Can't wait to hear your updated theory & glad you're okay after the hurricane. I'm actually driving into Florida to visit one of my podcast co-hosts - idk how y'all live in Florida. I can't handle that stress 😂
@ScreenFavorites7 күн бұрын
@@MoviesAreDope420 I love the show, very much, but felt like the last season jumped the shark, maybe my expectations were too high or I thought too much into it. But logically imo so much didn’t make sense. I don’t like to talk negatively on anything but focus on the positives, I saw more negative than positive so I stopped covering it. I’m born and raised here so you kinda get used to it, the storms are usually far and few between. There are worse things here than a hurricane every few years.
@MoviesAreDope4207 күн бұрын
That's so clever! Your subscriber Jenny & you Dallas are so smart for picking up on those hints - I completely missed those I wonder if next season will be the final one when tackling that cold case - the writers are so freaking smart for leaving the breadcrumbs so beautifully Love love love OMITB
@ScreenFavorites7 күн бұрын
@@MoviesAreDope420 Jenny knows her stuff! Show runner stated before that he had a 5 season arc, the cold case may be tied to the most recent murder in the building, I hope it does all tie together.
@MoviesAreDope4207 күн бұрын
@ that's awesome! Couldn't find any confirmation it would end with season 5, but that seems to be a very popular season number in television. I'm gonna be super bummed when it ends
@ScreenFavorites7 күн бұрын
@ after season 2 on a Reddit ama John Hoffman said 5 years. I would like more years but we will have to see if he changed his mind.
@MoviesAreDope4207 күн бұрын
@ I'm half crying inside & half happy we will have a completed story hour they planned it to be But I hope they end it with season 5 for the same reason I don't want a Ted Lasso season 4 even though it's my favorite show. I'm scared of it becoming a shell of what it once was
@BowieSlayz18 күн бұрын
This theory gets debunked in season 4 because Howard was recording the trio when the guy who texted the trio the picture of the “I’m watching you” but hopefully it’s just someone else who texted because this is a good theory and I hope it’s right in season 5
@tonjehansen929726 күн бұрын
Nice catch
@giuliopianese6690Ай бұрын
Sto riguardando la prima stagione, e, consapevole di quanto è successo nella quarta, ho notato un particolare che mi fa sempre più pensare che la mente dietro a tutto sia Howard. Nella quarta scopriamo che qualcuno spia i protagonisti con delle telecamere all'interno delle loro abitazioni, quindi sa esattamente quello che succede. Nella puntata 8 della prima stagione Jan continua a dire di considerare l'ipotesi di Howard, ma tutti la ignorano. Dopo essere stata cacciata trova un biglietto fuori casa sua con scritto "ti tengo d'occhio". E se quel biglietto l'avesse scritto Howard dopo aver visto che Jan continuava a sospettare di lui? La cosa però che mi fa oensare che non sia lui è il fatto che nella puntata 6 della stagione 4 i protagonisti scoprono la telecamere nascosta, e qualcuno gli manda un messaggio con scritto "vi tengo d'occhio ", però Howard è lì con loro, quindo non può essere stato lui ad inviare quei messaggi (a meno che non abbia un complice)
@paulsolon62292 ай бұрын
Funny Zany
@eyemah44402 ай бұрын
❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉
@gloria33732 ай бұрын
Dallas we want to tell you we miss you, and it’s not the same without you!! Hope all is well with you.
@greenmonkey29952 ай бұрын
Me watching this with only one episode left in season 4. 😅 Oh my.
@keithfustos55202 ай бұрын
Great theories
@psiloveyou19642 ай бұрын
I noticed that there are 2 signatures with Cookie in them( on the ledger Howard looks at) One is P Lazazzera Cookie. I forget the secind name that has Cookie in it. Cookie is on the murder board. Maybe were going to meet her.
@maximusdraco21992 ай бұрын
I hope that you are doing well and that you are safe and sound
@slack__2 ай бұрын
3:46 ive been looking for this clip for SO LONG
@PhoebeFayRuthLouise2 ай бұрын
I hope you are okay, Dallas! It’s good to have a video from you! I really hope that there’s another season for them to completely wrap up all the loose ends!
