Yamaha FS5 Review

[@kathyshortt353]

Hello Randy great review and I think it is over prices too and you make any guitar sound good!

[@randysrhythm]

You always make me smile, Ms Kathy 😁. Thank you, my friend 👍🏻

[@johnnyl1957]

Randy . . . nice upload Mate . . . . interesting and honest. Smile on my face as I read your intro. Always a big like Randy. FYI . . . . I am not sure if you are aware but as I watched and listened, no less than five advertisements interrupted your clip. I appreciate they are due to the length of the video, but five seemed OTT. Anywho . . . . again, enjoyed my ol' Friend. 😊 ☮ 🎼

[@randysrhythm]

Thanks John. I have yet to monetize the channel, so YT is in full control of the commercials. Maybe I need to monetize, so I can at least control the slots? Not sure how all that works. Always appreciate your kindness, my good friend 👍🏻

[@johnnyl1957]

Randy . . . . that 'BTW' was just for your information. I reckon why it occurs on your channel is because of your subscriptions and the length of your uploads. Having said that , I had a YT friend alert me to the same on my channel . . . . go figure! 🤷🏻‍♂ I suppose we all have to pay for the privilege of having our uploads shared to the world. It's the least of our problems. Cheers Randy, J 😊 ✌

[@bronzesnake7004]

Hey brother Randy! I agree 100% with your assessment related to "Here Comes The Sun" it's deceptivly difficult to play being a capo on 9th leaving sparce real estate for our manly fingers, but what took me the longest to work out was the bridge between every two verses as well as the outro. Sounds simple, but it's anything but! I have a sweet Yamaha FG 340 in very rare black which I absolutely love! I've had it for over twenty five years, and it was gifted to me by my wife's late uncle John, an absolute diamond who I sorely miss! Funny story - he came to the house to give me the guitar and would not take no for an answer! So, he foolishly told me he was going Newmarket, a mid sized (and growing) city South of our little lakeside town. So, with that handy info, I scooped up the guitar and case and drove to his house and left it in the door. Then we went out for dinner. When we returned, I opened the door and there it was!! Yamaha are an enigma, they build some of the finest acoustics and electrics such as the SG series which I LOVE, and yet they don't promote them! If they would put some effort into promotion we'd see all kinds of pro artists using and loving them on stage and in studio! I stupidly traded my first real acoustic, a Yamaha FG 365 S with a sweet air travel hard shell case when I was 15 or 16 for an electric which was so awesome that I can't recall what it was or what happened to it!! sigh They are difficult to find, especially mint or near mint examples, and are selling for as much as $2,000. That sweet axe is on my bucket list! Another great, informative and honest review brother!! Thank you! Jack ~'()'~

[@randysrhythm]

Hey Jack, great to hear from you. I guess that Yamaha was destined to be with you 😁. Great story and I really appreciate you sharing the story and the kind words, brother man. Hope you and yours are doing well, my friend 👍🏻

[@colinclement2752]

Its beauty is in its quality and craftsmanship. It doesn't need any fancy inlays. Such a nice sounding and playing instrument. I think if it had a different name on the headstock it would be a 2500$ plus guitar. Good review sir.

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you, Colin 👍🏻

[@turrafirmaguitarchannel]

Hi Randy, greetings from Sydney. I was here doing the washing up and stopped to come over and listen to your rendition of Fire and Rain. Beautifully played! Guitar sounds very nice too.

[@randysrhythm]

You are too kind, my friend. What’s your first name?

[@JasonMckellMusic]

Hey Randy great review man.. I love how honest you are about your experience.. I really feel you though because I feel exactly the same way with my Furch.. it's clearly a great guitar but just had some minor things which really left a sour taste in my mouth. My Yamaha tuners were always fine with staying in tune but they did go really rattly after a while and I changed them out for some Gotoh SXN510's (I think thats what they're called) like the FG9's come with. Beautiful playing btw I found myself drifting off just listening to some of that picking👌

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Jason, thank you for the kind words. Yes sir, sometimes a guitar just doesn’t hit you like you’d hoped for and this was one of those times for me. I know it irritated a few folks, because they told me 😂. But, sometimes it just is what it is. Very kind of you to take the time to check out the video and I really appreciate you sharing your experience, brother man 👍🏻

[@JasonMckellMusic]

@@randysrhythm It is what it is.. never a truer word spoken. I really think it's important to play any guitar before you buy it if you can. I would have put my Furch back on the wall in the "nice but not for me" pile if I had played it first and it's sounds like you feel the same. I remember playing two identical Martins years ago looking to buy.. one I wish I did buy it and the other just wasn't the same beast. I keep buying guitars online still though saying that.. I'll be looking forward to your next video man👍

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you, sir. Yes sir, I agree. Sometimes we just don’t form a bond with a guitar 👍🏻

[@jaepark8922]

Nice review Randy ! I wonder if you just got a bad sample. But it sounded very nice with your playing. So many people seem to rave about the FS5. I’d like to get a smaller guitar but not sure which one now. LS16 or LS16M, but FS3 or FS5 were also in the running. Or could just go for a Martin 000-28 or 000-18 or the OM versions. M36 also is interesting. My LL16D is so loud and clear. Different from my FGX3 for sure.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Jae, thanks for the kind words. I may have simply gotten a bad one. That said, that’s not what I expect from a Japanese made guitar. Between the bad set up and the lack of volume, I’m not a fan. As far as the guitars that you listed, the 000-18 would be the better built counterpart. Always appreciate you, brother man 👍🏻

[@graham1745]

Oh, man, some great picking there as always, sir…..👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🎸🇺🇸

[@randysrhythm]

You’re too kind, brother man, and thank you, sir 👍🏻

[@kanato.archery]

Yamaha FG5 is a beast! I play and test some Martins and Gibsons the same day I try FG5 and Yamaha beats all the others guitars and for half price!!!

