Zur vs Lonis vs Yannett vs Tymna / Kodama | MTG CEDH Gameplay

[@SquidWithABigIdea]

I'd love to see a companion "Secret Santa" episode to this one, where players makes decks they think their chosen player would love instead of hate!

[@buddadragonmtg]

So glade to see this channel back!!!!

[@demonguitarist93]

glad your back. missed the games

[@EbonyButter]

What's good I'm here to say hi and welcome you guys back. Thanks for coming back and making sweet videos.

[@justinveron698]

Welcome back! Can't wait to see what content comes in the future!

[@asterlwolf]

Great to have y'all back

[@brawlerike1]

Editing and graphics were great! Glad to see y’all back

[@Fariorn]

Great video as always. Funny format and I'm really hyped for the upcoming vids! By the way Nate B and Jordan's voice are a bit off, in the deck introduction segment.

[@fwop7436]

So happy to see this channel back in business. Videos are fresh af.

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

Thanks!

[@mthlay15]

Oooo...gotta say that is a slick new take on opening hands display. I'm personally pretty keen on it.

[@bluevader13]

Glad to have you back, always loved your content

[@Ghaespar]

Glad you are back!! Fingers crossed that the next game Kodama does some epic stuff 😉

[@R3tro_Memori3s]

You guys are back! 🎉 RESPECT THE FISH!

[@justdeserts8343]

Great graphics/editing! And love the nemesis draft idea

[@drachir7146]

I love Casually Competitive as it's the exact content I like. It's the same feeling as the Playing with Power "Best commanders from x set." Just the idea of taking an idea and making it as powerful as possible is how I like to build

[@dawsonstubblefield9676]

Glad you’re back, I do think your old way of showing opening hands was way better than the half card on screen thing. Not everyone can identify cards by the top half of a picture. All in all welcome back, can’t wait for more content

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

Yeah we're going to re-address how we do opening hands for future videos, this one and the next one are just already finished so the best we could do was make it a bit more clear (compared to the last video) was to show a bit more of the art

[@johnweinhandl8890]

@@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG I actually like how you have hands. I will caveat I’m a pretty entrenched cedh player. So maybe more of your fans would benefit from some other way of displaying them? Regardless keep showing hands definitely sets you apart from pwp and play to win. Also I appreciate you guys are playing in person. Webcam no matter how good can never be as good as in person

[@razorskatermax35]

Hey I am glad yall r back. Please don't feel bad about thoracle win, we are watching semi cedh so it should be expected love your videos ❤

[@Foxribble19]

Aye casually competitive is back! Love the content!

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

Thanks!

[@Zilborg]

Damn y'all don't burn yourselves out! Loving the revival though

[@CosmicGiggalo]

I will say one of the quality of life things the gameplay videos here did was the stack as a chalkboard. Its probably tough to edit that consistently but I do miss it from the old show.

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

These first 3 gameplay videos were edited all at the same time, but for the next video we edit we are going to address all feedback people have about the design so hopefully the next revision is a bit better

[@mercadepalmer6967]

I missed you guys so much

[@piralos1329]

Casually Competitive, known haters of IRS-- More seriously, this was a super fun game! Watching people try to work through the various decks was very fun, and that ending was really interesting!

[@mwogelius]

Amazing, please make more. The salt is delicious.

[@jacuzzi_jake]

Love the new design of opening hands and life totals

[@MrTiddles69]

Glad to see you guys back, threat assessments were totally off in this game imo but ❤anyway

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

Would it really be Casually Competitive if we played the game correctly though?

[@danieln.2838]

Amazing videos again. Love it :)

[@Firefox410]

hot take thassa's/consulate is a fine wincon and anyone complaining needs to understand thats its CEDH gameplay and if they don’t like it go watch other casual gameplay that lasts hours on end

[@ladylockedown]

The players introing their own decks is *adorable* (灬ºωº灬) Keep up the good work!

[@AndrewWoodford]

Oh yes!

[@graxal8076]

It doesn’t really make a difference, but on turn 1 Bill should’ve gone to 35 right? Fetch, shock, probe would be 1+2+2 or can you have a shock land come in without the damage when you fetch it? Apologies, I haven’t played EDH in 3 or 4 years now

[@CrimsonJimi]

You are correct.

[@CasuallyNateL]

Don't apologize, you're correct with this! Must be an overlook with editing because were working with different video editors this time around. Thanks for pointing this out!

[@Cozy_MTG]

this sounds like such a fun idea

[@Closer2Zero]

Oh good god. Double Thassa Consult. This pod is gonna be a nightmare

[@Ethan-hy3ce]

i think the thoracle win was cool in this game, it didnt really feel out of nowhere.

[@al007625]

Feed the algorithm not the fish!

[@Rabbit3]

Let’s goooo!

[@crovax1375]

I have a Blim, Comedic Genius bad gifts deck, if that answers the question at the beginning!

