移民家庭逼子女學中文不切實際！陶傑：華人以中文作為母語有幾多個發達？

[@yanshingwu1282]

到左今日，陶生同鮑sir 分析好準

[@V1VIVIV1]

雖然陶生同鮑生都仍然繼續講嘢，但始終同2位一齊唱雙簧係唔同；聽咗2位一齊笑看風雲咁多年，忽然劃上句號，有啲失落。any way，好鍾意你地，多謝。

[@cooper2871]

都不一定.我兒女在五歲和六歲來美,女孩仍能寫漂亮中文字.男孩能講不能寫,但他們都能說中(香港話)英.西,韓.日,入滕校.但全都嫁娶歐裔青年,很好！ I am bilingual-speaking chinese and English. I take this advantage and am able to take care of English or chinese speaking clients. Same as bilingual with Spanish and English professionals, we won't lose our job and have a great opportunity.

[@bettywong9114]

很欣賞你們主持的節目、會記着你們，祝你們前程似錦！

[@lionsherkh]

我訂商台重溫有多年 ， 原因是“光明頂” ， 現在走了兩位主持人 ， 明年唔駛旨意我會再續約 ！

[@chimak8332]

我都是

[@ninnolose7298]

Thank you Mr. To for years of infotainment. We will miss 光明頂. Enjoy your rest.

[@angelafong8771]

非常同意你們的想法！最緊要他/她們自己喜愛, 不能強求!

[@anniejardie]

致敬陶生，鮑生❤️

[@36993020]

我覺得學語言一定有好處，唔一定話個語言有直接好處不過學語言開發小朋友發展唔同觀念同想法。我自己為例，細個學中文但係一早移民英文係我主要生活語言，但係因為由細已經 bilingual，我去理解其他國家嘅文化同文法都容易掌握。我之後再學法文同日文易比其他單一母語嘅同學快。

[@cooper2871]

你都好叻啦.我來美三十多年.在这里讀書工作.会中文和廣東話.但有时執筆忘字.因為Bilingual,工作無憂.識埋西班牙文和韓文,所向定無敌,由其西语,

[@cwso7030]

因爲陶生心中有一個前設→勉強。😄

[@lamto2430]

@@cwso7030 、:"、:·-

[@jamieng892]

My son was born in Canada. He picked up Cantonese first even though he attended local child care when he was 2. He learned English and French after. He can speak and write English and French but he can't read Chinese. He picks up Catonese is because the whole family speaks cantonese and our relationship is much closer when we can speak the same language. There is advantage to learn second language but it is not necessarily have to be Chinese. I heard some kids that actually hate being Chinese because their parents forced them to learn.

[@myGiantPandaChinese]

谢谢分享 Thanks 👍

[@jadensmith4203]

完全唔同意!! 我有好多同學都係回流既, 佢地有D根本唔係響中國/香港/任何華人社會長大, 但係唔知咩理由, 佢地結果都返來香港重新讀書, 繼而希望可以留響香港工作, 當然而家佢地可能已經一早走左了, 因為香港已經唔係當日佢地唸既!!! 不過, 佢地係好睇唔起香港/香港人, 佢地成日以美國/加拿大人自居, 又一味以唔識中文為傲(唔係真係完全中文文盲, 否則大學都唔收啦), 所以華人如果唔識中文, 其實不論外國人同香港人/華人都會睇佢唔起, 你唔識中文, 就無可能識中華文化既, 唔好講到個個係衛奕信甘叻, 好多人不過爾爾!!!

[@支翠翠]

學華文咪盞中愛支病

[@LEUK999]

首先你要證明中華文化有幾好而令到人覺得可以引以為榮？

[@kmng0219]

最重要有💰傍身

[@k17sher]

Always true.

[@littletwinstar007]

移民家庭逼子女學中文咁奇怪, 如是為何呢班家長要增取小子女讀BAND 1學校, 讀英英中學等

[@LoveToBeFree8135]

聽兩位的光明頂至少十年，以後無得聽。😒

[@DevilErnest]

想小朋友識好大程度係父母自己情意結。老實講識中文又點，對佢有乜用，俾個小朋友融入外國社會仲好啦。

[@jackliu5269]

我仔女糸美國出世，都識廣東話，佢哋認為糸自身根源，而且怨我唔教台山話，因為我自己亦講台山話唔好。

[@jadensmith4203]

個人認為華人仔女如果唔識中文, 普遍都係唔會尊重返華人/華人身份既人, 所以識中文係第一步

[@SilverSilence002]

佢哋未必一定會以中華民族為中心嘅態度去尊重自己嘅民族。 通常都係以西方自由派 互相尊重為基礎嘅態度去睇自己嘅民族。

[@tingting377]

會尊重人，唔係因為識唔識中文，係睇佢個教育品德，尊重別人係禮貌，係個人修養，除非別人不尊重自己，你都唔洗理果個人

[@carolfok1475]

真人真話!

