Will MSP Cost ₹10 Lakh Crore?! - The REAL Maths Explained | Akash Banerjee & Adwaith

[@thedeshbhakt]

Buy Term Plan & Get Online Discount Upto 10%👇 tinyurl.com/mrysvkks

[@anshumanchakraborty_7]

❤

[@Vibevault71]

सर मैं सोयाबीन की खेती करता हू , ऑक्टोबर से सोयाबीन घर मैं पडा है मेरा खर्च भी 😢 नही निकलता 4200₹ भाव से

[@Vthepeoplefirst]

Here is another data people consumption has gone up and number of poors went down, this is because of BJP modi. Consumption is up that helps everyone including small businesses and overall economy.

[@ankurupadhyay8434]

Sarkarkar ko modern Krishan yojna Lani chahiye jise Krishan or agey jaye jaisa aj america me hota hai😢😢😢😮

[@Not_A_Bhakt]

*Great Report* ❤ *Video शेयर करके अपना देश बचाने में मदद करे* 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@sahiljindal]

Sometimes, people forget that economy is not just about money, but also people involved in the economy.

[@23367388]

Bewakoof

[@AaryanTushir-m2b]

Thanks! For raising our voice.

[@AaryanTushir-m2b]

@@iamhimanshusharma2358 rashan khareedne ki jaroorat terko hogi. Kisaano ko khreedne ki jarurat nhi hoti. We grow our own food.

[@puneetsahota]

Thank You for putting together a comprehensive overview of MSP and its implications for farmers and others.

[@puneetsahota]

@Prakhar2410 It depends if all cloth mills are collectively failing and there are steps that can be taken to help the industry as a whole you can petition the government and/or demand help.

[@puneetsahota]

I empathize with small business owners and them having to struggle to make ends meet. The whole system is pivoting towards capitalism; the small man has no support. We have seen this happen world over in the last 50 years. The farmers as a collective have been organized for a while and thus are in a position to get their voices heard. And as far as majoritarianism is concerned, hawa toh ussi ki hai aaj India mein. Isn’t UCC majoritarianism, or the whole Hindutava movement. If 54% of the country(farmers) is facing a crisis should we ignore that saying yeh majoritarian politics hai?? Your points raise a good question;something we should all think about.

[@centristlibertarian]

@Prakhar2410 bhai tune logical question kaise pooch liya? Tujhe nhi pata kya iss desh mei sirf kisaan hi bechara ho skta hai? Middle class people ko koi bhi loan waiver nhi dega. Tu mehnat kar, tax bhar aur phir woh tax se farmers ko pension milegi. Aur tune farmers ko criticize kiya toh tu andbakt.

[@Zlurpa]

​@@centristlibertariantum bichare ho to protest karo, agar careless ya lazy ho than don't blame those who fight for their rights

[@puneetsahota]

Basically you guys are saying g no one has it easy in the country- middle class, small business, baki sare mehnat kash log. Toh ek doosre pe apna gussa nikalo. Farmers pe gussa nikalo ki woh kyu demand kar rahe hai…. But don’t ask the people who can actually do something about this😢

[@hardeepsingh4300]

Akash Bhai, Excellent Stuff ! 👍Very well researched episode. Legally binding MSP is much needed for Farmers at the moment. Agri experts and Activists like P. Sainath and Devendra Sharma has been telling this for long time. .... Thanks a lot.

[@thedeshbhakt]

thanks hardeep!

[@happygolucky111]

Kucch din me inko apne channel pe msp chahiye hogi. Aur tax free bhi

[@IamShashankMishra]

"The man who asks question is a fool for a minute, a man who doesn't ask is a fool for life." ~ Confucius❤❤

[@ghanshyamjoshi587]

“It's better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than open it and remove all doubt” ~ Mark Twain ♥♥

[@ArnavTHR]

WAIT WHAT 💀💀 @@ghanshyamjoshi587

[@dinupathade6439]

🤔Only keep your mouth shut when it is needed because "You might say something extreme or hurtful. This can lead to a breakdown in communication and can make it more difficult to resolve the issue at hand" he said that quote for avoiding problems and consequences by shut 🤫(This is not applicable for questioning gov.)😊

[@ghanshyamjoshi587]

@thade6439 And who will decide that what is applicable and what is not...? Armchair critics and youtube influencers. The earlier laws are drafted on the suggestions of almost all the agriculture scientists with years of effort but went straight to dustbin.

[@skyinearth]

​@@ghanshyamjoshi587 Learn the word Democracy before quoting irrelevant lines.

[@Manveer.626]

ਜੋ ਆਉਣੇ ਦੇਸ਼ ਦੀ ਭਾਸ਼ਾ ਨਹੀਂ ਬੋਲ ਸਕਦਾ ਓਹੋ ਦੇਸ਼ ਦਾ ਕਿਵੇਂ ਹੋ ਸਕਦਾ ਹੈ ਸਭ ਹੀ ਇੰਗਲਿਸ਼ ਚ ਲਿਖ ਰਹੇ ਹਨ ਇਹ ਤਰੱਕੀ ਨਹੀ ਹੈ 👍 ਵੈਸੇ ਸਰ ਤੁਸੀ ਬਹੁਤ ਵਧਿਆ ਬੋਲੇ ਧੰਨਵਾਦ

[@Piyush24s]

Konsa desh vhaai desh to ek hi hai ek hi rhega bharat🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@yaduyadav---]

धन्यवाद लेकिन हिन्दी मे टाइप करने मैं थोड़ी दिक्कत होती हे इसी वज़ह से सब इंग्लिश में लिख रहे हैं।

[@Hardik-nq7xm]

Humare desh mein itni bashayen h ki agar har koi apni bhasha me bolega or likhega to bohot samay barbad hoga. Isliye asani ke lie sab angrezi ka upyog krte h isme koi sharam ki baat nhi is hi karan se humare desh mein angrezi ko raajbhasha banaya h

