The Other Paul - 2025 Plans
9:50
28 күн бұрын
Language Resources: Ancient Greek
15:56
TableTalk - Rev. River Devereux
1:51:15
How to Read the Church Fathers
40:00
My Goals for 2024
6:19
Жыл бұрын
TUTORIAL - How to Use Biblindex
8:46
BEFORE You Claim "The Fathers Say..."
12:39
Did the Early Church Have the Bible?
11:08
Heresy Slander 2
1:05
2 жыл бұрын
The Real Presence is NOT "Literal"
8:18
Heresy Slander
0:29
2 жыл бұрын
The Other Paul SubscribeStar Promo
4:57
"Plato is in hell"
1:32
2 жыл бұрын
Пікірлер
@Bradford.C.Wallsbury
@Bradford.C.Wallsbury Сағат бұрын
Stoicism: The world is hard, and things are out of your control, so time for you to take it into your own hands and let nothing bother you. Christianity: Stoicism: The world is hard, and things are out of your control, so time to put it into Christ's hands and let nothing bother you.
@unlocktheautism9748
@unlocktheautism9748 5 сағат бұрын
Will you do more videos with Jeem?
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 5 сағат бұрын
@@unlocktheautism9748 I don't see why not.
@sarmata2528
@sarmata2528 5 сағат бұрын
Why you have video on your channel with character Dagoth Ur? You know that Morrowind was written by occultist Michael Kirkbride?
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 5 сағат бұрын
@@sarmata2528 ok.
@johnmichaelbullock594
@johnmichaelbullock594 12 сағат бұрын
*sees both styles of hair The duality of man
@Catholic79
@Catholic79 2 күн бұрын
Protestantism's Big Justification Lie: kzbin.info/www/bejne/gmKXhoGglr99o5osi=dX_jW7BKihE1pcxA
@darrenlee1480
@darrenlee1480 2 күн бұрын
Just a side note, Moore College is outwardly Anglican, but essentially it's more or less a Zwinglian Baptist seminary using a hermeneutics similar to Baptist New Covenant Theology. Their systematic theology is defective because they only want to rely on the field of biblical studies (namely exegesis and biblical theology) to construct doctrines. There's very little consideration given from them on how various loci of doctrines impact other doctrines and how doctrines guide our exegesis. And furthermore they don't engage much with the confessional scholarship of Presbyterian and Lutheranism, and the primary sources of classical Anglican theologians such as Cranmer, John Jewel, Richard Hooker and so on...hence they have lots of blindspots in the field of systematics and historical theology. That being said, they are decent when it comes to biblical studies and biblical languages.
@ConciseCabbage
@ConciseCabbage 2 күн бұрын
You both have really nice mics, but it sounds like you’re both using the default one attached to your laptops or something…
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 2 күн бұрын
Far out I did not notice; stupid Streamyard must have swapped to the darn cam mic without me knowing. Thanks for telling me.
@unlocktheautism9748
@unlocktheautism9748 5 күн бұрын
What do you think about John Milbank?
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 5 күн бұрын
@@unlocktheautism9748 subversive libtard "Anglican" with a dash of upper class English snobbery.
@warrior_of_the_most_high
@warrior_of_the_most_high 7 күн бұрын
Based
@ConvincedofChristianity
@ConvincedofChristianity 8 күн бұрын
I love Church history! Thank you for the recommendation!
@CharlesDavis-yd2yx
@CharlesDavis-yd2yx 10 күн бұрын
When I went to a service at S Lawrence and the celebrant could not wear the chasuble. What nonsense if you go to an Anglican church in the UK you don't have this problem. Priest are allowed to wear what they like.
@alphaepic6335
@alphaepic6335 10 күн бұрын
1:11:14 Very surprising to hear Trent admit that
@0...00..19
@0...00..19 13 күн бұрын
First off youre assuming people didnt have dissagreements with things, which is simply outrageous. Second off you're youre assuming they didnt even come together to discuss these disagreements because the clear answer is supposed to appear out of thin air. If the bible showed God can listen to our prayers and his angels and even change his mind about things surely we should follow that example. Hence the concept of Magisterium
@Slave.of.Christ08
@Slave.of.Christ08 14 күн бұрын
Yo I wear that exact crucifix
@MarkRhodesSongs
@MarkRhodesSongs 14 күн бұрын
I just finished the Maier translation. I had read Eusebius---perhaps 20 years ago---and don't recall the translator's name. (Whoever did the Penguin edition widely available then in paperback.) Maier's organization makes the book easy to get around in. The footnotes are helpful, as is the parallel list of Emperors and bishops of Jerusalem, Antioch, Alexandria, and Rome. The photos and maps are a great help. This is a good edition for taking notes and being able to find sections quickly when needing to review a section.
