Wood Cook Stove Comparison: Elmira Fireview Vs. J.A. Roby Chief

[@paulmaxwell8851]

Just a quick recommendation from a Canadian customer. My wife and I bought a La Nordica Suprema wood cookstove from Obadiah's about four or five years ago. We're very happy with the stove, and Woody at Obadiah's was very good, answering all my wife's questions and making sure our new purchase made it safely to us out here in the boonies of British Columbia. A great company to deal with!

[@tburrows357]

I’m in northern BC and planning on building a new home. We want a second wood cook stove to supplement the heating and cooking needs. Any other suggestions or experience in ordering that you could provide me?

[@donblunkall5607]

Such beauty and lines, love the fact that the elmira can be hooked into water supply and using the gas burners during summer months is awesome. Well done, bravo.

[@elvinadhludhlu5380]

Im glad that these stoves, still exist. Tech being what it is. Black-out's are not fun.

[@stevenfoust3782]

Imagine this was what America had to cook and stay warm with. Amazing

[@jfm562]

This is fancy and "high tech" compared to what many people had/have to work with.

[@stevenfoust3782]

@@jfm562 true the modern version sure looks nice

[@soillife1]

All the millions Amish still do.

[@adamfrbs9259]

Dang...known of these for years...but never realized that's why my house chimney is where it is. It's closed off now for years...but it's literally in the kitchen. It's a very old house. Ha. I should bust the sheet rock out and use the chimney and this stove again. Ha

[@RobertSmith-kf2eg]

My grandma used to cook all the time with wood stove and the food was delicious 😋

[@soillife1]

Everybody used to 😉 Far enough back. Im 70 now My grandparents, both sides. Had no running water in their homes until I was 12 and 14 on ranches in south East Kansas. Wood stove cooking and heat was all they had.

[@Kevin-i6t5i]

​@@soillife1I'm 59 and we didn't get running water inside til I was in 4th grade, wood heat and Cookstove by my 2nd grade year, Yeah I don't miss the outhouse at all! 😂😂

[@christinamoneyhan5688]

I had a cook stove that you could turn the grates over so one side would burn wood the other way it could burn coal. It was all cast iron and the color was a blue/ gray enamel and chrome trim with the cast iron top with various size lids that you could open and put your pot or skillet over if you wanted or just keep it closed up .It also had warming oven . Very nice even if it was 70 years old and that was 30 years ago so that cast iron stove is 100 years old now. I do not remember the name of it because I too am 70 years old . I heated and cooked on it during winter months in Pa.

[@kirksway1]

I'm so glad I saw this. I didn't realize anyone still made wood ranges anymore.

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Yes, we actually sell many different models. Its always good to have a backup heating/cooking source. All of the models can be viewed on our website here: www.discountstoves.net/wood-cook-stoves-s/37.htm

[@andreaandrea1405]

​@@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroywhat is the price for a wood cook stove?

[@patrikloring7956]

The almira is the best wood cook stove I have ever seen. Never could seem to afford one. Every time I saved the money they cost more money !

[@unclelar819]

I have always liked the looks of the Elmira stoves and the added feature of the gas burners for quick cooking. Thanks for another informative video, Sarah!!!

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Thanks for your comments! The gas burner is definitely a handy feature!

[@davidyetter5409]

I grew up in a house heated by a cook stove. Also all the cooking was done on the stove.

[@fasx56]

Beautiful Stoves, that add to the appearance of a Kitchen or living room with a rustic and warm look. Very nice to have one of these stoves if the Electricity goes out for warmth and cooking if needed.

[@manleynelson9419]

That chick is amazing. She did that on her own uncut no script and was an excellent communicator and presenter

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Thank you. :)

[@wooden5c]

You still rock, Sarah.

[@johnbouwens2024]

Wowzer im home sick for mama's cooking now... All us kids had ta chop wood to feed ma's kitchen stove granny's too.. It was just a part of growing up.. Sure do miss home Wyoming...

