Will Kolkata be Rich Again ? || RISE - FALL - RISE AGAIN ||

#Kolkata #FutureWestBengal #westbengal
Join us on a captivating journey through Kolkata's past, present, and future as we delve into the intriguing question: Can Kolkata reclaim its status as one of India's wealthiest cities? 🌇💰
In this thought-provoking video, we explore the fascinating history of Kolkata, once hailed as the epitome of opulence and prosperity. We shed light on the factors that contributed to its former glory and examine the challenges that led to its current decline.
From the grandeur of the colonial era to the birthplace of Indian intellectual and cultural movements, Kolkata's rich heritage is undeniable. However, as the tides of time changed, the city faced economic downturns, urban decay, and migration of industries to other regions.
But is hope on the horizon? We discuss the potential catalysts that could spark Kolkata's renaissance and revive its economy. Through interviews with experts, entrepreneurs, and passionate locals, we gain insights into the innovative ideas and initiatives aimed at revitalizing the city's fortunes.
From urban redevelopment projects to emerging sectors such as technology and tourism, we uncover the untapped potential that Kolkata holds. Could this city, steeped in history and resilience, rise once more to reclaim its position as a vibrant economic powerhouse?
Join us as we examine the possibilities, challenges, and aspirations of Kolkata's resurgence. Be a part of this exciting conversation and share your thoughts on whether Kolkata can transcend its decline and embrace a prosperous future.
🎬 Don't miss out on this captivating exploration of Kolkata's past, present, and future! Subscribe to our channel and hit the notification bell to stay updated with our latest videos. #KolkataRevival #RediscoverGlory #FutureProspects #EconomicResurgence #RevivingKolkata #ProsperityUnleashed #KolkataComeback #RebuildingDreams
🔔 Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @powertrain
OUR OTHER CHANNELS
⚪VLOG CHANNEL - / @aakashbhavsar2342
⚪FOOTAGE DEMOCRACY - / @footagedemocracy3663
⚪SHORTS CHANNEL - / @powershorts1068
FOLLOW US ON
⚪INSTAGRAM 1 - / aakash_rb
⚪INSTAGRAM 2- / powertrain_yt
⚪FACEBOOK - / powertrainofficial
⚪TWITTER - / powertrain_yt
⚪DISCORD - / discord
_____________________________________________________________________
INTRO MUSIC IF PRESENT - LEMMiNO - A THOUSAND YEARS
• LEMMiNO - A Thousand W...
CC BY-SA 4.0

[@falltooth4415]

Kolkata is a example of how a bad leadership and politics can destroy one to the top city

[@CHINMOYGAMING]

India too. Once time a rich country. This time India has world 30 percent poor people

[@falltooth4415]

@@CHINMOYGAMING there is a difference, India is poor because of colonization

[@CHINMOYGAMING]

@@falltooth4415 Britishers give us Railway Network,every major city, Hospital, University, Bridge. Every major infrastructure built by Britishers just like howrah bridge, CSt Station. British colonized also Malaysia, U. A. E, Qatar, Srilanka, more than 60 countries. This time mostly country richer than India

[@CHINMOYGAMING]

@@falltooth4415 British Colonized Malaysia, U. A. E,more than 60 countries, Netherland colonized Indonesia More than 350 years. Still they are Rich, looks developped, cleaner than India

[@CHINMOYGAMING]

India is poor because Huge population, Corruption, corrupt government, officers, No development. Don't blame British they are better than our corrupt government

[@TheBharat645]

The Major problem for Westbengal is 90℅ dependency on kolkata . We want More Newtown in other cities also not only in Kolkata

[@Abhi46159]

new town City itself has a horrible planning , bad transportation , high property rates which the common folks can't afford we don't want new town like cities .. we want better cities than it

[@navnathsurvase3490]

@@Abhi46159 Bangalore, Pune, indore, Chandigarh are much cleaner and higher economic opportunities.

[@Nightcrawler81]

​@@Abhi46159Try visiting other Indian cities and you will understand how expensive everything is lately.

[@alamsheikh4251]

@@Nightcrawler81 Indore...? Kuch bhi

[@Suman_x_108]

​@@alamsheikh4251 Pakistan ke baat nhi horhi hai indore bola hai usne .......

[@GoddessFreyaa]

Two main problems in west bengal is ...tmc and Bangladeshi immigrants.

[@ayanbanerjee7479]

What about biharis?

[@RomanReigns-be9jj]

@@ayanbanerjee7479 Banerjee = Bangladeshi

[@killersm1634]

​@@AllInOne-bv1tiwell according to Indian government data, Patna is the dirtiest city in India.

[@GoddessFreyaa]

@@ayanbanerjee7479 just because they are poor doesn't mean they are problem. They are Indian first of all. Secondly Biharis is not going to create a problem like Kashmir in Bengal. The islamic jihadis will try to overtake everything once they get in majority. Like they did everywhere in the world.

[@ayanbanerjee7479]

@@RomanReigns-be9jj That's why pakistanis like you need education 🤣

[@sumandutta4834]

I don't have much hope since the society in West Bengal is more interested in useless politics instead of industrialization.

[@XenithForPm]

buddhadev bhattacharya was the best

[@AO-xd2ml]

@@XenithForPm Communists and TMC are both the problem.

[@Arkaworldd]

​@@XenithForPm he tried but after all his party is cpim, known for kicking out industry. JYOTI BOSE was worst.

[@rohitsawant5805]

Finally someone said it, this comment should be highlighted and have the highest likes but alas people want to hear sweet lies than the cold truth. It takes guts to say this openly being a Bong. Most Bongs I have met working in Bengaluru, Mumbai refuse to acknowledge this always in denial, when we talk about Industry, business, jobs. They will come up with 100 different reasons why Waste Bengal got left behind or failed but never acknowledge their own community's lazyness masquerading in the form of intellectual anti business attitude.

[@sauron2000000]

​@@rohitsawant5805 Because they are Bengali. Unlike you.

[@anirbandas1732]

Kolkata is a living museum with old sculptures and old-minded people also.

[@AS_41]

Exactly! We should modernise our city as well as our perspective and to do this we should kick our illiterate government out.

[@whitewhite4462]

Mamta banerjee er o akhon bhimroti shuru hoye geche, mamta is now 80% "jyoti basu"fied.

[@bidyutmanna3900]

@@AS_41 Which government is illiterate?

[@arijitadhikary2902]

​@@bidyutmanna3900Mamta Banerjee

[@ayushsingh1943]

Kolkata is just a randikhana

[@cyan3692]

Being a Bengali I can literally bet you Kolkata will never rise if political environment doesn't changes. 14 💀 on Panchayat election day alone, overall 35+ 💀row over a Panchayat election. The ruling party and people supporting majority in the state are hiting their own leg with an axe and soon our children have to face the consequences.

