Why the 2020 Farm Laws Won't Solve India's Farming Crisis | Part 3 | FULL EPISODE

[@RajdeepSingh-se8rm]

I’m a farmer and I salute scoopwhoop for coming between us, talk to us, understanding the problems, try to find solutions and for supporting farmers

[@aldrinkolakkal3034]

Hey !! Thank you for feeding us!! RESPECT+

[@funbegins2371]

salute to you and ur gang for taking india backwards by decades

[@Beinghumane1]

These farm laws would have been easily repealed and new reforms could have been done if our media system did their job honestly to serve citizens not government.

[@thv4808]

Are our media is doing it's job so promptly... Kitne wafadaar hain o tabhi government k against kuch ni bolte jo bhi law aaye uska hamesha benefit hi dikhaya jaata hain.. Uske alawa ye log bhaag b to rhe hai celebrities k peeche controversial k liye

[@ashwanichandola7899]

Please tell how

[@namanjain8559]

@@ashwanichandola7899 chl gya pta?

[@phantom2k858]

yeah this bs , was so confusing to watch on tv , nice thing i found this channel

[@arribahumano-javiermontes9118]

Holy shkt ,thats so true!!

[@LakhanUK]

Not farmer but full support to farmers, their way of protest won my heart. Don't think that peaceful protest is not helping you, we all are watching your dedication,patience and fair demands , and also supporting as much as we can

[@Hightides897]

@Vishal Gupta chal be baniye, saal bhar se baith rakhe hain. Khud BJP wale sab karwate hain. Home ministry jawab dehi hai ki log Lal Qile tak kaise pahunche aur BJP ne hi Guru Granth Sahib ki beadbi ke liye bhade ke tattu ko bheja tha jisko Nihango ne jhatka diya.. tu apni kapne ta kirane ki jo bhi dukan hai woh sambhal kisano ke maamle me na muh mare.

[@starboi5909]

@@Hightides897 tameez nhi sikhyai kya tumhare badho nai ?? Kya bey baniya kya hota hai Is this is a respectable way to address someone

[@Hightides897]

@@starboi5909 mere badho ne sikhaya hai ki koi pyaar se bole to double pyaar do aur koi battmeezi kare to dho do. Aur tumhe itne logon me mera hi comment dikha aur jo log Sikhs ke baare me bak rahe hain woh nahi dikh raha. Selective reading ka bimar insaan.

[@mansirautela7527]

Thank you so much Scoopwhoop Unscripted, for uploading this series on KZbin. These videos are very important. Keep up the good work!👏❤️

[@harveyspecter1795]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGSsi5RsqbWHjas

[@mcboat3467]

In short we need same stuff that russian peasants and workers did in 1917. Destroy capitalism

[@sidakkcreativity2205]

RESPECT to whole SCOOPWHOOP team lots of love and support

[@harveyspecter1795]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGSsi5RsqbWHjas

[@AnuragSingh-gj7ou]

Yes how smoothly they get exposed by cobrapost😂 respect ok

[@penacle7]

@@AnuragSingh-gj7ou cobrapost never exposes piyush goel how since 2014 when he sells companies he makes 1000 x profit , or cobra post never covers everyone be Amitabh Bachchan, Aishwarya rai or Ajay devgan whose names were in Panama files nothing happened to them, while even in rouge state like pakistan took action against Nawaz Sharif coz then PM when his name appeared in Panama files, Cobra post never questioned regarding the qualification and ability of Jay Shah, or fact during Bengal elections Home minister said soon after wining elections ABP will be on our side, cobra post never exposed UNA BJP leader and how he killed the whole family of the rape victim?

[@harpreetsingh6075]

Bhai itne likes tu to star ban gyia 😊😅😅

[@AnuragYadav-jw1dq]

Government can only buy MSP crops in limited quantity as per the requirements of their food security programmes . It's practically impractical that one think government must buy all farm produce from farmers . Government must only provide subsidy for fertilizer , irrigation . If one thinks government can buy entire farm produce and achievable then good luck socialist policies can never be pushed too far as Venezuela .

[@guptalokswain6115]

This is a matter of concern..we should support our farmers in all aspects..so that together we will grow and make a better future...

[@indiathatisbharat7252]

You know who arhitiyas are, they have money and therefore power, just see what happens next after Capt gone, have you seen this protest in Kerala or Assam or arunachal Pradesh. This is just a pro khalistani movement with personal interest of people from other side of border. You forgot how udta Punjab came , this chitta ie white powder ie drugs has already ruined many youth and comes via other side of border, why do you think near election now more and more drones from Pakistan are coming, more underground tunnels are being found, sidhu is with Pak now even captain said it so now don't call me sanghi or that shit ok. I'm a civilizational nationalist person so not with BJP , no party does all I want. This is just time to chose that a instability in this region will be beneficial to who. Now options are BJP plus Capt Or AAP the most dangerous one Or Cong Or akali and bsp No full support in my sight, I live in himachal Pradesh near China border which is near to punjab uttarakhand and the uncle saying potato he sold at 8 rupees , I sold at 13 and do 4 crops of potatoes a year , and comparing indian farmer with 1 acre land holding to Americas with 100 acres of farm's then you know how intelligence is being used. Just disorder is what this protest is , if farmer's were all the time on roads then why are Agri production and exports at all time high.

[@harisadu8998]

There are too many farmers in India, that itself is a big problem.