@divinityofblackness6330
@divinityofblackness6330 14 күн бұрын
it's quite eye opening when one realizes that corporatism and capitalism are not the same.
@Anglo-ton
@Anglo-ton 14 күн бұрын
Honestly, glad to see more up I’m reading the book i’ve got it for Christmas
@bourgeois4494
@bourgeois4494 14 күн бұрын
1:12 But what is that in Freedom units? But on a more serious note, do you think this book would be a good starting point for someone like myself who would like to start delving into Church history? And are there other books you would recommend as a good starting point? Thanks and God bless.
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 14 күн бұрын
Approximately 1 and 1/3 Big Macs long, 4/5s wide, and 2 french fries thick. Yes, I absolutely recommend this for beginners, per the video. As for other sources, that greatly depends on what area(s) of Church history you are focusing on. If you give me an idea of that I can help more.
@toomanymarys7355
@toomanymarys7355 13 күн бұрын
​@@TheOtherPaulI'm writing history textbooks for homeschoolers. I need to do my research on church history, because there will be substantial sections regularly. Because I am doing real history, not godless nonsense. Source you recommend?
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 13 күн бұрын
@ very based. Well, per the video, I recommend you pick up this book and look at the sections of the bibliography which cover the periods/places of Church history you are writing on. Although I could probably help too if you give specifics.
@toomanymarys7355
@toomanymarys7355 13 күн бұрын
@TheOtherPaul That was my first impulse because it seemed like just what I was looking for. There are some really cool resources that you have to know about to find, like compilations of the canons of all Frankish councils.... They're super important, but you have to know they exist!!!!
@bourgeois4494
@bourgeois4494 13 күн бұрын
@@TheOtherPaul Well my favorite part of Church history is the Reformation, so what would be a good source to start researching the Reformation? I also want to start researching the whole of Church history, from the beginning of the Church to the present day. What source would you recommend to start researching the early Church?
@jonahsanctus9839
@jonahsanctus9839 14 күн бұрын
Hey, is it a sin to download books from shadow libraries given Romans 13 and 1 Peter 2 about obeying the government? As I understand those passages, we as believers need to obey the government so long as it does not contradict or affect our saving faith in Christ and so long as we don't end up disobeying Christ by obeying the government. I think shadow libraries should be legalized, I don't think the laws on it are fair. So does Romans 13 and related passages apply when I think the laws are unfair, in this scenario, books on Biblical studies which help me grow in the Lord both in the heart and the mind? I usually download books from Telegram from theological e-libraries where I can request books from seminary people and they upload them. Only when they don't have a certain book I want, I download it from Z-library, but I have stopped downloading books from Z-library altogether because I am feeling convicted for downloading books from Z-library. I just wanted your insight as to what I should do. As a fellow believing Christian who is also a theology nerd, I would hope to get some insight from you. In Christ, Jonah Sanctus
@neil_disciple
@neil_disciple 14 күн бұрын
If you are feeling convicted, dont do it. I dont think its wrong, personally; but I am curious what TOP has to say. You should also ask your pastor about this.
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 13 күн бұрын
Thanks for the Q, and it's a very pertinent one (perhaps warranting a video one day). In the objective sense, no, I don't believe there is any divine or natural institution of "copyright" or "intellectual property," and so there is no sin per se in the downloading of free book PDFs via shadow libraries. I would also say that submission to the government in Scripture refers to the overall posture, and not with every dictate; these must be evaluated by multiple axes case by case. Here, I believe that given the metaphysical non-existence of intellectual property and its virtually exclusive purpose being the inflation of corporate profits at the expense of intellectual interests, I believe it is not only permissible but just to defy such limits, HYPOTHETICALLY.
@jonahsanctus9839
@jonahsanctus9839 13 күн бұрын
@@TheOtherPaulAgreed. Why shouldn’t people be allowed share content that they bought with their own money? The laws are not fair at all. And I don’t think it’s contrary to Romans 13 or 1 Peter 2, cause there are no consequences of merely downloading, and I wouldn’t face legal action for doing so (at least where I live). Copyright laws vis-a-vis shadow libraries have no clear rational nexus imo. I will continue to get material from places like telegram, and only if I can’t find them, and if I really need a particular book or journal article, as a last resort, I will download from shadow libraries like Z-library. I still haven’t conclusively settled this issue though. I need to give it some more thought, get opinions from a number of people. Thanks for replying.
