“You’re Using It As A Platform For Propaganda” | James Whale Ends Interview With Palestinian Author

Sir Keir Starmer battled to maintain Labour discipline with members of his front bench in open revolt about his stance on the Israel-Hamas conflict.
The Labour leader has resisted pressure from within his own party to call for a ceasefire, instead urging both parties in the conflict to agree to a humanitarian pause to allow aid in and people out of the war zone.
TalkTV’s James Whale clashes with Palestinian author Ghada Karmi over the Hamas massacre.
James: "Let's stop this interview. You're just using it as a platform for propaganda."
#talktv #talkradio #israel #hamas #palestine #gaza

[@zubairhussain888]

Dumb and dumber here are an embarrassment to UK journalism, however it'sown standards have absolutely gone rock bottom during this recent massacre.

[@mogznwaz]

And you are completely neutral are you? I don’t think so. If you don’t like British journalism you are at liberty to not watch, read or live around it.

[@zubairhussain888]

@@mogznwaz Every time I hear that argument, for some reason it sounds dumber. The "if you don't like the system, move" argument demonstrates limited understanding of the fact that it's the democratic right and responsibility of its citizens to protest and speak out to improve its system. These two are a comedy duo.

[@jean2740]

And the locusts taking over our !°land

[@jean2740]

​@@mogznwaztrue there not British anyways

[@Woop-fy5nk]

Agreed. Those two are just clowns

[@harrycallahan9143]

Appalling interview.

[@judydavis9770]

If he would shut up and stop interrupting, she might be able to say something

[@ilan_NahshOn]

She lies. 1- Only Israel let Palestinians work permit.Egypt block permanently Gaza. 2- Hamas deliberately attacked civilians and kidnapped!! Civilians.. I can go on

[@RvtQe]

This is disgusting and purely evil. Cant believe how these two adults acting like five years old brats and disrespecting this lady. But one good thing happened in the interview though. We found h Out how disgusting the two adults are. Thanks for exposing them

[@danielaharon9961]

They've just had enough with pro Palis morally bankrupt rhetoric, and I can quite frankly understand them.

[@empower.1982]

I agree 100% there like 2 petulant 5 year old bullies, clowns

[@annamariana8140]

​@@danielaharon9961 any wonder why the world is against u now? I think your moral compass is faulty or maybe you never had one

[@danielaharon9961]

@@annamariana8140I understand your desire to see yourself as the world, but it doesn't work that way. Some people agree with me, and some will agree with you (probably more, understandably, given how many Jews there are in the world comparing to Muslims). and it doesn't matter anyways - having more people on your side doesn't make your side right.

[@annamariana8140]

@@danielaharon9961 btw in case you missed while still hibernating inside, the Pope has even branded you people as terrorist.

[@jamshedykhan]

To be honest, I used to believe that Indian talk shows were the only ones lacking ethics, manners, decency, and maturity. However, after watching these British shows, I'm utterly speechless and frustrated by the low quality and bizarre behavior of the hosts.

[@mohdalimat1502]

Spot on brother. It's simply irritating to have your talking continuously disrupted by the these two idiots.

[@mogznwaz]

And you two are obviously not biased in any way. True British patriots, right?

[@AA_Rait]

BTW india was occupied by the British terror who converted India to an example of scams and no ethics

[@jean2740]

Are you kidding cos he doesn't agree with your views ??

[@jamshedykhan]

@@jean2740 its not about my views! Its about the host's views.

[@GodIsInHisHeaven]

I actually really wanted to hear her thoughts, good or bad. Shame once again James and sidekick ruins an interview for everyone.

[@guntersg]

This was so hard to watch. Whether you agree or disagree with the interviewees perspective, let her finish a sentence. They just kept badgering and interrupting her and their high handedness was loathsome.

[@VoiceOfThe]

💯 Terrible interviewing. I was genuinely wanting to hear her reasons for the justification but she was not allowed to finish her sentences before being interrupted. Farcical!

[@captsonko.9345]

U know they know that there is nonsense in what these hamas propagandist talk, just yap things they don't understand, that's why they aren't given much time.

[@guntersg]

@@captsonko.9345 The way I see it is if you invite someone on, listen to what they have to say. You don't have to agree but give them an opportunity to get their point across.

[@captsonko.9345]

@@guntersg depends on what they say .

[@guntersg]

@@captsonko.9345 Agreed, but give them a chance to say it.

[@tillyt4054]

Patronizing old bint excusing murderers

[@millwallholdings]

Think she will be in hell soon enough

[@tillyt4054]

@@millwallholdings I hope so 👍

[@tomgallagher7870]

Think james hit the nail on the head when he said how would u like someone coming into your country and killing u..oh wait it did happen it was 1948.but lets forget about that.prick

[@tillyt4054]

@@tomgallagher7870 There was no Palestine before 1988 so that would be a bit difficult

[@fleetingmoments]

So you justify babies being mass murdered in Gaza? 4000 and counting?

[@kimhaslam664]

She was right in her first sentence: she doesn’t have the words to condemn Hamas.