[@Sagar-wn1po]

WHAT CAN YOU DO? Diversify your diet, eat more of nutri-cereals like Bajra, Maize, Ragi, Alsi, Chana in shape of Chapati. Make vegetables and fruits main part of your diet. Have one handfull of Dry fruits and peanuts per day, eat Amla (candy or murabba or raw). Create demand of products other than rice and wheat, market will follow you. P.S- Me and my family has done this 2 years ago. We are healthier too.

[@Sagar-wn1po]

@@indiathatisbharat7252 bhai Potato saal me 4 saal kabse hone lag gayi :P? I am from southern haryana and yaha potato october crop hai. Agar aap 4 bar grow kar rahe ho to ho sakta hai wo Pahadi potato honge. Unke daam 13 kya, 20 hone chahiye. Kisan Ekta Zindabaad. Kisan Andolan Zindabad. Hum bhi Indian hi hai, aapka pata nahi par hum to army me bahot log bhejte hai, ek bar google karo, Ahirwal, land of soldiers. Nationalism ka gyaan humko nahi chahiye, hum apna nationalism Olympics me medal aur border par shaheed hokar dikhaate hai.

[@hackbaba999]

@@indiathatisbharat7252 i mean, there's only 1 way to find out if what you're trying to say is true. Repeal the laws, make msp a law and then see if they finish the protest or not? If they don't, you're right, and if they do, you're a sanghi proved!

[@Sammy-rb9uz]

Jai kissan jai bharat💯🙏

[@harveyspecter1795]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGSsi5RsqbWHjas

[@satishpatil5865]

That's one of the finest brief analysis I ever watched on state of Indian Agriculture. Thank you. Keep up good work..!! 💐🙏

[@shantanushinde7291]

for your info ADANI group in himachle buying apple at cost of 16 rs per kg and selling it 240 rs per kg . while APMC (mandi) buying it 130 rs ... and mandi in himachle is shut down ... farmers are protesting against adani group ..😭😭

[@sachinsain9952]

To is hisaab se mandi choti chor h and Adani bada chor h....lekin chori dono kar rahe h.

[@godofparadoxes6190]

Please increase your knowledge your comment seems like full of stupidity and propaganda

[@sachinsain9952]

Please increase your sense of commenting on social platforms.

[@shantanushinde7291]

@@sachinsain9952 i have sense .. ✌✌

[@vanshsingh3254]

@@shantanushinde7291 no bro

[@amansharma-ol4ou]

this triseries is damn good , gonna recommend it to everybody who argue that farmers are wrong

[@amigo2hundred]

Who made the graphics for this video ?!!!!!!!! They are DAMN GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD!!!!!!!

[@saptarshimukherjee009]

If you don't watch vox.. You won't get where from they got these graphics😉

[@Shubham-fk5oq]

@@saptarshimukherjee009 they actually copied whole mograph at this point

[@HakikatBirSinghBhatti]

Raunaq singh chopra is the Man ... he did not just the script research and camera but also the EDITING AND ANIMATION sachmein, one man army ... Maaan gaye Raunaq bhai. Pehley sirf Johnny Harris ka tha ab aapka bhi Fan ❤️

[@batman3490]

@@Shubham-fk5oq nothing wrong in copying good things if it gives good results to people. who knows vox also may copied from somewhere else...

[@MuhammedYaseenofficial]

@@saptarshimukherjee009 😍😀

[@SajanSOneWorlD]

India really needs this type of detailed documentaries for understanding the core issues we are faceing... Love from kerala❤

[@HarkiratSingh-iv9zb]

This was explained beautifully 🥺

[@renainsafi4645]

Answer to your closing question: absolute lack of empathy, absolute lack of will.

[@anonymou.s817]

Agree. 🙏

[@ameyjain3462]

Because its hard and privatization is easy

[@deeptobhattacharyya3249]

@@ameyjain3462 at this point we dont really need a govt if there are no institutions, lets just take a subscription for everything

[@parwindersingh84]

Hatsoff to this explanation.. it truly depicts the pain of farmers.. Those who envy punjabs wealth.. need to understand the wear and tear of its resources..

[@nofsy5271]

This laws will intensify ongoing pollution by the so called green revolution & make Punjab a desert land like Rajasthan. which will eventually force famers to suicide , migrate , do labor. this is how punjabis will be diminished till 2050.

[@doesntmatter155]

@@nofsy5271 what is the law? Without looking into google can u tell me? Or are you doing bullshit over what people are saying or what media is saying...?

[@leonardodicaprio9973]

This is the best video I've ever seen in ScoopWhoop Unscripted. I feel like I'm watching Vox. The editing of this video is excellent.

[@Avi_lays]

Isn't gov responsibility to make and ensure there is more and everywhere the mandis????

[@GS-ku2gz]

Yes it is..... But they don't care

[@bhaaweshkumar552]

They only work for corporate

[@nss2302]

Well to them, development of mandi seems like a waste of time and money.

[@GS-ku2gz]

@@nss2302 they want to keep 60%population (farmers) as poor otherwise they'll start demanding their rights and won't be satisfied with 5 kilo wheat and 10 kilo rice

[@gauthampai896]

mandis are completely useless tho. there is a reason why so many farmers commit suicide.

[@prashantjd]

You guys should make seperate episode on how to do restorative agriculture revolution. So people should get more idea about it .