[@randysrhythm]

@@kanato.archery Once they are setup properly, you are spot on. I’ve had mine for a while now and the sound is only getting better. I just wish they would put more time and effort into the setup from the factory, brother man 👍🏻

[@smandez2023]

I cannot justify paying $500 more for the FSX5. I first played the FSX5 and was smitten, one of the best guitars I’ve ever heard or played. When I say it can almost hold its own against Collings or even SCGC of comparable bodies and wood pairings, I mean it. The shop owner also agreed. Later I found an FSX3 at Guitar Center and, other than the fact that the FSX5 has a bone nut and saddle and comes with a hard case instead of a gig bag, there are no other differences I can see or hear. I will be making the purchase on a FSX3❤

[@randysrhythm]

I’m really glad to hear you’ve found one. In my case, I wish now that I had bought the 3 as well. Perhaps it wouldn’t have had as many issues. Either way, as irritated as I am with Yamaha right now, it is one sweet sounding guitar!

[@bruceharvey6986]

Nice to see another video from you Randy 👍 😀. Like your hat 👏👏👏👏

[@randysrhythm]

I like the hat more than the guitar 😂. Thanks, brother man 👍🏻

[@gavincarrollmusic7401]

Great guitars , I had the FS5 but swapped it for the FG5 both are great IMO but I would rather the FG version! You should check out the ll16 my friend they are amazing got me one 🇮🇪

[@Wobbz9413]

Amen.

[@randysrhythm]

Hey there Gavin! Great to hear from you and hope you and the family are well. I’ll see if I can find these 2 guitars and play them. I really appreciate the suggestions here, brother man 👍🏻

[@BOHEMIANHUNTINGCLUB]

Nice honest review Randy! Guitars are like everything else, you shouldn't really have to do anything to right out of the box for it to work well. You got it fixed nicely, sounded good there at the end. 👍😁

[@randysrhythm]

Great information, James and I agree. Thanks for being a constant supporter of the channel, brother man and the kind words 👍🏻

[@paulgeorgia8013]

Another great video, Brother man. Great playing, and very informative, as always!

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you, brother man Paul! Don’t forget, it’s fingerpicking Saturday 😁

[@MatthewCuda]

I prefer the LL16. Man that guitar is stunning. I will say that the atmosfeel Pickup system is one of the best in the world. It even has a sensor for percussive players.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Matthew, I came close to getting the X version. I've heard great things about it, brother man 👍

[@SongsFromTheRuaRoom]

Always liked Yamaha's (and I don't mean motorcycles) :) Great video again Randy

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Daithi, great to hear from you. It seems the older I get, the more I work. I know from watching your channel that you are suffering the same dilemma 😂. Hope the family are all well in Ireland and Belgium. I need to get back over and visit your channel, as I’ve noticed you have pulled in a ton of new talent in the studio. Always appreciate such a talented individual finding time to visit and provide encouragement. Thank you so much, brother man 👍🏻

[@KyleCastroTheDrummerBoy090613]

So beautiful performance my Dear friend Randy!! Love and respect Kyle!! 😊🥁🇵🇭

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you, my wee friend Kyle. Say hello for me to your parents 👍🏻

[@バイト戦士M]

Hello, comment from Japan. 😊Thank you for the great video. I'm having trouble deciding between the YAMAHA LS16, FS5, and the Recording King RO318. Which do you think is better? Is the FS a bit iffy?

[@randysrhythm]

Welcome Japan. If you’re looking for volume and clarity, it’s the 318. I hear good things about the LS16, but I’ve never played one. This FS5 didn’t impress me. There’s not a lot of volume and it had serious setup issues, which surprised me. At some point I’ll pick up the 16. I hope this helps.

[@バイト戦士M]

@@randysrhythm Thank you for the useful information, brother. Recording King has an agency in Japan and is now available for purchase. I will definitely consider buying a Recording King ^^ Next time I'll have to decide between the 328 and the 318 😂

[@JimmysBasementStudio]

Nice Review Randy!!! Sounded really good, Great Cowboy Hat !!! 🎸🎶

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you, brother man Jimmy 👍🏻

[@skadinkus419]

Nice review, Randy 🙂. Would appreciate your opinion on how this guitar compares to the Recording King RO-318. Thanks!

[@randysrhythm]

Hi skad, funny you should ask that, because I was just thinking this morning that the RO-318 is really a better guitar, if.. you can get it set up properly. The woods are much higher quality and the sound is pretty dadgum impressive. Great question, brother man and timely 👍🏻

[@xaviqueroblues]

Great performance, Randy!! Sounds really cool, my friend!🎸

[@randysrhythm]

Hey Xavi, great to hear from you. Appreciate the kind words, brother man 👍🏻

[@maldf4i]

I can't stand an acoustic guitar with the electronic control panel mounted on the side. It just seems wrong.

