SIDEMEN ACCENT CHALLENGE

Sidemen Accent Challenge, what should we do next?
● Sidemen Do My Make Up: ► • SIDEMEN DO MY MAKEUP! ◄
● KZbinr Impressions: ► • SIDEMEN KZbinR IMPRE... ◄
● Twitter: / zerkaahd
● Instagram: / zerkaahd
● 2nd Channel: / zerkaaplays
Vikkstar123: / vikkstar123
Miniminter: / miniminter
Wanna suggest some other group Sidemen videos we can, leave a comment and we'll read them all!
CONNECT WITH ME:
● 2nd Channel: / zerkaaplays
● COD Channel: / zerkaacod
● Twitch: / zerkaa
● Instagram: / zerkaahd
● Facebook: / josh.zerkaa.zerker
#TeamZRK

[@TBJZL]

Crying at Vikk's Scottish accent ffs

[@lukepoore5190]

You want Sum??

[@nino5543]

Hi tobi :D

[@Krakefan]

Me too Toby...

[@Brandon-ft6kh]

Ikr xD

[@dickyanders8138]

*Andy Tate voice* Don't care

[@lyly0451]

key:* 00:28 USA,NY 01:04 Birmingham 01:49 Bristol 02:31 French(frog) 03:19 Queen's English 04:15 Scottish 05:28 German 06:23 Indian 07:33 Australian 08:12 USA, TX 09:15 Jamaica 10:04 Irish 11:02 Cockney 12:14 Yorkshire 14:08 Russia 15:08 Geordie 15:46 Italian 16:19 California/sassy white girl 17:14 Scouse 18:00 Welsh 18:39 Nigerian 19:23 Mexican 20:21 Spanish 20:51 East Asia * May be off by a few seconds. (you're welcome).

[@motalebhussain8479]

Thanks!! I was looking for it.

[@mysterious5998]

Thanks man

[@sophie_4667]

Thanks!

[@muhammadasharab5610]

you are a LEGEND

[@aenz1268]

at ".....Good time...........Jai Ho" I cracked up

[@ishmamsabab174]

Lol me too

[@benwallace8470]

Who the fuck puts prawns on the barbie over here

[@starrygrimes500]

I didn't get it haha

[@krona2894]

I broke something when Josh said jai ho...

[@MultiShabow]

+Prathmesh Tiwari at 7:23

[@katiekamatie3292]

Josh's Indian accent killed me 😂😂

[@TheBachWings]

0:10 I found where G-Eazy got his lyrics from

[@aser0176]

exactly 😂😂😂😂👏👏👌

[@Chauncie26]

Lol I thought the same thing...😂😂😂😂

[@skillerzfc5507]

Hahaha

[@AH-gv8js]

Haha

[@maabmohamed1107]

Does anyone notice that vik NEVER AGES!!! He always looks the se

[@maabmohamed1107]

*same

[@seadosmanagiq3382]

+QueenMamo 28 hes eyebrows do

[@thatloganguy646]

Because he from southern Malaysian

[@mirhaque9857]

No he's Indian. He is from Sheffield, which is in England/UK and was born and raised there. His family is from India so I don't know where the fuck you got the Malaysian part from

[@Ellamarss]

ThatLoganGuy DA fuq were did you get that from

[@GrittyTones]

5% of comments people saying why the didnt do a certain country 1% people butthurt josh said tennessee was in texas 4% people saying they are a nationality mentioned in the video 90% people saying the accent were stereotypical and offended them

[@GrittyTones]

i am dominican by the way and i wasnt offended

[@xavierlagual8674]

so did i

[@matthews1366]

and no matter what people try to do these comments won't go away.

[@graceisaphilion]

I lost it at jai ho 😂😂

[@aditidas2044]

Grace Lee Same here considering that I woke up my sleeping family with my laughter😂😂😂

[@ItsMeAndrewGD]

😂😂😂😂

[@tracybrass8692]

XD I’m dying

[@petersharpling410]

He said Jaipur which is an Indian city

[@pratikshasuryawanshi394]

@@petersharpling410 aaaah what?

[@kallumgreen9705]

We Australians don't ride Kangaroos... We ride Koalas.

[@Jamesnrvng]

Kallum Green nah mate we box kangaroos also i thank you your the only chip company that doesn't sell air :)

[@kallumgreen9705]

xxtpjxgamingxx IKR. Damn Doritos!