[@sgill7059]

Restorative Agriculture is good but this whole thing is about giving fair price of crops to farmers. Btw i am supporter of restorative agriculture practices.

[@brothermanbill7338]

Acha.. ScoopWhoop ye karega to policy makers aur Govt kya karegi??

[@prashantjd]

@@brothermanbill7338 Government par kuch bharosa nahi raha ab

[@kritikaghai5882]

@@brothermanbill7338 why do you think it's just government's job to do everything... Listen.. you need to understand that jese private players ke hath main sab kuch chorne se barbad hota hai.. ese hi sabkuch sarkar ke bharose chorne se bhi barbad hota hai. People need to think and use their brains also. For example, Kerala. If you know about the agricultural shift in Kerala you would know that it was done in partnership of people and government. Akele nahi hoga. Sabko contribute karna hoga.. vo chahe advice ho kyu na ho.

[@freddythobhani6181]

It's very sad to see everyone around me thinks farmers are protesting for no reason. National media and govt have made farmers villains. Same on India as a nation. Great work ScoopWhoop.

[@joylearner7501]

👍👍

[@itsnotraunaq]

One of the best explanations on the issue!

[@shubhamjohri290]

Scoopwhoop's stand on this issue was as expected

[@jsksingh88]

Great presentation !! We need everyone to see this.

[@geandraige3936]

It's kinda sad we have twice as much grain than needed and there are still starving children just make a system distributing the excessive grain to the slums or those below the poverty line sort of like the lungals its not like we will need all of those extra 40 tons of grain for our storage just use them to feed the less privileged

[@gundeep0]

Basically, you are right, it will change nothing for the govt and do good for the country. But govt wont do it, i also wondered why so here is the maths, remember india has time yo time donated the grains to some other countries for relief work... But the problem is in the economics. The grain even if not used, on paper costed something, even if some of it rots, its still equivalent in equity to what it costed. But if huge sums.of it is distributed to the poor, even if it doesn't cost anything to the govt, in the books it has to recorded as expenditure, and goes under fiscal defecit.. So if govt wants to keep fiscal defecit low it wont distribute it, even if it rots in FCI godowns Basically when i say "distribution costs govt nothing" actually it does. as the govt has to allocate the equal amount to FCI, which actually holds the grain, and this amount goes in expenditure. ..,... So its just a numbers game.

[@geandraige3936]

@@gundeep0 but why are they valuing fiscal defecit at such a high standard mean as long as the records are made public as to why the expenditures have increased I don't think it will affect the over all administration sure it will make their records a mess in dew time but that in my opinion can be fixed in few days with a committe of experts also why is our goverment paying to take out food from its own storage I mean fci bought that grain using government assigned budget and now to use that food goverment has to pay again Brother this system is a mess

[@gundeep0]

@@geandraige3936 see if you have 1000 cash in a box and spend 500 to buy gold and place it in the same box the box is still worth 1000, so no profit no loss in buying, it only makes a difference if now you give the gold to someone for 100 cash and place 100 in the box, now your box is worth 600, So act of buying is not an issue and act of distribution is.

[@gundeep0]

@Weasel Can't Swim you cannot replace something which is poorly functioning with something 10 times worse, these farm laws will not solve anything. Instead will destroy the current farming, that is exactly what the video is about, these laws have been implemented in various countries only bringing farmers to even poorer state. Even in india bihar already has these from more than a decade, but the in this decade their farming is so severely destroyed.

[@superabadtalkies2157]

malnourishment doesn't mean starving, the main issue is we consume more carbohydrates and no protein and other minerals which is detrimental to kids health. for example, see what kids eat under the midday scheme

[@gurpreetmann6684]

We know about other nations situation as well. So these laws will definitely not work in favour of farmers. See what adani did in Himachal.

[@suteekshnamishra5218]

What did he do?Any lights?

[@gurpreetmann6684]

@@suteekshnamishra5218 read some news about himachal apple growers how Adani is manipulating its prices although u get same apple at 200-250 per kg. He is giving 12-75 per kg. But selling at 250.

[@schrodinger8605]

Itne paise chatti pe leke jaenge kya yeh log

[@gurpreetmann6684]

@@schrodinger8605 lagta hai

[@parvsaxena5006]

Buddy I have a campsite in Manali and I have given my camp premises to Farmers for collection and packing of apples. Seems like your knowledge is limited to news only. Farmer's there have choice to send their apples to anywhere and this year they are getting surplus amounts.

[@sanskar4539]

Let’s have another agriculture revolution for our farmers ✊Kisaan Ekta Zindabaad ✊

[@sanskar4539]

Sushant Kumar Green Revolution ki tarah firse kisaano ki zindagi achi krne ke liye ek revolution ni hosqti?🙂Isme hass kr bilkul manhoos lgrha hai tu .

[@SuperYoman100]

@@sanskar4539 Green revolution ki tarah?! Part 1 aur 2 nahi dekha isi video ka?!

[@sanskar4539]

SuperYoman100 arey I mean to say let’s get back to organic farming. So let’s say organic farming and distinct farming revolution

[@sanskar4539]

SuperYoman100 padhliya bhai ik green revolution se kisaano ka nuksaan hua hai

[@jazzkharbanda4050]

I Support Farmers. National Media can learn from SU. All those who disliked this video belong to Godi Media or Andhbhakats.

[@abhishekspyware]

Learn to disagree

[@jazzkharbanda4050]

@@abhishekspyware learn to give logical reasons.