[@randysrhythm]

You and me both. Yamaha seems to do it less intrusively than others, but still makes me cringe a bit. I think the way Takamine does it, scares me the most. I’ve seen a few of those that, because of the guitar itself, I really wanted, but no way I was going to spend the cash for that risk. A hole in the side steered me away from Gibson’s G series. Appreciate the input, brother man 👍🏻

[@lindsaymix9522]

I have the FSX5. I totally agree as well. Bugs the heck out of me to look at. Went looking for one without electronics. Store had one with and sold it for the price without ($200 less) and I thought okay I’ll get used to it. But I can’t. Still a fantastic guitar to play.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Lindsay, it does have a beautiful tone 👍🏻

[@trevorhansbury]

Hi Randy, I just thought I'd drop by quickly as you may know I have very little spare time at the moment, but anyway its great to see you doing your review thing, I really like that fast finger picking piece you were playing at the start of the video, it was too short ha ha, anyway great review and wonderful playing, well done my friend 👏👏👏👏

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Trevor, thanks, my friend. Yes sir, I thought I’d speed that old hymn up a bit 😁. I’ll upload the whole of it at some point. During the chorus, you have to move up the fretboard several frets to a chord shape that I don’t know the name of 😂. Always appreciate you, brother man 👍🏻

[@JuusoHoo]

thanks 4 your honest thoughts!😂

[@randysrhythm]

You are most welcome, brother man 👍🏻 Appreciate you coming to visit.

[@FlowEckurt]

Wonderful performance !✨

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you 👍🏻

[@stevebernard221]

I like the FG series, but there are reasons why I haven't bought one...and I am a big Yamaha lover. For me, I go mainly for the dread body, and tend to stay away from smaller bodied guitars. The dread version of that guitar do sound pretty good (from both china and japan factories). But, I dont think they are worth the money. Not sure if yamaha changed it or not but I believe the pickguard is a regular black guard with a textured decal to mimic the wood look. I do love Yamaha, but my love is for the Luxury Line, the L-Series. I can't say I love the New FG9 either....its good, real good, but it gets away from Yamaha's usual build techniques and sound. A lot of people think the FG9 is the most expensive Yamaha, or their flagship model.....its not! Anyway, great vid Randy. All the best!

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Steve, great to hear from you. I would tend to agree with you about Yamaha. I think something has changed with those folks. This one just didn’t hit me like I wanted it to. I may give them another chance later on, but it may be a while. Hope you and yours are doing well, brother man 👍🏻

[@GuitarType01]

I own this guitar and love it. I use a separate fishman humbucker and get a decent sound from it. I also professionally installed a pin on the side of the neck to strap my guitar. I’m convinced this will be the last acoustic guitar I will own.

[@randysrhythm]

After having this guitar several months, I think I’ve nailed down why I wasn’t as impressed as I expected to be. The neck angle on mine escaped the factory with an issue. While I hate to spend more money on it, I’m going to. I’ll do an update afterwards, brother man 👍🏻

[@markhansen3111]

I just ordered one and am eager to get it. I considered the X version with the pickup system but shied away from it. Another review I came across found the tuners to be an issue too.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Mark, it's a conundrum of a guitar. It sounds beautiful, but the more deception in advertising I hear about, if true, the more disappointed I become. Regardless, it sounds great. It's lightweight and possesses a certain charm. Let me know, please, if the setup is, from wherever you're buying it from, is good, bad, or great. Japan has really disappointed me with their lack of attention to detail when it comes to that, brother man 👍

[@markhansen3111]

@@randysrhythm I ordered it from Sweetwater. It was more expensive from them but I thought it was worth the extra cost because Sweetwater service is good. I'll let you know what I think about it after checking it out.

[@markhansen3111]

@@randysrhythm Hi Randy. I received the guitar today and my first impression is very positive. It looks beautiful and sounds awesome. The setup right out of the box is very good. I ordered it from Sweetwater. So far it seems great.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Mark, I am extremely pleased to hear about the guitar and Sweetwater treating you right. Sounds like you're going to enjoy this one, brother man 👍

[@dada1952]

The tuners are just fine on this guitar. Tuners have basically zero to do with keeping a guitar in tune. The FS5 sounds fabulous finger picked IMO. In the hands of someone who has a delicate touch it is remarkably responsive. As far as the binding etc. Martin uses plastic, as does Gibson and a host of makers. The black binding looks classy as the whole guitar does in an understated manner. I have many high end acoustics and the FS5 is my daily go to guitar to play. An absolute joy.

[@randysrhythm]

Appreciate the information 👍🏻

[@davidbaillieul109]

@@dada1952 I just purchased a fgx3 that was sitting in the shop unsold for about a year. The original strings were dead, so.i replaced with EJ16. The open tuners needed some tension adjustment ( middle tuner screw backed off a hair on 2 of them ), and.petroluem jelly for lube. Took 15 min and saved a trip to the dealer.