[@deficrypto1234]

Its not balanced to ask people to condemn Hamas when they dont condemn Israel. Israel killed 20k people in Lebanon. Do u condemn it?

[@patthewoodboy]

@@deficrypto1234 I condemn all violence , never chose a side in a conflict like this.

[@sharonreichter2537]

Let's have a bit more information about that. @@deficrypto1234

[@user-fq8rs7rz3i]

She certainly does have words. They include supporting’Hamarse’. 🇬🇧🇮🇱

[@deficrypto1234]

@@user-fq8rs7rz3i Stop lying. When did she make any statement supporting Hamas?

[@revdwendy1019]

James Whale is appalling here - diabolical as an interviewer not allowing your guest to explain.

[@ispy3836]

Explain?

[@fairhall001]

The whole point of this interview is that she had nothing to add but propaganda.

[@revdwendy1019]

@@fairhall001 she had no propaganda - he wouldn’t let her speak it is the Israeli victim narrative that is propaganda. Clearly Mossad knew of the “attack” - it gives them Carte Blanche to commit the evil genocide the world is now witnessing - Israel is clamping down on its ethnic cleaning operation

[@fleetingmoments]

@@ispy3836the whole point of a debate is letting another get their point across.

[@lucabriatore7891]

He's a bully

[@talatsajawal3133]

Why does he keep interrupting her! Let her have her say, this is a disgusting way to conduct an interview!

[@grahamgreatorix2124]

It's not an interview, it's an interrogation. They're in the wrong job - if you can call what they do is a job

[@mogznwaz]

I notice anyone with a Muslim sounding KZbin name has an issue with any challenge to Hamas propaganda. Funny that.

[@MAC-mp2hu]

You should let her speak whether or not you agree with it or not. I think James Whale likes the sound of his own voice too much

[@jean2740]

And it's a nice decent English vouce

[@husseinshuaibu3560]

He could loose his job if he let her speak the truth. Saving himself by interruptions😅😅

[@SeanT649]

Are they doing something under the table or why so close ??At the start i thought one of them was a puppet.After watching i realise that a puppet would have conducted a better interview .These two are completely useless at interviewing its that simple .

[@shauntownsend55]

😂😂 spot on

[@Imana23]

Could not finish watching. He just can’t stop. He has to be his own guest and host.

[@IanTula]

Lol...that's funny...but true!

[@ahmedgulaid4108]

😂😂😂

[@Petal4822]

This woman talked in circles.

[@empower.1982]

She wasn't allowed to talk, ​@@Petal4822

[@IrfanAli-qp1gm]

James Whale should start by first condemning himself. What a scumbag.

[@racerx3667]

lol he is like a james bond villain

[@jamesmulvey1386]

Very witty from the xxxxxxx who can xxxxxx to non believers.

[@nirmalsandhu5256]

He is an utter waste of space

[@faywarnock2311]

Just found this. I am absolutely horrified! What an explicit example of disrespect to a learned scholar. Blatant silencing attempts by dumb and dumber. The first interviewer clearly had no intention of listening to anything other than his own voice. It was also clearly obvious that he lacked intellectual capability to engage in critical discussion with Dr. Karmi. Why bully and humiliate the person you are interviewing.? Dr. Karmi, I am so very sorry that you were treated so badly. There are more reputable sources that the public can turn to gain an in-depth and informed understanding.

[@SvendBosanvovski]

Then first time I hit on this channel I thought it was the Comedy Hour with two well made hand puppet's mimicking Statler and Waldorf. But they seem to take themselves seriously.

[@danielaharon9961]

They've just had enough with pro Palis morally bankrupt rhetoric, and I can quite frankly understand them.

[@mogznwaz]

Learned scholar? 🤣🤣🤣

[@grahamgreatorix2124]

@@mogznwaz far more than you alas

[@mariammaulidi3088]

Rubbish 😮

[@chrisbanks5925]

There is no historical justification for what Hamas did on October 7th.

[@Earl-Dumarest]

quite right .skirting the issue, this frightful woman is as slippery as they get.

[@ransertu7630]

What did Hamas do?

[@FDCAFOK]

They were following instructions from their prophet.

[@britishbulldog50]

@@ransertu7630You being serious ?.

[@ransertu7630]

@@britishbulldog50 I've been through a lot of the available footage and worst I have seen is Hamas shooting civilian cars up as they rode into town. Have you heard of the Baghdad Thunder Run? Do you think Hamas just needed better PR or a cooler name for the ingress? Maybe I'm missing some evidence that would convince me why genocide is an appropriate response.

[@johnpatmos1722]

He doesn't give her any opportunity to speak.

[@dreamtshirt]

James Whales interview method leaves a lot to be desired. He constantly interrupted and didn’t allow the speaker to voice her opinion in a measured way.

