Yugioh World Champion Rates Famous Magic Cards | Staple or Stinker ft.

  Рет қаралды 81,691

Cardmarket - Magic

Cardmarket - Magic

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 289
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic 7 күн бұрын
Want to see a real, competitive deck with Tibalt? bit.ly/488D5uf (plus a couple of decks with Thalia/Lurrus)
@Abdojtj
@Abdojtj 7 күн бұрын
suggestion for a future video, as a sort of variation on staple or stinker. make non magic players guess if cards are real or fake, showing them magic cards with wierd rules text on them, and fake cards with the same.
@pervertesacker7131
@pervertesacker7131 7 күн бұрын
@@Abdojtj I like the idea, but I'd rather see it in a format with maybe younger magic players or magic players that do not have encyclopaedic knowledge. The reason is that I do think if you show weird/fake magic cards to non-magic-players it would be a coin flip each and every time whether they guess it right. With Staple/Stinker they can at least somehow try to evaluate if a card is good based on their limited understanding of the game + hints that the team give them. There's no way one could try to make sense of weird cards enough to tell them apart from fake ones.
@Abdojtj
@Abdojtj 7 күн бұрын
​@@pervertesacker7131 that sounds awesome too
@tomaszchmura9246
@tomaszchmura9246 3 күн бұрын
I'm honestly surprised that no one tried Tibalt with Madness. Perhaps I'm too new to MtG, but it would seem like the obvious direction to me.
@Abdojtj
@Abdojtj 3 күн бұрын
@@tomaszchmura9246 lots of people did. randomly discarding is bad, really bad, so bad that the only playable card with the effect is literally a 1 mana tutor for anything.
@SkylarPastor
@SkylarPastor 7 күн бұрын
it's so funny that without the context of previous Planeswalkers, Tibalt just so obviously seems terrible 🤣
@Falterfire
@Falterfire 7 күн бұрын
To be fair, part of the reason Tibalt was so highly valued was an overcorrection from how often actually good planeswalkers seemed obviously terrible based on just the card text. For example Elspeth, Knight Errant looks incredibly underwhelming but was a Modern staple for several years. At the time Tibalt came out, you could pretty safely guess based on just the card type Planeswalker that a card would probably at least be relevant to Standard even if it didn't end up in the absolute best decks in the format.
@SkylarPastor
@SkylarPastor 7 күн бұрын
@Falterfire so like... without the context of previous Planeswalkers? :p
@Falterfire
@Falterfire 7 күн бұрын
@@SkylarPastor My point is that without context, I think *most* Planeswalkers 'obviously seem terrible'.
@MrSyltphademus
@MrSyltphademus 7 күн бұрын
​@@Falterfire As a reminder, many pros though Jace, the Mindsculptor would not see play because you could just play Jace Beleren
@caseykiesling4348
@caseykiesling4348 7 күн бұрын
I feel like tibalt would be a staple if it just looted with its +1 the random part is rough
@JohnFromAccounting
@JohnFromAccounting 7 күн бұрын
A nice piece of trivia on Lurrus is that it was one of the few cards to get BANNED in vintage. As it turns out, having an extra card in your hand that you can cast with Black Lotus, and then immediately use to recast Black Lotus, was too strong. Lurrus was so broken that it made Black Lotus, the best card ever, even stronger.
@SyntheticNuclear
@SyntheticNuclear 7 күн бұрын
It was banned because you only needed one. Limiting it to one per deck would do nothing
@neldar1075
@neldar1075 7 күн бұрын
I like the statement that when Wizards released companions, before their nerf, Lurrus was a card of about the same power level as P9.
@veryblocky
@veryblocky 7 күн бұрын
It isn’t, it’s not even restricted in vintage. EDIT: I’ve just looked it up, it was unbanned after the change to cost 3 to add it to hand
@SyntheticNuclear
@SyntheticNuclear 7 күн бұрын
@@veryblocky it used to be banned
@seandun7083
@seandun7083 7 күн бұрын
​@@veryblockyit was banned, then they changed the companion mechanic. Previously you could cast then directly from your sideboard. Now you first need to pay 3 to move them to your hand. Literally doubling the cost did a lot to dampen how utterly broken it was, though it's still good enough to get banned in Modern *and* Legacy.