[@jameshuxley9654]

Do you ride kroks

[@kallumgreen9705]

James Huxley Yeah Bruh

[@jameshuxley9654]

Kallum Green what's your name

[@buzzardfollower8133]

This was brilliant, the Indian accent was the best from josh !!

[@johnmartyn5631]

Do dublinese

[@ArreSidu]

JAY HO! lololol

[@I_Am_Stin]

FOLLOW THE BUZZARDS!

[@deathwing4195]

Jay ho is my favourite songs

[@bethkirk8403]

Why am I crying of laughter over the fact that Simon looked generally concerned for josh when he tried doing a Cockney accent!? 😂😂

[@fanged5483]

6:35 I know how it feels Vikk. I'm Indian and all my friends can do better Indian accents that me😂😂

[@xNOTX3x]

yo Same

[@lemon_bloom289]

not me i can speak indian and do a good accent bc i am from india

[@twizzle8536]

@@lemon_bloom289 r/whoosh

[@HoseoksPinkyToe]

@@twizzle8536 r/stfu thats overused lol

[@chloeisanxious800]

I'm going to admit, Simon's Australian impression was pretty on point, not the way he said it, but the swearing. Yeah, us Aussies do swear a lot

[@chloeisanxious800]

+Chloe Smith And Vik's, his was pretty on point too

[@ldrums]

Not as much as us Scottish

[@chloeisanxious800]

+Iona Flett-grieve idk, maybe its because I'm Australian and Scottish I tend to swear more, idk tho

[@FlopPvPIMinecraftMore]

+Iona Flett-grieve yup

[@FlopPvPIMinecraftMore]

+Iona Flett-grieve yup

[@lukemontgomery1774]

The only reason people are good at accents is because they have listened to them a lot, that's why Simon did an amazing Consuela, as he is a family guy fan.

[@BN-xj8wr]

WAIT REALLLLLY?!?!

[@lukemontgomery1774]

Brad Navarro Pretty much.

[@BN-xj8wr]

SICKKK M8

[@cindychelsea]

Simon's Nigerian accent had me cringing on the floor! TOO FUNNY!

[@kateh3277]

16:22 "here we come"simon's cali accent is so good

[@shamiralberto9610]

Vikks Texan and Australian accent should've been on point since he plays with Preston (TBNRFrags) and Lachlan.

[@manubajpai7731]

vik is indian he has a better acc ent

[@seth4617]

Manu Bajpai Vikk is English

[@alexc5087]

Yes, but he's of Indian heritage.

[@elfuego2899]

Hes indian lol

[@malzzzed8647]

Shamir Alberto lol guys just because he's born in India does not mean that he'd be better at an Indian accent

[@kybayne6711]

Im from yorkshire and vikks accent was spot on

[@kybayne6711]

Also im from sheffield and sheff weds are better than sheff u

[@theunknowngamerx5648]

I'm from leeds

[@charlie-bf4ku]

im from leeds :D

[@loganaitken7559]

charlie Maclean I'm from $cotland

[@lukeboddy9218]

I'm from middlesbrough

[@malinsilevani330]

I Love Simon's laugh!😍😂😂

[@malinsilevani330]

+Dylan Wedel wtf

[@wedeldylan]

Nops lmao

[@malinsilevani330]

+Dylan Wedel grow up

[@wedeldylan]

Malin Silevani stop denying facts

[@jazjeon7309]

He's bae af 😍

[@jess6907]

when josh said 'jai ho' i fully lost it 😂

[@ishmamsabab174]

Yeah lol

[@alexprice7149]

That Birmingham one killed me I'm crying 😂😂😂I sound nothing like that 😂

[@random-zp4hl]

PHANDOM

[@hackingtv9936]

I do😂😂😂😭😭😭

[@bigmanclayt0953]

alex price I'm a bit late but that was a yam yam accent

[@TKM12]

Same lol

[@SuttyJoe]

Your yorkshire accent was on point in video being from Yorkshire meself I laughed so 'ard

[@charlierobertson1393]

Same mate hahaha

[@decent620]

vikk is from yorkshire he didn't really need to try hard

[@kylesmith-yq3hu]

Yay go Yorkshire

[@kipper123321]

Fuck Yorkshire sheep sheep shaggers Lancashire for the win!