[@TUBEORATER]

Cheap Cheap Cheap says the baby bird. Sooooo not impressed

[@TUBEORATER]

...because it's junk

[@davidbaillieul109]

I have owned an FS3 and a FG3. In my opinion, the FG3 was a cannon, and the FS3 was just ok. I actually found a Guild Westerly OM-120 that I liked much better than the FS3 for half the price.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi David, I’ve heard several folks compliment the 120. Glad you were able find it. The FG3 is on my list to play, so I much appreciate the heads up on that, brother man 👍🏻

[@MrPanetela]

In my teen years i concentrated on rock/country/ragtime/blues. requiring knowledge of notes on the fret board. then by chance, i realize, a capo at the 4th fret, allows the notes at the 5th(A, D, G, C, E, A) access to (G,C,E,A) which is the tuning for a Ukulele. except the 2 extra low strings allowed for extended chords. So every guitar has a built in Ukulele available at no extra cost. However, a mandolin, may look like a guitar but is tuned like a violin. so playing a guitar exactly like a mandolin isn't possible. At best one can only emulate them. Wow, really nice sound projecting from your FS.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Mr P, I just learned something. I had no idea that mandolins were tuned like a violin, so thanks for the information. Great to hear your thoughts on this, brother man 👍🏻

[@Calif5150]

Good Morning Randy 😎🎸, thought I'd share w you about what happened w this brand new Epiphone Hummingbird inspired by Gibson, I took your advice and took it to an excellent tech who's done pick up upgrades and set ups on my Les Pauls to have the action lowered, due to having to shave down the bone. Anyway, he took one look then showed me how the bridge actually had started coming off the guitar. I just bought this a few weeks ago I ya remember me. So henmade me a great deal to fix the bridge, and do the set up for me. He tells me this is something he's been seeing more and more of these things seperate way earlier than you might see them start to kinda come up off, and they need to be repaired, glued and reset. But the do this 20 or 30 years down the road, hot 6 weeks after I bought the guitar. He says Gibson, Taylor, Epiphone, all of them aren't taking the time to prep these surfaces properly before gluing the bridge, as like my guitar, there was alot of the finish that wasn't removed completely under the bridge, so they don't get a good adhesion. I got her back yesterday, feels pretty good, except I seem to get too much fret buzz on the 12th fret on the E and A strings. I'm not sure if the buzz, and it's in some other spots, I my playing, being still kinda of a beginner of acoustic player, and I'm not doing a proper press on the notes. You can get away w alot on an electric guitar that you can't on a acoustic. So we will see how it goes. Was gonna look up what measurements need to be, and measure my strings, but the guitar still sounds amazing. I've been practicing my finger picking, man it's tuff, and slow going...practice continues....loving the channel Randy😁🎸

[@randysrhythm]

I’m a bit sick over this. Would you mind looking at the soundhole sticker and letting me know what the 5th & 6th digits (from left to right) are? Forgive me if you’ve already told me, please. It will either read 15, or 23, and I just want to be double sure about what you have. It should also be an Orange label in the soundhole. I’ve never heard of a factory code 23 bridge lift before, so this would be very odd, if in fact it is 23. The fret buzz could be due to the truss rod adjustment. It could be a hair too tight. There are many videos out there on how to adjust the truss rod. Keep me posted, my friend. I hate recommending something and then someone gets a lemon. I really appreciate the kind words about the channel, brother man 👍🏻

[@Calif5150]

@randysrhythm Good Afternoon Randy, no worries, I love the guitar, I asked the Tech, who's great by the way, to set the action as low as possible without getting too low to not having clearance on all the frets. The guitar sounds amazing, and like I said, I still consider myself a beginner, even more so on Acoustic, and as I said you can get away w alot of things on an electric guitar that you can't on an acoustic, so we'll see, im sure there's a sweet spot in here to get the set up where it needs to be. If need be I can run it by the tech if need be, he's done great stuff on my electric guitars, and if he works on anything he will make it so you have what you want. As for the numbers you asked, yes Orange tag, and I'm glad I knew on the numbers to make sure it was some of the last still built in Indonesia, it's my understanding Epiphone has moved the production on these to China now. Numbers are 22102304359, so I guess it's a 23? It is the Orange tag, Top says Inspired by Gibson, then Hummingbird typed in on 1st line Then the serial # on the second line. Too bad you can't attach a photo on comments on KZbin. I did invest on a top of the line hard case, a plastic case at the recommendation of the tech, and a humidifier. I live in Denver, Colorado I'm at almost 6,000ft above sea level, and it tends to be very dry here. I wish I could attach a picture of this humidifier he said to use, it's a "Music Nomad", and it says to place it thru the middle of the sound hole on top of the strings. But it's width stretches the D and G strings, and I'm just concerned about the strings stretching, or messing up the Bridge? I read post after post people posted about sitting on the strings and if it would cause problems, bit Music Nomad has a channel here on KZbin where they show how to place the humidifier and claim its been used on 10,000 guitars w no problem. If you have a chance Randy, would you mind checking that Humidifier out, I'd like to hear your thoughts, and if it's OK to use, even if the guitar is in the case for Ling periods of time. The case I bought is a hard case, and plastic to protect the wood. Sorry that this post turned out so long. Thanks for everything your doing here.

[@turrafirmaguitarchannel]

It is a lot harder to apply finish to a top after the bridge is glued down. But you need the bare wood to make that bridge stay stuck. I wonder how they are doing it at the Epi factory in Indonesia?

[@randysrhythm]

@Calif5150 You might consider Humidipacks. Here’s a link below. reverb.com/item/31835918-d-addario-humidipak-automatic-humidity-control-system-for-guitar-pw-hpk-01? You definitely have the right Hummingbird, so my thoughts are that once you get it right, you’ll never let go of it, brother man 👍🏻

[@Calif5150]

@turrafirmaguitarchannel yeah your right in line with the Techs who worked on mine, they basically said same thing. They get pressed to get these things built quickly and are just gluing the bridges on top of some of the finish and don't get a good adhesion. They said they are seeing it on alot of guitars, even top tier models with Gibson, Martin, Epiphone, Taylor etc... They said this problem isn't usually seen until guitars are alot older. I'm still loving this guitar though man, it just sounds incredible. This dude I know wants to trade me his J45 for it, and keep telling him I'll think about it, but honestly this guitar is a keeper, and I haven't felt like that of any guitar ive owned in 20yrs. Being one of the last built in that Indonesia shop, I think she'll be a collectable one day.