[@satishsharma9307]

हार्दिक भाई, आपको टाइप करते वक्त key pad को बस हिंदी में सेट करना है बाकी गूगल अपने आप आपकी इस Hinglish को हिंदी बना देता है (जैसे मैं लिख रहा हूं)। बस अपने सेटिंग में Key board की सेटिंग में हिंदी भी add कर लीजिए ।

[@Manveer.626]

@@Piyush24s ਆਪਣੇ ਦੇਸ਼ ਪ੍ਰਤੀ ਇਹ ਭਾਵਨਾ ਠੀਕ ਹੈ ਪਰ ਅੰਧਭਕਤੀ ਨਾ ਕਰੋ ਕਿਉਕਿ ਹੋਰ ਵੀ ਦੇਸ਼ ਹਨ ਮੰਨਣਾ ਪੈਣਾ ਹੈ 👍ਉਹਨਾਂ ਦੀ ਤਰਾਂ ਤਰੱਕੀ ਕਰੋ ਕੁੱਛ ਸਿੱਖੋ

[@assamantaamal]

This episode was surely a good analysis and presentation - it was Great!

[@jeevankumar1082]

Please watch analysis from Think School.....This guy mentioned the short term advantages only

[@Tejas-zx7ie]

This is dumb. IDK why its so hard to understand.

[@TheBatman909]

I am the son of a farmer, and I understand the immense effort that goes into our work. My father tirelessly tends to our fields even in the scorching noon when the sun is at its peak, while others enjoy the comfort of air-conditioned rooms during the summer. Despite this, some blind fans unfairly label us as over-demanding and extravagant. This episode holds significant meaning for me, thank you Akash Sir❤❤

[@Gourav.Kaliramna]

Few years back mustard was purchased Rs 60/kg Then 45-50/kg And farmers stopped growing. Import increased. And mustard oil hit 200 per litre. MSP is a tactic to continue farming and save country from food inflation and food crisis.

[@parmsoftech]

​​​@@Artrader_em8koif this bjp government private limited company have the capacity to write off the lakhs of crores to corporate friends then what's the problem with farmers? Asking about the numbers, you should present data of how government is out of money as on one side they are claiming more and more people are coming under epfo and direct tax slabs and have collected record taxes from direct and indirect taxes. Dont cry with your 5% tax paying people lolypop. Everybody is paying indirect taxes, from morning cup of tea to good night mosquito coils, from LPG to petrol and disel, they even imposed taxes of necessary items like flour which even east India company never did. Chech the inflation index, it's on record high at the times when unemployment is also at record high. Check malnutrition index, MSMEs are bankrupted, the shopkeepers are out of market and crying about of their survival, right becoming more rich because of easy access to capital and loans by presenting artificially inflated stock prices of their company shares by their shell companies from tax havens, the black money in Swiss bank is at record high while the farmers and students are committing suicides but all the government funded undertakings are being sold to corporate (Airport, Rail, SAIL,...) And govt vacancies are record low which will further shrik. The schemes like agniveer is trailer, they will make everything on contract and exploitation of citizens will reach new heights by this govt private limited company. This BJP private limited company is maximizing the taxes revenue and minimising the expenditure by selling everything to corporate friends. BJP private limited is looting multiple times as compared to east india company.

[@tarunkhapra7211]

@@Artrader_em8ko Is it only the duty of farmers to suffer? You don't complain when petrol prices are above 100 even though it's at their lowest in the international market, but when it comes to food, you want it to be the cheapest in the world. Then you compare the market prices of wheat with America, where the average farm is around 500 acres, but when it comes to subsidies to support farmers, India becomes poor. It's surprising and hypocritical.

[@RiteshKumar-di7dr]

Prices are driven by demand and supply, it shouldn't be intervened by govt. Instead of MSP govt should provide better storage facilities to farmers at lowest cost so farmers gets benefitted most when prices increase.

[@user-db9vw7si3x]

Farm laws k time bicholiya ko bhagwan mante the Aaj fir kese bicholiya villian ban gaye

[@MrSam-mg5ut]

@@Artrader_em8ko there is no crop insurance. Govt dont give any insurance. You only get some money if there is heavy flood or rain in the entire area

[@iQrar__Rehman]

Being a science student, watching these kind of episodes make me feel intrested in economics 😊

[@runajain5773]

I may recommend to watch study iq video on farmer protest and economic concern

[@manishmkv5524]

Iski aadhi video true aur aadhi dikhai hi nhi

[@Marion3ttist]

Good atleast you are not following Islam

[@ONKARKAHALI]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/kJyblqKoq7JoqJYsi=JEc_Zkg29_koNydX

[@bbbbb2490]

​@@Marion3ttist😂😂😂😂

[@ajazamin9843]

Our country's agricultural governing system needs an overhaul in nutshell. Need involvement of economists like Manmohan Singh sir and others.

[@CuriousJuggernaut]

Thanks for this amazing video

[@shashankmaikhuri_007]

Mostly farmers of Punjab, Haryana and Western UP gets the benifit of MSP and that's why they are the only ones protesting

[@GpSingh9120]

Because MSP only on wheat or peddy in punjab, hariyana and wup but not on other crops and second reasons in swaminathan report msp

[@gurpalsinghsehra4399]

Because of ground water level short day by day they want to come out this crops that is reason come want to grow other crops

[@sarcasm614]

U really think that they are farmers who protesting do check the facts sir u will get to know the truth why there demand is infeasible

[@pramodkumarnag33]

Yes brow you are right but this kind people's ony makes this kind of videos to impress their own political parties or nothing else.

[@amritpalkaur1052]

Who said only Punjab Haryana farmers protesting Karnataka tamilnadu farmers r also protesting but our media is not showing n govt unhein Delhi pahunchne he nahi de rhi search on google

[@jishnudesarkar]

If MSP is provided I think minimum wage should also be implemented properly. Also rich farmers selling at MSP to the govt should be taxed.

