategy in Ladakh - • Why is China taking ov...
Upcoming US Recession Affects Indian Economy - • How US Recession will ...
Best of Business:
1. Asian paints - • How Asian Paints Built...
2. Amul - • How Amul beat its comp...
3. Haldiram - • How did Haldiram Build...
4. Malboro - • The Genius Marketing S...
5. Lijjat Papad - • How 7 Mumbai-based wom...
►Books Everyone should read:
1. Sapiens: amzn.to/3wIqqtG
2.Jab Jab Jab Right Hook: amzn.to/3eb36ym
3.Presuasion: amzn.to/3nF4Xi8
4.Start with why: amzn.to/2R7UHCW
5. Culture code: amzn.to/3tfaxsZ
6. Hooked: amzn.to/2R9G9CM
7. I will teach you to be rich: amzn.to/3AUDLSO
8. From Third world to First: amzn.to/3yQSjAV
9. This is Marketing: amzn.to/334VNlL
🎧 Want to buy the equipment we use?
1. Our Laptop: amzn.to/3z66odv
2. Our Mic: amzn.to/3liQQyi
3. Camera Stand: amzn.to/3z8l3ov
4. Mobile holder for stand: amzn.to/3xgCF25
5. Laptop: amzn.to/3gMYXRi
► Invest in the Stock Market : zerodha.com/op...
Study materials : Link to consultation paper
prsindia.org/f...
#businesscasestudy #thinkschool #telecombill Credits: CNN-News 18, WION, NBC News, Money control pro, Business standard, TV18,Business Today, ABC news, CNBC, ET now ,Bloomberg originals, Financial Times, DW documentary, AL Jazeera English, BBC news, Firstpost. Fair use - This video is for educational purposes only. All materials used in this video, including images, audio, and video clips, are the property of their respective owners and are used here under the doctrine of fair use. This video is intended to provide commentary, criticism, research, and education on the subject matter. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

[@ThinkSchool]

If you want to support us like and share this video with your friends and family! Invest in the Digital Inclusion smallcase: link.smallcase.com/FyMCJPa32ub

[@sarveshraghavan9786]

Hi Ganesh, Everything is great about your content but why do you use unnecessary click baits? Not like anyone falls for it, but it would eventually drive your subscribers away...

[@LulzAsh]

Please I dont have any friends

[@anshulgupta8253]

@@sarveshraghavan9786 clickbaits are basically lies told to engage viewers, in the end there is a ? so that the viewers can decide. Try to take a second glance before misinterpreting

[@kumarnavneet6079]

Bro pls make a video on total investment come under PKI scheme till now ,and national edible oil mission

[@kumarnavneet6079]

Make a video on national edible oil mission

[@kaavyasurianarayanan8247]

I'm so glad that you point out the good schemes, as well as the bad ones that are implemented by the government. So happy that you take the stand of making Bharat a revolutionary, safe, powerful and peaceful country, and that you are not supporting one party as such. Jai hind!!

[@Himachali_Protagonist]

Hey Girl !! Aur U Bharat Natyam ( Classical) Dancer ? DP is Fascinating ❤👌

[@Amitytamang]

@@Himachali_Protagonist yes I am..

[@AmanGaur-fe1gh]

Everyone please share this video to oppposition parties at their Social media handles before it comes in parliment 🙏🙏🙏

[@chaudhary6293]

@@AmanGaur-fe1gh to everyone to family members also truth is not that they always see on sold tv

[@Himachali_Protagonist]

@@Amitytamang if You Are.. Then Take So Much Love And Respect From Me To still Choose Classical Dance. We are Heading Towards Westernization At very Fast Rate. Our This Kind Of Heritage will Going To Be Lost... If People Like you Will not Be There.

[@popefrancis2946]

This is what I call positive , constructive, logical criticism

[@agentsmith_]

Hey Popes

[@manojramesh4598]

So u don't want to criticize government?

[@manojramesh4598]

The government is being very authoritative like China always keeping eye on people's freedom

[@popefrancis2946]

@@manojramesh4598 can u read

[@popefrancis2946]

@@agentsmith_ Hi Smith

[@CAajaynegi]

In a neutral manner you have explained this case study....love that man

[@abhinavnegi4859]

Thats the name of my dad.

[@naharsahu]

@@abhinavnegi4859 but I'm yours..😂😂 Joking bruhh ladne na lagna

[@CAajaynegi]

@@abhinavnegi4859 UK ??

[@abhinavnegi4859]

@@CAajaynegi delhi, i'm a garhwali

[@rishabhnegi1337]

I am Negi too.

[@umeshsidhaye1396]

No mainstream media would ever take pains to indulge and discuss issues as important as these.. Great job.. Keep it up 👍👌

[@shivam_nagar69]

lol usne intro mai hee bola ki Media ne questions kiye h🤷‍♂ of course itne detailed video nhi banate mai aisi videos sirf WION se expect karta hu news channels mai sadly woh international issues pe hee banata h.

[@Sunshine10101]

I feel this bill will overtly empower govt to intervene in personal sphere of citizens. This then can be used by gov to penalise it's critics by intercepting their personal details, chats and so on. This is highly dangerous from the perspective of democracy at gives too much power to govt over Personal spheres of common citizen.

[@anootoshsarkar686]

In short, this would mean the end of democracy and people's rights in this country. We must not support such a law

[@secretjosh5619]

@@anootoshsarkar686 sadly, it is already out of the hands of the common man. The bill will surely be passed, and will never be repealed. We must either comply, or leave.

[@claudeshannan4000]

Bill will be surely passed it will drastically affect democracy

[@vishnuskandata2355]

That is already being done by tech giants now.

[@yogeshvachhani6740]

​@@anootoshsarkar686 this also means WhatsApp will have to either comply or leave India

[@Hellobguys]

Think School is an way to change the Indian Education system 🔥❤️❤️

[@josephabhishek9243]

Edit an to a Your comment will get more likes if done so

[@daivasjallencherry4335]

Modiji ne kiya he toh soch samjhkar kiya hoga

[@harunarandy1423]

[@cresponoe9451]

There are many reasons for this drop in value. One of the main reasons is that there is an ongoing debate about whether or not Bitcoin should be regulated as a security or as a currency.

[@beverly8480]

I would advice you to trade your assets rather than hodl for a future you aren't sure about, only predictions.

[@harunarandy1423]

@@beverly8480 Well, I've tried but was so confused with the inflation in price, due to the pointers on how to make substantial progress in earnings?