[@SuttyJoe]

wankershire?

[@rosiecreaser6687]

I'm laughing so hard at vik doing the Yorkshire one because it's so true! "To the boozer" 😂😂😂😂

[@kellyknox8715]

Rosie XO I legit just that second watched that part😂😂

[@helmetness]

Rosie Creaser I am reminding you of this videos existence so that you may laugh again

[@Kahrvile]

Simon should've said "This is my swamp" in the Scottish accent, I would've died

[@nicholaspana2682]

It's a common misconception that people think that Australians ride kangaroos. We actually ride emu's, they're a lot faster

[@jovsto4180]

Hahah best comment I've read all day🙌

[@matthewgoldsmith1635]

I ride a bike and I'm Australian lol

[@karenkentta1235]

I ride wombats

[@nickjoksic2409]

I ride platypus

[@ColdPrata]

josh's indian accent 7:19 ffs haahahahahahahahah

[@naveenm7422]

yep that was really funny

[@MadhavanShah]

Omg our names...they match @navee madhavan!!

[@naveenm7422]

Yeah

[@jameshill9654]

+scouttf2 That moment when josh says 'Jai Ho'

[@Draceus]

+scouttf2 and we are going to hit... the three sixty noscope

[@coleforeman6904]

Josh without a beard looks so young, like anyone watching in December 2016

[@remniwhite3804]

Cole Foreman Yes!! He looks so young.

[@bluecrayon9350]

same

[@isabellytle5900]

Cole Foreman I am

[@reecejohnson6357]

Isabel Lytle no you're not

[@macnicholson_]

None of you can do Australian and none of us put shrimp on the barbie hahaha

[@juantips6382]

Mac Nicholson oh just shut up

[@kingseal7381]

Mac Nicholson they got the swearing part right doe haha

[@budtheworst5901]

yeah and we dont ride kangaroos mate im agrring with you that thay are shit

[@diarmuidodriscoll4185]

Mac Nicholson u no there just messing like its a bit of fun

[@apothiconwrath5840]

Mac Nicholson yeah but nobody from England eats crumpets all the time or drinks tea all the time, yet loads of people say it, just like how people say all Texans are racist and stuff

[@laurabrown3950]

"In Australia we ride kangaroos and put shrimp on the barbie" 😂😂😂 In Australia we don't even call them shrimps😂👌👌👌

[@jakehealeas_1713]

Hahahahahahaha so fucking hilarious Jk(shut up Meg)

[@thor4572]

+Laura Brown our babies ride dingos though

[@kavvis5461]

We put snags on the barbie haha

[@jodiesimonson9659]

Is it just me or is simon really fit 😻

[@RachaelSlaven]

Omg yes😍

[@rachelpaget2531]

Absaloute crushhh💔

[@1403AMY]

jodie simonson Yes yes yes!👌

[@cl9925]

jodie simonson no

[@1403AMY]

tommyzoom1996 Yes

[@africkingpineapple2320]

This is prime sidemen lmao

[@poppylou9399]

I'm from Yorkshire and I wasn't even offended I was in stitches laughing 😂

[@ajgooner6728]

It's great to see you laughing at this, there are some Americans who are taking offence to this 😂

[@poppylou9399]

+Alex Laycock it was actually hilarious 😂 my cousin from Australia watched this and he said he died😂

[@snowy184]

WOW Vikk and Simons impression of Australia was pretty on point

[@iddy_paerau3062]

Umm....no not really😑

[@snowy184]

+Itz FizzaH its wasn't that bad and I know cause I live in Australia

[@ConnorAnderson2013]

We don't ride kangaroos and we call shrimp prawns. That only thing that was on point was the swearing

[@joshcaputo1701]

+Connor Anderson and the really cute koalas

[@joshcaputo1701]

+Connor Anderson (Australian

[@ksribbles]

Vikk should know how to speak Australian, because Lachlan is his boyfriend xD

[@_differentbutthesame_6686]

#vikklan

[@Grannyplumninja]

#coolkidclub

[@anon9133]

#Vikklan #Merome #Poofless

[@anon9133]

#Vikklan #Merome #Poofless

[@CakeZiggler]

+KatTheWolf #Vikklan4life

[@ella-dt5yx]

Its fucking 7:25 mins into the vid and ive already got abs from just laughing too much andddd its 1:23 am so im screaming in my pillow to stop any noises help

[@maryelizabeth9887]

phan

[@aditidas2044]

Uhitsmia omg yay I'm not the only one watching this at 1:30am and dying of laughter!!!!