[@Decoding_chem]

Ek bar kheti kar ke dekha mere dost There is nothing like monthly payment in bank account Sometimes all your crop get wasted with one rain then will government will give full money to farmer

[@Decoding_chem]

I am not against you farmers are only how feed you and all country don't behave like this please 🙏

[@rawjatin3191]

​@@Decoding_chemg wagon chalane wale ko pension chaiye 😂

[@Sunnybhai22465]

@@rawjatin3191 firstly wo gwagon diljit ke gaane ki shooting h,

[@artadray]

@@Decoding_chem crop insurance milta hai government se in case of natural disasters

[@Rahulmoond786]

You are the true deshbhakt .. hats off 👍

[@AHUJASS]

Thanks

[@kvafsu225]

Excellent analysis of the MSP assurance scheme. Pople talk without having a clue. Thankyou.

[@RUDSOFFICAL]

Its bullshit analysis no facts no numbers lmao, go for think school

[@tsawal]

And is india not a socialist nation? It is... ​@@Artrader_em8ko

[@DemonSlayer-vh8uy]

This is a nonsense analysis- just trying to garner views. And yes this fellow did not pay tax at all till 2021. Thats why he came up with this conclusion

[@tatakaetatakae9959]

@@Artrader_em8ko bot spotted,

[@indianking5618]

plzz watch abhi and niyu or think school dont believe this deshbhakt....he didnt do the calculation....abhi and niyu did the right research

[@tejafarm]

Much love and respect brother, You are a True Deshbhakat.. Thankyou for this video.. going to share this everywhere to raise awareness.. Keep doing the great work, and thanks once again

[@Deshbhakat0786]

धन्यवाद सर जी हम किसान भाइयों के साथ है 🌾🇮🇳🙏

[@ChessGuy7]

​@@Artrader_em8koman tum andhbhakto ka kuch nahi ho sakta. Etna bhi kya chatna tum logo ne

[@GunslingerYT]

@@Artrader_em8ko kbhi 100 rupay liter petrol aur 1200 rupay gas ka b puch lena kisi se ki kisan aur desh k logo prr kya asar pdd rha , tum logo k ghar walo ki jab pay wages badhte tabh to na economy prr asar padta.

[@ankukumar7]

@ankukumar7 0 seconds ago HELLO MR AKASH ...GOVT OF INDIA IS READY TO MAKE A LAW ON MSP OF 23 OTHER CROPS BUT NOT ON WHEAT BCZ OF THRE GROUND WATER LEVEL IN PUNJAB WHICH IS GETTING LOWER YEAR BY YEAR... AND PUNJAB FARMERS WANT TO JUST GROW WHEAT DUE TO HIGHER PROFIT MARGIN BUT THIS WILL CAUSE EFFECTS ON OTHER CROPS ..CAN U EXPLAIN THAT.... AND WHY ARE YOU NOT HIGHLITING THE DEMAND OF THE PENTION OF 10 K FOR THE FARMERS OF INDIA.. AREN'T YOU PROVIDING HALF INFORMATION JUST LIKE A ANDHBHAKT

[@Tarunkumar-xw1co]

@@GunslingerYT Hann...bhai...Pata Hai agar msp lagu hogi ta...tax...badhega

[@hafizasad3365]

Thanks for make it simple!

[@Departedstudio]

People never saw a true government in India 😅 Democracy is still a theory..

[@lakshyasharma3826]

Thik h bhai democracy nhi h India me ab khush vese bhi record ke according dictatorship country me development is much more easier Ek hi baat ke peeche lag gye jese pehli Baar hua h Indira Gandhi ke time highest number of presidential rule Laga h emergency bhi Unhi ke time Laga h Arvind Kejriwal ne bola h hame corrupt logo se hath Milana padega kyuki hame Amit Shah and Modi ki Jodi break karni h Koi dudh ka dhula nhi h na BJP na congress

[@comedyshorts2173]

​@@lakshyasharma3826toh phir india mein kyun nahi hai development india to dictatorship hai na

[@Fansvoice-g2p]

​@@comedyshorts2173officially jab Tak nhi aayegi tab tak review ya opinion dena sahi nhi h i guess

[@SovereignSocialistRepublic]

​@@Fansvoice-g2p Cancer ka symptoms dekh ke baith gye to maroge jarur 🥲

[@beautyinbarishromanceinrai9512]

​@@comedyshorts2173 live in North Korea for just one day, and then you understand what is meaning of dictatorship, dhruv lathi ka ek paid video dekh ke comment mat karna

[@Anshikakush_]

When a FARMER plant a crop , it's not just a crop it's future of his family. Future of his children.🌾🌾

[@YaseenKabir]

And a hope to the world.. that's we won't be hungry in future 🙏🏼

[@jaskaransohi2959]

BURI HAI NAZAR SARKAR DI - SIDHU MOOSEWALA AI SONG kzbin.info/www/bejne/qXuxhaWDidKBhtEsi=O5mF5UzSv2AFOYov

[@YaseenKabir]

@@Artrader_em8ko I generally don't agree with think school as he turning more towards current government.. his past video are the some of the evidence he is more acting as a puppet of the govt and showing the Glory side to the think schl community... Ganesh need to be more neutral and doesn't need to in politics he is good in business 🙃 May be some point where I totally agree with Ganesh but not just that

[@varunchhabra497]

It’s true for any occupation. When you go to office, it’s not just a job, it’s future of your family.. Future of your children. These are just generic statements. At the end of the day, it’s very important to make farming profitable which can be done only if it is run as a business. Yes, there will always be some subsidies or government support required in agriculture, but in the end it has to be made profitable.