@jonahsanctus9839
@jonahsanctus9839 13 күн бұрын
@@neil_disciple Thanks.
@neil_disciple
@neil_disciple 13 күн бұрын
@ The electronic copies should be properly priced. The cost of production is just once, and then its just copy-pasting for free for the publisher (like other websites). This SHOULD reflect in the price. And this is different from the physical book where there is a material cost besides the intellectual right-whatever that is. Also the e-books should be very easily available for purchase.
@theinfiniteawe
@theinfiniteawe 14 күн бұрын
Unbothered. Moisturised. Cheeky. In his lane. Focused. Flourishing. Good head. Good stuff, TOP. All the best with 2025.
@bradleymarshall5489
@bradleymarshall5489 14 күн бұрын
Revenge of the Sith was 20 years ago?!
@neil_disciple
@neil_disciple 14 күн бұрын
First! Thanks, mate! I will check the book on Church History.
@eduardoacuna9408
@eduardoacuna9408 14 күн бұрын
Clearly not Catholic teaching nor dogma. Thank you for your reaction, was wondering if this was a good Catholic bible commentary to buy, not this edition. Good praise our Catholic Church. God bless!
@cannab-al9582
@cannab-al9582 15 күн бұрын
Scripture existed before the bible.. how is that confusing. Sola Scriptura implies Scripture, not the collected works that is the bible, just it contains...
@cannab-al9582
@cannab-al9582 15 күн бұрын
The main reason i want to read them is i hear people say one thing about the father, and then someone completely contradicts the other. This is more.to know who's lying to me. Im starting with the apostolic fathers, and I'll keep reading until I've read all the books I can get about the church. Personally, i dont believe in denominations or traditions. There is no one true chruch after all
@cannab-al9582
@cannab-al9582 15 күн бұрын
Starting with the apostolic father by Micheal w holmes
@StefanoNikolaou
@StefanoNikolaou 17 күн бұрын
Some facts - In the Apostolic Period the only Bible the Church had was the Old Testament. The term 'Bible' hadn't even been invented yet. The same for the term 'Tanakh.' The non technical term of 'graphe' or 'scriptures' was just normal writing in Greek and Latin respectively. The early church quickly came to the idea that four gospels and Paul's letters were the core of more authoritative writings but examples like Serapion of Antioch allowing the Gospel of Peter shows there was flexibility. New Testament Papyrus 75 shows codices existed with less than four Gospels. P75 has Luke and John only. In the end with 90% of the population being illiterate and all books being handwritten the only way the Church have had the Bible the way Protestants imagine is with the advent of printing and we all know that didn't happen for a long long time.
@KnightFel
@KnightFel 19 күн бұрын
Abraham was justified before God before he took Isaac to the alter. 🤓
@timsanduleac1646
@timsanduleac1646 19 күн бұрын
Such a great conversation, brothers. Thank you for this!
@peterlloyd7922
@peterlloyd7922 21 күн бұрын
Hey Paul, I’m discerning joining the Anglican Church but I’m in Queensland what are your thoughts on the Diocese of The Southern Cross?
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 21 күн бұрын
@@peterlloyd7922 great to hear mate. From what I know they're basically *the* goto option for those in otherwise apostate dioceses, as that was the purpose for its establishment. At minimum, a parish under the DoSC will be orthodox on sexual ethics. By almost necessary consequence, they will also be orthodox on Scripture's authority. Whether they are traditional or contemporary is another question, however.
@Silverhailo21
@Silverhailo21 21 күн бұрын
Short answer is yes.
@raphaelfeneje486
@raphaelfeneje486 8 күн бұрын
Can't refute any argument. Just jump to a video that disagrees with you and comment ignorantly
@Silverhailo21
@Silverhailo21 8 күн бұрын
@@raphaelfeneje486 It doesn't disagree with me, the subjective opinions put forward are in disagreement with Christ and reality.
@raphaelfeneje486
@raphaelfeneje486 8 күн бұрын
@@Silverhailo21 Christ and reality?? Imagine making claims without evidence. You just assume it. Hilarious.
@Silverhailo21
@Silverhailo21 8 күн бұрын
@raphaelfeneje486 So, who are you and why should I take your opinion over that of any of the Church Fathers?
