World's First Ever Lab Meat Poses Challenge To Muslim Scholars - Is It Halal?

Is lab meat halal? What does Islam say about meat that was made out of cells grown in a lab?
👉 IMPORTANT: SUBSCRIBE TO MY NEW CHANNEL HERE: bit.ly/friendlyexmuslim 👈
► My blog: friendlyexmuslim.com/
Source article: www.nytimes.com/2020/12/02/bu...

[@littlefinger3312]

300 years from now, people will look back and think "Damn, they actually killed animals for meat? “

[@gamenigeria]

Killing animals is not going stop.

[@ashs7462]

@@gamenigeria not sure about that since growing and taking care of animals (That we eat) takes a lot of space and time it’s gonna stop surely

[@etistone]

More like: "Shit, even the working class ate meat and many lived in accomodations with more that 30 square metter per person! Some of them even had gardens, can you believe..."

[@JohnStopman]

@Littlefinger331 300? Make that 75 years ;-)

[@el_killorcure]

As long as people have to eat, they are going to kill animals for food, not just farm crops. Just like carnivores will continue to kill animals for food. If veganism was natural, carnivores would not exist...

[@islamicclarity7062]

Fascinating topic.

[@_abuanusnarrated_9299]

You Are Interesting Sir.

[@tatiavanus5437]

I am reminded of Dr. Jay Smith 🤭🤭😆😆🥰🥰

[@tatiavanus5437]

Haram.. not slaughtered in the name of Allah.. Maybe the moment they culture the cells, they may say those bismillah thingy.. 🤣🤣

[@MustAfaalik]

Maybe the covid vaccine is haram???

[@RustyWalker]

How do you know it wasn't slaughtered in the name of Allah? Maybe it was.

[@tatiavanus5437]

@@RustyWalker how does one slaughter a culture?

[@gunarsrepse232]

​@@tatiavanus5437 Imagine all the time you would save as a halal meat factory!!! Instead of saying the factory workers catchphrase Bismillah Allahu Akbar all day long when killing a 1 tonne worth of chickens, you just take cells from 1 healthy chicken, culture the heck out of its cells in a lab so you now have a 1000 kg of lab-grown chicken meat, and then you kill the 1 still alive chicken that was the donor and say the "necessary" ritual sacrifice words! Slaughter house factory workers and their unions should really lobby this. IMHO.

[@mr.normalguy69]

@@tatiavanus5437 You take a knife, and keep saying Allahu Akbar as you cut the culture in two. There, Halal meat.

[@henricahyosetiawan]

Haram. Not slaughtered by name of Allah.

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Haha

[@henricahyosetiawan]

@@AbdullahSameerVideos greeting from Indonesia

[@RustyWalker]

Maybe it was - originally!

[@hendiherawan]

MUI Will announce it as halal since it's not originated from living breathing animal, it's just fake meat

[@henricahyosetiawan]

@@hendiherawan Maybe. But this is a real meat, not a fake meat. Fake meat meat analogue means a food made from vegetarian ingredients. Many fake meat, called analogue meat are soy-based (e.g. tofu, tempeh) or gluten-based, but now may also be made from pea protein.

[@abominathor]

I'm from Singapore and I'm sure the Muslims here will go bonkers over it 😅

[@julianw7097]

I’d say it’s vegan.

[@emanuelyasheav1040]

Even though you cause pain by taking animal tissue? When I say you, that is in general

[@julianw7097]

@@emanuelyasheav1040 Assuming that is avoided. Though, even if it isn’t, the about of pain per burger is incredibly low.

[@whole4339]

The more the world develops in science, the more hypocrisy will be found in Islam. They can not ignore the development, nor they are willing to avoid their religion. Therefore hypocrisy is the only way.

[@AtheistEve]

I wonder if there’s anyone on the planet that isn’t a hypocrite, or doesn’t rely on some form of cognitive dissonance to get through life.