@jamesaditya5254
@jamesaditya5254 7 күн бұрын
As someone who's rather new to Magic, the idea of Planeswalker is a very flavorful concept. Loyalty is so aptly named, losing some when they take damage because you (the player) choose not to block for them and if they reach 0 Loyalty from taking damage they basically go "peace out, jackass. I'm done with this". Effects that accumulates loyalty for them are like their signature cantrips so you're letting them do their thing, and ultimates are exactly that, an exertion of their mana that will more than likely render them unable to continue fighting but provides a boon for an ally Planeswalker. I think the only slight flavor fail is they are represented as counters in game, so effects that interact with counters like proliferate or doubling season will also affect loyalty counters and the only reason it does is "game mechanics" with not much flavor behind it. But that's just a minor nitpick to what would have been a 10/10 design
@Futuristic271
@Futuristic271 4 күн бұрын
I think it's not too bad of a flavor fail because I see proliferating as increasing the potency of boons or banes on things on the field, so proliferating a +1/+1 counter is further increasing the effectiveness of the buff, so proliferating an allied Planeswalker could be seen as boosting their strength as well. Not totally on theme with the name of the counter but buffing your friend will make them more willing and able to fight for you
@rheawelsh4142
@rheawelsh4142 17 сағат бұрын
The actual flavoring of card types with magic and how they play into different fantasies is one of my favorite bits of the game, sagas and classes also do a really good job at this
@friesen_m
@friesen_m 7 күн бұрын
Want to see Staple or Stinker 2:Combo edition, where its 2 or more cards and see if the combo is staple or stinker. Examples include Faithless Looting + Sneaky Snacker or Karn Lock
@cataleptickraken3197
@cataleptickraken3197 6 күн бұрын
i'd show lantern of insight + codex shredder
@henke37
@henke37 5 күн бұрын
And of course the classic Donate + Illusions of Grandeur combo
@askmeagain43
@askmeagain43 Күн бұрын
Harmless offering + anything that eventually causes it's controller to lose the game
@MathisGries-ml5qv
@MathisGries-ml5qv 7 күн бұрын
I love this series! Another good idea would be cards that have seemingly BIG build-your-deck-around-this effects, like Scapeshift, Genesis Wave, Warp World, Dragon Storm, Ignite Memories, Eye of Ugin, and then ask the guest if this seems competitively viable.
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic 7 күн бұрын
This would require too much magic knowledge to answer. Most of these would only be answerable if they got to know the other cards that exist in magic. But it's a fun idea if it was possible :)
@MathisGries-ml5qv
@MathisGries-ml5qv 7 күн бұрын
@@CardmarketMagic Fair point, it probably *would* be too difficult to estimate
@VCV95
@VCV95 7 күн бұрын
​@@CardmarketMagicdo a 4 way versus series with build around meme decks! That could be hilarious, especially depending on hosts/guests!
@seandun7083
@seandun7083 7 күн бұрын
Doomsday!
@maxastro
@maxastro 7 күн бұрын
Without a lot of context about the game it would be really hard to understand why like, Genesis Wave is okay but not great but Scapeshift is crazy good.
@igappai2638
@igappai2638 7 күн бұрын
Now we 100% need a MTG showmatch between 2 winners of Staple or Stinker!
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic 7 күн бұрын
That's a really fun idea! :D
@RoxyGotMoxy.
@RoxyGotMoxy. 7 күн бұрын
@@CardmarketMagic oooh or two people who have won Staple or Stinker, looking through and picking a few magic cards each from MTG's history and testing each OTHER on Staples or Stinkers. Just let two kids loose in the candy store and see what they pick to come back with. Could have a stipulation that they have to pick 3 staples and 2 stinkers, and have them try to make it difficult for each other, like, one picks Necropolis Regent and the other picks Huntmaster of the Fells, one picks Black Sun's Zenith, the other picks Killing Wave etc.
@joedoe7572
@joedoe7572 7 күн бұрын
​@@CardmarketMagicYou should get them to build their own decks and play against each other. It would be great to see what they could come up with!
@ovrava
@ovrava 5 күн бұрын
@@CardmarketMagic give both of them a bunch of cards, and let them build their decks.
@chasm9557
@chasm9557 5 күн бұрын
@@CardmarketMagic Have them play two games: one with only staples and one with only stinkers.
@sh41
@sh41 7 күн бұрын
Nice reasonings, it's very tricky to evaluate companion without knowing that it was erratated
@timw9745
@timw9745 7 күн бұрын
Yeah and he was right but didn’t why. But he did a spot on job! Well he did know why but didn’t realise how broken it really was.
@dramajoe
@dramajoe 7 күн бұрын
I know it bogs down needing to explain formats and all that but I really feel like it does a disservice to describing the power of Lurrus to not mention that it's the only card to ever get a power level ban in Vintage. "So in MTG there's a format called Vintage where the only banned cards are joke cards, ante cards, racist cards, and cards which literally do not work. Black Lotus isn't banned. Lurrus is the only card in history to get banned in that format for being too powerful."