[@Sanjay-gc1fd]

It's political anyways, where people are protesting against CAA NRC etc.

[@jazzkharbanda4050]

@@Sanjay-gc1fd u look like a andh bhakat, who picked a topic, not discussed in this video.

[@taurusied7447]

@@jazzkharbanda4050 I would like to check the authenticity of these farmers

[@chiragsharma1496]

So happy that scoopwhooop unscripted posted this series on KZbin

[@user-cv1jb9xv2p]

I request all in name of Bhagwaan, Allah, Raabb please share all the three parts of this series and ask them to share it also. It's an humble request please

[@faizanahmad8120]

Andhbhakt will won't understand brother

[@SooheRang]

What a beautiful presentation with full of facts and information! Loved it 👍🏻

[@rupanbrar5601]

Chahe ads zyada daal diya kro but video youtube pe hi upload kar diya kro

[@rajwantkaursohal4819]

Good job Unscripted Team

[@Drdeepz]

Farmers are the breadwinner of humanity. I would never be against our indian farmers. This tells too much commeralisatiin is death of civilization. One need to improvise and not nullify the old system. My wholehearted support to the farmers 🙏👍

[@Eagle-eyesight]

China.....Agriculture before 1978 and after 1978....

[@shubhamjohri290]

Farmer unions are just looking to further their own interests, they also got concession in anti stubble burning provisions of new laws. So switch on your brain and think what's in YOUR interest, not theirs.

[@xdgtwjk23_rtfd]

America/europe wale bhi yhi bolte to.. wo bhi aaj hamari tarah gaddho me sadak dhundh rahe hote...

[@dhruvpuri6546]

@@shubhamjohri290 how much brainwashed you are xd :) how much old are ypu

[@dhruvpuri6546]

@@shubhamjohri290 seems like to me 14-15 years

[@utkag06]

Bhai salute hai editor ko God level editing ki hai dono parts ki ( 2 and 3) Really loved the explaination. Plus the people who were there as guests seemed pretty knowledgeable in their respective fields. I am proud and happy that our country's citizens are taking ecological and sustainable concepts seriously.This was though these kind of analysis were also required in 1970's but it's never too late.

[@jasdeepkaur2495]

Very well explained. The government needs to watch this so that they can educate themselves.

[@GurmeetSingh-pm9kj]

Bhen ji Govt is acting oversmart here to benefit industrialists.

[@jasdeepkaur2495]

@@GurmeetSingh-pm9kj Yes

[@translatingthingsCS]

@@GurmeetSingh-pm9kj They even know the things they're doing is wrong.... Not talkin about modi he's idiot his cabinet play's the game for ambani & Adani.

[@translatingthingsCS]

@Time Machine oh ho hoo look guys we have intellectual arround here first of all kiddo Farmers don't pay direct tax but just look at the indirect taxes they're paying which is even more than an average common person taxes "ek baar agriculture needed products ka bill dikhaunga toh teri fat ke hath me aa jaayegi" And Punjab brings cancer so kiddo who's in first place to sown thet seed bro you're commenting on video which you've not seen... Atleast bother to see that video.. that who give this mastermind idea to burn parali and thing logically who's duty to fix this mess.

[@translatingthingsCS]

@Time Machine and Idiot you're gettin orgasm about private players bro they're not here to invest in Agriculture Sector that's goverment duty they not gonna bring some good techniques they're just coming in this sector for buying and selling! What are you imagining kid? Some dreams

[@girlwithweirdthoughts]

Respect to the farmers of the country and the ScoopWhoop unscripted team.

[@eng.lit.carnival4810]

An 👁opening video.

[@aemssw2387]

Farmers should be Categorised, Just like Middle Class, based on "Income & Land"

[@kashvisingh297]

This is so heart breaking! Thank you for explaining it so well

[@theecho4667]

A great example of Restorative Agriculture has been setup by Chhattisgarh’s current Chief Minister Shri Bhupesh Baghel, Narwa-Garva-Ghurva-Bari. It is doing wonders. He has started a revolution already, Narwa means Canals, Garva means cattle, Ghurva is Compost Pit and Bari is Kitchen Garden.

[@aryapraagya]

I subscribed once and could only watch the 3 videos that were on unscripted news app at the time. In my opinion, its really hard to justify a subscription every month. Maybe make it a lifetime subscription of Rs.1000 or something We genuinely want to support the work you do. Keep it up!

[@dubscore9343]

If you will see the there is a lot of money required for research and for ground report. Giving Rs.1000 For one time wont help them to continue their work. Thats why all the OTT companies like Netflix wont consider selling a lifetime subscription to general public. Be sensible and Appreciate whats being provided.

[@harveyspecter1795]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGSsi5RsqbWHjas

[@MrBruh-xc1qy]

@@dubscore9343 there's not only one type of content on Netflix it has a lot of content from the starting, if Netflix had 10 or 20 movies and thier price was 1000₹ per month or something they would never even earn enough to buy copyrights for movies so I would say starting at a low rate and then making a sustainable price when there's enough audience would be better. No hate tho 😊

[@adityapatil325]

@@MrBruh-xc1qy Netflix is middle man, Schoopwhoop is creating the content. Schoopwhoop might need to consider more options (like paying small amount for single video). Hopefully the money they get helps them expand.

