유희열의 스케치북 - 레드벨벳 - Dumb Dumb.20160401

레드벨벳 - Dumb Dumb

[@himchann5561]

Their vocals are no joke

[@user-ml6xi8li7s]

+Him Chann I think so

[@nandokgg]

+Him Chann No freaking joke, and the breathing tecnique to support singing on that lvl while doing that lvl of choreo? Ugh, amazing

[@cynthiafransisca3531]

IF SOMONE SAID RV CANT SING LETS FIGHT ME

[@hudaothman5119]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@haneefah01]

+cynthia fransisca count me in! ¬.¬

[@myselfmeu8862]

let's form a group. 😁😎😎

[@sharifahnursaadahsyedalwi3171]

+cynthia fransisca i want to join xD

[@myselfmeu8862]

+sh saadah alwi yeah. let's join. prepare the guns haha

[@AbbeeAbby]

seulgi's vocal projection and stability while dancing are really good. she's seriously incredible.

[@indravdx]

7yrs paid off ;)

[@ismusicbox726]

+emojiphobe Yasss, showing Seulgi some love!!! I feel like her talent as a vocalist gets overshadowed by Wendy most of the time, because Wendy usually sings the higher notes. To a lot of people, higher notes = better singer, but Seulgi has so much control and her voice remains stable through all the live performances they've ever done of this song. On top of that, she's the main dancer, so she's usually dancing the most powerfully, but that don't change a thing, lol. She really is incredible. #moreloveforseulgi

[@myaj6762]

+Music Box yea seulgi has stability and Wendy has range, I think they both work well together

[@ismusicbox726]

+The Feels Yeah they do balance each other out that way. They have contrasting vocal colors too, so when their voices are together it's something beautiful. They need a duet PRONTO!

[@inquisitvem6723]

trained for 5 yrs...sure paid off!

[@user-lv2yc7hs7i]

Wendy must have like 3 extra lungs or something damn how the hell does she do that prolly only eats CD's for breakfast

[@yolandaagustin4812]

ahahahah😂ikr

[@enigmaticblackcrow21]

this comment made my day 😂😂 "eat cds" more like breathes them ~Wendy for life

[@abbycher444]

This is the best live version of Dumb Dumb Red Velvet had ever done. The dancing was excellent, not sloppy or tired, the singing sounded stable. Usually when they did this, usually dancing will be good, but singing is off. They improved. Go red velvet.

[@eternalmoon52]

+Abby Cher That's the power of Sketchbook sound system!

[@norsyafikakhusni9019]

and sketchbook recording always at the beginning of their promotion period , so their vocals are not tired yet and they can perform well .. same goes to any other groups .. plus the soud system of sketchbook is the best of any show exists now , i've read it in some article before ..

[@nanaasmah938]

I think the type of microphones they used effected the way they sounded as well. They are using handheld microphones here so I think it helps their voices project more clearly

[@Julia-py9mk]

Yea it's mostly a difference in sound system. Hand held mics will always sound better, the other ones don't do their voices justice which is why it sometimes doesn't sound as good.

[@velvetra29]

Best Dumb Dumb with mic performance so far.

[@user-xn7nj2ll1u]

David Dadoali 4

[@justpaleiei]

You don't know how hard Wendy had passed. She was chubby when she lived in Canada but she want to be singer so she is always diet and now she has never stopped. Please don't say that to her.. I don't want my girl to stress with her weight anymore.. I love the way she is.

[@daventoyhacao]

She's still damn pretty tho 💘💘💘💙💙💙💙

[@lovejiyeon4ever]

How can seulgi sound so good while dancing so hard omg i sound like a dying whale alr without even dancing .............

[@caamicam]

+lovejiyeon4ever 7 years of training ! she's a goddess

[@user-xw1ou4gy4u]

레드벨벳은 신인 때부터 라이브 정말 강점인 듯 라이브도 라이브지만 다섯명 모두 음색도 예쁘고 그 합쳐진 음색합이 너무 좋은 듯 갠적으로 음색이나 화음은 걸그룹중에서 레벨이 돋보적이라 생각함

[@user-cz6zi5pt6i]

슬기 웬디 애드립 하는거 성량 쩐다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 와 진짜 레벨이들 라이브 언제나 최고였다..