@DaviRenania
@DaviRenania 7 күн бұрын
Racist cards? Huh? How does that work?
@Demonic0Jester
@Demonic0Jester 7 күн бұрын
how about a format for just the racist cards that'd be a good time
@moldybones142
@moldybones142 7 күн бұрын
to be fair, companion cards were banned for power level reasons because restricting them would have done literally nothing, and those are the only two things you can do to a card in vintage
@RoxyGotMoxy.
@RoxyGotMoxy. 7 күн бұрын
@@Demonic0Jester thats just.... life.
@Demonic0Jester
@Demonic0Jester 7 күн бұрын
@@RoxyGotMoxy. be a lot cooler if it was
@JoeKell365
@JoeKell365 7 күн бұрын
not convinced Josh couldn't win an RCQ with only a few weeks of training. he's crazy good at Yugioh and had great analysis of all the cards in the video
@BoltTheEmolga
@BoltTheEmolga 7 күн бұрын
I’m admittedly kinda sad that you didn’t mention that Lurrus got banned in *Vintage* pre-errata, really want to hear someone’s reaction to that But fantastic job on the 5/5, I love these videos so much
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic 7 күн бұрын
I did :) but it got cut out since the explanation was too long
@BoltTheEmolga
@BoltTheEmolga 7 күн бұрын
@ Ah, gotchas - ty for mentioning it at least, can imagine
@CaptainMarvel4Ever
@CaptainMarvel4Ever 7 күн бұрын
@@CardmarketMagic Could we ever get unedited? Josh is quite... an opinionated individual about cards and decks so I'd love to hear him unfiltered.
@T1zzle
@T1zzle 7 күн бұрын
I love this series, generally this shows that good players understand power level even with limited context of the game! Also, for non yugioh players, a floodgate is like a stax piece
@brunogarcianolles3417
@brunogarcianolles3417 7 күн бұрын
Carl: I will start to only make a video a week Also Carl:
@broshmosh
@broshmosh 7 күн бұрын
Is this not the video for this week?
@maidonopai
@maidonopai 7 күн бұрын
I just don't hope he's gonna overwork himself again....
@brunogarcianolles3417
@brunogarcianolles3417 7 күн бұрын
@@broshmosh it's a joke because they uploaded a 2 minute video yesterday (too long to be posted as a short)
@maidonopai
@maidonopai 7 күн бұрын
@@broshmosh second but barely the first one was 6 days ago
@Tharkon
@Tharkon 6 күн бұрын
I only see a video from the 14th and the 21th, that fits once per week perfectly.
@ninjawxyz1260
@ninjawxyz1260 7 күн бұрын
Staple or Stinker is my favorite series between the Cardmarket Yugioh and MTG
@crawdaddy1234
@crawdaddy1234 7 күн бұрын
I remember when Tibalt was originally printed. We tried so hard… and got nowhere. And in the end, Tibalt never really mattered.
@henke37
@henke37 5 күн бұрын
At least not this incarnation of him.
@Chris_seh
@Chris_seh 7 күн бұрын
Oh pog! Big fan of staple or stinker
@CaptainMarvel4Ever
@CaptainMarvel4Ever 7 күн бұрын
Bro you got Jesse Kotton to play Staple or Stinker!? (heh, sorry but I can't help but rub salt in the wound after this year's worlds finals). Also here's something Josh didn't even realize, he actually reacted to Sam doing Staple or Stinker a year-ish ago (he was in pain watching Sam's attempt), and he saw Sam get Thalia, and Josh guessed it right there too. Guess he forgot about it, but either way, he's a champ for a reason (and he might be picking up another YCS win this week after getting one around this time last year in the same city no less).
@sorin_markov
@sorin_markov 7 күн бұрын
I feel like Tibalt is way easier to evaluate without the influence of knowing Magic planeswalker history
@danielklein5829
@danielklein5829 7 күн бұрын
I'd love you guys to try and get Josh to evaluate utility Lands. His analysis is so good that it'd be really interesting to see him interact with the game economy.
@violaknapp7904
@violaknapp7904 7 күн бұрын
Now we need a final Staple or Stinker battle between Tyler and Joshua to decide once and for all who gets to wear the crown!