[@jakesummers2206]

I see logic in those person, If your under military occupation for 75 years, how would you react? When they steal your home kill your parents and put you in a open air prison, what you think people will do, deaf dumb and Blind

[@banares6880]

Totally agree with you can't handle the truth shame on you James and Ash

[@barnabywild2215]

His "style", for want of a better word, has always been that of a bully. Whale always takes the safe, populist side, which is always the least pleasant, and then just browbeats the guest with his views, never letting them answer a question lest it undermines his stance. It's basically a TV version of the beginning bit of a bullfight where the yobs get to stab the bull with lances from behind the safety of a pen before the main event. Whales is at the lower end of mob entertainment. Sadly the days of proper unbiased news, interviewing, and reporting are long gone. Even the BBC reports are subtly worded in favour of the perceived narrative. We're deliberately kept ignorant of world events by these clowns.

[@Balenza345]

She wasn't measured. Her whole narrative is based on propaganda. No surprise really. She stated at 2:22 that "hamas did not perform that operation" which was a direct reference to Oct 7th. JW rightly stopped her in her tracks and didn't allow her to spread her vile propaganda.

[@IanTula]

Ya he's very hard to listen too! Even if I'm agreeable on the subject he's not good at making it look favorable!

[@rarecockneyguvnor4945]

she won't condemn Hamas because Hamas are Guilty

[@beastman.330]

Do you condemn the killing of Palestinians by isrealis ?

[@jakesummers2206]

Blaming one side and failed to acknowledge the other side, deaf dumb and Blind

[@joycegibbs5267]

and they never accept they're wrong.

[@SpiritOfStyx]

@@beastman.330 what should Israel’s response have been to 1400 innocent people, including women, children and babies, being murdered by Hamas terrorists who then scurried away back to their tunnels in Gaza? What would the correct response have been in your eyes? If they didn’t respond at all, do you not think Hamas, Hezbollah, PLA etc would be emboldened to commit worse atrocities on an ever more consistent basis? Clearly there had to be a response from Israel and it was always going to be severe, as much as I never want to see a single innocent person die on any side of a conflict. You have to be realistic here - any country in the world would respond in the same way to this kind of attack.

[@rarecockneyguvnor4945]

Exactly right.@@joycegibbs5267

[@bannon1000]

She is right. It was not an interview but a diatribe from the interviewer

[@Jesusdisciples27]

I can’t believe those two blokes are allowed on the television

[@thomasbaader6629]

It's normal in an interview that you're asked questions, right?

[@Jesusdisciples27]

@@thomasbaader6629 it’s normal to allow your guests to answer

[@stanleylewis2819]

I see this woman no less than my mother,the disrespect.These punks need to be dealt with!

[@ianwatson5605]

Fortunately James Whale hasn't got long to go.....he is gutter journalism at its best.

[@Alhena-wp6vj]

And that’s just fucking evil!

[@jean2740]

Wow cos he has an opinion of his own wow how disturbed some people are

[@londonsburningup]

Notice how he keeps asking for her personal views so he can block any truths! This is not about personal views! Im disgusted in the disrespect shown to this lady . James whale has no place to speak on this tragedy neither do 99 percent of the talk radio so called journalists.

[@thereanimator926]

She said that calling for Jihad in the London marches was a good thing 🤪

[@Bonnatella]

Intimidation and fear is all they know. It doesn't get anything accomplished.

[@Balenza345]

She wasn't measured. Her whole narrative is based on propaganda. No surprise really. She stated at 2:22 that "hamas did not perform that operation" which was a direct reference to Oct 7th. JW rightly stopped her in her tracks and didn't allow her to spread her vile propaganda.

[@rogerwilkie8555]

Watching James unveiled and out ratio’d says it all. He bows out when he’s called out. He doesn’t have any fundamental understanding of the situation and it shows. He’s like a big child that doesn’t want to play anymore when it shows he’s losing.

[@vanessanda]

They need to stop attacking her and putting words in her mouth, and allow her to speak!!! I want to hear what she has to say!!! Journalists should be unbiased! Disgraceful, two men against one woman! bullies!!!!

[@user-fc8pl4ej4u]

Attacking her rubbish. She is spouting history as if it makes the 7 October justifiable. She has a hate for Israel

[@MargaretAnderson-ti1sw]

She didn't say anything. Repeated over and over nothing at all. Where'd they find her?

[@multi-purposebiped7419]

Did you see two men? I didn't.

[@katedenisow-qb8vc]

​@@MargaretAnderson-ti1swyou right, he wanted just simple answer but was getting only usual propaganda

[@barnabywild2215]

I think this is the first time I've ever seen James Whale and 'journalist' in the same sentence.

[@rod7139]

Are these two guys modern day Abbott and Costelos? They are surely Comedians?

[@rueessop4345]

How absolutely rude. I'm shocked with the behaviour of the interviewer...

[@Nadinenoodle]

No one is denying the horrors of October 7th, however it does not justify the sexism and harassment toward a woman living in a war zone. They are completely unprofessional

[@user-gw4fo2xf2o]

What really does one expect from TalkTV / James W? Churchill said "I Disapprove of What You Say, But I Will Defend to the Death Your Right to Say It" I see James is from the echo-chamber school of journalism..

[@KCC1956]

Really, is that a woman?