[@lazyloser678]

@@adityapatil325 Netflix also help creaters. With money to produce or direct their movies or tv shows and marketing.

[@randeepsingh4999]

Very knowledgeable...Watch all 3 parts one by one... Thank you so much for sharing🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@ashish4900]

If MSP is increased for crops other than rice and wheat subsequently year by year along with awareness campaigns among the producers, then I think farmers might adopt the mixed farming.

[@Maverick170]

we want to do mixed farming a year ago we grow mustard plants. but we didn't get actual prices.

[@jagjeetturka3379]

We r happy with mixed farming but no fix price for these crop, and risk factors is high

[@BHULLARGAGAN]

Yes you are right.. Most farmers wants to do mixed farming but they will not get fair price

[@Ari-ne2yb]

@@jagjeetturka3379 Yes. Government should definitely fix the price for other crops. Has the government been willing to negotiate with farmers after the repeal?

[@Amith-ky8hw]

Amazing series by Sccopwhoop unscripted . Cheers to the entire team 😊

[@arijitpal2294]

When few businessmen run the country and a wellfare state starts to act like a broker to business entities then this happens.. Standing with farmers..

[@shubhamjohri290]

Awwwwwww, which businesses's mobile and intenret you are using?

[@mankirat18]

@@shubhamjohri290 who facilitated jio acquiring licenses at a short notice? Who facilitated the defence industry of anil ambani for manufacturing rafale airframes when he did not even have an aerospace manufacturer license yet...moreover a minimum 10 years of experience required to produce fighter aircraft's airframe was bypassed for ambani by which government??? Dasault raised objections 6 times regarding this disastrous cronyism but was overruled by which govt ?? Andhbhakti m tum salo apni maa bhi bech doge modi ko .

[@penacle7]

@@shubhamjohri290 which country apart from India which uses JIO? In how many countries is reliance growing or has so much dominance apart from India? I use airtel of bharati mittal who is also an Indian, also he was not lying and killing competition it was government to protect other businesses also. why airtel doesnt give jobs or is not own by an indian so why so jio jio? only difference is reliance funds political party

[@arijitpal2294]

@@shubhamjohri290 Awwww..This is because of monopoly market...Awwww by the way your chacha doesn't provide it for free...Awww I do pay for this...Aww I think you got my point...Awww the whole world is now Ambani and Adani..Right mr Awwwwwww????Btw mr Awwww myobile is not from JIO...Mr Awwww 😂😂

[@amritpalsidhu6454]

@@arijitpal2294 haha le li tumne toh awwww... Ki , jab 1.2 business person ke pass monopoly hogi toh unki hi banai hui cheej use krni padhegi na . Jab roti pani bhi woh control krenge tab iski awww... Niklegi

[@shreyans.kothari-78]

Everything nicely done, explanation, graphics, content, story line. Awesome, keep up the good work.

[@shahistashaikh7481]

I was waiting for this these farmers are so brave and powerful hatsoff to them and also to schoopwhopp unscripted for showing the real side

[@shubhamjohri290]

Yes you will support anything against BJP we know

[@penacle7]

@@shubhamjohri290 read the farm laws, so you are saying the law which says hoarding is good is for farmers and consumers ? you are saying law that encourages black marketing is good? Ok then BJP also said no one died due to lack of oxygen during second wave so many people even im who know so many who died due to shortage of oxygen and medicine so they are wrong BJP is right and we cant even question the govt who says we acch din aayenge? kyu ? if the BJP govt was making scene and running around protesting when fuel price was 35 rs and now when its 100 rs , especially when all reserves are stocked last year when crude oil price was all time low so you are saying if we question for fuel prices we are wrong or again? kyu ? why they lied ? when today unemployment is all time high and if we question bhai what are you doing to generate jobs coz i never met a company owner or factory owner who would like to hire more people , in othr countries its govt that ensure people have jobs and less unemployment , also its not i but PM who every year at red fort promises jobs , if we question then we are against ? kyu

[@penacle7]

@@shubhamjohri290 you are reflection of failed education system, nor you can question a teacher when you dont get or understand anything or nor you seek to solve problem, you just mug from tutions or teacher notes or guide and omit in exams and forget everything. even if someone is sick good doctor will ask questions the patient to understand the symptoms and patient will ask doctor what i got and how the treatment will work and in what time i will be fine ? you are strange asking a government that make number of promises but didnt deliver and if we question then who are you ? are you from north korea maybe you are use to the system there ??

[@narendranarendra5143]

@@penacle7 first you read them

[@penacle7]

@@narendranarendra5143 In chapter 2 point 6 of the farm bill, its clearly mentioned that any trade outside the APMC won’t be entitled to tax, or any trade out of the mandi would be free of the APMC act. Presently, any trade in APMC or mandi is entitled to 8% taxation. So my nature no one is a fool and willing to pay a tax. This is a way to facilitate farmers to go for more private player, eventually no trade in APMC will result in mandi to dissolve over time. As the private players initially will give lucrative prices. However, overtime this will result in shrinking and weaking of APMC and eventually end of them. Then farmers would be left only to private buyers. These buyers normally work in group. How I know, as I have worked and had dealt both the ends. I know the union of the private buyers and how they control certain prices. People are debating mandi or APMC are bad. However, data shows the farmers are doing well with present APMC both in Punjab and Haryana. Mandi, have always been shown bad but in other states hardly in Punjab or Harayana, also there can be few bad apples that doesn’t mean the system is not working there. Also, you should understand the 8% tax goes to state govt. State govt need to carry out different activities which are not paid why centre and are state affair and this tax contributes towards it.Also, government says there wont be any foul play in private trade outsid APMC mandi then why 4 cr of fraud took place in MP where BJP in power and why this law failed?