[@sajanpandya3297]

@@Artrader_em8ko That would be expecting too much from DB audience. They hardly have any touch with ground reality and what it takes to run a government or economy or anything for that matter. Every KZbinr knows his target audience and they defend that perspective no matter what. Even if it means not looking at the facts.

[@VisitPunjab]

Wonderful explanation brother hat's off for you

[@hellman1350]

​@@Artrader_em8kobhai.. r u farmer pls tell.. r u farmer yes or no?

[@stanyog]

Honestly, exhaustively and beautifully explained. ❤ May God bless you !😊

[@shabnasulaimanss]

Thank you for explaining the concept of MSP so elaborately. You are doing good work. Keep it up 👍 India needs more people like you.

[@arunsuthar4783]

I am from farmers family and I can say u r correct

[@vinaysinghrawat2342]

My question are in depth, and is with the assumption that farming is a business 1) Why Farmers need loan for seeds, seeds and manure is given by Govt water is also provided by govt via canal with minimum price, the major expenditure is usage of tractor but that is not in lakhs, 2) Even farmers needs minimal loan the KCC offer loans Upto 3 lac at 4% 3) More over why farmers are only growing wheat and rice, today import of wheat and rice is more economical than purchasing rice from our own farmer. 3) if we still need to define MSP for farmers, then can this be limited to the BPL farmers for support and it should be scrutinised properly, I am aware people with multiple source of income does declare themselves in BPL

[@user-pv2wo3xw2w]

For 3rd question it's always better to buy something from your country rather than outside as u become dependent which may cause problems later

[@AaushKumar-ob6wc]

See KCC loans are not that effective kisi ko eaaily nahi mil paata mere parents ne bhi try maara tha aur rice wheat ugaane ke peeche 2 reasons first ki these two are the staple food our country and procurement mil jaata hai phir

[@BaljeetSingh-nm8hu]

If government can import cheaper crops, then there should be option for farmers to directly export their produce it they find better price in a neighbouring country without paper work and government interference. see now Polish farmers protesting not to import cheap agriculture produce in Europe.

[@vinaysinghrawat2342]

@@BaljeetSingh-nm8hu that’s understandable however asking MSP as a legal right is not fair(all the other questions comes for asking more privileges), My father is also a farmer so I know the perks being a farmer in this country, however it is a business too so the owner is liable for the profit and loss

[@natureloverbandikuidausa7222]

शानदार वीडियो 🔥🔥🔥 लगभग सभी प्रश्नों का समाधान कर दिया सर ने 🙏

[@aryanshgautam2096]

Thoroughly Reasearched, Data Wise Explanation And A Great Indepth Video To Understand The Conditions Of Farmers And Solutions To It. Very Greatful And So Much Gratitude To You For Providing The Right Information Without Labelling Farmers. Proud To Be A #Deshbhakt

[@KishoreM-xp2cs]

No sir, with due respect. He do not know the ground reality of the rest of the India. Just went ahead which few theories !! Farmers means -- Not just Punjab, Haryana, and west UP.. There are other farmers also in india !!! This is literally taking hostage of the rest of the farmers in the country !!!

[@lovezall531]

In Agriculture: Electricity, Seeds, Pesticides, Irrigation all are provided by state governments. All crops have different input cost in different state? How would one ensure 50% profit on them? Moreover why 50% profit on Agriculture only? Why not to all Shopkeepers, to all manufacturers? Problem is consumer pays full amount for all grains and vegetables. But the farmer gets only 10% of it. WHY?

[@SDFNI3894YR]

No aryan, he just made guessess and assumptions. agar msp laga diya, then india will go into deep economic crisis.

[@estherraj8489]

Very good information about C2+50% to the farmers. Sir thank you. Thankful to our farmers who grow my food with their hardworking ,I salute them .... feel pained the way they are treated.

[@Tussu17]

@@Artrader_em8ko They literally don't know what's going to happen if the government imposes the MSP. Crazy!

[@chintamanisatavalekar5482]

Great! Think about this C2 + 50% consists of all costs (seeds+ fertilizers + pesticide + land rent + electricity + water) The farmers want a complete loan maafi on electricity and water and still want to include them as the cost? Does this seem fair? You dont incur a cost because of subsidies and loan cancellations but you still consider them as costs. The C2 + 50% formula is full proof. No one can deny that

[@arunchhajed]

Beautifully Explained...

[@hamster68653]

​@@Artrader_em8ko Stop spamming this comment over and over again.

[@witchilich]

​@er202 he just heard a few magic words in godi media and will only watch channels that repeat those. numbers like "10 lakh crore" are deceitfully spreaded to make the common people think farmers demands are impossible. many of these measures were already implemented by china decades ago, its India that needs to modernize.

[@DevanshSharma4999]

@@Artrader_em8ko I had watched both side and understood if the leader was a little bit educated he would have applied this after proper study on loss and profit and how much msp should be applied if he can give 80 cr. people free rashan then why he cannot help farmers he wants that we should live on 1 time rashan and his friends adani Ambani would take whole money with them RADHE RADHE 💕🙌

[@Imcrazyfornaruto]

@@Artrader_em8kohave you watched that video ,, please tell the basic points of what you have understood about MSP , direct subsidy or indirect subsidy

[@teamviratien]

भाई देशभक्त तेरे अब तक का बेस्ट है।।

[@rahulshaw2627]

I am fascinating to know Why this problem is persistent with Punjab Haryana Farmers only....😕😕

[@yourkoala]

Kyonki wha 1 kisan ke pass jyada jameen hoti h baki state se compare kro to 10 guna jyada

[@rahulshaw2627]

Maine v apni padhai k liye loan le rakha hai....mere uper v bhot responsibilities hain to kya govt mera v loan maf kar sakti hai....ya loan leke padhne k bad hm govt ko bole hmko v subsidy do student loan pe....koi businessman loan leke business kholta hai to kya wo v bole Bhai business nhi chala to loan maf do....& So on.