[@BirkeLaFolle]

Is Britain a war zone?

[@obsidiancurse429]

I don’t think she is phoning in from Gaza mate 🤣

[@rogerwilkie8555]

Watching James unveiled and out ratio’d on his own platform says it all. He bows out when he’s called out.

[@najjararchitects3541]

These nastg guys don't let her speak .. so why asking here? Do they really think the audience so stupid not to see that ! Bravo brave Lady !

[@ismailbomogao5565]

True audience like us are seeing their stupidity.

[@robcandiani6355]

Shes a true muslim,oh boy😢

[@angelaconner3131]

This woman is an embarrassment. My goodness.

[@deficrypto1234]

How? These fools wouldnt even let her speak.

[@gavriel121]

​@@deficrypto1234To hear her say what exactly? Dumb terrorist apologies and nerrative shifting?

[@deficrypto1234]

@@gavriel121 Its best not to assume, hey? I will go based on what she said. Gahrda Kharmi is an expert and she has always been true to the historic and academic record, something that scares the living daylight out of proponenets of zionism and Israel.

[@millwallholdings]

@@deficrypto1234 "Expert" 🤣🤣🤣 The old fossill

[@gavriel121]

@@deficrypto1234 Lets speak history then and not palestinien lies.. Was there a 2 state solution in 48? Yes or no? Yes, so guess who didnt want the solution and satrted a war and lost? Exatly the palestiniens so that means 75 years ago its all started because of them. And then it happened again at 67 same old story. So dont give me rubbish. The palestinien people are eternal victims who cant seem to win wars and cry to the whole world about their plight that they themselves created. They get billions of dollars for aid worldwide that goes to the pocket of the leaders they elected. They should get no aid until they would change the view of the world like someone owe them something. Pathetic

[@mohammedjamil6669]

Wow , the double standards stink . Let the lady spark the truth you devils

[@roblloyd1879]

She ignores the horrors that were perpetrated on Israel by Hamas which has its base in Palestine. If the Palestinians are not prepared to deal with Hamas then the Israelis have to to protect their citizens.

[@357XPHusky]

Tell us about the horrors Israel has done on the Palestinians over the last 40 odd years.

[@usmanbinaffan8405]

​@@357XPHuskyvery well said

[@357XPHusky]

@@FaceFcuk Not Israel. Tells me you know nothing about the history of the conflict.

[@JaEDLanc]

@@357XPHuskyno, YOU tell US!

[@deficrypto1234]

She isnt ignoring it. Stop lying. She given u the true historical context. Israel started this problem when they expelled Palestenians and never let them back. U dont know the history. U know the propaganda.

[@bossdeman]

She is such a funny woman and showed these two stooges their true colors. She was trying to speak but the they ganged up on her...

[@mummyd1990]

It is a great comedy show 😂😂😂😄😄

[@danrobinson5444]

Shame on the Arab world for not adopting the Gazan people by opening the borders and providing Jars of Honey, Baskets of Fruit, Branches of Figs and Olives for the people. Mercy is shown by accepting the Gazans into the land of Egypt.

[@deficrypto1234]

Y should they open the borders when Israel put them under siege?

[@Roughpaws_Studio]

The Arab nations aren't taking them in because the Palestinian people over several decades have pissed most of them off, especially Jordan and Egypt.

[@mikel7544]

Thousands of Gazans crossed over into Israel every day to work and provide for their families. Hundreds of trucks entered Gaza every week from Israel, carrying goods. Hundreds of Gazans and Arabs from the West Bank crossed over into Israel every week to be treated in Israeli hospitals. Israeli volunteers meet them at the border and take them to hospitals and help them to be processed, and drive them back. One of the hostages held in Gaza is such a volunteer.

[@deficrypto1234]

@@mikel7544 So? Thousands of Brits go to American for medical treatment. Wats ur point?

[@millwallholdings]

@@deficrypto1234 No they dont Fake news

[@KausarBegum-gh4tv]

No respect how to let a woman have her say but kept on interrupting her.

[@AndyDavisTechnicalDiving]

Pointless women

[@stevieg4949]

IDF took 6 hours to report the Hamas attacks - there is too much fishy going on, did they want the attack to go maximum to have a reason to commit genocide? (ALso who is that long haired dude needs to relax himself)

[@ronmurray5112]

Dont agree with anything she says, however, wouldn't let her speak,

[@ss-xy2im]

It's true Israel closed it in 2007 after leaving in 2005 and the gazains sent in many suicide bombers, what else do you expect? Open it more to allow more? What do you think Hamas tried to achieve now, do you believe they actually thought it will make life easier for the palastinians? They never cared about the Palastinians and neither does anyone who supports them.

[@deficrypto1234]

Israel is still the occuping power in Gaza. Thats the expert opinion of Yoran Dinstein, Israels leading International law expert. y hasnt Israel defined its borders with Gaza? Especially with Hamas accepting the 67 borders? Israel had put in the siege before the suicide bobers. Stop lying. Hamas was able to get the whole of Gaza militants observing a ceasfire for a year. Israel refused to lift the siege and kept assasinating Hamas militants. So Hamas dsefended itself. Who has ever fought on behalf of the Palestenians? No one except Hamas. This is all Israels fault.