[@whole4339]

@@AtheistEve Yes, you are right. But that hypocrisy is from personal level and in that sense almost all of us are hypocrites. But doing something secretly ignoring the religious canon thus showing the society that I am strict follower of religion is different from your view on hypocrisy. Taking the advantage of scientific advancement and again imposing the religious command on its followers establishes as the source of hypocrisy .

[@apostate424]

Can I use a tape recorder and machine to pray my namaaz?

[@amuaiz]

just like how to pray in ISS, how to fast in the poles, they'll make stuff up into new rulings.expect nothing less

[@thepoorsultan5112]

You have to estimate it and the evidence for it is It was proven that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) told his companions about the Dajjaal (antichrist). He was asked how long he would stay on earth, and he said, “Forty days, one day like a year, one day like a month, one day like a week and the rest like your days.” It was said, “O Messenger of Allaah, the day which is like a year, will the prayers of one day be sufficient for us then?” He said, “No, estimate them.” So the day which will be like a year is not regarded as one day in which only five prayers will be sufficient, rather we are obliged to offer five prayers in each twenty-four hour period. He commanded them to offer the prayers at intervals as on a regular day.

[@mr.normalguy69]

@@thepoorsultan5112 Alhamdulillah brother! Could you please explain to us if prophet Muhammad flying to heaven on a winged horse is true or not? Is it true that the moon was split in half during prophet Muhammad's time?

[@joseditto8099]

if people are happen to live in other planet then the qibla must be to earth. in ISS that move 27000 km/h, the qibla direction should be changed every minute. Qibla itself actually suggests (will work only if) the earth is flat. how is it possible to face qibla from the other side of earth? the qibla then must facing down. muslims from location more than 90 degree away from kabah will not find proper direction.

[@thepoorsultan5112]

@@joseditto8099 again this is refuted 1400 years ago (2:115) The East and the West belong to Allah. To whichever direction you turn, you will be turning to Allah.115 Allah is All-Embracing, All-Knowing.116 When you don’t know the Qibla you can pray in what ever direction you think is correct And Qibal has nothing to do with shape of earth!!!

[@thepoorsultan5112]

@@mr.normalguy69 first of all it id Buraq and Buraq is not a hourse it is an unknown animal the hadith only says smaller than hourse Secondly yes the prophet PBUH travelled to heavens The Ulama are divided in regards whether his body with soul went or only soul!! When he came back people even asked him!!!, The polytheists mocked him, so the prophet PBUH gave signs he said i saw so and so caravan on the way and told them the signs of masjid al aqsa how many windows it has etc... As for the moon splitting it also happened!!! Some stupid people say if it happened why didn’t the romans record it!! Here is a better explanation m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/nmitXmOgpctmgas

[@Ayesha-be4fv]

Nice content 👍 brother new to your channel

[@grahamashe9715]

There is only one thing every mullah and Islamic scholar since the dawn of Islam until the end of time is certain of. The compulsory nature of the daily prayers and fasting in Ramadan.

[@overcspurs8027]

If they can't say prayer before slaughtering as there isn't any slaughtering, so it's not allowed?

[@TheRationalizer]

I suppose it's only Halaal if the original animal had its throat slit? I don't know, let them worry about it, along with how to fast until sunset in Svalbard.

[@ahamedumusaafir9856]

First it will be haraam. Then it will be a face saving halaal. Ex: first they did not accept man going to moon. Then said, Mohamed (sal) flew to several skys above.

[@zd5116]

AS, AP and IC... you guys rock ✌🏼

[@hamidmydin9717]

In Malaysia, they are questioning whether AI technology is halal😅

[@GoodGuyChucky-666]

I used to work in a restaurant owned by muslim, one day at work, phone call came from what could be a potential customer, I answered the call & he asked me if the meat we serve was halal, I said yes it is & he asked me if we have a certificate & we have no certificate, so i gave the phone to my manager, my manager said to him that our supplier says it's halal, so we can only take their word for it, he gave him the name of our supplier & so I've learnt that there is no guarantee if the meat is halal, after all we haven't seen the animal killed with our own eyes

[@AtheistEve]

As a vegan, I’m unlikely to eat those cultured meat products. I might try one, but I’ve been vegetarian for too many years to take a step back. Maybe cultured meat is halam or haral.

