XG - WINTER WITHOUT YOU / THE FIRST TAKE | MADEIN93 FIRST REACTION / REVIEW

[@tiekss7699]

Their vocals are insane ! 🔥 W Reactions 💯

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Facts Bro Thank You Once Again For Watching!!!💯

[@soliver25]

These girls are built different, the live version is better than the studio version, how is that even possible? 😅

[@honks9484]

No it’s not better because they didn’t do the run when they say “so hOwWw”😭

[@soliver25]

@@honks9484 they didn't do that run, but they added in harmonies at the end that weren't in the studio version, and they sound way better

[@bovisqui]

i literally listen to only the first take version 😭 its so beautiful

[@joshalvarez5138]

Facts I’m just like, how? Like this is crazy and maya vocals crazy too with the vocals.

[@Nannaphatz]

XG MASTERPIECE💙🐺

[@kaecee1991]

Chisa in this is just wow

[@W8ANDC]

Harvey doing her own adlibs 🤌🏽

[@bn6244]

love this performance, Love XG!!!

[@RudeMekanicals]

Bro almost tore his own headset off because of the acapella ending! It's called cuteness aggression!!!!

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Nah Fr Tho 😂😂😂😂 Thank You For Watching!!💯

[@AuntieNina68]

Cocona's swag, Hinata's earnestness, Maya's vocals and Chisa doing her best Ariana Grande impression. I love this!

[@juanrockone]

Chisa even got the hair.

[@missladylexx]

Harvey’s Harmony! 😊

[@MsNekaa26]

Only the hair her voice is 100% hers is absolutely beautiful

[@juanrockone]

@@MsNekaa26 agreed. Just pointing out the obvious. Her hair is super cute btw.

[@AuntieNina68]

@@MsNekaa26 That's exactly what I meant.😁

[@MarkCalica]

Just by looking at their eyes, you can see the emotions they put in that song. And you’re absolutely right. This version definitely sounds better than the record. All 7 are vocalists. Simon mentioned that Cocona is an exceptional singer. Not just Maya but the same with Harvey and Jurin

[@jpopspeed1]

Not just live, but the first take! no redos!

[@TexasTandyRestorations]

the fact is this 1 take is they sing it live, no editing, so what you see if what they are truly are.. beautiful expert in their fields of vocals and rapping.. they are magnificient

[@dhanimals.]

Nahhh bro thank you for the support to our Xtraordinary Girls! Your reactions have been my favorite as of recent for XG and there’s a lot of reactors out there.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Yoooo I Appreciate That Fr!! Thank You For Watching💯

[@タラちゃんねる-c7u]

Amazing XG👽💕 R&B X-POP🐺

[@erichoodlet3505]

Man down! They got my boy. They got us all.

[@TheYearOfJerome]

other groups can make you vibe other groups can get you hyped but no other group can make you **FEEL** like this

[@SkyMiku2023]

Word!

[@xokaponrxmt]

もっと世界に広まってほしいウィンターソング

[@ChRisu_Ojisan]

no cap this surpassed the main source.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Nah Fr Tho 😂 Thank You Once Again For Watching‼️💯

[@RobertSmithSWSMITH]

They deserve all the success, love them. Their personality and passion is amazing

[@yunoka5052]

あなたのリアクション動画が好きです。ＸＧのリアクションをありがとうございます。

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Thank You For That And I Appreciate You Watching!!!💯

[@LayaneMirelly-ho5eb]

they managed to make the song even better, xg never disappoints!

[@briannajackson8958]

I want to see them do first take again with other song ,but I want to see more songs with them going in full vocals like this.The Days gone cold part always blow my mind that real vocal singing that part.

[@megsyy0101]

blessing our ears

[@juanrockone]

They all rap in TGIF. Only singing is the bridge. It's very simple but super swaggy.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Ok Bet!!! Thank You For Watching💯

[@markjoon6489]

Bruh if Cocona ever is given the chance to let loose your jaw will drop. Simon/Jakops/CEO doesn't call her the All Rounder for no reason. I've only seen a snippet of her singing but her dancing & rapping is shown as she has one of the least amount of time on the songs but she still shines. I'm just waiting till she gets her time. FYI Jurin & Harvey can sing too. Harvey gave you a snippet of her chest register singing @5:22. We just have to wait patiently as they release more songs they will slowly reel you in as they show more bits of XG's talent.