[@Lucius-ix8dt]

@@rahulshaw2627 j adania da 12,270 coror maaf ho skta hai bakio ka tou pta hi nhi kitne lakh coror maaf hue.bt kisan de 5 lakh nal desh doobta hai

[@RiteshKumar-di7dr]

@@Lucius-ix8dt please share the source where Adani's loan was waved off? When Adani's loan was waved off by bank means Adani wrote off loan from its liability from financial statement?

[@RiteshKumar-di7dr]

@@rahulshaw2627 bro don't repay loan, bank will write off your loan declaring it as NPA lol

[@Inaf1987]

My problem is that they're asking for MSP for cereal and Sugarcane , while we desperately need more pulses and oilseeds.

[@Kevin-tl1zs]

We need everything

[@Thunder44420]

They want MSP on 23+ crops, monthly pension and exit from WTO.

[@_Anurag_Thakur_]

@@Thunder44420 abe yar sarkari Naukri thori hai

[@jaswindersinghnarula4379]

So if farmers get MSP on oil seeds and pluses wont, they grow that? Which is easier to grow instead of rice in Punjab. Rice is not best crop to grow in Punjab but farmers there grow that only because they get good price on that.

[@A123456789Z70]

@er_em8ko Lol if they can afford to write off corporate loans, they can definitely afford MSP... where's your outrage when your lord modi handing out favors to his boyfriends Adani and Ambani!

[@lalitagrawal684]

But by this logic, inflation is good, prices will increase, producer or ultimately someone will make money and it'll grow the economy. And btw the price offered by current MSP is somewhere around what we get the grains at home! It'll create massive inflation of about ~20-25% because after selling at msp, there's transportation, packing and commission of trader involved. I think you'll agree that government will not come in mandis and sell the grains for farmers, that thing has to done by the traders which will ultimately not be possible if MSP is legal right!

[@rinkibanerji7092]

MSP can help Farmers - 1. Feeling safe financially and feeling unexploited will raise motivation levels to do better be creative welcome better techs 2. More ppl who left farming may come back to work on their lands 3. Overall there will be a sense of self worth in farmers instead of being treated like slaves 4. May improve the stocking and distribution system when the servant and loser mentality is replaced with self worth to control and oversee the same 5. Can improve the country's Overall agriculture and yields going ahead

[@harishsharma172]

Bro I wish our leaders could be this educated & understanding 👏🏻

[@ONKARKAHALI]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/kJyblqKoq7JoqJYsi=JEc_Zkg29_koNydX

[@jeevankumar1082]

Please watch analysis from Think School.....This guy mentioned the short term advantages only

[@abhijithch3880]

Exactly watch think school analysis. Economics won't work out

[@firstnamemohanm]

This commnet of yours deserves more likes.@@jeevankumar1082 ..

[@surajp914]

Perfect ❤.

[@surajp914]

@@Artrader_em8ko That means there is no inflation in cylinder, petrol, pesticides, but the grain grown by farmers will increase in inflation? And according to you, Akash is happy with 1000 rupees cylinder, and 100 rupees petrol, but if farmers get their hard earned money, Akash will cry.😄

[@hellman1350]

​@MovieEe-rw2tsHr chiz ki msp hoti h bhai..🥲🥲 market me kis chiz ki msp nhi h.. or rhi baat petrol diesel.. modi k bhkto .🥲.. petrol purchase to 30 35 rupe me ho rha h.. jb 60 rupe tha yhu bjp thi?.. m I right yhi bjp thi.. jo chilati thi? Bahut mhnga h petrol? Ab fir cylinder free bant rhe h chicha modi..🥲fir mhnga hoga mrega kon.. tum or ma .. bhai farmer's demand smjh dhik h.. na to govt kma rhi h na kisan kma kon rha h business man..

[@izharfarooqui7183]

Excellent Efforts Sir,Very Thankfull u have Elaborate every aspect of agriculture sepcially 1.farmer collapse with the Heavy debt & 2.Need of money for rotation of crop .

[@shaelethal4591]

Your breav presentation is very good please always do the reality keep it up ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@pcnerve]

From NYC USA : Very well researched supported with correct data analysis - you're the best, and the best presented Banerji. Salute to you.. I totally agree what you said and support MSP for Farmers.

[@ArshdeepSingh-cg8zw]

Beautifully explained this topic.

[@ThinkifyIndian]

We Support Poor Farmers, Real Farmers ❤ We don't support POLITICAL ACTIVISTS disguised as Farmers

[@otakuROHIT]

I agree Punjabi kisan are one of the wealthy people in India but what about mp up bihar Rajasthan Maharashtra, they needed those 3 farm laws but sadly Punjabi kisan didn't support them

[@rawjatin3191]

​@@otakuROHITthose who are doing protests are not farmers come to Delhi we suffer a lot from them they are driving g wagon playing sidhu Moose wala song with the slogan khalistan zindabad.

[@bloodwargaming3662]

​@@rawjatin3191source - Modi's @$$

[@prerna4u]

@@rawjatin3191 bhiya vo sab jane do lekin pure bharat ke kisano ko ye mange jaruri hai ki nahi vo bata do

[@otakuROHIT]

@@rawjatin3191 I'm from Delhi and I don't support Punjabi kisan, but I'm concerned for UP BIHAR kisan

[@TeenaMalhotra]

Wonderfully explained 👍🏻👍🏻

[@tsawal]

This is a goldmine for upsc aspirants if a question on this comes in mains...good work..i revised the whole farming topic in 22 mins

[@Noob-uk4np]

You fail in Interview with this knowledge

[@amannsharma]

Watch next ias video on msp

[@puneethere1]

UPSC ka main interview clear kar bhi liya toh kya.? Iss se kisi achi country me jao waha lakho kamao har mahine aur life standard b acha

[@Noob-uk4np]

@@puneethere1 Times have changed now you can earn more money in India than U.S. ( If you look at the overall expense )

[@puneethere1]

@@Noob-uk4np UK Australia New Zealand jaisi countries me har koi bht acha kama sakta hai par india me nhi. Waha 22-23 har koi well settled ho jata hai. Aur jyada kharche bhi nhi hai.