@Shadfillet
@Shadfillet 7 күн бұрын
6:38 You can effectively think of floodgates as Yu-Gi-Oh!'s version of stacks pieces. Preventing your opponent from playing the game :3
@carlmariavonweber9875
@carlmariavonweber9875 7 күн бұрын
Yaaaaay Joshua ❤ nice vid thanks for all your work guys, i am so happy to see a new cardmarket video in my inbox 🎉😊
@qwertasdfg3447
@qwertasdfg3447 7 күн бұрын
Josh's card assessment skills is honestly impressive
@Datuna-vw3un
@Datuna-vw3un 7 күн бұрын
Tibalt did not only destroy hands, but entire decks, when people tried to build around making random discard good.
@user-gj1lb6xp3t
@user-gj1lb6xp3t 7 күн бұрын
best MTG channel on KZbin, no negativity, great production quality, and a great team, thanks for these awesome videos and don't overwork yourself! ✌️
@simonteesdale9752
@simonteesdale9752 7 күн бұрын
Whoo! It's back. If you wanted to set the comments section of fire, putting Temple of the False God, Reliquary tower and Enlightened Tutor on there would be hilarious.
@definitelynotmany4972
@definitelynotmany4972 4 күн бұрын
1:20 An Enchantment is the Magic equivalent of a Continuos Spell, not a Field spell.
@austinwilburn1772
@austinwilburn1772 7 күн бұрын
3:49 cards like that always throw me off. Like how do you handle cards that were definitely mvips at one point in time but those days are gone… and/or cards that are really great but only in specific niche decks.
@herzerj.5045
@herzerj.5045 6 күн бұрын
Also this was in the ravagan meta and having a blocker for ravagan was super impactful.
@TheHeadsHunter
@TheHeadsHunter 3 күн бұрын
Here's a funny idea: get Taylor and Josh to learn to play MtG, one coached by Carl, another by Thoralf, both trying to emulate their favorite yu gi oh decks inside MtG, say something like an MtG version of Tears or Mystic mine stun, and see what they can come up with
@CaptainMarvel4Ever
@CaptainMarvel4Ever 2 күн бұрын
lol, I know Josh won that one YCS with Mystic Mine but he still hates that card and all flood gates like it. I doubt he'd wanna play MTG just for more floodgates. I also don't think he's ever been much of a Tear enthusiast. Josh would probably prefer a deck like Paleo or Runick.
@Kylada-o5t
@Kylada-o5t Күн бұрын
josh likes tear but he isnt a fanboy of them. He is runick andy. Also he hates floodgates
@hurrdurrmurrgurr
@hurrdurrmurrgurr Күн бұрын
Josh is a control player, you want Jesse Kotton for Tears.
@ThetrueKidGoku
@ThetrueKidGoku 4 күн бұрын
Pak is at Bologna for a YCS, hopefully they invited him. Would love to see him analyze Magic cards
@CaptainMarvel4Ever
@CaptainMarvel4Ever 4 күн бұрын
He works a full time job in addition to all of his other endeavors. It might be a lot to ask for him to immediately go from Italy to Germany and then take an extra day or two off work.
@ThetrueKidGoku
@ThetrueKidGoku 4 күн бұрын
@CaptainMarvel4Ever Oh I completely understand. I just think it would be cool. Also a good opportunity since he's already in Europe, which I don't think happens a lot.
@CaptainMarvel4Ever
@CaptainMarvel4Ever 4 күн бұрын
@@ThetrueKidGoku Oh hey I agree completely, I love Pak, and seeing him flex his analysis skills would be great. It's just tough for him since he's so ambitious not only in Yu-Gi-Oh, but all aspects of life. In the meantime, Julius Schwarzkopf may be a good pick. He's where Pak was 5 years ago as the current #1 rookie, and he's a local of Germany. Just like Pak he made top 8 today, and with Mermail no less (his feature match was over in no time as he got a quick and clean win).
@Blizz3112
@Blizz3112 7 күн бұрын
Carl, you lie... Tibalt is NO friend... but a FIEND :-P
@huggelion
@huggelion 7 күн бұрын
i will allways haunt you josh you can never escape speedroid
@Ondas563
@Ondas563 7 күн бұрын
So happy to see Josh here again, I love watching him
@Scholar-r7w
@Scholar-r7w 7 күн бұрын
The more I read Tibalt, the more I can't understand how people though it was going to be a good card.
@Kylora2112
@Kylora2112 7 күн бұрын
4 random discards to *maybe* have a payoff...if your opponent isn't playing creatures, you're SOL.