[@jaepark8922]

Well against your good advice, I tried a FS5 at a local music shop where I started taking lessons. I was a bit shocked at how well it resonated, far better than my FGX3 with upgraded bone nut, saddle and ebony pins. I tried an Fsx3 there and it was like a smaller version of what I had. The FS5, seemed to be set up low which I like so I traded my Fgx3 for it and brought it home. I then realized that at the 12th fret, the strings were very high, I only played cowboy chords at the store, so I missed that. And adjusting the truss rod makes the height at the 1st fret too low. After thinking about it, I had another matching saddle (ordered from Yamaha, thicker than 3 series). I sanded it down to lower the string height and now it plays well. Nut is a little low making the height at the first fret lower than recommended but I can live with that. Anyway I can see what you are saying about some setup adjustments needed to make it work, it was disappointing to see how they let this guitar setup this way out the door. Now after some work, I’m very happy with the sound, I enjoy it more than my FGX3, every bit as loud too for a small body. 5 series are definitely a step up, in my mind based on this sample anyway. Thought I’d share that with you Randy 😊

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Jae, that’s exactly the issue mine had. It nearly ruined what should have been a great experience. Disappointing is an understatement as far as their setup policy, especially for a guitar company touting themselves to be reviving that 60’s vibe. You’re certainly right, sounds great, but a Chinese setup. Glad you got it fixed, brother man 👍🏻

[@jaepark8922]

@@randysrhythm it’s very odd as I had 4 other lower priced Chinese Yamaha and the setup was very good to excellent on all of them. Must be some first day apprentice teaching another first day apprentice how to set it up, in Japan no less. In Hamamatsu they probably focus on their L series, 26, 36, 56, FG9 and let the kids work on the 5 series.

[@randysrhythm]

You may be more right than you realize, brother man 😂

[@josephryan5396]

Hey Randy, thanks for the review. How do you think the fs5 compares to the epiphone masterbilts or other brands it the same price range.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Joseph, if you’re talking about the latest Chinese versions of Epiphones, such as the J-45 Banner, I don’t know. I think it’s a dice roll. They are similarly priced, so it’s a great question that I’d like to have an answer for. The Indonesian IBGs are killer and about half the price, so I’d say IBG for sure. I’m still waiting to hear an honest, non-sponsored review of the newest lineup from China. A great question and very much appreciate you reaching out. You are very welcome for the review, brother man 👍🏻

[@dcallan1]

The recording sounds excellent.I owned the FGX5 and that was a great guitar. Ultimately, not for me. What I didn't like about it, was the shorter scale and slightly tight string spacing. The tone and the pickup were really nice. Worth the money to me.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi David, the FG and LS/LL are on my list in the Yamaha lineup, so thanks for mentioning one of them. I certainly can’t argue about the sound. It was a lot more about how it arrived. That just sunk me, considering Yamaha are known for details. They were rookie mistakes that you would never expect from such a reputable company. Appreciate your insights and experience with the brand and you’re surely welcome at this fire anytime, brother man 👍🏻

[@virgilioalbarese2603]

Thank you so much Sir, for opening my mind in this special case. I was thinkin´ about buying one of theese. So after looking and listening your review, I´ll think it over and might buy a good old Martin instead....... thanks again from Souther Bavaria - Virgil

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Virgil, and thanks for the kind words. You're very welcome. Great to have someone from Southern Bavaria on the channel and looking forward to hearing more from you, brother man 👍

[@virgilioalbarese2603]

@@randysrhythm I'll do my very best Sir 🎶👍

[@bakisha111]

Hi, great demo. I have only one question. I've watched a lot of videos about this guitar and they all sound like it doesn't have enough bass. What do you think? Is there anything true or am I wrong?

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you for the kind words. It’s not got the bass that I was hoping for. However, the balance is pretty spot on. I’m just not a fan of this model. If I had it to do over again, I’d pick up a Gibson L-00 Original. Just yesterday I was at Norman’s Rare Guitars in LA and I played the higher end L-00, which has Rosewood back and sides. It had killer punch with a great bottom end. On my Community tab, you’ll see a pic of me playing that guitar. It took every ounce of discipline that I posses to walk out without it. You’re not wrong, brother man 👍🏻

[@bakisha111]

@@randysrhythm Thanks for the comprehensive answer. I wish you all the best.

[@randysrhythm]

Btw, I meant to say “Norman’s Rare Guitars” not Morman’s 😂

[@USNAVDC]

I don't know how it sounds in person but it sure records like a bigger guitar on the video. It sounds pretty great on the recording! Really surprising bass and sustain is really nice! It sounds better to me than you give it credit for.....