[@adityagupta3251]

Much awaited video sir ❤

[@navjotsinghsk88.]

Excellent Anaylsis and good explanation of MSP, Farmer Problems.👍

[@krishkris007]

What a brilliant video! We should make government liable. The way the myths around the said topics were debunked was so simple yet powerful👏👏 1. Cost of MSP to society 2. Effect of MSP policy on mandi system 3. Need of Govt intervention to regulate mandi system

[@zarnigash-kazmi.]

Respect button for king journalism ❤

[@Success_area_dose]

You are true the deshbhakt 👍👍🇮🇳

[@varundave6860]

😂

[@centristlibertarian]

😂😂

[@varundave6860]

@@Artrader_em8ko leftist itna dimag nahi chalate 😂

[@unchainedYT]

Can anyone please tell me if MSP is made legal right, then won't private players import food grains to get those at cheaper prices? Will it decrease our Forex & other cost burden to government?

[@vikashgauravvkg]

Yes it will but our desbhakt will not mention this😂

[@unchainedYT]

@@vikashgauravvkg 😩😩😩😩

[@harmeetsandhu8366]

This really makes sense. You showed them their mirror. Huge respect sir

[@FPS-bg9hc]

Huge Respect ❤ Akash sir ❤

[@shonitmajumder4090]

From what I remember that the frist farm bills where brought to cut out the middle man , the farmers didn't quite like it 😅

[@ADDSGRDJ]

Farm bills were not to cut middle man but gave unparalleled powers to big private players like Adani to purchase and store farmers produce without any guarantee of MSP. Those laws would have forced small farmers into even deeper poverty. Read the full 3 law details first.

[@VanyaMishra20]

You remember wrong because your knowledge is half-baked. Do you think the lacs of farmers are stupid that they'll protest without understanding this?

[@souravgupta7251]

Yes brother but some chamchas and knowledge less people spreading that farm law is not good 😂😂 without knowing ffull details

[@souravgupta7251]

​@@ADDSGRDJbrother u read in detail farm bill is for farmer benefits not for private entities brother by this bill farmer can sale their crop to private enterprise in their own price brother plz dont be a chamcha of khangress be an Indian ok 😂😂😂

[@souravgupta7251]

​@@VanyaMishra20 sister they are paid for that 🤣🤣 if u will be paid u will also be in protest 😂😂😂😂

[@ManjuBhasin-w2f]

Great Explanation . Keep going Sir

[@नारायण_97]

Amazing explanation as always,keep enlighte to everyone

[@kamaldeepsingh3988]

Only 6-8% kissan have got MSP in India...

[@SHAHID-tx9pt]

In reality 10-14 % according to gov. Survey

[@prajwal5501]

Then what about rest 85% farmers?

[@itzinsaane]

2011 ke baad census nhi hua😢(aisa kabhi bhi nhi hua hain)

[@Zlurpa]

​@@SHAHID-tx9ptgovernment will always say more 😂

[@prashanthkashyap]

94% who got Msp is from Punjab and haryana Source- vikas divyakirti​@@kumarkishan1498

[@GautamAggarwal-p1l]

What an amazing explanation. I have watched many videos of lots of creators on youtube regarding this topic but no one has explained in such an effective way you explained the whole Pros. and Cons. of this topic. Hats off to you sir keep it up well done.

[@kvafsu225]

I could not agree with you more.

[@chintamanisatavalekar5482]

Try watching the Carvaka podcast episode on this as well... analyse all points mentioned in both videos and then make a decision

[@kvafsu225]

It is about facts and not comparing various presentations. Bhakt Banerjea is convincing,

[@chintamanisatavalekar5482]

Exactly my point@@kvafsu225 You think Akash has covered every point? Everyone who puts forth a different opinion is wrong? If so then by all means stay in your little echo chamber. I am not saying what the non left is saying is the truth, watch what both the sides are saying and then make a decision for yourself.

[@jeevankumar1082]

Please watch analysis from Think School.....This guy mentioned the short term advantages only

[@tylerb8032]

What is really baffling tomme is that the Richest lot amongst farmers i.e farmers from Punjab n Haryana are demanding these MSP law not the ones from the other parts of the country. Wish the farmers" redorms were implemented in 2021

[@vatsalpancholi3122]

If you study carefully, what you call richest farmers have monthly income of around 26 thousand.

[@kangkansarmajyoti]

Explanation level is awesome.... 💯💯

[@agustus26]

You're promoting think school for how much? Is it paid per comment?​@@Artrader_em8ko

[@wanikhawar]

@@Artrader_em8ko bro think school is another channel funded by BJP IT cell. They pushed these so called "unbiased" channels to mislead centrist people. That couple Abhi and NIyu is another example.

[@iaazp]

Regardless of the math a lot can be achieved by having a transparent dialog with people who want a stable livelihood instead of creating barriers and making one sided proclamations against them

[@gurjar_up16_aala]

@@Artrader_em8ko bro if govt. Is buying some crop on msp then it can sell it further and even import... We all know the price of packaged wheat flour and all... And it's more than 10x of the price that's paid to farmers... So govt. Buy from farmers and then sell it to people with few margin it would be beneficial to farmers , normal people and govt. As well but it won't be beneficial for the big corporates who are selling food items at very high prices amd the prices are kept on increasing every year...