[@AtheistEve]

@Pyrrhonist Pescatarian, then vegetarian for 30+ years, vegan these last three or so years. I’m vegan.

[@RustyWalker]

I began by reducing how much meat I was eating, then tried out veggie options to find the ones I liked, and then switched to fully veggie. Still working on being fully vegan. That's not quite as easy because it's still quite a bit more expensive.

[@ashs7462]

An advice: take vitamin pills you’re gonna need them since meat give us lots of stuff that you can’t get from viggies :)

[@RustyWalker]

@@ashs7462 Don't worry. My degree covered an introduction to nutrition. I'm a little more informed than average, though not by any means a nutritional expert.

[@MrCip]

@Pyrrhonist To stop the needless suffering of innocent animals. You can get everything you need from plants, so why pay someone to stab an animal in the throat for a few moments of taste pleasure. And it doesn't have to be more expensive, cheap options are available. If you don't think animals suffer watch "dominion" on KZbin.

[@mahmutcankaya3321]

@Pyrrhonist İn the production of eggs,male chicks are almost always killed because they can't be used.Milking causes stress on the mother cow and they have ostheophorosis which causes their lifespan to be 1/10 of their original value.There are also other things but I think this would suffice.

[@MrCip]

@Pyrrhonist The difference is that vegans don't pay for animal cruelty. Vegetarians unwillingly pay for cows to be impregnated from one year old. Their babies taken away (most males killed) then after about 5 babies, they are killed for cheap meat. This is because their milk production declines. So cheese isn't a good excuse.

[@hassan10ify]

Hi abdullah what made you leave Islam

[@chemstuff2657]

Lab grown meat is awesome I don’t why Muslim scholars think they can say something is halal or haram on topics not mentioned in the Quran

[@chemstuff2657]

WanderingSoul that’s what I’m saying?

[@anandpandey5105]

That is the problem, One of the very foundation of Islam is that there is nothing that is not mentioned in Quran. Because Quran is complete book.

[@chemstuff2657]

Anand Pandey that claim from Muslims can easily be debunked. The Quran does not even state to pray five times a day, how to pray or even how to perform hajj lol.

[@pandhunareswara]

Ijtihad, is third source of islamic law after u went to al Quran and al Hadeeth. that's why. so its based on ulama (scholars) thinking, but the thinking based on lots of consideration. So, here's the thing. if the consideration were wrong from the truth (we never know this), it's still okay and not a sin. So in the case of lab grown meat, we may look at the Ijtihad by our scholars.

[@grambo1690]

@Tranquility TenThousand that’s your opinion

[@anshuljain7464]

Like you I also acknowledge that Veganism is superior than vegetarianism (me being a vegetarian). What's right is right. I love your logical thought process, you never attach your ego with ideas... Love from India...🙏

[@mo_7199]

It is true. I am a vegetarian too, but I wish to go vegan soon.

[@h2lo704]

Interesting... Let say that it is decided that lab grown meat is considered halal, then is lab grown pork halal?

[@nusratalbert1336]

no little heart for me and not even a comment of my comment ? Hmm...

[@laurameszaros9547]

It's a challenge to vegans as well, and there is debate in our community about it. I'm on the flexible side of the vegan spectrum so I'm in favour of lab produced "meat" on the whole, because I think it will avoid much more animal suffering, in the long run, than it will cause. Slightly at a tangent to the purpose of your post, but I thought I'd mention it.

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Thanks!

[@a.person_]

Islam cannot stand the test of time. Time, technology and common sense will eventually be the undoing of all religions.

[@fvillag1]

Yes and no ISLAM WILL DIE Christianity and Judaism will survive.