[@amit_45..789]

Mamata

[@alive6281]

I wanna add the education system into this as well. 30k+ fake teachers, there are 2 in my own area 😂

[@cyan3692]

@@alive6281 bhai wbcs which is most popular state level civil services exams uska 1 years se zyada ho gaya prelims ka result nhi nikla... us state mein elementary education kaisa hi ho sakta hai bhai... Sad truth bro

[@Thuglife-nm1kt]

@@cyan3692 --- hindi bole ho ...usko aag lag gai hogi 😆

[@sarbojitroy100]

​@@Thuglife-nm1ktpar dhuya to Tera pichwara se a raha hai

[@aandjain8274]

As long as this TMC govt is there in power, expecting any major reform would be foolish. Most shockingly even now there is a large section of educated crowd in Kolkata who wanted Communist revival & wanted to bring them in power again even after their disastrous 34 yrs rule. So it's difficult

[@rudranilpal3074]

Yes, They are useful idiots. I hate my fellow Bengalis for this kind of thinking.

[@snehadeepaich3149]

Yes tmc are focusing on freebies no , major devlopment

[@ramkrishnamaheta2400]

@soumikhazra9354 Woke culture, LGBTQ, ignorance, intelluctualism , communism, gomutra jib, mahua mutra . just name a thing and it will be there

[@ayanbanerjee7479]

@soumikhazra9354 Whats wrong with feminist? What do you mean by woke culture?

[@henrystevens3993]

​@@ayanbanerjee7479woke culture is the art of talking about freedom of speech a lot but never implements it.

[@bhargabkumar5598]

Mamata Banerjee is finishing the last hope for Kolkata. Commis were there to degrade this beautiful city and Mamata is putting last nail in it. Only buddhadeb bhattacharya was one who had done something atleast

[@bobbyaxelrod3242]

Allamdulilah

[@ramkrishnamaheta2400]

commies killed the city and mamata is doing final ontim sanskaro of the city

[@MaclarenJamie]

@@ramkrishnamaheta2400 in your dreams poor demo

[@anandaman16]

WB playbook: Step 1: Destroy businesses - Stop Industrialization, Kill Businessmen, Shun Capitalization and embrace Communism Step 2: Strike, Strike - Stop working Step 3: Make businesses flee, encourage violence (This still happens - Taken over by Islamic violence after Communist violence and TMC Violence), Play religion card, encourage Islamic radicalism, immigration from Bangladesh, religious extremism and crimes. Step 4: Progress falls - HDI lags, Industrial output lags, prosperity lags - Surprised pikachu face for WB Step 5: Encourage Business, MSME, but fail miserably Step 6: More surprised Pikachu face Step 7: Blame center for step brotherly treatment, Blame center for all the mis-steps that did... Step 8: No changes in status - More surprised pikachu face... Step 9: IT Comes as rescue but overall still decline... continues... × Future: Step 10: Momota loses election.... Things start to improve.. with CAA/NRC implementation...

[@LHRTW]

@@MaclarenJamielal kukur

[@baby_yoda709]

Kolkata is a beautiful city. It has an amazing blend of history and modernity. Hope it regains its lost glory.

[@anandaman16]

WB playbook: Step 1: Destroy businesses - Stop Industrialization, Kill Businessmen, Shun Capitalization and embrace Communism Step 2: Strike, Strike - Stop working Step 3: Make businesses flee, encourage violence (This still happens - Taken over by Islamic violence after Communist violence and TMC Violence), Play religion card, encourage Islamic radicalism, immigration from Bangladesh, religious extremism and crimes. Step 4: Progress falls - HDI lags, Industrial output lags, prosperity lags - Surprised pikachu face for WB Step 5: Encourage Business, MSME, but fail miserably Step 6: More surprised Pikachu face Step 7: Blame center for step brotherly treatment, Blame center for all the mis-steps that did... Step 8: No changes in status - More surprised pikachu face... Step 9: IT Comes as rescue but overall still decline... continues... × Future: Step 10: Momota loses election.... Things start to improve.. with CAA/NRC implementation...

[@ronisamanta4435]

​@@anandaman16bhai aap sirf kolkata bare bol rahe hai kya aur sab rajya mei kya sab thik hai

[@Sngh-sw3jl]

Stop being in denial, Kilkata is filthy as hell. It is either slums or falling apart infrastructures.

[@rohitsawant5805]

Waste Bengal failed coz Bengali people are lazy and don't work hard, they would rather do 2 rs politics and waste countless hours on useless debates than actually work hard and improve productivity. If I were a investor or business man trying to set up shop in India I would go to a pro business state like Gujarat, Maharashtra, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, or nowadays even UP ( NCR region mostly ) Never going to a Commie state with lazy anti industry attitude. Waste Bengal will remain waste Bengal.

[@TJSaw]

Kolkata is a shithole.

[@Doraemon-75]

Kolkata & whole WB needs a major infra upgradation & new infra also

[@bidyutmanna3900]

@@AllInOne-bv1ti But have better infrastructure than kolkata.

[@veena_93_.]

@@AllInOne-bv1ti they don't need as much as WB.

[@shreyanghosh758]

Point to be noted... After so many setbacks Kolkata is still 3rd largest economy city in India much bigger than Bangalore 4th...Mainly due to reason that kolkata is only big city in Eastern and Northeastern India hence every operation be it Government or Private Company is done from here.....kolkata caters to 7 states of NorthEast Bihar Jharkhand eastern UP Odisha and West Bengal.... Trade with Bangladesh is controlled from here,Nepal uses kolkata sea port for its trade also...

[@Saurabh529_]

don't include up up is not depend even a Inch on Kolkata

[@-EIE--ShouvikBanerjee]

@@Saurabh529_ UP comes in the Kolkata port hinterland

[@shreyanghosh758]

@@Saurabh529_ Yes UP developed a lot in recent years...but thats mainly on western central and NCR region...although UP is not dependent on Bengal..eastern UP lacks development and its Eastern UP trade is also done through Kolkata port or haldia port in Bengal

[@shreyanghosh758]

@@svk0071 thinking and facts are not the same.... Even in this vedio it is said kolkata is 3rd largest economy in the country after Delhi and Mumbai.... Bangalore and Hyderabad is largely based on IT... Kolkata has a diverse economy.... And I also mentioned the reason why it is 3rd largest and it will remain like that.... Main reason is Kolkata and West Bengal Geographical location... No matter how much Bad policies State Government frame still somehow develop largely because of that

[@biharisuar7734]

Lol odisha with 4.5cr population gives 4400cr gst as compared to 5100cr gst with 9cr population.dont include your slumgal with odisha

[@SDBoral007]

Kolkata aaj IT industry par hi jinda hain... Kolkata nahi West Bengal firse apne achche din pe wapas jaye...bass yahi ichcha hain...❤

[@RishikeshKumarMishra-ky6on]

Kya IT Industry 🤣Google , Amazon,Meta,Netflix ,Flipkart jessi Product Based Companies hai hi nai ayya ek bhi Service Based Compines hai bas jesse Wipro,TCS wagera jo bas 20k-35k p.m deti hai starting salary in comparison to Product based jo 70k-150k p.m deti hai starting mai . Bengal se zyada acha IT Industry to Noida mai hai

[@SDBoral007]

@@RishikeshKumarMishra-ky6on 🤣🤣 Noida mein jitna product based companies hain usse kahi zyada service based companies hain... Chahe toh count karlena...