[@AnviAish]

You have explained well about the demand of the farmers ❤ GREAT.. 👍💐💐

[@sciencespectrum3855]

Very good logical explanation and deep explanation 👏👏

[@rakeshchhillar8311]

u r true sir

[@sammyj29]

Beautifully done Akash! Love your work. ❤

[@Rajatguptasecurity]

Very well explained. Thank you Akash. Worth watching for everyone

[@kapil7575]

Thnkas for explaining the real issue in simplest way. 🙏🙏🙏

[@hellman1350]

​@@Artrader_em8koAbey kha c copy Kia h hr jgah yhi line utha rha h😂😂

[@manjindersinghbholarandhey2398]

Wah, god bless you and ten family

[@subhojitacharyya7838]

Very informative. Thank you channel Deshbhakt for bringing up this kind serious issues of the ongoing society. Keep going. ❤

[@IamLookingforWoody_________786]

Awesome explanation about farmer protest.

[@yaduyadav---]

बहुत अच्छा समझाया आपने अभी तक मुझे सिर्फ़ ग़लत तथ्य देने वाले लोग मिले जो सिर्फ मन की बात कर रहे थेl लेकिन यह देखने के बाद मेरा नजरिया बदल गया है l Msp कि देश को जरूरत है ना कि सिर्फ किसानों को l 🫡🙏🙏

[@tanyaojha8141]

Jab mahgai badhega n to inse hi aake magna ok

[@tanyaojha8141]

Phir modi ko mat hi koshna

[@yaduyadav---]

@@tanyaojha8141 pehli bat akela Modi koi sarkar nhin h , or decision hamare hat me nhin h sarkar ke hat m h. Ham sirf opinion rakhte hn agar galat decision ya galat tarike se implement kregi to jaroor kosa jayega jisse wo galti dobara na ho. Kisne kaha ki nyay mangna or galti batana jurm h.

[@lalitpatel367]

Shi ke liye mehangaai bathegi na ki sirf apke liye Abhi sab ko Kam praic me sije chahiye but apko pta kisan ko kitna loss hota h ​@@tanyaojha8141

[@lalitpatel367]

​@@tanyaojha8141are bhai ap modi ho kya

[@Msfinancials93]

After watching this detail video I agree with MSP concept condition if MRP is also implemented. For example if I am purchasing mango from market where there is no MSP and exported to Europe, US, Canada market after all calculations on average 1 kg of mango we get around 100 to 120 rupees because max profit to farmers are coming from export So for consumer I should have MRP in these products If gov want to increase income of farmers then they should think about below middle class, middle class consumer who has to purchase these stuff.

[@Deffinite]

mainne is topic ke pe aur bhi KZbinr ki video dekhi hain lekin kisi ne bhi itane Aasan tarike se nahin samajhaaya hai is topic ko, Hats off Abhishek sir keep it up well done.

[@lakshyasharma3826]

I think ki your video day by day aur unbiased hui h you learn from your mistake ❤❤

[@AnkitGupta-nt2ih]

Dhruv rathee biased hai pr aap nahi❤️

[@DeveshChaudhary05]

thoda dimag bhi laga bhai sirf ek ne jo bol diya vo mat sun, agar ye msp aa gayi to kisan demand supply ko bhi nhi dekhega aur apne profit ke liye sab log jyada se jyada vo fasal karenge jisme jyada profit ho kyoki unko to fixed price par fasal bekne ko milega aur isse supply bhadega but demand nhi.

[@lakshyasharma3826]

​​​@@DeveshChaudhary05nhi bhai jese rice ki baat kare to vo pure Desh me Kuch jagah hi h jaha rice grow ho sakta h wheat millets kuch jagah h jaha grow ho sakta h region par cheeze bohot depend karta h aur major 23 crops par msp ki baat ho rhi h jo major crops h agar max Kisan ye hi 23 crops bhi grow kare to Apne aap jinn par msp nhi h vo crop ki demand badhege kyuki unhe koi grow nhi kar rha fir jinn kisano ne Bina msp ki crop grow Kari unhe high demand ka faida milega Kisano ka 1 maang bilkul sahi nhi h jo bhi 60 age se upar h usko 10 thousand per month Middle man is real problem

[@prerna4u]

​@@DeveshChaudhary05bhai tum sabji daal oil kharidata hai to boli lagata hai ya kimat puchhta hai?

[@Vichitragupta823-xm9iq]

Trying to show as neutral. Intentionally hide some fact like farmers demanding to leave WTO and using misinformation.

[@Dhirendra_346]

Well done sir I'm with you❤❤❤❤❤

[@76denzil]

Sir, I don't think there is anyone as intelligent as you and your team in the Govt who could study the pro's and Cons of the MSP issue and implement it. You have done a wonderful job. Kudos to you and your team...

[@divyranjan254]

1. Land rent would vary statewise. Wouldn't that create a lot of issue in C2 calculation? 2. What if private players turn to foreign import instead of buying from farmers if they get it at lower price? Please answer these queries.

[@matkarharsh881]

If middle man get removed they will protest for unemployed 😂😂

[@krishnajimahadimane2766]

Excellent Video Akash Desh Bhakt

[@shaktisharma7615]

Punjab mai Electricity, Pesticide, Seeds, Water sab free ha,, uske baad loan maaf hote ha... fir bhi MSP kyu???? Ese to sab business man MSP mange ge

[@sikandersingh-oz6co]

Bhai pehle punjab ayo fir dekhna ki electricity, pesticides, seeds free milte hai ya nahi kuch free nhi milta bhai agar kahi se milta hai toh aap mujhe lakar de dena bhai social media per kuch or dikhaya jata hai or ground reality kuch aur hai voh aap akar dekh lena kbhi bhi bhai

[@sikandersingh-oz6co]

Aur bhai aap keh rahe ho ki business man msp mange gye fir bhai vijay maliya jaiso ke hazorn crore rupye ka loan maaf kr diya jata hai per kissano ka 25k loan ho toh uski jaan nikal lete hai yeh partiality kyu bhai hmare loan kyu maaf nhi kiye jate yeh bta do bhai aap agar aur kuch samaj nhi aya toh aap Shahrukh khan jo recently movie ayi thi jawan woh dekh lena bhai ek bar dhyaan se usme jo dikhaya gya hai voh sab sach hai bhai