[@gunarsrepse232]

@@fvillag1 Oh, that seems like such a naïve theist answer. I have a very strong urge to assume you identify as one of those groups, but of course it doesn't necessarily have to be true. I have no love for any religion, except for when it is in its most benign forms, yet I fear that religion will always be there in one form or another and therefor religious persecutions. My hope is that, if modern nonsensical religions cannot change into mythologies, they will become reformed into "a way of life and philosophy" kind of thing, that takes the best bits from any books of old while scrapping the superstitious, the contra scientific and evil parts. What I'd really like, is for people to try to understand each other better and accept that some differences will always be present and that meaningful change takes time and that us vs. them mentality will almost always bring more harm than good.

[@zachseabass7414]

@@fvillag1 Are you high or what? Judaism is a lot more conservative than Islam and as for Christianity - it just lives in more or less indifferent post-Christian society which consider it as a cultural part rather than actually worshipping it. IMO all religions will eventually transform and evolve into something less dogmatic through time.

[@DeeBoudreau]

Are humans exempt from predator/prey concept that is dominant in the animal world?

[@brianbouf8303]

We are the Gods, so we can make new rules as we evolve ethically and scientifically.

[@NitoTerrania]

Halal ? Haram ? Screw that ! Is it delicous grilled ? How much does it cost per Kg in retail stores ? How long before it rots ? Can we order a custom percentage of fat within the meat ? Can you made it with marbling fat like the Japanese Kobe Beef Wagyu ? Those are the important questions here

[@wishuonmyjourney818]

💚 kzbin.info/www/bejne/qYilXpKYeZ6MjbM

[@pastorsex6639]

Pork is delicious

[@SofaaKing2]

the ingredients are proprietary - i sure as hell wont eat it lol

[@stewiegriffin6503]

good video

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Thanks

[@jamescustodio3094]

If you think about it, lab grown meat is vegan, cus no animal abuse nor cruelty is being done. As for the halal-ness of it, well, if you individually slit the cells and said the chant, it might become one? But tbh, its moot. True cruelty free meat!!!

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Lmao

[@JohnStopman]

Vegan still simply means 'they who _only_ eat veggies', I'm sure some vegans will use that as an excuse against labmeat.

[@jimmyshrimbe9361]

That's not how words work....

[@JohnStopman]

@@jimmyshrimbe9361 Most words have a standard (base) definition, else things become [very] ambiguous pretty quick (if we can 'use' words any way we 'like').

[@mahmutcankaya3321]

@@JohnStopman No I'm vegan but if there is no harm on animals,I would eat lab grown meat.Most ethical vegans I know would actually eat it.I think people have a warped understanding of veganism.

[@gingercat7061]

Yeah, i mean what for, it is all came from organism, i mean meat is edible right?

[@theseeker9591]

don't worry, Islamic scholars would let you know when it start coming in market. Islam is religion for all ages from time of Prophet, until the world ends. God is great, & God knows best.

[@theseeker9591]

And Sameer u r foolishly associating the action of slaughtering to lab made meat. it's like u r associating the issue of milk from cow to meat from cow. just instead of milk we are having vitro-meat. it's just like taking a milk from cow, that's isn't haram. why would then this meat would be haram except if it has harm. see it's so simple to understand, & Muslims look in Hidiths only when a important decision is to be taken. yes, a true Muslims looks everytime because his every decision & time is important. God knows best whether u r Muslim or not (though u proclaim not, but God knows what I don't), but Sameer I would advice u too don't waste ur time in maligning Islam, instead what question u have send it to an Ulema. make ur channel work for something better rather making it against Islam (which is best). best u can't beat but better u can be. I advice u of better, don't malign (rhetorically) what's best. May God guide all of us.

[@Veegan4theanimals]

Thank you so much for not bashing veganism. I’ve been vegan for 15 years. I believe in the evolution of the collective consciousness. We are evolving. Even the historians say that we are less violent now than years ago.

[@absarius1216]

I think Moderate Muslims will land on something like performing one last Dhabiha on one animal and use its cells and modified versions of them for all Halal items.