[@RishikeshKumarMishra-ky6on]

@@SDBoral007 Bhai tumne baat nahi samjhi mera kehna tha Service Based Companies acha pay nahi karti aur dusri baat yaha jitni Service Based Companies usse waha hai aur bina Product based Companies ka kessa IT Industry ka hub hai wo jagah

[@SDBoral007]

@@RishikeshKumarMishra-ky6on Maine apki baat se sehmat hoon. Par yeh v dekhne wala baat hain ki FAANG companies ki india office mein jitne kaam karte hain, unke lie kam number ki offices kafi hain... Aur lagta nahi ki top product based companies india mein apna offices aur increase karengi... Par dusre taraf cts, tcs jaise companies k lie bahut sarein offices chahie...toh isme ultimately alag states ka hi help ho raha hain...toh hone do bhai...🤗

[@prasenjitbhattacharya2920]

Bengalis have always been nostalgic in nature and proud of their culture. This is not a bad thing necessarilly. It is unfortunate that Kolkata has lost its elegance over the years due bad action by different governments. Kolkata can still regain its lost glory.

[@richik12]

Mainly due to political instability between Central and State govt and Ignorance from central govt since independence.

[@MN-mq3ql]

​@@richik12mainly due to one single party in bengal

[@AO-xd2ml]

Stuck in the past, while Odisha races ahead. And Odisha is becoming the preferred in the region. Too bad.

[@anilallipilli1569]

Nostalgic?

[@rohitsawant5805]

Productive hard working Bongs leave Waste Bengal, let's be honest they know there is no future for Waste Bengal. I see so many Bongs working in Mumbai, Bengaluru, Delhi, Pune, Hyderabad. Deep down they know Waste Bengal will never offer them the kind of opportunities they want.

[@simplyrohith2163]

By the time Kolkata recovers and starts positive progress it'll be competing against our t2 cities. Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Ahmedabad are already some of the fastest growing cities in Asia. Hope a good leader can change the outlook and make the city rise again.

[@DannycageGhostrider]

Noida is the fastest growing City

[@Immortal10364]

Hey actually there are 8 tier 1 cities Ahemdabad and Pune. But if you take tier 2 cities even Nagpur, surat is fastest growing cities.

[@simplyrohith2163]

@@DannycageGhostrider Noida is a t2 city🤡. It's GDP is not even $80 billion. Surat is the actual fastest growing city followed by Coimbatore and Gurugram

[@oppertunist-trader]

West Bengal is recovering, having more than 15% GDP growth rate. Kolkata is already the 3rd highest GDP city in India and future looks promising

[@AS_41]

@@oppertunist-trader people like you are stopping Kolkata and West Bengal's growth 😂 have you ever seen the modern world of today? Kolkata is living in 1960s, too dirty, polluted, least livable.

[@rohansaha26]

Sometimes lot's of people thinking that Kolkata means West Bengal. West Bengal doesn't have any another big cities. As a Bengali it hurts. Bengal needs atleast 2 or 3 planned cities which can attracts Businesses, Investors and Manufacturers. Local media just covering about political news, corruption and riots etc. So the focus of government distracted from developments and investments.

[@31davidwarner]

Exactly no city except Kolkata

[@dwaipayanmoitra4651]

The biggest problem is socialist mindset that was ingrained by the left , Congress and perpetuated by TMC.

[@sounakchakraboty9700]

Just like Karnataka Telangana Bihar madhya Pradesh

[@31davidwarner]

@@sounakchakraboty9700 ever heard of Mysore Mangalore Indore Bhopal

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

They should develop metropolitan region of asansol and durgapur. They can make a metro there. Second they should develop Siliguri as the entry of North East

[@bhomikmathur7584]

If Kolkata can reform itself, it will be a boon not just for West Bengal but the entire eastern belt of India including Eastern UP, Bihar, North-Eastern states, Odisha, Jharkhand, etc.

[@connoisseur670]

UP is good under the Yogi regime and Odisha is doing too well, Kolkata can help the rest of the states But currently Kolkata isn't able to help itself

[@Saurabh529_]

😂😅

[@dipteshbasak4810]

@@connoisseur670 western up sirf develop haa and western up se eastern up ka distance kolkata se bhi jaida haa

[@connoisseur670]

@@dipteshbasak4810 still UP doesn't need Kolkata in any sense

[@AO-xd2ml]

Odisha is better in every way, including being closer to major shipping lanes. Investors will no longer tolerate Bengal's failures to elect a proper government and administration. All east coast business houses are establishing in Odisha, AP and Chennai. Bengal is being silently bypassed.

[@sharmapd1]

The fact is, when India was under British Rule, Bengal was at the forefront in India's Independence Struggle. That Independence of India brought 'Downfall' to Bengal in every respect including its Economy.

[@agod2449]

Not independence but clueless and vision less politicians and people who vote for freebies and appeasement

[@CHINMOYGAMING]

India is a sucks country, super poor country don't blame only one state okk

[@harshjoon5288]

dimag me kuch kami h tere😂😂 kuch bhi bol rha hai

[@CHINMOYGAMING]

@@harshjoon5288 sahi toh bol raha hai, British Jamaneme bengal ka matlab bangladesh, west bengal ek sath tha.ab divided ho chuka hai dirty Indians

[@rohitsawant5805]

Yes, because Bangali communist intellectuals came to power and destroyed the state. It's almost as if the Bangali intellectual class would rather do 2 rs politics and useless debates than actual hard work. There's the real reason for your downfall. Do more intellectual bakwas instead of real* work and see it go even more downhill from here. Anyways thanks to you laziness and anti industry attitude our state benefitted. Cheers to the Commie overeduacted intellectuals 😂🤣😂🤣

[@akbrahma7739]

As a Bengali, the period from 1940-2000 was a great humiliation. It's not just the economy tanked, the civilization fell apart. The pride, knowledge, bravery all collapsed. First came the 1941 famine 4 million dead, then 1946-47 Kolkata-Noakhali massacres, then 1965 East Bengal genocide, then 1971 Operation Searchlight and genocide, and finally the 1980-90s FEP. The economy was the last thing that collapsed, the people were already broken, they fought the most, they bled the most, they suffered the most. Today we are humiliated everywhere as poor immigrant labourers. If anything has taught me, it is that no one will see your suffering, they will laugh when you're languishing in pain, but they will only respect you, only if they fear you. Today everyone respects Maharashtra coz they fear Maharashtra's ability and efficiency. If Bengal can suffer this much and still stand then she can surely leap, no excuses.