@codyhanson1344
@codyhanson1344 5 күн бұрын
Would be cool if red had cards that had a triggered ability specifically off of being randomly discarded
@sineupp
@sineupp 5 күн бұрын
Tibalt would be great in a Dark World deck (not that we want more support for solitaire decks)
@hurrdurrmurrgurr
@hurrdurrmurrgurr Күн бұрын
@@sineupp I don't think adding more rng to dark world discards on top of the dangers would make the deck better.
@ChaffyExpert
@ChaffyExpert 11 сағат бұрын
Well you can proliferate to increase it's power, then you just need to protect it. But having to build the deck around making it work means it's probably a bad card. Unless it instantly wins (which this doesn't really.) At least fervor will most definitely have at least some payoff, Tibalt is just more of a cost to 'maybe' use it's ultimate.
@Divreon
@Divreon 6 күн бұрын
Floodgates are known as Stax in MtG
@kylegonewild
@kylegonewild 7 күн бұрын
You were spot-on with Tibalt. He needs to stay around a long time to get real use out of his stronger abilities and the random discard is too steep a cost for such a fragile permanent. It *might* have been playable (and even that might be a stretch) in aggro decks or graveyard decks if you got to choose the discarded card but alas, he is complete ass. Even the next worst 2 mana Planeswalker is lightyears more playable than 2-mana Tibalt and it has a restriction of not being castable for the first three turns of the game lol.
@herzerj.5045
@herzerj.5045 6 күн бұрын
It is also easyer for Non-Magic-Player to guess it, because they dont know how busted most 3 cmc PW were at this time.
@x_chaos_x
@x_chaos_x 7 күн бұрын
Floodgate is the equivalent of stax the more you know!
@fiendfi7119
@fiendfi7119 6 күн бұрын
most planeswalkers: kill on sight tibalt: let the opponent discard their good cards
@Majias
@Majias 7 күн бұрын
You guys really need to ask Joshua to evaluate cards for an upcoming edition during spoiler season 😁
@DuskoftheTwilight
@DuskoftheTwilight 4 күн бұрын
My thoughts on each card as presented, as someone who has played a number of card games but never really got into Magic Furvor - reads OK, but my impression of Red is that it already has plenty of creatures that have haste or otherwise do things on play, and if you're doing a multicolor deck, you're paying 3 mana to set up for a combo, which doesn't sound amazing. - Stinker Arboreal Grazer - this is ramp and ramp is good, the question is how does this compare to other ramp cards? I know Magic has one drops that can tap for mana, so how does this compare to them? Unlike those, you need to have 3 lands in hand to make use of this turn one (a forest to tap to play it, a second land to get from the effect, and a third land to play at the start of your next turn or else what was the point?). Under that condition, this is better than those because you get the extra mana every turn going forward, even if this creature is removed, and it can also be used to attack or block or such since it doesn't need to tap itself. Needing to have 3 lands in hand feels a bit dicey but i think Magic players are used to needing to draw lands, so I don't think it's actually that much of an ask - Staple. Thalia - Taxing most cards can cause a lot of problems for your opponent (and for you but presumably you're deckbuilding to account for this), and its a little hard to remove since you need to block with at least a 1/3 or cast a removal spell that will get cost increased. The obvious counter to this is a creature that can hit it for one on play, or any effect already on board that can ping it for one damage, but I'm not sure how common those are. I'm a bit torn on this overall but i think what it comes down to is that if this card was a staple, I'm not sure it would be healthy for the game overall and would get complained about a lot, so - Stinker Lurrus - oh i think I've heard of this one, isnt this the one that got the Companion keyword changed? Oh wait, they're talking about it with the updated text, I think originally you just got to play it for 3 from out of the game right? I think i heard that change killed the mechanic so - Stinker Tibalt - the +1 filters and maybe stages something in the graveyard but the first two effects dont seem amazing and i doubt this ever survived to do the -6, especially if there are creatures on the board to be stolen - Stinker
@betabrett0223
@betabrett0223 7 күн бұрын
should add a fan submitted card into staple or stinker as an extra variable
@teadeity363
@teadeity363 7 күн бұрын
You should display cards in front of the two Staple/Stinker winners and have them build a deck by picking a card out of the selections, which are Staples and Stinkers and then have them play
@eq2lornick
@eq2lornick 5 күн бұрын
Dude knows his stuff. It's nice that game theory spans across genres. It's also kind of hilarious that a Yugioh player can evaluate MTG cards better than a lot of MTG players. Tibalt was one word away from being a good card. "Random" makes the card infinitely worse. I honestly don't think he'd be all that busted if you took the random aspect away either. I think they played it too safe with him.