[@beverly8480]

@@harunarandy1423 If you are not conversant with the markets, I'd advise you to get some kind of advise or assistance from a financial/investing coach. It might sound basic or generic, but getting in touch with an investment broker was how I was able to outperform the market and raise a profit of $2.5M For me, its the most ideal way to jump into the market these days

[@harunarandy1423]

@@beverly8480 That's sum cool profit. I dream of that

[@tssri8071]

man, your channel is one of a kind at least here in India. you are doing a wonderful job in spreading awareness in people. even my family and friends have started watching your content regularly and we have these little discussion on the topics. its refreshing. keep up the amazing work! wish you all the best!

[@norabassey]

Because of the economic crisis that always comes up the best thing to be on every wise individual's mind or list is to invest in different streams of income that's not depending on the government to generate funds.

[@aquilaede9338]

@Brandon Justin I think you all should understand that difficulties in trading need an expert and professional like Mr. Anderson Taylor

[@edwardjack9449]

@@aquilaede9338 Same here, earn $13000 a week. God bless ANDERSON TAYLOR he has really been a blessing to me my household.

[@ojotueleojo]

@@edwardjack9449 I started with just 4,000 dollars now earning up to 17,000 dollars from my investment with his company.

[@anthonyanna5964]

@clarkrobinson His trading income stream is too notch, I also trade with his company. I've made 60k so far trading with his guidance/mentorship

[@brittanyhemp]

@Blythe Masters for me Crypto trading is the best investment anyone could get into. As it could make you rich in a blink of an eye, A big shout out to Mr. Anderson Taylor.

[@criscrosxxx]

Nobody questioned the integrity of the Modi govt for passing a law for anonymous funding for Political parties . Horrible state of govt transparency.

[@zebesque]

It's basically legalised lobbying but people of India, the majority of them, are clueless as to what lobbying is, even as far as to believe it is nothing wrong if they were to know about it

[@shaa1415]

For example if you gave funds for congress party because you like congress party but BJP comes to power BJP government will create problems. Do you know how much MLA spends to get elected funds are nothing compared to that.

[@AS-pb4uj]

More than 99% of the electoral bonds are given to the BJP only.

[@varunkhatri3199]

For a Government that says "Government has no business in getting into businesses", this government surely interferes a lot.

[@saijaljain7285]

Haha right

[@samsam150]

If gov did not interfere then soon u will be converted Varun khan .... Or Varun d Souza.....

[@ravneetsingh02]

@@samsam150 bas aise tum bhakt logon ko bewakoof bana rahe ho

[@pavanw]

Everytime BJP wants more control over anything, it cites National Security.

[@orkkojit]

@@samsam150 another bhakt 🤡🤡

[@pratikranjan4622]

I feel that this will give government unprecedented amount of control over our lives, which can go very dark if misused (i.e china govt using censorship),the govt should work on the 2nd and the 3rd part but the 1st is something that is too risky as well as threatens the privacy of citizens like us . edit:after reading the replies I agree with most them but still i have mixed feelings about this, internet is one of those tools that helps us keep the govt in check ,it is like a double edged sword so the best case - we improve our security worst case-anything against the govt is removed and we lose the essence of democracy

[@Himachali_Protagonist]

Actually I want Government To ban Current Instagram. And Government Should Force Meta to Launch a Different Instagram without That Reels Kind Of Shit.

[@abhijithkrishnag8842]

Well I agree that too much regulation over social media is too risky. But regulation of content in social media and other internet platforms really is a need of the hour. Like people literally spam whatever nonsense they want nowadays and make money out of the internet.

[@dhi1083]

You are not some Shehensha that Gov will snoop on you... This is meant to snoop on terrorists' and anti national elements who are threat to your life... Stop jumping like popcorn without using your brain...

[@manojramesh4598]

privacy is important as security.......u can't catch criminals just simply by investigation.......they always escape one or other way.......they need to solve problems directly instead of hindering people's freedom and privacy

[@rakeshmaskare5050]

China became 2nd biggest power in the world, and it is going to became most powerful very soon, and it happened in a span of mere 40-50 years, and people there are happy with their life, Censorship massively help them to boost the growth.

[@stannyjd]

Ganesh, I fervently hope that we as Indians are not going to be naive when it comes to any government taking control of such an important tool of free speech and innovation in the guise of national security. Crony capitalism is clearly getting a fillip past 25 years in India'and getting worse last few years thus bridging the gap between the ultra rich and the middle and poor class much much wider. Such a Bill will only spell disaster to a free and fair society. Thank you for your classy breakdown of facts around the draft Telecom Bill. Appreciate it...

[@sachin2842]

yes cronies are on rise in India

[@bhoxchamp7584]

This country in not that smart, they blindly follow whatever government sells to them.

[@joydeepsinha5463]

Bro i can't pay for all social media platforms it's even though to pay for internet service 😩

[@deepakwagle5107]

India needs benevolent dictator to save India from the hands of Mafia network. Narrative benevolent dictator can as well be understandable as Godfather in appreciative sense.

[@SCP4life]

@Syedbakeruddin Bekar oi oi oi mate... Here for a brawl..

[@saiaditya4397]

Kudos for explaining the telecom draft bill 2022 in a very engaging and simplified manner. One of the concerns that is being neglected and revoked again and again is the individuals privacy and protection of the data. We are super hyped with the convince that we are getting out of ABHI or UHI and UPI. But one of serious concern is that government are having the control over all the data that is being transferred and transmitted. One may argue that it is for the sake of so called SECURITY. It's not the case most of the time. Now with telecom draft bill, it sounds much worse. If this continues we will end up giving huge amounts of power in to the government and its Associate business (private). While there are ways to get things done by preserving Financial privacy, and personal health privacy. Government is looking forward for ways to harness this data for its own ulterior motives and purposes. If we don't react ,then sooner or later we will end up being a new china . For sure we will see growth and upliftment in very short term ,but on a long term we would be responsible for destroying our own democracy. I would love to hear you thoughts on this as you are one of the few people ,who has an understanding of both the world's. And please keep making amazing thoughtful and thought provoking content, so we are enabling people with right information to act.

[@tulshandas7776]

Just wanted to say that he is doing the perfect job to educate people like all of us how the world works. Massive respect to this guy. A channel worth watching. Thank you.

[@mssumitrapal]

Totally disagree, he is working with an agenda

[@SamDessage]

Innovation is going to get stifled immensely. And most importantly it's also highly improbable and extremely naive to think that the government won't abuse this power handed over to them. We have all seen what the USA did for national security after 9/11. If it wasn't for Snowden, we'd still be in the dark all this time. "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Benjamin Franklin

[@lovekanaujia345]

Even if enacted, it will not pass the privacy test in Supreme Court. KYC on social media is bizzare.

[@alwynbradmanarulcharles926]

Facts

[@deepakwagle5107]

India needs benevolent dictator to save India from the hands of Mafia network. Narrative benevolent dictator can as well be understandable as Godfather in appreciative sense.