[@JULIAN............]

i left kolkata at 2008, but it was/is/will an imotion for me, hope my motherland will recover soon

[@BackspasmANDniggle]

At?

[@prembagui7104]

Kolkata or Bengalis doesn't lack in anything, the problem is mostly of Crab mentality due to bad policy decisions of British and public utility Infrastructure, People of bengal really needs to see what is in their self-interest keeping in mind that loss in one person's business will some day cost your own job.

[@val-schaeffer1117]

Rubbish. Bengalis are indeed weak and lazy. Success rate of WB in IITJEE and civil service exams are abysmally low. On the other hand, use of domestic help is among the highest, which are typically done by household members in North and South India, leaving lower class to work in primary sector (e.g. manufacturing). Judging objectively, an engineer in Kolkata would have much higher rate of hiring household help (which is tertiary sector) whereas an engineer in another city. So an engineer who works as engineer but also cooks and cleans, is much more productive than one who needs domestic helps to tune him up for his regular work life.

[@DESIBOY-fe7nm]

Yeah let's blame everything on Brits. And give TMC a clean chit.

[@anirbanghosh1670]

Crab pulls each other not because they are crab but because they are put in a jar. It's the pbm of jar not the crab.

[@val-schaeffer1117]

@@anirbanghosh1670 And why is that. Bengalis are weak and lazy, which they try to compensate by acting intellectural or cunning. The expression of the latter is crab mentality. Bengal's former prosperity was because Calcutta being British capital. Not because of entrepreneurship. And what is this analogy of being put in a jar. Neither Bengal partition not imposing communism was a natural catastrophy. It was outcome of your own act. You are not landlocked Mizoram. Punjab was partitioned too, and Sindhis were entirely uprooted. Look where they are now. Just admit that you are objectively inferior.

[@samratvchakraborty5157]

Problem is partition, one sided population exodus and radical islamism

[@Your_real_dad]

If Kolkata's ppl wont change them it's impossible. From last 55 years Kolkata is electing Central offender government ( CPM , they opposed Congress government LPG reforms, TMC opposing BJP is every way possible). Honestly cause this city we north bengal ppl are suffering.

[@debalinamukherjee7197]

why not North bengal separate themself from West bengal and make North bengal ut i know North bengal people r more heard working and talented for bengal they can't grow

[@muditbothra3266]

The Brits were so smart. Not only did they cut off India from accessing Central Asia through Pakistan partition but also shattered dreams of post colonial era industrial development by partition of Bengal. Big L for Indian Civilization.

[@pranavingale6850]

So the whole india being poor is because we don't have direct access to central Asia, big W to you my friends 😂😂

[@muditbothra3266]

@@pranavingale6850 Central Asia is the access point to Europe, Soviet and Middle East and lot of natural resources of Central Asia to exploit genius. Why do u think China was building BRI? Ofc economic reasons.

[@pranavingale6850]

@@muditbothra3266 well yeah i agree only central Asia is the factor that can make or break a country i agree😂

[@muditbothra3266]

@@pranavingale6850 India is both broke and broken. Step outside room.

[@pranavingale6850]

@@muditbothra3266 central Asia being the most important issue-topic and your reply- india being broke and broken, 🤔...i....i don't.....I am sorry.....I am not on your intellectual level....i don't get your response..... And yes stepping outside, it looks lower middle class not broke

[@rohma220]

UP, BIhar and West Bengal are hyperintensively populated regions and to support this population we need very high Industrialisation and diversification of their job opportunities. This Doctor, Engineer, Lawyer mindset ain't going to take these states anywhere. If harnessed they'll be the growth engines of the nation, if not, they'll turn nation into disarray.

[@kolkataguy3917]

I Agree with you.

[@AO-xd2ml]

Agreed 100%. MANUFACTURING is the future. That is the core industry and UP is already heavily invested in it. Odisha is also joining in to create the port access. Bengal will be bypassed if it continues on its current path.

[@EMTMZ]

Medical and engineering should not be only profession. These are very high educational profession. Low IQ people needs jobs according to their merit and skill.

[@Uda_dunga]

End me yhe hoga bihari UP aur Bengal me jaake rhegee dekh lena

[@PoojaVerma-ux2pr]

But People don't have money

[@sangeet_official533]

I am from Rajasthan but really love KOLKATA ❤️ ❤️❤️

[@subhrajitchakraborty8170]

Thanks ❤

[@arindamdutta9371]

❤

[@chrisevans1857]

Lekin recent kalkata westbengal ke bahar ke logo ko bohiragata (outsider) bolta he

[@soumapriyamondal3808]

​@@chrisevans1857yes BIMARU beggars

[@ritamray344]

@@chrisevans1857 Wo sirf Mamata Begum bolti hai😂😂

[@alapandas5630]

Thanks Mamanta and CPIM for this achievement

[@koushikguha4152]

Please come to Saltlake....you fill it's Chandigarh.....and if u come to Newtown it's same as Gurugram....every city has its old part .... Delhi our capital also have old delhi part which is worse then old part of kolkata....and mumbai also have dharavi and lots of slums...some peoples come to Kolkata and visit old part of it same as old delhi and pass this type of comments....I have visited all these Citys and I realised that.....

[@-EIE--ShouvikBanerjee]

yes u r correct ...but these people are very biased spreading hate in the comments section and the content is not correct too.....But I will always be with Kolkata....for me its an emotion

[@harisjilani2313]

Yes bro I'm also from ASANSOL I also visited there

[@srinjayr3112]

​@@-EIE--ShouvikBanerjeeekdom❤

[@TaslimaKhatun-ht5pi]

You are 100% right.

[@rajdipchandradafader5367]

Kolkata will rise again, With its strategic location..❤

[@ayeaayush]

When I went to Kolkata recently, it felt like it was a very, very big rotting 'village'.

[@Maruti_800_original]

Thanks to chuslims

[@Maruti_800_original]

@@bobbyaxelrod3242 pissmillah bhoijaan

[@NOVA10993]

@@bobbyaxelrod3242 lath marke Bangladesh vaga denge bhenchod

[@surajagarwal7685]

​@@bobbyaxelrod3242muslim capital bnne se kolkata developed ho jayega kya 😃 Mudarsa chop😃

[@somvaarblues]

@@bobbyaxelrod3242 more like refugee capital

[@saptaksarkar30468]

They need to incentivize development of industry and IT sector in sub-urban Kolkata, especially Barasat, Naihati & Budge Budge. They have good transport & man power.

[@EMTMZ]

Why IT near Kolkata why not in Medinipur Division????? We want new state Whole Medinipur should new state.

[@nileshmajumdar7530]

​@@EMTMZchup bc😂😂😂😂

[@ankitganguly2382]

@@EMTMZ well said, I am not supporting Midnapore as a new state, but West Bengal should not be Kolkata centric. Midnapore is situated in a junction point of WB ODISHA AND JHARKHAND. Govt of WB should built and IT hub in Midnapore town, and kgp mdn can be made as twin cities.

