Wooden Plane VS Metal Plane

[@KD-sl3ve]

I just discovered your site a couple of days ago. I have my grandfathers tools, no one in the family wanted them and I could not let them go. I remember him making things like whirly gigs, but the one thing that really stood out was, he used them to build his house. They date from the 1930's to the 1960's depending on the tool. I am not a wood worker but you have inspired me to give his tools a try. Thank you for your explanation of the Planes, He had both metal and wood and now I understand how they are used.

[@GetFvckedRecordz]

Give it a go dude, I've found a load of scrap wood around town n the neighborhood, bought a few planes and chisels aswell as both those hand drills and some different sized bits, it's so much fun man!

[@PootisPenserPow]

Godspeed, those tools want to be used to craft things again. I wish you all the best in your woodcraft. Keep your fingers behind the blade. You don't want to learn that lesson the hard way.

[@woodworkingandepoxy643]

That's awesome. Always enjoy seeing people not only use their grandfather's tools but see the history and importance behind them

[@maureenmango1]

Your content is always so interesting and informative. I feel like I’m just listening to a friend when I watch your videos. I don’t even do wood working too much myself but I love watching and learning from you! keep on keeping on ❤️

[@EoinReardon]

Cheers lad, thanks for your comment I appreciate it.

[@PootisPenserPow]

I've been a woodworker since I was a schoolchild, but you've inspired me to turn my attention to some of the more traditional tools and techniques. Power tools are great, but they don't produce the same satisfaction as a good antique plane or chisel. Thank you.

[@joshholton4712]

Love your long-form stuff! Thank you for sharing your expertise!

[@EoinReardon]

Cheers Josh.

[@joearnold6881]

The wooden ones are chaotic evil, them being cannibals

[@TheMadTatter]

Cracking video again, sir! When you were talking about the biggest weakness in the different planes, it brought to mind something my old man says, that "the biggest weakness in any tool is shite on the end of it", meaning the operator, one of those phrases I never forget and use probably more than I should

[@rhozzy]

I have no clue about woodworking, but to be completely honest just watching you explain it all is so fascinating. A part of me wants to start figuring it out, seems very blissful.

[@williamutting6435]

I do a bit of antique "dealing" in Wales. Planes are very nice to get my hands on, satisfying to get them into shape and cutting again.

[@jonkoskie8587]

I've always been a bit intimidated by hand planes. Never really understood the purpose of them. Watching your videos, especially this one, I'm now beginning to realize I could really use one. Would solve a lot of my woodworking issues that power tools just can't. Thank you!

[@pitsnipe5559]

Good comparison. I have a wood jointer and jack that I bought 45 years ago, still using them. Also have a metal no. 5 that’s about 75 years old. Still works fairly well.

[@mike2228]

Couple of points to round out your fantastic video: 1. Throw a very light coat of oil on your metal plane, or wax, to keep the metal rust free. 2. When storing your wooden planes be sure to back out the wedge so it isn't tight or they can split when the weather changes.

[@dougierbarder]

Also get used to store your planes on their side to avoid chipping the blade etc!

[@TheAlphaZulu]

Long time viewer from TikTok and had no idea you had a KZbin channel! Love the long form content!

[@moistson3560]

Thanks for the tips! You've really helped me with restoring a wooden plane I got after my grandfather.

[@stephenholmes5362]

Great content, I know you will go far! KZbin needs more like you, learn so much from you!

[@BakerVS]

On the continent (where I live) metal planes never became very common, and professional woodworkers kept using wooden planes until they eventually switched to power tools. Here, wooden planes in good condition are very easy to find and cheap. I prefer metal planes, for the simple reason that they're faster and easier to adjust and sharpen. Getting the wedge out of a wooden plane, and adjusting the blade just right can be a pain. Also, I find my metal planes to be more comfortable in my hands than my wooden ones. Wooden ones do however have the advantage of sliding over the work surface with less friction!

[@lance1083]

Would love to see a project from start to finish exclusively to the KZbin channel enjoy watching all your videos and your knowledge is top notch! Keep the good work up! 💪

[@JackStevenson5045]

You are brilliant. Keep the Irish tradition alive!

[@shanksjeffcott8598]

Great videos. Iv ready the comments im sure im going to repeat something here so if i do sorry in advance. Your correct with the rear adjustment, for lowering the blade that button on the front of the plane is for you to tap this will lower the blade. This way your don’t damage the back of the blade and the button is there so you don’t damage the timber. Give it try see what you think. You rock

[@fredazcarate4818]

Young man you are a wealth of practical information. Continue on and bless you and your family.

[@daveyjones6148]

Prior to subscribing to you I knew next to nothing of carpentry and woodworking. Your informative content has taught me so much in so little time. Carry on lad your doing incredibly well!

[@zanderchiasson8064]

The extra weight of the metal can also sometimes help with momentum for smoother cuts in some instances

[@NAH1907]

Metal planes are very convenient, need to take a heavy cut? Twist the frog knob to have more iron in the cut. A lite/smooth cut? Well twist the knob the other way. Wooden planes are like old ways of having light before the light bulb and electricity were a then. It an odd way compare, but it makes sense to me. I will admit though using a wooden plane feels very nice. Amazing video as usual.