[@shubhamchandrakant3144]

Awesome, I have shared with all my students. Keep it up ❤❤

[@jasmansingh3760]

respect to all of you

[@parmindertalwandi3530]

Thanks to this channel from all indian FARMER #NO FARMER NO CHEAP FOOD#

[@hasrathussain4747]

Respect for Indian Farmers

[@rahuliganlife]

WOW!! Superb informative video, guys. Keep up the good work, team scoopwhoop unscripted. Godspeed!!

[@Ranvirkhokhar]

Thanks scoopwhoop unscripted otherwise people have no time to think about food providers 🙏🙏

[@bhaviktanna6451]

Awesome video guys ! Probably the best one I have seen it till now on this topic. Keep up the good work 👏

[@anubhav.music28]

Best video I've seen today. Much needed information for common non-agricultural people like me. And I want to thank ScoopWhoop for keeping alive this dying issue of farmers protest.

[@shubhamjohri290]

Video never mentioned that MSP was never a law before, why should it be a law now.

[@singhtalks2256]

Love your team, please spread this

[@studyonline4763]

The new farm "laws" will only amplify the bad and destroy whatever good that still remains in the current system

[@Manish_Kumar_Singh]

there is no good in the current system

[@munnaengineer7630]

Very nice video.. credit to research team and anchor to presenting a knowledgeable video. Love your work 💕

[@sudeepchauhan243]

Really feeling bad for farmers , now today they understand government intentions our people start calling them terrorist . 💔

[@dennisphilip6479]

True media sensation , keep up the great work , Scoopwhoop always comes correct with socio political issues ! The research and development done in all your videos is commendable !! Please make more content like these 🙏

[@177_atulsharma9]

Such a great series it is thank you scoopwoop 👍👍

[@krishnachaitanya1220]

God bless our farmers jai Jawan Jai Kisan 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@mustardoil3841]

I don't know who told them about Bihar but most of farmers in Bihar have land as small as 1800 sq meter ie 1 katha or 100 to 200 gaj.This land was fit for making house not farming.The largest size of land anybody holds in Bihar is close to 10 bigha .And anyone who owns 10 Bigha is a rich landlord who will have multiple business.

[@Aman12353]

Bihar and up is disaster that's why they come to Punjab to sell their farm product

[@tmkc14]

Bro 1800 sq mtr is more than 1800 gaj, everything else is okay 😅

[@gurwindersandhu5715]

Average landholding is half acre in bihar . I googled it. Keralites have even less avg landholding but still they are richer. So , i don't think bihar's poor farming system is because of less landhilding.

[@user-cv1jb9xv2p]

12:40 to 12:53 Absolutely right, true.👌👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

[@suriyasuriya671]

Maturity is when u realised farmer's life doesn't improve before farm law and goes into hell after farm law

[@navjeetkhatkar2954]

Thank you scoop whoop for representing real situation and not just proving any agenda.

[@abrahammathew5872]

Meanwhile the migrant workers from Uttar pradesh who are working in the fields of Punjab and Haryana return to there state,vote for BJP and support farm laws. 🤣🤣🤣

[@Ajaypalsingh_]

🤣🤣🤣🤣 Up valo ka kch ni ho skta 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️😂

[@INDPYROTECH]

😂

[@mohitchoudhury2739]

Hatta off what a series 🙏

[@KameKurma]

As if there are farmers only in Punjab . Moreover , they do farming which literally damages the soil and uses a way lot more water. Some serious changes are required to help the farmers.

[@Iabshsndkdvd]

Thanks for showing truth🙏 Jai kisan ekta

[@injeelahmed]

ScoopWhoop seems very much inspired by the VOX documentary's editing.

[@rishabyadav8439]

Restoration, mixed and organic farming is the great way to revive ecosystem and economy at the same time.

[@mustardoil3841]

Organic farming can happen at a very small scale.Result of doing it on large scale can be seen in Sri Lanka as a food crisis.

[@rishabyadav8439]

@@mustardoil3841 its not about only organic farming instead government should give assured minimum pricing on other crops and vegetables also instead of only with the rice and wheat. By doing so will not only boost confidence in farmers to produce other seasonal crops too but also creates a variety in the market with more dynamic economy.

[@mustardoil3841]

@@rishabyadav8439 do you know how msp is paid to farmers It is done on taxpayers money and the crops brought are used to feed the poor or given to ration shops.The food on our plate are generally not msp bought.If every thing is guaranteed and sold on msp then we would require more middlemen.Everything would be bought by government.Already a large part of budget goes into this.If everything was to be purchased at msp by government , then there woild be no money left for anything else.Everything would be bought by government and sold by government.Already the system is overlogged.This would just create problems and where would the money for buying all the crops come from??

[@rishabyadav8439]

If government can pay msp on rice and wheat throughout the year and collects 91 MT of grains and just 48 MT is sufficient then it shows that government have enough funds to provide msp. Government only have to restructure their msp policy by providing msp on different crops with corresponding season. In the season of wheat provide msp on wheat, in the season of maze switch msp from wheat to maze and so on. Instead of providing msp on same crop through out the year..regulate msp on different crops in different seasons.