[@pandhunareswara]

great vids, appreciate that. but the creator's actually tricky one. with arabic name, yeah stereotypically muslim oh exmuslim at the end lol. but the explanation seems logic. Am i the only one expecting this guy explain this case from perspective of Islamic rule? So, im a muslim and looking for answer for this from scholars, but not yet to find. anyway dude, i don't want to judge of your converting. but um, just wanna say what went to my mind (TL;DR) uhm. yeah it's kind of hard to reconcile between logic and dogma for certain issues like this. I still use my logic anyway, but still have question to God in my mind, why this why that not allowed, but I still I think. the existence of us in this earth is still a huge mystery. imagine like how come, human as animal can be the only animal that could survive with lots of civilizations, why not other animals have their own civilization? and along with other planet and galaxies, why only earth (assumtion as we dont know others) is the best environment for living creature? the cloud, weather, stability, being safe from meteors, pull of gravity by other big suns. i think who made this real balance and safe environment? i think it's God. and what about the afterlife, atheist may question does heaven and hell exist? okay we know abt this we don't know scientifically abt it for sure cuz it's hard to proof scientifically, but what we do is we believe. we can think scientifically abt that, but we believe too. think and believe, we dont only think, but plus believe. so wht abt afterlife? lets bet bro. i bet universe and afterlife is according to the islam. okay cuz atheist, lets assume your bet is nothin. no afterlife, no hell, no worries. if you're right, we don't exists afterlife. if I'm right .....( u know what will happen)

[@AtheismActually]

0:19 And Jewish scholars. Probably even more so for Jewish scholars. Not to say it's A-OK for Christianity, considering that there was some debate about whether it's okay for Catholics to eat plant-based "meat" on meat abstinence days.

[@jimmyjim5yearsago376]

6:21 "Islam is out of date" But what do you consider as Islam? What do you consider as a religion? The texts? The people? I mean as you said, in Saudi people use tape recorder for zabiha. Is that considered as Islam because the people doing it is muslim? Or not because there's no Islamic religious texts says so?

[@tkbagga]

Of course if you pay 3 percent to Zaquat foundation you can get halal certification and they will find some verse in the holy book supporting it!

[@worldpeace1822]

Story twist the animal the cells taken from wasn’t killed to begin with.

[@orvuhs]

If someone is a atheist, there is no point of arguing with him or her. Believe is something, breaking up religion believes with logic is vulnerable. So I can't agree with you Abdullah. You are going wrong direction brother take care.

[@gunarsrepse232]

300 years from now, if the practice of growing of meat in a laboratory is actually viable, sustainable and cost-effective and there is demand for it, I would bet my right foot (feel free to dig it up from my grave if I'm wrong) that there would be at least some parts of the world, if not the whole planet, where human meat that is grown in the lab - with full knowledge and permission of the donor of the human cells, of course - is readily sold and used for consumption and other things. A bit outlandish, I know, but most of the negative aspects of human flesh eating that have plagued us until now - namely the principle of sanctity of human life that is violated when killing or maiming the actual human being whose meat is then consumed as well as the taboos associated with the practice - would no longer apply. That is the strange idea that I had. That would definitely add another possible meaning to the phrase "eat me" :) It seems strange at first, but then again a lot of the things that are new and go against the tradition seem so in the beginning. Like, say for example, transfusing blood from a donor when it is the only way to save a patients life or using stem cells that come from unborn children or the global first of lab grown "cultured chicken" meat being approved for sale in Singapore for the first time in human history in year 2020. Strangely enough I am quite okay with this cannibalistic eventuality, so I would welcome your thoughts on the matter and all possible reasons against it. P.S. @Littlefinger331 this idea was sparked by your comment. If anything, please blame him (I'm joking, of course). TL;DR - don't read.

[@biggiesmol]

It's pretty sad that the older Muslim generation of those above 60 facing the reality of mortality binge reading religious scholarly book instead of reading the Cosmos and other knowledge affirming books that will make us see the world in a clearer point of view.

[@flonoiisana4647]

First comment Edit : Yay😂

[@JohnStopman]

First to comment on your comment 😂

[@flonoiisana4647]

@@JohnStopman loll

[@flonoiisana4647]

@@JohnStopman I even got a like from The friendly neighborhood ex-muslim himself! It was ALL worth it!