@psiloveyou19642 ай бұрын
I'm so happy to see you back. I hope you have been safe in the hurricanes. I've been thinking that Lester may be involved. Sazz' body could've been put in Charles missing suit bag. Put on the luggage cart, & taken to the incinerator. Anyone that might have seen him would think nothing other than he was just doing what he normally does as part of his job. I have other ideas. I'll be back later. I have relatives in New Smyrna Beach Fla. None of them have had power for hours now (3million in FLA without power). I hope you haven't had any damages. Be safe my favorite go to person for theories, & clues.
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
Thank You! ive never really thought about Lester. He could use a luggage cart, its minimal lifting. We saw him Carry the baby thing up many flights of stairs for Nina in season 2 so its definitely possible. Hes got great cover for his actions in case anyone saw him. But what would be his motive? Do you think hes smart enough to install cameras and known how to work them? He seems like hes very old school and not a fan of technology. Ive got just a few pieces of siding and shingles missing, nothing too serious. We have power so were back to work!
@psiloveyou19642 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavoritesmaybe Lester is the 6th Avenue slasher, lol. When Charles said something about 19 bodies buried under the Arconia, I don't think so, too many tenant's could witness that. If there are bodies buried someplace, my guess would be on the property that sazz wanted to open her trampoline place?
@psiloveyou19642 ай бұрын
Charles sister's husband could be the crooked cop in the police department. Cinda is still on my list, of a possible person behind all of this. I'm still getting Cinda vibes off of Bev( mannerisms, etc). I wonder if Cinda could be related to Bev.
@dugferd22662 ай бұрын
Ana signed the check register at the bodega with her right hand.
@jenm12 ай бұрын
I think the lefthand stuff is a red herring
@dugferd22662 ай бұрын
@@jenm1 yeah, feels like all the actors' conclusions were nonsensical.
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
@@dugferd2266 It could be nothing or everything. I wouldn’t say what the actors said was nonsensical. They made some good points especially about the notes on Sazz desk.
@dugferd22662 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavorites Having played woodwind instruments, I know there's only one way to hold them to play; you can't infer someone's dominant hand from that, so that made me think the whole smudge/left handed thing was inaccurate as well (they cited role research as reasons for knowing those things). Maybe this is an error of the show, but I don't believe we have never seen something from Sazz's desk which said "door note." There are still some loose ends from S1, like the two handwritten supposed suicide notes, one in Jan's handwriting (mostly lower case except her detached capital Js which gave her away to Charles) and the other was all caps like the "I'm watching you" note. They were on different kinds of paper, too. I think that's why Sazz's scribbled "2 notes?" on her deli delivery receipt, not the door notes. Who wrote the all caps suicidal note and how did it wind up in the blue handle trash bag?
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
@@dugferd2266 I play multiple instruments, inferring a dominant hand form an instrument that must be played one way is very different than actively seeing someone use a hand when they have a choice. But the Smudge thing could be inaccurate. The Actors stated research as a reason knowing these things, and I actually think it tracks, they would be more worldly informed than the trio, so just as good as if not better detectives. No we never saw anything that said "Door Note" but other things on her desk said things that looked to reference season one and the idea that someone has been watching them from the beginning. The two notes could be a reference to the different handrwriting on the suicide notes. I forgot about that one all together, I think I took it as a production error and the two notes are the note left on Jans Door and Olivers. Only time will tell!
@Mashingbutton282 ай бұрын
It was Lester all alone
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
You think he could have moved the body by himself?
@Mashingbutton282 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavorites I do think he kill Saz but I do believe he wants the podcast out the building and I think being that he has been there since season one out of everyone still in the building he would be a surprise to be the main person
@rizzzzzzzzzzzz2 ай бұрын
Hi!! Hope everything's all right with you through the hurricane!!
@cheri70542 ай бұрын
The actors suggested the killer is left handed. Do you believe them??