[@seedoflight3453]

ਟਿੱਕਰੀ ਬਾਡਰ "WMK" 🙏 #kisaan_mjdoor_ekta_zindabaad

[@Keepitupfootball]

Very informative. Cleared lot of doubts and improved my awareness towards new farm laws and the way our system works. Seriously need a big revolution now. But unfortunately the political system doesn’t have the will to improve the lives of our farmers

[@aruntaneja2997]

Your channel is revolution brother in this scenario of corrupted media. May God gives you more strength and endeavour to do the right thing👍🏻

[@gurman2267]

Why does the government not provide MSP on other types of crops? Why MSP is provided on crops like wheat only? Is there any reason behind that? If MSP is provided on other types of crops, I think it may encourage our farmers to produce different kinds of crops other than wheat. This will reduce the over-supply of wheat and hence reduce the wastage of wheat getting rotten in storage facilities. There must be some logical reason behind this.

[@harveyspecter1795]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGSsi5RsqbWHjas

[@rupanbrar5601]

Govts just like to do easy tasks and do not take much burden.Other crops need high quality checks and expensive to store. Quality of wheat and paddy do not vary largely. Procurement is easy and strict quality checks are not required

[@Sanjay-gc1fd]

do you even know what these MSP buyers do? they say ki hamare yaha ka storage bhar chuka hai, kahi aur ko becho. Fir vo kisan kisi bhi aadmi ko kam rates me bech deta h otherwise it will rot. Fir wohi MSP wala usi admi se kharid leta h, isse us Entry wale ki kamai hoti h, kyunki usne MSP ke rate se kam me kharid liya. Toh it doesn't matters, corruption loopholes pehle hi nikaal leta h na

[@gurman2267]

@@Sanjay-gc1fd Yes I did not know about this loophole. Thanks for pointing it out. fir to jo traders hai...jinhe license milta hai...unpe scrutiny honi chaiye....ya unka license har 2 saal me renew hona chaiye after thoroughly scrutinizing them and their past deals and the feedbacks of the sellers, if any. But again, as long as there is corruption, buyers/traders will keep on finding these loopholes in the system :(.

[@Sanjay-gc1fd]

@@gurman2267 Yes aur India me sarkari officers ko bahot power di jaati h, let me give you another example jaha pe Mumbai ke twin towers ko demolish kia jaa rha h bcs illegal construction, lekin officers pe koi charge nhi laga jinhone construction hone dia, unhone ghus leke kaam krne dia hoga. Aur zyada se zyada sarkaar karti bhi kya h, unhe posting ya 1 week ka suspension de deti h Lol. Aur ye corruption toh direct cause h colonialism ka, imagine india kitna corrupt hoga british ke under me lol

[@srijitaray587]

Love, prayer & respect! ❤️ Couldn’t have had a happier morning! 💛

[@Iabshsndkdvd]

See Himachal pradesh model, Adani buys apple on large scale and have built-in monopoly their. Price's haven't increased there after adani have come. They are getting prices compared to 2012 prices. Adani is buying apple at rate of 18/kg and selling it around 150/kg to 200/kg depending on grade A, B, C.

[@KoachWithKunal]

What a research Rounaq. Very well scripted. Very impactful production.

[@PHEROMONE-wz9bz]

Andhbhaktoo ko utha le re baba uthalee 🙏

[@na-gi1xb]

Andhbhakts are also important

[@hassanyt7394]

ha

[@asifsayyad21]

Wow man, bhai kya video banaya hai bhai ... 😍itni knowledge. I will share this with my friends who are andh bhakt so it can open there eyes .. love you and keep it up 🥰

[@mayankbisht7691]

I think farmers should make their own party. Instead of relying on Congress or BJP, they must take stronger stance.

[@SG-cv4pf]

Most likely that's what will happen. For example, Yogendra Yadav is the leader of Swaraj India.

[@nawabkanda9709]

Thankyou swu..... thankyou for showing the real mirror...and that too to everyone .. including government and farmers.... I hope this attracts as many eyeballs and educate as many as possible.

[@raghothamrao9130]

Even if they would have thought of repealing the 3 farm laws (hypothetically), they won't because now it shall hurt their image and ego!! Sad state of affair.

[@amanmeena724]

Thank you scoopwhoop

[@dhruv1906]

Anyone who truly wants to understand this. Please watch drishti ias's video on farm laws. It covers ALL the points. Ye 10 minute ki video dekh ke vo kisaan bhi aa rakhe hain aur log bho yaha label baatte firre hain ek doosre ko. Liberandu aur bhakt. Laga lena label lekin pehle poora 100% ache se samajh toh lo. Prejudices dono side ki hain , ek baar apni side ke prejudices ko side pe rakh ke dhyan se neutrally samjho. Fir socho kya sahi hai kya galat.

[@rahulray5411]

Sahi baat

[@shubhamjohri290]

No we will get our facts from arts graduate journalist

[@amazon7891]

Omg! There are farmers in this video.. so don’t watch this.. the ones actually doing the job! What logic! Some officer after reading some books would know more about laws than the farmers whose generations have been in farming… hope you also lose some rights in your life and suffer like this…

[@rahulray5411]

@@amazon7891 these are rhetorical arguments. When we build a home do we listen to the architect or do we listen to the labours? Better yet, listen to both parties and make your own choice since it’s your own home. Also no one is losing any rights. Deregulation feels like some people are losing their rights because they had advantageous positions before deregulation, it happens in all kinds of markets and not just farming. As for wishing Bad things happening to other people because because they disagree on something, that is not a good attitude to have in life. We all do some work to survive, sometime businesses close and we struggle, then we get up and do something else, apply to new jobs. Waiting for government to end all struggles is bad strategy.

