Why the Puppet has ALWAYS been the Stuffer [FNaF Theory]

[@Taro_Yanada]

You also forgot to mention that, in the FNAF 3 files, the suits of the animatronics are called "gifts". Further implying that the animatronics are the gifts, they are what Puppet gave to the kids. It's such a good narrative. But it's also understandable that people believe WillStuffed.

[@Spawnmatism]

Yeah! That is a great piece of evidence, thank you for pointing it out. I didn't know how to put it in the script around the debunking, and I agree that WillStuffed is a very strong and valid theory to have, which is why there is pretty much a 50/50 split between PuppetStuffed and WillStuffed.

[@Patolagos]

What if it turns out that this is also the case in the movies? With Garrett becoming the puppet and William ordering the puppet to stuff the bodies in the animatronics...

[@Spawnmatism]

Could be! Kinda fitting for the Puppet to be controlled like a puppet by William.

[@Kakikito1234]

The man on the phone clearly said that Pupet is always thinking. Apart from that before Jeremy (as Gusardia) there was Wiliam and Pupet, being in his box, could not see the changing of the guard, thinking that the player (us) is Wiliam Afton.

[@Spawnmatism]

I agree!

[@Kakikito1234]

@@Spawnmatism 💝

[@Kakikito1234]

In “your the band” Pupet have powers😊

[@Spawnmatism]

Yeah, it was really cool in that story. But I don't believe it showed it having the unique ability of fusing soul to machine.

[@Kitkat-rz3gn]

GREAT GOOGLY MOOGLY! another certified banger...i love the way you explain your points and i love your editing - you are a skilled and talented person and i can't praise you enough!!!!!!

[@Spawnmatism]

[@echothesilent4693]

FINALLY, everyone makes thirty minute long videos with William stuffing as a basis despite having concrete evidence of otherwise even back in the 2nd game. I had to be disappointed so many times because many KZbinrs would ignore one of the most concrete facts, it's like ignoring the Mr.Afton name drop in SL but no one ignored that.

[@Kakikito1234]

The Pupet literally want to save the dci, we can see that in “save them”

[@Spawnmatism]

Yeah! Same way it wanted to save the MCI, in my opinion. Im actually in the process of making a video about SAVETHEM and the DCI next.

[@Kakikito1234]

@@Spawnmatism 🫶

[@_o.0_]

Do we really know Mike is an Afton, he could have just kid napped someone who turned out looking just like him, I think young and the restless was hinting that Mike WASN’T actually William’s son, even though the similarities are damning

[@Spawnmatism]

Mike calls William "father" after the events of Sister Location. Which is after he watched Immortal and the Restless, after he saw what his sister had become, and after he saw the experiment rooms. Things that would really make him hate William. So if Mike really was kidnapped by William, it wouldn't make sense for him to refer to him as father after knowing that he is not his true father and that he is instead an evil monster. But it would make sense if William is his actual father, as that would just be a matter-of-fact statement rather than out of endearment. But at the end of the day, what you are saying could be possible too. Since we only have Sister Location and FFPS as the only evidence that Michael is William's son.

[@_o.0_]

@@Spawnmatism the way he says “father” sounds sarcastic, like it could be referring to it as a “you turned me into this” instead of biological

[@Wizardjones69]

Idk But with glitchtrap literally luring us into the stage, to become later freddy, and dance in Joy, implying that he's happy that we turned into freddy Already implies willstuff, and, on the novels The death of Elizabeth caused afton to commit the mci, not charlie

[@duckisacoolguy]

but I thought it was just a silly pizza restaurant

[@Horrorbutterz]

Nah there big spooky lore 👻

[@Spawnmatism]

The animatronics do get silly at night.

[@Kakikito1234]

Michale brooks ≠ Michale afton

[@Spawnmatism]

Yeah, I do admit to they are depicted as very different characters besides the family name change. The "equation" I made in the video still works though, since you can instead say "If the character named Michael in the [insert media] is not Afton's son."