[@woowah32]

Yep, people forget this. They had a chance and f**ked it up. I’m no Sherlock Holmes but it might be because they’re terrorists…🤔

[@coltaylordyath5180]

People like this cherry pick the facts (and hope that most people are too young to remember or don't do independent research). Also, this does NOT go back to 1948. The Jewish people settled in Israel thousands of years ago, before Islam was even a thing. They merely reclaimed what was theirs.

[@celectial]

Exactly. And archeology proves this.

[@salahrasheed2324]

This woman is highly respectful and Wiles needs a harsh person to deal with his offensive way of discussion

[@jean2740]

Makes a change though

[@benjiwaterside]

Regardless of anyone's view on this matter, this is an preposterous manner in which to conduct a televised interview. Had to turn it off, simply unbearable to watch

[@greenlight4412]

This was an interrogation not an interview.

[@btet19]

If Britain was at war with Isreal or Palestine. These people protesting on uk streets for Isreal and Palestine .Who would you fight for during that conflict .Bearing in mind most of these people will be British citizens .Theres your problem ie briging in people from all parts of the world .That want to live get the benefit of these great isles .Then show no affinity to Britain whatsoever.

[@biffabacon1203]

Bearing in mind the police force were instructed to bring in multi cultural officers..would those officers be professional or sympathetic to religious conflict.

[@TTTT-oc4eb]

She was angry and hostile even before the interview began. The Palestinians have horrible spokes(wo)men, they are all the same; extremely angry, aggressive, hostile and loudmothed and constantly interrupting. They think they win an argument by intimidating their opponent.

[@rajarsi6438]

Tawriyya, kitman, muruna and hiyal are common practise for muslims.

[@deficrypto1234]

Y shouldnt she be angry? PEOPLE ARE DYING!

[@theinngu5560]

@@deficrypto1234 if you are angry you cannot help and bring peace. Firstly people need to let go of their anger and righteousness and desire for revenge…on both sides. Finger pointing, blame and anger cannot coexist with peace in the mind.

[@deficrypto1234]

@@theinngu5560 Nonsense! People go angry to war and it led to peace. Revenge and anger are two different emotions. If ur not angry that innocents were killed, ur heartless.

[@keepingitreal618]

​@@deficrypto1234😂

[@annar99]

She was talking about blockade but had no mentioning nor connecting this to the election of hamas who started smuggling weapons into gaza. Nor she said no word it was done by Egypt as well.

[@jakesummers2206]

I see you have no logic. If Ukraine has the right to resist why can't Palestinian have the same right? Or is it because one is white blue eyes and blond and other is simply Arabs.

[@annar99]

@@jakesummers2206 these two wars are very different. Ukraine didn't send rockets, didn't commit atrocities nor terror attacks against Russia. Russia is just trying to expand its borders to become imperia. Israel is one who defends itself. It didn't start the war, it answered it. Hamas attacked and hamas holds hostages which Israelis trying to free. Hamas also is shielding itself by own people. I heard today that hamas officials said it's not their task to protect civilians, it's on UN. Do you see the difference?

[@annar99]

@@jakesummers2206 BTW, I don't have blue eyes either. I can also ask the same question all these Palestinians supporters. Why there is no huge outcry when Ukrainians are being killed by Russians? There are tens of thousands casualties which were killed on purpose. 70 thousands of kidnapped kids. 10 millions displaced. Where are they to try to stop Russia, going against China, Iran, North Korea for its support? Is it because these people are not Arabs?

[@dellaird9160]

True, the Muslim ‘brotherhood’ are the instigators of hamaSS.

[@osamaelnagar2558]

@@annar99 this your logic ? make your researsh before you talk its annoying .This is Asralie propaganda Palestinian under occuption since 57 years this didnt start in oct 7 before you talk put your self in their shoes if another country occupied your land puting you in abig cage they killed your family your friend they cut water gaz food how you think they will react ? they will be cool with Asraiel ? check history before you talk see how many Palestinian killed by Israel since 1948 you the one who put jewish peoble in gaz chambir not us .

[@derekaccount9183]

Would have been interesting to hear what the woman was saying instead of james whale saying stuff she never mentioned! Typical journalist.

[@garrymcfadden4105]

I agree

[@pamelagaull3928]

James Whale loves and admires himself so much he doesn’t listen to anyone. I usually make a point of avoiding him.

[@fleetingmoments]

I’d use the word “journalist” very loosely in this context. This level of journalism is poorer than poor.

[@barnabywild2215]

Journalist? Shurely shome mishtake?

[@myarose5809]

These interviewers were painfully bad… she barely got a full sentence out!

[@andrewdudson7750]

The Jewish people were living in Israel before the Quran was even written,after what the Palestinians did to the Lebanon and Jurdon, that woman is a spokesperson for Hamas

[@johhny711]

Yes but not the ones that came from Brooklyn last week and not the ones who displaced 700,000 Arabs in 1948 .