[@RocioMylenee]

you know it's dumb dumb when they change heels for sneakers lol

[@MissColourful02]

SEULGI THO WOW I'M BEYOND AMAZED BY HER STABLE ADLIBS WHILE DANCING THIS HARD

[@sweetcelynz4715]

She've been trainee for 7 years for something

[@bichbyeol]

9월도 가는 중.. 난 오늘도 보는 중.. 지금도 레벨의 덤덤 보는 사람 있음?? 이 노랜 잊지 못하겠음.

[@user-ih5zyoim]

와 라이브 미쳤다.. 너무 잘부르네

[@constanzagonzalez6088]

Wendy's voice is sooooo amazing, so freaking stable 😍

[@pinkhyacinth]

Wendy's voice!!! 😍

[@drhf1214]

both red velvet and mamamoo debuted in 2014. i only stanned mamamoo for a while but after watching rv performances, I realized how talented they both all are. rv's vocals really are one of the best around girl groups right now and that's a fact.

[@PinguinoSod]

no matter what seulgi wears, she always look so good for me

[@giovannifighting9611]

My heart is too weak for Joy and Wendy guys i can't ... somebody save me XD

[@jenimjae2665]

SAME FCK

[@joyyiipark3142]

the screm when joy's singing part 💕💕💕

[@nicole93206]

melon Hot Trend Now Wendy《Who You Are》 1 Seulgi《I Have Nothing》 4 Red Velvet (레드벨벳) 5 Jessie J 7 Joy《이젠 그랬으면 좋겠네》 9 Red Velvet is RED!!!!!!!!!!

[@reveluv8642]

+Nicole Hsu WOW Im so proud of them especially Wendy my bae :)

[@supahunniegoddess3538]

When none-idols or netizens got bullied and called them fat.. They cry :'( and stuff But when Wendy got criticized by lots of people and called her fat She's still plastering a smile on her face as well as making people happy especially us rv fans

[@NoSanaNoLife2521]

Considering she grow up in Canada I don't think she really cared if she's skinny or not or what people's gonna say about her weight

[@pinkhyacinth]

I really hope the comments don't get to her. Her body is perfect

[@tvpivm]

Yeri sounds so good omg i feel so proud i could cry T.T

[@Andrew-cx1hq]

im so proud at how much better our little turtle has gotten

[@yullovelevolluy]

WENDY'S EXPLOSIVE VOICE OMGGGGGG!!!!

[@hehehehe6537]

When they scream for my bby Joy YASSS GURL

[@peaxchyc3128]

At least Wendy's not starving herself. She's still beautiful even if people call her fat. Haters gonna hate.

[@irenecatarina5613]

Tbfh i can't understand knetz, because if wendy is fat, then what about me? a whale?😂

[@peaxchyc3128]

me neither XD no matter what they're going to say Wendy will slay! Slay those haters.

[@MimiCupcakiex]

+Irene Catarina i dont understand it either. I think its different since shes an Idol. Knetz expect every idol girl group to be beautiful and to have a thigh gap. I'm a whale as well XD

[@peaxchyc3128]

yes. Much like whats happening to Umji right now. I feel bad for her :( . Idols get criticized for being ugly and fat but when they had undergo surgery they criticized idols even more.

[@bababayoya1313]

+H E A R T C I N D Y someone told me that having a thigh gap is not normal

[@sophisticated96]

Goddess Wendy. Love her vocals especially at the "It must be" part. Love the vocal dynamics shared among wendy, seulgi and joy.

