Why won't Charli XCX call it a remix?: “brat and it’s completely different but still brat” analysis

[@Clara-kf5jd]

Great review but God, were you insistent with the Taylor mentions. It feels somewhat reductive of Charli's artistry to constantly, forcibly exclaim the need of another artist's perspective on her songs, her music, her album. Especially when she and Taylor do not have a good relationship or have ever showed musical synergy. Just my two cents, but by the time you got to I think about it all the time I was annoyed to bits by this.

[@professorskye]

I'm actually going to address this comment (and others like it) in my Kesha review coming up.

[@kackareznickova5431]

it's interesting because I love the caroline polacak remix the most. I believe the remix is perfect reinterpretation. The first one was about how everything is romantic how even the weird stuff in life. But now Charli is asking if living this life is still romantic now that she literally has everything. What stays is the romanticising of normal life and caroline's lyrics are so captivating. But the remix deepens the first meaning. The first one is vacation kind of vibe, here everything is romantic and the remix is you trying to romanticise the life you have. I also find the whole song absolutely beautiful and i did cry to it.

[@PabloHernandez-rr1or]

AVAA, prof skye's brat review but its completely different but still prof skye's brat review

[@sandradee8093-c4g]

Woo a birdy is at the feeder

[@KoffeeShak]

The burdies are nice :) yessir, that’s whaddawannahear

[@weam9999]

Taylor doesn't get to be on brat. That's her punishment. 😂

[@celioski3698]

The Taylor pushing is so unnecessary. I understand you enjoy her lyricism but I would prefer a myriad of other artists to dream about being on this album than her. Nothing between those two worlds getting together makes me think of good music, chemistry or even good vibes. I don't think Charli thinks of her as much as you think she does :/ other than that interesting analysis as usual

[@Yvy-temp]

Loving the night lighting. It's like in those old nintendo games where the city would change if you played at day or night. It's like your previous brat review, but it's different but it's still a brat review.

[@ghostghastly3898]

AVAA Love Bladees verse, feels like something teenage me would have posted on Facebook I must confеss, I'm under stress I'm under prеssure in my head I'm six feet down beneath myself I'm tryna catch up with my breath Even with everything on deck I'm only thinking about less Thinking how to move like chess The mirror leaves me unimpressed.

[@ivyr8371]

Died at the Jizz in my pants comparison, I can’t stop saying “free bleeding in the autumn rain” like Catherine O’Hara. AVAA prof, thanks for all the Brat content!

[@ivyr8371]

Picasso plate 👀 50:28

[@johnnyflamevlogz8203]

Love the pronunciation of "Troye Siobhan"

[@hervanrossi]

regarding the yes/casablanca thing-- the piano in the original version, even though it was credited to Herbie Hancock, reminded me of owner of a lonely heart from the very moment I listened to it, so I thought expanding the reference in the remix was expected and even obvious. my reaction was like "aha there it is!" when it came up. maybe not crediting yes was a just a slip and they'll eventually do it? (don't know how these things work to be honest.) AVAA!

[@lamoona4269]

AVAA, perhaps I'll partake in brat autumn. assuming that i wont be completely engulfed with seasonal depression this time around.

[@scudtube]

AVAA I thought it was interesting you brought up Charli starting a record label because she already did in 2016 with Vroom Vroom Recordings, their first release was her EP with songs produced by Sophie and A.G. Cook. However, they don’t seem to have released anything since 2020. It could be interesting to see if the success of brat could lead to something bigger for her or if that whole experience contributed to her frustration with the music industry.

[@sweetilicious]

AVAA you're really cool prof. Raw and real efficient

[@jonas-j3h]

AHAA (awesome hair as always)

[@derfuchs3296]

Glad to hear so Bladee appreciation! AVAA

[@justnachoday5811]

Avaa. Subscribed. Liked. Continued watching.

[@franccci]

very good in depth review, 10/10

[@CypiXmusic]

This is the first time i've seen any of your videos. Honestly i love the way you go in depth on all these ideas and formulate them thoroughly. Big ups!

[@strawberrythiefproductions]

Avaa have already been listening to the fsookers thanks to your earlier vid, excellent recommendation

[@Myythril]

AVAA made me happy seeing Bladee on the tracklist

[@MyRealNameIsCLARENCE]

AVAA you’re a legend thank you. Would love to see you talk about Sickboyrari, he just dropped an album ‘Ballad of a Glime’ and it’s so good. Peace & love ty

[@junyaiwase]

Bumpin that

[@CypiXmusic]

1:58 fun little reference there hahah

[@dertodesking.]

Troye Sivan is not a 'happy to be there' thing. Troye is a regular in the Charli-verse by now. Other than that, great breakdown.

[@kackareznickova5431]

The sympaty is a knife with ariana made me sad because it was shallow? The line about being so pretty they don't believe it sounded more like a weird flex than being vulnerable. I did like the line about dissecting her body on the front page. That has to be hard for her.