[@monicaw6247]

We live in California and my son was born here. He speaks English ( mother tongue), fluent French and broken Chinese ( he cant write Chinese ) and I think its absolutely ok. I can understand his Cantonese so thats all it matters.

[@chimak8332]

我二女兒都是英語為母語的。但廣東亦都非常好。但到孫仔那代就只是英文了

[@homehunter1854]

我只想佢地讀到金庸小說

[@babychocolate9550]

我肥我唔多運動，培養小朋友運動純粹為佢健康及培養興趣，本住自己唔夠健康，冇理由要仔女陪我一樣唔夠運動健康嘛～非虎媽要仔女拎獎

[@wongkellybibi2465]

真係好鐘意聽你哋嘅節目，分析超級透轍，香港有啲人直係好假，以前響香港見到明明一家人係香港人，但係專登講英文，咁樣係咪會高人一等？我兩個小朋友黎英國之前都係讀國際學校，但係我好坚持同佢地講廣東話😬，其實識講就可以

[@yvonlau]

香港人在英國辦中文學校 就可延續香港文化啦

[@rchung9408]

天真.

[@hinydrlee2274]

Learn Germany 🇩🇪 Russia 🇷🇺 Spain 🇪🇸

[@k17sher]

My 8-year-old daughter is BBC. We don’t actively teach or force her to learn Cantonese. Her first and only language is English.

[@黃耀弘-p6v]

港人移居他國就必須融入當地文化，請問香港殖民地文化有啥好留戀，當移民子弟代3代小孩已經把香港文化忘光了

[@kammykwok2888]

🙏❤️🙏 光明 頂 = 講 真 心 話 = 冇花 冇假 ⋯ 孔子學院 = 有 真 也 有 假 🙏❤️🙏

[@hinydrlee2274]

Learn Chinese must learn full version Chinese language please 🙏

[@HonkuenWong-x9t]

0:18 😅❤😅

[@leokong8988]

愚色盜, 天人合一, 中華文化博大精深 :)

[@chimak8332]

忘祖忘宗有誰理會你。群居朋友中只要什麼言語主要通話。聽陶生講英國全面。

[@sillyfillet]

唔單只路牌紅綠燈師承英國，我嚟咗英國頭一個禮拜已經發覺，原來香港人好多小動作表情都同英國人近似，呢樣嘢其他華人係無!

[@whli7988]

學中文係好煩嘅事，又簡體、又繁體;又互相排斥。唸中國歷史更煩，真假歷史難分，若干年後，當權者又推翻一切。相比之下，學習其它語文如日、韓、甚至泰、俄文都絶無此煩惱。故我決不會强要下一代學中文！

[@georgejack1744]

致各香港家長： 己所不欲, 勿施于兒

[@日本哥哥美國爸爸]

唔識中文點反共呀,唔係用英文反共

[@大馬仔-h8f]

有道理

[@k17sher]

I absolutely agree with 陶生. No need to force next generation to learn Chinese. I can’t even read and write Chinese properly myself after living in the UK for 28 years.

[@kennethx2]

Agree, but at least you need to learn how to speak, is good for you anyway to learn multi language

[@kennethx2]

其實大部份鍾意細路仔學中文嘅都係講虫国語嘅父母，我聽過有啲打算送細路仔返大陸讀小學初中，話打好數學根底喎

[@rchung9408]

見到香港BNOs走去英國 話叫香港仔女學廣東話 保留香港人文化就覺得好笑 而且香港變成咁 唔多唔少同香港人文化同廣東話好大關係 我係英國亦唔主動同香港裔同事聯絡....垃圾文化 唔學都無所謂

[@kmng0219]

有冇揸BNO的香港人會住武士橋呀？

[@hinydrlee2274]

Very expensive place . Hard to living there . Ha ha

[@wmwu2219]

鮑偉聰正宗慢打鑼的表表者

[@SunnieWoo]

睇吓呢一代嘅香港人講廣東話帶住重重嘅懶音就知香港人有幾尊重中文🙇🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️

[@moonmong4197]

😞 so sad!

[@Ginbaubabe]

End of a golden era. So9sad 😢

[@fannymak108]

發嗡風，中文，學到米學 lor, 為何咁主觀。。。 你覺得你的見解至叻咩？ 呸！ 做人有根好過冇根的觀念！ 自由言論！ 有時已好怕聽單打說話 係時候沒頂，都已無所謂！ 👍 思想太渺小！

[@sl9915]

苟延殘存

[@hkccp]

你係香港人就反攻中共啦，根本香港人只係鍾意食兩水，炒樓，扮嘢

[@kaiwahchan7487]

A

[@sdxyzmsCN]

聽咗2位一齊笑看風雲咁多年，忽然劃上句號，有啲失落。any way