@boonlincoln
@boonlincoln 2 күн бұрын
Staple or Stinker - Vanilla Edition (with the caveat that some used to be staples) Staples: Isamaru, Hound of Konda Watchwolf Stinkers: Gigantosaurus Yargle and Multani Aegis Turtle
@SneoK
@SneoK 5 күн бұрын
Saying Tibalt is a tough one is the meanest bait I have ever seen :P
@Bubblenuts13
@Bubblenuts13 6 күн бұрын
Now you gotta have both of them on but interview them separately. Reference the KZbinr Rarran. He’s had a lot of similar types of videos! If they tie, have a tiebreaker ready!
@joakimgille9677
@joakimgille9677 15 сағат бұрын
Hearing this glowing review of Thalia, and looking at the meta now as a modern taxes player makes me weep.
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic Сағат бұрын
She's still played in legacy and pioneer :)
@Syr_Robert
@Syr_Robert 4 күн бұрын
Carl just gave the best explanation of a planeswalker in a game of Magic I've ever heard. By the way, is Grazer a staple? I would of thought it was a straight up stinker -only good in turn one, and after that you wouldn't want to draw multiple of them-.
@reeonboi937
@reeonboi937 7 күн бұрын
WE LOVE JOSHUA SCHMIDT!!!!!!
@Ricardo-zo1ti
@Ricardo-zo1ti 7 күн бұрын
I love staple or stinker, but I feel it's getting a bit too easy... Make them suffer! 😅
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic 7 күн бұрын
These were hard, we just had one of the world's best players. We would need to find worse contestants 😅
@Feklq
@Feklq Күн бұрын
Idk if josh will ever see this but there were soul sister decks that would main-deck run a few copies with another card called Heliod the sun crowned. They didn't see top table success but it did float around tier 3 in modern at the time
@hphoenix13
@hphoenix13 7 күн бұрын
Can't wait for the farfa episode
@MasterDecoy1W
@MasterDecoy1W 4 күн бұрын
I don't normally go in for this kinda content, but my boy getting the crown made it all worth it.
@michaelabere6770
@michaelabere6770 7 күн бұрын
Cardmarket got me to start playing again and I went from never getting these to knowing them straight away
@bblivid
@bblivid 5 күн бұрын
OK hear me out: if you get the crown, the next person has to answer one more if they want to go for the crown. And then one more to challenge that person.
@OlAgony
@OlAgony 7 күн бұрын
I love how he went on analyzing Fervor the way it could be Fires of Yavimaya
@DarthRPG1
@DarthRPG1 7 күн бұрын
Carl pulling out the tactical Tibalt😂
@adn267
@adn267 4 күн бұрын
9:22 hahah the real time realization that Lurus + Thalia is broken
@galaxyboy7060
@galaxyboy7060 9 сағат бұрын
The missing context for why Lurrus was broken was that the floor was often that you looked at the top of someone's library and drew an extra card for free every single turn because of Mishra's Bauble, and if you were doing anything other than that it was absolutely obscene But I love that Joshua has zero context for how planeswalkers actually play out and Tibalt on its face *still* seems awful even then
@BruderSeth
@BruderSeth 7 күн бұрын
I tried to reason with myself that Fervor might not be too bad in casual commander.. Which means it's an absolute stinker :'-)
@AgusSkywalker
@AgusSkywalker 7 күн бұрын
In my Krenko deck I have 4 cards that give permanent haste to all my creatures. All of them are better than Fervor. They all cost 3 mana as well but do something else: - Goblin Chieftain is a goblin creature that gives all the other goblins +1/+1. - Goblin Warchief is a goblin creature that reduces the cost of every other goblin by 1. - Tuktuk Rubblefort is a 0/3 wall creature with reach, meaning I can also use it to block, even flyers. - Rising of the Day is power-crept Fervor. It's exactly the same but also gives my 5 legendary creatures (including my commander) +1/+0 (it's also an uncommon against Fervor that's rare). So given that Fervor is so easily outclassed in a format where it would be somewhat useful, I deduced that it had no chance of being good in a 1v1 format.
@minabasejderha5972
@minabasejderha5972 6 күн бұрын
I knew (or, at least, I had a hunch) that Josh would hate Tibalt because he values consistency a lot and would thus hate the random discard.
@monsteret7522
@monsteret7522 7 күн бұрын
damn he nailed it despite not knowing what lifelink does
@MunetsuguTakeno
@MunetsuguTakeno 7 күн бұрын
Tbh Tibalt biggest issue is that he dies to lightning bolt...(and that the discard is at random). If he either was starting on 3 or you could pick what you discard he would be at least all right. Granted I dont remember If lightning bolt and him were legal at the same time, but one of the check for planeswalkers is, can you survive lightning bolt? If they cant they need to have very good ability since they are better to be treated as one ability only Unles you are Ajani, Nacatl Pariah then you bring so much value that you can die to LB and its fine.