[@dhruv1906]

@@amazon7891 clearly you didn't watch the 3 hour long video. It is that long because it goes deep into every single argument given by each side. But its okay I'll still suggest to watch the video and then reconsider what you said.

[@sachinbuttar978]

Amazing 🙏🏻...and thank you 💖

[@na-gi1xb]

Farm laws are good by there are lots of changes need to be made.

[@arshgudani8366]

this was suuchhhh a great series!! thank u for putting in so much effort :)

[@madhukarv5267]

This was an amazing series. Can you do one on Rural Healthcare?

[@rachitsrivastava362]

Great work 👍👍

[@deepakrawat-po2ze]

I have never seen such a detailed and factual video

[@sujanpoojary5284]

I recommend to watch IAS drishti channel get complete understanding of these law.As far I understand our agriculture need these law,yes it's not completely flawless many things need to change as per farmers need.

[@Akki046]

Flawless, Farms laws are like poison. Upsc ka mains ka answer writing wale angle se to fir pros and con's mil hi jana h...

[@LakhanUK]

😂😂 I WATCHED IT , I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW HE GAVE SO POSITIVE VIEWS ABOUT CORRUPT SYS. He is far from reality . He said farm laws are not unconstitutional. But he didn't tell what is under entry 33 of concurrent.

[@Akki046]

@@LakhanUK Exactly man. And the sad thing is many people admire his logic behind the farm bill because he is a renowned teacher.

[@LakhanUK]

@@Akki046 yes he is a upsc teacher and always give more positive and less negative views about govt policies. Its hilarious he thought business between big corporates and poor farmers without stringent rule and regulations

[@Akki046]

@@LakhanUK Well, He is just another businessman who is following govt. Policies. I must say Even a farmer who is protesting in ghazipur tikri and singhu border will explain the farm laws better then him.

[@rohitsangwan7582]

Thankuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuyyyy very much scoopehoop 😘😘😘 Thankuuuuuu soooo much for understanding the problems of our farmers Thank you guys for explaining so well👌👌👏👏👏👏👏🤝

[@khushalkhan257]

I am an Bsc Horticulture student and the way scoopwoop has done this Green Revolution and Farmers crises reality series Is just mind baffling. In my 3 yrs of college education we have only glorified Green Revolution but the harsh truth is being concealed

[@amish613]

Thank you scoopwhoop unscripted.

[@chandanduggal4973]

all farmers are very awared and full of knowledge. And BJP says they can't understand the bills. 👎👎

[@ashu5193]

This is one of the best explainer series on India's farming crisis. Well done ScoopWhoop team!!

[@dhbhatta]

Msp has created a viscous cycle. We should have msp for all agricultural goods. Wow. Such logic 🙏

[@chewypiano7194]

MSP on few agri goods will make farmers exclusively produce these goods, hence market flooded with excess stocks leading to low price. If MSP on most goods then market vicious cycle will be broken. Country is going down gutter when idiots like you think they are genius.

[@LOKESHNAIK619]

MSP creates vicious cycle because MSP for grains like Rice and Wheat is more than other things😛if you give good MSP for other products you will ease out the "vicious cycle"

[@dhbhatta]

@@chewypiano7194 it is a utopia solution. The difficulty to achieve this is not thought about. Should onions from Maharashtra and Uttar Pradesh have the same MSP? How about rice in the one season from the next in the same place? How frequently will a MSP be announced for a agricultural good. No one thinks that. We all want what's best for our farmers but the truth is agriculture is a loss making business unless we radically move the youth from the fields to the industry.

[@adityapatil325]

@@dhbhatta While the youth needs to be moved away from agriculture to blue collar jobs, we need some stopgap solution which makes sure we are not just producing few cash crops.

[@chewypiano7194]

@@dhbhatta Shifting from agri economy to manu/service economy is not the objective of the farm laws. Objective is to create monopsony where prices are exploitative, hoarding occurs and there is no legal protection or any system for payment to be processed. It is terrible idea to open up commanding heights of economy to few pvt players, instead manu/service sector should be opened up.

[@persaud1]

👌👍✊ Why Crony Capitalism? What if these capitalists are governed & binded by government policies. Afterall even mandis are private players governed by Government laws. If mandis have not succeeded wherever implemented then why continue with the same model? Anyways the basic problem still remains, Green Revolution, GM crops & food independance. Farmers grew GM crops and stopped oil seeds & millets for the additional profits it promised. Farm bills se Krushi Sankat door nahi hoga, we must fight to alter the bills, not completely withdraw an immediate solution. The only long term solution can be answered by, Are we urbans ready to change our food habits, promote growth of non GM local seeds & millets and are we ready to pay higher price or atleast equivalent to the imported grains? 👌👍✊

[@MayurPanghaal]

We have seen what pvt schools and hospitals have become : loot factories and killers

[@imtiazu8]

Indian Private Sector is a bunch of hyenas looking for fresh meat...

[@jashanhanda1423]

Thanks for all team 🙏