[@choclatecrayon8671]

Love kanuajia really dont u give ur details to make id, share ur contacts, photos, data with american apps and cia ..but u hav issues if indian government regulate americab apps and controll their anti india , anti hindu racism, interference in elections etc

[@randomghost1080]

@@choclatecrayon8671 yes, I don't have a problem with that. Cause those "American" apps, whatsapp or telegram (kind of) etc. CANNOT read the messages due to something called End-to-End encryption. It cannot be broken, unless the government forces it to. And no, if the US government forced it, it would be all over the news. Cause it really does not take much effort to check if it actually works, anyone with basic CS knowledge can test it. Oh, and before you point out Facebook or Instagram, there's a difference between voluntary and involuntary consent (you know, how sex between married couples is voluntary and rape is involuntary). I don't post my Aadhar details or my home address on Facebook or Instagram.

[@bala6619]

You guys will be remembered by future entrepreneurs and generations!!! If this bill comes into force, I can't imagine the repercussions!!! Thank you for sharing such a valuable information!!!

[@adityajaitly2872]

Really like you being neutral and not leaving a room to point out things which are not positive or good in general. Keep going. Always watch the case studies in first 2 hours. They are so informative.

[@sumitbharti7815]

But about the title of video, can you read it again?

[@deepakwagle5107]

India needs benevolent dictator to save India from the hands of Mafia network. Narrative benevolent dictator can as well be understandable as Godfather in appreciative sense.

[@dineshparihar1890]

Neutral objectives we should have: 1. Prevent BJP to get 2/3rd seats in parliament so that they cant change the Constitution. 2. Prevent BJP to get in majority of states so that there remain Federalism and not dictatorship

[@YouTubeVivek]

What type of dictatorship you faced ?

[@mohammedabdulkareem2790]

@@KZbinVivek its human being, if one of were given unlimited power we will definitely take advantage of it. Its not good to give so much power to one party irrespective of what we support. To remain in democratic forever we need to distribute our votes to opposition also.

[@vyomjain3468]

As a developer, I feel that some aspects of this bill would cause more harm than good and might cause make it really hard for anyone trying to create an application. Right now, it's easy for the govt. to intercept messages by using the IT laws and pressuring companies, but if such a bill would be introduced, people would de-facto switch to private networks and applications beyond the control and purview of the internet providers or the govt.

[@japaneselanguage2557]

You are Showing logical and constructive criticism and analysis. Most of the KZbinrs lack this. My mian issues with is are (negatives) 1)new players will find difficult to get license 4:30, which will kill some innovations. 2) Internet shutdown is some way good but, if used wrongly will have great negative impact. 3) Sometimes privacy matters. Positive: 1)showing those company calls names, and stopping our ph no/our data passing to others, ads issues. 2) security issues like internal terrorists using social media can be tackled easily. 3) now recently many insta acc selling live nude video calls for money. So underage kids won’t be addicted(or become victims) those shit if government bans these types of accounts in normal social media apps like insta or Facebook. If they it in other porn sites, it may be ok. But why use normal social media. Government should rethink this and change some of rules in the bill.

[@manishparab7128]

What terrorist in their right mind use social media to communicate? Also knowing the current government the internet shutdown is going to be used for anything but safety of the people.

[@archanajha4458]

Internet shutdown is taken into a controlled measure by government agencies. It's not to be seen as a threat for normal human beings, citizens.

[@ankitdeep3302]

I think On Negative 1) It should be easy to get licence to start a communication application Negetive 2) actually internet spreed more misinformation about riots so it's point less to talk on this point On Positive 2) they are not tourist they are Pakistan jihadist changing name and writing fake misinformation

[@amansinha3311]

license for calling apps.. i dont know how many devs are after a calling app

[@ankitdeep3302]

@@amansinha3311 not just calling app social media and messages apps

[@ic0068]

I'm part of IT and testing community where Security Testing is one of the key elements and I say support this bill. I'm a Big fan of Think School and Ganesh (presenter), but I also check the original study materials and other sources to have my own understanding and stance because I know the power of media and social media. My suggestion to all of you also is to not get easily influenced by anybody and to do proper due diligence. Keep doing it...don't stop...because everything changes... Now let me define what national security is being mentioned here in Telecom Bill after seeing the docs shared here...We all know today that data is collected from any device which has a MIC in it like Amazon Prime, Smart TV's, Smart watches, mobiles, Alexa etc (Even without it being on)...Have you noticed off-late your phones in India display "Calling using Whatsapp" on calling modes without giving permission..so anywhere you are talking or doing anything in your life there is no privacy...every data goes to different countries....that's how scary the situation is. If you want to further understand this, see the series "Person of Interest" in Amazon Prime which will blow your mind the kind of technology being talked and what it can do in early 2010s itself. So what do they do to you....they do something called as "Social Engineering" by influencing you by a continuous bombardment of info that they want you to see and change your mind with. This is used for destabilizing states (i.e governments) and the Economy, Terrorism, Radicalisation, Conversions, Political influencing, Phishing, Cyber attacks....you name it and everything is achieved....Now I value my security the most...I know this bill will not stop the problem, but there will be a great reduction of the problem at the source which is most important...This should have been done long time back where there are proper regulations..some points in the bill might need to be changed but it should start somewhere... Finally, innovations etc happened from the time Mankind started thinking so this bill will not kill any of it....infact this will create greater transparency and authenticity for talented individuals/companies. PS: For me, it does not matter which political party did this, I would have supported this.

[@torrtuganooh2484]

And you want to become china then with the fear?

[@gouthamsudheer2080]

This I Fear Will Introduce "Licence Raj" System in Telecommunication (which will Hamper Innovation like Pre-1991 Era)

[@rockzzchannel1670]

This is a good observation.. like we know that nsa(national security agency) of usa can penetrate in any phone or app of anyone without interrupting the process. This gives a bigger threat to the national security of India . Nowadays mostly all big economies are trying cyber attacks. My point being here is through the data of citizens of a country foreign states can manipulate and create chaos among them!!! And if you think of privacy in terms of digital world there is no thing as privacy every data can decode and read even the highest level encryption .... So worry less about the privacy and try to keep sensitive data in external hard drive....

[@tear-down]

Bro he is 2 rupees per comment guy he will never going to understand about the consequences.

[@sanal4492]

@@gouthamsudheer2080 Well, Licensing is itself not bad if it is done properly keeping. The 'License Raj' system was flawed because the no of licenses issued were limited and was strictly controlled by an incompetent and corrupt bureaucracy.

[@adityasharma09]

It is high time...we should ACT against this bill NOW!