@iamkrazy1
@iamkrazy1 6 күн бұрын
5:45 JUDGE, aktchually🤓if Thalia fights a 2/2 they both die but if she blocks or is blocked by a 2/2 then she kills it first
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic 6 күн бұрын
I'm trying to explain this to a non-magic player ;) trying to use the exact terminology assuming they would know what it means would just confuse them
@iamkrazy1
@iamkrazy1 2 күн бұрын
@@CardmarketMagic I'm fully aware don't worry I just like being facetious
@psymar
@psymar 6 күн бұрын
So here's the thing about Lurrus: it's *the only card* to ever be banned in Vintage for being too powerful. Most obscenely powerful cards get banned in other formats but merely restricted in Vintage to being 1-per-deck. But that doesn't help with Lurrus, because the companion mechanic means you're only keeping one copy in your sideboard anyway! Lurrus has since been unbanned in Vintage, however -- and to give you an idea of Vintage's power level, Thalia isn't restricted, while cards like black lotus, ancestral recall, and time walk are all restricted (and can all be re-cast with Lurrus -- in fact, Lurrus recasting Time Walk is a two card infinite turns combo.)
@lastnamefirstname8655
@lastnamefirstname8655 7 күн бұрын
nice! mtg traps with yugioh expert guest!
@tlow5766
@tlow5766 7 күн бұрын
My favorite format on this channel!
@xolotltolox7626
@xolotltolox7626 7 күн бұрын
Woo more content with Josh!
@bobjones4469
@bobjones4469 3 күн бұрын
I can't believe a Yu-Gi-Oh champion didn't realize how broken an Extra Deck monster is.
@MartinLaurvigBrandstrup
@MartinLaurvigBrandstrup 7 күн бұрын
Oh, such timing. Video just uploaded as I opened youtube xD
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic 7 күн бұрын
Maybe we were waiting for you to open youtube to post it 👀
@kurowasanabe
@kurowasanabe 7 күн бұрын
Seth is FUMING at Arboreal Grazer being classified a staple right now.
@panko2848
@panko2848 7 күн бұрын
i remember day 9 referring to arboreal grazer as the worst card that was still somehow good enough for competitive magic
@RobTriBri-f2z
@RobTriBri-f2z 3 күн бұрын
Fervor would be more like a Continuous Spell. Field Spells are basically World Enchantments or Legendary Enchantments.
@byrontheusurper6505
@byrontheusurper6505 7 күн бұрын
I got the first one wrong, it seemed good, but that is fair.
@henke37
@henke37 5 күн бұрын
Now you will need to do more cards in one video to break this tie.
@jorritdriessen5728
@jorritdriessen5728 7 күн бұрын
Could you show them Gurmag Angler I think it's called and Arclight Phoenix? I think those are interesting cards. Maybe Karn Liberated and Karn, The Great Creator as well?
@LawnChair43
@LawnChair43 7 күн бұрын
I got 4/5 while going through the video! I got fooled by Ferver lol
@jozza923
@jozza923 7 күн бұрын
The thing is, is Fervor is actually okay in certain decks (such as decks that rely on activated abilities of creatures) but it is a stinker because there are similar cards that are strictly better, such as "Rising of the Day" which does the same thing, for the same mana cost, but also gives your legendary creatures +1/+0...
@MindstabThrull
@MindstabThrull 7 күн бұрын
I played with Tibalt in Standard. He really wants a deck where his "disadvantage" is less painful than elsewhere - you can't just usefully throw it into any deck. Back then I played Boros Reanimator - excuse me, Boros Resurrector - and probably about 2/3 of my deck didn't mind ending up in the graveyard. My deck originally had two copies and really wanted a third. But yes, in general, it's a Bad Card.
@zz1000zz
@zz1000zz 7 күн бұрын
I am so glad they hit hte buzzer at the end. I would have been hearbroken if we didn't get to hear it at least once.
@jk844100
@jk844100 2 күн бұрын
Chekhov’s buzzer
@user-od3yc8mr6w
@user-od3yc8mr6w 5 күн бұрын
The main reason why lurrus was not being played in decks a lot ist easy ... Because you then could not play him as companion.
@bestpinoza
@bestpinoza Күн бұрын
Lurrus is the king of vintage. That’s how good it is right now.