[@argetlamzn]

Love to learn about this type of thing. Thank you!

[@philgrimsey3637]

I love your videos. Knowledge imparted with passion is a sure way to hold my interest. If I ever meet up with you, I owe you a pint.

[@henryeccleston7381]

I got a Veritas plane iron recently and it was $50 CAD, well worth the money and came to me lapped and sharp (I touched it up because I never trust factory sharp and with five minutes touching up it can take a shaving you can easily read through even on a cheap Stanley body). Veritas is good quality mid range planes these days, but I’ve heard from enough people that building your own wooden plane is worth the time to give it credit.

[@declanthiele]

Never liked the wooden planes too much. All the sudden watching this video I think I caught a bit of a crush on em 😳 Jokes aside I always preferred working with hand tools and while I love the smoothness of the steel planes, the wooden ones are catching my attention now too. I always loved the raw feeling behind hand tools, and I think there's something special to that ol' "tap tap tap, yeah that's just about right" dance you gotta do on the wooden ones to dial them in

[@chriskelly4894]

I was taught never to rest a plane on its sole but on its side, to avoid damage to the cutting edge when putting it down.

[@paulfisher6918]

I’m watching from Cumbria uk absolutely love the channel brilliant hand working tools carpentry done properly thanks 🙏

[@irisheye100]

I thought you were the Irish version of Roy Underhill from the Woodwrightshop, but I think you are much more thorough in covering a subject. Keep up the good work.😊

[@Vincent-S]

I like the woodies, they glide nice without any wax and nice and light. Only annoyance I have with them are particularly the double iron kinds with depth adjustment and how the edge scoots away from the cap iron for a deeper cut. I learned a workaround by putting a couple sheets of paper on either side of the plane sole when inserting the iron so that it’s slightly too deep and all I have to do is hit the rear and wedge to get it where I want it, but it made me really appreciate the adjusters on metallic planes, or even transitionals, more. Still fun to use though! I like making them too from spare vintage irons taken from destroyed bodies or current reproduction irons.

[@adammcguinness9950]

I like both. When I’m using metal planes, I enjoy it. When I use my wooden planes, I enjoy that process too. Handplanes are such a satisfying thing to use.

[@morganhurst_redridge]

I bought a No. 7 a few months back that was in really rough shape, the guy I bought it from didn't think it was going to be usable so he was basically throwing it away! After a weekends work I now have a beauty of a jointer plane that cost basically nothing! Alot of the wooden planes I've seen at flea markets and the such are massively overpriced, everyone selling them seems to think they are something super special whereas the Stanley are so common they usually aren't very expensive.

[@tennesseevalleyhomeimprove8810]

Just subscribed to your channel. Great content! As we say in Tennessee, well done brother & keep your hand to the plow.

[@ImMartinKai]

Your videos are amazing, they are just so good

[@charlesdavis7087]

I really enjoy watching you give these lessons on woodwork. But I can't help but wonder: when are you going to come up with your own high quality tools? World class... Tools by Eoin Reardon of Ireland. You'll be selling tools around the world. Blessings, Charles of the USA.

[@happiman9484]

Wood, I'm not a blacksmith for pine's sake the blade is plenty enough for me thank you

[@daiedalous]

Found your videos through Shorts, and they're just so fascinating. Something really nice about the concept of not using power tools... But the way that saw is positioned, it looks like the teeth are facing you and super close, and it keeps making me nervous 😂

[@vaggelis0855]

Hey eion if you can put the camera a bit closer man it's kinda hard to see what you're talking about. Other than that continue your amazing work you've made me really fall in love with carpentry and generally doing/making things myself

[@scratticus8274]

Not sure if this is the right place to ask Eoin, but I recently bought an antique German nuthobel, or plough plane. The steel is old and needs a sharpen, and that's ok but it only came with one bit of steel. Could I get away with placing a chisel in there to give me a range of groove sizes, or would I need to adjust the bevel, etc to make that work?

[@fredslayton]

Great video! Even greater hat! Can you share where you got it? Brand, style?

[@okxden]

i never thought woodworking was this complicated

[@ALe-dh8oq]

always tighten the wedge when you hit your plane to take out the blade... the wedge also moves when the blade moves..

[@Vikingwerk]

Very informative, thanks!

[@tommy_ironman_2024]

Love your content, bud

[@thomashverring9484]