[@EMTMZ]

@@ankitganguly2382 Really its too much. Kolkata people rule us looted us. Still they are doing now politically

[@ankitganguly2382]

@@EMTMZ by the way where are you from, I am belonging form the division head quarter city

[@ranajit2355]

Come back is always possible. But for that leadership is needed. At the same time it must be noted that Calcutta is the only city which had to directly face the impact of partition and refugees. Also talk about central govt policy of freight equalisation and licence raj policy which directly served the economic condition of western southern and northern India at the cost of Eastern India

[@adamhendrickson512]

One of the other major factor behind the downfall of Bengal is the rampant corruption.

[@sidhughosh6469]

Kolkata will not change never 😢

[@harisjilani2313]

So bro how it is India's 3rd largest GDP and richest city ? Still a population of 1.5 crore ? Whereas Mumbai and Delhi have population of 2.5+ crore So they are 1st and 2nd Think again

[@gauravpandey44]

Kolkata is Very rich city bro.....after 5-7 Year Kolkata is bounce back again 😊

[@sankhasubhrapratihar2293]

Kolkata will change only your type of people will stay same forever.

[@ayushghosh1155]

Why is office absorption higher than rest of the years then this year? Why is UK more interested in developing WB? They are coming for the sake of it? Please think again.

[@harisjilani2313]

@@yumi-e2o Agar past mai he rehta kolkata tou aaj woh top 10 richest city mai bhi nhi aata Aaj ke dor mai WB mai 3 vande bharat train chalti hai 1st metro kolkata mai chali thi Oh ye tou past hai 👆🏻 1st under water metro kolkata mai chali hai Jaake news dekho Kolkata abhi East India ka richest or financial city hai Kolkata ab tou IT sector mai per faila raha hai

[@aniketram3545]

TMC hathao Kolkata bachao 🙏😂

[@VikashJaiswalSharma2-ke9gi]

Agree brother

[@rohanchakraborty-n11je]

Kolkata ko barbaad Congress ne Kia hai TMC nahi .

[@Shortsisland-el6ib]

@@rohanchakraborty-n11je to itne saalo se TMC ne kuch kar paya ?

[@minhaz0015]

As a west bengal citizen really.. Kolkata become worst day by day

[@jaymondal8699]

I agree with you brother 👍👍

[@srib2381]

Iam from Coimbatore Tamil Nadu. In my area there are more than 7-10 bengali saloons. In Tamilnadu every local barbers left the barber job and now Bengalis earning in lakhs.

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

Damn. Barber are making in lakhs😢

[@sarthakadak2454]

@@ShubhamMishrabro their establishment are like semi posh saloon, that's why.

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

@@sarthakadak2454 ohhh

[@ERa_7]

😂

[@srinjayr3112]

Interesting

[@rediscoverlife101]

Kolkata city is the city of 80s We need high tech cities like Hyderabad ,Bangalore

[@akashpatel8410]

​@@AllInOne-bv1tiBengali dick girl living in US

[@SOUVIK_RAY_]

Still trying to understand what high tech did you see in Bangalore or Hyderabad?

[@debraj2075]

Kolkata is best for living. Everything is very affordable. Only job sector wise it needs improvement. That will happen.

[@biharisuar7734]

Half of city footpath is slum

[@debraj2075]

People from Bihar are coming huge in nos in Kolkata. And all cities have similar structures. It is not slum. Mumbai has more slums than Kolkata and old Delhi also has those areas.

[@rajarshimanna5825]

Bihari Fut Bengal se

[@biharisuar7734]

@@rajarshimanna5825 bihari n Bengali are 🐖🐖🐖🐷🐷

[@nileshkujur8025]

Kolkata has everything that can a make a true global cosmopolitan city for India. We just need to work on everything to again make Kolkata the greatest city of India. It has the potential to surpass Mumbai, New Delhi, Chennai, and Bangalore.

[@Nontouristicindia12err]

Very tough..there are lot of poverty at..cultural area of kolkata..sovabazar..baghbazar..shyambazaar area..cossiepur..to towards dkhineshwar go and see how poverty and homeless has grabbed the city

[@hi-oj1jh]

True, only the Bengalis have a negative & weak mentality which is hindering them from contributing towards the development of their state. Else, West Bengal has immense potential.

[@bijoyghosh1813]

The fact is Kolkata knows how to save its rich culture and history and simultaneously make development. The north is culturally rich keeping its old culture alive and developed the southern Kolkata. However, world's first underwater metro us in Kolkata.

[@arkapratimchangdar969]

Kolkata will come back for sure ❤

[@hjsaha.]

As a "Probashi-bangali" I can say the major reason for the degradation of West Bengal is the club culture. Most Bengali youth are drawn to clubs from young age where nothing more than politics, drugs and drinks goes on. The time when they should focus on career and growth, they focuses on all the irrelivant things.

[@idontknow014]

Kolkata firse 1 number par jayega ✊

[@divyajyotisamadder7576]

I feel like Calcutta will never grow 😭😭😭😭

[@navnathsurvase3490]

Kolkata is dead city Sooner banglore, Hyderabad overtake Kolkata GDP

[@ujjawaldutta3859]

Jab tak leftist ka pas trinumul Kolkata hoga tabtak ya Aisa ni raihaga

[@gamingtech451]

​@@ujjawaldutta3859😅

[@Iam.bihari.]

Mamta Banerjee best cm hai.

[@ujjawaldutta3859]

@@Iam.bihari. I am sorry can't see her as best CM I think trinumul and marksheets is responsible for downfall of Kolkata

[@AmanRouth]

Kolkata development means whole east India development I'm proud of Kolkata beautiful

[@Rudeus86]

With Time Kolkata will rise again

[@abhilashjash7714]

Kolkata in terms of GDP comes after Delhi and Mumbai. Govt just needs to strengthen infrastructure and bring back the talent that it has lost to other states. Which is actually happening. It's a very planned city with greatest network of public transport in the country. I am a Bengali. I live in Bangalore which is another bengal in itself. I regularly monitor my home city Kolkata's progress and it it really commendable atleast for the last few years.

[@sertaer861]

nope bengaluru and hyderabad has replaced it

[@arindamdutta9371]

Yes. I also travel from abroad... And for last 5-6 years seeing progress.

[@rishavrakshit3995]

You must be really delusional.

[@rskmahesh3531]

Dont ever try to call our bangalore as your bengal, its not stinky hell like kolkata.

[@abhilashjash7714]

@@rskmahesh3531 stay in your delusion mate. There's no scope of comparison for us coz we have seen far far better. 😌 "Par weather accha hain dost, maa kasam." 🤣

[@ibrahimmolla8501]

We need to enhance Siliguri as proper city to support Kolkata as well as West Bengal...

[@cygnetsam]

This is the most accurate video which shows the accurate positive direction on which the city is going.