[@randysrhythm]

Got us a Navy man! Appreciate all you do, or have done. I agree with you on the sound, but there were a few things I detest with guitars over $1K. One is when they invest no time setting it up before it leaves the factory. If you like this guitar, you’ll probably like my next move with it. I plan to give it away on the channel. I hope to do it the week before Christmas. Due to shipping challenges, it’ll only be for US folks, brother man 👍🏻

[@bronzesnake7004]

Hey, again, brother Randy. Do you have recording software? If yes, how would you feel about adding acoustic to an original song I wrote recently? It has a distinct country flavour mixed with 70's style classic rock and I think you'll dig it. Right now I'm dealing with a health issue, but "I'll be better, doc, I'll be better as soon as I am able"! Take care brother!! Jack ~'()'~

[@randysrhythm]

Hey Jack, yes sir, I do have recording software and I would love to tackle that 👍🏻

[@bronzesnake7004]

@@randysrhythm Awesome brother. The health is improving! I'll get a ghost track to you over the next couple of weeks which you can use to familiarise and play around with. I'll also send lyric sheet and chords and you can go ahead and come up with anything that float your boat bro! It's a real simple song very straight forward country/rock chords you'd play in front of any campfire! This is gonna be what "we in the business" call "a hoot" ! LOL! Do you sing bro? If you wanna throw some harmonies in, feel free!! This is gonna be a lot of fun bro, I'm already excited!! I'll get something over to you as soon as I can bro!! Do you think we should hire security? You know, to keep the crazy hot chick action at bay? LOL! The only "hot chick" action I've had in several decades in an angry wife!! Jack ¬'()'¬

[@randysrhythm]

@bronzesnake7004 You and me both!

[@stevecroft5068]

Nice review as always Randy, I've been on the lookout for a 3 or 5 series Yamaha since they came out. Now this may be controversial, but I am pretty certain that both the 3 and 5 series guitars are made in China. Where they differ is that the 3 series are completely done in China, whereas they ship out the finished carcasses of some of these to Japan, where fretwork is done there, along with adding that fake Ebony pickguard on top of the original Black plastic one. They add a slightly wider bone saddle for better intonation, and a bone nut. They also give it a hard case, call it the 5 series and claim it's Japanese made and price accordingly. Personally I would get the 3 series and mod it up to a 5 myself. This kind of thing has been done before. The John Lennon reissue Casino's of late 90's-2000's were all made by Terada in Japan. Those fully finished carcasses were shipped to the USA where the electronics and hardware were added and the guitars were set up and sold with a little sticker on the back of the headstock stating"Assembled in the USA". They were basically Japanese, and still people think they were a US made reissue. Keep up the good work Randy👍

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Steve, you’re the second person to mention the factories to me and the pickguard. I suppose this marketing deception is common these days, as you say. I was disappointed in the QC, and now the deceptive marketing, more than anything else. Yamaha, I’m afraid, have become another highway cafe to me, in that you stop there to eat once, then put it on your list of places to never stop again. I detest misleading advertising. The guitar sounds good, but lying to your customers is simply evil. These guys got me once 😁. Always appreciate hearing your insights and appreciate you taking the time to share, brother man 👍🏻

[@blackmax222]

Great work Inspector Clouseou. Now what finger am I holding up? Could you please support the accusations you've implied. I own my own research and development company so I'd like to verify

[@randysrhythm]

@@blackmax222 @stevecroft5068 you’re up 👍🏻

[@JulieDeeAmber]

Howdy randy - sweet Cowboy boy !!! I wonder why you would not buy th guitar again? I mean it sounds pretty - for beginners maybe but you are far from that - you are a pro!!! I can understand that your expectacions are way bigger than this !!! but anyway it sounded lovely played by you !!!

[@randysrhythm]

You’re too kind, Ms Julie. It just wasn’t a guitar I bonded with. It happens from time to time. Always great seeing your smiling face, ma’am 👍🏻

[@dot1958]

It does sound good!

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you, Dot!

[@gordonwyper7324]

Sounds amazing that guitar ..

[@randysrhythm]

Thank you, Gordon

[@triples4good]

I have to say I totally agree with your review. I bought this exact guitar. I was hoping to be stoked about it, but ultimately just kind of disappointed overall. I’m really leaning toward selling it. For the price point, there are better options and for a little bit more cash the options area lot better. As always great review. God bless.

[@randysrhythm]

I think it looks like a 1960’s, but the vibe just isn’t there for you and I. I guess that’s what happens when your expectations are too high. I may have let the reviews taint my expectations a tad 😂. I did find another guitar company out of Canada recently called Mackenzie & Marr. I sure wish I’d have went there instead. After my disappointing purchase of the Yamaha, I found those guys. I was blown away. The prices were much better than Yamaha and the quality was just killer. Appreciate you sharing your experience with us, brother man 👍🏻

[@triples4good]

@@randysrhythm I know what you mean. I watched all the reviews and I’m sure that’s what caused me to over expect the build and quality of this guitar. I will definitely check out Mackenzie and Marr!

[@ramz118]

@@triples4good I had the same exact experience as you both...a couple of years ago, I bought a new Yamaha FS5 and a Martin 000-15m and compared them extensively for a few weeks before returning the FS5...influenced by the reviews, I kept tried to convince myself that I should like the FS5 more and was expecting to return the 15m, but in the end the Martin was just far more responsive, easier to play, more organic, sounded better with capo, etc....the FS5 sounded great strumming open chords with a pick, but it otherwise sounded a bit flat and dull, lacking proper high end especially when fingerpicking, felt much heavier, had various cosmetic blemishes and just felt like a blanket was wrapped over it despite having the pre-aged top. Glad to know I wasn't crazy as, at the time, there were no negative reviews, only praises, and I wasn't sure if I was making a mistake by returning it. The 000-15m is a lifer.