[@kinganarkzie]

DNA tests have shown that the indigenous Palestinian population of Jews, Christians and Muslims, are all the same racial group. In other words the Palestinians are the original Jewish race. What's happened is that they converted to other religions over the years, which would make sense when you consider the crusades and Jihads that took place in the area. To what extent European and North African Jewish people are related I don't know but they are heavily mixed with the locals in those areas.

[@danwaterman4003]

Andrew, there are 80 million Irish living abroad. Would those 80 million Irish be allowed to return to Ireland? There are 80 million Italians living outside Italy scattered like the Irish. Are they allowed to return to Italy? Would Britain allow the Romans to return to England? In case you do not like someone, doesn't necessarily mean you should accuse them of being a Hamas. Ghada is 85 years old, she is a professor and has been living in the UK all her life, a doctor and an academic. Grow up!

[@eyetrackerru]

I am on Israel side of this conflict, but it is not a good way to take interview. She had no time to answer at all and was interrupted, and the host was expressing his own thoughts, and not listening to the guest.

[@VoiceOfThe]

💯

[@Lana98714]

This kind of interviews are very short. There is no time for same stories what we already know. There is question, answer it with few sentences without long preambles. It’s not really difficult if you have your own point of view.

[@eyetrackerru]

@@Lana98714 Short is OK. But good interviewer should lead a dialogue, not monologue. E.g. I would ask: OK, please, tell me what goal was those great fighters for freedom going to achieve? What freedom can be achieved by burning people alive? Etc.

[@theinngu5560]

Let’s have a march for peace with no flags, no chants for one side or another but only speeches for peace and respects for the dead, the hostages, the suffering and those in fear , without any finger pointing and blame. A march where there is kindness only.

[@btet19]

No let's just deport all the cowards protesting .Why come to the uk and protest about other countries wars .I assume these people have been or are British citizens .Some of whom fled gaza and have been given asylum and granted British citizenship .Because they were to cowardly to protest their cause in Isreal /Palestine .This is the uk its not our problem .Those protests show that those people given citizenship here have no affinity to these isles .Other than they can use it t

[@nightowl7459]

@Theinngu Just not going to happen, some don't want peace, they would only hijack the march.

[@millwallholdings]

🤣🤣🤣

[@woowah32]

Sorry, lovely sentiment and all but you need to live in the real world.

[@woowah32]

@@millwallholdings 😂This was going to be my reply but I genuinely felt sorry for them..🤦🏻‍♂️🙄

[@wolfy789]

Why are Gazans in a 'cage'? They launched rockets into Israel, after Israel withdrew from Gaza unilaterally in 2005!

[@dellaird9160]

When the ‘Wall’ was built, the terrorist attacks declined sharply, so strange that Israel protecting its people, is condemned... An idea so good, the Saudis copied it, for the same reason, to keep terrorists out of its country..

[@nadakbar]

Wrong

[@Jesusdisciples27]

Wrong

[@JenepherDEEPLAL]

Israel put up wire fencing to protect their lands.

[@IrfanAli-qp1gm]

Wrong

[@kenwatts6867]

They're not in a cage, they have Egypt one side and the Mediterranean on another

[@johnwebber750]

Remember the Flotilla? Nobody but Israel can use the sea there.

[@zubairhussain888]

Tell me youre too lazy to Google without telling me too lazy to Google basic facts

[@ransertu7630]

The baldie was extremely annoying. His impatience made him interrupt the interruption of the interruption. Then that made him more impatient and angry

[@Anigmama]

She didn’t say it wasn’t Hamas. She didn’t say it was ok to kill children. She didn’t say killing was ok. She didn’t get to say anything. Because Whale likes the sound of his own voice.

[@TheHauntedKiwi]

James Whale on the other hand, said he agreed with genocide.

[@Jesusdisciples27]

So true

[@mikerb3572]

Nice one

[@brightrose9405]

Listen again She did say it was Hamas

[@ItsNotRealLife]

She didn't answer the question eirher

[@VoiceOfThe]

You need to let her speak and stop interrupting her. I wanted to hear her speak and try to justify what’s happened and you wouldn’t stop interrupting her.

[@ianwatson5605]

WELL SAID Ghadi Karmi .....She held her dignity together professionally, unlike these 2 oafs.

[@vivpace7049]

How can he totally disregard all Israel has done to Gazans for 6 decades. Palestine had no right to defend themselves?

[@user-ns8py8by1x]

Whaler, you were shown up , mate. The lady with dignity refused to be your dancing monkey.

[@thewizeguide9128]

Terrible biased journalism

[@evielynekali4377]

I appreciate how patient she is to talk with these 2 idiots!!

[@barnabywild2215]

True. They're teamed up because the producer thinks they may be able to produce at least one brain cell between them. He was wrong.

[@marina12345678911000]

Hearing her helps to imagine what 'innocent' Palestinian Arabs in the Gaza strip might look like.