[@hanyeonri9690]

What i feel bout Joy "Pretty neighbrhood with friendly personality" 😂😂😂😂

[@wenderp8412]

this is there best best dumb dumb vocal performance as you can see they weren't trying as hard on the dancing but the dancing still slayed

[@openmyrice7720]

i keep repeating this..wendy is my bias with reasons, she can sing high note effortlessly,flawlessly, beautifully, from her face, she didn't find it difficult at all😍😍😍

[@mermaidangelica9717]

Y'all hear those screams for Joy??? YASSSS

[@songofapple]

ㄹㅇ 다시없을 띵곡이다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그와중에 구사즈 성량 무엇ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@ari-zi4zi]

Seulgi and Wendy's voice is so stable💕💕

[@Seulgimylove13]

SUCH A PERFECT HUMAN BEING.. GOD BLESS YOU, SEULGI...

[@windarosmaniar3642]

seulgi can manage her singging well, yeeaay i ike it

[@franklin897]

라이브 미쳤누... ㅠ

[@MeonieA]

omg Seulgi's voice ♥

[@maikhanhmai]

when the mr remove video has more views than the official video

[@JamesJL]

Wendy be killing me with them eyes!

[@tfishing2.0]

i'm out of breath just watching them sing and dance

[@marchi3955]

LOL I love how we can hear their hard breathing here. It shows how hard it is to do the choreo on top of singing their high notes - and yet they still nail it! RV's talent and visuals are really out there, SM just needs to promote them more.

[@ikonbobbyswife7172]

Wendy's legs is the most beautiful!!!!! All the Korean actresses and singers has skinny legs and in my opinion it's not beautiful because there is Nothing to show!!!! But Wendy she has very beautiful legs and for you to know many dancers Thierry producers preferring chubby legs that has something to show

[@annecharlize2069]

I'm happy about Wendy looking more Healthy! but I'm worried that SM might do the same to her like what they did to Sulli :(

[@tofubyul]

+Anne ChaCharlize what did they do to Sulli! ):

[@Haceeena]

sulli???

[@mushroomseason]

+Anne ChaCharlize how does looking thicker have to do with being more healthy?

[@marklee80299]

looking skinny doesnt equal unhealthy just like looking thicker doesnt equal to healthy.

[@keserutimea]

+Byun Baek true.

[@maryvnxo.1.5mviews2]

If Wendy's fat than am I a fucking whale???

[@yolandaagustin4812]

feel the same things, bud😂😂

[@rettychaterinsiahaan7354]

Wow seulgiiii seriously how can you manage dancing and singing at the same time so well???? My bias is a perfect package as idol. Luv luv luvvvvvv 💛💛💛💛

[@ayudevitadamayanti8772]

MA BABY JOY HAS A LOT OF FAN💞💞💞💞💃💃💃 I'M HAPPY FOR YOU

[@sagarael]

SEULGI's dancing and vocals!! AWESOMENESS!!

[@ismusicbox726]

#moreloveforseulgi - I don't know, but I feel like Seulgi barely gets any love every time I look at comment threads on RV's videos. She's so well-rounded, she really is the golden member: She has the most stable voice live in RV, and her vocal color is so pleasing to the ears (She has what I like to call a "Disney Princess" voice); Not to mention her ability to emote while singing (the "One of these Nights" performances do her so much justice); Her dancing is so clean and precise, and she has these sharp eyes that make her gaze so captivating. So let's see: Voice? Check. Dancing? Check. Visuals? Check. Definitely on my list of ultimate biases of all time.

[@wenderp8412]

Some fans think Seulgi is underrated but trust me a lot of fans always comment about about Seulgi, almost every rv video I watch there's like SOOO many Seulgi comments on how talented she is, for me yeri is underrated Cuz she has the least popularity and is always getting hated

[@ismusicbox726]

+Tenzin Choezin That's why I was thinking "Idk if it's just me or something", but I still do feel like she's one of the lesser appreciated ones compared to Wendy, Irene, and Joy. I think Yeri gets a lot of attention, sadly though a lot of it is from haters like you said. Which I think is so messed up because she is such a cutie pie, and it seems like everyone in SM adores her too. Lately she's been getting some love because she's a gorgeous girl, and she's good at portraying the emotion in "One of these Nights." Nevertheless, let's all support our girls together!