[@randysrhythm]

If you’re crazy, Steve, you now have company 😂

[@HayesTech]

I actually watched this one right after you made it and didn't leave a comment...lol.. As far as the sound goes, I think it's sounds great and I'm a huge fan of Yamaha guitars too. But since that is a new guitar, it may take a little time for it to open up. But honestly, over KZbin's audio compression (that's applied to all uploaded videos), it sounded good to me. Sorry it took so long for me to comment too. Had we not talked today, I would have completely forgot. Lol...

[@randysrhythm]

No worries and great observations. Always appreciate you, brother man 👍🏻

[@christopherwatkins9729]

G'Day Randy... Enjoyed your review with reservations ???? and... Cannot decide what your (possible) problem is ? THAT guitar in your hands is a 'Beauty' ! Compliments to your fingers ! 'Tone' is EVERYTHING with me and THAT guitar is just singing it's own sweet song... Own a range of Guitar models and styles, including a YAMAHA F310CEQ ... Golden Mahogany and Spruce Top with different Tone to yours... Love my guitar and would also love that guitar you have demonstrated... Nothing wrong with those tuners and suspect those strings just need "playing in" for a couple of hours over period of time ???? Binding ???? Some of my guitars are beautifully bound and some are simple or none at all... Randy... It's all about Tone and suggest a cuppa coffee and reconsideration could make you the happiest owner of that FS5 worldwide ! Price ? Mmmm... Am inclined to agree with you and would say value is approx US$1,000-00 ... but... quality and value are subjective variances to individuals... At the end of the day (?) "Pay up and smile" if you desire that particular guitar... (Show me two guitars the same ?? Have never seen or heard same yet, whether same Brands, Models etc)... Good Cheers ! 🤠

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Chris, you make a ton of great points. I suppose the guitar is good enough, but it just didn’t seem to measure up to the hype that I was hearing. You likely know how that can be sometimes. I really appreciate the polite way you put all of that 😁. You’re too kind, brother man 👍🏻

[@thekycoffeebean]

I will agree , she sounds better with a pick , seems like something is hold her back finger picked , maybe she will come around ? She is a good sounding guitar and has simple looks which there is nothing wrong with that. Now what comes in as you said the price , you can get a lot of guitar for $1500. but $1500 and she is not staying in tune , Yeah I can taste that bad taste ! Colonel I hope she comes around for you and we will see a video that she "Knocked Your Socks Off " , it just needed time !

[@randysrhythm]

Colonel Terry, great to hear from you. Yes sir, let’s hope I can get some of the issues solved, then maybe a bit of time to properly open up, and hopefully all will be right with the world, brother man 👍🏻 Always appreciate your feedback 👍🏻

[@Jgraytn]

Well, I thought it was just me until I heard your review. I usually bare finger pick, and I heard immediately that it was just not the quality sound that I have experienced with my other guitars. Fit and finish is extremely nice, but I was expecting a more full and satisfying sound for the price and all the hype about this Japanese made guitar. And the tuners disappointed me, as well. Like you, I would advise someone to consider other options at this price point or to save just a little more and go for a truly great guitar. I would definitely say this is one model you should play first before buying…I skipped this important step after hearing the raving reviews and talk of how under priced the FS5 and F5 are.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi J, I think you pretty much summed it up. Great analysis and while others may really like this FS5, I found it really dull for fingerstyle. Really great overtones when strummed in an open chord position, but unfortunately we do more than just open chords, brother man 👍🏻

[@custodialmark]

i started in summer of ' 68. broked leg layed up so mom bot used electric. no thing to do for months but play with myself. as said still do. hear me here or faced bookked. iv bot an gifted a dozen local used like this. cordoaba entry levels and a step up version only 400 most i paid since sfew 12 strings. i look for one like this maybe. sexteen hundred is a bit but what think i may be worth to intertain with better than ones we got at home i use. . thanz for info. i may have been led to it in store or online. i want a setting next to find gud one...

[@randysrhythm]

You’re most welcome. Appreciate the story and the feedback 👍🏻

[@LegsON]

Just started watching, Randy! Still wanna say I just got my Epiphone IGC SJ-200 and the tone is FANTASTIC, the BEST guitar I ever played. However, the neck is SO fat and round...

[@randysrhythm]

I’m going to be taking a hard look at that one. I don’t mind a fat neck. I think it’ll match my fat belly 👍🏻

[@Wobbz9413]

Nice guitar. But you should try an LL16. now THATS a nice guitar.

[@randysrhythm]

If I can find a used one that’s reasonably priced, it’s now on my list, brother man 👍🏻 Appreciate you, as always.

[@Wobbz9413]

. That guitar is the best sounding guitar youve ever had on your channel, by far. Still no LL16, but a damn fine guitar. I have heard about the tuners being bad on those. But it is not typical of yamaha. I have never owned a yammie with bad tuners, and Ive had a few.

[@LegsON]

I've played a couple of LL16 and didn't enjoy them at all. They were heavy, too tight. Guess the plastic nuts-saddles-pins, undersaddle trash and heavy tuners affect the tone so much. Fixing all of these issues would easily give a guitar +15-25% in tone. Glad you're loving yours though!