@OlgaZuccati
@OlgaZuccati 7 күн бұрын
surprised that the vintage black lotus loop went unmentioned
@danielcohenmunwes
@danielcohenmunwes 7 күн бұрын
This series is pretty good
@mykgKende
@mykgKende 7 күн бұрын
More Josh please!
@cfcolodettifilho
@cfcolodettifilho 7 күн бұрын
It's good to see you back to non commander content
@CardmarketMagic
@CardmarketMagic 7 күн бұрын
We only do commander once every two months or so 😅 :)
@arsena1147
@arsena1147 7 күн бұрын
When are we getting domain video
@Grimlock2183
@Grimlock2183 7 күн бұрын
can we get the outro music released as a short or a vid? I'm absolutely JAMMING to it
@TheVP_SSBU
@TheVP_SSBU 7 күн бұрын
Let's go my goat Joshua Schmidt.
@JohnThompson-es3ph
@JohnThompson-es3ph 5 күн бұрын
After evaluating fervor... should then show fires of yavimaya.
@hazeljoy1
@hazeljoy1 7 күн бұрын
Great vid! I love josh, he's my yugioh goat
@styfen
@styfen 7 күн бұрын
Need a head to head to determine the true champ.
@jonathanagostini7469
@jonathanagostini7469 7 күн бұрын
I love Joshua i play runick stun by his fault haha
@esrohm6460
@esrohm6460 4 күн бұрын
i think we undersold lurrus a bit. lurrus is quite possibly the strongest card in all of mtg including power 9 and other absurd early mtg cards
@Leyus03
@Leyus03 7 күн бұрын
Finally ! Assemble !
@miniyodadude6604
@miniyodadude6604 7 күн бұрын
I dont really follow standard, but i play magic in general (old precons with my dad when i was younger, mtga, commander), but these kinda all seemed obvious to me.
@bat9056
@bat9056 7 күн бұрын
I think 9/10 is still less then 5/5. It would have been nice to show him Fires of Yawinaya and discuss the difference including the difference in the standard environments of the time
@psymar
@psymar 6 күн бұрын
I feel like fervor could have a place in a red-green storm deck just to play all your llanowar elves, birds of paradise, etc for free in one turn...
@laytonjr6601
@laytonjr6601 5 күн бұрын
Arboreal Grazer isn't that useful if you have 2 lands in your starting hand and don't draw another one in your 2nd turn
@ShadowWasntHere8433
@ShadowWasntHere8433 7 күн бұрын
Give that man to CGB for some CBT Staple or Stinker, these are too ez
@mattcampbell4150
@mattcampbell4150 7 күн бұрын
in magic we call floodgates, stax pieces
@emer2475
@emer2475 6 күн бұрын
I would not put that Tibalt in a Tibalt-themed deck.
A Yugioh Player Judges Basic Magic Cards
14:38
Cardmarket - Magic
Рет қаралды 125 М.
How many people are in the changing room? #devil #lilith #funny #shorts
00:39
If people acted like cats 🙀😹 LeoNata family #shorts
00:22
LeoNata Family
Рет қаралды 28 МЛН
The IMPOSSIBLE Puzzle..
00:55
Stokes Twins
Рет қаралды 187 МЛН
Lazy days…
00:24
Anwar Jibawi
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
How I Ruined a Pokemon Tournament
1:26:45
WolfeyVGC
Рет қаралды 1,5 МЛН
Yu-Gi-Oh Darlings Rate Classic Magic Cards
20:58
Cardmarket - Magic
Рет қаралды 190 М.
Which Card Game has the Best Mana System?
20:26
SodaTCG
Рет қаралды 113 М.
The Sliver Kids: How Two Nobodies Broke the Pro Tour
17:17
Hungry On Plane
Рет қаралды 471 М.
How One Card Broke A Card Game
13:21
Rarran
Рет қаралды 1,2 МЛН
300 IQ Magic: the Gathering Plays
28:50
MTGGoldfish
Рет қаралды 156 М.
The Most Iconic Card from Every Year in Yu-Gi-Oh!
30:15
Cimoooooooo
Рет қаралды 99 М.
The Strange Method for Building EDH Decks that I Can't Stop Using
13:19
Salubrious Snail
Рет қаралды 129 М.
Europe's Best Yu-Gi-Oh! Player Rates Classic Magic Cards | Staple or Stinker?
15:37
King of Yu-Gi-Oh Rates Classic Magic Cards
15:16
Cardmarket - Magic
Рет қаралды 280 М.
How many people are in the changing room? #devil #lilith #funny #shorts
00:39