Remember to tap the wedge every time you adjust the iron! And use the striking button, that's what it's for. You would normally use a standard claw hammer or similar to adjust the plane (at least in any English speaking tradition). I use a small dead blow with acrylic faces, though. No reason to bang it around with anything more serious than that. Rex Krueger, however, did make the informed decision to go for the authentic (again English speaking tradition) choice and only use a claw hammer. My point is, have one hammer at hand to adjust it with-and it should be of a size that can also tap the wedge. Your bench hammer was perfect for that. You are talking from an English speaking traditional perspective (UK and American (the continents)), in the rest of Europe wooden planes are still the norm. They do not rot away. Most of them are made by stable wood that don't even move anymore. It's common to find wooden planes more than 100-150 years old that work fine, and new ones are still made. And the wear you talk about I can't quite recognize. Not that I haven't found beat up wooden planes, I sure have. I made a worn slethøvl (between a scrub and a smoother, closer to the smoother) into a scrub. It's absolutely perfect. Most of the wear is superficial. But of course they wear, but it will take many, many years! Just use a little bit of wax on the sole. Not that wooden planes need much lubrication, but it doesn't hurt. And if the sole is worn out, make a new plane or a new sole. That's the whole point of wooden planes in the olden days. You made your own. Stanley just wanted to make money on something people would normally make themselves. For professionals using wooden planes look up Peter Follansbee, Graham Blackburn, Mortise and Tenon Magazine, and Richard Maguire to mention a few. And Stavros Gakos for plane making. In my opinion wooden planes are much easier to adjust and use. You just tap them; down, on the strike plate (if it has one), on the side (you can hold it in your hand, no reason to put it on its side), etc. and then on the wedge. Always on the wedge! It's extremely fast and intuitive. I don't really like all the knobs and adjusters on metal planes; they make the planes seem less in touch with the work. But that's just down to personal preference, of course. (By the way, when adjusting a wooden plane you don't sight it, you have your fingers over the mouth and feel it. Watch Mortise & Tenon Magazine video "How to Use a Wooden Handplane". They're also using a claw hammer.) The point is. Metal planes aren't superior to wooden planes at all-it's only a question about personal preference. You can't do something with a metal plane that you can't do with a wooden plane and vice versa. And, for crying out loud, stop shaving your hairs 😅

[@kylenmaple4668]

I have that same green thermos. Nice

[@P1CKFD]

Would you prefer using the wooden plane or the Stanley when you’re making shtuff?

[@blusoda0021]

I'm no professional but I'd have thought that the metal bodied plane would take the smaller shaving as I'd have thought the very obvious predictability of the metal, would be able to get the blade lower and closer to the bottom of the body. But then again the Japanese style wooden bodied plane takes off incredibly thin shavings if set up/used correctly.

[@anthonykp25]

Very informative!

[@gav2759]

As shipwrights we had both types at our disposal. They were used for different jobs. A wooden jack is far superior to a steel one for fairing planks, or mast making. The bailey type hand plane no use at all for hull fairing, compared to the ergonomics of a coffin type wooden hand plane.

[@HolisticJedi]

Which came first; the flat piece of wood or the plane?

[@josh4236]

Hi mate what diamond stone do you use ?. Great video again btw.

[@RobertGlover-oz2rb]

You have not explained the button on the wooden plane.

[@ronruckman4980]

I noticed you mentioned Japanese plane. Was interested have you ever invested in a japanese pull saw or any of there wood working tools? Id recommend. Keep going lad great content. Kiss the blarney stone for me bud lol

[@joshuarieger3103]

Hi, I'm looking to buy my first plane soon, nur don't really know with which to start. Would you recommend a No. 4 or a No. 5 to me?

[@samanthaharvey7901]

The day I see a ring on his finger, I'll be both sad he's off the market, and happy he's found the one

[@karelenhenkie666]

I use mh stsnley planes for most precise work and my wooden planes for more course work because they are much ligther en feel nicer to hold really strong

[@LavLightKnight]

0:45 until 0:52 Phrasing?

[@SUpahh100]

Nice

[@rolandgdean]

Did European carpenters ever develop WIDE box planes like the Japanese ones that are 1 foot (1 shaku) wide or wider? I've often wondered that.

[@BrandonGrantSplash]

what happened at 3:40? why'd you cut part of the video you hiding something from us XD

[@EoinReardon]

I’m just not good at editing. Practice pending

[@BrandonGrantSplash]

@@EoinReardon That's okay your great at teaching :) and you videos are a blast to watch

[@xxdiamond_knightxx9772]

Here in switzerland we only use wooden planes

[@detectivewaffle]

I have a modern-ish metal/wood plane hybrid

[@autumn2333]

Could you make a guitar?

[@santi-og3hx]

Favorite pokemon

[@oler777]

Eoin 😂

[@joytekb]

Must have been used used by sime famous guy in middle east some two thousand years ago

[@ken78969]

😍

[@bungle1jungle]

hey

[@floppa2713]

Hi

[@EoinReardon]

Wagwan

[@szxnv]

💪

[@jcoul1sc]

Oil is no good for oxidization/rust, you need a coating

[@johnschillo4452]

yeah, wooden planes don't rust and they're simply nicer to hold

[@sambaggins2798]

It’s funny to think there are way more Irish throughout the world then who actually live in Ireland (People who are descendants of Irish immigrants).

[@Annalovesautumn]

Bit less funny when you think about the reasons so many left, unfortunately. Interesting fact, at any rate

[@SkippoSkippo]

yupla

[@mary9135]

What is your opinion on big booty latinas?

[@RobertGlover-oz2rb]

Don't put your plane face down on the bench.

[@figueredoruley8050]

Woodglut has very good designs and plans.

[@DeathDontWait4NoOne]

Simple Metal=more durable Wood=easier to repair