[@happyman8322]

mc phanburger xix actually I understand that my pillow is deaf now

[@arnonwu]

What did Josh say?

[@jackandconormaynard80]

that's so ryan k

[@Megane1410]

Simon calling Josh a wee lassie is literally the highlight of my day

[@owenslevin3609]

Greatest vid ever

[@Darjack]

Itsonly up 10 minutes

[@riathari]

Reply

[@LoryTee21]

That's how italian-americans talk! The actual Italian accent is way different! Luckily my accent is not too thick

[@ArtOfElectro]

I can still hear it!

[@LoryTee21]

Almitrul Lol I know! I hope I don't sound like BIBIDIBUBADIBABA (Damn you Peter Griffin!)

[@hackedgmgamemaster860]

I'm italian

[@Nadia1995ism]

Simon's laugh is fave oml😂😍

[@whiterondo7504]

I live near California, and simons accent is actually perfect

[@markoliver6359]

"I'm from Tennessee Texas" -Josh 2014 they are two different states😂🙈

[@TheGogoy3]

The three players they mentioned from France don't actually have french names! Benzema, Zidane, Sagna all African names.

[@skyman276]

Actually benzema is a legitimate French name

[@gregorkelman6258]

Benzema is Algerian, so it kinda makes sense. Even though he's Algerian, he moved to France when he was young, so he considers himself French

[@littlehouseontheprepostero8457]

i know right! i mean debuchy, giroud and mathieu were right there! even courtois sounds french!

[@kaptenyuz1682]

^ same thing with zidane

[@welloui09]

I think Mathieu, Deschamps sound more French.

[@zflyguy7022]

Cant get over how Simon and Josh laughed exactly the same 9:57-10:00 😂

[@BasicRBN02]

I'm from Wales, and that impression/accent they did for Wales was funny as 😂😂 Simon: "I live in the valleys, and I like sheep" 😂❤️❤️

[@welshgib8079]

same

[@aaronnxo]

That was Vik...

[@aaronnxo]

That was Vik...

[@aaronnxo]

That was Vik...

[@BasicRBN02]

oh yh, sorry lol

[@starrai6345]

"Tennesse, Texas" was he saying tennesee is in texas becauseeeeee

[@Jelloitsme]

I was looking for this, thinking the same thing....

[@bearfender8039]

Same LMAOOO

[@ajgooner6728]

+JelloItsMe Because us Brits don't know American states at all, we're bad at these things, I guess it would be the same with you guys and the counties in the UK 😊👍🏻

[@jfewster]

+Alex Laycock I'm Australian and I'm 12 and I know all 50 states and quite a few counties

[@aminaidris]

Tennessee and Texas are two different states 😂😭😭 lmaooooooooooo

[@geezillcats]

Hands down one of the funniest videos on KZbin and one of my favourite Sidemen videos. 💖💖💖

[@olliepainter6177]

This is the funniest sidemen video 😂

[@julianash9382]

It's funny because when someone says Australia for accents, people automatically think that everyone says G'day mate, barbie and stuff, 'bewdy'. Not true to all Australians

[@mollymiller9480]

We don't say throw anouther shrimp on the barbie we call them prawns

[@Graveyard151]

Molly Miller shrimp and prawns are two different things...

[@mollymiller9480]

Yeah Umm I know that

[@Graveyard151]

Molly Miller so if you were eating shrimp, you would in fact be putting shrimp on a barbie. If you were eating prawns, you'd put prawns on a barbie

[@mollymiller9480]

I know but its just annoying cause thats the first thing thy think of saying if you not Australian you won't understand jeez

[@pabloherreragarcia2921]

Best you tubers in one video 💎

[@thenamesdave107]

"Can we go surfing?" "I eat pears and shit" Best dialogue out of this entire vid 16:27

[@allylauren3623]

Best video I've seen in ages

[@androidstar1445]

Patience Challenge:Dress up as a Footballer and as people to play football with u until they do if not follow them!