[@JohnStopman]

@@flonoiisana4647 it always is ;-)

[@truthnationet8926]

I Don't Understand Why a Person Like You Does not Become a Vegan yet ....

[@pagangods5191]

Slaughter in the name of God. Cruelty.

[@zanaamir8143]

Yeah true your ppl have been doing it from centuries lol

[@othmane0313]

Why do you still eat meat if you think it is unethical?

[@katesebastian431]

Lab meat sounds like the way to go

[@sasquatchmodchris7364]

Food is food thousands of people every single year die ov starvation eat what ever you want religion is out dated but always remember the sun sets in muddy water 🙈🙊🙊🤣🤣👍

[@gingercat7061]

Oh shoot 😂

[@tayetrotman]

I’m sceptical that this will become that popular. The placebo effect is powerful, and people are going to taste this synthetically produced meat and convince themselves it tastes worse because the idea is strange to them. And that’s assuming it’s actually as nutritious as normal meat, and largely healthy and safe. I think it will be in time but, who knows what research will tell us.

[@chemstuff2657]

Yeah, probably those people who always say natural is better. Poison is natural lol. I hope it gets popular.

[@quzofrommycoke]

Dr. Shabir Ally has a funny video asking if the halal industry has gone too far. The Indonesian who contacted with the question says they have "halal electrical appliances in Indonesia (e.g. fridges)". The video suggests there's some shysters taking advantage of people's gullibility and it was good of Dr. Ally to highlight this (for example companies could be paying lots of money for certification in the hopes of getting more customers and it becomes like a kind of "protection racket", think Mafia). Source: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oZWrhIZmfq2AiMU I've seen some very dubious (pink) meat products marked as "halal". Somehow that cheap highly processed meat I saw is "halal" but the best cut of pork money can buy is not okay to eat? Something is wrong here. Allah needs to release an update to the Qu'ran, pronto!

[@obiwan3850]

Schooler schoolers uff

[@ankitanandy6076]

one day veganism will be the normal. I strongly believe humanity will take ethics seriously.

[@alhazenmediax]

Eating meat is not an Ethical question. If ethical then plats are also alive. Having said that, I respect anyone who wants to be a vegetarian.

[@TheMSS1977]

Looks like Allah loves the image of streams of flowing blood. Animal/human all the same.

[@thepoorsultan5112]

Refuted 1400 years ago A group of people once said to the Prophet (pbuh): "Some people have come to us with meat, and we do not know whether the Name of Allah has been mentioned over it or not. He replied: "You yourselves mention the Name of Allah over it and eat." Sahih Bukhari

[@ottopotatum5775]

then why do people look for label now?

[@thepoorsultan5112]

@@ottopotatum5775 what labels?

[@MustAfaalik]

@@thepoorsultan5112 The Halal label. Der!

[@thepoorsultan5112]

@@MustAfaalik if you don’t know if it is halal or not then the hadith i provided is applied, read the hadith again it says “we didn’t know if it was halal”

[@father88888]

this move will break the chain of animal suffering, endless cycle of cause n effect of retribution due to killings of animals, more sustainable world, less pollution, less primitive, easier done than convincing ppl to go vegetarian....

[@sahil98031]

This is funny as hell

[@yurafeg5970]

3:10 the rise of Muslim Skynet...

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

hahaha

[@fredericalan7815]

When your ancient Religion not relevant anymore to modern world

[@adriandecu6846]

Meat growing... Bad stuff... But, to pose challenge for the scholars??? C'mon! Isn't it the quran, a book of all knowledge?!? How can the prophit, not forsee this? I mean, the quran is explaining the big bang, but not the halal/ haram for meat growing???

[@chemstuff2657]

Quran contains nothing about the Big Bang lol

[@adriandecu6846]

@@chemstuff2657 eexacthly! ( Zakir Naik )😂😂

[@KenadoCC]

Good.