[@randysrhythm]

I’m not as sure about it being the best sounding guitar I’ve put up on the channel, but I certainly have no issues with you thinking that 😁. I like it well enough, but a ton of action issues right out of the case that was disappointing for me. It doesn’t make them all bad at all. I appreciate you mentioning the colour and I have now corrected that in the description. My wife’s biscuits always brown up nicely, so I made an improper assumption. Thanks again for such a detailed comment, brother man 👍🏻

[@Wobbz9413]

​​@@LegsONsorry your experience wasnt good with the LL16. I love them, and have never played a better guitar. The pickup is one of the best proprietary examples available in my opinion, but its an opinion, and yours obviously varies. Pick on my friend, we are indeed, spoilt for choice.

[@Wobbz9413]

​​@@randysrhythmcheers Randy. Our opinions may differ, and tastes obviously do, but I respect your honesty and your opinions, so thanks for the content and stay well my friend. Oh, and you are a finer player than I could ever dream of being, so yeah. Thanks mate.

[@randysrhythm]

@Wobbz9413 Absolutely, we are always a great, trusted relationship my friend, and I definitely respect any input from you. You are too kind about the fingerpicking, but it surely made me smile, brother man 👍🏻

[@ThePnikola007]

you've never sounded better. Cheers ;)

[@randysrhythm]

Very kind of you to say, brother man 👍🏻

[@myungmusic2383]

47^~~♡ Hello l subscribed have a good day 🛎 🎁

[@LegsON]

I played FG3, and my experience was similar! I was surprised with how vibrant the tone was, but it felt like the tone didn't have "meat". A bummer. Tuning machines are stylish, but the shafts are TOO HIGH. That robs the tone a little. Also, you won't be able to replace those machines without exposing the traces of the old machines. Bummer. And it just looks tooooo plain. No visual personality, unfortunately. I say that as a D-15 enjoyer!

[@randysrhythm]

Appreciate the additional information here about the tuners, Mr LO. I’m a little sad over all of this, but I’ll give them another chance. There have been some great suggestions for other versions of Yamaha that I’ll likely pick up at some point. Sometimes you just get one that doesn’t like you 😂. Great and useful input, brother man 👍🏻

[@grooooved]

As if you needed another reason to love that guitar - that's no rosewood pickguard. It's a plain black pickguard covered with some sort of sticker. Peels right off. Crazy. Between that and the tuners, it reminds me of Gibson goin sideways in the Norlin era. ie Why?! Haha. Cheers!

[@randysrhythm]

For a minute there, I thought I was on this island alone, so thanks for shipwrecking with me. You’re the second person that’s mentioned the pickguard to me. I’ll check that out today. Appreciate you, brother man 👍🏻

[@grooooved]

@@randysrhythm I peeled mine off and wrapped the truss rod cover with a piece of it as I didn't care for the retro look cover on this guitar. Works great for that application. Much better look to me. Haha I love the guitar and agree with your thoughts on strumming. I consider it my 000-Dred as I use it if I want a smaller body while I'm jammin with others. Best part of mine is that I got it new for 500 shipped - it had a slight crack around the nut from shipping to the dealer, but nothing a lil fish glue and a clamp or two quickly rectified! I'm a deal seeker - "penny saved, penny earned" type guy. My 000's stay home next to my chair for the most part. Got less than 2 grand total in both of em - one a 000C-16 and one a standard 000-18. Wooohoooo

[@randysrhythm]

I’m a huge fan of the 000-18. Great collection, brother man 👍🏻

[@TUBEORATER]

Bone nut and saddle? Sounds pretty average. Anything outstanding?

[@randysrhythm]

Yes sir, they are bone. I’d say the volume is impressive, but for me that’s about it.

[@danaeverhart6487]

Hey Ol’ friend and dearest brother! Just stoped in to say how great 👍🏻 that intro was!! Hope you are well. Come by and see us sometime. Sounding great to me, peace and love and support . Hope to see ya 👋🏻 Dana E💫👽☮️✌🏻

[@randysrhythm]

Brother man Dana! Great to hear from you. I need to get over to see you. Business travels have been rather busy lately, so haven’t spent as much time tubing. Hope you and Ms Dana are doing well, my friend 👍🏻

[@TUBEORATER]

Buzz o matic.

[@andysfishingandflytyingcha2310]

Thanks Randy. For $400 more than the Excellente it should have been better. No excuse for tuners not being top draw at that price. Could be a 20% guitar.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Andy, yes sir, it was a bit of a letdown. I’ll tinker around with it for a while and see what happens. Appreciate you, brother man 👍🏻

[@jantomasowe4562]

You keep repeating yourself forever about some disappointments that never became clear to me other than with the tuners that you think makes it go out tune.

[@randysrhythm]

@@jantomasowe4562 Point taken. The guitar sounds very good, but the was it arrived was nearly unplayable. I could have driven a truck through the twelfth fret, strings vs fretboard. The trussrod has very little impact on the neck. It doesn’t appear to me that the guitar was given any QC attention from the factory. Hope that clears it up and appreciate your candor 👍🏻

[@michaeldonaghey]

You need a Yamaha LS 36.

[@randysrhythm]

Hi Michael, Mitch Malloy, former vocalist for Great White, suggested the 36 to me a few weeks ago. I should have listened to him. I’ll try to pick one up, brother man 👍🏻

[@multipipi1234]

Beginner guitar was a bit of a shock statement. Its pricey. My beginner guitar made my fingers bleed.

[@randysrhythm]

😂 okay, you made a great point. I’m afraid my disappointment overshadowed my common sense. You did make me laugh when I read this, brother man 👍🏻

[@multipipi1234]

And pianos