@raphaelfeneje486
@raphaelfeneje486 8 күн бұрын
@@Silverhailo21 "take your opinions over that of the early church fathers." Can you point me to any of these church fathers that claim Infallibility?? I'm waiting.
@MrJayb76
@MrJayb76 21 күн бұрын
When you start a video with that type question you already know you don't even take Church that seriously. If every single church structure was ignored today you'd be totally OK with it.
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 21 күн бұрын
@@MrJayb76 what on earth does this even mean?
@MrJayb76
@MrJayb76 21 күн бұрын
@TheOtherPaul what I was trying to say is that you obsess with scripture so much that you water down Church authority to the point where it is totally optional. You don't take ecclesiology seriously.
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 21 күн бұрын
@@MrJayb76 do you enjoy making things up? You have no clue what I believe on this.
@MrJayb76
@MrJayb76 21 күн бұрын
@TheOtherPaul if the church can't settle matters and only scripture does then why even have a church?
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 21 күн бұрын
@@MrJayb76 there you go assuming a univocal sense of "settle," showing you haven't watched past the first few minutes. Do that (the whole video), then get back to me.
@famtomerc
@famtomerc 21 күн бұрын
I love your content. The answer to the question is yes because otherwise we ordain women. God bless!
@nektariosO1399
@nektariosO1399 22 күн бұрын
Total Caesaropapist victory! Lol
@doubtingthomas9117
@doubtingthomas9117 22 күн бұрын
Good video. I too find the claim arrogant that the more educated one is the more likely he’d convert to (Roman) Catholicism. However there are many other who have considered the claims of Rome and extensively studied the church fathers that have discovered (with apologies to Newman) that to be DEEPER in history is to cease to be papalist.
@Michael-gx6mi
@Michael-gx6mi 22 күн бұрын
Yes we need the magisterium Judah now stop being prideful and kiss His Holiness Pope Francis' ring.
@IronleafJosh
@IronleafJosh 22 күн бұрын
Very good, Paul. I found that incredible helpful. The distinction between the verb and noun form of interpretation was interesting.
@neil_disciple
@neil_disciple 22 күн бұрын
That was refreshing, and good, although I will have to listen it a few times to fully appreciate your argument. I mean that as a compliment. A quick question: do you suppose that the doctrine of Real Presence (as in Jesus is present in the Eucharist in "some" real way even if not in the way Rome teaches) is binding on any believer who reads and studies Scripture? Or stated differently is Scripture clear enough to indicate to a serious Bible student that something supernatural happens at the Lord's supper (and that its not merely a memorial meal)?
@neil_disciple
@neil_disciple 22 күн бұрын
I have come across many Christ loving people who believe that the Eucharist is nothing more than a memorial meal - and that there is nothing supernatural and extraordinary about it because Scripture doesnt support anything more than a mere memorial meal. Hence the question.
@TheOtherPaul
@TheOtherPaul 22 күн бұрын
@@neil_disciple many thanks, and yes, I do believe that a *very basic* sense of Christ's presence is clear in Scripture and thus binding on all believers, from Paul's statement on how the bread/wine are a participation in the body/blood of Christ. That is no longer mere symbology.
@neil_disciple
@neil_disciple 21 күн бұрын
@ Cool, thanks.
@stephenbailey9969
@stephenbailey9969 22 күн бұрын
The church got along for centuries with the episkopoi discussing things over time with collegiality and equality. When necessary, they came together in council to work it out. (The Jerusalem council described in Acts 15 as the first such.) That is quite different from the much later assertion of supremacy for the bishop of Rome which precipitated the schism between East and West.
@Presbapterian
@Presbapterian 22 күн бұрын
17:40 is the best moment in this video 😂 Thank you for this wonderful presentation, Paul. I pray that this will help the Ecclesialists realize how their arguments fall short of the substantial truth and how many of their pop apologists have conflated different issues in such a way that makes even Scripture look bad and not perspicuous in their fans' eyes.
@neil_disciple
@neil_disciple 22 күн бұрын
Liked without watching the video. Now, watching!
@Old_Catholic
@Old_Catholic 22 күн бұрын
Magisteriums are only as useful as humans are scared enough to follow them. In my case, like many other Christians, I have blatantly rebelled against at least half a dozen clear dogmas of the Roman Catholic Episcopacy. Therefore, magisteriums can exist by the tons, potentially, and they aren't going to help with building unity in the Christian faith.
@ninerocks
@ninerocks 22 күн бұрын
Awesome bro, nice work!