[@nospamallowed4890]

If you wanted a complete history you'd have to go back to the days of the Romans when they renamed Judea as Palestine precisely to take away the identity of the jews. Then move forwards to the early 20th century when there were mainly jews in what is now Israel/Palestine and the British imported middle-eastern moslems to work in their oil export businesses. Then the end of WW2 and the British relinquishing their colony and in an act of fairness divided it between the then main inhabitants (jews and moslems) into what became Israel and Palestine. From there on... it's been a matter of Palestinians trying to invade Israel and getting beaten, until they became occupied. And they kept at it until today, triggering the need for walls and other defenses, plus retaliatory strikes. Always Palestinians blamed it on a terror group or another, never trying to eliminate those terror groups themselves. Time and again Israel tried to find a peaceful solution and give Palestine an independent state and every time they were close the Palestinians would back out or have their pet terrorists launch an assault to derail the negotiations. The best deal they had was the one that Arafat turned down, and since then their options have been gradually shrinking. Frankly, it is no surprise that the Israelis no longer trust them and have zero interest in a negotiated solution... as the Palestinians never once kept their word. And now that the Palestinians face the end of their pet terrorists for good, they panic and make all kinds of "human rights" claims that have little credibility since the only numbers and reporting comes from the terrorists and their supporters. We used to fall for their sad stories but we are now fully aware that they are nothing but disinformation campaigns spready by monsters that on Oct 7 were even dancing on the streets and passing candy while their pet terrorists slaughtered thousands of men, women and children and committed horrible atrocities. They behaved so bad and gave themselves such a terrible reputation that NONE of their moslem "brothers" is willing to grant any of them asylum, not even women and children. Sorry, but it is hard to have any sympathy por people like these.

[@rani40757]

This

[@draftin68]

Today conflic israel and palestina is a comodity for some powerful contries, Afraid that no peace in the coming days

[@IrfanAli-qp1gm]

Hamas is a militant group but it is going too far to call them terrorists. Most of the first PMs of Israel were terrorists as per the British Govts of the time.

[@texasuncle1500]

ur history knowledge started from Romans when it actually began way before

[@lucabriatore7891]

Very biased, dude!

[@giovanni8304]

The two interviewers are continuously interrupting her and not letting her complete her thoughts. These guys are completely useless.

[@deficrypto1234]

Cos she was about to unleash the truth.

[@ududy22]

"Yes, please tell us what in your sick opinion justifies the targeted slaughter, torture, rape and kidnapping of more than a 1,000 non combatants"

[@ianmerrill5279]

Why does Whales bother to invite guests and then just talk over them ? Weird

[@gavinlevy1693]

I am surprised she didn't bring out her Hamas membership card.

[@woowah32]

Yep, she might as well have done.

[@Jesusdisciples27]

The both of them are brainwashed and not qualified to talk to her 😮

[@HOPELESSALICE]

the only 1 brainwashed here its the palestinian that seeking for obliterate an other country so pls

[@ezerma1]

Craps! She justified Nazis Arabs were killing jews way before 1948 not only in Israel but also in Arab cou tries in Iraq, Morroci, Algiria, Yemen, Egypt and the list is continues.

[@javaidramzan]

I am utterly appalled at the way this interview was conducted. The interviewer purported to ask questions with a pro-Israel bias including having a pro-Israeli guest who intermittently was badgering the guest. She was asked questions and then repeatedly interrupted by the interviewer who prevented her from answering the question as she wished and was entitled to. I have never seen such a biased and disrespectful interview, what a shame. Is this how low journalism has got to. Not interested in the relevant history to the war whilst plugging what the Jewish guest had said previously.Truly appalled.

[@aixaharris6630]

I feel the same way, first these two gentlemen are so unprofessional and disrespectful to this lovely lady. They are practically on top of each other, were they sitting on the same chair. They ask questions and put words into the guest answer. they are both discussing.

[@fleetingmoments]

They are no journalists. Poor excuses for journalists, that’s all.

[@charleyblack6796]

People are bored of those terrorists talking points she was repeating.. People are not stupid. Mankind has benefited nothing from you arabs, but somehow you think you're the smartest.

[@user-ls7ud3ic5x]

I am in hysterics - please tell me that was not a genuine interview - this was seriously comical ! These two blokes just yelling at this poor lady whilst she tried to give her point of view and then not letting her say anything unless she agreed with them - No wonder she was laughing at the end 😂😂😂 absolutely hilarious !

[@paulmilburn1537]

100% "Answer the question!" Lady answers, gets interrupted, "answer the question!" beheaded babies, "answer the question!" Lady answers "Beheaded babies, r**e M****er, "ANSWER THE QUESTION!" And on......................................... WTF?

[@Jesusdisciples27]

And she still managed to own them with ease 😂😂

[@loulou69star]

Yeah, she owned them with stuttering, uh,uh, uhs and no proper answers. Dread to think what you actually constitute an answer. She knew full well what the question was and chose to ignore it. Those blokes are pillocks but she was just dumb 😢

[@denniswijmer4988]

Quite a normal interview. Reporters looking for truth. Want to know her opinion on some serious subjects. She avoids the answers. Makes the interview into a sherade.