[@moinulhasanjalali1316]

Thanks PT for such an informative video. We really hope Kolkata bounce back soon with new technologies, but The dirty political business not only by the leading power also by each and every party.

[@richik12]

It is reviving. WB just need the importance that the central govt gave to Gujrat and southern India in terms of Industrialization.

[@biharisuar7734]

In your dream 😂😂

[@PranavKovale]

Where do you get this information? Your efforts are just commendable. Your way of spreading this information is very neutral and non-partial. It is pure information and will help the common man to know more about the country and its history.

[@nemesiszz]

west bengal would have been like bihar if not for the ports.

[@KishanKumar-qz1kt]

West Bengal without kolkata is worst than bihar

[@just_a_curious_thinker]

​@@KishanKumar-qz1ktWest Bengal without Kolkata is equal to Bihar without Patna

[@spilltea4241]

​@@just_a_curious_thinker the poorest districts of West Bengal is richer than Begusarai

[@friendshipcharging7657]

it is very similar Kolkata gdp ~155 billion west bengal~ 220billion, that state is a joke

[@KishanKumar-qz1kt]

@@friendshipcharging7657 220-155=65 billion dollars. 65 billion dollars for 85 million people

[@surajitghosh4172]

This video ends with a positive note. As they say, hope should be the last thing to die. May Kolkata shine again. 🙏

[@sujathaviswanathan7210]

I visited Kolkata many years ago and saw a once great bustling city crying for attention! Nothing can be said about the future! Kolkata MAY rise again as a booming city if and only if the government and its citizens want it to be so! Personally, I don’t have any hope!

[@sandipanmahato5313]

The fun fact is Kolkata is still India's 3rd richest city as per GDP 😅

[@mangeshadbale4337]

Mumbai>Chennai>banglore>Kolkata or Hyderabad

[@idontknow014]

​@@mangeshadbale4337Mumbai>Delhi>Kolkata>Bangalore>Chennai

[@mangeshadbale4337]

@@idontknow014 hmm i thought Delhi was like a ut/ kinda state ,but also Chennai or Bangalore > Kolkata

[@mangeshadbale4337]

​Deak lo bhai Chennai ultra HD slum hai par Kolkata 144p slum hai😂

[@31davidwarner]

Chennai is better than Kolkata But Bengaluru is better than Chennai Delhi is better than Bengaluru

[@studytime2570]

One thing that was missed was the detrimental effects of freight equalisation policy.

[@arindamdutta9371]

Yes. This also was a major reason

[@BOMBBUSHKA]

Joy Bangla ! God Bless Bengal ! Make Bengal Great AGAIN !

[@deeptobhattacharyya3249]

Nostalgia is Kolkata's curse

[@souvikghosh5768]

Some product base company like Atlassian, Airbnb, Google, Amazon, Walmart, Browserstack, Paytm, Flipkart......... If 1 or 2 companies like these come to Kolkata & open their development centre then it would change Kolkata's IT market drastically..

[@happys6057]

it needs a very large international manufacturing giant .

[@shreeyanksinghvi7748]

why they will come to calcutta, a failed region failed state

[@TheLargestCompanies]

why not the opposite direction, the internationalization of Kolkata companies: kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZqSvpaeQibSphsksi=IsCXIns31ZLO9JO0 is probably a good alternative

[@brahmajitghosh3536]

Dhaka,the capital of Bangladesh,is now far ahead in Many aspects from Calcutta.

[@snehasishghosh7278]

Impartial and factual content..keep it up👍👍

[@dipanchaudhuri5551]

Kolkata will definitely rise again....

[@azankhan88]

Partition along with Frieght equalization had a bigger role in diminishing Kolkatas economy

[@Informativeeye]

Who creates that Kolkata economy?

[@Akarsh-kq9uf]

Teri hi community ne India ka nash kiya

[@arpan9937]

​@@Akarsh-kq9ufchal be chamar. Agar azadi Dena naash hai, to tu nookar ki kafi hai. Jahil.

[@someonejustsomeone1469]

It will become rich the day when the people there stop talking about the "glorious past".

[@invisiblegamer2377]

kolkata will be rise again as soon as possible

[@searchvishal]

You will feel Joy in Kolkata. Buraiya hai Kolkata me no doubt but jo acha feel jo anand feel hota hai wo kisi dusre seher me nahi hota, Wish ki Kolkata aur jada beautiful aur advance city ho jaye ❤

[@royarnab26]

My own maternal Grandfather have come to West Bengal & settled here from Jessore Bangladesh in 1970 to save there family from Pakistani Armys persecution of Hindus in East Pakistan. Now we r proud Indians. 🇮🇳

[@shreeyanksinghvi7748]

you should have kicked out muslim family like Punjabi have done in east punjab

[@spilltea4241]

Even after 76 years economic mismanagement, Kolkata is still the 3rd richest city of India Thats something imo

[@DipakkrSaha]

Are bc.... Kolkata metropolitan region includes howrah and hoogly...so the area considered is much larger than Bengaluru or Hyderabad metropolitan region...we are way behind in GDP per capita accept it😂

[@SHUBHAMSG]

Imagine how far ahead it was :/

[@nilaymallikk]

Sasta Economist be like 😅😅

[@EMTMZ]

Kolkata will be like Karachi. No economics but Islamic fundamentalism persists.

[@spilltea4241]

@@DipakkrSaha well if u just consider city proper Kolkata only has 40lakh people while Bangalore has over 80lakh.

[@mohammadmubashirmallick9961]

Always make best videos

[@kashyapkotak7629]

Mumbai also seems to be going the Kolkata way... except the downfall maybe starting. Already lost IT economy to Bangalore, financial dominance to GIFT city in future, losing many industries at rapid pace due to expensive real estate, delayed mega projects like Eastern business front, metro lines, new airport, etc, and the state being stuck in a weird political situation.

[@rohitjoshi3875]

mumbai is world class city what are you talking about there is no comparison between Mumbai 👑and shitty kolkuta😂 Mamta destroyed whole bengal

[@tiger-wt8dm]

Vote for 2 gujju whole maharashtra will be destroyed.

[@tamanna4697]

Mumbai is far far better than Kolkata

[@krishnajain6841]

🤡 that's why there is Navi Mumbai to solve this problem

[@abubakarshaikh1638]

Yes, u r absolutely right

[@rishiroy6545]

many people don't know why it is still the 3rd richest city...Everyone just look at the IT sector as it is less then Bangalore and hydrabaad....But kolkata's wholesale market plays a hugh role here...Bara bazar is the most populous wholesale market in India and due to this kolkata is still the 3rd richest

[@CHINMOYGAMING]

It Industry is not everything. You know what is it industry. Only 3 lakh people work in it industry

[@soumyajitchaudhuri1777]

It's easy to comment as being an outsider! Request you to live in this city for a couple of years and I bet you will fall in love with this city! 🌹🌹🌹

[@shreeyanksinghvi7748]

they why people migrating out of Kolkata ? specially bengali

[@soumyajitchaudhuri1777]

@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 migration happens everywhere bro! Not every city can offer you everything!