[@peterweikel7123]

absolutely love the pedestal model. that is a sharp looking stove

[@jodanabright4105]

I absolutely loved my Elmira cook stove.

[@victoryfirst2878]

I am just amazed that these stoves can still be bought new.

[@rebeccahuber7824]

These are the coolest stoves I have ever seen!!

[@jtwilliams3615]

Best informative video yet!! Thank you Sarah!

[@xendarcodm]

Thanks for these videos. I plan on getting a wood cook stove in the future.

[@jackiecase6440]

What are the prices on these two stoves? Your video was very helpful.

[@TicklerDude]

One of the stoves is more expensive than the other. Does that answer your question?

[@gedhuffadine1873]

They never say!

[@patrickgrant3767]

Good morning From Nova Scotia.. Great Info on Cookers.. Thanks

[@GaryB33]

Very nice stoves. You did a great job. Thanks for the video

[@animallover4955]

I bought a wood burning & electric cast iron stove in australia in 1990. Great stove

[@duraizwani7707]

I appreciate your hard work

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Thank you!

[@jeanineott9580]

How much is the elmira wood stove.? And i want a water heater to heat up water for showers and dishes. Can you send me more info

[@mamabear9389]

Thanks Sara. Great video.

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Thanks, I appreciate your comments. :)

[@agentfrankvideos]

Sarah, you are not only smart, you are gorgeous !!

[@leroywilliams618]

Could you give me more information I would like to purchase one from where her I can get a hold of one I appreciate that other than that that’s good very good

[@brianbranson2306]

so what i really want to know is how the hot water tank is/was plumbed on the old stoves ?

[@SteenyLou]

In which other video do you go into more detail about the gasket on the Elmira for increasing the burn time? I did, after watching this video, and after speaking to you on the phone, go out and get some 1/4-in flat gasket and installed it, but it has not made any difference in how long my fire will burn overnight. Not sure if I'm doing something wrong. Any ideas?

[@dannyallen4357]

Very thorough review. Thank you.

[@flyingwrenchesautomotive]

So I came here for a review and after 1 has a tighter box but the other can take a longer log…. I’m done here 😂

[@bobthecreator106]

Can you use it just for heating the house?

[@TheMountainman211]

I'd buy whatever she told me to lol ☺

[@thandekankomo9394]

Hi, I really like your presentation on those stoves is it possible to get it from South Africa.

[@todddebockler7786]

I like the legss on the stove to the right

[@offgridmangogrower]

Can you tell me the stove with largest oven ….. and largest fire box…? I would be using it more for baking…..

[@jamesglenn520]

OMG 😲!! After comparing all the trim options. Size and shape and being able to see those beautiful legs. My number one pick is Sarah and the runner up is the Elmira!

[@LateNightSummerRain]

thank you for sharing this

[@todddebockler7786]

Awesome wood stoves excellent presentation love your outfit smiile your beautiful thank you very informative

[@greenenergybruce5798]

Very well presented. Informative!

[@randelldarky3920]

I was not paying much attention to the stove. Could You please repeat that?

[@Wildflower_Breads]

I tried to comment a few minutes ago but now I can't find it to edit it. Maybe it's buried in there amongst the 157 messages that are on here so far. I will try to recap. I spoke to you a few days ago, from British Columbia, regarding the Elmira Fireview that I have. Mine is almost the same as the one in the video except I don't have the gas burner option. I already have a gas stove separately. Anyway we were talking about the possibility of me ordering some fire brick from you to replace the badly cracked one at the back of my stoves firebox. I can only order the whole kit through Elmira in Ontario and the cost is unbelievably high. I don't need the whole kit, I just need brick for the back. Also, I do wonder if it is possible to use regular brick and not worry about that little dip down part at the bottom, or would it be a problem over time having that little space not be covered by fire brick? You mentioned in the video about adding gasket to the cooktop in order to increase the burn time to as much as 12 hours? That is absolutely fascinating to me. I've only been able to get about 5 or 6 hours on a fully stoked firebox. I went to the local Home Hardware yesterday and found that they had 5/8 inch gasket with adhesive in a kit. It looks thick, so I didn't buy it. You had mentioned on the phone that it was a quarter inch gasket. Either way, that seems really thick. Am I supposed to put it all the way around all of the cooktop plates, or just the one over the firebox? You had mentioned you would email me but I'm wondering if perhaps you got the address wrong. Let me know if you attempted. I don't see anything at all in my inbox or spam.