[@yami6499]

TRUE. This is worst bil....it's absolutely going to KILL IT-startup culture of India. I think Indian BABUS got too annoyed that IT-sector has remained outside their clutches for too long(the only reason why IT industry could grow in India was it didnt have to deal with absurd Indian laws like other industries). If you notice IT is only sector where normal middle-class ppl can start companies successfully in India...because it isnt so eavily regulated...while other 'REGULATED' sectors are just playgrounds of Big Businessmen with lots of contacts in gov and sarakaari-offices.......The 'level-playing field' which gov is talking about is actually pushing away the innovative startups and replace it with companies of their own 'friends'

[@saravananram3740]

its a draft, voice out your opinion, its likely to change.

[@yami6499]

@@saravananram3740 It has to be 'withdrawn' if Indian IT industry needs to be saved.

[@tothemoooon]

you are traitor sir if you oppose any policy regulated by this government

[@rayedshamim7329]

This bill will greatly help the government in suppressing criticism from journalists and maybe also force mainstream media to comply with anything the government says without giving them "extra" penny... basically end of democracy...

[@YouTubeVivek]

कुछ भी ?

[@iotasymbol8498]

@@KZbinVivek you guys really care about democracy??

[@nihalahmad7195]

Give us ur money, give us your privacy and let us have all the control. This government is so messed up.

[@sigmagrindset939]

This government is doing really good in developing India but downside is they're controlling almost every independent body from CBI,ED,Police and even Jυdιсїаrу to some extent. With Appreciating them for good work everyone needs to raise voice against undemocratic work as well.

[@piyushprasad8731]

Current government is trying to become a totalitarian government

[@hindustanimapper]

Extent* #NotAGrammarNazi

[@dreadfulbodyguard7288]

Now, even trying to control play store and app store.

[@theeternal6890]

*I agree with u 100% bro. This bill may lead to disaster if implemented as it is without considering negitive factors and consequences.*

[@ToastRusk]

Same thing with demonetization

[@choclatecrayon8671]

Kedar demonitization was a success. Whole economy got digitalised and most got added to formal economy. Ed made scores of 100 crore, 300 crore discovery of black money from various people. Cut down black money for terrorism due to which terror attacks compared to before is down

[@deepmishra9940]

@@choclatecrayon8671 demonetization was success 😂 Yes for corrupts and persons with black money but they have taken risks so credit must be given to them but it was most beneficial for bank managers and employees . They get huge commission for converting black money to white.

[@choclatecrayon8671]

Deep mishra not interested in ur fairy tales without proof. Keep ur whats app univ fake data with u

[@hehesalad]

@@choclatecrayon8671 delusional lun-bhakt

[@letsquestion]

It is great to see that this this channel focuses on the topics and their merits, instead of parties, ideologies or personalities. Even in agreement we will have disagreements and even in disagreements, we will have agreements. Not looking at things as absolute but breaking it down and analyzing with reason and facts is the best way to gain people's mindshare. Excellent presentation & topic as always ! My only suggestion - the cover image of this video could be less dramatic so people go through the points without prejudice, which is very important for this topic.

[@shubhammodanwal6713]

No wonder why our democracy freedom index is plunging down..

[@shiwaniagrawal9335]

This is very well explained. The GoI clearly needs to execute the Bill in a way that it does hamper the innovations.

[@deepakwagle5107]

India needs benevolent dictator to save India from the hands of Mafia network. Narrative benevolent dictator can as well be understandable as Godfather in appreciative sense.

[@shivam_nagar69]

does not*

[@Leto2ndAtreides]

Since there's no way to ensure that governments themselves be fully trustworthy, limiting of government power (along with any other significantly powerful group) is necessary for the well being of any country.

[@manojramesh4598]

privacy is important as security.......u can't catch criminals just simply by investigation.......they always escape one or other way.......they need to solve problems directly instead of hindering people's freedom and privacy

[@danielBAC]

@@yesudeep but criminals and terrorists will roam free then.

[@kabirkhan456]

@@yesudeep you don't understand my friend. If modiji doesn't do this than India will become Pakistan and hindus will be in danger and Muslim population will be 10billion. So for India's betterment this has to be done.

[@protograde2723]

@@yesudeep One policy cannot change the world's largest democracy into a 4th grade rogue nation like North Korea.

[@chostme]

@@manojramesh4598 What privacy you are thinking a private company which is tracking every step you take became more trustful than your own government. But we forget that our entire Aadhar , Pan , Income , Bank details are already with the government itself so did your aadhar, pan , income tax details got sold? Or are you getting any spam emails like "according to your account statement and income details try this new jobs" but you are getting the spam mails from the search history, message history , or from keystrokes . Now tell me who is giving you privacy is it the meta which tracks your keystrokes or the Google which sells your search history . If governments leaks your data or tracks your every movement everyone will be making bandhs/riots/ whatnot but what did we can do to Google or any other companies which are already doing that. There's no privacy at all with this just a beautiful lie enforced on us by these giants , we are second guessing our own government but never dared to questions about ourselves is my data really safe with these companies. From Kerala to Rajasthan we have seen people killed (sar tan se juda movement) for prophet remarks in nearly every case a whatsapp group was there they freely planned the murder but the police got the chats only after 2days-1week . Here you should think of 2 things 1. They still got the data so there is a provision for that it's a long route, now government wants a short route. 2. When it's in government they could take action before the murder or even after the first murder happened they can get alert the alert and could have saved all the other victims. It's not like they are going to keep looking at your entire without any reasons. They can search for these kind of keywords like sar-tan-se-juda and get the data and find the people who are planning it. And I want to say one more thing let's say the government really want to play dirty is there anything stopping them now . Let's say government wants to get data of me and my families and friends chat they can still get it even now. So there's no major privacy issue here. We are just magnifying the issue here. And personally i trust my government more than those giant companies who is selling my search history for ads everyday.

[@drarunaj]

You are doing a much better job than the opposition of this country.. Constructive criticism is essential for good governance. Keep up the good work.👏

[@sg9257]

I come here for quality content related to government schemes. Thanks for the effort and quality you're putting out

[@deepakwagle5107]

India needs benevolent dictator to save India from the hands of Mafia network. Narrative benevolent dictator can as well be understandable as Godfather in appreciative sense.

[@finshorts6822]

Absolutely right. Both lack of regulation and over regulation makes average people's life miserable. We criticized whatsapp when it tried to remove end-to-end encryption. We shouldn't allow now just because it's Central govt doing this time. As a professional from IT sector, this bill will kill the innovation by small and big players of industry. New Internet shutdown will obviously be misused as the current bill is already being misused(provides less power than newer one). Now the Central govt is planning to regulation OTT, citing cultural reasons. It will restict content which are not favorable to govt. They shouldn't implement the bill.