[@androidstar1445]

This includes all of the sidemen.... RECOMENDATION:Dress up as a team

[@bitez_playzgamez4916]

Yeah you tell him

[@maxi7786]

when I thought of Australian I thought of lachlan and when I thought of texes I though of preston

[@elleinasuarez6031]

I did too!

[@harrypullen7154]

Why are u watching the sidemen ur like 6

[@jamesocallaghan5180]

And Indian you thought of Vikk. I don't know the pack and where they're from.

[@justaguyyy]

+Meghan D Seriously. No offense but minecraft is shit

[@jcs3543]

+JustAGuyGames umm no offense but they all have separate channels besides minecraft

[@cheez3158]

Josh looks so different in this video

[@LilEmily69]

Ikr

[@ronaldjr.newman5671]

I know right

[@juliaduck8523]

Well this was 2 years ago

[@MaxFadri]

cant believe this was 6 years ago

[@connorbourne9568]

Australians say prawn not shrimp in Australia shrimp are different things

[@abbyhunter8150]

I know right, I didn't even know what a shrimp was until I watched an accent challenge from someone else a little while ago

[@Jluyoungzone]

I think it was a tourist advert for Australia back in the 80's or 90's that popularised the term of "putting shrimps on the barbie". We call them 'prawns' in the UK as well

[@bushyman477]

Prawns and Shrimp are both crustaceans, with prawns being the larger (most often). Being a kiwi, I know that we (and Australians), don't say one nor the other, they are different.

[@CrashDevinator]

Nobody is going to talk about the "Tennessee, Texas" thing XD I understand that they are from England but damn

[@jessxx1636]

I just watch this on repeat it's honestly so funny😂😂

[@fluffyllamalover22]

damn... simon's cali accent... damn

[@LilEmily69]

Am I the only person who loves when simon is speaking Spanish quite quietly?!?!

[@fletcherwilliams6002]

The welsh accent made my night! Considering I'm from wales

[@michaeljohnstone5984]

Unfortunately it was the fake welsh accent m8 :(

[@fletcherwilliams6002]

What do u mean?

[@michaeljohnstone5984]

S.wales everyone immediately does that accent

[@fletcherwilliams6002]

Im from that area haha

[@lloydcostigan9067]

Fletcher Williams same lol

[@chloeisabellagrace1868]

Why are people so offended? I'm a Geordie and I didn't even find it offensive, I thought this whole video was pretty funny😂👌

[@AryanKumar-bw9ut]

Watching this 8 years later is crazy

[@littlebird431]

I'm offensive and I find this Yorkshire

[@BolanioHD]

Your offensive?or offended

[@XCOOKIENINJAZ]

He's from Yorkshire and that's offensive

[@zhevulture]

He switched the 2 words purposely.

[@bens5806]

No, he is from Yorkshire so never got taught English ;)

[@billgamin1899]

I know right!

[@xxabbyxx8817]

Scottish accent-- First thing that comes to Vikk's mind ," Aye am Scottish an a like to eat haggis un where kilts on the weekend" We're not that bad are we ? LMAO

[@katieodowd3305]

Omg josh looks so young in this 💞💞 who's watching In Summer 2016 💞

[@rachellouise_x._3611]

Me

[@DesktopMemes]

yeeees

[@thatsexycucumber2329]

Me haha

[@annamedrano6078]

Me lmao

[@j1gamer55]

Meeeee!!!!!!!😊😊😊😊😊

[@freckldfiend]

Vikk is me every time someone brings up Yorkshire in a conversation.

[@lethallangangaming9992]

Im from sheffield too and vikk was spot on

[@makeyys]

Same haha

[@ashlmtl]

Same! Haha

[@UKXFace]

Vikk is from Sheffield

[@exil3d974]

We speak nothing like that 😅 #brummy

[@tom-6912]

Fancy some CHIPS AN' GRAAAAAAAYYVY

[@exil3d974]

+Tom Hogan nope

[@uwaishafizal2747]

yeah like apparently I don't sound like I'm from Birmingham

[@uwaishafizal2747]

+Sam Perry and why do you think that

[@mzinnoo7417]

Ennit

[@kasidypierce4529]

15:15 Simons laugh oml, that's great

[@williamhaldane398]

Josh: "There is a pigeon in your bank account. My name's Trevor McDonald."