[@judygarrett3095]

What is the price?

[@judygarrett3095]

Do you have an Elmira with electric instead of gas?

[@juniergonzalez9814]

Quiero una de éstas, cómo la compro? Y dónde? La quiero aquí en Panamá Ciudad. 🇵🇦🇵🇦🇵🇦 Sería un sueño 🙏🏻

[@eshaghesaee6795]

Can please say, how much is it both of them left side ???

[@lindseyrojasrd]

Lastima en Costa Rica no tenemos de esas cocinas tan hermosas.

[@donaldturner5124]

Just so you’ll know the Elmira stoves run approximately 6-7 k.

[@deanwinchester6666]

I have a question. I am lookimg at one of your smaller stove/ovens and it is covered in chrome. This stove/oven is perfect, but I like my stoves to look like a traditional cast iron stove and was wondering if i could order one without the chrome on it. Or if i could just take it off myself.

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Both the Elmira and JA Roby models have the ability to be ordered with black legs. :)

[@deanwinchester6666]

@@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy i was taking about the concept air two mini. The whole front is lined wirh chrome or stainless steel. CanI have the option to have it traditional? I'm old school and hate the flashy junk.

[@ruzicacale4747]

Super su 👍🏼 a koliko koštaju takve peći !?

[@denniscostabile4264]

Love the idea of a wood cook stove, but I live in Pittsburgh. Where exactly do you find free wood?

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Being that you are in a city, you will likely have to purchase the wood. You will need to check locally to see what prices are for wood if its cost effective or not.

[@jefflamb6599]

So where are you located? Can these be purchased in slc utah?

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Yes! We are locate in Kalispell, MT. However, most of our products on our website include free shipping. This JA Roby can be viewed on our website here: www.discountstoves.net/J-A-Roby-Chief-EPA-Wood-Burning-Cookstove-p/cbch.htm Prices includes free delivery in lower 48 and no sales tax.

[@josephshaff5194]

3D Models in Sketchup so I can plan my kitchen Design ?

[@rogenaqshairy3097]

How much dose cost?!

[@randywells4674]

What is the name of the stoves you carry

[@bbcake001]

Is it possible for these wood burner stove to become a broiler to heat up the whole entire house?

[@bbcake001]

of course, It needed to be fabricated!

[@TicklerDude]

@@bbcake001 Why did you ask and answer your own question?

[@TheWestlandgirl]

8,800 for Elmira wood/gas 48 inch model with all the options. Worth it!

[@uncledoc9010]

hi there.. if you like to see the best stove of this kind, you need to have a look to switzerland‘s Tiba stove. most efficient stove, robust as a rock. they‘re made to last... and they are beautiful...

[@amcken]

I think they have to be hydro though.

[@Binu29]

How can I get this in India 🇮🇳...I love this product

[@knucklehead4233]

The Elmira sounds like the better of the two.

[@alan_marx]

What a wonderful stove. I would like to get one. But life is not fair and I can only dream.

[@alan_marx]

@Abraham Morrison She has an amazing pair of stoves. I watch every video just to see them.

[@MACEDONIAbitola]

@@alan_marx KEEP DREAMING 😁

[@jamesturner7728]

Do you ship to the UK

[@JaniceMenard]

Elmira is the best to me

[@mickeymouse1697]

whats the price and do you ship to europe ?

[@UK_Stuboy]

Is this video in slow motion

[@officespace3494]

Thanks Sarah very Beautiful Video.. شكرا سارة فيديو رائع..

[@sirilucksarampakul7355]

How much?