[@sahilm9490]

"Government is the biggest monopoly in the market". Man your words come true, with this bill Truecaller business will end. Message to the folks study government bills are important in business. Rightly said by you. Thanks

[@shreypaliwal6298]

Only non biased channel i find on youtube for India....loved your content bro 💥

[@yash_kambli]

The question is will they listen to us. We can throw thousands of comments on twitter yet might be remained unnoticed. At the end Gov will do whatever they want.

[@ssmaity_youtube]

Thats why the voting system still exist.

[@giornogiovanna9475]

2024 may

[@sonalikasinghh]

I was waiting for your video so that firstly I would understand the bill in a better way and secondly I would get both negative and positive aspects of this bill. Love your work❤️

[@theeternal6890]

Suggest other related videos if possible plz. I want to know more before things go south.

[@sonalikasinghh]

@@theeternal6890 he has given the study materials in the description of this video I think a quick read would be enough.

[@bobyluvs]

You made the policy details easily understood for even common people. Great Job.. First thing is Govt must frame personal Data privacy policy for country now, or whatever policies or acts they bring, they might not be much beneficial... we are already vulnerable to attackers... Very bad data privacy policy, where even the courier agency asks Aadhar card to deliver.

[@ammaarshaikh6781]

Telecom Draft Bill? More like We are charging you extra without paying you extra or Give Us Money , Give Us Your Privacy and We will Silence You 🙂 Very Kind Govt I See

[@dreadfulbodyguard7288]

The most important thing we should do for national security is - Build a cloud infrastructure with help of domestic companies. Remember how during Russia-Ukraine war, all tech companies stopped providing services in Russia? If US wants, it can ask its companies to stop AWS, GCP, Azure services in India and it will overnight kill all Indian digital ecosystem. Old comment - ``` Indians need to understand the importance of privacy. There is no reason for govt to have power to force software companies to 'remove anonymous accounts'. If people feel some app is becoming too spammy, they can just leave the app and chose different app. Let the free market decide .. not government regulations. ```

[@itachi9016]

Bro The government's job is to govern.If you don't give them any power, then what's the point of electing a government in the first place.I understand your point but i would trust the elected government over a software company.

[@meetankush]

How comfortable it is to demand accountability from a publicly visible government while hiding yourself from any scrutiny behind an anonymous account? If government is a business that pays you services, it’s your job too to use the services in their intended way or the service provider won’t be responsible.

[@dreadfulbodyguard7288]

I think I somewhat misunderstood bill from this video. Watched some other videos to clarify it and I now think it's a step in right direction. Govt is only regulating 1-to-1 calling systems; not public messaging or email systems.

[@pratikislove2893]

Privacy is myth. Cia america all have our data as american apps take all our pics, contacts, and other details. Wierd slaves Indians have become can share all data wth american firms and american govt but nt own Indian govt

[@meetankush]

@@yesudeep You drawing an analogy between running a country and cricket is all we need to know about the collective psyche of the people of this country. Amuse me some more, please.

[@prakashtiwari8003]

Correct me if i am wrong, isn't Mr Shashi Tharoor was heading this IT law drafting committee? Because when I was on twitter in 2021, Mr Shashi Tharoor accused twitter of not complying to Indian IT law. And he said we are joining to make a strict new data protection law.

[@iamAyush_singh]

Man he is not in power

[@prakashtiwari8003]

@@iamAyush_singh atleast do some research bro.

[@nav.abhi100]

Twitter and other apps which are not Indian based social media platforms exports huge amout of data outside country. Government does need this policy to regulate them before It's too late. We don't need our data be selling out like this unnesscary privacy breach

[@jishnum851]

@@iamAyush_singh 🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️ modi govt had made him the head of committee

[@tear-down]

Bro here you won't get 2 rupees per comments. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@akarshaha]

dear sir, i don't know your name but trust me you are one of my gurus..i m preparing for the competition and the updates and recent developments provided by u help me gain insight and a better & holistic understanding of the topic. hope in future too this channel will be as it is now.

[@1977skay]

His name is Ganesh Prasad

[@ashishrain1455]

@@1977skay for real?

[@prasadbhadane608]

@@ashishrain1455 yes. Ganeshprasad. One full word

[@international_fraud]

@@prasadbhadane608 he is from

[@yogeshcyr31]

Thanks for the concise breakdown. 1. Is app licensing available only to Internet communication apps or all apps with elements of limited communication embedded? If it's just Internet communication, then licensing with transparency and no fees in a specified duration is Ok otherwise it clearly reflects the Crony capitalist nature of BJP's tenure, Adani entering the telecom business is common knowledge now. 2. Curbing down spam is always welcome, at the same time identification of the caller is a good move. 3. Did Govt shut down the internet Illegally in the past? Sure Internet doing riots or curfews has its pros and cons- most of the time it leads to rumours and worsening of the situation, the local administration is accountable and answerable either ways. Is the bill passed?

[@nagendrareddyd]

My national security is my main priority and i trust the present govt so support the bill. And if this bill doesn't pass now. It doesn't mean future govts doesn't bring anything big then this bill. So it's our responsibility to choose a govt who really thinks about our country's growth it's a continuous process.

[@TommyJefferson1801]

Hey Buddy can you make videos about the following Indian Philosophies: 1. Questions in Prashna Upanishad such as How was the universe created, What is Constant with Human Beings etc. Most of these questions do not even have an answer today 2. Bhagavad Gita 3. Uddava Gita 4. Upanishads 5. Charvaka Philosophy 6. Why Yoga and Meditation is so Efficient 7. Debates in Ancient India 8. Why Indians worshiped idols, nature and everything. There are a lot of controversies around this. Many invaders and current day Indians criticize this. But Gita gives an excellent answer

[@abhiudaysurya]

Channel ke main topic se mat deviate karo bhai...geopolitics and business and policy case study

[@hindustanimapper]

Geopolitics and buisness only.

[@CAajaynegi]

Bhai this is something entirely different from this niche....there are various channels in which you can find more about these topics

[@yash_kambli]

Mohak mangal is right guy to discuss upon these topics ,u can put this comment on his video. Moreover this channel is based on businesses and geopolitics .