[@shaileshkumar929]

Now they are looking for halal vaccine 😁

[@MustAfaalik]

One reason to avoid halal meat is that the animals are not stunned before being slaughtered thus prolonging their psychological trauma. Problem arises when an ideology is based on worldly values and pride.

[@MustAfaalik]

@Ibrahim Awad I hope YT does not remove my comment should i replace ideology with Islam. Is science an ideology?

[@romanski5811]

I'm in favor of lab grown meat if they also aim to produce lab grown cat meat and lab grown dog meat. And heck, I can't see any ethical reason as to why there shouldn't be any lab grown human meat. I would most certainly try that.

[@romanski5811]

@Pyrrhonist Well, it's true, human beings are irrational when it comes to these things but since the available arguments clearly favor one side, maybe over time it will move in a more rational direction. I do think, though, that dog and cat meat would have to come first to let people get used to the idea and also to let them overcome their argument-lacking initial gut-feeling reaction, before lab grown human meat becomes commercially available. At the very least it should be allowed to produce, even if almost nobody would buy it at this time in history.

[@romanski5811]

*commercially viable

[@pandhunareswara]

Ijtihad, is third source of islamic law after u went to al Quran and al Hadeeth. that's why. so its based on ulama (scholars) thinking, but the thinking based on lots of consideration. So, here's the thing. if the consideration were wrong from the truth (we never know this), it's still okay and not a sin. So in the case of lab grown meat, we may look at the Ijtihad by our scholars.

[@misterpayah7723]

Allah is omniscient but couldn't look just 1400 years into the future and add a quranic verse on bismillahing lab meat. Would certainly have saved his poor muslims a lot of trouble.

[@IvanSensei88]

Or just pay us a visit again. How hard would that be for an infinitely wise being that also has infinite power? Heck, if you wanted to let everyone on the planet know you exist..... why send and angel to a single illiterate person while he's in a cave where conveniently no one can see that happen? If Allah decided to pick a random human, give him god powers and said "your task is to let everyone know I really DO exist" 99% of them would've done a better job at it than Allah did, or even more.

[@Ramy_Ramz]

Not mentioned = not haram Scholars probably will say it’s haram cause it’s shirk because they’re trying to replicate god’s creation 🤦‍♂️

[@PooftMancrap]

Hmmm...you had me up until you mentioned Vegan! 😂😂😂

[@DIYTAYSEERworld]

So what do we do with all those animals that grows. Faster than we even eat... Those animals will die and make more waste and biohazard then you have ever imagined... Is man is the only complete religion.. Islam not only talk about halal.. But it also cares about your health.. Similarly.. Killing a pig in a halal fashion dooes not makes it halal... MAY ALLAH grant us HIDAYAH.. AMEEN

[@Dan.TheFriendlyGuy]

You left islam, and you make videos about it. You haven't studied islam at first, you just inherited islam from your father and grandfather.

[@rehanbshah]

It’s proven plants feel pain too, stop hurting them as well.

[@nusratalbert1336]

If your aim is to enlighten Humanity, it would be fair to include " kausher" slaughter as well, which is very similar to "halal" but without prayer. Muslims have more in common with Jews that you can imagine!

[@overcspurs8027]

Didn't see it coming? How can that be? You are belittling All Knowing Perfect creator, and that's blasphemy!

[@hoseashpm7810]

A lot of low income people might buy it since it's cheap. Meat from slaughtered animals may be a luxury for the wealthy and animals farmers. But how will meat companies fight back? Will they invest in lab meat? What will happen to eggs? Find out on the next episode of Hoomans!

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Haha

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

At the moment it's damn expensive

[@hoseashpm7810]

@@AbdullahSameerVideos Bummer~

[@freethinker730]

it is a good day for humanity . lab meat is more ethical , and will be cheaper , and better for the envirement , and may be better than the classical meat for our health .