[@wendellbell6164]

Thank you for this video. I learned alot .

[@olchat2012]

Now you can learn a lot 😊

[@enriquemacias7770]

Cuestion how much fee that stoves

[@lindahinshaw4941]

What does the pedestal hold one the first one?

[@darleneclark6098]

Looks like an ash collector. I have similar on my pellet stove

[@andrewnichols1240]

Can I bake 6 loaves of bread

[@Useitorloseit1]

Do any of the stoves allow exhaust from the fire to enter the oven to flaveor the food?

[@paulmaxwell8851]

No, no wood cookstove does, that I'm aware of.

[@palmspringsperrry]

Elmira for me

[@markgalyen38]

Does anyone make a full combo stove (wood/electric or gas) ? Like monarch used to

[@ObadiahsWoodstovesTroy]

Not at this time. There are stoves that are built as a suite that could be set side by side, such as the Rizzoli line. I'm looking into a cookstove with electric cook top, but the oven will always be solid fuel.

[@estelamoralesoropesa4482]

Cómo no me plática en Español x que me agradó la estufa

[@Summerwind3010]

👍👍👍 Great cooking Maschine 👍👍👍

[@frogmarched6869]

lovely

[@jaredsavik2825]

Thank you!

[@rich1879]

That's what some would call " built like a brick shit house,," I don't mean the wtoves

[@estelamoralesoropesa4482]

Como conseguir una y de $ yo soy de México estado de Tlaxcala

[@olchat2012]

En Chihuahua hay una fábrica de estufas le leña y en mi opinión, son mejores oiga 😊

[@artur.321]

Сколько стоит такая печь.

[@doctoralam1995]

Man, she is built..damn

[@deliasanchez1303]

Pues me gustan cuando menos podrian traducirnos y darnos precio x qsi estan muy buenas

[@olchat2012]

En Chihuahua México hay una fábrica de estufas de leña también 😉

[@randylenart9674]

Nice stoves

[@princesstshofela9834]

Oh l want one.

[@Camz316]

These are around $5,000

[@sharky1267]

thumbs up for the legs

[@BD-mm4vv]

really enjoyed this

[@reydeguerra2807]

I am not here to see the stoves.

[@kirksway1]

Those are some nice legs, aren't they ;)

[@norrisb4301]

@@kirksway1 I was Hoping No One Noticed her Legs!! That's why she wears the mini skirt.🤣🤣🤣

[@lenjames]

Wow....and that is not the stove I'm commenting on.

[@deannaspencer8988]

All Stores Please lower the cost of all Military and Local for all for all Appliances and Accessories and Production Cost Now That's a Much $$ The Whole thing Now 🙏🙏🙏

[@וולודיהוולודיה]

не подумайте,что я пытаюсь сумничать и поблестать чешуёй на фоне сложившихся обстоятельств, но мне действительно кажется, хотя я тоже могу заблуждаться, как и любой из нас. но тем не менее я не опротестовываю чьё-либо мнение и с уважением отношусь ко взглядам каждого человека и к его личному мнению,а так же осознаю и в какой-то степени разделяю его позицию.и учитывая все аспекты,всю концепцию и разность мировоззрения,допускаю мысль,что.... офигееееть: забыл нафиг,что и сказать-то хотел.

[@smashthemachine3746]

great set of legs.....i mean oven, yea great ovens

[@alanballard7466]

Serious how many of you men click because you see too big pretty legs not worrying about a wooden stove. 😀

[@robert4747]

We made a drinking game out of this video. Every time she pushes her hair behind her ear. we had to take a drink. Poor jj was lit three minutes in...

[@jeffreysmith5175]

Now that's cool. Like to have one. What it truly was like to live in those days. I like women with long slim legs

[@antoniofranciscodemesquita4341]

Mande um desses pra mim.

[@sahanuluc1223]

I've not need a woodstove. She's enough for me. 😊 Just joke. Thank you.

[@bobmccoy4652]

👍👍

[@lucasalvesdeoliveira6995]

👏👏👏