[@ashishumrao5768]

Then why bengali coming to India?

[@ashishumrao5768]

​@@soumyajitchaudhuri1777but there is lot of bengali coming to India do something on your state

[@sakibmullick]

Absolutely

[@adhirbose9910]

Kolkata will soon become the 2nd biggest city. Of Bangladesh .

[@ffloversgaming5095]

😂😂😂 Of India 😂😂

[@soustabhpaul3591]

Share the links of the stat. Being a Kolkatan, I need to cross check the fact, because it seems wrong information is circulated intentionally.

[@ayushghosh1155]

Which is the wrong info? I request you to actually go to the sources, they are legit.

[@baristaccd]

Some Positives on West Bengal -Read on to Find out!! : 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 Let Bengal shine, Let all States Shine, Let India shine. Jai Hind!! 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 West Bengal has many Positives, which we miss to Highlight Properly: -West Bengal has the 6th Largest State GDP in India -West Bengal witnessed CAGR of 12.62% between 2015-16 to 2020-21 -It has a Thriving IT sector at Saltlake City and New Town areas, and is home to companies like TCS (~50,000 ppl at 15 Locations in Kolkata!), WIPRO, IBM, ACCENTURE, HCL, Capgemini, Cognizant, HSBC-HDPI, to name a few! - Thriving Agricultural sector - being the Largest Producer of Rice and 2nd largest producer of Potato in the country! -Accounts for 30% of the country's Tea Production -Total IT and Software export to soon reach USD 4 Bn - Home to 45 Universities, IIT, IISC and IIM - West Bengal accounted for 11.62% of Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs), the most among the top 10 states of the country. - West Bengal has the highest number of MSMEs in the country with 52,69,814 units!!! Geographically, one of the most gifted -- from Himalayas, The Ganges, Sunderbans ( largest riverine delta), to the Jungles and wildlife of North Bengal!! *KOLKATA is the 3rd Richest City in India, after Mumbai and Delhi!!! *KOLKATA has the 4th Highest Per Capita GDP among Indian Cities, followed by Hyderabad and Bangalore (5th & 6th) *Home to First Metro Rail services and First Under-water Metro Services!! The above, are also Facts and Numbers collected from reliable Sources from the Web. NOW, to understand more about how Thriving the City has become in the last 25 years, after liberalization of the Indian Economy -- I just urge u All to Search and Watch one Video on KZbin themed - 'Kolkata a Shining Metropolis'' .. u will be Amazed!!~~• ----Now the IT Sector in Kolkata------: Kolkata is doing quite well with more than 70 Tech n Consulting Giants opening centers in New Town (The IT Hub of the City) in Kolkata in last 2 years: Partial list: Infosys Accenture (already there) TCS (Huge presence) Deloitte USI Mindtree (other than their office in sector V their permanent campus coming in Newtown) LTI (Setting up 6 Towers in NewTown over 20 Acres for ~20K People) Delloite US EY GDS Zensar Global delivery center Zoho PWC and TCS are expanding hugely Grant Thornton Bharat Prestige group Juniper networks (big one ) Avisys services KPMG India & KPMG US division Indorma venture Capegemini Trangile services Consultant Factory Mantra lab Zuru tech Atomberg technology 360 degree cloud technology Data consultant corp. Tradebull Madison World US based PTS consulting Hexagon Verolt Maantic Inn. Hitachi rail (R&D , design division) Sasken technology Sterlite technology Lexmark is expanding JUspay Protiviti Mpokket. Tismo CBNITS Iskraemeco Bizom Birlasoft Luxoft Worley Motorola solutions Rapipay fintech Cinedigm Redefine 88 East Oracle Persistent system Surprising, but TRUE- Kolkata Tech Sector is Gaining in Momentum - to emerge as a strong center - catering to Talent from Eastern India - which is good - as will recalibrate the pressure on places like Bangalore and NCR. Jai Hind 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@ritabratagoswami7724]

Kolkata back then Calcutta used to called as "London in the east" or the sister city of London at early 20th century. 100 years back. I dont think kolkata downed because of opening of sewage canal and so shifting industries to the west i.e. maharastra. This because of wrong politics of CPI. Because At the same time just after the ww2 China was developing. Shanghai, Gunazhou, Hong Kong, Japan was rapidly expanding and also the Malaysia, singapore. Kolkata still had much greater opportunity then Mumbai. Because Kolkata is only closest city to S.E Asia and also ideal city to capture Market in bangladesh and at that time highly skilled and educated work force only used to found in bengal. But it was not focused by Joti basu. Opportunity also came in 2007 in singur by TATA NANO. But CM of CPI lead govt buddhadeb bhattachrya Failed to eliminate the nuisances of TMC. And so TATA went to Anand Gujrate. Fun fact TATA choose bengal first not Gujrate because of skilled work force. If TATA were into the bengal today. Kolkata would have the no 1 city in terms of GDP by now not in 3. And coming to IT sectors. Bengal silicon valley as it is planned, if the plan execute properly It may have chance to replace bengaluru and hydrabad and it may prevent the brain drain to out of bengal. I hope upcoming BJP govt will take it seriously.

[@rajbiswas249]

Just look at the current political situation in west bengal. Murder loot arson bombs. Do you think that any sane minded industrialist will invest his money here?????

[@SumitPalTube]

Learn about the freight equalization policy of India. It is a big factor.

[@bobbyaxelrod3242]

brilliant analysis

[@NoName-is3tu]

Once upon a time Bengal was so rich in literature,science, patriotism and economy that it was compared with the rest of the world....now its just a history...since independence bengal has been declining and the main reason is dirty politics and corruption

[@44455525]

Rightly pointed out 80% occupancy rate of office spaces by big companies post pandemic at Kolkata ,Salt lake city and New Town as per Knight frank..We need a a corruption less stable government now which can bring our glory back.

[@Enigma0071]

there is no corruption in TMC....Mamata still wears 200 Rs saree and 120 Rs chappal....Mamta's chappal is even cheaper than 150 Rs Kejriwal's chappal

[@user-fc7mq9cq7u]

The last edition of the BGBS took place in April of 2022 where the government claimed to have attracted investment proposal worth Rs 3.42 lakh crore. In the previous five chapters, a total of Rs 12.35 lakh crore of investment proposals were received, data from a government website showed.

[@Enigma0071]

@@user-fc7mq9cq7u kon se madarsha se liya hai yeh figure? Furfura Sareef??

[@soumyajyotidutta3113]

Newtown is smartest city of India🇮🇳 🇮🇳 Newtown, Saltlake sector-v, Rajarhat, Bidhannagar, Baguihati, CBD......these areas are really next level....and IT is growing like anything in this particular areas.