[@nymphinthewind]

her voice sometimes reminds me of arianas. its so beautiful

[@kt2526]

XGと出会ってくれてありがとうございます😊 私は1年前から…出会えてラッキーでした！

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Yoooo I Appreciate That Fr!! Thank You For Watching💯

[@NatsuDragneel-gt4tj]

ITS LIVE EVERY (THE FIRST TAKE)

[@poisondarts]

"I SHOULDN'T BE LIKING CHRISTMAS SONGS!!!" HARDEST. SAME. EVER. this is the type of christmas song I didn't even know I needed

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Fr Tho 😂😂 Thank You For Watching!!💯

[@Gumigee]

I loved your reaction.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

I Appreciate That Fr!! Thank You For Watching💯

[@yulioparota978]

one word¨ heaven¨

[@Tiffii.official]

Xtraordinary live performance! They are on a different. They are doing everything better!

[@___Mimi___]

This reaction was a vibe. I was vibing right with you - loved that you have done a live performance reaction and I'm looking forward to seeing you react to not only XG, but whoever your journey lands you at. Much love 93 💚

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Thank You So Much I Really Appreciate That!!! Thank You For Watching As Well💯

[@risacruz616]

@8:40 breathe my brother breathe 😂. This song is really dope! They are really talented! You got me listening to them now,King! W reaction as always!!!

[@sayuri___]

I'm a Japanese. Thank you for loving XG ！

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Thank You For Watching💯

[@thecoconutnot]

this song indeed got a lot better! crazy a live performance could outdo a studio version this good. i mean the studio version is already so good

[@ZioComposite]

9:44 lol that's me, but for those who missed it: XG is insane when it comes to talent and 7 is actually the perfect number for this group: Rap - Cocona, Jurin, Harvey is the bridge that completes this group Maya - Is the BRIDGE that connects the 2 (Rap/Vocal Line) Vocal - Chisa, Juria, Hinata is the bridge that completes this group I like all their songs, some more than others but so far haven't had one that I can't listen to at all. How much much they keep leveling up is just crazy.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

😂😂😂😂 Thank You For Watching💯

[@Neige700]

5:39 Exactly !!! 🤯

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

😂😂😂😂

[@kobemoss]

Bro, XG IS THAT GROUP!.. ONCE IN A GENERATION TALENT

[@ohyeahwhooyeah]

Top tier song man. The live vocals are insane, harmonies for days and the ad-libs 🔥

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Facts!! Thank You For Watching💯

[@MsNekaa26]

I watch this and you are the third if you are watching I love this this is so amazing the voices are so clear is so beautiful and like one part, I didn’t know it was cocona and it was her that it was her, because I always thought it was during it is so beautiful and then oh my God you have to watch the behind-the-scenes of the video because it is absolutely beautiful. It will have you crying.

[@fabianjohnson7352]

SIMPLY THE BEST

[@domhur]

Maya and Cocina are definitely the ace of the group where they can do everything. This is better than this studio version.

[@sasasasasa7360]

cocona

[@HaponesaJones]

🔥🔥🔥 They are amazing!

[@BrockEvil]

Yes, they got this first take, but also a It's Live band version on the MDR channel coming tonight or tomorrow. They also got a reality travel show coming on the M2 yt channel.

[@litanosuke8905]

I enjoyed your reaction as always. I know you are the fan of them now.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Thank You Once Again For Watching!!!💯

[@tench1ttaphon1eecha1yapornku1]

Listening to WWY as a letter from their parents to their daughter, it sounded different. I feel that it is also meaningful for them to sing a letter from a parent to a child, as they are in the position of a child. In the behind-the-scenes of the MV, some of the members were seen in tears when they saw the video message from their parents as a surprise. Also, the scene at the beginning of the MV where Chisa calls out in the snowy mountains is a tribute to the film 'Love Letter', so the whole song feels like a love letter to a loved one far away. Anyway, thank you for your lovely reaction！

[@jeannipb]

Thank you for your love towards XG It’s heart warming

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Thank You For Watching💯

[@djvillan]

XG do sing live but this, like many other so called live singing channels is not 100% raw live vocals. Things like pitch, tone, and key correction, autotune, vocal filters, background vocals, studio recordings and live singing are combined and mastered in post production.