[@jkoreosrock]

this line is referring to how ppl keep saying she has had plastic surgery (face lifts) even hough she has no had that done

[@kackareznickova5431]

@@jkoreosrock em yeah i understand the lyric. I just feel it's not a good way to say it. "It's a knife you're so pretty you must be fake." How is it a knife? What hurts you? That you are so pretty? If she said something like "it's a knife when they don't believe that you're not fake." I could be like yeah it has to be uncomfortable when people don't believe you even if you are saying the truth. But her wording made is weirdly shallow. Like: It's so horrible i'm just so so pretty you dont even believe i am not fake. And the thing is celebrities were denying plastic surgery for decades now. I just don't believe she didn't do anything, not because she is so pretty but because she looks a tiny bit different than she looked and that's not a bad thing. I don't think she's "fake" I think she was beautiful and she made few tweeks and still is beautiful.

[@tehkokhoe]

​@@kackareznickova5431 read the full lyrics, find an interpretation that you are satisfied with. Why get so upset lol. Just have some imagination.

[@kackareznickova5431]

@@tehkokhoe im not upset im just saying i find it shallow that's all

[@deeptochatterjee532]

Because people are refusing to just accept her and treat her as a person. Saying "you are so pretty you must be fake" is also objectification​@@kackareznickova5431

[@franciscovincent7035]

AVAA! Professor, this might be a bit more underground than you tend to cover, but I would love it if you could give some words on the new Harlow Road album

[@MikeZucchini]

AVAA Can you do Godspeed You! Black Emperor Prof Skye please

[@sandradee8093-c4g]

Um I like the birds😂 Okay I'll hit the like button😁🐦

[@messyjesseB]

AVAA, would love to hear your thoughts on the new Porches album!

[@annalukas6332]

Wonderful recommendations in this video! AVAA

[@annalukas6332]

And I don’t mind your “mistakes”, they make your videos more conversational which I prefer over something highly edited

[@StayBlessed47]

Unc Skye!

[@hyess4640]

Hey Prof Skye, did you listen to the new voidz album considering youre such a big Julian Casablancas fan? AVAA

[@EricAB-ct7tf]

This Charli fan does need to hear Matty’s version, thanks very much. And why wouldn’t a British artist feature another British artist? This album is available in countries other than the USA.

[@lolzalot44]

AVAA I rejoice when the charli scholar uploads

[@stay_puft]

you mention you're a french professor as much as charli mentions where she recorded her tracks

[@MzHeather-904]

Word of the day boys and girls " fangs"

[@luislicup7937]

thanks for reaching the fuhsookers, AAVA

[@brieclarke]

I too pronounce Bon Iver "wrong" because I know it's right

[@ethan2k297]

AVAA BLADEE FANS REJOICE

[@chidalso]

AVAA Professor ❤ And u don't like to shoot a ball in the basket because ***** ******* painted in that plate (Censored to avoid spoilers)

[@MaleTears]

A bee keeper 👀

[@gabrielelijohannsson8729]

Meow the jewels is a worth while remix

[@sadoklajmi]

I wish my professors knew what brat is let alone think it's aoty 😆

[@rehab_herr]

good video

[@sandradee8093-c4g]

Birdies

[@itsboundo.]

AVAA! I did not count how many mistakes you made but I think calling me "It's Boondo" is the funniest one lol

[@t-wolff8058]

hey professor skye can u talk about lil ugly mane please please i like this vid and ur other vids goodbye

[@DrawingZerberus]

Avaa ❤

[@edwardgeorge8025]

King Tubby

[@harlanthater]

Avaa!

[@kingchipson]

AVAA!!

[@NogaAsherGoshen]

36:29 this

[@wardpaine8194]

RE-volver

[@franccci]

the background is very brat

[@maisiemakesvideos]

Man if you bring up Taylor again

[@oogi5461]

AVAA

[@johan1969aqua]

Avaa

[@riordanberry3908]

Bro, this is fun but please stop talking about Taylor Swift we dont want to hear abput her lol

[@Peter-fu7jl]

avaa

[@CompletelyInadequate]

how do you know you want kids? lol

[@Thimasehren]

God I’m so sick of the Brat mania.

[@nnnnnn496]

You're Such a brat!

[@italothejunior]

Please, EDIT

[@PabloHernandez-rr1or]

AVAA, prof skye's brat review but its completely different but still prof skye's brat review

[@muriloalvarez935]

AVAA!!!

[@harryyrrah9942]

AVAA

[@wardpaine8194]

Avaa

[@TonyHank131]

avaa

[@mikitoramirez7406]

AVAA

[@georgetyree5641]

AVAA

[@tiago9679]

AVAA

[@susanmelo1092]

AVAA