[@adityabanerjee0244]

😂😂 no product base company is coming in kolkata ...only some service based and cement companies r choosing kolkata...and fdi investment is only 3000 crore this year 2023...that's the major problem where as bangalore 80000 crores...in 2023...and wb debt to gdp ratio is too much high...

[@Your_real_dad]

​@@adityabanerjee0244credit to Amader priyo pishimoni 😊

[@SumitPalTube]

Dada sab hobe, product based company o aasbe. Trust Bengal, trust Bangali.

[@jerry-sb1238]

​@@SumitPalTube😂 bongs sala gaanja foonke industry ko setup hi hone nhi denge

[@jerry-sb1238]

​@@SumitPalTubeasebo sapna mein

[@sadenb]

Kolkata can still rise with good leadership. Currently it is a dying city though.

[@abubakarshaikh1638]

nice info, ❤

[@bharatlaljayswal2653]

THE DUBAI OF 20TH CENTURY KALKATTA

[@vaibhavsingh321]

Bhai thoda elaborate karke explain Karo video agar 20-30 min ka Ho bhi jaye to bhi Problem nahi hai. At least after watching video humare mind me ek picture kind of summary create honi chahiye. Which is missing?

[@soham6649]

Agreed! Please explain why the policies did not work, what's the context? Simply saying they didn't work raises more questions

[@FHANTOMCRAFT]

I hope the day will come.

[@banarulsk4929]

Tumara channel bohot jaldi million per karega

[@amadeussocal7833]

Kolkata is not a dying city, it's already a dead mummified city. Unless there is a drastic change in present political landscape, with a dynamic government in power, any upheaval of Kolkata and Waste Bengal is impossible.

[@harisjilani2313]

Every thing is possible WB have heavy future projects which work is almost completed It is not waste it's best Bengal Kolkata is 3rd largest GDP and richest city of india Think again brother And Habibi come to Kolkata I'm from Asansol

[@summertimegamerz3665]

Kolkata ka major problem rapid up bihari he bassss....jab West Bengal me election ata h tabhi youtubers jyada Bengal ki economy k bare me sochte he....kabhi Kolkata k dankuni dulagarh panagarh aye ho....jitne bhi industries he sab bahar k log Kam karte he....up bihar se ate he.... Kolkata jaisa he khud se agee badega , Refuge crisis , downfall k baad bhi Kolkata aj tika he jo india k kisi city ke pas dam nahi he.... lekin aj bhi 3rd largest metropolitan city he . New town smart City he or kya bolu samahjne wale samjhenge

[@dipteshbasak4810]

Bro Kolkata 3rd richest city abb haa par gdp per capita and human development index mein baki metropolitan cities se kam haa. Kolkata ka gdp growth rate kam haa dusre cities se agar aisa hi raha tooh next 3-5 years mein kolkata niche chala jayega. We need a strong and anti corrupt leader like yogi ji.

[@ibmongergamingyt5869]

I really love Kolkata

[@wassuphomies263]

powertrain did you use AI generated black and white images for this video ? Many of the images seem eerily AI generated

[@-EIE--ShouvikBanerjee]

yes i felt the same his videos show the downfall but never the climb of kolkata

[@soumyajitchaudhuri1777]

Be it rich or poor the amount of life, energy and emotion is infused in kolkata you won't find it in any other indian city! ❤️

[@sudeb6537]

Hmm emotion nie thakun

[@CHINMOYGAMING]

India ki sabhi city bekar hai. Phir bhi mere hisab se Delhi, mumbai ka kuch area acha hai. Baki city village jesa

[@soumyajitchaudhuri1777]

@@sudeb6537 advertisement er trap e pa deben na Pls!

[@AmanKumar-wh8tk]

this, this exact mindset is the biggest deterrent to Kolkata's development and growth. Talk about emotion, energy and all other bullshit crap instead of focussing on tangible economic parameters. Bengalis are dumb. This is coming from an alumnus of Jadavpur University.

[@mickeysaini403]

WB playbook: Step 1: Destroy businesses - Stop Industrialization, Kill Businessmen, Shun Capitalization and embrace Communism Step 2: Strike, Strike - Stop working Step 3: Make businesses flee, encourage violence (This still happens - Taken over by Islamic violence after Communist violence and TMC Violence), Play religion card, encourage Islamic radicalism, immigration from Bangladesh, religious extremism and crimes. Step 4: Progress falls - HDI lags, Industrial output lags, prosperity lags - Surprised pikachu face for WB Step 5: Encourage Business, MSME, but fail miserably Step 6: More surprised Pikachu face Step 7: Blame center for step brotherly treatment, Blame center for all the mis-steps that did... Step 8: No changes in status - More surprised pikachu face... Step 9: IT Comes as rescue but overall still decline... continues... Future: Step 10: Momota loses election.... Things start to improve.. with CAA/NRC implementation...

[@ABCDEF26090]

Wet dreams of a Chaddi 😂😂😂

[@mickeysaini403]

@@ABCDEF26090 This is communist and TMCs history like the poll violence of Islamists and TMC where more than 15 people have died. Lol loosers communist, Islamists and liberal's wet dream is abusing chaddi even though they have nothing to do with WB and majority of Indians are centrist but hey throwing ad-homenim is a sign of intelligence among communist, TMC supporters and Islamists. Did your parents feed you lead chips for dinner or what?

[@EMTMZ]

You are right.

[@mickeysaini403]

@@ABCDEF26090 Also, look at the state of affairs of so called rotting city still stuck in 1950s. Did you forget Bengals's history itself? Well it is expected from morons. The most backward state around with violence every election as if monkeys live there... Even Bihar doesn't see this much religious and political violence since independence...

[@-Irfan-]

Stop copying

[@rishithalder2740]

I Think It's Time To See A New Political Face In west Bengal Sri Abhishek B 🎉

[@55_hetpatel74]

I wish Bengal Will grow again Love From Guj

[@sumit2302]

मोका हुम्बा हुम्बा बम्बा बम्बा 😂😂😂

[@SayounGaming]

Kolkata had been left far far behind almost all major growing cities

[@koushikdas657]

Yes it's now similar to Siliguri or durgapur. But previously those cities were small towns competing in Kolkata size and modernity.

[@atharvasurshetwar6957]

Great

[@OCF-OperationColdFire]

Make Bengal Great again

[@loveu5045]

Illegal migration over the decades is the biggest problem. Since independence central gov. intentionally have created this problem. Just look at India pak border how secured and well structured it is. But in India Bangladesh border, there's literally 100s of km have no modern and effective structure to stop trespassing. BSF is least efficient here.

[@andyc9902]

Hindus are welcome

[@Akash_Bardhan7]

British East India company & CPIM ruined the pride of Kolkata. But I'm sure it will rise again.

[@sayantansam5468]

Very nice Analysis 👌 👍

[@HimadriBhowmik]

I am just wondering, why all these videos from reputed channels about Kolkata and West Bengal, almost always comes in increased numbers before elections in West Bengal. Always perfect timing. Maybe a coincidence. Or maybe a try to influence public perception.