[@alandraper7901]

Although I am totally against what happened on the 7th of October, Nor against Israel's retaliation. James Whale was completely out of order with this woman. He did not, 'Take her down' he bullied her and then ended the interview when she was trying to answer the question he asked. She had already said she didn't support the Hamas attrocities. He needs to get HIS act together. The other guy was just anger on starting blocks. Bullying an old woman is disgusting and that is exactly what it was.

[@tweetenoe]

Just let her speak. I don‘t agree with her, but they way this interview was conducted was very rude and disrespectful

[@constantinvaldor3742]

It hurts Israel as well. They can't defend Israel because they're scared. If they wasn't scared they would let her talk

[@sardork]

those guys forgetting about more than 25 000 days of killings of civilians in Palestine and only remember 1 day tragedy? What about genocide that's been going on more than 3 weeks now? you cannot blame hamas and massacre civilians who are under your occupation. you are responsible for people under your regime. Disgusting to see that

[@AribunMiah]

Poor woman

[@suhailobaji3940]

The behavior of those two men treating an old lady like that speaks volume regardless on which side of the conflict you are, it is pathetic. This behavior reflects the deterioration of our values and our ethics at West😢😢😢

[@thomasbaader6629]

I disagree. They asked questions, which is normal in an interview. The old not-lady hat problems answering thses questions.

[@ObiePaddles]

Whatever happens elsewhere the protest and threats in London and elsewhere is unacceptable.

[@ocean77359]

Please do not allow demented people like these. Their words will only inflame other foolish people.

[@captsonko.9345]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@efree3462]

you refer to the host, right? i agree he no longer knows how to converse and take turns

[@Jesusdisciples27]

Yeah he’s referring to the host, non stop butting in and refusing to listen to reason

[@tomster1414]

These people are so different to us , you would have to be daft not to see it . And we have millions in the uk that think like her

[@mohammedshafiullah4110]

James, can you stop acting like a clown and interrupt your guests when they talk about the root cause of conflict - the Israeli apartheid?

[@janpetersen7440]

Are the 'idiots' interviewed by Talk TV randomly chosen or are they actually handpicked. If handpicked then a bad choice with the lady here.

[@simonsaphire]

I don't agree with this woman but she was treated badly here. Come on guys you can do better.

[@jangeerbostan5893]

The interviewer is a complete nonsense and is spurting out propaganda. He is not accepting any alternative view

[@PaulCowcher]

Hamas are Palestinians!

[@SD-rn1fn]

What about the NHS doctor what was he doing operating under a false name ?

[@robertturner6530]

the problem is they living in the past

[@johnwebber750]

So isn't it Israel that invokes a 5,000 year past?

[@user-xe6yv7kc2u]

2 male bafoons

[@davidcrosier2761]

Whale is possibly the worst interviewer around in the UK. And that's saying something...

[@cindyd.554]

You ma'am have history wrong, the land has always belonged to Jewish people, and been Israel since then, get it straight and you won't have to fight for cr@p you are selling.

[@deficrypto1234]

Dats a lie. it belonged to the Cannanites first. Israel didnt exist from 70CE to 1948. Stop lying.

[@tilly.....editssssss8056]

​@@deficrypto1234And who were they? Canaan is the name for Israel

[@valeriegrimshaw1365]

She couldn't say anything else or they'd kill her....

[@afroasialines364]

Bad words that I know are simply not good enough to misbehave abuse the host of this show.

[@sonofednawelthorpe8609]

All this time and she’s said absolutely nothing. She’s just spouting propaganda. She’s wasted everyone’s time including her own.

[@VoiceOfThe]

He kept interrupting her and wouldn’t let her speak!

[@user-dv3rb6nl4c]

@@VoiceOfTheshe wasn’t debating she was spouting Hamas talking points.

[@nadakbar]

She was trying to give you a history lesson which you obviously missed

[@user-dv3rb6nl4c]

@@nadakbar Here is the history lesson, there is no such place as Palestine, where is their prime minister, president. education secretary, foreign minister, health secretary, currency and banks.

[@nadakbar]

you proved my point, you do indeed not know history. Have a quick Google

[@HughJason]

Bullying.

[@willow666able]

She dragged it out as best she could. They attempt to brush away the actions of Hamas.

[@andrewm7945]

Richard Herring's let himself go.

[@alwalaniabdo1983]

Say what we want or we will finish the interview, it feels like I am watching a Russian or Belarusian show

[@johnwebber750]

Now you know it can happen anywhere...

[@sueedwards9334]

Good to see who the apologists for slaughter of innocents are. Gaza has had no Israeli government since 2005, and the other Arab countries aren’t doing anything. He could have asked her about why the other Arab countries don’t support Hamas.

[@benachiesween]

That these two thugs are given airtime with a national broadcaster indicates how low our democracy has fallen.

[@mohammediklaqkhan4046]

This is the current state of british journalism. What a joke

[@DM-vq8ux]

They should listen to her even if they don’t agree. Such bad manners 😮