[@abhiudaysurya]

@@yash_kambli good joke

[@SaiPraneethMullapudi]

Hello Ganesh Anna I couldn't watch last video regarding UHI because of an exam. I was so eagerly waiting for the Draft Telecommunication Bill finally it's uploaded. And thank you for providing a deep dive into UHI and how a health revolution in India is in making. My comment of UHI: For all the existing MAJOR health records of patients you see whenever any treatment happens in the hospital atleast Phone number of the patient is registered with the hospital. Most of the hospitals right from 2000s started to use computers. Then as we all know Phone number is linked with Aadhaar Card and Aadhaar Card is linked with UHI... So as we all can do payments by just simply typing phone number in the same way hospitals can upload the existing health data as well. But the major challenges of UHI according to my understanding of Indian citizens and existing healthcare industry are: 1) People always take medical history as a personal thing and don't want other people to know about it so I think few people might restrict doctor to upload the information into National health stack one of the blocks of Ayushman Bharat.... I feel this can be one of the biggest challenges of UHI. 2) Another big challenge is... As we know there is a bad image regarding private hospitals in the people that the hospitals usually create a few health issues to earn money despite patients having no such health issue. And this is true till some extent. So it will cause a geniune fear in the minds of people that hospitals might upload even non existent health issues as well to earn money and in order to retain patients. It's hard to get solution for this. One solution can be a regularly updated full body checkup. Second solution can be post treatment full body tests treatment but few tests aren't possible after undergoing certain surgeries. Last possible solution can be insurance companies YES because they usually examine a lot before releasing money. 3) Providing AFFORDABLE prices will be the biggest challenge. When in UHI app where there will be list of service providers there must be a regulatory body which keeps control on the prices without causing any loss to all the parties involved right from service providers to customers which includes Ambulance division as well. 4)We cannot expect a quicker deep penetration like UPI because still there are no adequate number of diagnostic centres and hospitals. I hope 4th point will prove to be wrong Few key areas to focus on 1) Security: In this Digital world cyber threats are a serious matter of concern so to avoid that we must have a strong Cyberdefence mechanism to protect Digi lockers, important meetings, transactions etc. 2) Increasing penetration: No doubt government is taking visionary steps but reach is not as much as expected so to increase the reach Government and people should act together and encourage citizens of India to use Digital services and they should also help citizens who don't know to use Digital services. 3) Maintainance: Servers should be maintained well and should ensure regular updates fixing bugs & issues 4) User friendly interface: Interface should be easy to access for all people because most of previous generation people especially in rural areas don't know how to use apps properly. 5) Data: Last but not the least data privacy should be the biggest priority and there should be two factor authentication which includes Sign in and OTP verification as well. And we must ensure the health data of citizens under UHI is stored in Indian servers only. If properly implemented I think this can turn into "Indian healthcare model" for many middle income densely populated countries.

[@saalemkhan5471]

My greatest concern as a doctor is uploading this huge amount of data on UHI

[@prashant642]

What exam you are preparing?

[@SaiPraneethMullapudi]

@@saalemkhan5471 Yes but the same can create data entry jobs When doctor gives a prescription then the data entry operator should enter the data into UHI

[@SaiPraneethMullapudi]

@@prashant642 it was a college exam Its bit difficult subject

[@sonianarendramodi2605]

@@SaiPraneethMullapudi bsdk pado,, yaha pe kya kar rahahi

[@BFanatic]

What a idiotic clickbait on this video. I respect this channel for the knowledge but don't undermine the reputation you have built by putting sensational click baits on the poster of the video. Please! Give respect to prime minister of the biggest democracy in the world for doing a phenomenal job. He is not your clickbait material!

[@sanketjadhav42]

Seriously yours is the only YT channel from which I am always eagerly waiting for new videos. And It's like morning ritual to watch your video along with the morning bfast. Really keep up the great work. May your channel grows to maximum 🤘

[@indiaversysrider]

I think if implemented correctly this is a step in right direction.. we as consumers wants data with cheap rates so that we can do whatsapp / facetime calls free of cost.. somewhere someone has to bear the cost right.. Also in the past there has been many instances where whatsapp have outrightly refused to cooperate in some investigations related to criminal cases.. in other countries most of these services are regulated but In a huge market like India they have a free hand to operate at their will... even if they have to pay for the license they should absorb that cost rather than passing it on to customers.. they have been earning limitless from markets like India till now.

[@smartboy8918]

The simple solution is rise the cost of data. The apps are already making money.

[@nityasomaiya5001]

Love these government policy explanations, It’s the most important Information for citizens and yet the least discussed

[@kunalchhabra7967]

hahah lol...democracy is fading my friend

[@balakoushiksanku7373]

@@kunalchhabra7967 in which multiverse 😂😂 If congress in power democracy is safe If congress is not in power then omg democracy dies😂😂😂 What a joke of the century infact democracy did suicide in congress regime dur to appeasement politics

[@chaudhary6293]

@@balakoushiksanku7373 in your own blind sadakchaap

[@pardesi_swiss]

Time for Farmer bill 2.0 😂

[@Jaibheemmusalmaan]

@@kunalchhabra7967 democracy faded with art 30 (1) under nehuru.

[@durlovesaikia]

This is hands down the best channel I have subscribed to...

[@vlv5845]

License for apps from creative developers??? That wasn't expected Will kill India's software market growth and potential so easily

[@vishwasha1312]

Good point, but Unlicensed apps can also aid antisocial elements. Anyone with avg coding skill can create app and do what ever he wants with it.

[@vlv5845]

@@vishwasha1312 This bill is acceptable only if getting the license isn't expensive and the license should be accessible to everyone(not only registered companies). But yeah the content in the apps should be regulated and monitored before getting the app into public.

[@kamalkumar7978]

Hey Think School, make a video on the followings:- 1. Lack of or non-existance of intra-party democracy in the Indian political parties and its impact on the overall development. Are we being ruled by groups of oligarchies ? 2. The absence of representation of leaders of different regions of India in the *high commands* of the national as well as regional political parties and its impact on the geographical development of India. 3. Impact of IT cells of the political parties on the demography, freedom of speech and the development of India.

[@rajdeepdas9216]

@ThinkSchool Just have a question.. if it is all about national security, then why 500-600 crores required for licensing? Also if possible, make a video on the topic "shouldn't a taxpayer have right to decide where certain percentage of their Hard earned money be used?" You're doing great!! Keep up the good work..

[@WhatApp-kq8sk]

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@theancientwonderer3607]

He is just assuming. Licensing fees will depend on many things.

[@PramodSubramanyam10]

They should have done this after bringing down the corruption to a negligible level. This Draft bill will surely increase corruption for new innovators who are applying for a license!

[@YunusParvezKhan]

If this bill passes, our visions for the country will die on the very moment and the people who rejected idea of going abroad for India's growth will start to go out.

[@dreadfulbodyguard7288]

Totally agree. Innovators and creatives want freedom, not unnecessary restrictions.

[@chaloouser9496]

I am thinking the same

[@getamazed3473]

I believe in this govt.. There is always a vision.

[@manishparab7128]

@@getamazed3473 the vision is to turn a democracy(what'sl left of it) into a dictatorship

[@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz]

Did muslim ever agree with any govt bills. You ppl will always oppose be it good or bad. Whether you do riots from circulating fake videos and kill tailors like kanhaiyalal for posting something with intention or not.