[@AsuraCloudwalker]

I agree with you. This live version made the song better; that ending was "chef's kiss". Also, admit it, bro; you love Christmas songs...🤣🤣🤣 Fun Facts: Cocona actually won a few contests for her singing prior to her rapping skills when she was younger.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

"Admit it, bro; you love Christmas songs"😂😂😂😂 Thank You For Watching I Really Appreciate It!!!💯

[@ThePeej]

Here’s the thing: this is undoubtedly a never-before-seen level of SUPER talent. They’re a super group. Future shit! But there’s also another layer here, in that the production team, the training, & the LIVE PRODUCTION is on some future shit too. There’s NO QUESTION they sang this live, and they were AMAZING. But there’s also some LIVE filtering / mixing & production happening that’s equally impressive. The flange on Harvey’s voice at 2:36 is really obvious. You can hear the dips in the end of each line. Their whole performance is live auto-tuned. THAT DOESN’T MAKE IT LESS IMPRESSIVE!!! It’s just that, without their entire production crew at the soundboard in the background, this performance doesn’t have the same feeling. If they showed up at an open mic night at a bar & plugged an iPhone in with a karaoke version of the track, they would still sound AMAZING, but it would sound different.

[@Keeeeeel]

JAKOPS is the fking goat

[@knkweb]

XG is super talented and gorgeous Angels!! 💕 First Take Performance in Japan!! 👏

[@love_laugh_troll1832]

I put XG in that Bruno Mars category. Where they sound better live than a radio version. I’ve seen enough live performances that’s puts them top tier. That’s my opinion. 🤷‍♂️

[@nana04120220]

i agree with you

[@Tiffii.official]

More XG reactions please! If you haven't yet, please check out XG Tape, Vox, and Move.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

HERE IS MY XG PLAYLIST: kzbin.info/aero/PLVMtPhorZIy2Lc-01oAjUVT3xVxAkkKUZ&si=JaybxTTWX89EoEXO

[@thewarrior5486]

These beyond talented ladies put in 5 years of blood, sweat and tears in competition to become XG. They were already on a high level as individual young girls before the competition, but the training they received from Simon and his crew just pushed these ladies into another galaxy. I HAVE SO MUCH RESPECT FOR THEM.

[@tobe4real]

I feel this, it is so crazy that even the main rappers can sing like this. I need this on download

[@tokyobento]

Since they’re experimenting with all these styles, I’d love to see and hear them do an original song in a cappella. I wonder if Cocona can beatbox.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

If They Start Beat Boxing I'm Going To Lose It! 😂😂😂

[@donnabachmann-bonnell8169]

Hi, thanks for watching this. They are wreckers! I loved your facial expression after your drive by comment-priceless! Merry Christmas, hope all goes well.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

😂😂 I Really Appreciate That!! Happy Holidays And Def Thank You For Watching!!!💯

[@Shaomander]

Hope you're ready for their world tour next year!

[@d.rrntoh]

I’m so excited for more XG ahhhhh 😭

[@Gumigee]

Yeah TGIF is my less favorite but it grew up on me. The dance practice for TGIF is also very nice. They sassy!

[@jonathanadajar6230]

We need a moment of silence after this reaction HAHAHAHHAHA SOOOOOO GOOOOODDD! 😂

[@SHIORIK]

Winter has came in Japan. Its got cold all the sudden and I wanted to listen to this song but instead of going to Spotify, I came to KZbin to watch reaction videos cause I wanted to share my feelings with someone at the same time. Ugh I love this song… あなたのリアクション大好きです🩵

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Thats dope I appreciate you vibing with me!!! Thank you for watching💯

[@ppswift]

xg has done like 3 live performances by now and the first take is my favorite one so far!

[@defmeta]

i just binged all your xg reactions. this version of WWY is my favourite song of theirs. and this is my favourite reaction of yours. peace and respect MI93!

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Yooo thank you!!!💯 I really appreciate that and yeah this version is 🔥🔥🔥

[@酔ってるなジジィ]

『XG』ちゃん達の底力を改めて知る素晴らしいコンテンツ… というか… 打ち込み等一切の妥協を許さない『XG』が最高…｡ﾟ(ﾟ´Д｀ﾟ)ﾟ｡

[@averageatbest8146]

I hear you on this bro. I prefer this version over the album version.