[@SonePH]

+Music Box Whaaaat??? It should be #MoreLoveForWendy Seulgi has tons of fans! When did you get out of your cave? Hmmm. Sorry about that. Its just that, I wouldn't call Seulgi underrated, it's really Wendy.

[@ismusicbox726]

+Sone PH YoonAddict First off, no I don't live in cave, hehehe. I follow most of RV's videos, and any fan can tell you there are so many comments about Wendy girl!!! Either about her voice, her facial expressions (which crack me up lol), or her personality. I personally think she's really popular, especially with international fans. Maybe my desire for more Seulgi love is just coming from my bias towards her, lol, but either way, I wanted to simply express the things I appreciated about her. I hope no one thinks either that I have anything against the other members, I love them all!!!! Yeri is a cutie pie, Joy is so gorgeous with her tall self, Irene is my mother and part-time goddess, and Wendy is my homegirl, lol!

[@SonePH]

Music Box There's the difference between the "comments" and "love". RV fans tends to comment most about Seulgi and Wendy, but it's Seulgi who gets the most "love". Seulgi and Irene. and then Joy. and then Yeri & Wendy (my 2 biases.) Which is very sad. :(

[@maymayavenido9812]

Wendy's leg...i have those and loved it. 😍😍

[@Nikkiboo2012]

Have what?

[@maymayavenido9812]

+Nikkiboo2012 have those legs like her like the shape but her is more smooth and fair hehehe mine is just hmm never mind...😂

[@rv.dc.loona.enthusiast732]

Now that's what you call a LIVE ^_______^V ❤️

[@ebelism7246]

fINALLY THEY PERFORMED AT YOO HEE YEOL I WAS WAITING FOR THIS !'!1!1!1!1!

[@TY_Track]

These mics are awesome they really let us hear their crisp vocals!

[@kingsrback553]

What did they eat for breakfast?! Their CD?! They sing so great!

[@marial5770]

CAN WE PLEASE TALK ABOUT HOW MUCH YERI'S VOCALS HAVE IMPROVED I MEAN

[@minaesunnny]

웬디 사랑해에에에에에에ㅔㅇ레ㅐ아으아이에에ㅐ온니이이이ㅣ잉

[@truonghieudong101]

Seulgi ~~~ Kang Seulgi ~~~ Oppa, I love you =))~

[@tmvkrjf]

단단해보이고 라이브 너무 편하게 보고 있어 건강하고 이뻐보이고 너무 안말랐으몀

[@janeshaidenvalcorza4390]

Is SEULGI a 'nobody' ? Because she's f*cking "PERFECT" .

[@neerfahcrs_]

레벨 최고

[@yuniharyantiyunus5853]

im just happy everytime i hear yeri's voice.

[@kimchitranthi7338]

Seulgi and Wendy so best 👍

[@jannaticahyani6786]

Joy is so precious👑💚

[@hazelglenn2553]

Com'n doesn't mean she's an idol she has to be thin or sexy. Wendy's body is perfect, it's just right for her. I love it. jinjja.

[@sabcode-dd]

I wonder why the starting cut is a view from the legs. That's an uncommon angle for these sort of videos.

[@trbl6066]

Seulgi is the best for sure

[@haylinarnett6529]

I don't know how to describe my Seulgi.. Let's start with the word PERFECT, followed by AMAZING, INCREDIBLY TALENTED, GORGEOUS, LOVABLE BEAR EVER !

[@jennylynganiban3164]

Irene is so pretty!

[@eclairmanufacturing1827]

If there is a group that have all the quality and capability to be the next nation’s girl group after SNSD, then it is them. SuperVelvet 🔥🔥🔥

[@rosarioch1022]

Owww i am so proud of ma girls :)

[@maecho21]

still get chills while listening to wendy's vocals!!!