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
I think that’s very likely but they could be wrong. It may be too big of a giveaway
@cheri70542 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavorites They're actors all of a sudden they think they know everything. I love actors but for them to be high and mighty and yet the writers make our trio look stupid
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
@@cheri7054 I think thats the point, its a little meta, the trio are actually themselves actors too IRL. It appears the actors in one night figured out some things that the trio didnt. Just like Sazz in 5 minutes figured out things the trio couldnt and The Arconiacs brought things up that the trio didnt think about. No reason not to be open to a new perspective especially from people with diverse backgrounds of study. They could be wrong, but it literally never hurts to try.
@cheri70542 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavorites The actors may be right or wrong but I didn't buy what they were saying. I think their ideas are red flags. The work Howard did was the best. Mabel was the one suggesting Howard get info and boy did he get info.
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
@@cheri7054 Mabel had to direct Howard to be productive, the actors are actively want to do more and were being told no. I think if they switched places Eva could have gotten the info from be bodega alone. But Howard may not have put together that “sick pup” on Sazz’s desk likely refers to Winnie. Red herrings maybe but red flags? Why?
@finolaharvey89052 ай бұрын
Hope you are safe and sound. On the case..Loretta is left handed, ep301 she highlights her script for with her left hand. I definitely thing Loretta could be the long game.
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
This would be a twist I didn’t see coming!
@randomhuman192 ай бұрын
been rewatching S1 and Im looking as Lester very closely now
@jennyb45432 ай бұрын
I just learned Hulu has an "extras" tab, and it shows some scenes for the next episode. I think the note in it might validate my original theory, if not for Sazz, for Dudenoff. My crazy theory was that Sazz hired someone to kill her. She was in pain, a sick pup, and wanted to go out in style, but it was a sensitive subject and didn't know how to break it to Jan or Charles. I suspected the chiropractor to be who she hired. And Glen may have hired her too- maybe a brain tumor causing hallucinating rats. Now this note from Dudenoff inviting them to a funeral, maybe that's where she got the idea. (I'm pretty sure he allowed the westies to keep signing his checks) The only thing I can't piece together is who put the cameras in - it would have to be someone from the Arconia since it's from season 1. I'm sure Howard is connected to all Murders (intentionally or not), but now I'm starting to lean more towards Uma because she always seems to be in the lobby or elevator when they are. Also, could Dudenoff be Sazz's dad? I know they have different last names, but maybe he was a stepdad, or maybe Pataki is a stage name. Maybe Dudenoff was a stunt man turned teacher after breaking too many bones. It could be why Sazz listens in on the ham radio, had the code and info about the Westies, etc. Also, could Sazz have been seeing Helga after her and Xmas guy broke up and before Sazz started seeing Jan. They said Helga was crazy; maybe she's who Sazz was trying to get away from.
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
We don’t have power and my cell service is spotty. I like what I’m hearing I’ll look for the extra tab when we get power and internet back!
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
The extra video is now here on YT. Im surprised to what it shows. I think Sazz and Dudenoff are too close in age to be related that way, but she could have been another one of his students. Maybe she went to him after he retired and he was helping her with something. I dont know why the trio has not asked any of them if they knew Sazz. If howard didnt put the cameras in, I feel like it has to be a somewhat younger person. I feel like people like Uma or lester would need help setting up cameras. Sazz dating Helga is something I didnt think about , but would be a good reason for her to be over on the west tower.
@jennyb45432 ай бұрын
Glad you're safe from the 1st hurricane. Hope you stay safe during this one too. ❤
@LeviColtrane2 ай бұрын
Yes! I've also been suspicious of Anna from the beginning... she just seems sneaky. Hope you're okay through the storm! 🙏
@ScreenFavorites2 ай бұрын
Still no power or internet but I’m charging my phone in my car lol.
@LeviColtrane2 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavorites we're thinking of you, hang in there buddy!
@gloria33732 ай бұрын
Good luck Dallas, stay safe! We love your podcast and thorough detective work!
@momoye773 ай бұрын
Missing this channel and all your excellent observations this season! Hope all is well
@loganwebb54493 ай бұрын
Probably the Westies.
@Metal_Fingers.3 ай бұрын
I don't think so, It will probably some from the same building.
@gloria33733 ай бұрын
Catch u on the rooftop
@jennyb45433 ай бұрын
hope you're safe from the hurricane ❤
@psiloveyou19643 ай бұрын
Dallas, I miss your OMITB reviews/theories. I hope you are doing ok?