[@k-dawg2104]

I love the visualization of the stack, however it might be a bit small? I haven’t decided yet part of me likes it smaller part of me wishes it was the same as the central card rect

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

The idea behind it was that the card would have been shown larger at one point, it wasn't entirely necessary to fully show it again, but after the next video (since the next video was also edited at the same time) we are going to go through all the feedback and hopefully come up with a solution that everyone enjoys and can easily understand

[@derrickpaulson3093]

I really liked the old version of openers with larger hands, showing what was put back with mulligans and even the power level and average mana costs.

[@cdee34]

The 🐐s

[@soorian6493]

Just putting out there because generally only the most passionate people in the subject comment, thoracle consult lines are fine with me. It's the most efficient win con in the format. It'd be boring if it's all y'all did, but there's plenty of game before it happens and it wouldn't feel like cEDH if you ignored it completely.

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

Our general plan is to try to plan pods around consult decks so it doesn't get too repetitive. For example, the next 4 pods after this one don't have any consult decks, but after those we might do a pod with multiple. That way we can play the consult decks we want without it appearing too frequently

[@Kalimier777]

Here’s one for the editors!!

[@emarmy00]

Dude love cEDH, show more fast games, Thoracle for the win!!!!!

[@donovanlouvierre655]

Comment to feed the algorithm overlords

[@Giga-lemesh]

#feedtheeditors

[@crooker23]

Friends don't let friends play Simic

[@WushuTaz]

Nate drew all those cards and still couldn't pull out a win. That's crazy. Good game though guys.

[@TheAdontalis]

Comment for the algorithm

[@DarkEinherjar]

Why didn't Jordan send Kefnet back to the library?

[@BUHDAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA]

where did my mans get his anime nissa mat??? @casually competitive mtg

[@supermarth64]

Hi Joseph, is there anything in the works to maybe add in a noise gate during recording? The narration occasionally has you breathing into the mic.

[@JohnSmith-hs9ez]

I love that casually competitive is back. Y'all seriously don't know how to play against mystic remora tho.

[@sibbypuglieseiv3270]

Honestly, with two consult decks that's something like a 50% chance of winning with thoracle. I wouldn't sweat it

[@WorldlyTutor]

Force of NEGATION!

[@SeekerOf7ruth]

FEED THE FISH. And feed the editors, ye 😅

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

I've seen these guys play magic for years at this point.. The fish stays fed

[@cchan3466]

For the algorithm

[@chucklingchocolate12]

I hate paying taxes too

[@TheGrifcannon22]

As a stax player, pay your taxes!

[@dondariohabibi5118]

For the love of god no more turn 1 Serra ascendant plz

[@wirakirros7281]

Do people really hate you guys for winning with Thoracle?

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

I wouldn't say they hate on us specifically, it's mainly people just find a Thoracle ending anticlimactic and boring which is fair

[@wirakirros7281]

@@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG yeah, I could see why. I just hope people understand the spirit of competitive EDH and won't hate your channel because lf it 😁

[@Belena711]

I was like #666... hopefully it doesn't mean anything. 😬

[@tserrofz9]

Im never mad at content creators for Consult. But I want it banned. Could you guys soft ban it for your pods for content creation?

[@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG]

Our current methodology for it is we will stack consult decks together and space those consult filled pods out. So for example, of our first 5 pods (tribal included), only this pod has consult lines. Stacking the consult decks together still lets us play the consult decks we want, but hopefully they will be sparse enough to not be repetitive

[@derrickpaulson3093]

@@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG seems legit. I too want to see other win cons, but like your method. Loved the tribal pod before this! Keep it up!

[@Duckandrun101]

comment for algorithm

[@chaelsonnen1]

Yeah, you guys do not pay your taxes IRL too huh

[@CasuallyNateL]

Avoidance is key. Be right back there’s some loud knocking at my door…

[@apd5084]

pronouced zoo - ol - ogist

[@apophis456]

The fact that 3/4 wincons are thassa’s oracle tell you how fucked the state of c is. That card has to go

[@JDPower-ej3rx]

It's cEDH, naturally people play the most mana efficient wincons. Commander is doing just fine, sit down with some friends and play some casual games it will refresh your perspective

[@apophis456]

@@JDPower-ej3rx just because it’s C doesn’t mean things don’t need to go. Look at flash hulk when it stagnated the format. I play commander casually 3 times a week, but thanks for the attempt at a recommendation

[@yoshisalaverry5502]

Tapping Hallowed Fountain instead of a basic island to pay for Remora was a mistake, and Nate L got immediately punished.

[@7upac]

three decks with thassas oracle win cons huh

[@thevergemtg2518]

I would be so frustrated if I were in this game. So much feeding the fish, wheeling everyone into 8 cards. Everyone was trying to give everyone else the game. So much cringe..

[@yugioh395]

Yeah, I especially don’t understand the ponder, not playing for rhystic, after drawing 10 cards off remora

[@kylemcgowan1]

I hate that overplayed combo and almost everyone here is playing it. Double thumbs down

[@R3tro_Memori3s]

It’s not like he rushed into playing it though. NOBODY paid any taxes, and he played it after seeing his opportunity after THREE Force of Wills.

[@johnaych8954]

get over it, lmao

[@johnweinhandl8890]

By FeliCa

[@kylemcgowan1]

@@R3tro_Memori3s just putting in the decks was enough to barf

[@morganelliott3145]

For the algorithm