[@geezillcats]

"Is that your posh English one?" "Yeah innit." 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Tara-yu4qd]

when josh said (Cwyoyfee) coffee in the new York accent it killed me 😂😂😂

[@wweadic]

This is the first vid I have watched of the sidemen back in January of 2015

[@ConnorApps]

I have no idea how many times I've watched this vid but it never gets old

[@orliathjones6347]

I'm Irish and I'm so ashamed that instantly they thought about leprechauns and rainbows we never see rainbows it always raining

[@saaish1055]

7:25 Jai Ho 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@speedophile7353]

I swear Josh's glow up is underrated and ignored because holy crap the difference between this video and now

[@mia-bw6gg]

omg yess 🙌🏽

[@aprilverian1262]

Simon's reaction when Josh did a Cockney accent was hilarious

[@joccoaa999]

A Welsh person when they meet some one new: "Yes I'm Welsh, No I don't"

[@DxrkestMatter]

RIP -Death by laughter #TooMuchSidemen😂😂😂😂

[@boomboom-fz5ur]

One of the funiest videos ever

[@KittyNoir3083]

Just seeing them trying to do a Welsh accent makes me laugh so much 😂❤❤❤

[@admirallarry5466]

Simon's Cali accent is pretty good

[@Alex-vs5dh]

The Brummie (Birmingham) accent was so bad! I live near Birmingham and no one sounds like that! I was laughing for so long

[@anon9133]

Ik same I'm facepalming right now

[@moustacheyoable]

Im From Spain and I Sound Brummie

[@tom-6912]

Fancy some CHIPS AN' GRAAAAYVVV

[@welshviking795]

Im from the valleys in wales and your accent was spot on, Vikk's welsh accent made me laugh so bad 😂😂

[@evie7473]

There Yorkshire accents were on point! 😂😂😂

[@TheIcyAH]

For the California all you would have to do is say starbucks or chipotle

[@brandie.f2796]

Mostly Starbucks....

[@steo7377]

For every irish accent that english/american youtubers do Leprechauns,"Top of the morning" and guiness atleast one of them is used

[@patchy64]

lol so fucking true

[@sophiebeaumont9608]

Steo7 What else does your country have?

[@pedro29695]

Sophie Beaumont Rashers.

[@patchy64]

Sophie Beaumont were good at rugby actually yea you got a point

[@dannymullane3993]

Limerick is d best county

[@JohnSmith-yn7ek]

Do part 2 of this.

[@SeanJ-]

Thanks for being so funny and ur were close with the Scottish

[@sammy8368]

I'm Indian and I was impressed by Josh's accent 😂 I laughed when he mentioned Jai Ho😂😂

[@fchgbdc3540]

is it just me or did Eiffel tower sound like a sex position the way he said it

[@Lglover3]

It is a sex position during a threesome

[@JarJarBlocks]

eZ Purge you're a sad boy

[@Mr2beerqueer]

JarJarBlocks He's not lying

[@m1ystswazey73]

Josh's intro me myself and I is now a killer song

[@soufian0603]

Im from Germany and you did actually really...bad.

[@EthanolMighty]

Arek are you 10

[@sophieb2317]

Entity YT Damnnnnnnn

[@JWMUFC02]

You are from german?

[@EthanolMighty]

Entity YT OOOOOOOO shit son

[@soufian0603]

MYNAMEISYANAN Yes.

[@braydenmorgan9933]

Omg he said Tennessee Texas and Tennessee is a state as well

[@derping654]

And a Texan accent and a southern accent sound different XD

[@lukepeele2025]

lol Ik

[@niamh_tomo8197]

I perfected quite a lot of accents from this xxxx

[@PiggyRulesMinecraft]

The Bristol ascent tho what was that lol 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@ashlynhiltabidel5788]

that moment when Tennessee isn't in texas....

[@khaledchaban]

The momment that you write to same comments for atantion

[@ashlynhiltabidel5788]

+khaled- Deir Ezzor that moment you can't even spell attention right

[@ashlynhiltabidel5788]

+khaled- Deir Ezzor btw it wasn't even for attention old man. it's a KZbin glitch ugh

[@2tiessupguys93]

Stop commenting the same thing twice

[@cazemerto]

+Ashlyn Hiltabidel that moment you didn't need to comment that