[@zanaamir8143]

Bro I'm not sure why u hate on Islam, anyway the answer is haram and u answered it in some point in your video... Look as u said Muslims do sacrifice animals to Allah so it not just about killing it a way to get closer to God, whether to say it unhuman... and all that bla bla... Bro u can see ppl and even kids getting....in Gaza and Sudan today right now in this moment and all the world do is looking, so please care about ppl before animals lol . If u want to eat that meat fine by us go enjoy but for us meat come from an alive animal and get proper dealt with, fast no pain.

[@hendiherawan]

It's fake meat, so it's halal, there will be time when this technology is common, muslim would prefer this kind of meat rather than the real meat since the halal-ness of mass produced meat from the factory is questioned

[@emanuelyasheav1040]

I think you still cause pain to the animal because you take a tissue of the animal, but still you don't kill the animal I hope that makes some sense...

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

No it's not done that way

[@bazza5699]

#goVegan :)

[@rasyazafaropane]

Some Non muslim be like : idc what r u talking about, but muslim is for sure is wrong and i will never be one Said some non-muslim, who intervere in a topic that they shouldnt intervere.

[@king-td1fo]

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👍

[@olee626]

Don't bother and waste your time listening. Have more knowledge before giving opinions

[@newfilmtrailer7733]

Who created this meat.. Oh.. allah is created this meat...not science..

[@williambutler5091]

Stop showing off about bitcoin. Lol, I'm just jealous.

[@JohnStopman]

Religion makes life so complicated.

[@pamelareyeshizon6743]

CENTURY TUNA,😁🤭

[@1derment]

Yes go vegan, do without meat, you can do it for the sake of the innocent.

[@Warzone-eh3vw]

Bruh it's simple, if it's not natural and completely synthetic in meaning the creation in a lab

[@TheMSS1977]

Cheating!!

[@gamingwolfAK]

vegasism destroys food chain

[@sebassanchezc-1379]

Now you derailed advocating for veganism. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 MOHAMMED just copied things he heard without knowing the reason (biological/ethical/spiritual).

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

I like veganism

[@sebassanchezc-1379]

@@AbdullahSameerVideos I like PHYSIOLOGY. We are not herbivores 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Well lab meat is here!

[@came2ownu]

@@sebassanchezc-1379 uh, yeah we are. Real omnivores don’t get heart disease from animal products due to cholesterol deposits.

[@JohnStopman]

@@AbdullahSameerVideos I want a slice of that meat! 🙏

[@joeynanez9897]

Good video brother but I ask you to please consider studying the bible because Jesus did die for your sins. God bless

[@thinkerslibrary4651]

Robert G. Ingersoll on the Trinity Christ, according to the faith, is the second person in the Trinity the Father being the first and the Holy Ghost the third. Each of these three persons is God. Christ is his own father and his own son. The Holy Ghost is neither father nor son, but both. The son was begotten by the father, but existed before he was begotten - just the same before as after. Christ is just as old as his father, and the father is just as young as his son. The Holy Ghost proceeded from the Father and Son, but was equal to the Father and Son before he proceeded, that is to say, before he existed, but he is of the same age of the other two. So, it is declared that the Father is God, and the Son God and the Holy Ghost God, and that these three Gods make one God. According to the celestial multiplication table, once one is three, and three times one is one, and according to heavenly subtraction if we take two from three, three are left. The addition is equally peculiar, if we add two to one we have but one. Each one is equal to himself and the other two. Nothing ever was, nothing ever can be more perfectly idiotic and absurd than the dogma of the Trinity. Is it possible for a human being, who has been born but once, to comprehend, or to imagine the existence of three beings, each of whom is equal to the three? Think of one of these beings as the father of one, and think of that one as half human and all God, and think of the third as having proceeded from the other two, and then think of all three as one. Think that after the father begot the son, the father was still alone, and after the Holy Ghost proceeded from the father and the son, the father was still alone - because there never was and never will be but one God. At this point, absurdity having reached its limit, nothing more can be said except: "Let us pray.

[@China786]

Listening to you first time and I am sure you are not a Muslim at all, don’t ridicule any religion. If you are an atheist go ahead and declare yourself, don’t insult others for their beliefs