[@brainpills5709]

you have passion in making videos , and i can clearly sense that passion in every video

[@akasht297]

Right to privacy is now a fundamental right. Including digital privacy. The state cannot promulgate such bills/laws to override the right of privacy of citizens when there are provisions in IT Act, CPC, Cr.P.C, Evidence Act etc. This bill is unconstitutional.

[@Nobody_114]

Thanks for making your excellently informative videos. When you made the video for UHI, I was afraid something like this would happen, resulting in Complete Government Control (CGC). I live in the US. People in the US are extremely scared of CGC. Imagine your livelihood being controlled by every little thing that happens to you regardless of whether it is due to natural causes or it being accidental. Telecom Bill 2022 is the next step towards CGC, and it will be a disaster for India. The only other country where this would work is Russia. Very scary. Very dangerous. No privacy.

[@agentsmith_]

Maybe mandating licensing is good for us? There will be less scam apps?

[@dreadfulbodyguard7288]

Play store already filters scam apps. Do you think govt can decide scam/non-scam better than Google? Also, I don't want to wait 3 months for govt license approval after each new version release.

[@mihirdiwedi3415]

Yup bro, Govt. could do everything by saying just "NATIONAL SECURITY", Same can be seen in some wierd clause of CRIMINAL IDENTIFICATION PROCEDURE BILL & VPN BILL. I don't know whether it is right or wrong but there should be some checks & balances by seeing this govt. majority in the parliament.... KUDOS to your storytelling.

[@iXpress]

Govt should focus on curbing online, cyber scams jamtara scams etc that can be done by current laws instead of making new Laws which is nothing but paper work

[@saliimmohammed9152]

The thing is debates on such important topics must be held on National TVs but no one wants to talk about it.

[@tanmaypatra9455]

When you consider messaging apps, there needs to be a control. What is happening now is Tom Dick and Harry are creating peer to peer apps and encrypting the messages while transmission. In case of investigations around terrorism and related activities, government is facing excessive hurdles to crack down cases. Also lets say while we want to do a video call from Airtel to Airtel, instead of people using Airtel video call, people are using whats app. This is killing the desire of innovation with the telecom sector. Being a software architect of distributed systems, I agree and support the licensing and granular control of government. This should have been done earlier as our government has to support 139 crore population and accountability of these US based companies is highly questionable.

[@WhatApp-kq8sk]

✅✅✅

[@ayansaxena1800]

If this bill is passed in the parliament. Then this bill will probably give monopoly to the central government in the telecom sector. There is no independent authority or commission in this bill to regulate this sector. Like in real estate (RERA), Special economic zone act. And chapter 4 of this bill, if you guys read biasely , then it is directly giving exclusive power to Adani group

[@amanbalani557]

Adani group???

[@ayansaxena1800]

@@amanbalani557 yes sir! Check section 13 illustration 2. As a law student what best can I infer from it is giving special privileges to adani group.

[@HiranyaGarbh.]

Law student! Do you know TRAI and TDSAT? What are they?

[@owk9018]

At least in Maharashtra RERA is practically toothless

[@killercl0wn]

@@ayansaxena1800 how is it special privilege to adani explain seriously asking read the draft myself

[@umeshchittirai]

China has initiated this move way back in 2010 to avoid losses incurred by telecom companies due to VOIP calls and messing services. In UAE its not allowed to use WhatsApp to make audio and video callsl.

[@umeshchittirai]

@@yesudeep where did you see I saying we are in a dictatorship? Govt took this step for many reasons what they thought is good like China thought its good to stop VOIP calls to save chinese telecom industry.

[@yashveer2negi]

If you are online then forgot the privacy. Privacy is myth in the world of internet

[@dreadfulbodyguard7288]

We currently can have anonymous accounts created with fake IP addresses and use them to speak against govt policies. With this new bill, govt will get too much power.

[@123456789abcd786]

Not only WhatsApp , EdTech Industry providing live classes will also take a hit.

[@-Rishikesh]

Loved the video, one constructive feedback is, if you had released this video a month prior we actually had an email address to voice our concerns. Giving opinion in twitter is ok, but to have our voice really heard during the draft stage would have been even better. Thanks for the awesome content as always.

[@Leto2ndAtreides]

India's current government has very Chinese government under Xi Xinping vibes (which has pros and cons)

[@rajatsharma8428]

Bss bhosdu agr na pta ho to mat likha krr ye sale baseless baate lodu ek democracy aur autocratic me kya similarity nikal rha hai

[@llj500]

Well it can help us develop.

[@coolguy-zm7tn]

@@llj500 ganta, again digital ecosystem is becoming elitist

[@durgashankarsharma6927]

The government who keeps calling itself business friendly surely wants its own license raj ....

[@VenkatSai04]

As a developer my perspective of this bill will be positive, but the charges for the carriage should apply for only them , who have greater influence in people. Making small startups more relaiable.

[@zackandderson7587]

We must put up a petition in front of the government this is a must to stop them from destroying the digital paradise they have created.

[@uv9111]

Amazing and informational video. Gov should be questioned for this controversial bill and asked to redraft it

[@WhatApp-kq8sk]

❤️❤️

[@ravichandransivaraman6106]

1. National Security is of utmost importance. 2. Licensing of applications can be made free while exercising necessary controls 3. Internet lockouts can be made as a two or three step authorisation

[@mayanksharma5478]

Exactly. Completely agree with point no 2. Govt is saying take licence from us, but where does it says you have to pay this much.

[@deepakpoddar8720]

@@mayanksharma5478 license process should be completely online otherwise an independent developers will never get license for their app. remember india lost to china and other east asian countries in manufacturing because of our great babus and their licence raj.

[@rdj2398]

Kudos to making such content especially in times like this where any criticism of government can land one in hot water

[@karthikeyan.m3417]

Nowadays ThinkSchools contents are not much addictive 😑

[@chrissygrey8096]

Only good thing I've heard of all things today - NO SPAM/FRAUD CALLS- soooooooooooo good. My grandmother recently lost 80,000 rupees due to these fraudulent call because she download a unauthorised app from the anonymous link. We tried to file a complaint but everything was done by her consent so they can't anything.