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@psiloveyou1964 work has been super busy and we just had a big storm come through 😞 I’m hoping to have one out tomorrow
@psiloveyou19643 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavorites I was just worried about you.
@maximusdraco21993 ай бұрын
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
@mallynp3 ай бұрын
why does a fitness nut have a lighter in his pocket? how come Vince was so angry and dismissive the second time we see him? why are Vince and the sauce family watching the trio from 14F? is it Helga M. Dudenoff? is it Helga on 445? how did Howard find Hammy Faye Bakker? why hasn't the trio compared handwriting or talked to Lester? what makes this an FBI case?
@mallynp3 ай бұрын
also, aren't Iberian hams illegal in the States? that's a multi thousand dollar ham hock
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@mallynpThere are many reasons he would have a lighter in his pocket but I do think it was a little convenient. It would have seemed more natural if he got it from a tables with Christmas candles or something. I don’t think Vince became irritated and dismissive until they started rambling to him, but it could just be a bad day. Do you think he had a conversation with someone maybe in the HAM radio? I think the Westies all use that room as a spare room. I have a few ideas if that’s Helga or someone else on 445, it will be in my review hopefully later today. It really doesn’t make sense how Howard would have found the pig unless he was on that side of the building. I think it was an oversight but he might have been over there snooping. I’m assuming they have the note and have talked to Lester but that note isn’t on the murder board, I think it’s their second day back in NY, hopefully they talk to him and Ursula. The FBI are involved because they think Jan did the crime she’s an escaped convict who has a history of violent crime and is thought to have left the state and went to Florida. This case now takes national coordination.
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@mallynp Iberian they are not illegal but there are struck safety requirements. I think Alfonzo said he’s a butcher, so he may have done it legally or have a connection.
@PhoebeFayRuthLouise3 ай бұрын
I love OMITB, and your out-of-context video was really funny!
@5cloudwalker3 ай бұрын
All good points✅. Curious if they can track the movements of Sazz’s phone like police do in real life
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@5cloudwalker IMO this is something they 100% should do. That way we know if the person went to LA or if they have been in the building the whole time.
@victoriajloveland31443 ай бұрын
Love this theory❤
@larrywade1663 ай бұрын
Why would shoot from across the street if you had access to the apartment? No body drag lines. "Tap in" looked like it was written in marker. They also made a point of letting people know sazz was "imaginary" and not a ghost. Love this show. Keep up the good work
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@larrywade166 I don’t think they planned on going to the Apartment, only after realizing that they killed the wrong person did they go to the apartment. I think they saw actual Charles in Oliver’s apartment and then went to clean up their mess. Why not just go in his apartment in the first place? If you go inside there is a chance other people could be there. It’s also TV so nothing is 100% I could also be 100% wrong and just justify the idea. Oliver stated that Gravey believed that a body was dragged. I think it was just lazy work to not make dragging body streaks. But I think I’m putting down what you are picking up. The didn’t use actual blood obviously it was likely some sort of paint, but it would have been a big marker to make such thick streaks. To write Tap In, we saw Sazz begin to write it, I think backtracking any of that would be too convoluted. When I say ghost, I don’t mean it in the literal sense but interacting with the presence of their memory just as Mabel did with Tim Kono. Ghost is often used in this way to highlight how the departed person’s influence or memory continues to be felt tangibly. I will ensure to use a different word in the future so no one thinks I believe there are actual ghosts in the story lol. Thank you for being here!
@cheri70543 ай бұрын
I don't understand what this cold case Oliver was saying.Was it a case in the building or somewhere else
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
It’s not outright stated but it’s implied that there is a cold case(unsolved murder) that happened in the building.
@cheri70543 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavorites I think someone was murdered in the vacant apartment.
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@cheri7054 I Think the same! I mentioned it in my trailer breakdown. The lady who was crossed out may be the killer.
@cheri70543 ай бұрын
If someone is just going off Charles why wouldn't someone go after Mabel and Oliver as well. They're all doing the podcast
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@cheri7054 I think that Charles was just the easiest target. He is known for being in his window visible from the west tower. Oliver may be harder to get to and Mabel is technically homeless and harder to track down. The killer may go after them later this season or are spooked because they messed up and killed the wrong person.