[@techsa2675]

​@@sikandersingh-oz6coapp hi ne to aap ko vote dia hy congress ko nhi

[@HARSH-q8v]

Who said you that seeds and pesticde are free

[@manojsinghgauniya5201]

One correction sir, 10lac crore is the cost of farm loan waiver which is one of the demand, not of MSP

[@rahulsen4010]

MSP lagu ho Jana chahiye Mujhe Lagta hay. Kyunki jada Nahi bas 80% of our entire GDP to hi jayega😊😊😊. Kya fark parta hay. Hamlok bina Infrastructure , Army se rah lenge 😊😊😊

[@muskanSheik77]

Vo hi iski soach Jatt par h Puri 😂 .ayiga to sher hi 😊💕 modi. Allah hu akbar bhaijan

[@vaishnavi-o6c]

Being an UPSC aspirant , i got a lot content for my answer writting , the way to u exlpain MSP ( postives nd negtives ) really appericiative nd salute to u research support team

[@ashishrajpoot6983]

#Question everything

[@SHU-be2lr]

Question your existence too.. 🗿👍🏻

[@rounakmishra7652]

sir, middle man concept was tried to eradicate in farm laws which was removed by the farmer in 1.0 protest which would create a strong mandi system FCI is not able sell its grains most of them are rotting away neither they are a profit making organization so if we spend money on more crops more rotting away causing more loss why to bear it instead if MSP the storage system and exporting system of FCI should be expanded for net profit

[@vishalmoudgil]

Basic questions 1. If MSP is the Amrut for farmers, why are farmers from across the country not on the streets? 2. Farmers already get subsidies on their input cost (C2), should MSP be given on this reduced input cost? Plz enlighten if possible 😊

[@agentsidhu]

The Govt. won’t give us MSP as per my knowledge and research so hear me out. 1)So we know the trend of bjp govt. is pro corporations and they want indian agriculture system to be in WTO(formerly GATT). 2)If you wanna know detail about WTO read it yourself. 3)So this has been a long term plan and slow crack down to make Indian lands Private like other countries in WTO and give power to pvt. Sector. 4)We were forced into signing this treaty, What has been protecting us since now is peace clause. so govt. have been breaking down this slowly with things like portal system and giving extra loans giving loan over already existing loan which they know farmers can’t pay back eventually one way or another leading to land getting acquired, Buying yield at low prices so that farmers take more loan. 5)Once implemented WTO policy says that if any of their rules and regulations counters Indian constitution, in that case that law in constitution will be changed not policy. 6)Idon’t have much hopes from BJP govt. nor from other OP’s cause its about facing the big brothers🗿 at international level they don’t have enough balls, yes there might be sanctions on us for exiting WTO but haven’t they tried once during 1st nuclear test and what did that do nothing and we successfully became nuclear power. 7)Those who can see the bigger picture and is not self cantered will understand and its not just us indian farmers there are many farmers from other countries protesting it. 8)This is long so i’ll keep it short, another point being that in other countries their is 1% farmer and 99% consumer whereas in India around 60% farmers and farmers themselves are also consumer. 9)there is also 9th schedule

[@mishrashailendra84]

Kuch samajh nahin aaya Yeh logic

[@agentsidhu]

@@mishrashailendra84 if you are interested i would suggest read up WTO and its policy regarding agriculture sector and read Swaminathan report, read 9th schedule of constitution and then read it again it will help.

[@satyamsatpute6084]

Their demand is not just msp 1)get out of WTO 2)Make a Khalistan😅😅😂😅😂

[@timewalker6654]

I haven't seen anything so well put in ages 😮👏👏

[@deepanshupatel260]

Hope I can like it more than once Very well put this matter Akash!!

[@Sntwlkr6128]

Very nice and amazing counterarguments. Such kind of contents with clarity are need of the moment.

[@DharmEnThakur]

जय जवान जय किसान ❤

[@Lava_RJ]

I applaud the effort put into this episode. It's very well constructed.... Keep up the good work, we are watching you 💪💯

[@sushobhansarker9668]

Liked the episode. However, I think you have not discussed one major allegation that the agitating Farmers constitute a small number of rich farmers from Punjab, Haryana and parts of Western UP and do not represent a large number of small farmers across the country and consequently the demand for MSP is only to benefit such rich farmers(of course in your example you have cited "a small farmer").

[@bhaveshkhalane3297]

Detailed information in easy manner Abhishek Banerjee sir is Truly Deshbhakt ❤❤❤❤❤

[@utathyaghosh475]

His name is Akash Banerjee

[@nisithdas4584]

Dear Banerjee I understood every thing, you give me answer if 1 question , why the farmers of Punjab and Hariyana is agigatating and not the rest of India.

[@GurdeepSingh-rl7so]

Only Punjab and haryana farmers get msp in India under govt. Scheme. They just want only law of msp. Rest of indian farmers do not get any msp. That is the reason income of Punjab is 10 times that other country farmers.

[@ravipativenkatesh6810]

really impressed with your work Akash. Government claims that there is a surplus of food grains and yet imposes bans on the export of rice and wheat, what could be the reasons behind this?

[@sravan55k]

This video of yours is an excellent example of Objective study in journalism

[@sunilthimmaiah615]

#FARMERPROTEST as a farmer myself. The farmers demands are unreasonable. Here are my thoughts 1. MSP should be restricted to farmers owning a land upto 10 acres. Therefore it does two things. A. Big land farmers doesn't get the benefits of cultivating of MSP crops (above 10acres). B. Farmers will diversify the crop cultivation which will increase their income . 2. Goverment should identify land best for a crop other than MSP crops and give them guidance and support to grow them . Because many farmers are used to grow rice and wheat from generations. They have no idea to switch to other crop .