[@nyxawesome9409]

This is the first video where I majorly disagree on most of your points: 1. Carrier v/s. Content: This is a long-standing issue in US too... Netflix / KZbin vs Comcast. It is not about "leveling field" as you say. It is because network providers like comcast are not ready to get bogged down just because KZbin / Netflix offered 4K services. Obviously Carrier is spending more to shuttle all that extra traffic and paying for hardware / bandwidth and they will have to raise their network prices. What is the advantage for the carrier? It has only been resolved by higher internet prices for home and excessively so for mobile. Just study US market with the highest carrier prices (home / mobile). 2. Data-Privacy / Lawful Interception: I agree. Btw, the way there is no need for a platform to enable 2-way encryption. If you really need to encrypt your communication (for whatever purposes, corporate, personal, govt. etc.) there are always means to do that (sender and receiver can both agree on 100's of mechanisms out there). Platform doesn't necessarily need to provide that service. It is a bonus for people who do not know. My apologies for the crude example... It is same as knowing how like a Mafia know how to dispose off a dead body vs just dumping it in a secluded place in a suitcase not knowing if any witnesses saw it or CCTVs caught it. 3. User / Caller Identity: You are misconstruing facts here. There is a difference between "Privacy" and "Anonymity". Same debate can be had for "Ensuring a Single Person in an ATM booth with hidden keypad" v/s "Wearing a Helmet in an ATM booth". 4. KYC: Know-Your-Customer/Consumer is necessary... Not-having-KYC is absolutely not in conflict or serve any benefit for the consumer in any form or manner. 5. Insolvency Code: Why Govt. shouldn't get back control of the Spectrum in case of insolvency. Banks own the financial / funding of operations aspect; they don't own the spectrum / technology. It is like if you are bankrupt, the bank which loaned your house will now own your wife / spouse. There is no transitive ownage concept like in the feudal system of yore. What can be given, can be revoked. It is that simple. Consumer-will changes and Govt-security is the only debatable point here. A very loose one at that as in that too consumer in a free market is free to choose. 6. Internet Lockdown: Why this is even a problem. Internet is not a "Fundamental Right". Every country has an "Emergency / Crisis / National Security" provision. In case of "Financial Distress" SEBI / Market has the right to choose, why shouldn't Govt. In case of a war or such conditions "Civil rights are dissolved". Lawful blockage of internet or a wire-tap (a non-fundamental right) is also had via Legal means. It is not in Govt. / Police hands. What is even the point here? Of course, there are problems of over-reach / opposition suppression, those are the "real" points to be addressed here...

[@elitex0007]

I prefer to make changes to the Bill so that it won't kill new innovations coming up. Though, other side of the bill is pretty good until misused by Center itself. This could be done as by using something called quotas and company will require the Licence if they exceeds the quota Limit, or there could be other way as well.

[@itachi9016]

This video is a bit misleading.the license is only for ott apps and apps with calling feature.

[@itachi9016]

@@yesudeep license is for the service these apps are providing.

[@missadventures3883]

first crypto-ban and then intrusion into my privacy, i think most of quality youth will leave india if government starts acting how they are suppose to do

[@tsource7]

This what happens when you give too much of power to an individuals.. why there should be a charge for internet related calls...

[@umeshbhilare4837]

Good review 👍 But I would like to express my support to the government on this. Internal security is a most important threat we face. For that we might have to face some discomfort. Result will be very helpful just like demonetisation.

[@Diffping]

Demonetisation was a failure

[@choclatecrayon8671]

Rogue demonitization was a success. Whole india got digitialized, informal economy got formalised, more pep pay tax now and under gst net. Ed raid weekly 100 crore, 300 crore from pep. Terror black money funding to naxals dead..terror attacks down

[@pratikislove2893]

Exactly demonitization was succes - india got digital economy, double times the people now online, informal economy became formal, more people in gst net and paying tax, terror attacks in naxal areas down coz whole black money in forest now rendered useless. Ed catching 300 crore , 200 crore weekly from industrialist and politicians

[@shahrukhkotwal7125]

Why doesn't the Government make Election Bonds transparent foe National Security 🤔???

[@nikhilkashid3284]

just a opinion : your previous set up was more compelling ; love your videos ❤️

[@samedu5163]

This bill should'nt pass... Already internet recharge prices are high... Don't want to pay more on watsapp n all now☹️

[@LifeGeneralist]

Marketing calls against DND is the biggest pro of this bill. As much as licensing is bad for voice calls and messages, national security is also pivotal in curbing terrorism both local and internationally sponsored terrorism

[@Tum_Tum_]

Ganesh praises good govt schemes and equally criticizes bad schemes. Good job think school.

[@dheevar]

Almost every government of leading nations have a similar provision in the name of national security. The most famous being Patriot Act. We also have to consider the way people including corporates misusing their rights because there is absence of clear cut rules. The main point here could also be of the revenue that the govt is expecting to earn due to these changes. Ultimately it all boils down to that.

[@MOHAMMED-gi2uh]

Amazing research as usual, never missed any of your video only due to quality of the content

[@आयुष_उपाध्याय]

Hahaha Mohmmad 🤣

[@sauravjaiswal2204]

🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈 Be careful umma

[@sachinrajgs]

Sorry to say this, Govt may even think to take this video down now

[@dhirendrarath8001]

Bjp is not like pongress

[@AntiFurryJihad]

This law will take your privacy and freedom in the name for national security for authorian purposes.

[@RahulKumar-we6sx]

The bill broadly excludes internet-based communication services and OTT platforms like apps from its licensing requirements. However, it grants the government the right to issue licenses for specific services as needed, leaving some uncertainty about future regulations. If the bill is passed your app might not require a license at this time based on the current definition of excluded services. However, it's important to closely monitor any future regulations or clarifications issued by the government, as the scope of licensing could evolve. If your app falls under specific services deemed crucial for national security or public safety, the government might require licensing in the future

[@harshchauhan9271]

The system has already been prevailing in most west 'developed' countries, which is what we want India to be (a developed country), therefore, there shouldn't be a problem with this bill passing.

[@cyrptolover]

Video editing, presentation and explanation going leaps and bounds...👌 50+ million subscribers by 2024

[@daxvadadoriya9519]

India doesn't have 50 million intelegent people.

[@cyrptolover]

@@daxvadadoriya9519 ban bollywood and cricket and we will probably have 250 million people

[@ajayd6237]

Plz don't put these misleading thumbnail. Btw, explanation is superb.

[@manishparab7128]

The thumbnail is on point. Said it as it is no bullsh*t

[@1234jokerboy]

Thumbnail like this inserts curiosity. It is an art. Nothing wrong with that.

[@ajayd6237]

as i can see the thumbnail is changed. i am talking about the first one.

[@charancherry8720]

It often requires the interest to look into thick and thin of every issue, may be of any kind. Really loved your analysis and I'm so curious to see what goes in the production of these videos and your preparation of staged analysis.

[@विचित्रलड़का]

Ok. 1. The license scheme is for voice call apps. Not every app would have to take a license for that. How will it prevent innovation? 2. The license doesn't restrict the apps from innovation. It just gets them in a category where government can apply rule to get information out of it.