[@Xlr8UrL1f3]

Love your commentaries. More than just reactions.

[@BrettMurphynorthps]

You kill me every time with that drive by sing off lol.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

😂😂😂😂 Thank You Once Again For Watching And Joining The Live Stream!!!💯

[@riopato2009]

This hits so different and hurts a little.

[@savanah1436]

They were so amazing live! The only thing I missed were their runs in the OG song I would loved to have seen that performed live

[@QuintrellDemary]

There really good xg I’m a new fan 😊💕

[@joemac8834]

this song is different.. I heard it the day it released and was like wow my new favorite Xmas song. But after seeing this pop in my feed it might just be my fav song of 2023. Props to JAKOPS what a producer and these talented ladies ... just wow im sorry I missed them at Kcom this year... next time... cant wait to hear you do the other tracks...peace

[@xhentaisenpaix9977]

I love the support, rocking from NYC ALPHAZZZZ ✨️🐺✨️💕

[@mentosu_XG]

これは頭抱えますよね😂あなたのリアクションが好きです。XGのリアクションありがとうございます。

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

😂😂 Thank You For Watching!!💯

[@Taboodie_]

BEEN SSYING THIS!! I really want to here some solo music from cocona too

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Hopefully It'll Happen 1 Day!!! Thank You For Watching💯

[@jorgesantana1089]

We get it. 😂❤

[@ShaychanXG]

Please please please do VOX #5: XGLEE CLUB. The vocal line will sweep you off your feet.

[@pattydicarlo1811]

ALPHAZ ON DECK❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@runthecomics]

Madein93 - "...the ones that are the main singers, I wanna hear them rap." XG - May 21st....we got you!!

[@skycub99]

I always enjoy your reactions. You seem very genuine.

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

I Appreciate That Fr Thank You For Watching!!💯

[@JXFQ]

Thank you so much for your amazing reactions, you show up how all of us feel about them.

[@boja8975]

They came in w the early 90s Lisa left eye, mc lyte rap flow

[@RosieIsPink]

react to XGlee Club!!! the main vocalists cover dope songs!!!

[@JusDavN]

It's crazy to think that Cocona is doing all the low notes at 18 lol. This was solid

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Yeah That Actually Is Crazy 😂 Thank You For Watching💯

[@rachaelraejohn149]

WOKE UP , just try listen it ! 😊

[@kanakana8289]

私もリリースした原曲よりこちらのバージョンの方が好きでした♡彼女達のチャンネルのショート動画でアカペラバージョンを披露してます。彼女達の才能と努力は本当に素晴らしい。

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

Thank You For Watching!!💯

[@Mae_Annabelle]

2:32 we got a 93 sing-a-long 😂

[@MADEIN93REACTS]

😂😂😂😂😂 🤫🤫🤫 Don't Tell Nobody

[@tiekss7699]

@Mae_Annabelle Good catch 😂

[@FadeSao]

Taking turn with the drive-by sing off is pretty accurate 🤣

[@thewarrior5486]

New subscriber here because your style rocks bro.

[@takapjp-ll9kf]

Thank you for your reaction. Have you checked ASL Ver. and Practice Ver. of GRL GVNG? If not, please react to them😀 I decided to support XG as an ALPHAZ when I listened to ASL Ver. of GRL GVNG and was stunned by the choreography of Practice Ver. of GRL GVNG.

[@bekkazz_]

Welcome to the ALPHAZ ☺️

[@onyroo]

Now we got the three piece combo (Jurin, Cocona, Harvey) 😂😂😂

[@bekkazz_]

YOU NEED TO DO THE VOX TAPES

[@gaorinxin685]

XGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG

[@vrezo.k]

Maya soo fire ❤❤❤

[@nergizmn]

Please watch xg- grl gvng mv and full version

[@tobe4real]

“I shouldn’t be liking Christmas songs 🤣

[@sulena8823]

Same i want solo stuff from cocona but ill be patient 🥲

[@Jelijiro]

Please eact to xg mascara and tippye toes and movie # 1,2,3,4 And vox # 1,2,3,4,5😊

[@user-maghiro]

👍🔥🔥🔥☃️🎄

[@user-bb2ir7pj9h]

日本人です🇯🇵 海外からの評価高くてとても嬉しい🩷