[@nurinaadlina3519]

I love Seulgi outfit

[@thecam.7998]

This still proves that SM emphasizes beauty and talent. Why have one when you can have all basically. So much hard work but it's worth it in the end

[@paoespo9551]

This video having less than 500k views makes me question people's perception on what talent and real performance is. RV Hwaiting!!!!

[@lizeth130311]

seulgi look so happy here and wendy too i love them

[@nvy9519]

Joy fighting...RED VELVET fighting!!!

[@KunoBaka0908]

i'm having goosebumps

[@chocomilk1694]

I’m goosebumps, red velvet vocal is insane

[@deeedeeee]

Wendy is sooooo incredible. I love herrrrr💕💕💕💕💕

[@ToezHoez]

Seulgi is GLOWING in this performance

[@MutiaWardani]

Still amazed everytime I watch this performance.

[@SiyaoDing]

irene's shirt makes her look like a disney princess! belle! n___n

[@joctapratama1375]

who cares about their mv viewers when they are always nailed the live performance with the vocals and dance they deserve the best female artist, in 1 year 2 comeback with difference concept and still slay #voteRVforMAMA

[@yendo2058]

good vocals but they need a new stylist

[@constanzagonzalez6088]

Sooo true!

[@Shaziara]

+Yen Do i think all SM's stylists are lil bit "eccentric"... hahaha

[@vanngocbaotram7996]

Me too!

[@tivanys5093]

I loved their style 😕💕

[@iremdogan2938]

Yes please. Look at Irenes clothes.. She deserves better :D

[@Endlesslove1974]

I love that you can barely hear Joy struggling with the rap here, cause the MR removed was so funny lol. At least she sang it live. Hot Joy strikes again!

[@sheisrossa9200]

Damn that vocal tho. RV Slayyyyyy

[@sirohuy7284]

Seulgi

[@nhanvo5321]

Seulgi's so nice :3

[@indravdx]

Seulgi is totally girl crush! Btw, i love their keds, esp Irene's

[@MelvinEncarnacion]

After watching the sped up choreo on Weekly Idol, I can't unsee it when I watch this lmao

[@user-fr8tr9yl8k]

it sounds like it's slowed down here

[@rachmaima108]

This is the 1st song that made me Noticed, Red Velvet. I watched almost all of they're live performances.. 🤗🤗💜💜

[@hanhuynh3807]

SEulgi really has excellent voice and breath !!!! As expected Wendy, my talented girl

[@pricelesswine1024]

kang seulgi fckin slay with that sharp dance & clear vocal

[@taehyungisbae2907]

They are all slaying ! Seulgi is just perfect she deserve moooore love ❤️💗💗

[@diahindriyani2871]

my baby bear seulgi, so on point both dancing and singing....you look so damn beautiful...

[@rettychaterinsiahaan7354]

Seulgiiiiii milov 💛💛💛💛

[@minicornOnly5]

Their vocal really on point! my Yeri ; ___ ;

[@annedeguzman5216]

+minicornOnly5 her vocals have improved i'm so proud!

[@25Rikki]

+Michelle Guido yeah but she couldn't sing even those lines so she improved a lot :)

[@eleanorpark7043]

+Brigi Alerise yeah she improved but I sometimes think how she debuted when she ....like...objectively couldn't really sing..tho

[@Andrew-cx1hq]

the squirtle has evolved?

[@annedeguzman5216]

***** compared when she first joined rv you can tell she's improved

[@slowtokkii]

I love you Joy. You're making me think to work harder. 💚💚

[@nurkhamalia4028]

Yeri slay!!!!!! Her style i was very admire!!!! ugh??!?!!!!. She just pretty...she really2 pretty with white hair...😣

[@mahirahmohammad8902]

IT"S A LIVE PERFORMANCE PEOPLE. HATS OFF, girls m so proudd!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@bluequarter7733]

this is how u perform on sketchbook !!!!! killin it vocally while dancing, that's my girls !!!