@rizzzzzzzzzzzz3 ай бұрын
we’re back!!
@timothycampbell97623 ай бұрын
I think there may be another room in the empty apartment. Mabel said it seems big for a studio.
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@timothycampbell9762 we saw the door to the side, that they never opened next to the window. Maybe they will go back next episode.
@larrywade1663 ай бұрын
Good catch
@PhoebeFayRuthLouise3 ай бұрын
I have been wondering about the notes to Oliver and Jan and the poisoning of Winnie all this time!
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@PhoebeFayRuthLouise me too! But I can’t imagine it solves a crime this season and not the final season. There have been so many twists and turns the writers are surprising us!
@kathylynn13753 ай бұрын
I really like how you explain things,, nice and slow , easy to follow... we have thought of most of your theories, We think its Teddy.. he has the means, the connections, the need for revenge, he told Oliver to his face I will Fu%$ you up......he has lived in the building for ever. Even from jail, is he even in jail, he could make it happen... Theo has not been mentioned this season and Mable was staying with him last season , why is she now living with Oliver??? I really enjoy your presentation except for spoilers in upcoming episodes... for example showing us the future murder board.... I did subscribe ... I want to stick around for your upcoming videos but I do NOT want spoilers......
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@kathylynn1375 The future murder board was shown in a promo for the show on TikTok on the OMITB account, so I don’t usually consider it a spoiler as it’s basically a trailer. I will in the future state that something “may be considered a spoiler” and also try to move it to the end of the video. If I ever put something that doesn’t come from official channels I state right away that there is spoilers and I do not include that information in other other videos until it’s come up within the show. Teddy is a good choice! We know he’s bad but hasn’t been around. We don’t know the extent of his crimes.
@PhoebeFayRuthLouise3 ай бұрын
One of the reasons why I love this channel so much is because Dallas is very careful with spoilers!
@kathylynn13753 ай бұрын
@@ScreenFavorites Thank you so much for your reply... I don't watch trailers... I love the mystery of this show and trying to figure things out as it goes along.... I also enjoy other peoples theories, its a fine line to know and not to know..... and Thank you again for being sensitive to possible spoilers....
@kathylynn13753 ай бұрын
@@PhoebeFayRuthLouise yes I subscribed ..... this is the only video of his I have seen... I will go back and watch for episode 1 season 4..... have fun!!!
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@kathylynn1375 No thanks needed! I love the mystery of the show and trying to figure out what’s going on but for me I take all the info I can from what officially comes out. I’ll be sure to say up front if anything I talk about it from anything other than from the show itself in the future and if so I’ll be sure to have it in a separate section at the end of the video. Thank you for being kind and understanding.
@117Derek3 ай бұрын
I ❤ your theory. The idea that Sazz voluntarily took the hit for Charles in order to get the Trio to solve a Cold Case is very good. I’ll keep it in mind as more story & clues present themselves.
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@117Derek it wasn’t all me! Jenny B had the idea over a week ago and I just expanded on it! We will both keep it in mind as we learn more this season.
@gloria33733 ай бұрын
Hey Dallas! We miss you!
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
@@gloria3373 I miss you guys 😞I’m hoping to get back on track this week.
@mallynp3 ай бұрын
def think Sazz was ill
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
I never thought of it before Jenny brought it up but it makes sense my brain just started running!
@finolaharvey89053 ай бұрын
Thank you..
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
You're welcome
@maximusdraco21993 ай бұрын
🎉thank you for posting this
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
Thank you for being here.
@PhoebeFayRuthLouise3 ай бұрын
I was so excited to see Jan! “I’ll tell you if you don’t kill me.” “I kill you if you don’t tell me.” We even got a “woof” from her!
@ScreenFavorites3 ай бұрын
Just seeing the shoes in his closet SCARED ME! I hate to admit that I see what Sazz saw in her. Something about her crazy is attractive lol. I didn't think the episode would be this good but they have continued to surprise us in different ways this season!
@PhoebeFayRuthLouise3 ай бұрын
I totally know what you mean! Jan’s crazy is scary, but it is also somehow mesmerizing!